Open Access Article
Phillip
Schmieder
,
Maciej
Grzywa
,
Dmytro
Denysenko
,
Manuel
Hambach
and
Dirk
Volkmer
*
Institute of Physics, Chair of Solid State and Material Science, Augsburg University, Universitaetsstrasse 1, 86159 Augsburg, Germany. E-mail: dirk.volkmer@physik.uni-augsburg.de; Fax: +49(0)821 598 5955; Tel: +49(0)821 598 3006
First published on 16th June 2015
The novel interpenetrated metal–organic framework CFA-7 (Coordination Framework Augsburg University-7), [Zn5Cl4(tqpt)3], has been synthesized containing the organic linker {H2-tqpt = 6,6,14,14-tetramethyl-6,14-dihydroquinoxalino[2,3-b]phenazinebistriazole}. Reaction of H2-tqpt and anhydrous ZnCl2 in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) yields CFA-7 as pseudo-cubic crystals. CFA-7 serves as precursor for the synthesis of isostructural frameworks with redox-active metal centers, which is demonstrated by postsynthetic metal exchange of Zn2+ by different M2+ (M = Co, Ni, Cu) ions. The novel framework is robust upon solvent removal and has been structurally characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, TGA and IR spectroscopy, as well as gas sorption (Ar, CO2 and H2).
Interpenetration, i.e. the occurrence of two or more structurally independent networks which are intergrown with each other, is a frequently observed phenomenon in MOF structural chemistry. The iconic MOF-5 was intensively investigated in terms of interpenetration in recent years.3 Depending on water content, reaction time and temperature, molar ratio of metal salt-to-organic linker or the addition of agents like melamine, non-interpenetrated, partially or completely interpenetrated network variants of MOF-5 were obtained. Interpenetration in MOFs often leads to a reduced specific surface area of the network. On the other hand, interpenetrated frameworks may also feature some additional advantages such as improved network stability, increased heat of adsorption for certain molecular probes or enhanced molecular size selectivity.3c,4
Aiming to extend the range of isoreticular MFU-4-type frameworks, we here report on the synthesis and the structure of CFA-7 (Coordination Framework Augsburg University-7) containing the largest straight linker molecule when compared to the organic bistriazolate linkers previously employed in the synthesis of porous MFU-4-type frameworks.5–10
The modular MFU-4 family is based on Kuratowski-type11 pentanuclear secondary building units (SBUs) of the general formula [MII5X4(L6)] (Fig. 1). In the pentanuclear coordination units, six triazolate ligands are monodentately coordinated to the central octahedrally coordinated Zn ion. The triazolate ligands are twisted around their coordinative bond to the central metal ion such that the nitrogen atoms are placed on the six edges of an imaginary tetrahedron, the four corners of which are occupied by four peripheral Zn ions. Accordingly, each of the latter are coordinated by three N donor atoms of the organic triazolate linkers. The coordination environment of each peripheral zinc ions is completed by an additional (anionic) ligand, i.e. a halide anion.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Kuratowski-type SBU of MFU-4-type frameworks (central octahedrally coordinated metal ion: purple octahedron, peripheral Zn: yellow tetrahedra; N: blue; C: grey, Cl: green). | ||
A special feature of the Kuratowski-type secondary building unit is the possibility to exchange the peripheral zinc ions by other (transition) metal ions. Adjusting appropriate reaction conditions it is possible to obtain heterometallic derivatives of CFA-7via postsynthetic metal exchange, as described previously for MFU-4l7,9,10 and CFA-1.8 Heating up CFA-7 with solutions of the corresponding metal salts in N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc) leads to replacement of peripheral Zn2+ by M2+ (M = Co, Ni, Cu) ions. Depending on the metal source and the initial stoichiometric ratio of metal ions in the suspension, different numbers of zinc centers can be replaced by M2+ ions. CFA-7 includes the fourth bistriazolate linker used to build MFU-4-type frameworks and represents the first framework of this type which is interpenetrated. Employing very long organic linkers we were aiming at MFU-4XL, a hypothetical cubic framework structure with extraordinary high specific surface area. The non-interpenetrated 3D structure of CFA-7 is termed MFU-4extra large (MFU-4XL, calc. surface17 up to 4500 m2 g−1, Fig. 2 top right) due to its very large unit cell as compared to the previously published cubic networks of MFU-45 and MFU-4large6 (Fig. 2). However, all attempts to synthesize the non-interpenetrated framework have failed in our hands so far.
514(2) Å3.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Optical microscopy images of CFA-7: (a) overview of the as synthesized pseudo-cubic crystals; (b) hexagonal CFA-7 crystals. | ||
It is also possible to synthesize CFA-7 in a microwave reactor at 250 W and 160 °C for 10 min. Morphology and surface details of the hexagonal crystals were investigated by DIC, SEM and AFM micrographs (Fig. 4–6). Differential interference contrast microscopy shows uniform hexagonal crystals with a size up to 30 μm (Fig. 4). Inspection of electron microscopic images reveals that the crystal faces of the hexagonal specimen are smooth and flat. An AFM measurement of a hexagonal single crystal of a size of about 30 × 30 μm was carried out in order to analyze the crystal's surface topography. In Fig. 6, it can be seen, that the surface is flat and exhibits no macroscopic height differences within the measured area.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 SEM micrographs of CFA-7; (a) hexagonal shape of a single- crystal of CFA-7; (b) partially intergrown crystals. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 AFM micrographs; (a) 3 dimensional view of a hexagonal CFA-7 single crystal; (b) 3 dimensional view of CFA-7 crystal surface. | ||
A single-crystal X-ray diffraction study of a hexagonal crystal reveals that CFA-7 crystallizes in the trigonal space group R
m (no. 166). Pseudo-cubic crystal of a size ranging from about 25–40 μm in each direction were also investigated but the single crystal structural analyses lead to the same solutions (trigonal crystal system and R
m space group), but the quality of the obtained data sets was lower in terms of resolution at high diffraction angles if compared to hexagonal crystal. The asymmetric unit including atom labels is presented in Fig. S15.†CFA-7 is constructed from {Zn5Cl4−x((H2O)3)x}(6+x)+ secondary building units interconnected by the two-fold deprotonated organic linker tqpt2−. Due to the conformationally flexible cyclohexyl unit in the middle of each organic linker molecule, the tqpt2− ligand in the CFA-7 network is not completely planar. About 80% of the CFA-7 network is constructed from regular {Zn5Cl4(triazolate)6} Kuratowski-type SBUs. The remaining 20% SBUs consist of singly charged {Zn5Cl3(H2O)3(triazolate)6} units, in which a single chloro ligand is replaced by 3 aqua ligands, thus leading to a non-coordinated (positionally strongly disordered) chloride anion which is placed in the void volume of the crystal lattice in order to retain a net zero charge. The zinc ions in the centers of the SBUs (Zn1 or Zn5, placed at a site of 3m symmetry) are octahedrally coordinated by six nitrogen atoms of six different organic linker molecules. The four peripheral zinc ions (Zn2 or Zn4, placed at sites of m symmetry) are four-fold coordinated by three nitrogen atoms of the organic linker and by the chloride anion. A fraction of 20% of the fourth peripheral zinc ions (Zn3 or Zn6, positioned at a site of 3m symmetry) is octahedrally coordinated by three nitrogen atoms of the linker molecules and by three oxygen atoms from water molecules. The different coordination schemes for both kinds of SBUs are shown in the plots in Fig. 8. The Zn–O distances are between 2.07–2.09 Å. These values are in good agreement with those found in the literature for similar Zn(II) compounds in which the octahedrally coordinated Zn ion binds three nitrogen containing ligands and three water molecules.15 The Zn–N bond distances span a range of 2.150(10)–2.209(10) Å for the octahedrally coordinated Zn1 and Zn5 and 2.010(6)–2.135(13) Å for Zn2, Zn3, Zn4 and Zn6. These values are similar to those found in structurally related Zn triazolate compounds of the MFU-4 family.10CFA-7 features a 3-D two-fold interpenetrated structure constructed from Kuratowski-type SBUs. The packing diagram of CFA-7, depicted in Fig. 7, shows two subnetworks. The simplified networks, displayed in red and blue colors, are shifted by 4.51 Å with respect to each other in [001] direction, which represents the shortest distance between two adjacent Zn ions belonging to different subnetworks). Fig. 7 also indicates the pseudo-cubic nature of the CFA-7 network pointing at the close structural relation to the non-interpenetrated (hypothetical) MFU-4extra large network. Fig. 9 (left) shows a schematic representation of both subnetworks of CFA-7. The minimal divergence from right angles (Fig. 9 left) makes it impossible to solve the structure in a cubic space group.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 Interpenetrated structure of CFA-7. In yellow the apparent pore aperture of the channels of the network is given (calculated with the Poreblazer software17). | ||
Calculations with the program SQUEEZE16 reveal that the initial solvent accessible void volume is 28
982 Å3, which is about 58.3% of the unit cell volume (49
703 Å3) for a probe radius of 1.68 Å, corresponding to the approximate van der Waals radius of argon.17 In the crystal structure of CFA-7 the pores are occupied by disordered Cl− ions and DMF molecules. The positions of the molecules were impossible to resolve and to refine from the electron density distribution. According to the crystallographic data there is an electron count of 7108 per unit cell (rest of the electron density), which corresponds to approx. 5.34 Cl− and 175 DMF molecules in the unit cell of CFA-7. Thus, the composition of the framework is determined as [Zn5Cl3.11(H2O)2.65(tqpt)3](0.89+) (Cl−)0.89·29.25DMF. This means, 0.89 chloride ions per SBU are displaced in the pores in order to retain neutral charge.
The calculation of maximal pore diameter and pore limiting diameter was performed using the Poreblazer software.18 The limiting diameter in the CFA-7 network is 6.83 Å and the maximum pore diameter is 11.71 Å. The diameter of the channels in the interpenetrated CFA-7 network is 10.80 Å. The organic triazolate ligand of the network is disordered along the c-direction (Fig. 9 right). Three oxygen atoms of water ligands coordinating to Zn3 or Zn6 are placed in the interpenetrated frameworks in a way such that a staggered arrangement of the altogether six oxygen atoms of adjacent Kuratowski units is obtained (Fig. 8a). The non-bonding distances between two oxygen atoms of each SBU range from 2.87 Å to 4.16 Å. It is possible that hydrogen bridges are formed between the water ligands of the octahedrally coordinated zinc ions.
Up to now, it was not possible to synthesize the non-interpenetrated network of CFA-7 (MFU-4extra large, Fig. 2). It is necessary to develop strategies to suppress the interpenetration in order to construct highly porous MOFs with high surface area. In literature different approaches for controlling the interpenetration in MOFs have been described.3c,4 In our hands, varying the reaction temperature (in the range of 60–150 °C) and the concentration of the reaction mixture (in the range of 2–25 μmol ml−1) had no influence on the interpenetration in CFA-7. Moreover, selecting solvents of different molecular size (e.g. N,N-dibutylformamide instead of DMF) did not lead to the synthesis of non-interpenetrated frameworks as confirmed by BET surface area measurements.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 Thermogravimetric analysis of pre-dried (blue) and not-dried (black) CFA-7 under nitrogen atmosphere. | ||
Variable temperature X-ray powder diffraction studies (VTXRPD) show, similarly to the TGA data, that CFA-7 is stable up to 400 °C in air.
430(6) Å3. The resulting plots are presented in Fig. S2.† The XRPD patterns of the other metal exchanged CFA-7 samples, shown in Fig. S4,† also confirm the stability of the framework upon metal exchange. In the case of manganese the Mn/Zn ratio obtained upon metal exchange is quite high, which is probably due to the precipitation of amorphous manganese impurities on the surface of the crystals (Fig. 12c). All exchange reactions were performed at 60 °C for 16 hours. The exchange reaction, when performed with copper(II) perchlorate gives a higher exchange ratio of peripheral zinc ions if compared to copper chloride employed as the source of metal ions. These transition metal containing frameworks are of potential interest for catalytic applications. The XRPD and IR data (Fig. S4 and S17†) of dry samples (300 °C per vacuum) indicate phase purity and thermal stability of all derivatives thus obtained.
| Metal salt | EDX [At%] | Molar ratioa Zn2+ : M2+ |
Morphology | Color |
|---|---|---|---|---|
a Theoretical Zn2+ : M2+ ratio for total exchange of the peripheral metal atoms is 1 : 4.
|
||||
| CuCl2·2H2O | Zn: 35.91 | 3.0 : 2.0 |
Cubes | Light brown |
| Cu: 23.72 | ||||
| Cl: 40.37 | ||||
| Cu(ClO4)2·6H2O | Zn: 19.70 | 1.6 : 3.4 |
Cubes | Brown |
| Cu: 40.80 | ||||
| Cl: 39.50 | ||||
| CoCl2·6H2O | Zn: 38.35 | 3.3 : 1.7 |
Cubes | Green |
| Co: 20.55 | ||||
| Cl: 41.10 | ||||
| NiCl2 (wf) | Zn: 36.16 | 3.0 : 2.0 |
Cubes | Dark yellow |
| Ni: 23.64 | ||||
| Cl: 40.20 | ||||
| MnCl2·2H2O | Zn: 2.04 | 0.1 : 4.9 |
Cubes with contaminated surface | Dark brown |
| Mn: 94.01 | ||||
| Cl: 3.95 | ||||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 13 Pore size distribution for CFA-7 calculated by fitting NLDFT model to the Ar adsorption/desorption data. | ||
High-resolution CO2 adsorption/desorption isotherms measured at 194.7 K show no hysteresis over the whole pressure range and thus confirm the structural rigidity of the interpenetrated CFA-7 framework (Fig. 14).
The isosteric heat of CO2 adsorption in CFA-7 determined from the adsorption isotherms in the temperature range 273–293 K, as described in the ESI,† is nearly constant at 22.5 kJ mol−1 (Fig. 15). This value is considerably higher as the one determined previously for MFU-4l (16.5 kJ mol−1),22 which is most likely due to the presence of basic amino functions in the tqpt2− ligand. Alternatively, the increased heat of CO2 adsorption could also be a special feature of the interpenetrated framework. However, the second explanation seems to be less likely since the heat of H2 adsorption is very similar to MFU-4l and decreases constantly from 7.4 kJ mol−1 at 0.18 mmol g−1 loading to 6.2 kJ mol−1 at 2.2 mmol g−1 loading (Fig. 16).
Interpenetrated MOFs sometimes show flexible character due to displacement of individual sub-frameworks against each other. Dramatic steps in the adsorption and hysteresis in the desorption of CO2 have been observed in a twofold interpenetrated MOF, Zn2(bttb)(dpni) (bttb = 4,4,4,4-benzene-1,2,4,5-tetrayltetrabenzolate, dpni = N,N-di-(4-pyridyl)-1,4,5,8-naphthalenetetracarboxydiimide) reported by Hupp and coworkers.23 Characterization of the structure by XRPD and pair distribution function (PDF) analysis indicated that structural changes upon CO2 sorption most likely involve the moving of the interpenetrated frameworks.24
In the interpenetrated CFA-7 it seems as though the interpenetration has no direct influence on the sorption properties. The much higher heat of absorption from CFA-7 for CO2 compared to MFU-4l is mostly due to the interaction between the carbon dioxide and the additional nitrogen atoms with pyrazine character in the organic linker molecule. Based on theoretical considerations, the incorporation of accessible nitrogen-donor functional groups, such as pyridine, pyrazine, imidazole, and tetrazole, into the pore walls of porous materials can dramatically affect the gas uptake capacity and selectivity of the materials, especially for CO2 capture, which most likely accounts for dipole–quadrupole interactions between the polarizable CO2 molecule and the accessible nitrogen site.25–31
A special feature of the system is the extended organic linker molecule with four additional (pyrazine) nitrogen atoms per linker molecule, which do not coordinate any metal ions under the reaction conditions described in this article. However, it might be possible to functionalize these N-donor sites under suitable reaction conditions, employing various organometallic reagents, for instance.
Similarly to MFU-4large and CFA-1 frameworks it is possible to exchange the peripheral Zn ions of each Kuratowski unit by Co(II), Cu(II) or Ni(II) to form open-shell 3d transition metal CFA-7 derivatives as a versatile approach towards redox-active MOFs. Further attempts to synthesize the non-interpenetrated CFA-7 framework (“MFU-4XL”) are currently underway. Studying this framework would help to understand the nature of the increased isosteric heat of CO2 adsorption which could also be a special feature of the interpenetrated framework.
The H2-tqpt ligand was synthesized in three steps from commercially available 5,5-dimethylcyclohexane-1,3-dione.11 The following methylation and oxidation reactions are documented in literature.11 The 1H-benzotriazole-5,6-diamine was synthesized as described in literature.12
Yield: 2.15 g (73%). 1H NMR (400 MHz, DMSO-d6/TFA-d, δ (ppm)): 11.67 (s, 4H, NH), 8.64 (s, 4H, ArH), 2.01 (s, 12H, –CH3). 13C NMR (100 MHz, DMSO-d6/TFA-d, δ (ppm)): 156.65, 139.88, 138.47, 112.52, 45.83, 31.23. IR (ν (cm−1)): 1459.53, 1225.48, 1097.79, 850.99, 611.90, 412.05. Elemental analysis calcd for C22H18N10 (%): C 62.55, H 4.29, N 33.16; found: C 62.58, H 4.20, N 33.22.
Yield: 17.65 mg (51%). IR (ν (cm−1)): 1456, 1271, 1211, 1146, 1105, 1070, 850, 613, 310. Elemental analysis calcd (%) for C66H48Cl4N30Zn5: C 45.82, H 2.80, N 24.29; found: C 45.89, H 2.71, N 24.30.
Yield: 20.11 mg (48%). IR (ν (cm−1)): 1410, 1311, 1196, 866, 422, 230. Elemental analysis calcd (%) for C66H48I4N30Zn5: C 37.82, H 2.31, N 20.05; found: C 37.89, H 2.41, N 20.30.
The particles were filtrated and washed several times with DMAc, methanol and dichloromethane. The sample was dried at 300 °C under vacuum.
Yield: 4.23–4.90 mg (90–97%); the number of M2+ ions in the formula unit calculated from the M2+/Zn ratio was determined by EDX. All metal exchange reactions can be carried out in the same procedure with the corresponding metal salt. UV/vis and IR spectra are displayed in the ESI.†
| a R 1 = ∑||Fo| − |Fc||/∑|Fo|. b wR2 = ∑[w(Fo2 − Fc2)2]/∑[w(Fo2)2]1/2. | |
|---|---|
| Compound | CFA-7; [Zn5Cl3.11(H2O)2.65(tqpt)3](0.89+) (Cl−)0.89·29.25DMF |
| Empirical formula | C307.5H516.1 Cl8N118.5O63.8Zn10 |
| Formula | C66H53.3Cl3.11N30O2.65Zn5, Cl0.8929.25 (C3H7NO) |
| M r/g mol−1 | 7831.59 |
| T/K | 100(2) |
| Wavelength/Å | 0.71073 |
| Crystal system | Trigonal |
| Space group |
R m (no. 166) |
| a/Å | 28.764(4) |
| c/Å | 69.369(9) |
| V/Å3 | 49 703(12) |
| Z | 6 |
| D c/g cm−3 | 1.570 |
| μ/mm−1 | 0.873 |
| F(000) | 24 822 |
| θ Range/° | 2.18 to 25.06 |
| Refls. collected | 200 917 |
| Refls. unique | 10 406 |
| Data/restraints/parameters | 10 406/264/453 |
| R(int) | 0.1992 |
| GooF | 1.129 |
| R 1 (I > 2σ(I)]a | 0.1299 |
| wR2 (all data)b | 0.3676 |
| Largest diff. peak and hole/Å−3 | 1.855 and −1.798 |
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: XRPDs from CFA-7 and its derivatives, NMR measurements of the organic linker, IR spectras and crystallographic data. CCDC 1062243. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c5dt01673h |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |