Nan
Chen‡
a,
B.
Reeja-Jayan‡
a,
Jonathan
Lau
b,
Priya
Moni
c,
Andong
Liu
a,
Bruce
Dunn
b and
Karen K.
Gleason
*a
aDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA. E-mail: kkgleason@mit.edu
bDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095, USA
cDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
First published on 14th January 2015
We report the development of nanoscale (10–40 nm), conformal thin film electrolytes realized by doping lithium ions (Li+) into poly-(tetravinyltetramethylcyclotetrasiloxane) (PV4D4) films, which were synthesized by initiated chemical vapor deposition (iCVD). This is the first time nanoscale films with siloxane ring moieties, which are excellent electrical insulators, have been demonstrated as room temperature ionic conductors. The films exhibit minimal changes in morphology and thickness during lithiation and are also demonstrated to be easily scalable over large areas. We show that the conformal nature of the iCVD polymerization process realizes complete coverage of nanostructured electrodes like nanowires by a uniform, continuous, and pinhole-free thin film, making the polysiloxane films attractive as a novel class of nanoscale electrolytes for the emerging field of three-dimensional (3D) batteries.
Conceptual insights3D battery architectures overcome limitations of traditional planar designs by creating non-planar electrode structures, which increase energy densities within a small areal footprint while maintaining the short ionic transport distances necessary for high power densities. One of the key technological limitations to the development of 3D battery architectures is the synthesis of a nanoscale ion-conducting thin film electrolyte that can uniformly cover complex geometries of 3D electrodes while occupying minimum volume. Shorter ionic diffusion lengths result in orders of magnitude lower ionic diffusion times in these nanoscale films, when compared with bulk or microscale polymeric electrolytes like poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO). The shorter diffusion times can thus compensate for modest ionic conductivities (∼10−8 S cm−1) in these nanoscale films, realizing a new class of electrolytes. The non-line-of-sight nature of the iCVD process further enables conformal coverage of high-aspect-ratio nanowires with precise control over thickness and compositional on the nanoscale. |
The iCVD process directly converts gas phase monomers into solid films through polymerization of the vinyl bonds.4 One of the primary benefits of iCVD is the ability to retain all non-vinyl organic moieties present in the monomer. In the case of monomers, like tetravinyltetramethylcyclotetrasiloxane (V4D4), the siloxane ring structure of the monomer is retained while reaction of the four vinyl groups results in a highly cross-linked network.5,6 The monomer and a thermally labile initiator flow into a reaction chamber, wherein thermal energy from heated filaments generates initiator radicals, which react with adsorbed monomer on a cooled substrate, forming a polymer film.7,8 The resulting polymer films are capable of uniformly covering such structures as arrays of high-aspect-ratio nanowires which serve as 3D electrodes.4 In this work, we demonstrate that the iCVD process can be used to deposit 10–40 nm thick polymer films conformally on high-aspect-ratio nanowires. The uniform thickness and composition of these polymer electrolyte films are very attractive for 3D battery architectures. In addition to conformality, we show that iCVD polymer films are extremely smooth, and virtually free of pinholes, exhibit low electronic conductivity and possess excellent high voltage stability,9,10 all of which are properties required for thin conformal electrolytes.1–3,11 We further establish processing protocols that enable the iCVD polymer electrolyte to exhibit reasonable levels of ionic conductivity at room temperature, with minimal change in morphology and film thickness during the ion doping (lithiation) process.
The most commonly explored polymeric electrolyte is poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO, [–(O–CH2–CH2)–]n).12,13 PEO and its cyclic variants are known to chelate ions like Li+. However, PEO is crystalline at room temperature and the segmental motion of the –C–O–C– linkages that facilitate Li+ transport only occurs in amorphous phase, resulting in improved ionic conductivity at elevated temperatures (>60 °C).14,15 Conjugating siloxane segments to PEO is reported to increase ionic conductivity and impart improved mechanical and electrochemical stability.16–24 The –Si–O–Si– bonds in the siloxane moieties are more ionic than –C–O–C– bonds leading to a more negative charge on the oxygen atom that can chelate Li+. The flexible nature and associated free volume of the siloxane linkages further facilitate ionic transport. Inspired by these properties of siloxane networks, we studied several multivinyl siloxane monomers that can be polymerized to form flexible, cross-linked network structures, with the potential for the ring structures in the monomer to stack to form built-in channels for Li+ transport.25
Among polymers derived from such cyclic siloxane materials, PV4D4 exhibits good mechanical and thermal stability,5,6 which is highly desirable for thin film electrolytes, but currently used bulk synthesis techniques are not suitable for growing conformal thin films.26 We demonstrate for the first time that Li+ doping of iCVD grown nanoscale PV4D4 films makes them ionic conductors with ionic conductivities >10−8 S cm−1 at room temperature. It is important to note that the short ionic diffusion times possible at nanoscale dimensions compensate for these modest ionic conductivities, when compared to conventional bulk or microscale polymeric electrolytes.3,27
In order to verify the chemical structure of the deposited film, we measured FTIR of the monomer (V4D4), polymer (PV4D4) and the lithiated PV4D4. In Fig. 1b, strong peaks at 1060 cm−1 are due to Si–O vibrations from the retained Si–O–Si rings. Comparisons between polymer and monomer spectra confirm polymerization as the single-peak at 1261 cm−1 (Si–methyl) remains unchanged while peaks at 1408 cm−1 (CH2 deformation) and 1600 cm−1 (CC) are reduced.5 Further evidence for the polymerization can be found around 2900 cm−1 indicating C–H stretching from the newly formed polyethylene-like backbone in the polymer. No obvious difference was observed between the spectra of original PV4D4 and the lithiated film. This is mainly because the major IR absorption of LiClO4 (Cl–O ν3 asymmetric stretching) appears around 1100 cm−1,30 which is overlapped by the strong Si–O absorption. The comparison also suggests the PV4D4 film remains chemically and mechanically intact without noticeable structural re-arrangement after the solution based lithiation step. We previously demonstrated that polysiloxane films are excellent electronic insulators that maintain high values of bulk electrical resistivity (>4 × 1015 Ω cm) under constant electrical bias for over 8 years.9 The highly cross-linked network from polymerization of multiple propagation (vinyl) sites is the main reason for the chemical and mechanical stability, which are attractive for electrolyte applications. In addition, such robust nanoscale conformal coatings can serve as protective layers on battery electrodes during electrochemical processes.31,32
The morphology of iCVD PV4D4 films was characterized by TEM and AFM. Fig. 2a shows a TEM image of a bare Ag nanowire (160 nm in diameter). As shown in Fig. 2b, 10 nm PV4D4 film covers the nanowire uniformly, demonstrating excellent conformality of the film over high-aspect-ratio nanostructures thus maintaining the high surface area of the nanowire. Smoothness is also essential for thin-film electrolytes as large variations in thickness statistically increase the possibility of pinhole defects.14 AFM micrograph (Fig. S1 and S2†) depicts as-deposited PV4D4 film on silicon is extremely smooth with root mean square roughness (RRMS) of 0.46 nm. Fig. 2c shows that PV4D4 coated nanowires retain their morphology after lithiation with minimal change in film thickness (mean thickness and standard deviation over multiple nanowire samples is shown in Fig. S3†).
Fig. 2 (a) TEM image of uncoated Ag nanowire; (b) 10 nm PV4D4 coated Ag nanowire; (c) 10 nm PV4D4 coated Ag nanowire after lithiation. |
Mechanical adhesion and chemical stability of these films were further verified by VASE measurements (Table S2 and Fig. S4†), which demonstrate no statistically significant change in thickness and refractive index of PV4D4 films after lithiation. Unlike typical polymer films which can swell ∼50%,29 the thickness change of PV4D4 films is minimal (<3%) after lithiation (Table S2†). Such minimal change in morphology and thickness of these nanoscale, conformal PV4D4 films upon lithiation is also attractive for deploying them as electrolytes in battery devices.
In Fig. 3, we demonstrate that the iCVD process used to engineer these nanoscale, conformal PV4D4 films can be uniformly scaled over a larger area. VASE measurements at various positions of a PV4D4 film grown on a 100 mm diameter silicon wafer show excellent uniformity – the standard deviation of measurements at different locations are within 4.6% of the average film thickness. These are encouraging results for commercialization of these electrolyte films, as the solvent-free iCVD polymerization process is readily scalable and easily integrated with other techniques, such as roll-to-roll processing.33
The electrical conductivities of unlithiated PV4D4 films were measured as 4.1 ± 2.4 × 10−11 S cm−1 and 5.7 ± 3.4 × 10−11 S cm−1 for the 25 and 35 nm films, respectively. The current–voltage plots (Fig. S5†) show an ohmic response and are stable over time. These measurements indicate that the unlithiated polymer films are excellent dielectrics and can withstand electric fields in excess of 104 V cm−1.
Impedance spectroscopy performed at multiple positions using a hanging Hg drop electrode arrangement (Fig. 4a) shows the dielectric response of the unlithiated 25 nm thick PV4D4 film as indicated by the vertical line in the Nyquist plot (Fig. 4b) and near −90° phase angles in the Bode plot over the entire range of frequencies (Fig. S6†). Similar results were measured on unlithiated 35 nm films. After lithiation, the impedance response of the PV4D4 film is that of an ionic conductor. The Nyquist plot for the lithiated 25 nm sample clearly depicts the characteristic semi-circles indicative of ionic transport (Fig. 4c). The impedance data for the 35 nm film (Fig. S7†) are also consistent with the RC circuit used to model charge transport. Using the averaged ionic resistance (Rp) determined from equivalent circuit fitting, the measured film thickness and the electrode contact area defined by Hg drop size, the ionic conductivity (σ) was calculated as follows:
(1) |
For the lithiated 25 nm PV4D4 film, σ is 7.5 ± 4.5 × 10−8 S cm−1 at room temperature. We hypothesize that oxygen atoms on siloxane rings of PV4D4 can provide favourable binding sites for Li+, while ClO4− counterions remain in the inter-ring space to minimize electrostatic repulsion (Fig. 4c). Besides Li+, ClO4− ions may also contribute to measured ionic conductivities. Efforts are currently ongoing to experimentally measure the Li+ transference number in order to determine the relative contributions of Li+ and ClO4− ions. The flexible Si–O–Si bonds further facilitate ion transport, resulting in ionic conduction at room temperature. For similar ionic diffusion coefficients (Dion), the ionic diffusion time (τ) increases as the square of the ionic diffusion length (Lion), as described by:27,34
(2) |
Accordingly, a 10 nm thick PV4D4 film exhibits 6 orders of magnitude lower ionic diffusion time (τ) compared to a 10 μm thick film of conventional electrolytes. Therefore, nanoscale electrolytes like PV4D4 can compensate for their modest ionic conductivity of ∼10−8 S cm−1 by their shorter ionic diffusion times, when compared with bulk electrolytes with higher conductivities. Additionally, as shown in Table S3,† iCVD synthesized PV4D4 films already demonstrate the highest ionic conductivity value reported among nanoscale, conformal thin film electrolytes. Furthermore, this value of conductivity at room temperature is important relative to that at higher temperature for several applications like sensing and medical implants that operate under ambient conditions.
For the thicker 35 nm PV4D4 film, σ = 1.3 ± 1.2 × 10−10 S cm−1. One hypothesis for the decrease in ionic conductivity as film thickness increases is that disorder in ring stacking increases with film thickness, leading to lower ionic conductivity. Alternatively, full lithiation of the thicker film may not have been achieved. While all positions on unlithiated PV4D4 film in Fig. 4a show dielectric behaviour, the variability in the impedance values seen at different positions on the lithiated PV4D4 film (Fig. 4c) suggests that there is an inhomogeneous distribution of charge carriers throughout the PV4D4 film. Optimization of the lithiation process is ongoing to eliminate this variability.
The absence of pinholes in a nanoscale thin film electrolyte is a critical issue for batteries in order to prevent short circuits caused by touching of anode and cathode particles. The most widely investigated thin film solid-state batteries typically have electrolyte thicknesses on the order of 1 μm and are sufficiently thick that pinholes are not problematic.35 However, in the present study, where the polymer films are on the order of 25 nm, the presence of pinholes is a greater concern. The approach we used to characterize pinholes in the PV4D4 films was based on electrochemical techniques which make use of different cyclic voltammetry signatures that depend on pinhole conditions in nanoporous, self-assembled monolayers.36,37 This method quantifies the number of pinholes of a given size over a specific area and thus provides a useful metric for evaluating an electrolyte as these defects represent potential currents paths that can lead to electrical shorting between electrodes.
The characterization method and the results obtained with the redox couples dmFc and CoCp2PF6 as probe molecules, are presented in Fig. S8 and S9.† Based on the cyclic voltammetry results, the pinholes can be reasonably estimated to be in the same size regime as the probe molecules, or approximately 4 nm in diameter.37 The number density of these pinholes were calculated (Table 1) and found to be somewhat less than those reported for self-assembled monolayers based on organomercaptans,37 suggesting that these PV4D4 films are effectively pinhole free. Moreover, the number density of pinholes decreases upon lithiation. This effect is most likely due to the closing of some pinholes as a result of the expansion of the PV4D4 film from the incorporation of LiClO4, as demonstrated by a slight increase in film thickness after lithiation (Table S2†).
PV4D4 film | Redox couple | Peak current density [μA cm−2] | Number density of pinholes [pinholes μm−2] |
---|---|---|---|
Unlithiated 20 nm | dmFc | 23.50 | 8.01 |
Unlithiated 20 nm | CoCp2PF6 | 14.00 | 3.68 |
Lithiated 20 nm | dmFc | 14.50 | 4.94 |
Lithiated 20 nm | CoCp2PF6 | 9.35 | 2.46 |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: iCVD synthesis details, AFM images, VASE data, comparison of thin film electrolytes, pinhole characterization. See DOI: 10.1039/c4mh00246f |
‡ These authors contribute equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |