Amit Shardab,
Rajesh Kumara,
Saimaac,
Nidhi Sharmaa and
Arun K. Sinha*abc
aNPP Division, CSIR-Institute of Himalayan Bioresource Technology, Palampur-176061, HP, India
bAcademy of Scientific and Innovative Research (AcSIR), New Delhi, India
cMedicinal and Process Chemistry Division, CSIR-Central Drug Research Institute (Council of Scientific and Industrial Research), Lucknow-226031, UP, India. E-mail: aksinha08@rediffmail.com; Fax: +91-522-2771941
First published on 4th July 2014
A green methodology utilizing a natural supplement such as L-arginine in conjunction with water and oxygen led to oxidative coupling of thiols into disulfides (S–S bond) whereas thiol–yne coupling to access vinyl sulfides (C–S bond) was facilitated in a nitrogen atmosphere. The tunable protocol offers several advantages such as low catalyst loading, high yields, clean reaction, no over-oxidation of the S–S bond besides being metal/base/waste-free. The synthesis of ubiquitous cystine and glutathione disulfide in the same catalytic system is an added advantage and the catalytic system has been recycled up to seven times.
Besides water, L-amino acids also dominate the natural world2 and display a central theme in biological systems.3 Recently, they have been efficiently employed as organocatalysts in triggering a variety of chemical reactions4 such as the synthesis5 of Pfizer's anti-glaucoma drug: latanoprost5a and the anticancer drug carboplatin.5b Interestingly, under physiological conditions, sulfur containing amino acids such as cysteine and glutathione, undergoes oxidative coupling to form the ubiquitous cystine and glutathione disulfide (GSSG) having disulfide (S–S) bonds which are of great practical value.6 Likewise, an alicyclic disulfide known as lipoic acid6a also acts as an essential cofactor of mitochondrial enzymatic complexes which highlights the importance of the S–S bond. Some of the medicinally significant examples of disulfide bond6b,c are shown in Fig. 1.
The disulfide bond is widely found in flora and fauna.7 It also plays a substantial role in the design of rechargeable lithium batteries, in a number of chemical reactions8 and catalysis.9 Furthermore, many of the next generation10 pharmaceuticals incorporating disulfide bonds have already hit the market. In this context, a large number of oxidative coupling protocols11–13 mediated by gold nanoparticles11a or rhenium13b metal as an effective catalyst have emerged for the synthesis of disulfides. However, most of the approaches suffer from disadvantages such as low selectivity because of over oxidation13a of the final product into sulfoxides/sulfones, the expensive nature of the catalyst with poor recovery and finally laborious work-up procedures. Recently, environmentally benign approaches to synthesizing heterocyclic disulfides13g have also emerged, which use a cocktail of enzymes, buffer and methanol. As well as these supported iron oxide nanoparticles13h have also been used to synthesize disulfides but these methods do not truly fall into the category of green reactions because of the use of organic solvent and the expensive nature of reagents. So there is a strong need to develop such a catalytic system for the chemoselective oxidation of thiols to disulfides, which has all the properties required, that is, a green catalyst, solvent, and reagent besides recyclability of the catalytic system and waste-free, green approach in comparison to relentless conventional protocols13b–f (which utilize metal oxidant/base/organic solvent).
Apart from making disulfide (S–S) bond, thiols are also known to participate in hydrothiolation14 with alkynes via thiol–yne coupling (TYC) click reactions14a to generate vinyl sulfide (C–S bond) which has many miscellaneous medicinal and physicochemical applications.14b Some of the medicinally significant examples of vinyl sulfides14c are shown in Fig. 2.
In this paper, we disclose for the first time, a waste free and atom economical protocol for the direct oxidative coupling of thiols to disulfides utilizing quasi natural compounds14d (amino acid–water–air) but precluding any oxidant, base or metal. Among the various amino acids tested, arginine (Arg) provided chemoselective access to disulfides including ubiquitous cystine and GSSG with an ample yield and with recyclability of the catalytic system for up to seven cycles. Additionally, the zwitterionic character of Arg also worked as a driving force towards rapid hydrothiolation of alkynes, i.e., TYC, thus leading to an environmentally benign synthesis of vinyl sulfides (C–S bond). Interestingly, our tunable catalytic system also clearly demonstrated that C–S bond formation is faster than S–S bond formation in a nitrogen atmosphere (Fig. 3).
Initially, 4-chlorothiophenol (0.25 mmol), water (0.6 mL) and L-histidine (50 mol%) were placed in a round-bottomed flask and stirred at room temperature for 12 h. The desired 4,4′-dichlorodiphenyl disulfide (1b) was formed with a yield of 64% [measured with gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy (GC-MS)]. It is worth noting that our green oxidative coupling process comprising histidine–water–air might be confirming a biochemical process where an intracellular16b disulfide bond forms in presence of amino acids such as cysteine. However, the amino acid, L-proline (Table 1, entry 2) gave a poor yield (37%) of 1b. Thereafter, a series of neutral, acidic and basic amino acids were screened (Table 1), out of which Arg, a basic amino acid with a pKa of 2.488 gave a good yield of 1b (70%, 12 h) in air (Table 1, entry 10) whereas a reaction using an O2 balloon provided 1b in same yield in the shorter reaction time of 5 h (Table 1, entry 15).
| Entry | Amino acid | Yieldb (%) | Entry | Amino acid | Yieldb (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a The reaction conditions involved usage of 0.25 mmol of 1a, atmospheric O2, 50 mol% of L-amino acid, 0.6 mL of high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) grade water.b Yields determined using GC-MS.c In an O2 atmosphere the reaction was completed in 5 h.d N2 atmosphere.e Ethanol was used as solvent.f Chloroform was used as solvent.g No Arg used. | |||||
| 1 | Histidine | 64 | 11 | Glycine | 42 |
| 2 | Proline | 37 | 12 | Aspartic acid | 15 |
| 3 | Serine | 33 | 13 | Glutamic acid | 14 |
| 4 | Phenylalanine | 23 | 14 | Cysteine | Traces |
| 5 | Glutamine | 33 | 15 | Argininec | 70 |
| 6 | Valine | 61 | 16 | Arginined | Traces |
| 7 | Leucine | 60 | 17 | Argininee | Nd |
| 8 | Alanine | 25 | 18 | Argininef | Nd |
| 9 | Isoleucine | 42 | 19g | — | Nd |
| 10 | Arginine | 70 | |||
As expected, 1b was obtained in traces in a nitrogen atmosphere (Table 1, entry 16) whereas when the water was replaced with ethanol or chloroform 1b was not formed (entry 17–18). This is possibly because of the lack of formation of hydrogen bonding and inefficient generation of a zwitterion in organic solvents. With this information, the amount of Arg used and the effect of temperature for the synthesis of 1b was optimized (Table 2).
Thus, a decreased catalyst load of 20 mol% in the presence of O2 was found to be the most efficient for promoting the synthesis of 1b in 15 min at 50 °C (Table 2, entry 6). A further impact of the contemporary tools namely, a microwave and an ultrasonicator was evaluated (see ESI†). Unfortunately, the reaction conducted in a microwave12g (50 °C, 80 W) had no profound effect on the efficiency of the synthesis of 1b in a shorter reaction time (up to 45 min) as it led to several side products. Interestingly, the reaction conducted in the ultrasonicator12f provided the desired yield of 1b (98%) in 10 min (see ESI†). However, because of the malodorous smell17 of thiols, the oxidative coupling was conducted under conventional conditions in a well ventilated hood.
Finally, optimized conditions using 20 mol% of Arg in 0.6 mL of water, 0.25 mmol of 1a and 1/2O2 resulted in a yield of 96% 1b (isolated) at 50 °C in 15 min (Table 3, 1b). The scope for using the substrate was explored using electronically versatile thiols which provided diverse types of disulfides (Table 3, 1b–11b) in moderate to excellent yields (up to 96%) and their nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) results agreed well with those reported in previous experiments.11,15d After the synthesis of aromatic and alicyclic disulfides (Table 3, 1b–11b) the synthesis of a heterocyclic disulfide (12b–15b) was inspired by a previous paper by Abdel-Mohsen et al.13g which utilizes laccases/buffer/methanol for oxidative coupling of thiophenols into a series of heterocyclic disulfides. The heterocyclic compounds have numerous added benefits over carbocyclic ones. The catalytic system provided heterocyclic disulfides in up to 70% yield. Unfortunately, 16b or 17b (Table 3) could not be obtained which was possibly because of the feeble zwitterionic interaction of Arg with thiol as well as electron rich hydroxy or amine groups. Thereafter, we decided to work towards establishing the mechanism for the synthesis of disulfides using the Arg–O2–H2O catalytic system.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 The probable mechanism of the formation of diphenyl disulfide via oxidative coupling of thiophenol. | ||
Subsequently, in the aqueous charged19b pool, hydrogen atoms of one molecule of thiophenol start interacting with the negatively charged carboxyl terminal of the arginine whereas the sulfur atom of another molecule of thiophenol interacts with the positively charged guanidinium group. This complex interplay of subtle non-covalent interactions led to the efficient union of two molecules of 4-chlorothiophenol and was studied using a UV spectrophotometer (Fig. 6). The study revealed that the λmax of 4-chlorothiophenol (1a) and Arg appeared at 246.5 nm and 207.5 nm, respectively. However, when the substrates were stirred, the spectral analysis clearly indicated that 1a and an aqueous solution of zwitterionic Arg led to the immediate initiation of complexation which was evident from the bathochromic shift from λmax 246.5 nm to 274.6 nm. It was observed that complexation between the iminium ion of arginine and the heteroatom (S) of thiophenol exponentially increased up to 9 min leading to a chromic shift which is probably indicative of an increase in the concentration of complex “C” (Fig. 5). Diminution in the absorbance (hypochromic shift) of C appeared after 12 min with the initiation of formation of 1b which was finally completed in 110 min at room temperature (see ESI† for details).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Absorption profiles of thiophenol, Arg, complexation and 4,4′-diphenyl disulfide at 0 min and at the completion of the reaction (after 110 min). | ||
Recyclability of the catalytic system is an important factor in the context of green chemistry as it has both economical as well as ecological benefits. In this experiment, 0.25 mmol of 1a, 20 mol% of Arg, O2 and 0.6 mL of water were heated at 50 °C, and the resulting product 1b was formed in 20 min. The aqueous solution containing Arg and 1b was extracted using ethyl acetate. The ethyl acetate layer was vacuum evaporated to obtain 1b, whereas the same aqueous solution containing Arg was used repeatedly for carrying out the oxidative coupling for a number of times. The product could be easily recovered from the aqueous medium merely by extracting with ethyl acetate. The remaining aqueous solution of Arg was reused for up to seven consecutive cycles (98–91%) (Fig. 7). Thereafter, there was a considerable decrease in the yield of disulfide. Interestingly, the addition of 5 mol% of Arg in the previously described catalytic cycle further increased the yield of 1b up to 96% (for up to ten cycles) because of the rejuvenation of the organocatalytic system.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 Recyclability studies using the same catalytic water–Arg–oxygen system for up to seven cycles. | ||
It is well known that GSSG with cisplatin is a well-tolerated therapeutic adjuvant called NOV-002 in standard anticancer therapy.20a Likewise cystine is also a physiological disulfide of clinical importance. Recent biocatalytic protocol highlights disulfides catalyzed by laccases13g but does not disclose the principles of the synthesis of physiological disulfides, i.e., cystine and GSSG. Thus, because of their medicinal significance and to test the rigor of our protocol, we attempted to synthesize physiological disulfides, i.e., cystine and GSSG under similar conditions documented in Table 3. It is prudent to state that oxidations of cysteine and related compounds have been extensively studied, utilizing metal phthalocyanines20b and expensive noble metals,13a however, their synthesis utilizing perfectly benign conditions sill remains a significant challenge.21 Interestingly, the organocatalytic system of “Arg–water–oxygen” that was developed successfully led to the formation of dimers (18b and 19b) of aminothiols namely, L-cysteine and L-glutathione in appreciable yields of 71% and 76%, respectively, at 50 °C for longer reaction times of 4 h (Fig. 8).
Like S–S bonds, C–S22 bonds are another critical22a–f and ubiquitous22g constituent of many pharmaceuticals22h,i and natural products,22j e.g., allicin, the antihelminthic drug – levamisole, and antibiotics such as penicillins and so on. To construct the C–S bonds, popular ‘click’-procedures such as TYC or hydrothiolation have become an outstanding tool for the functionalization23 of molecules. The TYC unarguably yields useful synthetic intermediates which have applications in organic24a transformations including Diels–Alder, thio-Claisen, acting as Michael acceptors and as versatile synthons in olefin metathesis. Certain reports reveal the synthesis of vinyl sulfides using a strong base24b and ammonia.24c
There are also numerous reported methods25 for the hydrothiolation of terminal alkynes to form vinyl sulfides using various transition metals such as Wilkinson's catalyst, lanthanides, late transition metal catalysts and various free radical initiators (Fig. 9). However, a method employing a mild, environmentally compatible, efficient25c and in particular, selective route towards the synthesis of the C–S bond has yet to be found. Therefore, in the light of its expected use,26 hydrothiolation between alkyne and thiophenol in Arg–water to generate vinyl sulfides was carried out in a nitrogen atmosphere (replacing the oxygen atmosphere to prevent the formation of the S–S bond). However, GC analysis of the crude product confirmed the formation of vinyl sulfide (20b) at a yield of 20% along with the unwanted S–S bond (30–35%) and unreacted thiol. Interestingly, the sequence of addition of reactants was found to be crucial, thus, addition of thiophenol to a well stirred mixture of phenylacetylene and water–Arg in a N2 atmosphere efficiently provided vinyl sulfide (C–S bond) (20b; Table 4) in 45 min with a yield of 81% as an E
:
Z isomeric mixture.23e
| S. no. | Thiol | Alkyne | Alkenyl sulfide (Z/E) | Yieldb |
|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions involved use of 50 mg of thiol, alkyne (1.1 equiv.), N2, 20 mol% of L-Arg, 0.6 mL of HPLC grade water.b Yields of isolated product.c E : Z ratio obtained using NMR. (see ESI† for details). |
||||
| 1 | R1 = 4-OCH3 | ![]() |
![]() |
81 |
| 2 | R1 = H | ![]() |
![]() |
71 |
| 3 | R1 = H | ![]() |
![]() |
75 |
| 4 | R1 = OCH3 | ![]() |
![]() |
85 |
| 5 | R1 = 4-CH3 | ![]() |
![]() |
80 |
The catalytic system has been successfully extended for anti-Markovnikov products (21b–24b)23e with variable appendages attached to the aromatic ring of thiophenol and alkyne in varying yields up to 85%. The catalytic system also led to the synthesis of 1-phenyl-3-p-tolylsulfanyl-propenone (24b) a unique and significant26c scaffold with α,β-unsaturated carbonyl moiety (O
C–C
C–S)26e,f which might be useful for applications in biomedicine, materials chemistry and bioconjugation chemistry.26g The probable mechanism for the formation of E/Z vinyl sulfides is presented in Fig. 10. Here it is presumed that zwitterionic Arg in water interacts with the thiophenol by the carboxylate terminal and the negatively charged sulfur atom interacts with the terminal alkyne resulting in the formation of vinyl sulfide. The exact mechanism of the formation of E/Z vinyl sulfides is currently under investigation.
:
Z isomeric mixture) having α,β-unsaturated carbonyl moiety (O
C–C
C–S) emphatically demonstrates the synthetic viability of the catalytic system. Therefore, because the quest for such a novel type of tunable catalytic system is high, the method could be used for applications in the construction of aromatic (hetero)/alicyclic/aliphatic disulfides as well as vinyl sulfides by concurrently maintaining the criteria of catalysis, greenness, recyclability and selectivity.
:
9.5) as eluent to give the corresponding disulfide. The results of the analysis of the disulfide (1b) obtained using 1H-NMR and 13C-NMR agreed well with the reported values.
:
9) as eluent to give the corresponding vinyl sulfide (E
:
Z isomeric mixture).
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Detailed UV-based mechanistic studies and NMR spectral values of compounds are provided. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra02909g |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |