Zheng-Hua Heab,
Jun Chen*bc,
Qiang Wu*a and
Guang-Fu Jia
aNational Key Laboratory of Shock Wave and Detonation Physics, Institute of Fluid Physics, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang 621900, Sichuan, China. E-mail: wuqianglsd@163.com; Tel: +86-0816-2491024
bNational Key Laboratory of Computational Physics, Institute of Applied Physics and Computational Mathematics, Beijing 100088, China. E-mail: jun_chen@iapcm.ac.cn; Tel: +86-010-61935175
cCenter for Applied Physics and Technology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China
First published on 22nd September 2016
Quantum-based multiscale calculations were carried out to reveal the rapid shock initiation mechanism of β-HMX (octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine). Tracking the dissociation process of HMX, we discovered a special catalytic action of intermediate-water. During early decomposition of HMX, water and its derivative (·OH) acted as oxidizer, dominated the carbon oxidation reaction, and promoted the oxygen-transport from nitrogen to carbon. Water monomer and its small polymers efficiently transferred proton and hydroxyl moieties between reaction centers, also contributing to the acceleration of the carbon oxidation reaction. The carbon oxidation significantly reduced the dissociation energy barrier of C–N bonds, causing fast and deep cracking of HMX. This water catalytic mechanism may contribute to the illustration of the intrinsic difference in reaction properties between sensitive and insensitive explosives, and shed light on understanding the rapid shock initiation process.
In this study, our aim was to discover the intrinsic mechanism of fast decomposition of sensitive explosives under shock loading. HMX (C4H8N8O8), as a typical specimen of sensitive explosive, had an extraordinary detonation velocity and pressure.29,30 The early chemical reaction mechanism and main products evolutions had been widely studied by experiments and theories.11–18,31–39 Three primary initial reaction models were proposed for HMX thermal decomposition: (I) cleavage of N-nitro bond to produce NO2,12,32,37 (II) HONO elimination by electrophilic adsorption of alkyl H and nitro O,31 (III) breaking of molecular ring.36 Kuklja and Sharia16,17,33 calculated the activation energies for these reactions using density functional theory, and illustrated the promoting effects of surface and defect. Long and Chen6 obtained 507 kinds of intermediates and 9677 kinds of chemical reactions for HMX thermal decomposition based on molecular dynamics (MD) simulation, and confirmed the main products of N2, H2O, CO2 under 42 GPa up to 50 ps. Goddard III and coworkers37 simulated the decomposition of HMX at different initial densities for 30 ps. They found that NO2 was firstly produced by cleavage of N-nitro bond. NO, H2O and N2 were formed shortly after the dissociation of NO2. For the shock decomposition of HMX, the molecular ring breaking,13,15 nitro O13 and alkyl H11,14 direct elimination were identified as the main reaction patterns. He and Chen15 found that the initial reaction sites closely depended on the angles between chemical bonds and shock direction. Ge et al.14 explored the early decomposition of HMX at the different shocks of 8, 10 and 11 km s−1 and suggested that the cleavage of N-nitro bond was suppressed at high pressure. Although the earliest reaction sites were studied deeply both in thermal and shock conditions, more details of the reaction mechanisms from first chemical bond breaking to fast decomposition were not sufficiently investigated. More importantly, the complex reaction performance of early intermediate products was not clearly understood yet. A clearly understanding of such reaction properties would not only open the new insight for the fast shock initiation, but also help to uncover the intrinsic difference for the reactivity between sensitive and insensitive explosives.
The quantum-based multiscale molecular dynamics (MD), were performed for β-HMX to reveal its shock decomposition process. Tracking the main small molecules reaction actions, we identified a special catalytic mechanism of intermediate-water (water derived from the early decomposition of HMX) for the rapid decomposition of β-HMX. We first analyzed the microstructure properties of water to more clearly understand its catalytic effects. Intermediate-water and its derivative (·OH) directly participated carbon oxidation reaction and transferred oxygen to carbon. Their monomer and small polymers displayed high efficient transfer capability for proton and hydroxyl and accelerated the carbon oxidation process. All the catalytic behaviors of intermediate-water obviously reduced the breaking energy barrier of C–N bonds within HMX molecules, causing a rapid and deep cracking of HMX.
For illustrating the catalytic effect of intermediate-water on HMX decomposition, the energy barriers of the some key reactions were calculated using density functional theory (DFT) with Gaussian03 (ref. 43) program package. The B3LYP44,45 functional combined with 6-31G(d) basis set were applied to the geometrical structure optimization for reactants, products and transition states (TS). The electron spin was considered for all open-shell species. The initial TS structures were obtained by reaction potential energy surface (PES) scanning.46 Furthermore, harmonic vibrational frequency calculations were performed to identify the various stationary points to be either a minimum or a transition state.47 Intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC)48,49 calculations were carried out to make sure that each TS connected its reactions and products. The energies discussed below were relative Gibbs free energies (ΔG298K). And ZPE (zero-point energy) corrected electronic energies (ΔE0K) were also provided for reference.
Condensed phase β-HMX possessed typical monoclinic molecular crystal structure, with the crystallographic constants of the unit cell a = 6.54 Å, b = 11.05 Å, c = 8.70 Å, and α = 90°, β = 124.3°, γ = 90°.50 In this study, a 5 × 2 × 2 supercell structure was constructed. The cell optimization was carried out to obtain the reasonable original configuration. Seeing in Fig. 1, the supercell structure was cut along the (1 0 0) direction, with the high activity N–NO2 groups exposed on surface. The surface of the model was employed to parallel to the y–z plane. An extra 5 Å vacuum was placed on top of it to eliminate the interaction between molecular layers. The lattice parameters of this supercell were a = 21.253 Å, b = 17.512 Å, c = 34.143 Å, and α = β = γ = 90°. To accelerate the reaction process, two-molecule vacancy was set in center of the model. Meanwhile, the models with six-molecule vacancy and without molecular vacancy were also used for comparison. Firstly, those structures were equilibrated under 300 K for 3 ps using MD–NVT method. And then, uniaxial compression of the shock wave was loaded along the x-axis with MSST method. The fictitious cell mass of 7 × 107 au was employed for MSST calculations. The shock speed of 9 km s−1 was selected, considering the experimental detonation velocity of HMX.29 The initial temperature and pressure were set to 300 K and 0 GPa, respectively. The MD–MSST calculation was run for 25 ps to reveal the complete decomposition process of HMX. For all MD calculations, the target accuracy for the SCF convergence was 10−6 au, and the time step was 0.1 fs. To identify the stable molecular species, we implemented a post-processing procedure based on bond-length criteria.6,25
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) Molecular structure of β-HMX (C4H8N8O8), (b) slab model of 5 × 2 × 2 supercell model of β-HMX with (1 0 0) surface (two-molecule vacancy labeled with green ring). |
During the shock compression process, the reaction system reached extremely high temperature and pressure (seeing Fig. S2 in ESI†), which were more than 4000 K and 70 GPa, respectively. Water molecules were rapidly produced under that condition, with the maximum quasi-density (the ratio of mass and system volume) of ∼0.31 g cm−3 at 2.0 ps. It was noteworthy that this reaction temperature and pressure were much higher than the critical point of water (T = 647 K, P = 22.1 MPa),54,55 and the quasi-density of intermediate-water was also close to the critical density of water (0.32 g cm−3).56 Thus, we could reasonably think that the intermediate-water might have the similar microscopic properties57–60 and reaction activities61–63 as the supercritical water (SCW). In fact, before ∼6 ps, the intermediate-water molecules preferred to form the small polymers (such as structure 1–3 in Fig. S3 in ESI†), which were the typical polymeric structures reported in SCW systems.56,60 And they were proposed to have effective transfer capability for proton.63 However, up to 25 ps, most of water molecules and early small polymers, even some of hydroxyl and proton, were locked within the final water clusters (seeing structure (6) in Fig. S3 in ESI†), diminishing their original reaction activity. We ascribed the water aggregation to extreme high pressure under shock compression, because the similar phenomenon was never detected in the thermal decomposition.37,64
For the shock decomposition of β-HMX, we first explored the evolutions of the chemical bonds of oxygen, to reveal the sketch of oxygen-transport process. In Fig. 3a, the population of O–N bonds decreased dramatically with reaction proceeding, while that of O–H bonds increased correspondingly. Although the number of O–C bonds also increased, which was obviously lower than that of O–H bonds during the initial 2 ps. It indicated that oxygen atoms were most and first transported from nitrogen to hydrogen. After that, the population of O–H bonds reached their maximum and almost kept constant during the following reaction processes. Whereas oxygen was sequentially transported from nitrogen to carbon, resulting in the number of O–C bonds to continue to increase. Up to ∼3 ps, the O–C and O–N bonds were also reached their dynamical equilibriums, with the number of 160 and 60, respectively. For more clearly understanding about this process, we reversely tracked the oxygen source of the new formed C–O bonds at different reaction periods. It was surprised to find that the earliest C–O bonds were mainly produced by direct N–O–C interaction, while more than 60% new C–O bonds derived from the interactions between carbon and water molecules after 2 ps (seeing Fig. 3b). It denoted that the oxygen was transferred from water molecules to carbon atom. The transport behavior became more significant with water population increase, and even dominated the further carbon oxidation process. Therefore, during early shock decomposition of β-HMX, oxygen atoms were mostly transferred from nitro groups to H atoms to form large number of hydroxyls and H2O, and then, transported to C atoms through the hydroxyl and H2O. In essence, intermediate-water acted as an inducer and carrier for the oxygen diffusion between N and C atoms. It was a special catalyst during this period. In comparing with the similar catalytic phenomenon observed in PETN decomposition,65 the oxygen-transport behavior of intermediate-water mainly occurred within the first 3 ps. So, we just distinguished this phenomenon as an “early carbon oxidation”. After 3 ps, although most of the new C–O bonds still derived from H2O, almost an equal amount of oxygen atoms were transferred back to H2O from the earlier C-oxide components (seeing Fig. 3c). There was no net oxygen transferred from water to carbon. The intermediate-water just promoted the oxygen diffusion between different C-species. We found that this process efficiently promoted the formation of carbon oxides (CO, CO2), causing a fast increase for their concentrations as showed in Fig. 2.
A detailed schematic of the oxygen-transport was represented in Fig. 4, which illustrated overall decomposition process of β-HMX to final gas products, like CO and CO2. Fig. 4a showed the main reaction pathways for the formation of initial water. The nitro O preferred to adsorb H atom to form nitrite group by interacting with vicinity alkyl hydrogen, which finally converted into water molecules with other hydrogen atom. Water also could be produced by adsorption of initial carbonyl oxygen and hydrogen atom. The oxidation of hydrogen displayed obviously advantage than that of carbon. Under explosion condition, the early formed water molecule was not a final stable gas product. Their dissociation occurred much faster than that in ambient condition with different mechanisms. Wu and coworkers65 proposed that unimolecular dissociation (H2O → OH + H) was the most frequent event during PETN decomposition at CJ state. While Schwegler et al.66 observed that the bimolecular mechanism (2H2O → H3O+ + OH−) was the main dissociation way in pure water system even at 2000 K. It seemed that the bimolecular dissociation mechanism was favored at lower temperature and higher water concentration. In this study, the reversible reactions of H2O ↔ ·OH were widely observed since water molecules produced, supplying the active center (·OH) to the reaction system directly. In contrast, water molecules mostly dissociated by interacting with surrounding electrophilic groups to eliminate the H atom, which was neither the unimolecular nor the bimolecular dissociation mechanism as mentioned above. This discrepancy was probably due to extreme high temperature and pressure of the explosion system, with a considerably high activity and close spatial location. By tracking thousands of key reactions within first 6 ps, we found that H2O and ·OH apparently participated the oxygen transport process. In Fig. 4b, three dominated reaction pathways of oxygen-transport were proposed according to MD trajectory analysis: I, carbon hydroxylation; II, C-carbonyl carboxylation; III, nitrogen hydroxylation. In pathway I, H2O/·OH interacted with C atom to form C-hydroxyl group. It was followed by two different branch reactions. For the first one, the C–N bond adjacent with hydroxyl directly ruptured to produce the terminal carbonyl (–C–O) (pathway I-1), which further converted into CO. Also, it could interacted with hydroxyl radical to form carboxyl structure (pathway I-3). For the second reaction path, C-hydroxyl reacted with terminal carbonyl to produce ether structure, eliminating H atom and transferring O atom to terminal carbonyl to generate the carboxyl group (pathway I-2). The carboxyl group was also produced by direct adsorption of water (·OH) O atom on carbonyl C as represented in pathway II. We noted that most of the oxidation reactions always produced the typical carboxyl structures labeled with red box in Fig. 4b. It seemed that the carboxylation of the C-carbonyl was the favorable reaction route for the oxygen-transport. H2O/·OH preferred to transfer oxygen to the partly oxidized carbon atoms. Fig. 4c displayed a typical example of that reaction process. Water O atom firstly adsorbed on the carbonyl C atom to form the analogue carboxyl structure. The water H atom interacted with the other O-species around it, such as hydroxyl and other carbonyl, to be eliminated. The corresponding C–N bond ruptured to generate the terminal carboxyl radical (labeled with red dotted ring). Further dissociation of terminal carboxyl group produced CO2 molecule. This process confirmed that intermediate-water directly participated the carbon oxidation reaction during β-HMX decomposition.
Besides, water molecule also interacted with the N atom in C–N backbones, to form N-hydroxyl structure (seeing pathway III in Fig. 4b). Like the pathway I-2, N-hydroxyl group could interact with terminal carbonyl, transferring the hydroxyl O to carbonyl C atom and producing carboxyl group (pathway III-1). Or it directly dissociated to form NO. During these oxygen-transport processes, water and ·OH actually acted as an oxidizer and donated oxygen to carbon atom. The initial small molecules, like CO, CO2 and NO, could not exist stably yet. Some of them reacted with other active radicals to return the oxygen recycle process, or combined into new C–N fragments. For instance, CO and CO2 preferred to interact with ·OH to form the carbonate groups (labeled with green ring in Fig. 4b), which was the important intermediate for carbon oxides transition.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Proton and hydroxyl transport of intermediate-water in β-HMX decomposition, (a) schematic for proton and hydroxyl transport, (b and c) proton transport, (d) hydroxyl transport. |
·OH was one of the main oxidants for the supercritical water oxidation process.62 It was also identified as the primary free radical carrier involved in hydrocarbon explosion,46 promoting the chain transfer and branching reactions. The hydroxyl transport was a reverse process for proton transport (seeing Fig. 5a), which was already observed in the gas explosion.68 In our study, hydroxyl radical combined with adjacent water molecule to form hydration-hydroxyl (H–O–H⋯OH). The water H atom was attracted by hydroxyl O to produce a new ·OH and H2O. The hydroxyl radical was transferred according to this schema till it collided with C atom to form C-hydroxyl groups (seeing Fig. 5d). This process efficiently increased the collision frequency between hydroxyl radical and carbon, promoting the oxygen diffusion from H to C and accelerating the carbon oxidation reaction.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Potential energy profiles for C–N bond breaking (the R, TS and P represented reactant, transition state and product, respectively). |
We detected that the carbon oxidation effects of intermediate-water were mainly based on the form of single water molecules or their derivative (·OH). Their transport actions for proton and hydroxyl were more significant among the small water polymeric groups. Therefore, the catalytic behaviors of intermediate-water just concentrated on the early decomposition of β-HMX molecules, when it randomly distributed within reaction system. These catalytic effects caused fast oxidation of carbon atom, accelerating the decomposition of HMX. However, after the aggregation of water molecules, most of them were bounded within the clusters by quasi hydrogen-bonding net and their reaction activities were diminished. They would not possess significant promoting effect on further reaction of explosion any more.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra21384g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |