Peter D. Matthewsa,
Timothy C. Kinga,
Hugh Glassab,
Pieter C. M. M. Magusina,
Gary J. Tustinc,
Philip A. C. Brownb,
Jonathan A. Cormacka,
Raúl García-Rodrígueza,
Michal Leskesa,
Siân E. Duttonb,
Paul D. Barkera,
F. Malte Groscheb,
Ali Alaviad,
Clare P. Greya and
Dominic S. Wright*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge CB2 1EW, UK. E-mail: dsw1000@cam.ac.uk; Tel: +44 (0)1223 763122
bCavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, JJ Thompson Ave., Cambridge, CB3 0HE, UK
cSchlumberger Gould Research Centre, High Cross, Madingley Road, Cambridge, CB3 0EL, UK
dMax Plank Institute for Solid State Research, Heisenbergstr. 1, Stuttgart 70569, Germany
First published on 22nd June 2016
The pyrolysis of 1,2-diphosphinobenzene at 800 °C gives a phosphorus-doped graphite (P-DG) with an unprecedented high phosphorus content, ca. 20 at%. In contrast with previously studied boron and nitrogen doped graphite materials, thorough characterisation and analysis of this material demonstrates that it is extensively disordered and contains substitutional P-atoms along with PO units in the host graphitic lattice, as well as P4 molecules trapped between the graphitic sheets. This represents a stabilised form of P4, which has been shown to covalently bind to lithium as Li3P in this material.
While the majority of the research on graphite has been concerned with intercalation between the graphitic sheets as a way of tuning properties,6,7 recent studies have looked primarily at the inclusion of boron or nitrogen substitutionally into graphitic sheets.8–12 Only limited attempts to dope phosphorus into the graphite lattice have been reported; even though this offers a particularly attractive option for novel lithium anodes.
Phosphorus has the potential to be a high capacity anode in a lithium battery: lithium is stored as Li3P, corresponding to a theoretical capacity of 2594 mA h g−1, which is nearly 7 times greater than commercially-used graphite.13,14 However, poor conductivity limits the real capacity of elemental phosphorus, making it commercially undesirable. Previous studies have attempted to decorate the surface of mesoporous carbon in order to improve conductivity and make the phosphorus more stable, or dealt with low dimensionality materials (nanotubes/graphene) however few have attempted phosphorus inclusion in the graphitic lattice, which is what we present here.15–19
A second application of phosphorus-doped carbon based materials is as metal-free anodes for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR).3,18,20–24 The ORR is the key step for the generation of energy in hydrogen fuel cells, which has been touted as one way of reducing/replacing fossil fuels in automotive engines. It is the reaction used in fuel cells to reduce oxygen electrochemically and oxidise hydrogen to generate electricity (producing water as the by-product). Traditionally, the ORR has been catalysed by platinum electrodes, however, these suffer from problems such as CO poisoning (CO binding and blocking the Pt active sites), and most importantly, the prohibitively high cost of Pt metal (∼£22000 kg at time of writing).25–28 While there have been some promising advances made using non-precious metal catalysts, a lot of attention has been directed towards carbon-based materials, including doped graphites.23 Liu et al. have prepared P-DG layers via the pyrolysis of triphenylphosphine and toluene as well as P-doped carbon nanospheres and multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), that have shown good electrocatalytic performance for the ORR.21,29,30
Synthetic routes to phosphorus-doped graphites (P-DGs) have traditionally involved chemical vapour deposition (CVD) processes utilising triphenylphosphine (TPP) as the source of phosphorus, in conjunction with a carbon source such as toluene. These methods produce phosphorus doped carbons (P-DG) but are limited to phosphorus contents of <6 at%.20,21,29,31 The CVD approach has also been reported for the production of P-doped nanotubes22,32,33 and graphene,34 though these have both a low P content and have differing properties to bulk graphite and so are not discussed in detail here.
We have reported previously that bulk samples of the stoichiometric N- and B-doped graphites C3N and C3B can be obtained efficiently via the thermolysis of the single-source precursors 1,3-(NH2)2C6H4 and 1,3-(BBr2)2C6H4, respectively.8,9 In this paper we show that this method can also be used to obtain highly doped P-DG with a phosphorus content of ca. 20 at% from the pyrolysis of 1,2-diphosphinobenzene (Fig. 1). Detailed analysis of this P-DG suggests that it is heavily disordered, containing intercalated oxidised phosphorus species as well as some PO and P substitution within the graphitic lattice, and, importantly, P4 intercalation between the graphitic sheets.
Although EDX is of limited use for the quantitative determination of low atomic mass elements, it was of value in showing the presence of carbon and phosphorus in the P-DG samples unambiguously. We turned to XPS in order to determine the C:
P ratio (Fig. 3). Argon ion beam milling shows that this ratio decreases as a function of depth. At the surface of the P-DG the ratio is up to 2
:
1, however, this moves towards a value of 6
:
1 (C
:
P) in the bulk (see Fig. 3b). The overall ratio of C
:
P is C4.17P, i.e. the graphite is doped with P atoms to 19.3 at%.
A substantial oxygen component is also observed by XPS, which decreases with depth, consistent with the presence of surface oxidation (Fig. 3b). As expected, high-resolution scans of the XPS spectrum in the P 2p region of the initial product of the pyrolysis reaction after air-exposure, and prior to washing, show high levels of P4O10 (ca. 95%, an expected product of the observed combustion of the residual elemental phosphorus and/or PH3 in air). Adventitious contamination with oxygen also causes a significant background oxygen level in samples, as shown by XPS analysis of graphite alone.36 This makes it difficult to accurately quantify the at% of O in the sample.
XPS analysis shows that surface P4O10 is efficiently removed on washing samples further with acetone (see ESI Fig. S3†). Only two phosphorus environments are seen at the surface after treatment with acetone/HF. Judging by their XPS binding energies, these appear to be PO-like (ca. 80%, i.e., oxidised P-atoms) and elemental phosphorus-like (ca. 5%). These two environments are present throughout the depth in the sample, as evidenced by XPS depth analysis using argon ion beam ablation (ESI Fig. S5†).
A further environment is also found in the bulk material (Fig. 3c), a phosphine-like environment which presumably results from P-atom substitution in to the graphitic lattice (ca. 15%), however this may also be assigned to a mixture of OxP–C type environments.18,37–39 A depth profile of the P environments in the P-DG (ESI Fig. S5†) demonstrates no real trend, though it is interesting to note that whilst the amount of elemental P remains relatively constant, the P–C type environment and the PO one are interlinked, potentially indicating that this is the major species that is being oxidised.
Deconvolution of the C 1s spectra (Fig. 3d) is very revealing. There are four major environments: sp2 C, sp3 C, C–O and evidence for C–P bonds, which is in agreement with the P 2p scan. However, this latter environment is not present throughout the sample – different scans at different points on the sample and at different etch levels show some or no evidence for C–P bonds (see ESI Fig. S4†). This suggests that the C–P component is small in the P-DG, but present.19
The overall graphiticity of the P-DG was demonstrated by both powder XRD (pXRD) and Raman spectroscopy. The increased D (1330 cm−1) to G (1560 cm−1) band ratio in the Raman spectrum indicates a high level of disorder in the material (see Fig. 4). The broad, asymmetric peaks of the pXRD pattern can be attributed to the turbostratic nature of the material: it exhibits good 2D order, but limited 3D order. The peaks at 26° and 44° correspond to the (002) and (101) planes, respectively, with the former indicating a slightly increased interlayer spacing of 3.69 Å compared to graphite (3.36 Å).40
Further evidence for the presence of phosphorus covalently bonded in the P-DG was provided by MALDI-TOF. In particular, it is clear from this analysis that the P-DG has a distinctly different ionisation ‘fingerprint’ to graphite. Fig. 5 compares the laser power required for ionization of the same carbocation fragments (Cn+) for graphite and P-DG. A significantly greater amount of energy is required for a given fragment of the P-DG compared to graphite. If phosphorus or phosphorus-containing species were simply decorating the surface or intercalated exclusively between the sheets of graphite then the same energy signature should be obtained for a specific ion, which is not the case here.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 MALDI-TOF analysis of required laser energy to make the fragments fly. m/z of 72 (dots), 120 (dashes) and 132 (line) are shown for graphite (black) and P-DG (red). |
The ionisation of P-DG generates peaks corresponding to Cn, 31Pn and CnP families. Strong signals attributable to phosphorus clusters appear intermittently; a species with m/z = 155, corresponding to 31P5, being particularly characteristic. This strongly suggests the formation of small grains of phosphorus embedded within the carbon framework, in addition to the previously noted P–C bonded fragments.
Using positive MS-MS mode, a small number of peaks corresponding to CnP have been identified and broken down with the aid of collision induced dissociation (CID) gas to form other CnP and Cn peaks (see ESI Fig. S6†). Combining this with the ionisation fingerprint, it can be concluded that there is some degree of C–P bond retention and/or formation, the P-DG is not just P decorated on a carbon matrix.
Resistivity measurements were also carried out on flakes of the P-DG (Fig. 6) using a standard four-point lock-in amplification technique from 300 down to 2 K. The resistivity at room temperature was determined to be 0.0029 Ω m, and rises with falling temperature. P-DG is therefore likely to be a semiconductor material; for T ≥ 240 K the resistivity obeys an Arrhenius activation law indicating a band gap of 16 meV. At low temperatures a three-dimensional variable-range hopping model41 is more appropriate, suggesting a strongly disordered system with localised charge and some cross-linking of phosphorus atoms between the graphitic layers.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) Ratio of the resistivity ρ(T) to its room-temperature value. Inset is Arrhenius plot for T ≥ 240 K. Red markers are data; black line is linear fit, indicating a band gap of 16 meV. (b) The same data at low temperature. Red markers are data; black line is best fit to a variable-range hopping model in three dimensions. Inset is natural logarithm of the resistivity against T−1/4, showing good agreement with the variable-range hopping model.41 |
Solid state NMR (ssNMR) spectroscopy, although often neglected in the study of doped graphites, is a very powerful tool for understanding the environments within the P-DG. 1D 31P and 1H NMR experiments and 2D 31P exchange spectroscopy have been used to study the pristine material. Fig. 7 shows Magic Angle Spinning (MAS) 31P NMR spectra of pristine P-DG at two different magnetic fields. The spectra contain two major signals at −521 ppm, corresponding to P4, and a broad signal between 0 and 500 ppm. There are also minor signals at −445 ppm and between −30 and 30 ppm. Comparing 31P and 1H NMR spectra of different pristine batches, we find that these signals correlate with the presence of residual water between 8 and 11 ppm in 1H NMR (ESI Fig. S7†). Therefore, the −445 ppm signal is tentatively assigned to P4 in contact with water, and the narrow signals between −30 and 30 ppm to phosphate species dissolved in residual water. The presence of P4 molecules trapped between the graphitic layers can be seen as a solid-state analogue of the host–guest incorporation of P4 in supramolecular chemistry.42
The line shape of the broad signal between 0 and 500 ppm is essentially independent of the magnetic field, which is typical of inhomogeneous line broadening. The low-field spectrum (Fig. 7b) reflects a shoulder at 210 ppm. Indeed, 31P NMR spectra of other P-DG batches suggest that the broad resonance between 0 and 500 ppm consists of three overlapping line shape components at 20, 210 and 370 ppm (see Fig. S7, ESI†). The diagonally elongated shape of these three overlapping signal components in 2D 13P NMR spectrum illustrate the inhomogeneous lineshape (ESI Fig. S8a†). The shift and line width of the peak at 20 ppm is similar to that of red phosphorus.43 The two other components are consistent with phosphorus embedded in the paramagnetic carbon matrix.
From all the characterisation data for P-DG discussed above, it is apparent that the material does not behave in a manner analogous to the boron- and nitrogen-doped graphite analogues, where a carbon atom is substituted for a dopant, with retention of sp2 hybridisation. Using the complete characterisation data collected by an extensive array of techniques, we have now elucidated the structure of P-DG. Raman spectroscopy, pXRD, XPS and ssNMR all indicate a high degree of disorder and inhomogeneity of the P-DG, so it would unsuitable to propose a periodic global structure for this material. However, it is possible to look at the material on the macro-, nano- and atomic-scales. At the macro-scale, the P-DG consists of large graphitic flakes of several hundred μm2 in area and ∼5 μm thick. These flakes are formed of turbostratically arranged nanocrystalline domains, that show substantial 2D ordering, but limited 3D order.
On the atomic-scale there are a number of different environments for both C and P. XPS reveals that carbon is present as sp2 C (most likely in C6 rings), sp3 C (hydrogenated or termination of flakes), oxidised to C–O and forming C–P bonds (Fig. 8, showing the atomic scale environments within P-DG). Phosphorus is found predominately as either elemental P or in an oxidised state, but XPS and MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry also demonstrate it bound to C. This data is in agreement with that observed in the 31P ssNMR spectra. P forms very strong bonds to oxygen (PO 560 kJ mol−1)44 and so the heavy degree of oxidation can be explained by initial air exposure, the aqueous work up and from scavenging any residual oxygen from the reaction apparatus.
The 31P ssNMR of a lithiated sample reveals a new signal at −250 ppm (Fig. 9a and c). This signal, which appears to grow at the expense of the P4 peak at −500 ppm, has previously been assigned to that of Li3P. This environment is also seen in the 7Li ssNMR at 7.6 ppm (Fig. 9b and d).15 The field-independent width (in ppm) of this signal indicates Li sites with symmetric tetrahedral or octahedral coordination. This is consistent with the crystal structure of bulk Li3P, which contains two types of Li in a tetrahedral coordination.45 The remainder of the 7Li ssNMR spectra reflect the presence of a predominant fraction of LiPF6 salt combined with oxidized species such as Li2PO2F2 Li2O, LiOH and LixH3−xPO4 species (−0.6 ppm). This signal is broader at lower magnetic fields, consistent with quadrupolar line broadening caused by local electric field gradients at Li positions.
19F ssNMR spectroscopy confirms the presence of LiPF6 electrolyte in the lithiated P-graphite, along with oxidised electrolyte species and polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) binder (ESI Fig. S8†).
There is a 0.7 V difference in voltage between the insertion and removal plateaus (ESI Fig. S10†), higher than would be expected for Li intercalation in carbons. This overpotential is characteristic of the formation of a lithium compound with covalent character. These results are consistent with the formation of the Li3P seen in the ssNMR spectra (Fig. 9). A similar profile has been reported for phosphorus decorated on the surface of carbon.15 No further electrochemical tests were carried out, as the P-DG rapidly degraded upon repeated cycling. These data indicate that the lithium is being covalently bound to the phosphorus of the P-DG as Li3P.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Detailed synthesis of precursor and material, along with further detail for SEM, XPS, MALDI-TOF, ssNMR, resistivity and Li binding measurements. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra08639j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |