Jiangbin Su†
ab and
Xianfang Zhu
*ac
aChina-Australia Joint Laboratory for Functional Nanomaterials & Physics Department, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, People's Republic of China. E-mail: zhux@xmu.edu.cn
bExperiment Center of Electronic Science and Technology, School of Mathematics and Physics, Changzhou University, Changzhou 213164, People's Republic of China
cInstitute of Biomimetics and Soft Matter, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, People's Republic of China
First published on 27th September 2017
At room temperature, an intriguing athermal uniform elongation and accelerated radial shrinkage in a straight and uniform amorphous SiOx nanowire (a-SiOx NW) as purely induced by uniform electron beam (e-beam) irradiation (without any external tensile pulling) was in situ observed and investigated in transmission electron microscope. According to a new model for NW taking into account the NW nanocurvature over its surface as well as the beam-induced athermal activation, a kinetic relationship between the shrinking radius and the irradiation time was established. The fitting results demonstrated that a curvature-dependent surface energy at the nanoscale (so-called nanocurvature effect) much higher than that predicted from the existing theories was exerted on the elongation and shrinkage of the NW. At the same time, the so-induced plastic flow of massive atoms and surface diffusion of atoms presented as well a further direct experimental evidence for our predicted soft mode and instability of atomic vibration as induced under energetic beam irradiation in amorphous materials. The study has important implications for the nanoprocessing or nanostability of future NW-based structures or devices. More importantly, it further demonstrates that the nanocurvature effect and the beam-induced atomic vibration soft mode and instability effect, which have been normally neglected or inadequately taken into account in the current literature, are universal concepts and applicable to explanation of energetic beam-induced nanoinstability or nanoprocessing of low dimensional nanostructure in general.
Based on the above consideration, in this paper we particularly study the uniform elongation and radial shrinkage of a-SiOx NWs as purely induced by a uniform irradiation of non-focused e-beam in an in situ TEM. It was observed that the straight and uniform a-SiOx NW presented a tensile pulling-free uniform plastic elongation and an accelerated uniform radial shrinkage at the nanoscale intriguingly. According to our new model for NW taking into account the nanocurvature of the wire, the kinetic relationship between the shrinking wire radius and the irradiation time was established. The fitting results showed a much higher, curvature-dependent wire surface energy at the nanoscale than that predicted from the existing theories on the shrinkage (that is, a pronounced nanocurvature effect on the elongation and shrinkage). Furthermore, the arresting plastic flow of massive atoms and surface diffusion of atoms at room temperature demonstrate a direct experimental evidence for our predicted athermal soft mode and instability of atomic vibration as induced under non-focused, uniform e-beam irradiation in condensed matter.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The change of length of the NW with the irradiation time as measured from Fig. 1. The length is measured as the length of the irradiated wire segment between the two red feature dots as shown in Fig. 1 to trace the change of wire length. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 The uniform shrinkage of the SiOx NW radius (r) with the irradiation time (t) as observed in Fig. 1. The dashed line is the fitting result according to the eqn (8) with a value of the constant b at about 3.5. |
The interaction between energetic e-beam and nanostructures including low dimensional nanostructures (LDNs) has been conventionally attributed to knock-on mechanism14 or even e-beam heating effect.1,16,17 However, our previous experiments demonstrated that the knock-on mechanism and the related simulations neither are fully consistent with, nor can offer a full explanation for, the experimentally observed nanostructure change and evolution (i.e., nanoprocessing or nanostability), especially the above tensile pulling-free uniform elongation and the accelerated radial shrinkage at the nanoscale during the irradiation. This is because the existing theories such as the knock-on mechanism and their related simulations were at the first place built based on consideration of the nature of equilibrium, symmetry, periodicity, and linearity of bulk crystalline structure or its approximation, whereas the energetic beam (including electron, ion and photon beams)-induced nanoprocessing or nanostability of nanostructure is intrinsically of non-equilibrium, amorphous, and non-linear nature. Moreover, the atomic movements at the scale of atomic bond length are difficult to be observed with the current TEM techniques, and thus a direct comparison of the simulated atomic movements with the experimental results is impossible. On the other hand, as mentioned in the experimental part, due to the extremely high ratio of surface to volume of NW at the nanoscale, the e-beam irradiation is determined to heat the specimen by no more than a few degrees10,13,14 and the dominant irradiation effect should be athermal. In the experiment, we also observed that even after the above elongation and shrinkage processed for a time, they would stop immediately once the irradiation was suspended. This further demonstrates that the processes are predominately driven by an irradiation-induced, instant, athermal activation rather than a beam heating-induced, slow, thermal activation. In fact, our previous work on the energetic beam irradiation-induced nanoinstability or nanoprocessing of LDNs, such as nanocavities in Si,11 carbon nanotubes15,18,19 and amorphous SiOx nanowires6,10 has proven that our proposed novel nanocurvature effect11 and energetic beam-induced atomic vibration soft mode and instability effect11 are universal concepts and applicable in the prediction or explanation of all the above energetic beam irradiation-induced nanophenomena. In the following, we attempt to reveal the above two effects on the uniform elongation and the accelerated uniform radial shrinkage at the nanoscale of a-SiOx NW under uniform e-beam irradiation.
For the nanocurvature effect on a NW, we can suppose that, similar to the particle case,11 when the radius r of a NW approaches its atomic bond length d, a positive nanocurvature on the highly curved wire surface will become appreciable. Such a positive nanocurvature would cause an additional tensile stress on the electron cloud structure of surface atoms which would lead to a dramatic increase in surface energy of the NW as schematically shown in Fig. 4(a). This dramatically increased surface energy would lower the energy barrier for the surface atoms to migrate or escape thus causing an intrinsic nanoinstability in the NW. Especially, it would give rise to a strong tendency of self-contraction of the nanocurved wire surface and thus provide a thermodynamic driving force for the wire to shrink in the radius direction and a corresponding massive atom plastic flow as self-extruded towards two ends of the wire.
Although the positive nanocurvature on a NW can lower the energy barrier of surface atoms and thus cause the nanoinstability thermodynamically, a further assistance from the external excitation such as energetic beam irradiation is still needed to soften the wire and kinetically activate the shrinkage or contraction and the plastic flow. In the case of energetic e-beam irradiation in TEM, we can assume that beam energy deposition rate6 of the incident energetic beam can be so fast that there is no enough time for the deposited energy to transfer to thermal vibration energy of atoms within a single period of atomic vibration. In this way, the mode of atom thermal vibration would be softened or the vibration of atoms would lose stability.11 The induced soft mode or instability of the atomic vibration can further suppress the energy barrier for the atoms to migrate or escape and finally make the structure changes kinetically possible.
The above processes can be schematically illustrated in Fig. 4(b). When the NW segment is subjected to a uniform irradiation of e-beam, the mode of the atom thermal vibration is softened or the vibration of atoms loses stability within the whole irradiated NW segment. As a result, the energy barriers of atoms in the NW segment were suppressed, and the atoms became unstable and easy to diffuse or even flow towards two ends of the wire or evaporate into the vacuum under driving of the effect of self-extruding or self-contracting of the nanocurved wire surface. Meanwhile, since the nanocurvature distributed over the wire surface is also uniform along the wire axis, the as-induced athermal diffusion and athermal evaporation (we can also simply call them as diffusion and evaporation for short) of atoms (including athermal plastic flow of bulk massive atoms) would proceed uniformly along the wire axis. In this way, as demonstrated in Fig. 1 and further illustrated in Fig. 4(b), a uniform axial elongation and a uniform radial shrinkage would occur in the a-SiOx NW during the irradiation of a uniform e-beam. Thus, the novel plastic flow of massive atoms and surface diffusion of atoms offer a direct experimental evidence for our predicted athermal soft mode and instability of atomic vibration as induced by uniform e-beam irradiation in condensed matter. In particular, with the increase of irradiation time, the NW became thinner and demonstrated an intriguing accelerated radial shrinkage at the nanoscale as shown in Fig. 3. This can be attributed to the nanocurvature effect of the NW during the NW radius is thinning down to the nanoscale.
It is expected that only diffusion of atoms (including plastic flow of massive atoms) leads to the axial elongation of NW whereas both evaporation and diffusion of atoms result in the radial shrinkage of NW. Also, in ref. 6, it has been reported that the relative contribution of the atom diffusion or the atom evaporation to the structural changes of NW is fully adjustable or tunable by the irradiation parameters which determine the beam energy deposition rate such as accelerating voltage and beam current density, etc. as shown in eqn (1) in ref. 6. For example, for a specific current density of 5.66 A cm−2 in the present case, after a similar calculation via eqn (1) and (2) in ref. 20, we can obtain a value of the evaporated volume larger than that of the diffused volume. It thus indicates that at this current density or energy deposition rate the evaporation of atoms rather than the diffusion of atoms dominates the radial shrinkage of wire. At the same time, we can further lower down the beam energy deposition rate with a reducing in the beam current density from 5.66 to 1 A cm−2 or in the accelerating voltage from 300 to 200 kV so that we can achieve a diffusion-dominated nanoprocess. Although a slower radial shrinkage and a slower elongation would occur at a lower beam energy deposition rate, in the end, we can easily achieve a uniform elongation and accelerated radial shrinkage in amorphous SiOx nanowire fully caused by athermal atom diffusion or athermal plastic flow without any athermal atom evaporation or ablation with an irradiation at an enough lower beam energy deposition rate.
To reveal the kinetics of the accelerated radial shrinkage during the uniform elongation, we can consider an irradiated NW segment of any fixed length of L, as illustrated in Fig. 4 and correlated the thermodynamic driving force for the radius shrinkage with the surface energy (capillary force) of the wire through Laplace law
F = (2πrL)σ/r, | (1) |
σ = σ0 + α/rb, | (2) |
σ ≈ α/rb. | (3) |
From kinetic consideration, we can further assume that rate of the mass transportation (decreasing number of atoms within the irradiated NW segment of the fixed length of L) during the elongation and the shrinkage is proportional to the driving force21 as shown in eqn (1). Note that the decreased number of the atom includes both the number of atoms diffused (or flowed) out of and that evaporated out of the irradiated NW segment of the fixed length of L. In this way, we can get
−d(πr2Lρ)/dt ∝ F, | (4) |
−d(πr2Lρ)/dt = KF. | (5) |
In eqn (4) or (5), ρ is the volume density of atoms which is taken as a constant value here, and K is the thermodynamic reaction constant which is defined as K = K0exp(−ΔG*/RT), where K0 is a constant, R is the gas constant, T is the temperature, and ΔG* is the activation energy for the structure change.15 Combining eqn (1), (3), and (5), we then have
rb+1dr = −K′dt, | (6) |
rt=0 = R0, rt=t = r(t). | (7) |
By integrating the eqn (6) and employing the conditions given in eqn (7), r takes the form as given below
![]() | (8) |
Based on the above considerations, we made a nonlinear fitting of the observed radius evolution of the NW as shown in Fig. 3 to the eqn (8). The dashed line in Fig. 3 shows a well-fitted result of the experimental data which gives a fitted value of the constant b at 3.5. This indicates that the additional curvature effect at the nanoscale on the surface energy of the NW is proportional to 1/r3.5 instead of 1/r2 as predicted from the existing theories.15 That is, the fitting results demonstrate a much faster increase of the surface energy with the curvature at the nanoscale than that predicted from the existing theories (called nanocurvature effect as defined previously). The reason for such a discrepancy is because the existing, related calculations have to rely on some approximations based on equilibrium, symmetric, periodic, and linear nature of a bulk crystalline structure, which may greatly underestimate real curvature effect of LDNs at the nanoscale. In fact, when the radius r of wire reduces down to a value comparable with the atomic bond length, the surface energy increases dramatically in the form of α/r3.5, which could cause a strong tendency of self-compression on the nanocurved wire surface thermodynamically. In this way, under the external activation of the uniform e-beam irradiation, the dramatically increased surface energy can athermally drive the near-surface atom diffusion or even plastic flow of massive atoms towards the two ends of wire as well as the near-surface atom evaporation into the vacuum. As a result, the a-SiOx NW shows a tensile pulling-free plastic elongation and an accelerated radial shrinkage at the nanoscale under the uniform e-beam irradiation, as demonstrated in Fig. 1–3.
In our previous work, we have obtained the constant b at a fitted value of 6 for the observed SWCNT radial shrinkage15 only via beam-induced athermal evaporation of atoms which is larger than that in the present case of a-SiOx NW at a fitted value of 3.5. This can be well accounted for from the great differences of structure configurations or nanocurvature effects between the SWCNT and the a-SiOx NW. For the SWCNT, it can be regarded as a hollow tube structure rolled up from an sp2 monoatomic layer of covalent bond with an outer surface and an inner surface. As a result, both a strong tensile stress by a positive curvature on the outer surface of the tube wall and a strong compressive stress by a negative curvature on the inner surface11 would lead to the dramatic increase in the surface energy of SWCNT. However, for the a-SiOx NW, it is an amorphous solid cylinder structure of Si–O–Si bridge bond with only an outer wire surface where only the tensile stress by a positive curvature could cause the increase in the surface energy. It thus indicates a less-notable nanocurvature effect and a lower surface energy exerting on the a-SiOx NW, which supports the conclusion of the constant b for the a-SiOx NW is smaller than that for the SWCNT.
Footnote |
† Both authors contributed equally to this work and should be considered as co-first authors. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |