Seong-Joon
Kim
a,
Min-Kyu
Park
a,
Sung-Eun
Lee
b,
Hye-Jung
Go
a,
Byung-Chae
Cho
a,
Yoon-Se
Lee
c and
Sung-Deuk
Choi
*ac
aSchool of Urban and Environmental Engineering, Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST), Ulsan, 44919, Republic of Korea. E-mail: sdchoi@unist.ac.kr; Fax: +82 52 217 2859; Tel: +82 52 217 2811
bSchool of Applied Biosciences, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, 41566, Republic of Korea
cUNIST Environmental Analysis Center (UEAC), Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST), Ulsan, 44919, Republic of Korea
First published on 3rd January 2019
Vehicular exhaust is one of the important sources of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in urban areas, and roadside soils can be directly contaminated with PAHs released from traffic emissions. In this study, roadside soils were collected at 10 sites in Ulsan, the largest industrial city in South Korea, to investigate the relationship between the traffic volume and the contamination characteristics of PAHs. The total concentrations of 16 US EPA priority PAHs (∑16 PAHs, mean: 1079 ng g−1) and organic-matter-normalized ∑16 PAHs (mean: 224 ng g−1 OM) were positively correlated with traffic volumes (Pearson correlation, r = 0.88 and 0.78, p < 0.01). The levels of carcinogenic PAHs were significantly higher at the high traffic sites than at the low traffic sites. High traffic sites (>25000 vehicles per day) located at intersections showed elevated concentrations of indicator compounds (e.g., phenanthrene, fluoranthene, pyrene, and benzo[ghi]perylene) for gasoline and diesel exhaust. The diagnostic ratios also suggested a strong influence of the traffic emissions on the roadside soils, not only at urban sites but also at rural ones. Consequently, roadside soils and road dust (which are expected to be much more contaminated with PAHs than roadside soil) can act as important non-point sources of air and water pollution. The cancer risk from exposure to PAHs in the roadside soils was in an acceptable range, but continuous monitoring is required to evaluate the influence of increasing traffic on the environment and human health.
Environmental significanceVehicular exhaust is an important source of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the urban area. Especially, roadside soils can be directly contaminated by PAHs emitted from vehicles, and they can act as a non-point source. However, previous studies did not clearly examine the relationship between traffic volume and the contamination characteristics of PAHs. In this study, therefore, we investigated PAH contamination in roadside soils, where traffic volume data were available. The levels of PAHs and carcinogenicity were statistically correlated with traffic volumes. Cars had the highest contribution to PAH contamination. Traffic indicator compounds were also identified. The major results of this study can be used for the prediction of PAH levels and patterns using traffic volume data. |
In urban areas, vehicles are one of the most important local sources of PAHs.8 Road dust and roadside soils can be directly contaminated with PAHs by vehicular exhausts.9 Asphalt, tires, and petroleum products are additional important sources of PAHs in urban road dust.10 Even in remote mountain areas, levels of PAHs in the air and soil are controlled by the proximity to roads.11 Road dust and roadside soils contaminated with PAHs are expected to affect the health of drivers and/or residents via direct ingestion, dermal contact, and inhalation.12 In addition, PAHs in road dust and roadside soils are transported to the aquatic environment by surface runoff.13,14 For these reasons, monitoring studies on road dust and associated PAHs have been conducted worldwide.15
The number of vehicles is increasing, for example, according to Statistics Korea, the number of registered automobiles in South Korea increased from 1.64 million to 2.18 million during the last 10 years (2007–2016). Accordingly, the emission of PAHs from vehicles and its relationship to traffic volume should be of high concern. Many studies have focused on the contamination characteristics of atmospheric PAHs from mobile sources.8,16,17 The atmospheric levels and patterns of PAHs in the gaseous and particulate phases can be different from those in dust or soil. However, the contamination characteristics of PAHs in road dust and roadside soils with respect to traffic volume have not been fully investigated yet. In addition, only few studies on the contamination of road dust with PAHs have been conducted in South Korea.18–20
Ulsan is called the industrial capital of South Korea and has a population of more than 1.1 million. Large-scale industrial complexes (automobile, shipbuilding, petrochemical, and non-ferrous industries) are located along the east coast of the city. The total number of registered vehicles in Ulsan is more than 0.5 million. Only recently, the first monitoring study on soil pollution with PAHs was conducted in Ulsan.21 This study identified the main sources of PAHs in the soil as industrial activities (e.g., heavy oil combustion, coke oven, and coal burning) and traffic emissions (e.g., combustion of diesel and gasoline). Previous studies on road dust in Ulsan18,19 also suggested the influence of industrial emissions and vehicular exhausts. These studies primarily discussed contamination patterns, particle-size distribution, and toxicity of PAHs. However, roadside soils were not considered, and traffic volume data were used in a limited manner for data interpretation.
In the present study, therefore, roadside soils were collected at 10 sites with a range of traffic volumes in Ulsan, South Korea to clearly understand the relationship between traffic volume and the contamination characteristics of PAHs. In addition, a probabilistic human health risk assessment was conducted. To the best of our knowledge, this study represents the most quantitative data to describe the relationship between PAH contamination and traffic volume in roadside soils.
Fig. 1 Locations of roadside soil sampling sites in Ulsan, South Korea. The sampling sites are classified based on the daily traffic volume. |
Site location | Traffic volume (vehicles per day) | Site description | f OM (%) | |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Estimated by own observation. b f OM values were determined using the loss-on-ignition (LOI) method.3 | ||||
Site 1 (35°34′35′′N, 129°11′07′′E) | Low traffic | 0a | Trail at the UNIST campus | 4.7 |
Site 2 (35°33′37′′N, 129°09′50′′E) | <500a | Farm village in a valley | 6.7 | |
Site 3 (35°33′47′′N, 129°08′12′′E) | <2000a | Approach road to a national highway | 5.3 | |
Site 4 (35°34′17′′N, 129°12′04′′E) | <3500a | Entrance of UNIST | 4.2 | |
Site 5 (35°34′06′′N, 129°16′14′′E) | 8181 (car 88%, bus 1%, truck 11%) | Intersection in front of a middle school in a rural area | 4.1 | |
Site 6 (35°32′48′′N, 129°20′10′′E) | 21866 (car 81%, bus 2%, truck 17%) | Residential area surrounded by apartments | 6.5 | |
Site 7 (35°38′24′′N, 129°20′40′′E) | High traffic | 32820 (car 71%, bus 3%, truck 26%) | Intersection in a rural/residential area | 8.0 |
Site 8 (35°33′18′′N, 129°15′56′′E) | 36754 (car 83%, bus 3%, truck 14%) | Intersection in front of a high school | 3.7 | |
Site 9 (35°33′20′′N, 129°16′34′′E) | 41142 (car 83%, bus 2%, truck 15%) | Intersection in a residential/commercial area | 5.8 | |
Site 10 (35°33′26′′N, 129°21′38′′E) | 52392 (car 73%, bus 3%, truck 24%) | Intersection near automobile industries | 3.5 |
Soil sampling was conducted on October 17, 2011. At each sampling site, roadside soils at three points were collected from the surface (<2.5 cm) using soft plastic brushes and metal trowels. The composite samples (∼200 g) in polyethylene zipper bags were stored in a freezer at −5 °C prior to pretreatment and instrumental analysis.
The 16 US EPA priority PAHs (i.e., naphthalene (Nap), acenaphthylene (Acy), acenaphthene (Ace), fluorene (Flu), phenanthrene (Phe), anthracene (Ant), fluoranthene (Flt), pyrene (Pyr), benz[a]anthracene (BaA), chrysene (Chr), benzo[b]fluoranthene (BbF), benzo[k]fluoranthene (BkF), benzo[a]pyrene (BaP), indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene (IcdP), dibenzo[a,h]anthracene (DahA), and benzo[ghi]perylene (BghiP)) were analyzed using a Gas Chromatograph/Ion Trap Mass Spectrometer (GC/ITMS, ITQ 900, Thermo Scientific) with a DB-5MS column (30 m, 0.25 mm ID, and 0.25 μm film thickness). The Selected Ion Monitoring (SIM) mode was used for the analysis of the target compounds. The carrier gas was helium (He), and its flow rate was 1 mL min−1. The GC oven temperature was as follows: 50 °C (1 min) → 15 °C min−1 → 120 °C → 10 °C min−1 → 230 °C → 5 °C min−1 → 300 °C. The final sample (1 μL) was loaded into the GC using a splitless mode, with the GC injector temperature of 250 °C.
Detailed Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) procedures and data were presented in our previous study.21 In short, lab blanks were analyzed using the same analytical method for the real samples to check contamination during the experiment. Mean recoveries of surrogate standards ranged from 85% to 97%. Method detection limits (MDL) were calculated using seven replicates of spiked blank samples and the Student's t value (3.14) for a 99% confidence level.
CDIingestion = (Csoil × IRsoil × CF × ED × EF)/(BW × AT) | (1) |
CDIinhalation = (Csoil × HR × ED × EF)/(PEFsoil × BW × AT) | (2) |
CDIdermal = (Csoil × CF × SA × AF × ABS × ED × EF)/(BW × AT) | (3) |
The cancer risks (Ri) for the three exposure pathways (denoted as i) were calculated by multiplying CDIs and cancer slope factors (CSFs) for the corresponding pathways.
Ri = CDIi × CSFi | (4) |
The values of risk parameters used for Monte-Carlo simulation for two age groups (children and adults) are listed in Table S1 in the ESI.† The total cancer risk (Rtotal) by the three exposure pathways is the sum of individual risks by each pathway.
Rtotal = Ringestion + Rinhalation + Rdermal | (5) |
The correlations between vehicle types (car, bus, and truck) and individual PAH compounds for Sites 5–10 were examined (Table 2). Cars accounted for 80% of the total traffic volumes and showed the highest correlation coefficients (0.972 and 0.970) with ∑16 PAHs and ∑7 carc PAHs at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). The traffic volumes of buses and trucks also had significant correlations with PAH levels. Out of the 16 target compounds, 13, 5, and 5 compounds were significantly correlated with cars, buses, and trucks, respectively. In particular, Nap, Phe, Flt, and Pyr were significantly correlated with all types of vehicles. These results suggest that these four compounds are very common PAHs released from major types of vehicles.
Napc | Acy | Ace | Flu | Phec | Ant | Fltc | Pyrc | BaA | Chr | BbF | BkF | BaP | IcdP | DahA | BghiP | ∑16 PAHs | ∑7 carc PAHs | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). b Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed). c The four compounds are significantly correlated with all the types of vehicles. | ||||||||||||||||||
Car | 0.820b | 0.873b | 0.792 | 0.806 | 0.937a | 0.931a | 0.981a | 0.916b | 0.869b | 0.838b | 0.946a | 0.816b | 0.947a | 0.932a | 0.708 | 0.901b | 0.972a | 0.970a |
Bus | 0.818b | 0.706 | 0.787 | 0.676 | 0.850b | 0.776 | 0.891b | 0.906b | 0.706 | 0.836b | 0.732 | 0.586 | 0.759 | 0.731 | 0.499 | 0.730 | 0.857b | 0.880b |
Truck | 0.838b | 0.705 | 0.833b | 0.740 | 0.856b | 0.801 | 0.843b | 0.940a | 0.664 | 0.775 | 0.709 | 0.547 | 0.747 | 0.743 | 0.441 | 0.770 | 0.862b | 0.880b |
Total vehicles | 0.859b | 0.860b | 0.836b | 0.819b | 0.952a | 0.931a | 0.983a | 0.961a | 0.846b | 0.857b | 0.916b | 0.772 | 0.927a | 0.914b | 0.660 | 0.898b | 0.980a | 0.984a |
As expected, Site 1 (control) showed the lowest levels of PAHs (310 ng g−1 of ∑16 PAHs), which is comparable to the average levels in rural (mean: 220 ng g−1) and urban (mean: 390 ng g−1) soils in Ulsan.21 Even though the traffic volumes at Sites 2, 3, and 4 are low (<3500 vehicles per day), their PAH levels (mean: 942 ng g−1) are similar to the level (1016 ng g−1) at Site 6 with a traffic volume of 21866 vehicles per day. Site 2 is in a farm village in a valley, and a reserve forces training area is located further up the valley (<300 m). Puffs of soot emissions from military trucks are frequently observed in this valley. Site 3 is located on an approach road to a national highway. Thus, the total traffic volume around this site appears to be much higher than the traffic load of the site. Site 4 is located at the entrance of the university near a circular intersection and the last bus stop. Therefore, emissions from starting and idling engines are likely the main sources of PAHs. Furthermore, Sites 1–4 are located in rural areas, which can be commonly contaminated by PAHs emitted from agricultural biomass burning and domestic heating.27 Site 5 is located in front of a middle school in a rural area, and Site 6 is located in a residential area surrounded by apartments. These two sites have no specific features for PAH contamination.
Among the high traffic sites, Sites 7 and 10 are located on a major industrial road from Ulsan to Pohang, a city with a large-scale steel industrial complex. Therefore, relatively high levels of PAHs at these sites can be explained by the high traffic volumes of heavy-duty vehicles traveling between the two cities. In our earlier study, the highest levels of PM10 and NO2 in Ulsan were measured along this road.28 In addition, Site 10 is located close to automobile and petrochemical industrial facilities; thus, the site might also be influenced by industrial emissions. Sites 8 and 9 are located at intersections with eight lanes in residential/commercial areas, resulting in heavy traffic volumes.
The levels of PAHs can also be influenced by vehicle speed; lower vehicle speeds resulted in elevated concentrations of PAHs.19 This may be one of the reasons that the rural sites with lower vehicle speeds on narrow two-lane roads showed rather elevated concentrations of PAHs. As all the high traffic sites are located at intersections, the higher levels of PAHs in the roadside soils can be attributed to the reduction of speeds, engine idling, and engine starting at intersections. Furthermore, the emissions of PAHs from vehicles can be reduced by improvements of engine performance and oil quality,29 suggesting that the traffic volume only is not enough for the estimation of soil contamination and the health effect. In addition, PAH concentrations can be affected by the pavement type. For example, asphalt roads showed higher PAH levels than concrete roads.19 Because all the sampling sites in this study were beside asphalt roads, the type of pavement was not considered.
The levels of ∑16 PAHs in this study (0.3–1.8 μg g−1) were generally lower than those found in road dust at different locations in the world,15 such as in Birmingham, UK (14.1–96.6 μg g−1).30 Previous studies conducted in Ulsan also showed much higher levels of PAHs in road dust: 11.8–245.1 μg g−1 (ref. 18) and 19.7–154.6 μg g−1.19 Meanwhile, previous studies on roadside soils generally reported relatively low PAH concentrations (Table S3†). For example, roadside soils collected in Tijuana, Mexico showed relatively low levels of PAHs, ranging from 0.05 to 1.86 μg g−1 with a mean of 0.31 μg g−1.31 The lower levels of PAHs in roadside soils can be explained by the fact that road dust is contaminated more directly by vehicle emissions and asphalt wear and tear than roadside soils.15 In addition, the dilution effect caused by less polluted soils might be responsible for the lower levels of PAHs. On the other hand, road dust samples collected from creeks in the Masan Bay in Korea showed levels of ∑16 PAHs similar to those observed in this study for the road with the heaviest traffic (0.45–4.1 μg g−1), industrial areas (0.1–3.56 μg g−1), and a residential area (0.32–1.95 μg g−1).20 These results suggest that road dust in Ulsan18,19 may be much more highly contaminated with PAHs than road dust in other industrial cities in Korea. However, additional comparison studies with other Korean cities are required.
Fig. 3 Average profiles of 16 individual PAHs in roadside soils according to traffic volumes. Error bars represent standard deviations. |
Site-specific relative fractions of individual PAHs and groups of ring numbers were also considered for 2 rings (Nap), 3 rings (Acy, Ace, Flu, Phe, and Ant), 4 rings (Plt, Pyr, BaA, and Chr), 5 rings (BbF, BkF, BaP, and DahA), and 6 rings (IcdP and BghiP) (Fig. 4). The patterns were generally similar at each site, except at Site 1, where several heavy PAHs with 5 and 6 rings were not detected. There was an increasing trend in the contribution of the 4- and 6-ring PAHs to the concentration of ∑16 PAHs with traffic volumes mostly owing to the substantial increases in Pyr and BghiP concentrations. As mentioned above, these two compounds are typically emitted from diesel and gasoline vehicles. Overall, this observation indicates that the levels and patterns of PAHs in the roadside soils were substantially affected by the vehicle emissions.
Fig. 4 Relative fractions of PAHs in roadside soils: (a) individual compounds and (b) each group of PAHs with ring numbers. |
Cluster analysis was used to more objectively investigate the similarity of PAH profiles at each sampling site (Fig. 5). Three clusters were identified: Group A (Sites 2, 3, 5, and 6), Group B (Sites 4, 7, 8, 9, and 10), and Group C (Site 1). The control site was definitely separated from two groups, further indicating less influence of traffic emissions. The low and high traffic sites (except for Site 4) were clustered into Groups A and B, respectively. This result reveals that traffic volumes alter the composition of PAHs in roadside soils.
Fig. 5 Dendrogram of cluster analysis for PAH profiles at each site with an option of average linkage between groups. The individual data were normalized by ∑16 PAHs. |
The contributions of heavy PAHs with 4–6 rings gradually increased with increasing traffic volumes (i.e., from Site 1 to Site 10) (Fig. 4b), implying that carcinogenicity was also enhanced by the vehicle emissions as was already shown in Fig. 2. Meanwhile, the BaP equivalent concentrations (∑16 BaPeq) did not show a statistical difference between the low (127 ± 61 ng g−1) and high (180 ± 21 ng g−1) traffic sites (t-test, p > 0.05). BaA, BbF, BkF, BaP, IcdP, and DahA have relatively higher TEFs (0.1 or 1) than other PAHs, but their concentrations were not significantly higher at the high traffic sites. Therefore, it is preferable to consider ∑7 carcPAHs and ∑16 BaPeq together for the evaluation of the health risks associated with vehicles emitting PAHs. The BaP equivalent concentration was lowest at Site 1 (14.7 ng g−1) with no direct traffic effect, demonstrating that vehicle emissions enhance the toxicity of roadside soils.
In addition, the ratios of Ant/(Ant + Phe) and Flt/(Flt + Pyr) were calculated (Fig. 6b). The Ant/(Ant + Phe) ratio was used to distinguish between petrogenic and pyrogenic sources, while the Flt/(Flt + Pyr) ratio can identify petroleum combustion and coal/biomass burning. These two diagnostic ratios were successfully used for the source identification of atmospheric PAHs in Ulsan.27 The scatter plot strongly suggests the influence of pyrogenic sources. The Ant/(Ant + Phe) ratio clearly demarcated the uniqueness of Site 1 as compared to the other sites, which were located on the pyrogenic side of the graph (Fig. 6b). However, Site 1 might not be directly contaminated by petrogenic sources; note that Ant was not detected at Site 1. The traffic volumes were not statistically correlated with the Ant/(Ant + Phe) ratios (Spearman correlation, p > 0.05). This result suggests that the Ant/(Ant + Phe) ratios cannot reflect the degree of PAH contamination by traffic volumes. On the other hand, the Flt/(Flt + Pyr) ratios were negatively correlated with the traffic volumes (Pearson correlation, r = −0.84, p < 0.01), indicating that the influence of petroleum combustion (i.e., diesel and gasoline emissions) on the roadside soils was intensified by the increasing traffic volumes.
Fig. 7 Probability density functions of cancer risk for (a) children (0–18 years old) and (b) adults (19–70 years old). |
Among the three exposure pathways, dermal contact was a dominant pathway, accounting for 53% (2.98 × 10−6) and 73% (3.74 × 10−6) of the total cancer risk at 95th percentiles for both children and adults, respectively (Fig. 8). For both age groups, the contributions of inhalation exposure were negligible (0.001% and 0.002%, respectively). The cancer risk by soil ingestion for children (2.63 × 10−6) was higher than that for adults (1.38 × 10−6), due to a higher value of soil ingestion rate (mg per day, IRsoil). On the other hand, a higher air inhalation rate (m3 per day, HR), a larger surface area of skin that contacts soil (cm2 per day, SA), and a longer exposure duration (year, ED) for adults resulted in higher risks than those for children. These patterns for the three exposure pathways are identical to the results of previous studies,25,35 but the other study34 reported lower risk levels via soil ingestion in children than those in adult. The reason for this discrepancy was that selected IRsoil values (geometric mean: 12.24 mg per day) for children were lower than those (geometric mean: 26.95 mg per day) for adults. However, the US EPA and the Korean Ministry of Environment recommend higher IRsoil values for children than adults.36,37
Fig. 8 Contributions of three exposure pathways to the total cancer risk at 95th percentiles for children and adults. |
A sensitivity analysis was conducted to evaluate the influence of important input variables for the variance in cancer risk simulations. In Crystal ball software, the contribution of individual input variables to the total variance of the risk simulation is calculated by squaring the rank correlation coefficients and normalizing them to 100%.38 Exposure duration (year, ED) and BaP equivalent concentration (mg kg−1, Csoil) were the most influential input parameters on the variance in total cancer risk, followed by body weight (kg, BW), dermal absorption factor (ABS), and surface area of skin that contacts soil (cm2 per day, SA) (Fig. 9), which are consistent with the results of previous studies.25,34 In particular, the contribution of BW for children was relatively high (−15.5%) because of a high relative standard deviation (53.6%) of BW of children with a wide range of ages (0–18 years). In this sensitivity analysis, several parameters, such as relative skin adherence factor (mg cm−2, AF), soil ingestion rate (mg per day, IRsoil), and cancer slope factors for BaP (mg per kg per day, CSF), were not considered because they were regarded as constants (Table S1†). Among them, AF was reported to be the second most influential parameter.25 Therefore, the AF values in the former studies25,34 were applied to this study, and they accounted for 8.3% and 11.2% of the variance of cancer risk for children and adults, respectively.
Even though Monte-Carlo simulation was applied to evaluate the uncertainty of the predicted cancer risk, there are still other sources of uncertainties. Korean exposure data for BW, IRsoil for children, HR, and SA were used (Table S1†), but other exposure parameters were mostly the recommended values from the US EPA. In addition, the uncertainty of TEFs for individual PAHs and limited dose–response data can be addressed.25,34,35
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8em00532j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |