Ilkan
Calisir
* and
David A.
Hall
School of Materials, University of Manchester, M13 9PL, Manchester, UK. E-mail: ilkan.calisir@manchester.ac.uk
First published on 4th December 2017
1 mol% MnO2 was used to improve electrical resistivity of lead-free 0.75BiFeO3–0.25BaTiO3 (75BFBT) ferroelectric ceramics; the materials were perovskite structured with major rhombohedral (R3c) phase. The method of incorporation of MnO2 was found to exert a significant influence on the structure, microstructure and electrical properties. Chemical heterogeneity in the form of core–shell grain microstructures was observed when MnO2 was added into the undoped calcined powder, in contrast to the relatively homogeneous materials that resulted from adding MnO2 into the precursor oxide mixture prior to calcination. Compositionally graded regions were detected across the grains consisting of a BF-rich core and BF-depleted shell. The occurrence of core–shell type microstructures led to various characteristic features including a high cubic phase fraction, contrast between ordered ferroelectric domain configurations in the rhombohedral core and the relatively featureless pseudo-cubic shell, constrained ferroelectric domain switching, and two distinct anomalies in dielectric permittivity at temperatures of 485 and 635 °C. The latter features are attributed to separate phase transitions in the relaxor ferroelectric shell and normal ferroelectric core regions respectively. The application of a thermal quenching procedure caused the formation of ferroelectric domain structures throughout the microstructure and resulted in dramatically enhanced ferroelectric switching behaviour. For example, the remnant polarisation of the as-sintered 75BFBT ceramic increased from 0.06 to 0.31 C m−2 after air-quenching. These effects are tentatively attributed to nanoscale phase segregation in the shell region of the as-sintered ceramics, resulting from thermodynamic immiscibility between the BF and BT solid solutions.
The origin of high conductivity in BiFeO3 has been a controversial issue, but recent findings have theoretically5 and experimentally6–8 confirmed that the conduction mechanism for BiFeO3 synthesised in air (oxygen-rich) is p-type. Based on this observation, the conductivity is attributed to the incorporation of excess oxygen (filling some oxygen vacancies) and the associated formation of electron holes. This can then lead to the conversion of Fe2+ ions to Fe3+ and Fe3+ ions to Fe4+.8 It was also found that decreasing partial oxygen pressure during synthesis led to a shift from p-type to n-type in (Bi0.5K0.5)TiO3-modified BiFeO3.8 Conversely, for Ca2+ (acceptor)-doped BiFeO3 it was found that sintering in a N2 atmosphere induced a transition from a p-type semiconductor to oxide ion conductor.7
According to the binary phase diagram of the Bi2O3–Fe2O3 system, it has been noted that a stable single pure BiFeO3 phase can be obtained only within a narrow temperature range, which can lead to the formation of secondary phases such as Bi2Fe4O9, Bi25FeO39, and Bi36Fe2O57.2,9,10 These reported obstacles have been overcome using various processing methods including mechanochemical synthesis,2 rapid liquid phase sintering,11 sol–gel method,12 microwave synthesis,13 chemical leaching,14 annealing under magnetic field15etc. Furthermore, site engineering has been applied to BiFeO3 by partial substitutions of A- and B-site ions in the BiFeO3 perovskite structure,16 including rare earth ions substituted for Bi3+,17–23 and transition metal ions for Fe3+.24–28 In addition, solid solution formation with other ABO3-type perovskite ceramics leads to binary,29–34 ternary35–37 or even quaternary38 compounds.
Although BiFeO3–PbTiO3 in particular has been reported to show superior properties, rising environmental concerns on the usage of lead-based ceramics39–41 have led to extensive research on lead-free solid solution combinations. Among them, BiFeO3–BaTiO3 (BF–BT) ceramics have been intensively studied as promising candidates for lead-free, high temperature ceramics. Nonetheless, the main focus of such research was primarily concerned with the magnetic properties due to the observation of weak ferromagnetism at room temperature. Subsequently, the dielectric, ferroelectric and piezoelectric properties have been explored and received considerable attention, particularly for high temperature applications.37,42
Despite improvements in the synthesis of single perovskite phase BF–BT ceramics, well-saturated P–E loops and low dielectric loss are rarely reported without any further modification,30 due to the presence of a relatively high leakage current. Therefore, many researchers have employed additional aliovalent dopants in order to increase its insulation behaviour. Among these, it has been found that a small amount of Mn has a beneficial effect on the electrical properties of BiFeO3-based ceramics.30,43–47 However, Mn is a transition metal that can exhibit various valence states (Mn2+, Mn3+ and Mn4+) depending on the oxygen partial pressure during heat treatment.48,49
The influence of Mn on the properties of BiFeO3-based compounds has been systematically studied and it has been concluded that determination of the optimum amount of Mn is crucial, since excessive amounts are found to cause deterioration of the electrical resistivity due to increasing valence fluctuations generating extrinsic oxygen vacancies.43 Generally it was found that 0.1–0.6 wt% MnO2 addition has a positive effect on increasing the resistivity. However, Mn was incorporated into the compositions in various different ways, including addition to the pre-calcined compositions as a sintering aid,30,43,50–52 as a substitution on to the Fe-site11,46 or as an excess addition into other starting precursor powders.44,53–56 This raises some uncertainty about the origins of the observed variations in the reported ferroelectric (remanent polarisation, coercive field), dielectric properties (relative permittivity, tanδ and TC), and structural as well as microstructural features.
Although extensive research has been carried out on Mn-doped BiFeO3–BaTiO3, no single study has addressed the issue of which addition route could be the most beneficial in terms of sintering, resistivity, ferroelectric and dielectric properties. Therefore, we aimed to clarify this point by evaluating different Mn-addition strategies. For this study, the 0.75BiFeO3–0.25BaTiO3 composition was selected to be doped with 1 mol% Mn (equivalent to ≈0.3 wt%) due to its reported promising properties30 and major rhombohedral phase existence,57 which can help to provide a clear indication of the influence of the Mn incorporation route on structural distortions. The doped ceramics exhibited highly insulating behaviour with interesting features, which were found to depend on the doping strategy employed; these included highly saturated or pinched P–E loops, multiple or single peaks in the dielectric permittivity–temperature relationship and homogeneous or heterogeneous microstructure leading to core–shell type grain formation. It is shown that the cooling rate plays a key role in determining the level of chemical heterogeneity and subsequently the functional properties.
The precursor oxides were weighed according to the required stoichiometric ratios followed by mixing/milling for 24 h using propan-2-ol and yttria-stabilized zirconia media. The milled powders were dried at 85 °C overnight followed by calcination at 850 °C for 2 h. The calcined powders were milled again for 24 h to reduce the particle size down to the sub-micron region. Polyethylene glycol (PEG) solution as a lubricant was added at a concentration of 2 wt% of the dry weight of the powder into the calcined powders to improve compaction behaviour. The calcined powders were uniaxially cold-pressed at around 150 MPa into 8 mm diameter pellets. The pellets were placed on a layer of calcined powder having the same composition to reduce the volatilisation of Bi2O3 and to avoid reaction with the supporting alumina plate. Burn-out of the organic additive was achieved by holding at a temperature of 600 °C for 1 h, following which the ceramics were sintered at temperatures between 990 and 1050 °C for 2–4 h in air, using a heating and cooling rate of 5 °C min−1. The as-sintered ceramics were annealed at 750 °C for 15 min, then directly quenched to room temperature, referred to below as air-quenched.
High resolution synchrotron X-ray powder diffraction (SXPD) patterns were recorded on the I11 powder diffraction beamline at the diamond light source. The crushed powders of samples were placed in a glass capillary tube, and the data were collected at ambient temperature in the 2θ range of 5–100° using the position sensitive detector (PSD). The X-ray photon wavelength was 0.494951 Å. Rietveld analysis of the data was undertaken using TOPAS v5 software. For the refinement, ICSD#15299 and ICSD#67518 were used for R3c rhombohedral and Pmm cubic phase, respectively.
The sintered pellets were ground using 800, 1200, 2500 and 4000 grade SiC paper and then polished with 3, 1 and 0.25 μm diamond paste followed by diluted OP-S silica colloidal suspension. Well-polished samples were chemically etched by immersing into the etchant solution (95% distilled water + 4% HCl + 1% HF) for 5 seconds. Microstructures of as-sintered and air-quenched surfaces were examined using a Philips XL30 FEGSEM equipped with EDS. The average grain size was determined by the linear intercept method over an area of approximately 4400 μm2 using a multiplication factor of 1.56.58
Prior to electrical measurements, the samples were polished to obtain smooth and parallel surfaces. In order to achieve a sufficiently high electric field for the ferroelectric hysteresis measurements, the thickness of the samples was polished down to 0.5 mm. For dielectric and polarisation–electric field (P–E) hysteresis measurements, silver electrode paste (C2000107P3, Gwent Group) was applied on the top and bottom surfaces and then fired at 600 °C for 20 minute. For the air-quenched ceramics, an air-dried silver paint (AGG3691, Agar Scientific, UK) was applied onto both surfaces of the pellets at room temperature in order to avoid changes in the effects induced by quenching.
Ferroelectric P–E hysteresis measurements were carried out using a function generator (HP 33120A) connected to a Chevin Research HV amplifier to generate the desired high voltage. The samples were subjected to 4 cycles of a sinusoidal electric field with a frequency of 2 Hz. The measured current waveform was integrated numerically over time to yield charge and hence the polarisation was calculated as the surface charge density.59 Dielectric measurements were carried out at fixed frequencies from 1 to 100 kHz over the temperature range from 25 to 670 °C using a HP 4284A Impedance analyser and a desktop computer which was operated by LabView-based program. The measurements were conducted in air using a heating rate of 2 °C min−1.
Parameters | Undoped 75BFBT | Mn-BC | Mn-AC | Air-quenched Mn-AC | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Goodness of fit (GoF) is the value of Rwp/Rexp. | ||||||||
Phases | R3c |
Pm![]() |
R3c |
Pm![]() |
R3c |
Pm![]() |
R3c |
Pm![]() |
Fraction, % | 96.5(1) | 3.5(1) | 90.3(6) | 9.7(6) | 53.6(5) | 46.4(5) | 70.0(4) | 30.0(4) |
Unit cell parameters, Å | ||||||||
a | 5.6241(1) | 3.9866(2) | 5.6245(3) | 3.9867(2) | 5.6158(6) | 3.9932(4) | 5.6158(4) | 3.9957(3) |
c | 13.9009(5) | = a | 13.8939(8) | = a | 13.8784(15) | = a | 13.8939(10) | = a |
Cell volume, Å3 | 380.78(3) | 63.363(8) | 380.65(5) | 63.445(12) | 379.05(8) | 63.670(2) | 379.47(6) | 63.792(14) |
R-Factors | ||||||||
R wp | 3.23 | 3.26 | 3.2 | 3.33 | ||||
R exp | 1.56 | 1.59 | 1.71 | 1.53 | ||||
GoFa | 2.07 | 2.04 | 1.87 | 2.18 |
By examining the involved cations in order to find the origin of such structural changes induced by Mn, it is considered that Bi3+ and Ba2+ occupy the A-site, while Fe3+, Ti4+ and a small amount of multivalent Mn occupy the B-site of the perovskite structure. These cations have different Pauling's electronegativities and ionic radii. The ionic radii of the B-site ions are reported as Ti4+(0.605 Å), Fe3+(0.645 Å), Mn4+(0.53 Å), Mn3+(0.645 Å) and Mn2+(0.83 Å).60 The ionic radii of Mn in both 4+ and 3+ valence states are within the range of sizes of Fe3+ and Ti4+, which could enter the lattice without distorting the structure. However, the ionic size of Mn2+ is relatively large compared to that of Fe3+ and Ti4+. Thus, Mn2+ could enter into either the A- or B-sites. On the other hand, it has been reported that Mn4+ is unstable at high temperatures, therefore the valence state of Mn regardless of starting compound can be considered as a mixture of 3+ and 2+ depending on the oxygen environment.48
It is also reported that the incorporation of 25 mol% of BaTiO3 into BiFeO3 causes a slight reduction of the rhombohedral distortion and the presence of a small amount of pseudo-cubic phase.57 Further additions induce a transformation from rhombohedral to pseudo-cubic relaxor ferroelectric phase over a wide range of composition in the solid solution system due to the large ionic size mismatch and charge difference between Bi3+(1.03 Å) and Ba2+(1.35 Å) at the A-site.57 Our results also confirm that undoped 75BFBT exhibits a predominantly rhombohedral phase, as depicted in Fig. 1(a) and Table 1. The effect of adding Mn ions on the crystal structure of BF–BT, specifically the transformation from predominantly R3c to a mixture of coexisting R3c and Pmm phases, cannot be explained purely on the basis of the ionic substitution. Instead, we interpret this effect as being due to the development of core–shell (rhombohedral–cubic) type microstructures in the Mn-doped ceramics, as discussed further below.
For the refinement of the Mn-AC powder, several binary phase models were considered in order to fit the broad asymmetric peaks; the best fitting was achieved by a combination of R3c rhombohedral + Pmm cubic, as noted above. In spite of the improvement relative to the single phase models, broad asymmetry was still present in the peak profiles for certain reflections, which was tentatively attributed to anisotropic strain. To verify this assumption, Stephenson's model61 was applied to these data during Rietveld refinement and an improved fit was obtained, as can be seen in the insets of Fig. 1(c) and (d) for the {111}p peak. Microstructural observations, described in Section 3.2 below, indicate the presence of core–shell type grains in the ceramics, which may be the source of the anisotropic strain and the associated peak broadening. It has been suggested that chemical heterogeneity in the form of core–shell structures can introduce internal stresses and lead to broad asymmetric peaks.62,63
Similar observations were made previously by Lennox et al.64 on the basis of neutron diffraction studies on BiFeO3–KNbO3 solid solutions. It was suggested that regions consisting of different A-site and B-site ion ratios, as a consequence of chemical inhomogeneity, can lead to peak broadening. Dolgos et al.65 also reported large thermal parameters in 0.75Bi(Fe2/8Ti3/8Mg3/8)O3–0.25BaTiO3 for the oxygen and A-site cations which is associated with considerable local strain as confirmed by diffuse scattering in the electron diffraction patterns. Our results are supportive of the argument that Bi:
Ba and Fe
:
Ti
:
Mn ratios may vary in the core and shell regions resulting in local strain within the grains.
The incorporation of excess MnO2, introduced as an additive prior to calcination, in solid solution can be understood in terms of the defect chemistry of the BiFeO3-based system, as follows. Firstly, we should recognise that some loss of bismuth oxide is expected during the high temperature calcination and sintering stages, leading to the formation of bismuth and oxygen vacancies.8
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
![]() | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
![]() | (7) |
It is evident that chemically etched undoped 75BFBT and Mn-BC ceramics display clear and homogeneous domain distributions across the grains as seen in Fig. 2(a) and (b), whilst the grains of Mn-AC seem partially etched, as shown in Fig. 2(c) and (e). A heterogeneous domain distribution was also observed, with domains occurring only at the core of grains. This was not observed in Mn-BC or undoped ceramic. It was first thought that this effect could be due to the artefacts of chemical etching; therefore, in order to eliminate the etchant effect, the surface was examined without any etching as shown in the inset of Fig. 2(c). In Mn-AC ceramics the greyscale contrast of the SEM micrographs, being related to the average atomic numbers, indicated the occurrence of microscale chemical segregation in the form of a core shell structure.
Prior to discussion of elemental analysis relating to the observed elemental micro-segregation, it is worth comparing the as-sintered (Fig. 2(c)–(e)) and air-quenched (Fig. 2(d)–(f)) microstructures for Mn-AC. It is evident that the domain distributions across the grains in the quenched Mn-AC are relatively more homogeneous in comparison with the as-sintered case. It should be noted that both samples were mounted on the same resin mould and etched simultaneously in order to prevent any etching-related microstructural variations. Therefore, it is confirmed that the chemical heterogeneity, which leads to the formation of core–shell type grain structures in the ceramics, is modified by air-quenching. The development of more homogeneous ferroelectric domain structures, achieved by quenching in Mn-AC, may also be responsible for improved ferroelectric properties, as discussed in Section 3.4 below.
The SEM-Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (SEM-EDS) elemental mapping results of non-etched, as-sintered Mn-AC ceramics are illustrated in Fig. 3. It can be clearly seen that Ba and Ti signals are weaker in the brighter regions of the SEM image, associated with the grain cores, under secondary electron mode (also confirmed for backscattered electron imaging mode, Fig. S1 in the ESI†). Conversely, Bi and Fe elements exhibited a slightly increased intensity in the same brighter areas. The results obtained for the Mn distribution were relatively noisy and uninformative due to the low concentrations. These results indicate that the observed core–shell like structures in Mn-AC are associated with the micro-segregation of Ba and Ti elements into the shell regions, while Bi and Fe are more concentrated in the core regions. A small amount of Fe-rich secondary phase was also identified, which has been reported in other BiFeO3-based ceramics,2,25 as highlighted by the Fe elemental map. It should be noted that the SEM-EDS studies were performed on the sample with a relatively short measurement time (1 min) in order to avoid the volatilisation of Bi due to irradiation.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 The SEM-EDS elemental mapping results of Mn-AC ceramics sintered at 1050 °C for 2 h exhibiting core–shell grains. |
It was suggested above that when MnO2 is added into the calcined powder, for Mn-AC, it accumulates in the grain boundary region and can inhibit grain-growth. Therefore, the formation of the core–shell structure may be indirectly linked to Mn addition since the ratio of shell thickness to grain size will be larger when the grain size is smaller. In previous work, the formation of core–shell microstructures was attributed to either kinetic or thermodynamic factors.66 For the former case, it can be argued that the BiFeO3-rich grain cores are formed first due to the higher reactivity of the constituent oxides, with the BaTiO3-rich shell being incorporated at a later stage of sintering. Such a situation is supported by the observation that the core–shell structure is favoured when grain growth is suppressed. The presence of MnO2 has the effect of retarding grain growth and interferes with chemical homogenisation during sintering. Hence, we suppose that the formation of the core–shell structure is driven by kinetic factors related to differences in reactivity66,67 and/or diffusivity of the oxide components.68
Thermodynamic immiscibility in the BiFeO3–BaTiO3 system could also play a role in modifying the structure and resulting properties of the pseudo-cubic shell phase. During slow cooling, the presence of a region of immiscibility would provide a driving force for chemical segregation that becomes more pronounced as the temperature is reduced.38,69 This could lead to nanoscale chemical heterogeneity in the shell regions after slow cooling. The effect of air quenching can be understood on the basis that such nanoscale phase separation is avoided or reduced, providing that the quenching temperature lies near to or above the region of immiscibility.
We propose that the unusual dielectric behaviour of the Mn-AC ceramic is a direct consequence of the core–shell microstructure, since it is anticipated that the core and shell regions will exhibit different types of thermally-induced ferroelectric phase transformations, both of which contribute to the overall measured dielectric response. It was shown in Section 3.2 above that the core and shell regions in the Mn-AC ceramic are either BiFeO3-rich or BiFeO3-depleted, respectively. In a previous study, it was found that BF–BT ceramics with relatively high BT contents tend to exhibit more diffuse phase transitions.71,72 Therefore, the low-temperature peak in dielectric permittivity can be tentatively attributed to the contribution from the shell region. The frequency-dependent behaviour of this contribution is consistent with the presence of polar nano-regions and a relaxor ferroelectric character. The presence of a pseudo-cubic phase (Fig. 1(c)) and a relatively featureless shell microstructure (Fig. 2(e)) provide further evidence to support this argument, since both of these points to the presence of polar nanoregions having pseudocubic symmetry in the shell region. The slight increase in TC, from 570 to 635 °C, for the higher temperature dielectric peak is consistent with a contribution from the ferroelectric core region, within which the BF-content for Mn-AC is enhanced relative to Mn-BC.
In previous studies, Kiyanagi et al.32 suggested that the observed broad relaxation in dielectric permittivity for BF–BT solid solutions is related to influence of a cubic phase coexisting with the rhombohedral phase. This proposition was supported by Rietveld analysis of XRD data and verified by Ozaki's TEM investigation.73 In other reports, the occurrence of multiple anomalies in the εr–T relationships for BiFeO3-based solid solutions have been attributed to the influence of polymorphic phase transitions,35 magnetic–electric dipole interactions,1,74 depolarisation processes,30 Maxwell–Wagner relaxation75 and thermodynamic immiscibility of two ferroelectric phases during sintering.38,69 The development of chemical heterogeneity, in the form of core–shell microstructures, introduces further complexity in the processing-structure–property relationships of such materials but also provides further opportunities for controlling their functional properties.
The influence of air-quenching on the dielectric properties of the Mn-AC ceramics is illustrated in Fig. 5(a), which compares the εr–T relationships of the as-sintered and air-quenched ceramics. For the Mn-AC ceramic, the main effect of air-quenching was an enhancement of the low-temperature shoulder on the dielectric peak, which developed into a clearly defined second peak. The frequency dispersion of the lower-temperature dielectric peak (represented by ΔTMax) was also reduced after quenching, as shown in Fig. 5(b) and Table 2. These results demonstrate that air-quenching had a profound impact on the structure of the shell and is consistent with the transformation from nanopolar to conventional long-range ordered ferroelectric state. The influence of quenching on the ferroelectric ordering within the shell region could be explained by the presence of a region of thermodynamic immiscibility, as noted above in Section 3.2. Further studies using high resolution TEM are necessary to establish whether evidence can be found to identify changes in nanoscale chemical segregation associated with variations in cooling rate.
As-sintered | Air-quenched | ||
---|---|---|---|
Sintering condition | Holding time at 750 °C | ||
990 °C-4 h | 15 min | 21 h | |
T Low at 100 kHz | 482 °C | 484 °C | 510 °C |
T High at 100 kHz | 635 °C | 639 °C | — |
ΔTMax for TLow | 102 °C | 33 °C | 25 °C |
The occurrence of two strong dielectric anomalies in the εr–T plot for the air-quenched Mn-AC ceramic indicates that the underlying chemical heterogeneity, in the form of the core–shell microstructure, is still present after quenching. To verify the stability of the chemical heterogeneity associated with the core–shell structure, the annealing time at 750 °C was increased to 21 h, followed by air-quenching. The results, presented in Fig. 5(c), show that the two dielectric anomalies largely merged into one broad peak although the inflection in the εr–T curve around 630 °C suggests that the underlying contribution from the core is still present. Furthermore, microstructural examination suggested that the core–shell features still persisted after annealing for 21 h, as illustrated in Fig. S2 and S3 (ESI†).
The significant alteration in the εr–T characteristics indicates that some inter-diffusion of core and shell phases might have occurred during the extended annealing procedure. On the other hand the pronounced frequency-dependence of εr and tanδ in the high temperature region, which are attributed to the effects of increasing electrical conductivity and associated interfacial (space-charge) polarisation mechanisms, could offer an alternative explanation. In this case it may be suggested that the apparent increase in permittivity is actually a result of further volatilisation of bismuth oxide during annealing (eqn (1)), which could increase the p-type electronic conductivity according to eqn (2). Calculations of the equivalent AC conductivity, σAC, in the high temperature region indicate that the conductivity was reduced after quenching but increased slightly for the 21 h-annealed sample, as illustrated in Fig. S4 (ESI†). Therefore, we suppose that the increase in the dielectric peak height is primarily due to partial inter-diffusion of the core and shell phases during annealing, although the influence of bismuth volatilisation during annealing cannot be completely discounted. Further studies, for example involving electrical impedance measurements at high temperatures, would help to clarify this point.
Mn-AC | Sintering conditions | Air-quenching (from annealing at 750 °C-15 min) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
990 °C-4 h | 1010 °C-4 h | 1050 °C-2 h | ||
P r (C m−2) | 0.06 | 0.07 | 0.11 | 0.31 |
P s (C m−2) | 0.13 | 0.17 | 0.20 | 0.37 |
E c (kV mm−1) | 2.81 | 2.46 | 2.98 | 3.85 |
Mn-BC | Sintering conditions | Air-quenching (from annealing at 750 °C-15 min) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
990 °C-4 h | 1010 °C-4 h | 1050 °C-2 h | ||
P r (C m−2) | 0.27 | 0.25 | 0.22 | 0.43 |
P s (C m−2) | 0.32 | 0.3 | 0.26 | 0.47 |
E c (kV mm−1) | 4.59 | 4.58 | 4.53 | 4.63 |
It is evident that the shape of the P–E loop for Mn-AC was unsaturated when sintered at relatively low temperatures, while a well-saturated P–E loop with a remanent polarisation value, Pr, of 0.27 C m−2 was obtained for Mn-BC ceramics under the same conditions. On increasing the sintering temperature, a constriction became apparent in the P–E loops of Mn-AC, suggesting the occurrence of an inhibited domain switching behaviour; similar effects were reported previously in BiFeO3 ceramics.77 The J–E loops for Mn-AC also exhibited multiple broad switching peaks, in contrast to the single sharp peaks of Mn-BC (Fig. S6, ESI†). On the other hand, a gradual decrease in the remanent polarisation of Mn-BC with increasing sintering temperature is attributed to the volatilisation of bismuth oxide, leading to the formation of Fe-rich secondary phases and a reduction in density (from 97 to 92%). It should be noted that sintering above 1050 °C caused a reaction with the alumina support plate, which precluded the use of sintering procedures at temperatures above this level.
The occurrence of tilted and/or constricted P–E loops in ferroelectric ceramics can be attributed to several factors78,79 including domain wall pinning due to oxygen vacancy-cation defect dipoles with related ageing effects,80,81 the presence of antiferroelectric phases82,83 or, as reported recently, reversible electric field-induced relaxor ferroelectric to ferroelectric transformations.84 For undoped BiFeO3 ceramics, it is commonly reported that the constriction phenomenon is associated with ‘domain wall pinning’ by defect dipoles.77,85
Several methods have been reported in the literature to identify the mechanisms responsible for such distorted hysteresis loops, including studies of functional property variations after poling or thermal annealing (‘ageing’ effects),86,87 application of a continuous cyclic electric field (field-forced ‘deaging’),77,87 poling at high temperature and thermal quenching. In the present work, it was found that continuous cycling under a high AC electric field (8 kV mm−1), either at room temperature or at an elevated temperature of 130 °C, did not cause any significant changes in the constricted P–E loops. Therefore, it seems unlikely that a domain wall pinning effect caused by dipolar defect associates could be responsible for such restricted and reversible ferroelectric switching behaviour.
On the basis of the microstructural observations in Section 3.2 above, we can propose an additional mechanism to restrict ferroelectric domain switching, which has its origin in the core–shell type phase microsegregation, particularly for BiFeO3-rich solid solutions. Due to the compositional variations over the grain, taking the form of core and shell regions, two different solid solutions exist, which have different dielectric and ferroelectric properties. The core region is BiFeO3-rich and exhibits a ferroelectric rhombohedral R3c structure while the shell region is BaTiO3-rich and exhibits a pseudo-cubic structure, presumably with relaxor ferroelectric characteristics.32,72
One possible explanation is that the reorientation of macroscopic ferroelectric domains in the core is constrained elastically by the nanodomain-structured shell, giving rise to a largely reversible domain switching behaviour. As the high electric field is applied to the core–shell type grains, the macrodomains in the core, which are assumed to be a predominantly rhombohedral structure due to the BiFeO3-rich phase, tend to switch along the electric field direction, resulting in a partial polarisation switching within the grain. However, due to elastic constraint of the core by the shell, the domain switching is partially suppressed giving rise to gradual changes in polarisation over a wide range of electric field strength rather than at a distinct coercive field level. The partially poled core is subject to residual stress upon removal of the electric field, which leads to reversal of the domain switching.
On the other hand, it should be recognised that the shell is likely to contain nano-sized domains, or polar nanoregions (PNRs), which is a signature of relaxor ferroelectric-type materials.88–90 In view of recent studies on electric field-induced phase transformations in lead-free relaxor ferroelectrics,84 an alternative explanation for the reversible polarisation switching behaviour can be proposed in which changes in polarisation occur predominantly in the shell region due to electric field-induced relaxor ferroelectric to ferroelectric phase transformations. In this case, the active shell region would be subject to elastic constraint by a relatively inactive BiFeO3-rich ferroelectric core having a high coercive field.
Therefore, the underlying mechanism is most likely based on heterogeneous ferroelectric switching behaviour within the shell and core regions, but at present it is not yet possible to identify which of these is the most active. Elastic interactions between the shell and the core give rise to predominantly reversible ferroelectric switching behaviour. It was reported by Liu et al.91 that the strain and polarisation mismatch can also induce lateral domain nucleation at the interface of the core and shell in 0.75Bi0.5Na0.5TiO3–0.25SrTiO3 ceramics. The occurrence of both inter-granular and intra-granular stresses could play an important role in the electro-mechanical fatigue behaviours of these core–shell structured materials, in addition to their influence on the polarisation- and strain-electric field relationships.
The core–shell type microstructure described here for BiFeO3–BaTiO3 ceramics has particular interest due to its influence on the reversibility of the polarisation switching behaviour and the electric field-induced strain. Recently, this type of microstructure has been reported in other Bi-based ferroelectrics.66,67,91,92 In the case of 0.75Bi0.5Na0.5TiO3–0.25SrTiO3, a large unipolar strain output of 0.3% at 4 kV mm−1 was attributed to the effects of reversible electric field-driven phase transformations in the shell region. On the other hand, to our knowledge core–shell microstructures have not been reported previously in BiFeO3–BaTiO3 ceramics.
In view of the previous studies on the influence of cooling rate on BF-based ceramics, we performed thermal quenching of the ceramics in air. The influence of such a procedure on the ferroelectric domain switching behaviour is illustrated by the P–E hysteresis loops shown in Fig. 6(b). It is evident that quenching greatly improved the polarisation switching behaviour of the ceramics; Pr values of 0.06 and 0.31 C m−2 were obtained for the as-sintered and quenched Mn-AC ceramics respectively. The observation of macro-sized ferroelectric domains throughout the grains in the air-quenched Mn-AC specimen, illustrated in Fig. 2(f), is directly associated with the enhancement in polarisation switching behaviour. At first sight, thermal quenching appears to eliminate the formation of core–shell structures based on the domain structures that are evident in the micrograph of the chemically-etched Mn-AC ceramic. However, microstructural examination of the air-quenched Mn-AC sample before etching revealed that the chemical inhomogeneity is still present, as shown in Fig. S1 (see the ESI†). The appearance of domains in the shell region for the air-quenched ceramic, in contrast to the lack of macro-domains in the case of the as-sintered material, indicates differences in ferroelectric ordering within the shell. With slow cooling (as-sintered), the shell tends to be pseudocubic with relaxor ferroelectric nature, while air-quenching transforms the shell into a long range-ordered ferroelectric state which is coherent with the core. Further evidence to support this argument was presented in the Section 3.3 above.
It is also worth noting that fast cooling has been reported widely in processing of BiFeO3-based solid solutions as a means to enhance their ferroelectric and piezoelectric properties; the underlying mechanisms are often unclear but usually attributed to ordering of charged defects.77,93–95 In a recent study by Kim et al.93 on the influence of cooling rate on the properties of undoped 0.75BiFeO3–0.25BaTiO3, the beneficial effects of fast cooling procedures were attributed to the influence of oxygen vacancies on the rhombohedral distortion and the transformation to an intermediate orthorhombic phase at high temperatures. In the present case, it is argued that the changes in ferroelectric behaviour are most likely to be associated with nanoscale phase separation, although further evidence (e.g. from TEM studies) is required to support this proposal.
The formation of the core–shell structure is attributed to kinetic factors and differences in reactivity during sintering, with the BiFeO3-rich core forming initially and the BaTiO3-rich shell forming at a later stage. Thermodynamic immiscibility between the BiFeO3 and BaTiO3 solid solutions could also play an important role, leading to further nanoscale segregation in the shell region during cooling. Quenching of the BF–BT ceramics in air from a temperature of 750 °C led to significant improvements in ferroelectric switching behaviour. The effects of such a procedure were particularly pronounced for the Mn-AC materials, leading to more clearly-defined peaks in the dielectric permittivity–temperature relationship and the appearance of ferroelectric domain structures within the shell region.
The results of the present study suggest that control of chemical heterogeneity in BF–BT ceramics by manipulation of processing methods and heat treatment procedures could lead to intriguing changes in the electro-mechanical properties associated with different types of ferroelectric switching behaviour. Further investigations of multiferroic/magnetoelectric properties are also warranted as a result of the formation of the multiferroic BiFeO3 phase grain core surrounded by the ferroelectric BaTiO3 solid solution.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c7tc04122e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |