Yanting Liua,
Jun Zhou*a,
Lu Zhoua,
Edwin Yue-Bun Punb,
Tao Jianga,
Lucia Pettic and
Pasquale Mormilec
aInstitute of Photonics, Faculty of Science, Ningbo University, Ningbo 315211, China. E-mail: zhoujun@nbu.edu.cn; Fax: +86-574-87600744; Tel: +86-574-87600794
bDepartment of Electronic Engineering, State Key Laboratory of Millimeter Waves, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, China
cInstitute of Applied Sciences and Intelligent Systems “E. Caianiello” of CNR, Via Campi Flegrei, 34 – Comprensorio Olivetti, 80078 Pozzuoli, Napoli, Italy
First published on 9th June 2016
Polyhedral gold nanocrystals (Au NCs) with quasi-spherical, octahedral and triangle-like morphologies were synthesized using a hydrothermal method, and ordered packing structures were formed by water droplet evaporation-induced deposition. The self-assembled structures of the polyhedral Au NCs exhibit shape-directive arrangement during the building block orientation process, and the structure-dependent plasmonic characteristics of the self-assembled NCs were analysed numerically using the finite element method (FEM). The surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) spectra of the self-assembled structures were measured by choosing 4-mercaptobenzoic acid as the Raman reporter, using an excitation wavelength of 785 nm. Both the theoretical and experimental results show that the self-assembled structures of polyhedral Au NCs have high electric field enhancements and excellent SERS performances, in particular, the octahedron self-assembled structures generate higher plasmonic enhancemence efficiency compared to other close-packed configurations. The superior SERS behaviours can be explained based on the electromagnetic enhancement mechanism and the plasmonic antenna effect of the interstitial hot spots, confirming that the self-assembly structures of polyhedral Au NCs offer an alternate way in the design of plasmonic enhancement substrates, with potential applications in bio-sensing and medical detection.
In the assembly of noble metal NCs, their elongated geometries are similar to periodic arrays and can induce a collective coupling effect of inter-particles, leading to special properties with potential applications in sensing, catalysis and medicine.16–19 In particular, the localized surface plasmonic resonance (LSPR) characteristics are of great interest because the transfer and confinement of electromagnetic (EM) energy around the NCs can be further tuned and even amplified.20,21 It is the plasmonic hot spot that arises from the EM coupling between two adjacent NCs with a distance <10 nm, resulting in an intense electric field enhancement.22–24 Thus, the surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) of well-ordered plasmonic hot spots in assembled structures of NCs is much higher than that of randomly spots on the surface of NCs.20,23,25 The SERS signal of molecules which are located at plasmonic hot spots region around the surface of assembled structures can be amplified further to increase the sensitivity.11,19 Thus, the design and fabrication of plasmonic hot spots in assembled nanostructures is very important in order to obtain distinct SERS enhancement.26
The structure-dependent plasmonic enhancements of assembled noble metal NCs have been widely studied, and their SERS characteristics relating to the assembled architectures have been demonstrated.27–29 For example, by adjusting the concentrations and the species of surface capping molecules, three dimension (3D) plasmonic arrays have been constructed by controllable self-assemble of Au nanorods, and the SERS performances exhibit structure-dependence for different arrangements of Au nanorods.12,13,18,30,31 Although closely-packing arrangements of noble metal NCs have been studied, attentions should be paid to the production of well-defined self-assembled structure of NCs with morphological diversity, because the packing and orientation behaviours of various assembled architectures will generate different and unique plasmonic hot spots which affect further the enhanced SERS properties.32–38 Hence, it is important to study the assemblies of noble metal NCs with anisotropic geometric morphologies, tune and optimize their collective plasmonic properties for SERS-based applications.39–41
In this paper, drop casting method has been used to fabricate densely packed structures consisting of anisotropic polyhedral NCs building blocks. The structural characteristics of different ordered assemblies with variable-shaped Au NCs, including quasi-sphere, octahedron and triangle-analogue, are studied systematically. The assemblies are found to be strongly shape-dependent by their building block NCs, and the structure-dependent plasmonic enhanced behaviours of these assembled nanostructures have been analysed using the finite element method (FEM) in details. The assembled nanostructures show excellent response with an incident laser light wavelength of 785 nm in the Raman spectra measurement, due to the nanoantenna effect of the enhanced electric field of the assembled substrates.
For the quasi-sphere Au NCs, they are spontaneously and closely packed into well-defined multilayers of face-centred-cubic (fcc) structures on silicon wafer. Fig. 1(a)–(c) show the different magnifications of the SEM images of the multilayer assembled structures, and Fig. 1(d) illustrates the packing mode of the sphere building block. As shown in Fig. 1(c), there is an average inter-particle distance of ∼5 nm due to the existent of surface capping agent. It is well known that the surfactant CTAB molecules can form self-assembled micelles consisting of a bilayer of partially interdigitated CTAB molecules with 2–3 nm thickness, and leading to net positive charges on the NC surfaces.45 This also provides the repulsive interactions among the NCs to prevent the random disordered aggregation during solvent evaporation.4 Hence, the surfactant plays a crucial role in determining the formation of assembled structures.14
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Different magnifications SEM images of multilayer assembled quasi-sphere Au NCs (a–c) and schematic of building blocks of the assembly structure (d). |
The synthesized octahedral Au NCs appear to be highly monodisperse in sizes, and can be spontaneously assembled into two different types of well-ordered arrangements on the silicon wafer. As shown in Fig. 2 and 3, the representative SEM images of the self-assembled structures of the octahedral Au NCs exhibit a parallel closely-packed hexagonal array of the {111} facets and a row-by-row packed array misalignment-stack by the truncated {110} edges, and are known as types I and II, respectively. For type I arrangement, as shown in Fig. 2(a)–(c), it is a multi-layer structure and the octahedron building blocks contact each other by their faces to form a closely-packed arrangement in each monolayer. Fig. 2(d) illustrate the schematic assembled structures of type I arrangement, and Fig. S1† shows the side view of the SEM images of the packed structures. The adjacent layers in the structures have a similar packing arrangement but an opposite and alternate packing orientation via complete or partial face-to-face contact, due to the fact that this deposition mode can minimize the free energy for such a layer-by-layer assembly.46 For the type II arrangement, as shown in Fig. 3(a)–(c), the self-assembled structure is distinctly different from that of type I. Here the octahedrons form misalignment-stacked multi-layer structure by the slightly truncated corners contacting the underlying substrate surface. This is also a stable packing arrangement, but requires the formation of a more extensive array of interlocking octahedrons to minimize the volume and the free energy. From Fig. 3(d), it can be seen that this packing structure is a regular array with a misaligned arrangement of adjacent octahedrons. The octahedron building blocks sacrifice some of the translation freedom on the horizontal plane in order to increase the orientation freedom along the vertical direction by misalignment stacking of NCs. Comparing type I with type II from the view of structure stability, type I is easier to be formed by drop evaporation, and type II exist only as large arrays with increased colloid solution volume for stability reason.47
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Different magnifications SEM images of self-assembled octahedral Au NCs (a–c) and schematic assembled structure of building blocks of type I (d). Inside (c) is a hexagonal arrangement. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Different magnifications SEM images of self-assembled octahedral Au NCs (a–c) and schematic assembled structure of building blocks of type II (d). |
Furthermore, although the truncated tetrahedron and truncated bitetrahedron were obtained in the same procedure and they are twin products, the two triangle-analogues can be separately packed into different self-assembled structures, which are shown in Fig. 4 and 5, respectively. From Fig. 4(a)–(c), the truncated bitetrahedron NCs were interdigitated and formed into interlock self-assembled structures which are like fingers of folded hands. In Fig. 4(d), the schematic shows the interlock closely-packed arrangement. The truncated bitetrahedron in adjacent upper and lower layer are face-to-face contact by the triangle (111) facets and then interlock with the truncated bitetrahedrons in other rows by the (110) facets. The face-to-face stack and interlock structure of the truncated bitetrahedrons is reconstructed in Fig. S2† for showing the 3D packing arrangement. On the other hand, the truncated tetrahedrons were packed into hexagonal arrangement, as shown in Fig. 5(a)–(c). It can be observed from Fig. 5(c) that there is an interspatial distance of 3 nm between all of the repeat units in the hexagonal arrangement, and only 2D monolayer structure is spontaneously assembled during the drop evaporation of the Au truncated tetrahedron NCs solution. The inter-edge aggregated consequence of the truncated tetrahedron NCs is distinguished from the assembly of the truncated bitetrahedron. In another word, the difference between the assembled structures originated mainly from the different geometric shapes of NCs and the inter-NCs interactions.7
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Different magnifications SEM images of multilayer assembled truncated bitetrahedral Au NCs on silicon substrates (a–c) and schematic image of assembly pattern of the building blocks (d). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Different magnifications SEM images of self-assembled truncated tetrahedral Au NCs (a–c) and schematic assembled structure of building blocks (d). |
To simplify the calculations in our simulations, only short-range ordered arrays are used in the modelling process. The electric field distributions of the monolayer and bilayer misalignment-stacked structures of Au octahedron arrays are simulated, and their cross-sectional views along x–y plane and 3D maps are shown in Fig. 6. It can be seen that the strongest enhancements of electric fields are located at the plasmonic hot spots, that is, the corners and edges of the octahedron building blocks, and can be attributed to the plasmonic antenna effect.13,48,49 By comparing the maximum values of electric field intensities in Fig. 6, the enhancement effect of the bilayer misalignment-stacked structures is higher than that of Au octahedron monolayer array. In fact, the bilayer misalignment-stacked structures can produce more interstitial hot spots because there are more gaps in between the octahedron building blocks.50
On the other hand, the electric field intensity distributions of the self-assembled truncated Au tetrahedron and bitetrahedron have also been studied. Fig. 7 shows the distributions of the electric field intensities of the interlock arrays composed of truncated Au bitetrahedrons under an excitation wavelength light of 785 nm and the polarization direction along the x axis. The maximums of the electric field distributions are at the positions of the corners, the edges and the faces of adjacent building blocks. As for assembled truncated Au tetrahedron, Fig. 8 shows that the stronger polarized light-induced electric fields are located around the inter-edges and the inter-corners. In Fig. 8(a), the enhanced electric fields of the hexagonally packed truncated Au tetrahedron NCs are located in the adjacent NCs due to the collective enhancement of plasmonic antenna effect of bowtie nanostructure (see in Fig. S3†). Fig. 8(b) demonstrates stronger enhancement of the electric field intensities of the reproducible geometric nanostructure, and can be attributed to the superimposed effect of the repeat hexagonal units. In addition, the distribution of electric field intensity of the quasi-sphere array is similar to that of the sphere array (see Fig. S4†). Comparing the maximum values of electric field intensity of the above four arrays, the enhanced electric field of the quasi-sphere array is much weaker than that of the other polyhedral assemble structures. It further confirms that the enhancement of the electric field of the assembled anisotropic nanostructures originate from the nano-antenna effect.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 The electric field enhancement maps for two interlock arrays of truncated Au bitetrahedron along the x–y plane (a) and y–z plane (b), respectively. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Electric field enhancement maps of truncated Au nanotetrahedron for a single hexagonal arrangement (a) and four repeat unit of hexagonal arrangement (b). |
Based on the simulations of the self-assemble structures of Au NCs, the plasmonic properties of the assembled structures can be further determined by additional SERS investigations with incident laser light. The assembled nanostructures of the as-fabricated polyhedral Au NCs have a ∼5 nm of gap between the adjacent NCs, corresponding to a bilayer of the cationic surfactant (CTAB), and has been described as the optimal separation between particles for the generation of hot spots. It is the synergistic effect of the hot spots and antennae effect that contributes to the large enhancement of electrical field which is beneficial for SERS according to the electromagnetic enhancement mechanism.20,21,51
In our experiments, the SERS performances of these self-assembled polyhedral Au NCs were conducted with a 785 nm semiconductor laser as the excitation source. By using 4-MBA as the Raman reporter, the polyhedral NCs were first labeled with 4-MBA molecules and then dropped onto the silicon wafer for SERS detection. To achieve reliable measurement data, the SERS spectra of 10 random dots in the outer rim area of the coffee-ring region were recorded and shown in Fig. 9. It can be observed that the SERS bands of the 4-MBA display fingerprint characteristics: two intense scattering peaks are located at ∼1078 and 1590 cm−1 which can be ascribed to the two dominant Raman bands corresponding to the ν(C–C) benzene ring-breathing modes. While other less intense modes, such as peak at 718 cm−1 can be assigned to the out-of-plane mode 13β(CCC); peaks at 847 cm−1 can be attributed the COO– bending mode (δ(COO–)); 1152 and 1177 cm−1 originate from the bending mode (ν(C–H)) on the benzene ring and a stretching mode at 1430 cm−1 (νs(COO–)), respectively. Due to the strong coupling between the transition dipole moment of benzene ring and local electric field, the ν(C–C) mode shows a higher intensity than that of the other modes.52,53
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 SERS spectra of 4-MBA at 10 random locations of self-assemble of quasi-sphere, octahedron and triangel-analogue Au NCs on silicon wafer. |
From the SERS spectra shown in Fig. 9, the assemblies of polyhedral Au NCs clearly show highly enhanced SERS activity as orderly packed structures, however, their SERS sensitivities and intensities are different. For illustration, the 1078 cm−1 peak intensity of the 4-MBA of different assembled structures are shown in Fig. 9(d). The self-assembled structure of the octahedron Au NCs substrate has the strongest Raman signal, which can be ascribed to the closely-packed and ordered structure of the aligned octahedron building blocks. As described in the previous section, comparing with the assembled structures of quasi-sphere and triangle-analogue NCs, the octahedron Au NCs can easily form long-range ordered arrangements and well-defined profiles in the self-assemble process, so that stronger antenna effect and increase plasmonic hot spots are generated. It can be concluded that the influence of structure-dependent electric field enhancement is the main factor for the SERS enhancement, which is in agreement with the simulation results. For the self-assembled structures of triangular analogue NCs, the self-assembled truncated Au tetrahedron and bitetrahedron are on the same wafer and their SERS intensity is also better than that of the quasi-spheres NCs. It further confirms that the antenna effect plays a key role in determining the SERS efficiencies in self-assembled NCs. Also, there are two synergistic contributions that have to be considered in order to understand such enhancement, one is the number of hot spots in the orderly packed Au NCs structures, and the other is the structure-dependent antenna effect. Combining with the analysis of the plasmonic enhancement of each type of assembled structure, SERS activity depends mainly on the strong electric fields of the plasmonic hot spots that were distributed at sharp points with lightening rod effects. Therefore, it can be expecting that assembled polyhedral NCs can serve as superior SERS substrate for the detection of a wide variety of molecules.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Additional SEM images of the assembled structures, the simulations of nanospheres array and the bowtie antennae structure. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra12868h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |