Fansheng Chenga,
Haibing Xuc,
Cong Wanga,
Zhengjun Gongb,
Changyu Tanga and
Meikun Fan*b
aChengdu Green Energy and Green Manufacturing R&D Centre, Chengdu, Sichuan 610207, China
bDepartment of Environmental Science and Engineering, Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu, Sichuan 610031, China. E-mail: meikunfan@gmail.com
cNew Materials R&D Center, Institute of Chemical Materials, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Chengdu, Sichuan 610200, China
First published on 18th November 2014
Here in this work, we report the fabrication of a (metal) ion selective surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) optrode, the counterpart of an ion selective electrode, for the detection of metal ions in solution. Following our previous work, a layer-by-layer self-assembly strategy was used to fabricate the SERS optrode, followed by modification with an ion chelating reagent, 4-(4-phenylmethanethiol)-2,2′:6′,2′′-terpyridine (PMTTP). The SERS spectrum change after binding with metal ions was used to identify and detect metal ions in solution. Cd2+ in aqueous solution was chosen as a sample analyte. Similar to standard pH measurement, through simple single point known standard solution calibration, a quick (semi-)quantitative analysis of Cd2+ was realized.
In recent years, surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS), a technique that not only can achieve single-molecule sensitivity with the help of nanostructured noble metals, but also is used for direct identification of substance using its inherent finger-printed spectra of molecules, has gained wide attention.11 In fact, SERS is considered to be one of the most powerful spectroscopic analytical methods.11–15
Inspired by both the merits of fiber optic sensor and SERS, different groups, including ourselves, have put efforts in building SERS optrodes.16–26 Currently, the focus is mostly on the fabricating of effective signal transmitting media, i.e., SERS substrate, where the protocols include layer-by-layer self-assembly of metallic NPs,20–24 chemical vapor deposition modification,25 in situ photo reduction modification,16,26 templated27,28 or non-templated29 physical vapor deposition,30,31 and nano-fabricated structures on physical deposited metal films32,33 on one end of the optical fibers (bundles).
However, the analytes of the SERS optrode currently demonstrated are limited, most of them are “sample analytes”, such as dyes,21,24,32,34 thiols,24,25,29,31,33 and other small molecules.24,27 Though there are reports using SERS technique for sensing metal ions in water with organic chelating probes,35–45 there is only one reported work about the development of SERS optical fiber sensor for detecting metal ions.42 However, it does not really fall into the definition of optrode since optical fiber only served as SERS substrate and signal transmitting media.42,46 In other words, it would be difficult to be applied in remote sensing situation. Further, unlike pH electrode and contrary to what the word optrode may imply, a series of concentration gradients have to be tested to obtain a calibration curve before each measurement.42 We believe two possible reasons might have hindered the development of ion selective SERS optrode: (1) the lack of methods for fabricating SERS optrode with high sensitivity and stability; and (2) lack of good chelating reagents that can flag the existence of different metal ions with SERS spectra change. Due to stability issue, it is hard to reuse the SERS optrode. On the other hand, since there is huge variation, it is almost impossible for quantification analysis through multiple SERS optrodes. All these make the idea of using SERS optrode for the analysis of metal ions less attractive compared with its counterpart, ion selective electrode.
Previously, we have demonstrated that through layer-by-layer assembly of Ag NPs on single mode20 and multimode21 optical fiber, SERS detection with near single molecule sensitivity could be achieved. Meanwhile, by incubating the SERS optrode in N2 atmosphere at 120 °C for 1 hour, the stability could be greatly improved. Both multiplexing and continuous monitoring of different sample analytes in a microfluidic chip were realized.21 In this report, we will examine the feasibility of developing SERS optrode for metal ion detection. We modified the distal end of the SERS optrode with a metal ion chelating reagent, 4-(4-phenylmethanethiol)-2,2′:6′,2′′-terpyridine (PMTTP, Fig. 2 inset). Upon binding with heavy metal ions, characteristic new feature(s) will appear. Cd2+ was chosen as the sample analyte. It was found that the binding of Cd2+ will introduce a new peak around 1020 cm−1, which was also reversible by treating with EDTA. By carefully choosing an intact band of PMTTP at 1040 cm−1 as internal reference, the normalized SERS intensity at 1020 cm−1 can be used for the quantification of Cd2+. Most importantly, this quantification could be done through a single point calibration. Cadmium in aqueous solution can be detected semi-quantitatively. The analysis procedure of our SERS optrode for determination of Cd2+ exactly mimics an ion selective electrode, such as pH electrode. Binding constant between PMTTP and Cd2+ was extracted and found to be in agreement with literature.47 We believe this is a very important step in building ion selective SERS optrode for metal ions analysis, which may open up great opportunity for (SERS) optrode sensor development.
The optrode was fabricated following our previous report by layer-by-layer self-assembly of Ag NPs based on APTMS sol–gel on the fiber tip.20,21 Five rounds of Ag NPs depositions were performed before it was cured at 120 °C under N2 atmosphere for 1 h. The synthesis of PMTTP (Fig. 2A inset) can also be found in our previous work.48
Later, the as fabricated optrodes were immersed into 1 mM PMTTP ethanolic solution for 10 min, resulting the formation of PMTTP layer on the optrode. Then, the SERS spectrum of the PMTTP on the optrode was recorded, as shown in Fig. 2A. Next, 5 optrodes were dipped into different solutions for 10 min and the respective spectra were recorded after, as shown in Fig. 2B, where special attention was given to the region between 960 to 1060 cm−1. It is clear that dipping into water does not change the SERS spectrum of PMTTP (Fig. 2B(a) and (b)), as expected, indicating there is probably no structural and/or orientational change. The difference caused by introducing of 4 different metal ions varied. First of all, lead ion seems do not interact with the PMTTP, at least not flagged by SERS. The chelating with Pb2+ added a tiny shoulder around 1016 cm−1 (shown by arrow). Cadmium, on the other hand, brought a more dominant band around 1020 cm−1. The largest change appears to be zinc, where the new band shifted to 1025 cm−1. Note that except Cadmium, which is 0.2 mM in concentration, the other three ions are all at 1 mM. It is also interesting to note that the degree of perturbation of the PMTTP spectrum falls into the inverse order of the atomic numbers. That is, for Pb2+, there is no observable change of the original spectrum of PMTTP. However, for the element with the smallest atomic number tested, Zn2+, it not only introduces a new peak, but also has the largest shift (higher wavenumbers). We suspect that the size of the metal ion plays a role here,49–51 since the valence of all the ions tested are 2+. We further tested 8 more metal ions and the results were listed in Fig. s1.† Though all the ions responded differently on SERS spectra, potential interference might exist when mixing different ions together. However, such kind of spectral interference can be resolved through method such as spectral deconvolution.52
Since the reusability of SERS fiber optic substrate is one of the key factors in optrode development,24 we first examined whether the binding of cadmium ion to PMTTP is reversible. As shown in Fig. 3, the PMTTP modified optrode was firstly immersed in 1 mM cadmium nitrate aqueous solution for 10 min, and then in 0.1 M EDTA solution for 30 min, then back into Cd2+ solution again. It is clear that due to the chelating with Cd2+, a new peak at 1020 cm−1 appears (Fig. 3b). The washing step with 0.1 M EDTA aqueous solution made it back to PMTTP's original SERS spectrum (Fig. 3c). However, even after 5 cycles, with the introducing of Cd2+, the peak at 1020 cm−1 appears again (Fig. 3d).
From Fig. 2B and 3 we show that upon binding of Cd2+, new characteristic peak at 1020 cm−1 will appear. We will further show that quantification of Cd2+ in solution can be realized based on this new feature.
As shown in Fig. 4A, it is clear that the new band at 1020 cm−1 increase with increasing cadmium concentration. However, there is almost no correlation (data not shown) between the absolute intensity and cadmium concentration. This is not surprising. In this type of indirect SERS analysis, usually a ratio of the affected and the intact bands were used, to minimize any environmental variations.53 Thus, we decide to use the band at 1040 cm−1 as the internal reference. In Fig. 4B, the SERS signal ratio I1020/I1040 (y-axis) was plotted against the concentration of cadmium ion solution (x-axis), and a non-linear response was found. To extract the binding constant between PMTTP and Cd2+, we further fitted the data with the well-known Langmuir isotherm model:54
x/y = x + 1/Kads, | (1) |
Fig. 4B demonstrates that there is a correlation between the ratio (I1020/I1040, y) and Cd2+ concentration (x) in the range of 10 μM to 200 μM. Since the binding of PMTTP and Cd2+ gives distinct vibrational spectrum change, it is possible to use the proposed SERS optrode to detect heavy metal ion Cd2+ in solution qualitatively and quantitatively. However, this procedure would still be tedious since a calibration curve needs to be built first. We then turn back and check the counterpart of ion selective SERS optrode. The simplest ion selective electrode is pH electrode. In field, people only carry one or two standard pH solution(s), and calibrate the pH meter right before any measurement. We feel that we could make our ion selective SERS optrode work the same way as a pH electrode. To do that, the Langmuir isotherm would be a better choice as the working calibration curve since it is linear form. For a specific optrode, the constant (1/Kads) in eqn (1) will then have to be amended via single-point calibration before applying to unknown samples.
As a proof of concept, in the following part, we will demonstrate how to apply the optrode to quantify cadmium ion in solution with single point calibration. Firstly, a SERS optrode was immersed into a known Cd2+ standard solution (40 μM in this work) and the SERS spectrum was collected. Thus the relative SERS intensity ratio I1020/I1040 (y) for the known standard was generated using the spectrum collected in this first step. This y value and the concentration x (40 μM in this work) were then substituted into eqn (1), so that a new constant was produced (C, column 2 in Table 1). Then, eqn (1) turned into
x/y = x + C, or x = C/(1/y − 1) | (2) |
Optrode | Constanta (C) | yexp | xcal [M] | R% |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Working equation: x = C/(1/y − 1) (eqn (2)). | ||||
1 | 1.70 × 10−5 | 0.562 | 2.17 × 10−5 | 109% |
2 | 0.621 × 10−5 | 0.694 | 1.41 × 10−5 | 70.5% |
3 | 2.09 × 10−5 | 0.601 | 3.14 × 10−5 | 157% |
4 | 2.17 × 10−5 | 0.572 | 2.90 × 10−5 | 145% |
5 | 1.77 × 10−5 | 0.519 | 1.91 × 10−5 | 95.5% |
6 | 1.46 × 10−5 | 0.487 | 1.39 × 10−5 | 69.5% |
7 | 1.98 × 10−5 | 0.524 | 2.18 × 10−5 | 109% |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra11260a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |