Open Access Article
Yonghong Hu‡
*a,
Caixia Mao‡a,
Zhong Yanb,
Ting Shua,
Hao Nia,
Li Xuea and
Yunyi Wu
c
aSchool of Nuclear Technology and Chemistry & Biology, Hubei University of Science and Technology, Xianning 437100, China. E-mail: hchyh2001@tom.com; Tel: +86-0715-8263712
bCollege of Material Science and Engineering, Nanjing University of Science and Technology, Nanjing 210094, China
cDepartment of Electrical Engineering, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Kowloon, Hong Kong
First published on 23rd August 2018
Group-IV monochalcogenides (GeSe, SnSe, GeS, SnS) are a class of promising monolayer materials for nanoelectronic applications. However, the GeSe monolayer is the only direct semiconductor in the group-IV monochalcogenides, which limits their application in nanoelectronic fields. Stacking is usually a good strategy to design two-dimensional (2D) materials with novel properties. Taking these monolayer monochalcogenides as basic building blocks, various van der Waals (vdW) heterojunctions can be constructed by different stacking methods. In this study, we systematically investigated the structures, stabilities and electronic properties of thirty-six few-layer group-IV monochalcogenide heterojunctions. All the vdW heterojunctions are proved to be stable. The degree of stability of the few-layer heterojunctions is found to increase with the number of layers. The band gap values of heterojunctions are dependent not only on the components, but also on the stacking order. Five novel 2D direct semiconductors (SnSe/GeSe, GeS/SnS, SnSe/GeSe/SnSe, SnS/GeSe/SnSe and SnS/GeSe/SnSe) are obtained. It's found that biaxial strain can not only tune the values of band gap, but also change the type of the 2D materials. The band gaps of the heterojunctions monotonically increase with the increasing strain and most few-layer heterojunctions transform between direct and indirect semiconductors under biaxial strain. Five heterojunctions (SnSe/GeSe, GeS/SnS, GeSe/SnSe/SnS, SnS/GeSe/SnSe and GeSe/SnS/GeS/SnSe) are found to remain as direct semiconductors under tensile strain (0–0.1). Since the band gaps of these heterojunctions are easy to control in a suitable range, they may have potential applications in nanoelectronic fields.
Due to its high stability, low toxicity and similar structure to black phosphorus,11–13 group-IV monochalcogenides (GeS, GeSe, SnS and SnSe) have gained increasing attention and shown excellent optoelectronic properties.14–22 Among the four monochalcogenides, only GeSe exhibits a direct band gap.21 According to the report of Zhang et al., GeSe monolayer has five different configurations: α-GeSe, β-GeSe, γ-GeSe, δ-GeSe and ε-GeSe.22 Various GeSe nanosheets have been synthesized by different methods, which are promising materials in photodetector devices.14–19 Mukherjee et al. fabricated high-quality GeSe single crystal nanosheets using chemical vapor deposition technologies, and produced a Schottky photodetector based on those with high optical flow gain.17 Under high pressure and high temperature conditions, the electrical conductivity of GeSe is higher than both black phosphorus and graphene.23 All the 2D GeSe configurations are classified into two different phases, i.e. black-phase and blue-phase.24–27 Theoretical research results of Ji et al. showed that the work function of the black-phase GeSe doesn't meet the oxidation potential of O2/H2O, while the blue-phase GeSe is a suitable photocatalyst for water splitting.28 Recently, Mao et al. have fabricated single-layer GeSe crystal using mechanical stripping and laser thinning techniques.29 Photoluminescence experiments showed that monolayer GeSe has potential application in solar cell due to its proper absorption peak range.30
Stacking of 2D materials has become a popular and effective method for designing new 2D materials. For example, bilayer phosphorene and MoS2 exhibit more striking properties than a single layer sheet.31,32 vdW heterostructures with two types of 2D materials seem to be a magic way to break through the limitations of single 2D materials. For example, 2D SiGe/h-BN vdW heterojunction exhibits inspired electronic and optical properties.33 Previously, we reported on the stability and electronic properties of single-layer GeSe (direct bandgap and small carrier effective mass),21 and stimulated the researcher's attentions to the 2D group-IV monochalcogenides materials.34–40 For example, Shi et al. studied the anisotropic spin transport properties and strong visible light absorption of few-layer GeSe and SnSe.34 Hao et al. predicted theoretically that vacancy doped few-layer GeSe has high thermoelectric properties.35 Fan et al. performed theoretical studies on the electronic structures of GeSe nanobelts and nanosheets.36 Sun et al. fabricated 2D SnSe/GeSe heterojunction nanosheets by solution method.37 Wang et al. predicted that few-layer GeSe has potential applications in near-infrared short wave polarization detectors.38 Xue et al. produced high quality GeSe single crystal films and found their important applications in solar cells.39 Kamal et al. investigated the electronic structures of group-IV monochalcogenides by first-principles calculations and predicted their prospects in light-emitting diodes and solar cells.40 In addition, there may exist two types of 2D heterostructures due to the reduced dimensionality, namely, vertical heterostructure (vdW interaction) and lateral (in-plane) heterostructure. Compared to vertical heterostructures, the lateral heterostructures have many virtues, such as simpler band alignment, less interface region, more distinct phase separation etc41. 2D lateral heterostructure attracted great interests of theoretical and experimental researchers.42–47 Recently, Zhao et al. studied the band alignment and electronic properties of lateral heterosturctures of monolayer group-IV monochalcogenides and reported their potential application in high-efficiency solar cell.47
In the present work, we designed a group of few layered 2D vertical heterojunctions composed of group-IV monochalcogenides monolayers, namely, 2D GeS, GeSe, SnS and SnSe configurations. Through first-principle calculations, the geometric structure, stability and electronic properties are systematically investigated from a theoretical point of view. The vdW interactions of the monolayers are weak. Therefore the linear band gap dispersion state is not perturbed in the heterojunctions. The geometric structure, stability and electronic properties of 2D few-layer heterojunctions are calculated and analyzed. The band gaps of these few-layer heterojunctions are dependent on both their stacking order and components. Moreover, an impressive decrease of band gap in the few-layer heterojunctions is found, and the values of band gap are tunable under biaxial strain.
, where Etotal is the total binding energy, n is the number of monolayers in the heterojunction system and Emonoi is the ith monolayer which constitutes the heterojunction. In-plane biaxial strain is defined as ε = (a − a0)/a = (b − b0)/b, where a0 and b0 are the lattice constants of the studied vdW heterojunction, respectively. Correspondingly, a and b are the lattice constants along the x and z directions under biaxial strain.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Optimized crystal structure of the six vdW heterojunctions. Among them, yellow, green, orange, and gray balls represent S, Ge, Se, and Sn atoms, respectively. | ||
), distance between the two monolayers (d), binding energy (Eb), and band gap (Eg) of the vdW heterojunction crystals of group-IVA monochalcogenides. In the table, “I” represent indirect gap, and “D”represents direct gap
| Models | a (Å) | b (Å) | χ | (Å) |
d (Å) | Eb (eV) | Eg (eV) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GeSe/GeS | 3.87 | 4.07 | 4.2% | 2.52 | 3.14 | −49 | 0.85 I |
| SnSe/GeSe | 4.10 | 4.25 | 3.2% | 2.71 | 3.21 | −46 | 0.29 D |
| SnS/GeSe | 4.03 | 4.14 | 1.7% | 2.60 | 3.27 | −51 | 0.69 I |
| GeS/SnS | 3.94 | 4.16 | 5.9% | 2.57 | 3.21 | −35 | 0.73 D |
| GeS/SnSe | 4.00 | 4.28 | 7.5% | 2.65 | 3.03 | −33 | 0.64 I |
| SnS/SnSe | 4.19 | 4.23 | 2.2% | 2.74 | 3.29 | −42 | 0.73 I |
The crystal structures of the eighteen trilayer heterojunctions and twelve four-layer heterojunctions comprised of group-IV monochalcogenides monolayer are shown in Fig. S1 and S2.† The corresponding parameters of lattice constants, average bond lengths, the mismatches of lattice constants etc are listed in Tables S2 and S3 in the ESI.† It's found in Fig. S1 and S2† that six trilayer heterojunctions (SnS/GeS/SnS, GeS/SnS/GeS, SnSe/GeS/GeSe, SnSe/GeSe/SnSe, GeSe/SnSe/GeSe, GeSe/GeS/SnS) retain black-phase structure after geometry optimization, but other twelve trilayer heterojunctions and twelve four-layer heterojunctions undergo structural deformations. For some configurations, such as SnS/GeS/SnS and SnSe/GeS/GeSe etc, the stacking styles in the original structures of heterojunctions (AA stacking) are changed after geometry optimization, which is determined by our geometry optimization process based on the lowest energy principle. Comparing the lattice constants in Tables 1 and S1–S3,† it's found that the mismatch rates of lattice constants in the trilayer heterojunctions in our study are less than 4.9%, and those of four-layer heterojunctions are less than 3.6%, both of which are acceptable and able to yield credible simulation results. The average bond lengths in trilayer heterojunctions are in the range from 2.51 Å to 2.76 Å, while those of four-layer heterojunctions are in the range from 2.63 Å to 2.66 Å. This indicates that the average bond length may decrease with the number of layers. The average distances between the monolayers in trilayer heterojunctions are in the range from 2.74 Å to 3.39 Å, and those of four-layer heterojunctions are in the range from 2.98 Å to 3.42 Å. The average distance between the monolayers in few-layer heterojunctions is independent with the components. The values of binding energies of trilayer and four-layer heterojunctions are all negative, showing that they all have good stability. The average values of the binding energies of six bilayer, eighteen trilayer and twelve four-layer heterojunctions are −42.7 meV, −66.1 meV and −69.8 meV respectively, which means that the stability extent increases with the number of layers in heterojunctions due to vdW interactions.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Band structure and DOS of six heterojunction materials. The Fermi level is indicated by a dashed line. | ||
As shown in Fig. 2 and Table 1, SnSe/GeSe and GeS/SnS are direct band semiconductors, and the other bilayer heterojunctions are indirect band semiconductors. As for the trilayer and four-layer heterojunctions considered in this study, it's found from Fig. S3, S4, Tables S2 and S3† that three trilayer heterojunctions (SnSe/GeSe/SnSe, SnS/GeSe/SnSe and SnS/GeSe/SnSe) are direct band semiconductors, while the other fifteen trilayer heterojunctions and all the twelve four-layer heterojunctions are indirect semiconductors. As reported in previous studies,20,21 GeSe is the only direct semiconductor in the group-IV monochalcogenides monolayers. Here, five types of novel 2D direct semiconductors are obtained through just stacking these building blocks into vdW heterojunctions. In fact, semiconductors with direct energy gap have higher optical absorption coefficients than those with indirect gap. So they are more appropriate to make optoelectronic devices (light-emitting diodes and photovoltaic cells). Furthermore, although GeS and SnS monolayers are both indirect semiconductors, GeS/SnS heterojunctions is a direct semiconductor, which means that stacking is also a effective method to tune the electronic properties of materials. This provides a new way to design direct semiconductor with suitable band gap value needed in practical applications from vast amount of indirect semiconductors in nature.
To further understand the electronic structure of the vdW heterojunction materials, taking bilayer heterojunctions as examples, we calculated the density of states (DOS) and corresponding partial DOS (PDOS) of the heterojunctions (Fig. 2). As can be seen from the DOS and PDOS in Fig. 2, the total density of states of the conduction and valence bands is dominated by the p orbit near the Fermi surface. We also calculated the decomposition charge densities of the valence band top (VBM) and the conduction band bottom (CBM), as shown in Fig. 3. From Fig. 3, one can find that the charge density of VBM is mainly located around the Se and S atoms. In contrast, CBM is mainly attributed to the contribution of charge densities around the Ge and Sn atoms. These findings on VBM and CBM are consistent with the analysis of PDOS diagrams. For brevity, taking GeSe/GeS as examples, the DOS are projected into different atoms, as is shown in Fig. S5.† It's found that the VBM is mainly contributed by the p orbital of S or Se atoms, and the CBM is mainly contributed by the p orbital of Ge or Sn atoms.
In addition, for all the six vdW heterojunctions in our study, the charge density distributions of CBM are similar. However, the charge density of VBM shows different characteristics in the heterojunctions with direct band gaps. As shown in Fig. 3(a), (b), (d) and (f), the VBMs between the upper layer and the lower layer occur no charge density overlap, which is different from the phenomena in Fig. 3(c) and (e). Therefore, interlayers VBM charge density has a crucial influence on the band gap type of heterojunction.30
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Variations of the band gaps of the six 2D group-IVA monochalcogenides heterojunctions with biaxial strain. | ||
It can be seen from Fig. 4 that the band gaps of the six heterojunctions increase with the increase of biaxial strain, which shows that the strain has a significant and continuous effect on the band gap. As shown in Fig. 4, the band gap curve of SnSe/GeSe is obviously different from those of the other five heterojunctions, since it's approximately a straight line in the strain range from −0.04 to 0.10. While the curves corresponding to the other five 2D heterojunctions increase nonlinearly with strain. The analogue results can also be drawn from Fig. S6 and S7† that the band gaps of four trilayer and two four-layer heterojunctions increase linearly with the strain, because the corresponding curves are also approximately straight lines in the strain range from 0.00 to 0.10. Altogether, the band gaps of the all heterojunctions monotonically increase with the strain increase from −0.10 to 0.10, and the continuously adjustable band gap ranges of bilayer, trilayer and four-layer heterojunction are approximately (0–1.23 eV), (0–1.16 eV) and (0–0.95 eV) respectively. Upon compressed biaxial strain (−0.10, 0.00), the band gaps of all heterojunctions change to zero, indicating the transition from semiconductor to metal.
The change of applied strain not only leads to the change of the band gap values, but also usually leads to the transformations of the band gap types of the 2D materials. It is found from Tables S4–S6† that the band gap types of most few-layered heterojunctions considered in our work occur transformations between direct semiconductor and indirect semiconductor except for eight heterojunctions, namely, GeSe/GeS, SnS/SnSe, GeSe/SnSe/SnS, GeSe/GeS/SnS, SnS/GeSe/SnSe, GeS/SnSe/SnS, GeS/GeSe/SnS/SnSe and GeS/GeSe/SnSe/SnS heterojunctions. For brevity, taking SnSe/GeSe and GeSe/GeS vdW heterojunctions as examples, the energy band structures of SnSe/GeSe and GeSe/GeS heterojunctions under several different biaxial strains are plotted in Fig. 5. It can be seen from Fig. 5(a) that SnSe/GeSe heterojunction remains direct semiconductor under tensile strain, but it changes to indirect semiconductor under compressive strain. And when the compressive strain is less than −0.06, SnSe/GeSe heterojunction becomes metallic. It can be seen from Fig. 5(b) that the GeSe/GeS heterojunction remains as an indirect semiconductor whenever under tensile or compressive strain. When the compressive strain is less than −0.08, GeSe/GeS heterojunction becomes metallic.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Electron band structure of (a) SnSe/GeSe and (b) GeSe/GeS heterojunction under biaxial stress. | ||
It is surprisingly that five few-layer vdW heterojunctions (SnSe/GeSe, GeS/SnS, GeSe/SnSe/SnS, SnS/GeSe/SnSe, GeSe/SnS/GeS/SnSe) are found to remain direct semiconductors under tensile strain, as can be seen in Tables S4–S6 in the ESI.† Through applying tensile biaxial strain, the tunable band-gap range (0–0.92 eV) of these few-layer heterojunctions is slightly wider than that in bilayer phosphorene (0–0.85),63 which shows that these vdW heterojunction materials are also promising for applications in optoelectronics.
The band gaps of the few-layer vdW heterojunctions are all significantly reduced compared with their monolayers. Therefore, we conclude that vdW stacking is an effective band regulation method, and this method can be used properly in designing the narrow band gap 2D heterojunction materials. Five novel 2D direct semiconductors (SnSe/GeSe, GeS/SnS, SnSe/GeSe/SnSe, SnS/GeSe/SnSe and SnS/GeSe/SnSe) are obtained, which are appropriate to make optoelectronic devices. The band gap values of heterojunction are dependent with not only the components of the heterojunction, but also the stacking order of the building blocks.
Biaxial strain is found to make significant and continuous effects on the band gaps of these heterojunctions. The band gaps of the heterojunctions all monotonically increase with the increase of strain, and the continuously adjustable band gap ranges of few-layer heterojunctions are wide enough for solar cell applications. Upon compressed biaxial strain, all heterojunctions change from semiconductors to metals. In addition, stain can not only tune the band gap, but also change the band gap types of the 2D materials. Five few-layer heterojunctions (SnSe/GeSe, GeS/SnS, GeSe/SnSe/SnS, SnS/GeSe/SnSe and GeSe/SnS/GeS/SnSe) are found to remain direct band gap semiconductors under tensile strain. And the band gaps can be tuned in (0, 0.92 eV), which shows that these materials are promising for applications in optoelectronics. Therefore, based on the group IV mono-chalcogenide stacking, the formed vdW heterojunctions shows great application prospects in nanoelectronic fields.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Details of optimized crystal structure and band structures of the few-layer heterojunctions, the band gaps variations of the trilayer and four-layer heterojunctions with biaxial strain, the lattice constants, average bond length, and band gap of the monolayers, trilayer and four-layer heterojunctions of group-IVA monochalcogenides and the band structure variations with biaxial stress for the few-layer heterojunctions. See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra05086d |
| ‡ These authors contribute equally. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |