Daisuke Sakamaki‡
a,
Akihiro Ito*a,
Takashi Matsumotob and
Kazuyoshi Tanaka*a
aDepartment of Molecular Engineering, Graduate School of Engineering, Kyoto University, Nishikyo-ku, Kyoto 615-8510, Japan. E-mail: aito@scl.kyoto-u.ac.jp; ktanaka@moleng.kyoto-u.ac.jp
bX-ray Research Laboratory, Rigaku Corporation, Matsubara-cho 3-9-12, Akishima, Tokyo, 196-8666, Japan
First published on 15th August 2014
From a structural point of view, the smallest macrocyclic oligoarylamine bearing the alternant ortho–para-linkage, tetraaza[14]o,p,o,p-cyclophane, can be considered as an intriguing compound: two para-phenylenediamine (para-PD) redox-active units are rigidly fixed in close proximity, being reminiscent of [2.2]para-cyclophane. The electrochemical, spectroelectrochemical and ESR spectroscopic studies revealed that the present overcrowded redox-active macrocycle increased its rigidity with increasing degree of oxidation with the assistance of complementary quantum chemical studies. In the radical cation of the macrocycle, very fast dynamic spin (or charge) transfer between the neutral and oxidized para-PD units via the ortho-phenylene π-bridges was observed in the measured temperature range, while the static spin-delocalization took place within a single para-PD unit.
Thanks to the synthetic availability by the recent progress on palladium-catalyzed aryl amination reactions,6–9 a variety of aza[1n]cyclophanes with different arene-bridged patterns have been reported so far (Chart 1). All kinds of macrocycles with the single substitution pattern, aza[1n]meta-cyclophanes (1),10–22 aza[1n]para-cyclophanes (2),23,24 and aza[1n]ortho-cyclophanes (3)25 were prepared to investigate spin–spin correlation in cyclic multi-spin systems, delocalization of the polaron generated in linear oligoanilines without chain ends, and possibility for new scaffold in supramolecular chemistry, respectively. In addition, tetraza[14]m,p,m,p-cyclophane (4), the smallest macrocyclic oligoarylamine bearing the alternating meta–para-linkage, and the extended congeners are appealing since the rigidity and stability of their toroidal multi-spin systems are indispensable for useful building blocks in magnetic materials.26–33
Chart 1 A family of azacyclophanes: tetraaza[14]meta-cyclophane 1, hexaaza[16]para-cyclophane 2, triaza[13]ortho-cyclophane 3, tetraaza[14]m,p,m,p-cyclophane 4, and tetraaza[14]o,p,o,p-cyclophane 5. |
On the other hand, tetraaza[14]o,p,o,p-cyclophane (5), the smallest macrocyclic oligoarylamine bearing the alternant ortho–para-linkage, is hitherto unknown in the azacyclophane family.34 From the structural points of view, macrocycle 5 can be considered as an intriguing compound: two para-phenylenediamine (para-PD) redox-active units are rigidly fixed in close proximity reminiscent of the arrangement of the benzene rings in the skeleton of [2.2]- or [3.3]para-cyclophanes.35,36 As a consequence of such a rigid molecular geometry, 5 and its oxidized species are expected to exhibit an interesting electronic structure, probably due to steric constraints between para-PD redox-active units clipped together by ortho-phenylene, as compared with meta–para-linked tetraazacyclophane 4, in which the distance between the confronting para-PD faces (∼5 Å) are too long to undergo the interannular interaction.26,28 In this article, we will report on the electronic structure peculiar to its rigid and overcrowded molecular structure of 5.
Variable temperature 1H NMR spectroscopic studies of 5 in [D6]DMSO solution were performed to obtain information about the chair-to-boat conformational change in the temperature range from 298 K to 423 K (ESI Fig. S1†). As the temperature was increased to 383 K, all the signals gradually broadened, and finally, twelve distinct aromatic signals corresponding to both conformers coalesced into broad six ones at 423 K, except for the partial coalescence of the aromatic signals for the N-anisyl groups, indicating that rapid chair-to-boat flipping motion takes place. It should be noted that two kinds of aromatic signals for para-PD units do not merged into one even at 423 K, providing strong evidence for the rigidity of 5. The free energy of activation for the chair-to-boat conformational change was estimated as 22 kcal mol−1,38,39 which is comparable to the inversion barrier for the sumanene molecule as a bowl-shaped fullerene fragment.40 Moreover, decreasing the temperature from 423 K to 298 K showed complete recovery of the original spectrum observed at 298 K (ESI Fig. S1†).
Slow evaporation of a dilute mixed solution (methanol–acetone) of 5 produced purple block crystals suitable for X-ray diffraction. Compound 5 crystallized in the triclinic system with space group P with two independent macrocycles per unit cell, and each molecule of 5 was associated with two disordered acetone molecules. The chair conformer was exclusively found in the crystalline state of 5, whereas the boat conformer was energetically stable as compared with the chair conformer in solution. Two crystallographically independent molecules of 5 adopted structurally very similar chair-shaped conformations with Ci symmetry (Fig. 2; ESI Fig. S2 and Table S2†). Two para-phenylene rings were slightly warped, and cofacially stacked to each other. The interannular distance between these two benzene rings were about 3.2 Å, and such a close proximity can afford the through-space charge and/or energy transfer as is the case of the [2.2]para-cyclophane (2.83–3.09 Å)35 and [3.3]para-cyclophane (3.14–3.31 Å).36 More noteworthy is that two C–N bond lengths in the para-PD unit differ considerably [1.399(3) and 1.445(3) Å for the molecule in Fig. 2 (1.397(3) and 1.436(3) Å for another crystallographically independent molecule)], probably due to the steric constraints induced by the macrocyclic structure of 5. As is shown schematically in Fig. 2(b), two nitrogen pseudo-sp2-planes in 5 were almost coplanar to the para-phenylene π-face (an effective π-conjugation with para-phenylene), while the other two nitrogen pseudo-sp2-planes almost perpendicular to the para-phenylene π-face (weak π-conjugation). This situation inevitably leads to the shorter and longer C–N bond lengths, respectively.
In parallel to the X-ray analysis, the DFT calculations were carried out on a model compound 5′ without methoxy groups in Ci symmetry and the optimized parameters for the two C–N bond lengths in the para-PD unit are summarized in Table S3 in the ESI.†41 At present, all the functional tested by using the 6-31G* basis set42 gave a tendency to underestimate the difference between the two C–N bonds, although the optimized structure for the chair conformer reproduced the structural features of the X-ray structure in all the functionals including M06-2X43 and ωB97X-D,44 which were developed to improve the accuracy for describing non-bonding medium range intramolecular interactions. In addition, the B3PW9145 functional and the local spin density (LDA) functional (SVWN5)46 did not show better performance for 5′, although those functionals provided the best results for specific cyclophane molecules.47,48 As has been frequently pointed out recently, the popular B3LYP49 can lead to a relatively poor description also in the case of compound 5′, in which two benzene rings are stacked within the van der Waals contact (3.4 Å). However, despite these moderate results for all the functionals tested in the present study, at the B3LYP/6-31G* level, the boat conformer with C1 symmetry was calculated to be slightly stable by 0.26 kcal mol−1, as compared to the chair conformer with Ci symmetry, thus indicating a good agreement with the 1H NMR measurement. In addition, as is described later, time-dependent DFT (TD-DFT50) calculations with the B3LYP functional were also satisfactory for assignment of the lowest energy bands observed in absorption spectra for 5˙+ and 52+. Hence, as a result of the present benchmark study, we have employed the B3LYP functional for the theoretical considerations of 5′ and its oxidized species.
The redox behavior of 5 was investigated by both the cyclic and differential pulse voltammetries in CH2Cl2 (0.1 M tetra-n-butylammonium tetrafluoroborate, 100 mV s−1) at 298 K. As shown in Fig. S11 in the ESI,† 5 showed three one-electron redox couples, and the shape of the voltammogram remained unchanged after repeated potential cycling. The large splitting between the first and second oxidation potentials [E1ox = −0.087 V, E2ox = +0.255 V, ΔE ≡ E2ox − E1ox = 342 mV] suggests the stability of generated radical cation of 5 due to the extension of spin distribution over two para-PD units. Furthermore, the ΔE value of 5 is larger than that of tetraaza[14]m,p,m,p-cyclophane 4 [E1ox = −0.01 V, E2ox = +0.22 V, ΔE = 230 mV],30 indicating that the replacement of the meta-phenylene linkers with the ortho-phenylene linkers strengthens the electronic communication between two para-PD units. On the other hand, although 5 has four nitrogen atoms, the redox process corresponding to the removal of the forth electron was not observed in CV of 5, and this is probably because the strong electrostatic repulsion within the overcrowded structure of 5 prohibits the generation of the tetracationic state of 5.
In order to clarify the electronic structure of 5˙+, the absorption spectral change upon electrochemical oxidation was measured by using an optically transparent thin-layer electrochemical cell. Fig. 3(a) shows the spectral changes during the oxidation process from 5 to 5˙+. In this oxidation process, a new absorption band with a asymmetrical band shape appeared at 1.43 eV (λmax = 865 nm) and grew with a slight red shift to 1.38 eV (λmax = 897 nm). During further oxidation to 52+, the absorption band at 1.38 eV kept on growing with a shoulder at ca. 0.6 eV until the intensity reached up to about twice that of the observed band for 5˙+ (Fig. 3(b)). What has to be noticed here is that the lowest energy band of 5˙+ and 52+. To understand the origin of these bands, we carried out time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT)50 calculations (B3LYP/6-31G*) on the model compound of 5˙+ without methoxy groups.
First of all, the geometrical optimizations for two conformers (the boat and chair conformers) of the radical cation (5′˙+) have been performed to estimate the relative energy between them. As a consequence, it was found that each conformer has two local minimum structures with different spin (or positive charge) distributions at the B3LYP/6-31G* level: (i) a structure with localized spin (or positive charge) on a single para-PD unit, which is referred to as spin-localized structure, and (ii) a structure with delocalized spin over two para-PD units, which is referred to as spin-delocalized structure. For the boat conformer, spin-localized and spin-delocalized structures were predicted to be virtually degenerate. However, when we utilize the M06-2X43 and ωB97X-D.44 functionals, it was confirmed that the spin-delocalized structure is converged into a local minimum corresponding to the spin-localized structure. Thus, it can be safely said that the spin-localized structure is the most stable for the boat conformer of 5′˙+. On the contrary, for the chair conformer, the spin-localized structure was calculated to be stable as compared with the spin-delocalized structure by 1.05 kcal mol−1. More importantly, it was predicted that the energy difference between the boat and chair conformers increased going from 5′ (0.26 kcal mol−1) to 5′˙+ (1.4 kcal mol−1). Thus, the contribution of the boat conformer should be more pronounced in comparison to the chair conformer. As shown in Fig. 4(a), in the spin-localized boat conformer, the C–N bond lengths (1.372 and 1.385 Å) in the positively charged para-PD unit were significantly shortened as compared to those (1.428 and 1.431 Å) in the opposite para-PD unit, and hence, it is inferred that the positively charged para-PD unit adopts a slightly bent semi-quinoid structure.
As is listed in Table 1, it was found that the TD-DFT-calculated results based on the spin-localized structure of 5′˙+ qualitatively elucidated the lowest energy band observed for 5˙+. In addition, the reasonable transition energy was not obtained from the TD-DFT calculations on the spin-delocalized structure. On the basis of the computed Kohn–Sham orbital diagram shown in Fig. 5, the observed lowest-energy band for 5′˙+ is assignable to the statically delocalized Robin and Day's class III intervalence transition (or charge-resonance band)51,52 whithin a single para-PD unit (β((HO-2)MO) to β(LUMO)). The charge (or spin) transfer band between the adjacent neutral and oxidized para-PD units via two ortho-phenylene linkers is predicted to be virtually forbidden transition (β(HOMO) to β(LUMO): hν = 0.21 eV; f = 0.0001).
Species | hν (obs) (eV) | Calcd hν (eV) (f) | Assignment |
---|---|---|---|
5˙+ | 1.43 (865 nm) | — | |
5′˙+ | |||
Spin-localized chair | 1.60 (0.289) | β-(HO-2)MO → β-LUMO | |
Spin-delocalized chair | 1.05 (0.296) | β-(HO-1)MO → β-LUMO | |
Spin-localized boat | 1.56 (0.312) | β-(HO-2)MO → β-LUMO | |
Spin-delocalized boat | 1.25 (0.302) | β-(HO-1)MO → β-LUMO | |
52+ | ∼0.6 (sh), 1.38 (897 nm) | — | |
5′2+ | |||
Chair | 0.85 (0.086) | β-HOMO → β-LUMO | |
1.54 (0.560) | β-(HO-1)MO → β-LUMO | ||
Boat | 0.61 (0.074) | β-HOMO → β-LUMO | |
1.58 (0.632) | β-(HO-1)MO → β-LUMO |
In contrast to the DFT-optimized asymmetrical spin-localized structure for 5′˙+, all the para-PD moieties were predicted to have a semi-quinoid structure in the B3LYP/6-31G* optimizations for two conformers of the dication (5′2+), closely relating to the fact that both para-PD units are equally charged by two-electron oxidation of 5′. In fact, we could not found any local minimum structures with charge localization for both of the two conformers for 5′2+. More noteworthy is that the energy difference between the boat and chair conformers further increased going from 5′˙+ (1.4 kcal mol−1) to 5′2+ (4.8 kcal mol−1). This strongly suggests that we can virtually ignore the contribution of the chair conformer in the absorption spectrum observed for 52+. As is apparent in Fig. 4(b), both of the two para-PD units in the boat conformer of 5′2+ adopt a same semi-quinoid structure.
Table 1 shows that the lowest energy band observed for 52+ is again qualitatively explainable by the TD-DFT-calculated transition energy based on the most stable structure with boat conformation of 5′2+: the observed band can be regarded as an overlap of two transitions, and the value of oscillator strength for the major transition is doubled, as compared to 5′˙+. On the basis of the computed Kohn–Sham orbital diagram shown in Fig. 6, the observed lowest energy band for 52+ is again assignable to the statically delocalized Robin and Day's class III intervalence transition (or charge-resonance band)51,52 within each para-PD unit (from β(HOMO) to β(LUMO) and from β((HO-2)MO) to β(LUMO)).
To gain a direct information on the spin distribution in the MV state of 5˙+, we recorded the ESR spectrum of 5˙+ generated by chemical oxidation with 0.5 equiv. of tris(4-bromophenyl)aminium hexachloroantimonate (Magic Blue) in CH2Cl2. As shown in Fig. 7, a nine line spectrum was observed at 293 K. This spectrum of 5˙+ was well simulated by the following hyperfine coupling constants: |aN| = 0.300 mT (4N) and the contribution from unresolved 24 hydrogen nuclei belonging to two para-phenylene moieties in the macrocycle (8H) and the benzene rings of four substituted anisyl groups (16H), which were incorporated in the linewidth of the spectral simulation (0.045 mT). Thus, the observed ESR spectrum of 5˙+ proved that the unpaired electron was dynamically delocalized over the entire macrocyclic molecular backbone on the ESR time scale. In addition, the ESR spectral shape for 5˙+ remained unchanged in the measured temperature range from 293 K to 213 K (ESI Fig. S12†). More noteworthy is that the equivalent spin distribution over the four nitrogen nuclei in 5˙+ demonstrates that a spin (charge) transfer between the semiquinoidal para-PD radical cation unit and the neutral para-PD unit takes place very rapidly (the transfer rate is estimated to be equal to or larger than 1010 s−1) in the measured temperature range (Chart 3). Unfortunately, the ESR spectrum reported for 4˙+ was too unresolved to extract the information on spin distribution.28
Fig. 7 (a) Observed X-band ESR spectrum of 5˙+ recorded in CH2Cl2 at 298 K. (b) Simulated ESR spectrum of 5˙+. |
When 5 was treated with 2 equiv. of the Magic Blue, the ESR signal almost disappeared, thus indicating the generated dication 52+ is diamagnetic. This result contrasts with the spin triplet state of 42+. However, the diamagnetic electronic structure of 52+ is predictable from the viewpoints of (i) the McConnell-I model,53,54 where allocation of opposite spin densities between contiguous atoms belonging to each π-face of para-PD units results in antiferromagnetic interaction in an eclipsed fashion as shown in Fig. 4(b) and (ii) the topological spin-alignment model,53,34 represented by Mataga and others, where ortho-phenylene can be considered as an anti-ferromagnetic coupling unit.
The influence of the closely π-stacked benzene rings on the electronic properties of 5 can be evaluated also by fluorescence spectroscopy. Although the fluorescence quantum yield was quite low, the fluorescence spectrum of 5 was measured in solution. For comparison, the fluorescence spectra of tetraaza[14]m,p,m,p-cyclophane 4 and N,N,N′,N'-tetraanisyl-para-phenylenediamine (TAPD) were recorded as the reference compounds of 5. The observed absorption and fluorescence spectra of 4, 5, and TAPD in THF are summarized in Fig. 8. Compounds 4, 5, and TAPD have similar absorption maxima around 310 nm (4: λabs = 312 nm (3.97 eV), 5: λabs = 315 nm (3.94 eV), and TAPD: λabs = 310 nm (4.00 eV)). Photoexcitation at 310 nm (4.00 eV) of these compounds gave weak emissions (4: λem = 412 nm (3.01 eV), ϕ = 0.029, 5: λem = 442 nm (2.81 eV), ϕ = 0.035, and TAPD: λem = 416 nm (2.98 eV), ϕ = 0.032). Although 4 and TAPD showed similar emission maxima, the emission maximum of 5 was red-shifted by 30 nm (200 meV) and 26 nm (170 meV) relative to those of 4 and TAPD, respectively. These results suggest the presence of excimer-like state in 5, which was reported in the case of oligo(phenylene ethynylene) dimers which are π-stacked by a [2.2]para-cyclophane linker.55
Fig. 8 Absorption and fluorescence spectra of 4 (dotted line), 5 (solid line) and TAPD (broken line) in THF at 298 K. |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details on synthesis, characterizations, theoretical calculations. CCDC 956891. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c4ra06065b |
‡ Current address: Department of Applied Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering, Osaka University, Suita 565-0871, Japan. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |