Jincai
Wu‡
a,
Feng
Yu‡
a,
Zheng
Zhang
a,
Yong
Chen
a,
Jie
Du
*a and
Atsushi
Maruyama
*b
aCollege of Materials and Chemistry Engineering, Hainan University, Haikou 570228, China. E-mail: dujie@hainu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Biomolecular Engineering, Graduate School of Bioscience and Biotechnology, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 4259-B57 Nagatsuta, Midori, Yokohama, 226-8501, Japan. E-mail: amaruyama@bio.titech.ac.jp
First published on 19th November 2015
Dimerization of two homologous strands of genomic DNA/RNA is an essential feature of retroviral replication. Herein we show that a cationic comb-type copolymer (CCC), poly(L-lysine)-graft-dextran, accelerates the dimerization of self-complementary stem–loop DNA, frequently found in functional DNA/RNA molecules, such as aptamers. Furthermore, an anionic polymer poly(sodium vinylsulfonate) (PVS) dissociates CCC from the duplex shortly within a few seconds. Then single stem–loop DNA spontaneously transforms from its dimer. Thus we can easily control the dimer and stem–loop DNA by switching on/off CCC activity. Both polyelectrolytes and DNA concentrations are in the nanomole per liter range. The polyelectrolyte-assisted transconformation and sequences design strategy ensures the reversible state control with rapid response and effective switching under physiologically relevant conditions. A further application of this sensitive assembly is to construct an aptamer-type drug delivery system, bind or release functional molecules responding to its transconformation.
For most of the DNA nanomachines constructed so far, oligonucleotides have been generally used as fuel. The common operating principles employed in this DNA-fueled nanomachine involve sequence-specific hybridizations and strand exchange reactions between the machine body and the sequential addition of DNA fuels. However, the operating conditions of the DNA-fueled nanomachines are limited. For example, the switch frequency is limited by the hybridization kinetics of complementary strands; it needs a high concentration of DNA oligonucleotide to retain the machine's dynamic action; a DNA duplex waste is produced in each cycle, and accumulation of the waste products leads to a progressive loss of operating efficiency.24,25 To overcome these weaknesses, a new strategy is therefore required for the development of DNA nanotechnology.
Our group developed a cationic copolymer-assisted strategy to solve this problem using G-quadruplex and DNA tweezer nanomachines as models.26,27 This strategy is partially an extended work of our previous studies on interactions between cationic comb-type copolymers (CCCs) and triplex or duplex DNA.28–30 In those studies, we demonstrated that CCCs composed of a polycation backbone and abundant hydrophilic graft chains (>90 wt%) influence the kinetics and thermodynamics of nucleic acid hybridization under physiologically relevant conditions. Detailedly, we found that the poly(L-lysine)-graft-dextran (PLL-g-Dex) copolymer significantly accelerates DNA hybridization.31 Moreover, the copolymer markedly accelerates the strand-exchange reaction (SER) and increases the stability of dsDNA relative to that in buffer alone.32–34 The SER acceleration of the copolymer has been applied for refining the DNA detection method35–37 and DNA nanodevices with improved response even at 200 times lower strand concentration (nanomole per liter range) than those in other reports.20,27 The foundation of our research is the interaction mechanism of CCCs and nucleic acid. The CCCs reduce an entropically unfavourable counterion condensation effect that accompanies a nucleation process of SER, lowering the energy barrier associated with breakage and reassociation of the nucleic acid base pairs.32
Nucleic acid chaperones catalyze the folding of nucleic acid into the most stable conformation. As artificial nucleic acid chaperones, a unique aspect of CCCs is that they accelerate the SER while stabilizing DNA hybrids. A naturally occurring nucleic acid chaperone, HIV-1 NCp7, also has the nucleic acid chaperone activity and plays a crucial role in the proviral life cycle.38,39 Dimerization of two homologous strands of genomic RNA is an essential feature of retroviral replication. In HIV-1, a conserved stem–loop sequence, the dimerization initiation site (DIS), has been identified as the domain primarily responsible for the initiation of this aspect of viral assembly.40,41 The DIS loop contains a self-complementary sequence and can form a homodimer through a loop–loop kissing interaction. NCp7 acts catalytically to induce the structural isomerization by accelerating strand exchange between the two stem–loops, and converts the DIS dimer into an extended duplex isoform.
Herein we examined the activity of CCCs to trigger the dimerization of a self-complementary stem–loop DNA, DIS25, similar to DIS in HIV-1 genome. The purpose of this study was to test whether CCCs facilitate the dimerization of DIS like in NCp7. Further, we assessed whether the anionic polymer could switch off CCC activity, soon dissociating a single stem–loop DIS from its dimer. If this strategy is viable, we can easily control DIS dimer and single stem–loop by switching on/off CCC activity. A biomedical application of this programmable assembly is to construct a smart aptamer-type nanoswitch that can bind or release functional molecules responding to its transconformation. Beyond this objective, the reversible state control with rapid response and effective switching is in great need, which is the main work in this paper.
After the incubation, 0.2 wt% poly(sodium vinylsulfonate) (PVS) was added to dissociate each copolymer from DNA. Gel electrophoresis was then carried out on a 13% polyacrylamide gel at 4 °C in TBE buffer. The TAMRA emission of T-DIS25-D is quenched by DABCYL when T-DIS25-D folds into the stem–loop structure. The TAMRA emission recovers when T-DIS25-D forms a dimer with non-labeled DIS25. Fig. 1A shows the PAGE images acquired by TAMRA emission or EtBr staining. The band with higher electrophoretic mobility is identified as the stem–loop monomer. After the gel is stained with EtBr, both the monomer and dimer bands can be captured. The gel images showed that the dimerization of DIS25/T-DIS25-D in the absence of PLL-g-Dex hardly occurred even after 3 h incubation. On the other hand, the hybridization was accelerated by PLL-g-Dex, which revealed that PLL-g-Dex thermodynamically stabilizes the intermolecular dimer preferentially over the stem–loop intramolecular structure. Another study with more PLL-g-Dex (N/P = 2, N/P = 6) and longer incubation (3 h, 10 h, 24 h) evaluated by PAGE is shown in Fig. S3 (ESI†). The results further testified that PLL-g-Dex markedly facilitates dimer formation. Note that upper bands of DNA in the presence of PLL-g-Dex are in the same level with the band of DNA after the renaturation process (heating to 90 °C for 5 min and slowly cooling to room temperature), which confirms that the upper band is for DNA duplex, not for the single strand coil with two ends far away from each other.
We then compared the activity of the copolymer (100 μM PLL-g-Dex) with those of different cationic substances, 5 mM Mg2+ and 500 μM [Co(NH3)6]3+ under physiologically relevant conditions, pH 7.2, containing 150 mM NaCl at 37 °C. As shown in Fig. 1B, 5 mM Mg2+ and 500 μM [Co(NH3)6]3+ resulted in 18% and 42%, respectively, conversion to DIS25 dimer, while PLL-g-Dex at lower concentration (100 μM) induced almost full conversion (>90%) to the dimer state from the stem–loop state. The result implied an effective stablilization effect of CCC on the DIS25 dimer.
In order to observe the kinetic effect of the cationic substances on the dimerization reaction in real time with a resolution of seconds, we employed the fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay. Fig. 1C shows that when we added PLL-g-Dex into the DNA solution, the fluorescence intensity increased to the maximum value within 900 s. The fluorescence intensity changes were not obvious in other cationic substances. These results showed that PLL-g-Dex significantly accelerated dimerization to stabilize the linear dimer structure even at 100 nM DNA concentration.
During the dimerization formation, CCCs spontaneously interact with DNA to form inter-polyelectrolyte complexes. The fluorescence polarization can be used to measure the apparent volume (or molecular weight) of DNA duplex. This measurement is possible because a larger duplex rotates more slowly. Hence, if CCC binds to the DNA duplex, the rotational rate decreases, and the polarity increases. According to this theory, the fluorescence polarity of the DIS25 dimer should be increased after CCC–DNA complex formation. Thus, we can investigate the changes of fluorescence polarity of the DNA duplex to examine CCCs’ binding. As shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†), the fluorescence polarity increased after PLL-g-Dex (N/P = 1) was added into the DNA solution. To confirm that the increase in the polarity was due to CCC–DNA complex formation, we subsequently added 1.2 times charge concentrated anionic polymer, PVS, to the mixture, and the fluorescence was polarity recovered, which shows that the anionic polymer can dissociate the cationic copolymer from the duplex. That means CCC activity can be switched off by a polyanion. Without CCC chaperoning, could the dimer stably maintain the conformation? To answer this question, the transconformation between the single stem–loop DIS25 and extended dimer induced by switching on/off CCC activity was evaluated by the FRET assay. The kinetic effects of PLL-g-Dex/PVS on dimerization of DIS25 or dissociation of the dimer at different temperatures were also investigated (Fig. 2 and 3).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Kinetic dissociation of DIS25 dimer triggered by PVS (1.2 times excess added after the course in Fig. 3). (A) at 37 °C, (B) at 45 °C, (C) at 50 °C, (D) at 60 °C. The value of fluorescence intensity was calculated with the following equation to yield a rate constant of the second-order reaction. kt = ln[(It− I∞)/(I0 − I∞)], where I0 is the initial fluorescence intensity of TAMRA-labeled DNA before adding PVS, It is that at time t, and I∞ is that after the reaction reached equilibrium. |
After the addition of PLL-g-Dex, fluorescence intensity increased, indicating the transformation of the stem–loop to the extended dimer form. As shown in Fig. 2, with increasing temperature, the dimerization rate slightly accelerated, while the variation range of the fluorescence intensity decreased above 50 °C. Note that the dimer was formed even at 60 °C in the presence of PLL-g-Dex. The copolymer increased Tm of the dimer from 54.5 °C (estimated by mFold) to 66.7 °C as evaluated by UV-Tm analysis (Fig. S5, ESI†).
Subsequent addition of PVS resulted in a relatively slow decrease in the fluorescence intensity, especially at 37 °C, as shown in Fig. 3. Since PVS-induced dissociation of DNA from CCC occurred shortly within a few seconds both at 37 °C and 60 °C (Fig. S4, ESI†), PVS easily divests the PLL-g-Dex–DNA complex of CCC chaperoning even at a low temperature. Thus the slow decrease in fluorescence intensity (Fig. 3) indicated that without CCC chaperoning the dimer was not still stable and spontaneously transformed into the stem–loop DNA. Further, the spontaneous dissociation of the extended dimer from the stem–loop DNA was considerably slower than the CCC-assisted dimerization. Since the stem–loop (Tm = 62.0 °C estimated by mFold) is thermodynamically more stable than the extended dimer (Tm = 54.5 °C estimated by mFold) in the absence of the CCC, transconformation from the dimer to the stem–loop is kinetically restricted by the high energy barrier between dissociation and reassociation of base pairs. As expected, the dissociation rate was accelerated at higher temperature close to Tm. Above 50 °C, the transition was very rapid (Fig. 3). The Ea value estimated for spontaneous dimer dissociation was 366.2 kJ mol−1, while Ea of CCC-assisted dimerization was estimated to be 113.2 kJ mol−1 (Fig. S6, ESI†), and also testified that spontaneous dissociation of the extended dimer to the stem–loop DNA was considerably slower than the CCC-assisted dimerization.
As mentioned above, at a relatively low temperature such as 37 °C, the slower dissociation rate resulted in a weaker transconformation response (Fig. 3), although the dimerization occurred rapidly in the presence of CCC, which is an obstacle to its further application in biological fields. To overcome this limitation, we found that modification of a DNA oligonucleotide sequence was a pathway to accelerate the transformation from dimer to stem–loop DNA. We slightly changed the loop sequence of DIS25, and changed G/C to A/T. The diverse stem–loop DNAs were marked as DIS25-2a and DIS25-3a and the sequences are listed in Fig. S1 (ESI†). Estimated by mFold at 2 μM and 150 mM NaCl, the melting temperatures of stem–loop DIS25, DIS25-2a and DIS25-3a are the same (62.0 °C), while the melting temperatures of the dimer DIS25-2a (45.3 °C) and dimer DIS25-3a (42.3 °C), are lower than dimer DIS25 (54.5 °C). That means the stabilities of dimers DIS25-2a and DIS25-3a are lower compared to DIS25, while the stabilities of stem–loop are maintained. In response to the added polyelectrolyte, the transitions of DIS25-2a and DIS25-3a were rapid and reversible and occurred at lower temperatures, 46 °C and 42 °C, respectively, as shown in Fig. 4.
On the basis of the results above, we can construct a kind of a DNA mechanical device that allows easy state control of the reversible extended dimer and single stem–loop DNA by switching on/off CCC activity. The operating principle employed in this system is shown in Fig. 5. This switch can be operated at very low concentrations of both DNA and fuels owing to strong interaction between polycation and polyanion or DNA.
We carried out the FRET assay for the real-time observation of the transformations of the nanoswitches. The operating temperature was raised to near Tm of the dimer to obtain quick responses. Based on this principle, self-complementary DNA nanoswitches (DIS25, DIS25-2a, and DIS25-3a series) with high sensitivity driven by a polyelectrolyte were constructed respectively at 60 °C, 46 °C and 42 °C, as shown in Fig. 6A, C, and D. PLL-g-Dex and PVS were added successively, which induced the transformation between the dimer and stem–loop DNA. The gel electrophoresis assay testified DIS25 nanoswitch's transformation of the first two cycles shown in Fig. 6B.
Unlike many other DNA-fueled nanomachines, it can operate without a supply of additional DNA strands, and there is no DNA duplex waste produced in each cycle. Therefore, at very low concentrations of both DNA and polymer fuels, switching should be highly reversible with negligible changes in efficiency. To testify this hypothesis, we changed the N/P value in DIS25-3a nanoswitch system at 42 °C (Fig. 7). The switching efficiency (N/P = 2, Fig. 7A) was decreased almost by half in the second cycle. N/P = 1.2 (Fig. 7B) and N/P = 1 (Fig. 7C) also showed an obvious decrease in switching efficiency after 4 and 6 cycles, respectively. When the N/P value was reduced to 0.5, the switching was well reversible and decreased only slightly in efficiency even after 13 cycles (Fig. 7E). Since a polycation–polyanion complex is produced in each operating cycle, high concentration of this waste polyelectrolyte complex induces loss of switching efficiency after several cycles. Therefore, the switching efficiency was increased with the N/P value decreasing. Using this programmable strategy, we further designed a double stem–loop DNA (DIS42), and constructed a more complicated nanoswitch system at 37 °C (Fig. S7).†
So far, a series of polyelectrolyte-assisted DNA mechanical nanodevices with rapid response were offered, achieving the original aim of this study. As we know, self-complementary stem–loop structures are frequently found in functional DNA and RNA molecules, such as aptamers. Aptamers provide additional functional information about a target protein, which makes them useful for therapeutic applications. Our study in progress is constructing a polyelectrolyte-assisted aptamer-type DNA nanoswitch system that can be instructed repeatedly to bind or release functional proteins, in rapid response to transconformation between the single stem–loop and extended dimer. This nanodevice has potential application as an intelligent drug delivery system.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: I. Sequences of DIS25, DIS25-2a and DIS25-3a. II. Structural formula of poly(L-lysine)-graft-dextran (PLL-g-Dex). 1H-NMR spectra of PLL-g-Dex in D2O. III. Gel electrophoretic analysis of dimerization of DIS25 with various N/P ratios. IV. The effect of polyelectrolyte on the fluorescence polarity of TAMRA-labeled duplex. V. UV absorption/Tm profiles of DIS25. VI. Arrhenius plots for spontaneous dissociation of the DIS25 dimer and PLL-g-Dex-assisted dimerization of DIS25.VII. Switching between double stem–loop DIS42 and extended multiplex drived by PLL-g-Dex and PVS. See DOI: 10.1039/c5nr05193b |
‡ J. C. W. and F. Y. contributed equally to this paper. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |