Open Access Article
Yang
Hong
a,
Jingchao
Zhang
*b and
Xiao Cheng
Zeng
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, NE 68588, USA. E-mail: xzeng1@unl.edu
bHolland Computing Center, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, NE 68588, USA. E-mail: zhang@unl.edu
First published on 8th August 2016
Interfacial thermal conductance plays a vital role in defining the thermal properties of nanostructured materials in which heat transfer is predominantly phonon mediated. In this work, the thermal contact resistance (R) of a linear heterojunction within a hybrid graphene/hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN) sheet is characterized using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics (NEMD) simulations. The effects of system dimension, heat flux direction, temperature and tensile strain on the predicted R values are investigated. The spatiotemporal evolution of thermal energies from the graphene to the h-BN sheet reveals that the main energy carrier in graphene is the flexural phonon (ZA) mode, which also has the most energy transmissions across the interface. The calculated R decreases monotonically from 5.2 × 10−10 to 2.2 × 10−10 K m2 W−1 with system lengths ranging from 20 to 100 nm. For a 40 nm length hybrid system, the calculated R decreases by 42% from 4.1 × 10−10 to 2.4 × 10−10 K m2 W−1 when the system temperature increases from 200 K to 600 K. The study of the strain effect shows that the thermal contact resistance R between h-BN and graphene sheets increases with the tensile strain. Detailed phonon density of states (PDOS) is computed to understand the thermal resistance results.
The miniaturization of devices and the critical need for improved heat dissipation rely on efficient thermal transport at the heterojunctions. Therefore, the phonon transport across an interface of a heterojunction has been of great interest. Using the molecular dynamics (MD) approach, the thermal contact resistance (R) at the graphene and silicon interface is calculated at 3.1–4.9 × 10−8 K m2 W−1.9 Hong et al.10 computed R between graphene and a copper substrate to be ∼2.61 × 10−8 K m2 W−1 at room temperature. It is found that by engraving the substrate with sub-nm surface roughness, the interfacial thermal resistance between graphene and copper can be reduced by 17%. Using a non-equilibrium molecular dynamics (NEMD) method, Li et al.11 computed the R value between graphene and 4H-SiC to be ∼1 × 10−8 K m2 W−1. Zhang et al.12 studied the thermal resistance between silicene and various substrates using a numerical pump–probe method. They found that the thermal conductance at amorphous interfaces was higher than that at crystalline interfaces. Thermal contact resistances between stacked 2D sheets such as graphene/silicene,13 graphene/h-BN14 and graphene/MoS215 have also been investigated. The calculation results suggest that the interfacial thermal conductance correlates positively with system temperatures and interaction strengths.
The aforementioned supported 2D structures are attached to the substrate via weak van der Waals interactions. But in a hybrid sheet, atoms located adjacent to the heterojunction are often connected by the strong covalent bonds. The thermal transport mechanism and phonon interactions of hybrid sheets differ from those of the stacked sheets and further investigations are needed. In this work, the thermal transport across the graphene/h-BN heterojunction is studied using MD simulations. The thermal energy dissipation at the contact areas is investigated comprehensively. The effects of system dimensions, heat flux direction, temperature and tensile strain on interfacial thermal resistance are explored. Detailed spatiotemporal isotherm and phonon spectrum analyses are conducted to assist the explanation of the computation results.
direction, to eliminate the size effects. Free boundary conditions are applied in the in-plane x and out-of-plane z directions. A lattice mismatch of ∼1% is applied to both graphene and h-BN sheets to construct a supercell with a lattice constant of 2.485 Å. A comparable lattice mismatch between graphene/h-BN is confirmed by ab initio density functional calculations.17 Slightly larger lattice mismatches of 2.5% and 1.9% were reported in graphene/silicene13 and graphene/MoS218 hybrid sheets from previous computational studies. Compared with other graphene-based hybrid sheets,19–22 the lattice mismatch considered in this study has negligible effects on the heterojunction's thermal properties.
The second generation of the Brenner potential,23 namely, the reactive empirical bond-order (REBO) based on the Tersoff potential24 with interactions between C–C bonds, is applied to model the graphene system. Interactions between boron atoms, nitrogen atoms and h-BN/graphene are described by the Tersoff potential,25 similar to previous studies.26–28 Non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations are conducted to characterize the interfacial thermal resistance. For thermal equilibrium simulations, the hybrid sheet is first placed in a canonical ensemble (NVT) for 600 ps (1 ps = 10−12 s) and then turned into a microcanonical ensemble (NVE) for another 400 ps. After the system reaches thermal equilibrium at a given temperature, heat flux controls are applied to the heating/cooling groups constantly for another 7 ns, which is long enough for the temperature gradient to reach a steady state. The heat flux is calculated using the equation
![]() | (1) |
is the heat flux, Δε the imposed heat energy, A the cross-sectional area, and Δt the time step. It is worth noting that if the heat bath is positioned in the middle of the hybrid system and the heat sink is split at the two ends, a factor of 2 needs to be added to the denominator in eqn (1) since the heat flux will propagate in two opposite directions. The temperature gradient is computed by dividing the sample into n slabs along the heat flux direction. The temperature in each slab is calculated according to the energy equipartition theorem:![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
The phonon mean free path (MFP) of graphene is measured at ∼775 nm near room temperature.2 The intrinsically long MFP induces a size dependent thermal conductivity in the graphene system. The confined dimension in the lateral directions will greatly affect the phonon behavior at the graphene/h-BN heterojunction. Thus, it is of great interest to investigate the effects of system dimensions on the interfacial thermal transport. Hybrid sheets with lengths ranging from 20 nm to 100 nm are used in the simulations. The predicted results are shown in Fig. 3. It can be seen that the R values are independent of the heat flux direction, but exhibit a decreasing trend with the increasing system lengths. The length dependence of R occurs if the system size is smaller than the phonon MFP. When the system size becomes larger, more phonon modes with longer wavelengths will be excited. Such phonons can pass through the interface with lower degrees of inelastic scattering and possess higher transmission rates, which can make additional contributions to the thermal conduction. The length dependence of R has also been observed in other hybrid systems.33–35 Aside from the length effects on the interfacial thermal conductance, the in-plane thermal conductivities of the hybrid graphene/h-BN sheet are also dependent on system dimensions. It has been predicted that the system length has significant influence on the thermal conductivity of h-BN. The calculated thermal conductivity for infinitely long h-BN is 277.78 and 588.24 W m−1 K−1, respectively, along the armchair and zigzag directions.36
Phonon power spectrum analyses are conducted to assist the understanding of the predicted results. After the hybrid system reaches a steady state with a constant heat flux, atom velocities of the h-BN and graphene hybrid sheet are recorded continuously for 10 ps, which are then used for the PDOS computation according to eqn (4). The computed PDOS results are plotted in Fig. 4. When the heat flux flows from h-BN to graphene, the PDOS profiles shown in Fig. 4(a) are nearly identical to those in Fig. 4(b) where the heat flux is reversed from graphene to h-BN, indicating that the thermal transport is independent of the heat flux direction. One of the crucial factors in determining the interfacial thermal resistance is the overlap of phonon states. If the phonon population at a certain frequency ω is low or zero, the energy propagation by phonons of that wave vector would be highly restricted. To quantify this variation, an arbitrary unit variable, which is defined as
, is introduced to help the analyses.11A(ω) represents the intersection area at frequency ω. The area of integration is proportional to the amount of energy transported across the linear heterojunction by phonons at these frequency intervals. The calculated δ1 for the heat flux from h-BN to graphene is 67.2% and δ2 equals 67.1% in the opposite direction. The equivalent overlap areas further prove the nondependence of R on the heat flux direction.
To take a further look at the thermal energy propagation within the hybrid sheet, the spatiotemporal temperature evolution is calculated for the 40 nm length hybrid sheet. After thermal equilibrium simulation at 300 K, an ultrafast thermal impulse with an interval of 50 fs is imposed at the end of the graphene. Atoms along the heat flux direction are divided into smaller slabs whose temperature is then calculated according to eqn (2). The isotherm contours are shown in Fig. 5. The pictures depict how heat flows from the origin to the entire field. Fig. 5(b)–(d) show the longitudinal (LA), transverse (TA) and flexural (ZA) components of graphene's thermal energies, respectively. Previous studies argued that the thermal conductivity in single layer graphene is mainly contributed by the in-plane TA and LA phonons, while the out-of-plane ZA phonon contribution can be ignored due to its small group velocity.37 However, a recent study shows that for suspended graphene, the ZA phonon modes can contribute as much as 77% at 300 K and 86% at 100 K of the thermal conductivity due to high specific heat and longer mean phonon scattering time.38 By formulating the ballistic thermal conductance of phonons in a 2D system and using the phonon dispersion relationship, Nakamura et al.39 calculated the contribution of the TA, LA and ZA phonons to graphene's thermal conductance. They also concluded that the ballistic phonon conductance is determined by the ZA phonon modes below about 20 K but the contribution of the TA and LA phonon modes cannot be neglected above 20 K, while the ZA phonon contribution is still dominant. Besides, by numerically solving the phonon Boltzmann equation, Lindsay et al.40 derived a symmetry-based selection rule which significantly restricts the anharmonic phonon–phonon scattering of the ZA phonons, and they showed that the lattice thermal conductivity of graphene is dominated by the ZA phonon modes.
Although many studies have been conducted to analyze the effect of ZA modes on the in-plane thermal conductivity of graphene, their effect on the interfacial thermal conductance has yet to be investigated. Here, one can clearly see from Fig. 5(d) that a strong thermal wave (ZA mode) propagates through the spatiotemporal isotherms, while from Fig. 5(b) and (c), no evident thermal waves (LA and TA modes) are seen. When the thermal relaxation time of phonons is relatively long, the thermal-wave effect becomes more prominent. Hence, it appears that the ZA mode is more significant than the LA and TA modes with respect to graphene's thermal energy dissipation. It can also be observed that the ZA phonons contribute the most energy transmission across the heterojunction towards the h-BN monolayer, indicating that the flexural phonons play a vital role in the interfacial thermal conductance of the hybrid graphene/h-BN sheet. The stress wavefront and thermal energy reflections at the interface are shown in Fig. 5(d).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Thermal resistance variations with temperature from 200 K to 600 K. The inset shows the fully relaxed atomic structure after the hybrid sheet reaches thermal equilibrium. | ||
The decrease of R can be attributed to two major factors: (1) The increase of overall phonon population: At low temperatures, only a limited number of phonons are excited and involved in the thermal transport process. When the temperature increases, higher frequency phonons can be excited, giving more contributions to the interfacial thermal transport and thereby lowering the R values. (2) The increase of inelastic phonon scattering at the interface (heterojunction here), which further facilitates the phonon transmission and enhances the anharmonic coupling. The interfacial thermal resistance calculated using the conventional acoustic mismatch model (AMM) and the diffuse mismatch model (DMM) is independent of temperature within the classical high temperature limit. This is because the only temperature-dependent part for both models is the distribution function, whereas inelastic scatterings are not considered at the interfaces. The NEMD approach applied here accounts for both elastic and inelastic scattering at the interface. It has been proven that at van der Waals heterojunctions, inelastic scattering provides a major contribution to the energy transport surpassing that of elastic scattering at high temperatures.41 The second reason for the increase in the probability of inelastic scattering is that at high temperatures the high frequency phonons might break down into large volumes of low frequency phonons. These low frequency phonons have a higher probability of getting transferred through the interface when compared to the high frequency phonons, leading to higher phonon transmission coefficients and the reduction in the overall interfacial thermal resistance with the increasing temperature. Similar results have also been reported in previous studies of different nanostructure interfaces.41–43
The definition of strain is given by ε = (l − l0)/l0, where l0 is the original length and l is the final length. Interfacial thermal resistance computations are performed with strain values varying from 1% to 7%. The predicted R values are shown in Fig. 7. Our results show that the interfacial thermal resistance increases with the tensile strain. Phonon power spectra analyses are also performed to further understand the results. Fig. 8 shows the computed phonon spectra of the graphene at thermal equilibrium. A notable softening of the G-band is observed when the tensile strain increases from 1% to 7%. The red shift of the higher frequency peaks reduces the phonon group velocities and results in reduced thermal conductivity according to the classical lattice thermal transport theory.53 The reduced phonon group velocities render less contribution from the phonon couplings to the interfacial heat flux, leading to higher thermal contact resistance between h-BN and graphene. A similar softening of the G-band was also seen in the Raman spectra of graphene flakes under uniaxial strain54 and in few-layer graphene sheets under uniform in-plane strain.55
| This journal is © the Owner Societies 2016 |