Open Access Article
Fengjie Maa,
Xiaolin Pu*a,
Bo Wang
b,
Jia Lia and
Cheng Caoa
aState Key Laboratory of Oil and Gas Reservoir Geology and Exploitation, Researching on Drilling Fluid Technology, College of Petroleum Engineering, Southwest Petroleum University, Chengdu, 610500, China. E-mail: mafengjie0906@sohu.com
bResearch Institute of Yan Chang Petroleum (Group) CO. LTD., Xi'An, Shan Xi, China
First published on 23rd October 2017
In this study, polyampholyte inhibitor DAM was synthesized from three monomers, namely, diallyl dimethyl ammonium chloride (DMDAAC), methyl allyl alcohol (MP) and 2-acrylamido-2-methyl propane sulfonic acid (AMPS), by aqueous solution polymerization. The inhibition performance of DAM was evaluated from the perspectives of particle-size distribution, hot-rolling dispersion test, linear swelling test, and inherent viscosity. Inhibitory mechanisms were investigated by molecular weight pattern analysis, infrared radiation (IR) spectroscopy, zeta potential measurement, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), and the scanning electron microscope (SEM) technique. The results demonstrated the good inhibitive effect exerted by DAM on the hydration and dispersion of shale, which achieved optimum values and showed a good synergetic effect with the addition of 3% KCL. Moreover, it is thermally stable at 288 °C.
The negative charge on the clay mineral surface can be reduced by cation exchange with inorganic salt, which can compress the thickness of diffusive electric double layers so as to inhibit shale hydration.7,8 However, when there are fewer cations for exchange or the inorganic salt concentration is low, such compression and inhibition effects are not satisfactory. In this context, the addition of a surfactant can reduce the hydrophilicity of the rock surface, thus reducing the water-adsorption capacity of shales and preventing hydration.9 Polyalcohol and asphalt surfactants can form hydrophobic layers on the rock surface by plugging the pores of shales so as to slow the migration of filtrates into shales and thus prevent shale hydration.10 However, the apertures of pores in shales are on the scale of a few dozen nanometers, making effective blocking difficult. The amino group is known to have a strong adsorption capacity for clay minerals, and various types of cationic organic amine salts have been tried in the field. However, they decompose minerals and produce an odor of ammonia, and they are ineffective in high-temperature conditions.11 Studies on other cationic shale inhibitors reveal that high molecular weight has a significant adverse effect on shale inhibition performance.12–14 These inhibitors have various limitations and do not always succeed in inhibiting the hydration of highly water-sensitive clays. Therefore, it is essential and urgent to develop a novel inhibitor featuring an effective inhibition function and environmental friendliness, which is favored in economically viable drilling operations.
Molecular chains of polyampholyte carry both anionic and cationic groups. Previous studies focused on protein macromolecules in amphoteric polymers, among which amino acids, derived from protein hydrolysis and containing both –NH2 and –COOH, were first introduced to inhibitors by Bruton.15 Polyampholyte inhibitors feature the stronger adsorption ability of negatively charged clay and better rheological properties and higher filtration capacity than conventional cationic polymer inhibitors. Therefore, more and more attention has been paid to polyampholyte polymers and their performance as drilling fluid inhibitors.
In order to deal with the shale hydration problem caused by water-based drilling fluids, we designed and synthesized a new type of low molecular weight polyampholyte inhibitor DAM, whose performance was then comprehensively evaluated. Strong adsorbent ammonium groups were introduced into molecules, which enable an anion hydrating group –SO3Na to bind with an adsorbent non-ionic hydrated group –OH, forming low molecular weight linear polymers. Finally, the synthesized polyampholyte inhibitor was characterized and evaluated, the results of which indicated an excellent inhibitive ability and strong resistance to temperature.
:
DMDAAC
:
MP = 4
:
3
:
4. Then, the mixture was stirred and nitrogen gas was kept flowing into the flask for 20 minutes to remove oxygen. When the temperature was raised to 65 °C, 4% ammonium persulfate initiator was added and after a 7 hour period the reaction was stopped and cooled down. After adding anhydrous ethanol to dissolve impurities, a white material was obtained, which was sheared and granulated, and then dried and abraded to a white powder. The reaction equation is shown in Fig. 1.
The linear swelling test was designed to evaluate the swelling rate/ratio of shale samples after contact with the test fluid.20 First, 10 g of Na–Bent was compressed under a pressure of 10 MPa for 5 min to form a pellet with a diameter of 25.4 mm. Then the shale pellet was put into the shale chamber, which was gently filled with test fluids. Once the shale pellet had made contact with the test fluid, the pellet would adsorb water and swell along the vertical direction. The swelling height was recorded by a sensing device, and the percentage swelling was calculated. A high swelling rate indicated a high potential for hydration and swelling.
| [η] = KMα | (1) |
This method refers to the People's Republic of China national standard GB12005.1-89 “Polyacrylamide inherent viscosity determination method”, and a single element can be tested for polymer intrinsic viscosity. The formulas are as follows ((2) and (3))
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
As shown in Table 1, the particle-size distribution curves shifted to the right and became narrow after DAM of different concentrations was added into the bentonite dispersion, demonstrating the enlargement of the bentonite particles and an effective inhibitive performance. When the concentration of polyampholyte DAM was 2 wt%, a more obvious shift in particle-size distribution curves was observed compared to other scenarios, indicating that the optimum inhibition that DAM can achieve should be at 2 wt%.
The evolution of median size (D50) and specific surface area with increasing concentration is plotted in Table 1. When the concentration of inhibitors was low, the median size increased and the specific surface area decreased. When the concentration was higher than 2 wt%, the median size began to decrease, and the specific surface area began to increase, indicating that relatively low concentrations were preconditions for effective DAM inhibition.
For fresh water without inhibitor, the rolling recovery was only 7.8%, while the presence of DAM could improve the recovery to 12.8% when the DAM concentration reached 0.5 wt%. The rolling recovery increased relatively sharply with an increase in DAM concentration before reaching 2 wt%, after which the rolling recovery enhancement was relatively gentle.
The above analyses demonstrate the relatively strong ability of DAM to inhibit the dispersion of clay minerals, but the recovery was still not high because the synthesized inhibitor DAM was a kind of low polymer for the highly dispersed shale cuttings. The addition of a single inhibitor failed to suppress the dispersion of clay minerals effectively, and therefore, the inhibitor DAM was added to the solution on a base of 3% KCL. The rolling recovery results are shown in Table 2 and Fig. 3.
| Numbering | Formula |
|---|---|
| 1# | Water |
| 2# | 3% KCL |
| 3# | 0.5% DAM + 3% KCL |
| 4# | 1% DAM + 3% KCL |
| 5# | 1.5% DAM + 3% KCL |
| 6# | 2% DAM + 3% KCL |
| 7# | 2.5% DAM + 3% KCL |
As shown in Table 1 and Fig. 3, the rolling recovery for 3% KCL was 29.1%. Then, with the addition of DAM, the rolling recovery increased rapidly. A solution containing 2 wt% DAM and 3 wt% KCL increased the rolling recovery to 92.4%, demonstrating efficient suppression. Therefore, it can be inferred that DAM had very good synergy with KCL, and greatly enhanced the suppression ability when used with other inhibitors.
As shown in Fig. 4, the hydration and dispersion of the Na–Bent pellet decreased with an increase in inhibitor concentration. Moreover, the linear swelling rate of Na–Bent under the action of DAM was lower than that under the action of a solution without inhibitor. Generally, higher inhibitor concentrations correspond to a stronger ability to inhibit clay expansion. When 3 wt% KCL was added into the DAM solution, the swelling rate reached as low as 9.2% when the concentration of DAM was 2 wt%. Similar results have been reported previously in terms of the strong synergistic effect to inhibit clay hydration and swelling.24
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| K | 6.31 × 10−3 mL g−1 |
| α | 0.8 |
| [η] | 3.37 mL g−1 |
| M | 2330 |
Generally, polymers are a mixture of substances of different molecular weight, and their molecular weight distribution also has a large effect on their properties. Therefore, it is necessary to test the molecular weight distribution of the polymer. Herein, the molecular weight distribution of DAM was determined by gel chromatography. The results are shown in Table 4 and Fig. 5.
| Name | Mn (dalton) | Mw (dalton) | Mp | Mz (dalton) | Mz + 1 (dalton) | Polydispersity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Molecular weight | 1742 | 2695 | 1659 | 4300 | 6039 | 1.546907 |
The molecular weight distribution of DAM was narrow, and the GPC results also showed that the polydispersity of the molecular weight distribution was 1.547. It was found that the number-average molecular weight was 1742, the weight-average molecular weight was 2695, and the Z-average molecular weight was 4300. A smaller molecular weight distribution enabled DAM to enter into the clay layers more easily so as to prevent water from entering, showing an excellent inhibitory performance.
As shown in Fig. 6, the absorption peak of the –OH stretching vibration appeared at 3446 cm−1, and it was strong and broad; that of the –CH2– group stretching vibration occurred at 2926 cm−1; that of the –C
O bond vibration in the tertiary amide group was at 1640 cm−1; that of the C–N bond vibration in the five-membered molecular heterocycle was at 1452 cm−1; that of the –CH3 bending vibration was at 1388 cm−1; that of the –SO3 vibration was at 1038 cm−1; and that of the C–S bond was at 618 cm−1. The DAM was a polyampholyte inhibitor containing several anionic groups and cationic groups. The cationic groups were adsorbed on the surface of the clay particles by electrostatic interaction, and they negatively charged the surface of the clay particles. Thus, the electrostatic repulsion was reduced between the particles and the hydration shell surface, which further enhanced the aggregation between particles. At the same time, the DAM molecule contained multiple adsorbate –OH, which could form hydrogen bonds with the alkoxy groups on the surface of the clay particles, which also resulted in multi-point adsorption to enhance its adsorption on the clay surface.
The zeta potential of virgin Na–Bent was −34.8 mV, indicating a stable dispersion. The adsorption of inhibitors changed the absolute value of the zeta potential to different degrees with an increase in concentration, while the addition of the inhibitor DAM changed the zeta potential of Na–MMT particles to different degrees. For DAM, the zeta potential changed from −34.8 to −19 mV with an increase in concentration. A similar result was reported by Wang et al.25 Such behavior was explained by a screening effect. On the one hand, in rock formations cationic groups can be adsorbed on the surface of clay minerals by the electrostatic effect, neutralizing the negative charge and providing an inhibitory effect. On the other hand, intermolecular anions and cationic groups can form a synthetic chain beam by electrostatic attraction, forming spatial reticulated structures that can coat clay particles and thus inhibit hydration and dispersion of clay minerals in the cuttings. Meanwhile, ion groups with the same charges between particles produced electrostatic repulsion, which weakened the flocculation effect. Therefore, the bentonite in the drilling fluid was moderately dispersed, which can balance the inhibition and dispersion of drilling fluids.
Amine groups would be protonated and changed into ammonium ions, which could be adsorbed onto the negatively charged sites of the clay surface by electrostatic attraction, as well as the formation of hydrogen bonds between the amine groups and the clay particles. After the adsorption, the surface of the bentonite particles was covered with a hydrophobic segment, which provided a certain shielding effect.26 The decrease in zeta potential indicated the reduced layer charge of the clay particles, resulting in a drop in the hydration repulsion of electric double layers.27 Therefore, the clay particles became less sensitive to water, and an effective hydration inhibitive performance was established. Moreover, in light of the relation between zeta potential and clay particle stability, the zeta potential value ranged from −30 mV to −16 mV, which indicated the commencement of weak dispersion.28
As shown in Fig. 8, the thermal decomposition of DAM can be divided into three stages with respective corresponding temperature ranges of 40.0–105.6 °C, 105.6–288.2 °C, and 288.2–409 °C.
From the analysis of the thermogravimetric curve of DAM, it can be seen that the reduction in DAM quality was lower before the ambient temperature reached 288.2 °C and without obvious thermal degradation. This is mainly due to the five-membered ring-stabilized structure of –NH2–, and its molecular structure was not destroyed by thermal degradation at high temperatures, which means the functional groups were still effective.
DAM in aqueous solution was linear, and a proportion of the molecules were tightly connected, because the molecular structure contained both anionic and cationic groups, which were close to each other due to the action of electrostatic attraction. Some molecules were in a separate state due to the electrostatic repulsion caused by ions with the same electric properties. This linear, low molecular weight polymer is more likely to enter the layers between the clay particles, preventing water from entering and enhancing the inhibition.
The introduction of strongly adsorbent ammonium groups into the polymer molecular chain can not only greatly enhance the inhibiting effect of the inhibitor, but also result in the formation of five-membered ring-shaped molecular chains, which can enhance the rigidity of polymer molecules so as to improve their resistance to temperature. As –SO3Na is insensitive to the cationic affect, and the large steric hindrance of AMPS improves the rigidity of the molecular chain, the polymer can be more temperature-, salt- and calcium-resistant. Moreover, the introduction of a polar hydration group –OH can facilitate the adsorption of clay minerals and the formation of hydration membranes.
DAM is a linear, low molecular weight amphoteric polymer. This particular structure makes polymer chains vulnerable to association, which can coat clay particles and inhibit the hydration of clay minerals. The introduction of cationic groups into the molecular chain can lead to the ionic adsorption of clay minerals, the neutralization of some negative charges on the clay mineral surface, and weakened hydration effects on clay minerals. Such a linear, low molecular weight polymer can be more quickly and strongly adsorbed on the clay particle surface than a high molecular weight polymer. In addition, the hydrochemical membrane formed by a large number of hydration groups in the molecular chain can prevent free water molecules from contacting the clay surface, thus enhancing inhibition.
:
DMDAAC
:
MP = 4
:
3
:
4, the inhibitor DAM was prepared by aqueous solution polymerization at 65 °C for 7 hours. The experimental results demonstrated its lower linear expansion ratio and higher rolling recovery rate. The rolling recovery rate can reach over 90% with KCL, and the inhibition performance is excellent. Infrared radiation spectrum analysis shown that DAM contained many adsorption groups like –OH, which could form hydrogen bonds with alkoxy groups on the surface of clay particles, and form multi-point adsorption to further enhance the absorption. The results of environmental scanning electron microscopy (SEM) identified DAM as a linear copolymer, which would lie in the clay crystal layer under the action of different chemical potentials, replace the inorganic cations between layers, neutralize the negative charge of the clay, then decrease the interlayer electrostatic repulsion, tighten the crystal layer by electrostatic action, and finally weaken the trend for layer spacing to expand. The cationic groups were adsorbed on the surface of the clay particles by electrostatic interaction, and the surface charge of the clay particles was neutralized, reducing the electrostatic repulsion between the particles and the hydration film on the surface. The multiple group synergistic action of DAM demonstrated stronger inhibitory effects, and further work to explore mechanism will continue in our laboratory.
Hybrid MC Simulations, J. Chem. Theory Comput., 2005, 1(6), 1211 CrossRef CAS PubMed.| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |