Weiping Zhoua,
Anming Hu*ab,
Shi Baia,
Ying Maa and
Denzel Bridgesb
aInstitute of Laser Engineering, Beijing University of Technology, 100 Pinle Yuan, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100124, China. E-mail: anminghu@bjut.edu.cn
bDepartment of Mechanical, Aerospace and Biomedical Engineering, University of Tennessee, 1512 Middle Drive, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA
First published on 23rd April 2015
Thin films with one-dimensional nanostructures and unique physical properties are potential candidates for next-generation high-performance electronic, optoelectronic, and electromechanical systems. Here we report that large-scale oriented silver nanowire films can be prepared by controlling the coffee-ring effect through tilting the substrates during the film deposition. The anisotropic optical properties of the orientated silver nanowire film are researched here. Surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) spectra were recorded from Rhodamine 6G adsorbed on the silver nanowire films. The SERS spectra showed striking polarization dependence according to the angle between the long axes of the nanowires and the light polarization. At the vertical excitation (i.e., light polarization forms a 90° angle to the long axes of the nanowires), the SERS intensity reaches a maximum. Minimum intensities were obtained at a parallel excitation. The three-dimensional finite element method was used to give an in-depth explanation of these properties. Angular resolution fluorescence is also studied. The fluorescence displays an angle-dependence similar to the Raman activities. Optical properties were also investigated through the polarization of reflectivity spectra. The reflectivity is smaller when the incident light is polarized parallel to the orientation direction. As the wavelength increases, the reflectivity increases when the polarization of incident light is perpendicular to the orientation direction. When the wavelength is greater than 870 nm, the amplitude can be up to doubled. Our study indicates that this technique is promising in the production of large-scale orientated silver nanowire films with anisotropic optical properties for high-performance electronic, optoelectronic, and electromechanical systems.
The Langmuir–Blodgett (LB) technique was traditionally used to align amphiphilic molecule monolayers onto a water surface. Though this technique has been proven to be a versatile and general tool for assembling nanowires or nanorods, there are still some limitations of this method. For example, the surface of hydrophilic nanomaterials must be functionalized with hydrophobic ligands for the LB experiment and the film has to be transferred to the surface of substrates, which greatly restricts their future application.13–15 The evaporation-induced method is one of popular methods for ordered nanostructures,16,17 but the degree of the ordering depend on not only the distribution of nanomaterial's size but also the dewetting of the solvent during the assembly process. It is still challenged to prepare a large area thin film using this method. Based on the interfacial ordering effects, interfaces provide a unique platform for the organization of nanosized building block films in recent years.18,19 But a suitable interface layer is a necessary condition, like the water–oil–air three-phase interface. In the contact-printing method20,21 knocking-down method,22 and strain-release assembly,23 it requires a mechanical force and the auxiliary process for nanowire assembly. In order to obtain ordered structures, physical forces, such as electric fields24 or magnetic fields25 are often employed. These processes often result in localized alignment. We report here a one-step method to prepare large-area ordered silver nanowire films on substrates based on a modified coffee-ring effect.26 Our experimental results show remarkable promise in the production of large-scale ordered nanowire films.
Novel optical properties can be generated by well-aligned Ag nanowires because of the large electromagnetic (EM) fields localized in the interstitial areas of adjacent nanowires.27,28 Importantly, because of the large EM fields, a film with well-aligned Ag nanowires could be used as an excellent Surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) substrate for the high sensitivity and selectivity detection of molecules.29,30 The magnitude effect of SERS is not only highly dependent on the excitation conditions and geometry of the metallic nanostructures,31,32 but also strongly dependent on polarization. Only fields polarized along the interparticle axis are enhanced.33 For this study, we fabricated large-scale oriented silver nanowire films and then used them to investigate the polarization-dependent enhancement of SERS and surface enhanced fluorescence (SEF). Also we will investigate the polarization-dependent effect on the reflectivity.
The silver nanowires films on silicon wafers were used as substrates for SERS, SEF and reflection spectra. Rhodamine 6G was dissolved in water by using ultrasonic cleaning machine for five minutes. The concentrations of the solution were prepared as 1 × 10−5 M. Then the solution was dropped on the substrate for Raman detection. The SERS and SEF signal were measured with a commercial Raman equipment (inVia-Reflex, Renishaw, Gloucestershire, UK) using a laser with a 532 nm wavelength as the excitation source, the measuring laser spot size was about 3 μm in diameter and the acquisition time was 20 seconds. Three-dimensional finite element method simulation was employed to give an in-depth explanation of SERS properties of these nanowires film samples. Polarization dependent reflectivity spectra were recorded by a commercial angle-resolved spectroscopy.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The characteristic (a), XRD patterns (b) and SEM image (b1) of silver nanowires. Statistical graph of the diameter (c) and length (d) of nanowires. |
Fig. 3 shows SEM images of nanowires films obtained at different deposition conditions. In Fig. 3(c) and (d), it can be clearly seen that the nanowires were deposited with an orientation arrangement. When a drop of nanomaterial solution dries on a solid surface or a liquid–air interface, the nanowires will adopt random orientations and finally leaves dense, well-organized assemblies because of both material–material and material–substrate interactions caused by the coffee ring effect.40 The capillary flow is responsible for the orientation deposition along the contact line, most commonly observed as a coffee ring stain.41 The resulting morphologies and the degree of the ordering achieved vary significantly and depend not only on the nanomaterial's size distribution but also on the directional capillary force, van der Waals attraction and the dewetting of the solvent during the assembly process.42 Rod-shaped nanostructure assembles in a number of ways, such as end-to-end or side-to-side, depending on their concentrations in the dispersions.43,44 Side-to-side assemblies can form ribbon-like structures or smectic arrays. Bates and Frenkel reported two types of phase behaviors for spherocylinders confined to a plane using Monte Carlo simulations.38 According to the result, long rods with aspect ratio >7 behave similar to infinitely thin needles and exhibit a 2D nematic phase at a high density. With the aspect ratio increase to 15–25, 2D bundle structures with occasional side-by-side alignment of bundles into 3D superstructures.45 On the other hand, the resulting outward flow can carry virtually all of the dispersed material to the edge. During drying, liquid evaporating from the edge is replenished by liquid from the interior and the contact line of the droplet undergoes stick-slip motion, that is, small movements interspersed with large and rapid displacements as a result of competition between the pinning and capillary forces. When the contact line is pinned (fixed), the solvent evaporating from the edge is replenished by solvent from the interior. Because the outward solvent flow carries dispersed nanostructures to the edge, the concentration of nanostructures at the edge is higher than that at the center. Owing to the anisotropic nature of the interactions, the tips of the nanowires would be directed along the flow of solution. This explains the self-assembly of rods that are predominantly aligned along the dewetting direction. As a result, the combined effect of the capillary flow and strong interaction leads to the formation of ordered nanowire arrays.46 At the edge of solutions, the contact line pinning and dewetting create the competition between the pinning and depinning forces. During evaporation of solvent, the contact angle decreases and the meniscus interface area increases. These changes cause an increase in a depinning force, without altering the pinning force. When the depinning force reaches a value greater than the pinning force, the contact line starts moving.42 With the solid–liquid contact line moves inward, the oriented silver nanowires film can be formed.
Fig. 4 shows the two- and three-dimensional surface profiles of the thin films by either Veeco Surface Profiler or AFM. Fig. 4(a) and (b) shows the morphology features of the thin film at an area of 10 square microns. The surface roughness of arithmetical mean height (Sa) of the film is 545 nm. The root mean square height (Sq) of the film is 650 nm. Veeco Surface Profiler was used to detect the surface morphology at a larger area (Fig. 4(c) and (d)). Quantitative characterization of the surface characteristics shows that the average roughness (Ra) of the film is 419 nm. The root-mean-squared roughness (Rq) of the film is 520 nm. Results obtained from the two methods are close. Quantitative characterization of the film by the two methods demonstrates that the film is very smooth.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Two- and three-dimensional surface profiles of the nanowire film. (a) and (b) obtained by AFM, (c) and (d) obtained by Veeco. |
Fig. 5 shows the polarization-dependent SERS spectra of Rhodamine 6G on the Ag nanowires films. The intensity of all the bands in this figure increased as the polarization angle θ changed from 0° to 90°. When the angle approaches 90°, the SERS intensity reaches a maximum. As the angle θ continue to increase, the intensity of all the bands gradually decreases. Minimum intensities were obtained at θ = 0° and θ = 180°. The apparent enhancement factor can be experimentally measured with direct comparison using the following relation: EF = (RSENH/RSREF) × (CREF/CENH), where RSENH and RSREF are the measured Raman intensities, and CREF and CENH are the solution's concentrations for normal and enhanced samples. The film exhibits a cross-section enhancement factor up to 3 × 104 as the polarization angle approaches 90°. It is 4.5 times of that at the parallel condition. To outline this periodicity, the strongest peak located at 611 cm−1 was selected to plot as a function of θ (Fig. 6(a)). It is obvious that the intensity of the Raman band experience fluctuations with respect to θ.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 The Raman results of Rhodamine 6G obtained at different angles between polarization and oriented silver nanowires. On the right side shows the schematic diagram of angle. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 The intensity of SERS (a) and SEF (b) at the peak of 611 cm−1 obtained at different angles between the linear polarization and oriented nanowires. |
The current theoretical understanding of SERS attributes its enhanced intensity to the local electric fields in a confined geometry where the probe molecules are located.47 A strong SERS polarization dependence has also been observed in aligned aggregates of high-aspect-ratio nanowires or nanorods. Unlike the case of isolated nanoparticles, the maximum SERS intensity observed for these assemblies of elongated nanoparticles is in the polarization direction perpendicular to the long axis of the rods/wires.48 Highly localized plasmon modes are created by strong electromagnetic coupling between adjacent metallic nanowires when the polarization direction perpendicular to the long axis of nanowire. So when the angle approaches 90° and 270°, the SERS intensity reaches a maximum.
The polarization effect can be illustrated that the strong and localized enhancement of the EM field possible at favorable locations in systems of interacting nanostructures. In brief, when two nanoparticles close to each other, the optical field in the interstice between them can become enhanced some 6 orders of magnitude above that in the individual particle assuming the exciting illumination is appropriately linearly polarized.44 The origin of the special enhancement obtained when the polarization direction illuminate across the nanowires (or two-nanosphere system) can be understood qualitatively by referring to Fig. 7(a) and (b). In Fig. 7(a), when a molecule located in the interstice is flanked by two sets of conjugate charges arising from the polarization of the individual nanowires, highly localized plasmon modes are created by strong electromagnetic coupling between adjacent metallic nanowires. Contrariwise, when the light is polarized in the other direction illustrated in Fig. 7(b), a molecule in the interstitial region does not benefit from proximity to the induced charges. To further illustrate this effect, the numerical electromagnetic simulations were performed with periodic boundaries (Fig. 7(c) and (d)). The optical material data for silver were taken from Johnson.49 From the Fig. 7(c), the polarization direction perpendicular to the long axis of the nanowires, incident radiation excites a plasmon trapped in the interstitials between cylinders, which lead to SERS enhancements. It correlates well with the predictions by García-Vidal and Pendry, who modeled EM coupling between aligned silver half-cylinders.50 In Fig. 7(d), only in the interstitials that between the ends of the nanowires there is SERS enhancements. Though the maximum enhancements of the ends of the nanowires (in Fig. 7(d)) is twice of the interstitials between cylinders (in Fig. 7(c)), when the polarization direction perpendicular to the long axis of the nanowires, periodic signal enhancement appear on the whole nanowire, and also the area of SERS enhancement is larger than parallel to the nanowires. So the polarization direction perpendicular to the long axis of the Ag nanowires may result in a higher probability of EM enhancements than the parallel polarization.
Raman scattering is an extremely weak nonlinear scattering process. Only when a molecule placed near the metallic nanostructure, Raman cross-sections are much larger than for a molecule in free space. This phenomenon is usually accompanied by SEF as a background.51 However, the research on the enhanced spectroscopy is mostly performed only with the SERS or SEF technique. They are rarely studied together so far. Fig. 5 also shows the enhanced spectra of SEF, which shows a broad based line profile for the fluorescence emission through the whole band. The sharp peaks overlapped on SEF are enhanced resonance Raman signals.47 From our experiment results (Fig. 6(b)), it can be seen that the fluorescent intensity shows the same fluctuation as the Raman signal. This probably indicates that SEF is also based on an EM enhancement mechanism, similar to that of SERS.47
In addition to the Raman and fluorescence properties of the aligned silver nanowire films, optical properties were also investigated through the polarization of reflectivity spectra. Fig. 8(a) shows the reflectivity of nanowires film obtained at different angle. The shapes of the spectra do not show any specific difference with different polarizations. However, the reflectivity is smaller when the incident light is polarized parallel to the oriented direction. It is because that the incident light was absorbed due to the larger dipole-oscillator strength in the parallel direction. This was consistently observed in several samples. Fig. 8(b) is ratio of the reflectivity at 90° to the reflectivity at 0°. It can be seen, as the increase of wavelength, the ratio gradually increased. The plasmon coupling in side-by-side vs. end-to-end dimers of nanorods modeled by discrete dipole approximation method shows an experimental shifts in the optical resonance bands, i.e., red-shift of the longitudinal plasmon band for end-to-end assembly in contrast to the blue-shift for the case of side-by-side assembly.52 So as the increase of wavelength, the reflectivity is larger and larger when the incident light is perpendicularly polarized to the oriented direction. When the wavelength greater than 870 nm, the ratio can be as high as 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 (a) The reflectivity of nanowires film obtained at different angle. (b) The ratio of reflectivity. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |