Hong Jianga,
Erkang Wangb and
Jiahai Wang*a
aNational Engineering Research Center for Colloidal Materials, Shandong University, Jinan 250100, People’s Republic China. E-mail: jiahai_wang@sdu.edu.cn; Tel: +86-053188363180
bState Key Laboratory of Electroanalytical Chemistry, Changchun Institute of Applied Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changchun, Jilin 130022, China
First published on 18th March 2015
Carbon dioxide (CO2), as one of the major byproducts of cellular metabolism, mediates many fundamental behaviors, and its detection is associated with the activation of protein ion channels expressed on olfactory sensory neurons. Inspired by this biological phenomenon, we developed an extraordinary gas-sensitive ion channel, reconfigurable ionic diode and bionic ion pump on the basis of the growth of a gas-responsive polymer film, which can be rendered hydrophilic with CO2 stimulus and hydrophobic with N2 stimulus. In particular, by alternatively purging CO2/N2 into the solutions which are placed on both sides of the channel embedded in the polymer membrane, the smart polymer-coated channel can be either closed or opened, which is independent of voltage polarity. Most intriguingly, under asymmetric stimulation with pH pairs (pH 6.5‖pH 9.0) or with gas inputs (CO2‖N2) on both sides of the channel, a change in voltage polarity can switch the channel between a closed status and open status, leading to the construction of a reconfigurable fluidic diode. Furthermore, by combination of gas inputs and voltage polarity, each of the gates of the channel can be individually manipulated, which is a very important prerequisite for the construction of a bionic ion pump that can be operated under physiologically mild conditions. It is envisaged that this new progress in the bionic pore/channel field will hold great prospects for the application of this kind of biomimetic device for energy storage, sample filtration and seawater desalinization.
In recent years, abiotic devices that mimic the function and structure of biological counterparts have become alluring and have received increasing attention. Among these artificial designs, incessant endeavors have been devoted to imitating ion channels, which mainly comprise engineered protein ion channels,24 solid nanopores20,25–27 in an ultrathin membrane, asymmetric pores28,29 in a polymer membrane and glass nanopores.30,31 Heretofore, many bioinspired ion conducting channels have been designed based on an artificial nanopore with one gate, which can be switched on and off by various external stimuli such as voltage,32,33 temperature,34 light,35 ions,36 pressure,37 ATP38,39 and pH.40,41 More recently, the Jiang group invented a biomimetic ion pump based on a nanochannel with two gates.13 In that pioneering study, two different responsive polymer brushes were grafted onto each end of the ionic channel and each gate could be switched from on to off or vice versa independently/synchronously by pH stimuli.
Among those external stimuli, pH stimulus is very appealing and easily accessible, and has been applied to change the size, surface charge and wettability of the channels. However, many operation cycles that require repeated addition of acids and bases into the solution can degrade the switching capability of the artificial ion channel and ion pump due to the salt accumulation in the solution. While substituting gas stimuli for pH has several distinct advantages: (1) salt accumulation due to the repeated addition of various pH solutions, which can diminish the performance of the biomimetic device, can be eliminated; (2) drastic conditions such as strong acid and strong base can be replaced by much more milder operation conditions; (3) the whole system can be easily restored to its previous status even after many cycles of operation. Furthermore, another common feature of previously made external-stimuli responsive ion channels is that a responsive monolayer is grafted inside the channel.16,18–20 When the channel/pore is in a closed status, the leakage and switching efficiency is highly diameter-dependent. Insufficient growth of the responsive polymer leads to the failure and leakage of the artificial ion pump, whereas the overgrowth of responsive polymers will deteriorate the performance of the channel. It will be more encouraging for scientists to develop more intelligent materials and devices with leakage-free properties and a high switching efficiency.
In this work, we develop an ionic channel device with both entrances covered by a gas-breathing polymer film, which possess the properties of an artificial ion channel, ion pump and ionic diode. Each gate of this ionic channel can be manipulated individually or synchronously. Purging CO2 into a buffer solution (pH 7) on both sides of the channel membrane can render the polymer films positively charged and hydrophilic, leading to ion transport though the polymer films and to the “on” status of the channel. Whereas, the polymer films can be switched back to a hydrophobic status and the channel completely shuts down when the solutions on both sides of the channel membrane are purged with N2 or replaced with buffer solutions with a pH ≥ 7. Except for the synchronous manipulation of both polymer films on both sides of the channel membrane, each gate can also be individually operated by a combination of gas (or pH) and voltage inputs, which are very important prerequisites for the construction of a bionic ion pump. Most interestingly, under asymmetric stimulation with pH pairs (pH 6.5‖pH 9.0) or with gas inputs (CO2‖N2), the change in voltage polarity can switch the channel between a closed status and an open status, leading to the construction of a reconfigurable ionic diode. The alternative passing of CO2/N2 into the solution can allow each gate of the channel to be operated repeatedly for many cycles, which fully eliminates the salt accumulation and degradation of performance. The second advantage lies in that this approach prevents any leakage and lifts the strict requirement on the size of the channel as well. It is envisaged that this new progress in the bionic pore/channel field will hold great prospects for the application of this kind of biomimetic device for energy storage, sample filtration and seawater desalinization.
000) for 8 hours at room temperature, and then the samples were washed with ethanol, followed by nitrogen flow drying. The surface immobilization of the ATRP initiator was adapted from previously published procedures.42 Briefly, 2-bromopropionyl bromide (10 mM) was coupled via an amide linkage to the PEI coated membrane surface in a buffer solution (pH 10, 32 mM Na2CO3). The reaction mixture was cooled in an ice bath, and bubbled with N2 for 30 minutes and lasted for 24 h under N2 protection. Reagents for polymer brush growth including H2O, methanol, 2-(diethylamino)ethyl methacrylate, CuBr and N,N,N′,N′,N′′-pentamethyldiethylenetriamine (PMDETA) were purchased from JK Chemical (Beijing, China) and used without further purification. The polymerization reaction took place for 30 minutes under N2 protection. After the polymerization, the PET film was washed with methanol and H2O several times to remove the redundant CuBr and the other reagents. Then the PET film was dried in a N2 flow and placed under vacuum for subsequent characterization.
To prove the successful growth of a gas-responsive polymer film on the channel membrane, SEM images were acquired (Fig. 2), including the cross section, and the top and bottom sides of the channel. Continuous polymer films fully covered both sides of the channel membrane after 1 hour of growth (Fig. 2B and C) and the thickness of the polymer film was measured to be 1.6 μm (Fig. 2F). It is clear that domains with various sizes exist in the polymer film and have a much larger size than the channel diameter (200 nm). From the cross section image (Fig. 2E), the polymer film growth predominantly happened on the faces of the channel membrane and the inside of the channel was left empty without polymer growth. To the best of our knowledge, growth of a gas-responsive polymer film on a channel membrane has not yet been reported.
The gas-responsive polymer film on the track-etched membrane exhibited repetitive switching between hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity (Fig. 3). Contact angle measurements (Fig. 3) illustrate that the contact angle of the water droplet on the nanopore surface showed a contact angle of 16.17° after the membrane grafted with a polymer film was immersed in a pH 5 buffer. Whereas, after the membrane was immersed in a pH 7 buffer and air dried, the contact angle increased to 54.71° (Fig. 3B). The contact angle could be further increased if a pH 9 solution was used. This result clearly manifested that protonation/deprotonation of the polymer film on the membrane can lead to a change in the hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity of the membrane surface. Instead of employing buffer solutions adjusted to certain pH values with NaOH, buffer solutions reversibly purged with CO2/N2 can also efficiently switch the membrane status between a big contact angle (57.50°) and a small contact angle (20.69°) (Fig. 3A).
A previous study19 proposed that toggling between hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity can play an extremely important role in the opening/closing of the channel on the basis of the pH-tuned polymer brush immobilized in the channel. Unambiguously, it has been clarified that conformation variation is a negligible factor which contributes to ion transport through this kind of channel. In contradiction to the immobilization of the polymer brush inside the channel, the present study entails only the growth of a gas-responsive polymer film on both sides of the track-etched membrane, which can fully prevent the leakage of the channel embedded in the membrane once the channel is switched to “off” status. Notably, several previous nanochannels with responsive properties are majorly related to the conformation switching of the monolayer immobilized inside the nanochannel surface. Obviously, this is not the same as our case. As shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†), in the presence of different pH values (5, 7 and 9), the morphology of the polymer film characterized using SEM did not show any distinct difference and the channel membrane was consistently covered by a continuous polymer film, which means that the conformation switching is not the important factor contributing to ion transport through the channel. Furthermore, the thickness of the polymer film was up to 1.6 μm, which was several times larger than the diameter of the channel embedded in the PET membrane.
In addition to the XPS and NMR characterization of the polymer film growth, each step in the modification process was confirmed and characterized with a current-versus-voltage curve (I–V curve). In this study, we present I–V curves for one cylindrical channel with a diameter of 200 nm and another conical-shaped channel with a tip diameter of 130 nm. The cylindrical channel in the PET membrane was fabricated under the same conditions as those in Fig. 2. The I–V curve (black curve in Fig. 4A) of the single cylindrical channel without any modification showed a linear shape without any rectification, which is measured in 100 mM PBS solution containing 1 M KCl at pH 3. Further tandem modification with branched PEI and an initiator did not exhibit much of a difference in the current-versus-voltage curves. Compared to the cylindrical channel, the asymmetric channel after PEI adsorption (red curve, Fig. 4C) presented an upward curve with strong rectification. For both the cylindrical and asymmetric channel, the polymer film growth fully blocked ion transport through the channel when measured in a pH 7 solution of 0.1 M KCl (curves in dark cyan, Fig. 4A and C).
Both the cylindrical and asymmetric channel covered with a gas-responsive polymer film can be switched on/off by using pH stimuli or gas inputs (Fig. 4B and D). Ion channel behaviors common to biological nanopores can be faithfully reproduced: when the pH value is above 7, the channel can be fully blocked in symmetric pH 7‖7 and 9‖9 conditions; when the pH value is decreased towards 6.5, the channel can be restored to an “on” status in symmetric pH 6.5‖6.5 and pH 5‖5 conditions. If the on/off current ratio was defined as the ratio of the current measured at pH 6.5‖6.5 to the current measured at pH 9‖9, the on/off current ratio corresponding to 1 V was calculated to be 34
418 for the cylindrical channel with a diameter of 200 nm. Furthermore, the current corresponding to the “off” status measured at 1 V was only 2.1 pA, which was defined as the leaking current. To the best of our knowledge, this is the biggest on/off current ratio and the lowest leakage current. As for the asymmetric channel with a tip diameter of 130 nm and a base diameter of 957 nm, the on/off current ratio and the leaking current were 6736 and 1.9 pA, respectively, which are calculated from the data in Fig. 4D. This is to say, the geometry of the channel was not a critical factor for determining the switching efficiency. The quality of the gas-responsive polymer film itself could play a crucial rule. The pH-adjusted ion transport through the channel, both sides of which were covered with a gas-responsive polymer film, was highly consistent with the pH-dependent switching between hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity.
Features belonging to an ionic diode can be exactly reproduced by this channel system symmetrically functionalized with the same gas-responsive polymer films. It has to be noted that previous ionic diodes based on a channel were almost accomplished via asymmetric functionalization with differently charged ligands or polymer brushes.13,14,16,44,45 In the current study, symmetric growth of the same gas-responsive film was executed on both sides of the channel. As shown in Fig. 5A, the upward curve with a nonlinear shape was divided into two parts including part I and part II. The corresponding cartoons about the ion transportation are also illustrated on the right hand side. When a pH 6.5 buffer solution was placed on the left side of the channel and the same solution but at pH 9 was placed on the right side of the channel, the voltage polarity decided the status of the channel. When a positive voltage was applied on the right side of the channel (part II in Fig. 5A), the slope of the I–V curve corresponded to an “on” status, which was exactly the same as the case when both sides of the channel were placed in buffer solutions at pH 6.5 (Fig. 4B). When a negative voltage was applied (part I), the channel was completely shut down. The “on” status and “off” status of the channel was exchangeable by swapping the position of the buffer solutions as shown in Fig. 5B.
Why did voltage polarity have such a significant impact on the ion transport through the channel when the channel with entrances covered by the same polymer film was stimulated under asymmetric pH conditions? To better understand this phenomenon, we have to understand the movement of ions under the applied voltage. When a negative voltage (part I in Fig. 5A) was applied in the chamber containing the buffer solution at pH 9, the negative ions such as OH− in the same chamber moved towards the polymer films and the concentration of OH− around the film increased, leading to closure of the polymer film due to deprotonation and hydrophobicity. When a positive voltage (part II in Fig. 5B) was applied in the chamber containing the buffer solution at pH 9, the negative ions such as OH− in the same chamber moved away from the polymer films and the concentration of OH− around the film decreased. Although the H+ ions in another chamber containing an electrolyte solution at pH 6.5 moved away from the polymer film adjacent to the chamber which contained the electrode applying the positive voltage, its concentration still overwhelms that of OH−, leading to the “on” status of the polymer film due to protonation of the polymer film and hydrophilicity. This similar mechanism can also be applied to explain the downward curve observed in Fig. 5B. Now, it is also very clear that by combining stimuli such as pH and gas with voltage polarity, each one of the two gates can be selectively shut down or opened up, which is the important prerequisite for construction of an ion pump with alternative gates and occluded states.
Once again, the features of this type of diode device which can be explained by the above mechanism can also be realized by an asymmetric channel with entrances covered by the same polymer film (Fig. S5 and S6, ESI†). Most interestingly, this kind of ionic device is not only pH-actuatable but is also highly CO2/N2-stimulable. By utilizing an asymmetric channel as a gas-responsive prototype, we carried out a series of experiments to challenge this kind of channel device with gas stimuli. Upon purging the buffer solution (0.1 M PBS, pH 7, 0.1 M KCl) with CO2, the pH value changed to nearly 5; by passing N2 into the solution, the pH value of 7 was recovered. Once the tip and base side solutions of the conical-shaped channel were purged with CO2 and N2, respectively, the I–V curve demonstrated extremely high rectification behavior and an unprecedented on/off current ratio with an upward nonlinear shape (Fig. 6A). One unique feature of this channel device is that the current rectification can be fully inversed. Upon purging N2 and CO2 into the tip and base side solutions of the same device, the downward I–V curve with excellent high rectification and on/off current ratio was obtained (Fig. 6B). The rectification inversion and current direction were highly reversible, which was only dependent on the gas pair (CO2‖N2 or N2‖CO2). Additionally, as shown in Fig. 6C and D, more than 5 switching cycles between the “on” status and “off” status have been presented in this study under the alternative stimulation with symmetric gas pairs (N2‖N2 and CO2‖CO2).
In this paragraph, we would like to clarify that under the asymmetric stimulation, the competition between H+ and OH− plays a dominant role in the status of the polymer film. By using a conical-shaped channel as a prototype, we compared three different pH pairs (pH 5‖7, pH 6.5‖7, and pH 6.5‖9). As shown in Fig. S7,† only pH 6.5‖9 among the three pH pairs offered the opportunity to observe the ionic diode behavior: the “on” and “off” statuses are determined by voltage polarity. Fig. S7A and B† conclusively affirmed that H+ won and only the “on” status was present, which was indicated by the curved shape of the I–V curve. Therefore, the combination of voltage polarity and the appropriate pH pair is crucial for the opening and closing of each polymer film gate.
The Role of Surface Charge, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2004, 126, 10850–10851 CrossRef CAS PubMed.Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra04712a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |