Open Access Article
Fuchen Zhang
,
Qiuxia Wang,
Lipeng Wang and
Yongping Bai*
School of Chemical Engineering and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, P. R. China. E-mail: baifengbai@hit.edu.cn; Fax: +86-0451-86414086; Tel: +86-0451-86413711
First published on 19th April 2017
Herein, poly(ethylene terephthalate-co-isophthalate) (PETI) was synthesized via an ethylene glycol stibium/γ-AlOOH composite catalyst and a study was carried out on the structural changes of the end groups of poly(ethylene terephthalate-co-isophthalate) (PETI). Based on this study, the effect of the structural changes of these end groups on the crystallization and optical properties of polyester has been discussed. Moreover, it was found that after the catalytic reaction, the γ-AlOOH and the carboxyl end groups of PETI generated terminal carboxyl aluminum coordination compounds. The composite catalyst generated alkoxy aluminum and alkoxy stibium. The strong nucleating ability of these new end group structures changed the crystallization properties of the polyester. Moreover, the optical properties of the polyester were affected and as a result, a 90.46% transmittance for PETI was observed.
The most common end groups in thermoplastic polyesters are hydroxyl and carboxyl, which have chemical activity and a complex impact on the polyester properties. The terminal carboxyl group is mainly produced via thermal oxidation and thermal degradation reactions. In these processes, the color of the polyester can be changed. Therefore, the content of the terminal carboxyl group is commonly used to evaluate the degree of the side reactions in the polyester synthesis process.16 Furthermore, carboxyl end group can also promote polyester hydrothermal aging, decreasing aging resistance of PET.17,18 Terminal hydroxyl and terminal carboxyl groups can be reacted with hydroxyl and carboxyl, respectively, which lead to capping, transesterification or chain-extending reactions.19–22 Therefore, the content and structure of the polyester end groups have an important impact on the properties of polyester. The metal ions of the catalysts react with the polyester end groups to complete the catalytic reaction; thus, the catalyst may affect the structure of the polyester chain ends after the reaction.
Poly(ethylene terephthalate-co-isophthalate) (PETI), as an important member of the polyester family, is a common thermoplastic polyester that is widely used in films, food packaging, and PET bottles, among other fields.23,24 In the previous studies, we investigated in detail the catalytic properties of the composite catalysts and the production of the byproducts in the catalytic synthesis of PETI. The Sb/Al composite catalyst consists of ethylene glycol stibium and γ-AlOOH. We proved that ethylene glycol stibium and γ-AlOOH have synergetic catalytic properties and the catalytic efficiency is higher when both are used.25 In a subsequent study, we unexpectedly found that this composite catalyst had an interesting effect on the crystallization properties and optical properties of PETI. Through further research, these changes were directly linked to the residues generated by the Sb/Al composite catalyst after catalytic reaction, which influenced the properties of PETI by changing the structure of the end groups in PETI.
:
2), and then this solution was coated onto KBr pellets. After the solution was dried, the FT-IR spectra were obtained using a Nicolet iS5 spectrometer (Thermo Scientific, USA) in the wavelength range of 4000–400 cm−1. The number of scans was 32.The amount of the catalyst used in the synthesis of PETI is generally very small, with the amount of PTA in the range of 0.02–0.06 wt%, and the low content of the catalyst and its residues is difficult to detect via conventional methods. We conducted two separate experiments in which we respectively used ethylene glycol stibium and γ-AlOOH as catalysts, but at 2 wt% PTA, to synthesize PETI. Therefore, it was easy to characterize the bonds between the catalyst and PETI after the reaction because of the use of a large amount of the catalyst. It was observed that while using the abovementioned amounts of ethylene glycol stibium as a catalyst, the PETI infrared spectrum did not significantly change. In this infrared spectrum, the benzene ring –C
C– bending vibration absorption peak at 1613.21 cm−1 and the benzene ring –C
C– stretching vibration absorption peak at 1577.79 cm−1 could be observed. However, when γ-AlOOH was used as a catalyst, the PETI infrared spectrum showed a new absorption peak at 1599.74 cm−1, which is the antisymmetric stretching vibration absorption peak of aluminum carboxylate (COO–) (Fig. 1). This shows that after the reaction, γ-AlOOH reacts with the carboxyl end groups of PETI to produce terminal carboxyl aluminum salt. When ethylene glycol stibium was used as the catalyst, the carboxylate absorption peak was not observed; thus, ethylene glycol stibium does not react with the carboxyl end groups of PETI to produce carboxylate.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 The infrared spectra of PETI obtained with ethylene glycol stibium and γ-AlOOH as the catalysts. | ||
Our previous study has shown that γ-AlOOH with ethylene glycol can generate ethylene glycol aluminum at high temperature (Fig. 2), which is a type of alkoxy aluminum polymer. Its molecular chains are linked via the alkoxy group.25 It is generally believed that in the catalytic process, ethylene glycol salts actually act as a catalyst. Ethylene glycol stibium was in the form of alkoxy stibium in PETI. Similarly, we speculated that ethylene glycol aluminum would be in the form of alkoxy aluminum in PETI.
In summary, γ-AlOOH with the end groups of PETI generates two structures after the catalytic reaction. One is a terminal carboxyl aluminum salt coordination structure, which is generated by AlO6 and terminal carboxyl (Fig. 3 A),26 and the other is alkoxy aluminum, which is generated by ethylene glycol aluminum and terminal hydroxyl (Fig. 3B). Moreover, a third structure as alkoxy stibium, which is generated by ethylene glycol stibium and terminal hydroxyl (Fig. 3C), was also observed. The PETI stereomodel shows that the abovementioned three structures can form a cross-linked center structure in polyester. [AlO6]n can be combined with several carboxyls; thus, the number of PETI molecular chains bound with it is more than those bound with alkoxy aluminum and alkoxy stibium.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Three forms of ethylene glycol stibium and the residue of γ-AlOOH after the catalytic reaction in PETI. | ||
Unlike the cold crystallization temperature, the variations in the thermal crystallization temperature
of PETI were more complex (Fig. 4c and d). When γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage, the thermal crystallization temperature first increased and then decreased. The highest thermal crystallization temperature was found when only γ-AlOOH was used as a catalyst. When γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage, the thermal crystallization temperature first decreased and then increased. Thermal crystallization temperature is directly linked to the rate of nucleation and crystal growth; thus, the abovementioned phenomenon has been explained by the non-isothermal crystallization kinetics and crystal growth rate.
To explain the changes of crystallization temperature, the crystallization behavior of PETI was investigated by the Jeziorny method, in which the Avrami equation, which is widely used in the isothermal crystallization analysis, was applied to non-isothermal kinetics, and the resulting parameters were corrected.27 On mapping Xt − t − t0 and ln[−ln(1 − Xt)] − ln
t (Fig. 5), the half crystallization time t1/2, Avrami index n, and crystallization rate constant Zc could be found. Note that the ln[−ln(1 − Xt)] − ln(t − t0) curve deviated from the expected function at the beginning and end of the PETI crystallization, but maintained a good linear growth in the crystal growth stage.
The calculation results show that the peak crystal growth rate Zc of cold crystallization was between 1 and 1.21 when γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage, and it was between 0.78 and 0.83 when γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage. This proves that PETI, synthesized with γ-AlOOH added at the esterification stage, had higher cold crystallization rate and higher thermal crystallization growth rate (Fig. 6a and b). End groups of PETI synthesized with γ-AlOOH added at the esterification stage can form alkoxy aluminum and terminal carboxyl aluminum coordination compounds. These new molecular chains are very similar to star polymers and ionic polymers and thus, the crystallization properties are greatly different from those of general PETI. Because the molecular chains are bound by alkoxy aluminum and [AlO6]n coordination structures, the chain segments are so close that it is easier for the chains to be arranged in order. These new structures are also inclined to form nucleating centers, which can promote the increase of the degree of crystallinity of PETI. The number of the abovementioned structures was less when γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage and thus the crystal growth rates were much lower.
The half crystallization time t1/2 shows the rate of crystal growth from the time scale. In terms of the cold crystallization of PETI, with the increasing γ-AlOOH added, the t1/2 variation was identical regardless of whether the γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification or the pre-polycondensation stage. The t1/2 was lower when the γ-AlOOH mass ratio was less than 40% (Fig. 7). Within this range, PETI end groups more easily generated alkoxy aluminum, alkoxy stibium, and terminal carboxyl aluminum coordination compounds, which form the star structures and complex ring structures. These structures may be the nucleating centers and more easily increase the crystallization rate of PETI. However, the variation of the PETI thermal crystallization peak was relatively complex. In terms of common polyester material, the processing is from the melt quenched into an amorphous state; thus, the thermal crystallization properties are very important. The thermal crystallization temperature of PETI synthesized with the composite catalyst in which γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage was lower than that when γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage. When adding at the pre-polycondensation stage, most of the γ-AlOOH participated in the catalytic reaction and remained in the PETI. These nanoparticles became crystallization nucleating agents that promoted PET melt crystallization behavior during cooling. However, when added at the esterification stage, γ-AlOOH in conjunction with ethylene glycol is more likely to generate alkoxy aluminum and terminal carboxyl aluminum coordination compound in a homogeneous material system, which has stronger heterogeneous nucleation ability. When only γ-AlOOH was used as a catalyst, t1/2 was the shortest, showing that heterogeneous nucleation was strongest in this case.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 The effect of different catalyst proportions and the time of addition of catalyst on PETI t1/2 of cold crystallization (a) and thermal crystallization (b). | ||
The degree of crystallinity of PETI synthesized with the composite catalyst in which γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage was higher than that in which γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage (Fig. 8). This further proves that the structure changes in the PETI end groups were influenced by the stibium/aluminum composite catalyst and can significantly affect the crystallization properties. On the one hand, alkoxy aluminum and [AlO6]n coordination structures can promote the orderly folding of the chain segments. On the other hand, these become nucleating centers. All these enhance the degree of crystallinity of PETI. The relative content of the new chain structure can be indirectly measured by the variation of the degree of crystallinity.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 The effect of different catalyst content on the degree of crystallinity of amorphous polyester. | ||
We observed the PETI spherulite morphology using a polarizing microscope after growing the samples for the same time at 230 °C. The spherulite size of PETI synthesized with only γ-AlOOH was significantly larger than that of PETI synthesized with only ethylene glycol stibium, and the number of crystal nuclei was lower in PETI synthesized with only γ-AlOOH. During the crystallization process, γ-AlOOH and its reaction promoted PETI spherulite growth and same phenomenon was observed with ethylene glycol stibium. The promoting effect of the former is greater than that of the latter, whereas the nucleation rate of the former is lower than that of the latter (Fig. 9a and b). When the mass ratio of the composite catalyst was Sb
:
Al = 80
:
20, γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage or at the pre-polycondensation stage to obtain PETI. The spherulite size of the former was greater than that of the latter, whereas the number of crystal nuclei in the former was lower (Fig. 9c and d), which shows that the heterogeneous nucleation was the main effect in PETI when we added γ-AlOOH at the pre-polycondensation stage. When γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage and its proportion was 20% in the composite catalyst, PETI had a higher crystal growth rate in the low temperature region (Fig. 10a). This may be due to the new structures formed by alkoxy aluminum and the terminal carboxyl aluminum coordination compound, which can make molecular chains folded to form crystalline regions centered on them. When γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage, the crystal growth rates of PETI synthesized with different proportions of the composite catalyst more intensely changed, which may be due to stronger heterogeneous nucleation in these PETI formulations (Fig. 10b).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 The spherulite growth rate curve of PETI synthesized with the Sb/Al composite catalyst. γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage (a) and pre-polycondensation stage (b). | ||
:
40, the transmittance of PETI can reach 90.46% (Fig. 11a). When γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage, the variation of transmittance was roughly the same as that of t1/2. With the decreasing t1/2, the transmittance gradually increased, and the transmittance decreased with the increase of t1/2. This shows that in this situation, t1/2 is the main factor that affects the change of PETI transmittance. If t1/2 of PETI is short, crystal growth time is limited; thus, the spherulite size is smaller than that of PETI when t1/2 is long. Compared with the addition of γ-AlOOH at the esterification stage, when γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage, t1/2 of PETI was longer; thus, crystal growth time and the spherulite size increased, leading to a reduction of the transmittance. However, the variation of transmittance was controlled by the crystal growth rate Zc and the half crystallization time t1/2, and it was mainly affected by the Zc. These variations also affected the haze of PETI. The haze of PETI was lower when γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage than that when γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage (Fig. 11b). Note that the transmittance was low and the haze was high when PETI was synthesized only with γ-AlOOH, indicating γ-AlOOH still existed as nucleating centers at the nanometer level after the catalytic reaction and led to deterioration of the optical properties.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 11 The effect of the amount of γ-AlOOH added on the transmittance (a) and the haze (b) in the compound catalyst. | ||
Abovementioned transmittance refers to the ratio of the luminous flux through PETI to the total luminous flux, but this cannot accurately explain the specific reasons for the differences in the optical properties of PETI. Through the spectral scanning study, it could be found that there were slight differences in the transmittance curve of PETI in the UV-visible-near infrared region when γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage (Fig. 12a); however, there were slight differences in the 500 nm wavelength region of the transmittance curve of PETI when γ-AlOOH was added at the pre-polycondensation stage (Fig. 12b). However, these differences may not result in a very significant effect on the transmittance of PETI.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 12 The UV-vis transmittance spectrum curve of PETI synthesized with the Sb/Al composite catalyst. γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage (a) and pre-polycondensation stage (b). | ||
Furthermore, the light reflection was the main reason for the change in the optical properties of PETI (Fig. 13a and b). PETI absorbs UV light with a wavelength less than 320 nm, and the reflectivity is generally not more than 10% in the visible region. With the increasing visible light wavelength, reflectivity gradually decreased. The higher the reflectivity of PETI, the lower the transmittance. The fundamental reason for the change of reflectivity of PETI is the change of the degree of crystallinity. The higher the degree of crystallinity, the higher the reflectivity.28 The use of the Sb/Al composite catalyst changed the degree of crystallinity and thus the reflectivity also changed. Finally, the transmittance of PETI was affected.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 13 The UV-vis reflectance spectrum curve of PETI synthesized with the Sb/Al composite catalyst. γ-AlOOH was added at the esterification stage (a) or pre-polycondensation stage (b). | ||
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |