S. I.
Sadovnikov
* and
A. I.
Gusev
Institute of Solid State Chemistry, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Ekaterinburg 620990, Russia. E-mail: sadovnikov@ihim.uran.ru
First published on 19th September 2017
Stellate sea-urchin-like silver particles with 24 to 56 rays of 30–50 μm in length have been synthesized by chemical reduction of silver nitrate aqueous solution by thiocarbamide alkaline solution. The synthesis was carried out under solar irradiation at room temperature. The stellate Ag particles are hydrophobic; their relative density is smaller than that of water. By varying the pH and the ratio between the concentrations of reagents, it is possible to produce fine-dispersed silver powders and films from stellate particles with different ray lengths.
Fine-dispersed silver powders are produced by different methods, including polyol synthesis,4,15,16 chemical and photochemical reduction1,17 hydro- and solvothermal synthesis,18,19 and green biosynthesis.20 Note that the formation of silver particles as an impurity is often observed during chemical synthesis of silver sulfide.21,22 Electrolysis is widely used in the production of silver powders.23,24 Silver nanodendrites are synthesized by electrodeposition25 and reduction from AgNO3.26 In physical processes, Ag particles are generally synthesized by evaporation–condensation method or by laser ablation of metallic bulk materials in solution.27–30
Silver nanoparticles usually have a spherical shape. In the last decade a new trend appeared connected with the production of non-spherical Ag particles of different morphology (flat triangles,31 plates,32 cubes,15 prisms,31 rods,33 wires,4,33 nano- and microdendrites,24–26etc.).
The preparation of sea-urchin-like particles of copper,34 nickel,35,36 zinc oxide doped with iron,37 and silver38 by different methods is described in the literature. To date, there are no publications devoted to the synthesis and properties of stellate Ag particles.
In this work, fine-dispersed powders of silver metal with a specific morphology of stellate sea-urchin-like multi-ray particles have been produced by a simple green method of silver nitrate reduction.
The pH value of the solutions was controlled by a pH/conductivity/TDS Tester HI 98130 ionometer (Hanna Instruments).
The synthesized deposits (powders) and films were examined using a Shimadzu XRD-7000 diffractometer and a STADI-P (STOE) diffractometer in CuKα1,2-radiation in the angle interval 2θ = 15–110° with a step of Δ(2θ) = 0.02° and a scanning time of 10 s per point. The crystal lattice parameters were determined and the final structure refinement was carried out with the use of the X'Pert software suite.39 The qualitative and quantitative phase compositions were estimated by means of the Match! Version 1.10 program package.40
The morphology of the synthesized fine-dispersed silver particles was studied by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) using a Jeol JSM LA 6390 microscope with a JED 2300 Energy Dispersive X-ray Analyzer. The elemental composition of Ag particles was carried out on the same microscope with the use of EDX analysis.
The optical reflectance spectra of the synthesized powders were measured on a Shimadzu UV-2401PC spectrophotometer and the optical absorption spectra of the synthesized films were obtained on an Edinburgh LP980 Fluorescence Spectrometer spectrofluorometer at 298 K.
The density ρstell of the synthesized fine-dispersed silver powders was determined on a Micromeritics AccuPyc II 1340 helium pycnometer.
The contact angle θ was measured with a Dataphysics OCA20 contact angle system at 298 K. The average contact angle value was obtained by this measurement at three different positions of a water droplet on an Ag film surface formed on the glass substrate.
Mixed solutions with pH values ranging from 9 to 10 were prepared from the initial aqueous solutions of (NH2)2CS and NH4OH. Mixed solutions with pH = 9 were prepared by adding 0.005 ml of NH4OH solution to 100 ml of thiocarbamide solution. For the production of mixed solutions with pH > 9, 0.01 to 0.5 ml of ammonia solution was added to 100 ml of thiocarbamide solution. In particular, the solution with pH = 10 was prepared by adding 0.5 ml of NH4OH solution to 100 ml of thiocarbamide solution. The concentrations of (NH2)2CS and NH4OH in the mixed alkaline solution with pH = 9 were 50 and 0.5 mmol l−1, and in the mixed solution with pH = 10 they amounted to 50 and 50 mmol l−1 (Table 1). The concentration of NH4OH in the mixed solutions with intermediate pH values (9 < pH < 10) varied from 1 to 40 mmol l−1.
No. | Concentration of reagents in aqueous solutions (mmol l−1) | pH of mixed alkaline solution | Concentration of reagents in reaction mixtures (mmol l−1) | Stellate particles | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AgNO3 | Mixed alkaline solution | AgNO3 | (NH2)2CS | NH4OH | L max ±5 (μm) | ρ stell ±0.20 (g cm−3) | Calculation | ||||
(NH2)2CS | NH4OH | ρ stell (g cm−3) | S sp (m2 g−1) | ||||||||
a Estimated values of ρstell for stellate Ag particles with core radius of 3 μm. b Estimated values of Ssp for stellate Ag particles with core radius of 3 μm and rays of conical or trihedral pyramidal form. | |||||||||||
1 | 50 | 50 | 0.5 | 9 | 50 | 5 | 0.05 | 60 | 0.40 | 0.21 ± 0.01 | 0.24–0.41 |
2 | 50 | 50 | 20 | 9.5 | 50 | 5 | 2.0 | 70 | 0.37 | 0.15 ± 0.01 | 0.25–0.42 |
3 | 50 | 50 | 50 | 10 | 50 | 5 | 5 | 80 | — | 0.12 ± 0.01 | 0.25–0.43 |
The fine-dispersed Ag powders were synthesized at room temperature under solar irradiation in the following way:
10 ml of mixed alkaline solution was gradually added to 100 ml of the initial solution of AgNO3 with a concentration of 50 mmol l−1 at a rate of 0.005 ml s−1. The ratio of concentrations of silver nitrate, thiocarbamide and ammonium hydroxide [AgNO3]:
[(NH2)2CS]
:
[NH4OH] in the reaction mixtures with different pH values ranged from 1
:
0.1
:
0.001 to 1
:
0.1
:
0.1. The duration of synthesis was 30–60 min. The synthesized solution was kept in sunlight for one day. As a result, a layer of black deposit appeared on the bottom of the glass with the synthesized solution, a black film was formed on the walls, and a pale-yellow film emerged on the surface of the solution. The film collected from the surface of the solution was dried in air at 313 K; as a result, a fine-dispersed powder was obtained. The quantitative X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis revealed that this powder (or the pale-yellow surface film) is face-centered cubic (space group Fm
m) silver Ag with preferable orientation in the direction [111] (Fig. 1a). In addition, a weak peak is observed in the XRD pattern of the Ag film in the angle interval 2θ = 34.1–34.5°; this peak corresponds to two neighboring diffraction reflections (−122) and (022) of impurity monoclinic silver sulfide.
The quantitative analysis of the XRD pattern of the black deposit and the comparison with the XRD data41–43 showed that the observed set of diffraction reflections corresponds to monoclinic (space group P21/c) silver sulfide Ag2S (Fig. 1b). The appreciable broadening of the silver sulfide diffraction reflections (Fig. 1b) is indicative of the small size of the Ag2S particles; the evaluation of the nanoparticle size from the broadening of non-overlapping reflections gives the value D = 50 ± 8 nm. The XRD pattern of Ag2S also contains weak reflections of the second phase, which is cubic metallic Ag. According to the quantitative phase analysis data, the content of the metallic silver phase is equal to ∼7.5 wt%.
For the second synthesis route, for the preparation of silver films we used a glass substrate. The synthesis was performed at room temperature under solar irradiation by successive ionic layer adsorption and reaction (SILAR). The substrate was sequentially immerged in a vessel with deionized distilled water, then into AgNO3 solution for 15 s, then again into distilled water, and after that into a mixed alkaline solution (Fig. 2). This four-stage cycle was repeated from 15 to 30 times, and after each fifth cycle the vessels with water were changed for vessels with fresh deionized distilled water. Silver particles were formed at the last stage of the cycle, when the substrate with Ag2+ ions adsorbed on the surface was immerged into the alkaline solution, where silver was reduced. The formation of a thin layer of bright yellow particles was visually observed on the “substrate–silver nitrate solution” interface. After 30 cycles, a black deposit in the form of a film appeared on the walls of the vessel with AgNO3 solution, and upon exposure of this solution to light for 1 day a yellow film was formed on its surface. The XRD patterns of the film that emerged on the surface of the solution and the film that formed on the substrate are similar to the XRD pattern in Fig. 1a and correspond to cubic Ag. The XRD pattern of the deposit (Fig. 1c) is identical to the XRD pattern (Fig. 1b) obtained from the same deposit in the first synthesis option and corresponds to nanocrystalline monoclinic sulfide Ag2S with a small (∼3 wt%) impurity of metallic Ag.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The scheme of the second synthesis route by the SILAR method: (a and c) deionized distilled water, (b) solution of AgNO3, and (d) mixed alkaline solution. |
Silver, as the main product of the synthesis, is formed as a result of several concurrent reactions.
The ammonia molecules bind Ag+ ions into complex ions [Ag(NH3)2]+. The thiocarbamide (NH2)2CS in the alkaline aqueous solution is hydrolyzed with the formation of cyanamide N2H2C and S2− ions. The solubility product Ksp of silver sulfide is very small (Ksp = 6.3 × 10−50 at 298 K),44 therefore the silver sulfide Ag2S is always formed in the presence of S2− ions in the aqueous solution of AgNO3. With this in mind, the deposition of Ag2S from AgNO3, (NH2)2CS and NH4OH solutions take place through the following reactions:
AgNO3 + 2NH4OH → [Ag(NH3)2]NO3 + 2H2O | (1) |
(NH2)2CS + 2OH− → N2H2C + S2− + 2H2O | (2) |
2[Ag(NH3)2]NO3 + S2− → Ag2S↓ + 2NO3− + 4NH3 | (3) |
Since our major task was to prepare a fine-dispersed silver powder, we performed the synthesis using a minimal amount of (NH2)2CS, which was insufficient for the deposition of all silver in the form of sulfide. In that case, the aqueous solution contained a large quantity of free complexes [Ag(NH3)2]NO3, which were reduced by cyanamide N2H2C to metallic Ag under solar irradiation at room temperature:
![]() | (4) |
The scanning electron microscopy of the silver metal film revealed that it is formed of stellate sea-urchin-like particles having from 24 to 56 pyramidal and wedge-shaped rays 30–50 μm in length and a medium-sized core of 5–6 μm (Fig. 3). Owing to the plasticity of silver, some rays were distorted during sample preparation. Fig. 3e displays a microphotograph of a stellate Ag particle ray with an indication of the scanning area on which the energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis was performed. The cumulative elemental EDX analysis is presented in Fig. 3f. According to the EDX data, the examined film contains 99.9 ± 0.1 wt% silver, i.e. it is metallic Ag.
It can be supposed that the silver sulfide nanoparticles appearing at the initial stage of synthesis promote the deposition of Ag atoms, which form stellate silver particles during subsequent growth. This can be confirmed by the presence of a small amount of silver impurity on the XRD patterns of Ag2S deposits. A similar effect of initially formed Ag2S clusters on heterogeneous nucleation of silver nanoparticles in the form of cubes was described in previous work.15
Gradual growth of silver rays in different directions (Fig. 3) decreases the wettability of stellate particles since they repel liquid as a result of air capture by the space between the rays, i.e. the microscopic texture of the rough surface. Earlier it was shown that multi-scale topography of the relief strengthens the water repellency of surfaces (the so-called “lotus effect”).9,45
Theoretical analysis and model calculations of volume, mass, relative density and specific surface area of stellate silver particles depending on the size of particles, numbers and lengths of rays are presented in the ESI file.†
The total real volume Vpart of a stellate particle is equal to the sum of the volumes of its core and rays, i.e. Vpart = (4π/3)r2(r + h) where r is the radius of the particle core and h is the length (height) of ray (see ESI†). The volume Vnonwet of space occupied by a stellate Ag particle in the case of nonwettability of its rays is tens of times larger than the real volume Vpart of silver entering into the particle. The relative density of stellate particles can be theoretically determined as ρstell = (Vpart/Vnonwet)ρAg, where ρAg = 10.5 g cm−3 is the density of silver. For example, the volume Vpart of a 32-ray particle with a core with 3 μm radius and the maximal distance between the ends of oppositely directed rays Lmax = 27 μm is equal to ∼510 μm3. The volume Vnonwet of space occupied by this particle with the assumption of partial nonwettability of its rays is ∼5280 μm3 (Table S1, ESI†). Taking this into consideration, the relative density ρstell of stellate Ag particles of such size is ∼1.01 g cm−3, i.e. slightly larger than the density of water. As the ray length increases, the relative density ρstell of stellate Ag particles lowers. For example, the volume Vpart of a 32-ray particle with the same core size but with the maximal distance between the ends of oppositely directed rays Lmax = 70 μm is equal to ∼1320 μm3. The volume V of space occupied by this particle is equal to ∼91950 μm3, and the relative density ρstell is only ∼0.15 g cm−3 (Table S1, ESI†). Thus, as the ray length (height) increases, the relative density ρstell of stellate Ag particles becomes smaller than the density of aqueous solution, and the particles come to the surface of the solution. Indeed, a film of stellate Ag particles does not appear on the surface of the solution at once, but a day after the beginning of the synthesis. The model dependence of the relative density ρstell of stellate Ag particles on the core radius r and length (height) h of the rays is displayed in Fig. 4.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Relative density ρstell of stellate Ag particles as a function of core radius r and ray length (height) h. The density of the aqueous solution is shown by the red line. (○) experimentally measured relative density ρstell of fine-dispersed Ag powders prepared from the reaction mixtures (1) and (2). |
Experimental measurements of the density of fine-dispersed Ag powders prepared from the reaction mixtures (1) and (2) gave values 0.40 ± 0.20 and 0.37 ± 0.20 g cm−3, respectively, which satisfactorily agree with the estimated values of relative density ρstell (Table 1). A large measurement error is caused by the small mass of powder studied. The measured low density of Ag powder is its relative density ρstell, the magnitude of which is caused by the superhydrophobicity of the powder owing to the almost full nonwettability of the surface. Earlier, the influence of superhydrophobicity of powders on reduction of their measured density was explained in previous work.46
The coexistence of Ag and Ag2S particles both in the film on the glass walls and in the deposit at the bottom of the glass is confirmed by the SEM data (Fig. 5 and 6).
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 SEM image of a film deposited on the glass walls. A dark-grey film of Ag2S with light nuclei of silver particles and ingrown multi-ray Ag particles are visible. |
Fig. 5 shows an SEM image of the film taken from the glass wall. Silver sulfide is a semiconductor, and silver is a metal, therefore during electron microscopy studies silver emits more strongly than silver sulfide. On the SEM image this manifests itself in different color shades: silver looks more bright and light, while silver sulfide has a grey color. At first, metallic silver nuclei appear on the dark-grey film of Ag2S, which are seen as light spots. Then silver nuclei grow giving rise to cubic particles of size 2–3 μm. Stellate silver particles with ingrown rays are seen to the left of the center. The growth of rays in different directions leads to the gradual formation of large stellate particles.
Silver sulfide nanoparticles and ingrown silver rays in the deposit taken from the glass bottom after 1 day of exposure of the solution to light are demonstrated in Fig. 6. The agglomerates formed by Ag2S nanoparticles less than 100 nm in size resemble small blossom clusters. A compact bundle of long silver rays is well visible in the center, and the same compactly connected silver rays are seen at the top on the right. The silver rays in the observed Ag particles grew only in opposite directions. The density of such Ag particles is greater than that of the aqueous solution, and they do not come to the surface of the solution, but remain in the deposit.
Four stages of silver particles growth from nucleation to stellate Ag particles are shown in Fig. 7. Primarily, Ag nuclei appear on the silver sulfide film. In the second stage, cubic Ag particles with edge length 0.5–0.8 μm grow from the nuclei. In the third stage, rays begin to grow at the vertices of the cubic particles and the particle size becomes as much as 2–3 μm. The last stage represents gradual growth of long rays and the final formation of large stellate sea-urchin-like particles.
The particles of metallic silver show a characteristic reflectance and absorption in the visible range of 390–450 nm of the electromagnetic spectrum owing to surface plasmon resonance (SPR). The position of the band caused by the SPR depends on the size and the shape of the silver particles. For example, for spherical Ag nanoparticles 30–140 nm in size, the band was observed in the region of 400–460 nm,47 and for Ag nanofibers with a diameter of 12–20 nm, the absorption peak was observed at 376 nm.48 Several bands can be observed in the absorption spectra of larger particles of complex shape with sharp edges. For example, for planar triangular Ag nanoprisms with edge length of ∼200 nm and thickness of ∼20 nm, absorption spectra display two peaks located at 342 and 932 nm.49
We measured the reflectance spectra of synthesized fine-dispersed powders from stellate Ag particles. In order to transform the reflectance spectra to the absorption spectra, the reflection function F(R∞) = (1 − R)2/(2R) is used. Function F(R∞) = (1 − R)2/2R is determined from the reflectivity R, measured in relative units, and is proportional to the absorption coefficient σ(ω), i.e. F(R∞) ∼ σ(ω). UV-vis reflectance and absorption spectra of fine-dispersed powders from stellate Ag particles with Lmax = 60 and 80 nm, constructed in the coordinates “F(R∞)–(λ)”, are shown in Fig. 8. These Ag powders were synthesized from reaction mixtures (1) and (3) (Table 1).
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 The UV-vis spectra of (a) optical reflectance and (b) absorption of fine-dispersed powders synthesized from reaction mixtures (1) and (3) (Table 1). |
The UV-vis reflectance and absorption spectra of the powder of stellate Ag particles contain an intense peak in the region of 300–315 nm and a weak line in the region of about 370 nm, which correspond to metallic silver. In the UV-vis reflectance and absorption spectra of the Ag powder synthesized from reaction mixture (3) and containing larger silver particles, the most intense peak is observed at about 304 nm. For the Ag powder with smaller particles synthesized from reaction mixture (1), the intense peak is present in the UV-vis spectra at ∼317 nm (Fig. 8).
Fig. 9 displays a UV-vis absorption spectrum of a film of stellate Ag particles on a glass substrate. Apparently, strong absorption without separation into individual peaks is caused by the sufficiently large film thickness, which is more than 30 μm. A wide absorption band is present in the interval from 280 to 550 nm, an explicit maximum of absorption is observed at ∼320 nm, and there is also a shoulder in the region of 450–460 nm. The etching of Ag film led to a general decrease in absorption, but it was not possible to separate the individual peaks.
The stellate Ag particles produced from the solution with pH = 10 have the largest ray length and the lowest relative density (Table 1).
Silver powder with stellate particle morphology can be synthesized only in reaction mixtures with the [AgNO3]:
[(NH2)2CS]
:
[NH4OH] concentration ratio ranging from 1
:
0.1
:
0.001 to 1
:
0.1
:
0.1. If the relative concentration of ammonium hydroxide in the reaction mixture is less than 0.001, thiocarbamide does not dissociate with the formation of cyanamide N2H2C, and silver is not reduced. If the relative concentration of ammonium hydroxide in the reaction mixture is larger than 0.1, the formation of silver sulfide becomes the main reaction. Silver sulfide is also formed when the relative concentration of thiocarbamide in the reaction mixture is larger than 0.1.
On the one hand, the multi-ray silver particles have a distorted shape resembling stellate polyhedra ranging from a great 20-ray stellate dodecahedron to a large 60-vertex stellate icosahedron (17th stellation of icosahedron) (Fig. 10). The ray length of stellate Ag particles is determined by the conditions of synthesis and is not connected with the symmetry relations typical of stellate polyhedra. On the other hand, the synthesized silver particles with long thin rays resemble sea urchins.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 The appearance of a 60-vertex stellate icosahedron, synthesized stellate Ag particle and sea-urchin (from left to right). |
The growth of rays can be owing to uneven distribution of static charges on the nuclei surface. It is known that enhanced charge is observed on sharp ends of solid particles. Apparently, the growth of rays beginning at the vertices of cubic silver nuclei is due to the negative static charge of vertices, to which Ag+ cations are attracted. The growth of rays in the direction from the center to the vertices of the cubic nucleus corresponds to successive occupation of (111) planes and equivalent planes with the largest atomic density by silver atoms and is in agreement with the presence of preferable orientation in the direction [111] in the examined Ag particles as revealed with the XRD method.
The synthesized fine-dispersed powder containing stellate silver particles with the maximal distance between the ends of oppositely directed rays Lmax = 60–70 μm has a small relative density of 0.21–0.15 g cm−3 (Table S1, ESI†), which is less than the density of water. Due to this fact, as well as to low wettability, the synthesized powder comes to the surface of the reaction solution in the form of a film, which considerably facilitates its removal from the mother solution. An important advantage of the fine-dispersed silver powder is the low wettability of its particles, which serves as a prerequisite for potential application of this powder or films made thereof as superhydrophobic materials. The superhydrophobicity of a surface is connected with its topology, texture and roughness, or the roughness of its individual particles.50 Preliminary measurement of the limiting wetting angle (or contact angle) θ of the synthesized silver film wetted with distilled water (Fig. 11) showed that the contact angle θ is equal to 155–160°, whereas that of ordinary silver is from 38 to 63°.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 A water droplet on the surface of the film of stellate Ag particles. The contact angle θ is equal to ∼156°. |
The combination of specific morphology and roughness with low surface energy is responsible for the superhydrophobicity and provides the stability of superhydrophobic surfaces. Indeed, in the simple case, the wetting of a surface by a liquid is determined by the energy of interaction of the liquid with this surface and is characterized by a wetting angle θ. Equilibrium wetting angle depends on the surface tension at the interfaces of liquid and solid phases. The Wenzel–Cassie model51,52 is used for the description of superhydrophobic surfaces of nanopowders, when the cavities of a surface texture are filled by air.
The contact angle of the Ag film is ∼156° (Fig. 11). This result indicates that the superhydrophobic film from stellate Ag particles has a high surface roughness due to the Ag particle morphology and low surface free energy. The little shape deformation of the water droplet observed under the influence of its weight also proves that the low surface energy of the Ag film studied is an important factor for its superhydrophobic properties.
It should be noted that superhydrophobic stellate Ag particles are still a rather exotic material. Sponge-based materials and mesh-based materials with soot, silica nanoparticles and others are the most widespread superhydrophobic materials (see, for example, a series of publications53–55 by Jian Li and co-authors).
In the synthesized fine-dispersed silver powder, owing to the particle morphology, the cavities of the surface texture are occupied by air, which provides their nonwettability with any liquids.
The specific surface area of stellate silver particles depends on the number and length of rays (see Table S2 and Fig. S1, ESI†). In Fig. S1,† the region between the surfaces I and II corresponds to the specific surface area Ssp, which is an average between the minimal (for stellate particles with conical rays) and the maximal (for stellate particles with rays in the form of a trihedral pyramid) specific surface area. For stellate Ag particles with core radius of 3 μm, the specific surface area ranges from 0.25 to 0.44 m2 g−1 (Table 1). This is 3–5 times more than the specific surface area of usual silver powders with average particle radius of ∼3 μm.
Unlike other methods of synthesis of sea-urchin-like particles described in the literature,34–38 the specificity of preparing stellate silver particles by the method of chemical reduction is directly related to the participation of Ag in photochemical reactions, which are the basis of the proposed method. We do not exclude the possibility of synthesis of stellate particles of other metals by the described method, but this is an independent problem.
The location of a large number of atoms on the faces and especially edges and vertices of the stellate particles make the synthesized Ag powder an attractive material for application in catalysis. On the one hand, it can be used directly as a catalyst for hydrogen evolution from aqueous solutions under visible light irradiation. On the other hand, owing to the large specific surface area, the fine-dispersed Ag powder can serve as a catalyst support.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Estimation of the relative density ρstell and specific surface area Ssp of stellate Ag particles. See DOI: 10.1039/c7ta07158b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |