Conglin Dongab,
Chengqing Yuan*ab,
Xiuqin Baiab,
Xinping Yanab and
Zhongxiao Pengc
aSchool of Energy and Power Engineering, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan 430063, P.R. China. E-mail: ycq@whut.edu.cn; Fax: +86-27-86549879; Tel: +86-27-86554969
bKey Laboratory of Marine Power Engineering & Technology (Ministry of Transport), Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan 430063, P.R. China. E-mail: ycq@whut.edu.cn; Fax: +86-27-86549879; Tel: +86-27-86554969
cSchool of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, The University of New South Wales, Sydney 2052, Australia. E-mail: z.peng@unsw.edu.au
First published on 7th April 2014
Nitrile Butadiene Rubber (NBR) is widely used to make water-lubricated rubber stern tube bearings in the marine field. Its tribological properties, which significantly influence its reliable life, directly affect the safe navigation, covert performance and operating costs of a ship. This study aimed to investigate the tribological properties and wear model of NBR under water-lubricated conditions. A CBZ-1 tribo-tester was used to conduct sliding wear tests between NBR pins and 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel discs under water-lubricated conditions. The surface morphologies of the worn NBR pins were examined using laser-interference profilometry and scanning electron microscopy. In addition, the friction coefficients, ageing times and wear rates were analysed and compared to study the tribological properties of NBR and to identify the factors that affect its wear mass loss. The results demonstrated that different ageing times, velocities and loads had a significant effect on the friction and wear properties of the NBR specimens. The ageing times positively correlated with the friction coefficients and the wear mass losses between the rubbing pairs. The anti-tear properties of NBR deteriorated when the material was aged at a high temperature for an extended period of time, which reduced its wear-resistance. The main wear mechanism between the rubbing pairs was severe adhesion tearing wear under the water-lubricated conditions. A comprehensive empirical model for its wear rate estimation was established based on the wear and friction power. The model revealed the relationships between wear and velocity, as well as load and shore hardness. The result produced by the model was largely consistent with the experimental results. The knowledge gained in this study is anticipated to provide the theoretical data for a wear theory study of NBR and be useful for the optimisation of water-lubricated rubber stern tube bearings.
However, the work environment of water-lubricated rubber stern tube bearings is extremely harsh, and their operation time is often very long. Thus, regular maintenance is normally required. Moreover, water is a poor lubricant for the bearings, which results in significant wear of the NBR stern tube bearings. The excessive wear of the NBR stern tube bearings reportedly is one of the most important reasons for the loss of their workability.4 Recently, the excessive wear of these bearings resulted in the unscheduled lay off repair and maintenance of Coast Guard ships.5 Significant manpower and money is often spent on repairing and replacing worn parts. The excessive wear problem of NBR stern tube bearings has become increasingly prominent in recent years as the global competition and demand for production outputs and economic returns have increased.6
The tribological properties of NBR have not been well studied. Its basic mechanisms remain unexplored, though some relevant experimental observations have been presented. Based on the results of experimental studies by Champ and Southern, the physical process of rubber abrasion might be considered to be a crack-growth process.7,8 The wear rate is a direct measure of a material wear property. If the wear trend of NBR is obtained using its wear rate, its remaining lifetime can then be predicted to ensure the safe navigation and reduce the operational costs of ships. Litwin and Mody noticed that the wear rate of composites is greater than the expected rate and that the relationship is nonlinear when the applied load is high.9,10 The wear rate is also influenced by other factors, such as the hardness of the rubber and sliding speeds, etc. Zhang established an empirical wear loss formula based on the experimental results.11 However, the equation formula only considered a single factor.
In reality, the wear of rubber is simultaneously affected by a number of factors, and their effects are not easy to evaluate separately. Therefore, the objective of this work was to study the tribological properties of NBR and find the factors that affect its wear mass loss. An improved empirical model to estimate its wear mass loss rate was to be established. To achieve this objective, NBR specimens were tested against 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel discs using a pin on a disc tribo-tester under water-lubricated conditions. The experimental apparatus and wear test details are explained in Section 2. The results and discussions are presented in Section 3 followed by the wear mass loss rate model and conclusions in Sections 4 and 5, respectively. The ultimate goal was to improve the wear-resistance property of NBR and extend its service life in marine applications.
Tensile strength (MPa) | Elongation at break (%) | Tensile set at break (%) | Volume change rate | Shore hardness (A) | Poisson ratio | Young's modulus E (MPa) | Initial temperature of thermal decomposition (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
18–21 | 396 | ≤30 | <5 | 63 | 0.49 | 5.83 | 233 |
The NBR pin samples were aged using a vacuum oven thermostat (SLH, China) to achieve different accelerated ageing conditions. The ageing temperature in the vacuum environment was set to 80 °C to reduce the effect of temperature on the results.12 The temperature fluctuating range was less than 1 °C (±0.5 °C). A total of 60 pin samples were placed in the oven. Two specimens were removed every second day to measure their shore hardness; these samples were not placed back in the vacuum oven. The longest ageing time was 960 h (i.e. 40 days). The shore hardness is one of the most important parameters to characterise the mechanical properties of NBR. High ageing temperatures markedly affect this parameter.13 This study selected the shore hardness of the NBR as the characteristic parameter. The behaviour of the shore hardness of the NBR pins for different accelerated ageing times is shown in Fig. 2. The shore hardness of NBR pins clearly positively correlated with the accelerated ageing times.
The surface morphologies of the tested NBR pins were examined using a laser-interference profilometer and a scanning electron microscope (SU-70, Japan).
The NBR pins that were aged for various accelerated ageing times were used to study the effects of ageing on the tribological properties of NBR. The different accelerated ageing times were 0, 120, 240, 360 and 480 h. The test nominal pressure was 0.5 MPa, and the rotational velocities of the tester were set to 0.11, 0.33, 0.55, 0.77, 1.1 and 2.2 m s−1. A total of 30 different sliding wear tests were conducted using NBR pins with 5 different ageing times and the six speeds.
The duration of each test was 60 min. All sliding tests were repeated twice at the same condition to verify the repeatability of the results. The friction coefficients were measured every five seconds during the wear tests.
The un-aged NBR samples were used to examine velocity effects on the wear mass losses of NBR. The nominal pressure was set to a fixed value of 0.5 MPa. The velocities used were 0.11, 0.33, 0.55, 0.77, 1.1 and 2.2 m s−1. A total of 6 different sliding wear tests were conducted using the 6 velocities and the one loading condition.
The NBR pins that were aged for various accelerated ageing times were used to study the effects of ageing durations on the wear mass losses of NBR. The velocity and nominal pressure were set to fixed values, 0.77 m s−1 and 0.5 MPa, respectively. 5 different sliding wear tests were conducted on NBR pins with 5 different ageing times at the fixed loading and velocity conditions.
The duration of each test was 48 h to ensure the stability of the wear mass loss. The wear mass losses of the NBR pins were determined by measuring the weights before and after the tests. The tested specimens before weighing were ultrasonically cleaned in water and dried for 48 h in an oven at 50 °C. The weight measurements were repeated four times for each specimen to ensure reproducible results using an analytical balance (MS205DU, Switzerland). The average friction power was the average friction work measured every hour after 48 h sliding wear tests. It is obtained as follows:
F = SP | (1) |
= F = SP | (2) |
L = vt | (3) |
(4) |
Fig. 4 (a) The velocity characteristic curves of the NBR pins without ageing; (b) the load characteristic curves of the NBR pins without ageing. |
Fig. 4(b) clearly shows that the average friction coefficients changed marginally as the nominal pressures increased at the same velocity conditions. This finding may indicate that the loads had little effect on the friction coefficients between the rubbing pairs at the same condition.
The average friction coefficients for the NBR pins aged for various accelerated ageing times and 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel disc rubbing pairs are presented in Fig. 5. The results showed that the accelerated ageing times affected the tribological properties of the NBR pins. In general, the average friction coefficients positively correlated with the accelerated ageing times for the same sliding velocity and nominal pressure conditions.
The sensitivity of the rubber material to temperatures was taken into consideration to explain the trend observed in Fig. 5 for the average friction coefficients as a function of the accelerated ageing times. A high temperature significantly affects the rate of the chemical reactions of the material. This phenomenon will markedly change the cross-linked structure of the material. The mechanical properties of the material likely degrade in response to accelerated ageing at a high temperature for a long time. The shore hardness of the NBR was measured to study the ageing time effects. Fig. 2 and 5 show the behaviour of the shore hardness of NBR pins for different accelerated ageing times. The shore hardness positively correlated with the accelerated ageing times. Notably, the behaviours of the average friction coefficients between rubbing pairs were similar to those of the shore hardness as the in the accelerated ageing times increased. These trends are consistent with Roy's results.17
The changes in the wear mass loss rates and average friction powers of the un-aged NBR at nominal pressures are shown in Fig. 6(a). The average wear mass loss rates of NBR positively correlated with the nominal pressure. The average friction powers linearly increased as the pressure increased. The pressure clearly positively correlated with the friction powers between the rubbing pairs. As a result, the NBR was more easily worn out in the sliding wear process.
As shown in Fig. 6(b), the average wear mass loss rates of the un-aged NBR positively correlated with the sliding velocities for the same nominal pressure tested conditions. The average friction powers showed mostly linear increases.
The behaviours of the wear mass loss rates and friction powers of the NBR pins aged for various accelerated ageing times are shown in Fig. 7. The wear mass loss rates of the aged NBR pins clearly positively correlated with the ageing times for the same nominal pressure and velocity conditions. When the ageing time exceeded 720 h, the slope of the curve decreased, which indicated that the wear rates slowed. However, the average friction powers linearly increased. As presented in Section 3.1, this behaviour may arise because the ageing processes promoted the degradation of the anti-fatigue and anti-tear properties of the NBR, resulting in a higher wear rate than that of the pin specimens not subjected to the ageing processes at the same nominal pressure and velocity conditions.18 This notion can be indirectly proven by the shore hardness values of NBR pins for different accelerate ageing times. The shore hardness of NBR pins positively correlated with the accelerated ageing times, as shown in Fig. 2 and 7.
Fig. 7 The behaviour of the wear mass loss rates and friction powers of the NBR pins for different accelerated ageing times. |
Fig. 6 and 7 show that both the wear mass loss rates and the friction powers increased with the pressure, velocity and ageing time. These two rates were hypothesised to be related. This paper will attempt to reveal this relationship in Section 4.
Fig. 8 The untested (a) and worn surface topographies before test; (b) of the tested NBR pins after test. |
To study the wear characteristics and mechanisms, the worn surface topographies of the NBR pins were examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). As shown in Fig. 9(a), a curly NBR asperity was evident on the worn surface. A tearing phenomenon was apparent at the contact position between the NBR asperity and the worn surface. Fig. 9(b) shows that part of the material was peeled off from the worn surface to form a wear particle.
Fig. 9 The SEM images of the tested NBR pins. (a) A curly NBR asperity on the worn surface; (b) a wear particle on the worn surface. |
The above analyses indicate that the friction and wear characteristics between the NBR pins and 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel disc rubbing pairs are very particular. The NBR asperities on the surface were stretched or deformed along the sliding direction of the upper disc. When the anti-fatigue and anti-tear properties of NBR pins are not sufficient to resist the combined actions of the adhesion and tensile stress, cracks form on the severely stretched NBR surfaces in the direction perpendicular to the stretching direction. At the beginning, the expansion of the cracks will not cause the deformed NBR asperities to peel off. Instead, this expansion often causes the NBR asperities on the worn surface of the NBR pins to be gradually torn along the sliding direction of the upper disc. The deformed NBR asperities will be further stretched into a long and curved feature, as shown in Fig. 10. The curly NBR asperities are in a stressed state. When the anti-tear property is insufficient to resist the combined actions of the adhesion and tensile stress, part of the curly NBR asperities will be peeled off from the surface and wear particles will be generated. Therefore, the main wear mechanism between the NBR pins and 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel discs rubbing pairs is severe adhesion tearing wear under the water-lubricated condition.
Ef = Et + Ee | (5) |
Eqn (5) provides two inferences: the number of the rubber wear particles positively correlates with the friction work at the same condition. Furthermore, less energy is required to make the rubber asperity into the wear particle if the mechanical properties of rubber degrade due to other influences, such as accelerated ageing; thus, the number of the wear particles will increase per unit friction work.
However, the theoretical relationship between the wear mass loss rates and the friction powers is not easily determined. Zhang and Liang experimentally determined that the friction work significantly affects the wear mass loss rates for rubber materials.22–24
The results and phenomena mentioned above suggest that the wear mass loss rates of NBR are in accordance with a power function for the increase in the friction powers, and the wear mass loss rate, A, can be estimated from the following equation:
A = kWn | (6) |
Based on eqn (4) and (6), A is described by the following equation:
A = knSnPnvn | (7) |
The friction coefficient between the rubbing pairs is apparently very important to the wear mass loss rates of NBR. In general, the friction coefficients are determined during the tests. Based on the experimental results mentions above and previous studies, the friction coefficient between the rubber and smooth metal surface under the water-lubricated conditions is related to the velocity, load and the ageing degree of the rubber.25,26 Eqn (8) describes the hypothesised approximate relationship between these parameters:
= avbHcFd = avbHcSdPd | (8) |
A = kanvnbHncSndPndSnPnvn = kanSnd+nHncPnd+nvnb+n | (9) |
A = qHαPβvγ | (10) |
Nominal pressures (MPa) | 0.1 | 0.3 | 0.5 | 0.7 | 0.9 | 1.1 |
Wear mass loss rates (mg h−1) | 0.185 | 0.509 | 0.71 | 0.958 | 1.054 | 1.239 |
Because Hα and vγ were constant, qHαvγ could be replaced by the constant q1. Therefore, the following empirical formula could describe the relationship between the nominal pressures and the wear mass loss rate, A.
A = q1Pβ | (11) |
A regression analysis using Matlab was carried out on the data in Table 3 to obtain the constants β and q1. The value of q1 was 1.205, and the value of β was 0.7876.
Velocities (m h−1) | 396 | 1188 | 1980 | 2772 | 3960 | 7920 |
Wear mass loss rates (mg h−1) | 0.215 | 0.373 | 0.467 | 0.627 | 0.777 | 1.075 |
Because Hα and Pβ were constant, qHαPβ could be replaced by the constant q2. Therefore, the follow empirical formula could describe the relationship between the velocity and the wear mass loss rate, A.
A = q2vγ | (12) |
A regression analysis of the data in Table 4 was conducted to obtain the constants γ and q2. The value of q2 was 0.0078, and the value of γ was 0.5499.
Shore hardness (A) | 63 (without ageing) | 77.3 (ageing 240 h) | 82.3 (ageing 480 h) | 84.8 (ageing 720 h) | 87.1 (ageing 960 h) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wear mass loss rates (mg h−1) | 0.719 | 0.819 | 0.938 | 0.967 | 0.994 |
Because vγ and Pβ were unchanged, qvγPβ could be replaced by the constant q3. Therefore, the following empirical formula could describe the relationship between the shore hardness and the wear mass loss rate, A.
A = q3Hα | (13) |
A regression analysis of the data in Table 5 was conducted using Matlab to obtain the constants α and q3. The value of q3 was 0.0106, and the value of α was 1.0133.
A = 2.227 × 10−4H1.0133P0.7876v0.5499 | (14) |
The wear mass loss rates of NBR pins at the other tests conditions were obtained based on the comprehensive empirical wear mass loss rate formula.
To verify the accuracy of the formula, the other conditions were tested using the tribo-tester detailed in Section 2.2.2. The un-aged NBR pins were used in the wear tests. The velocity and nominal pressure were set to 1188 m h−1 and 0.3 MPa, respectively. The wear rates estimated using the above formula were compared with the experiential results. The relative error (e) was calculated using the following formula (15).
(15) |
Nominal pressures (MPa) | 0.1 | 0.3 | 0.5 | 0.7 | 0.9 | 1.1 |
Ā (mg h−1) | 0.125 | 0.301 | 0.4 | 0.598 | 0.654 | 0.859 |
A (mg h−1) | 0.119 | 0.282 | 0.421 | 0.549 | 0.669 | 0.784 |
e | 4.8% | 6.3% | 5.3% | 8.2% | 2.3% | 8.7% |
As shown in Tables 6 and 7, the largest error was 12.9%; the others errors were less than 10%. Generally speaking, the errors were in line with the expectations. They could be accepted in engineering practice. These errors indicate that the comprehensive empirical wear mass loss rate formula is suitable for predicting the wear mass loss rates of NBR pins tested against 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel under water-lubricated conditions. This applicability of this formula to other test conditions should be further examined.
Velocities (m h−1) | 396 | 1188 | 1980 | 2772 | 3960 | 7920 |
Ā (mg h−1) | 0.145 | 0.273 | 0.407 | 0.427 | 0.537 | 0.708 |
A (mg h−1) | 0.154 | 0.282 | 0.373 | 0.449 | 0.546 | 0.799 |
e | 6.2% | 3.3% | 8.4% | 5.2% | 1.7% | 12.9% |
(a) High-temperature accelerated ageing significantly affected the friction and wear properties of the NBR specimens. The friction coefficients between the rubbing pairs and the wear mass losses of the NBR positively correlated with the ageing times.
(b) The main wear mechanism between the NBR pins and the 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel rubbing pairs is severe adhesion tearing wear under the water-lubricated condition.
(c) A comprehensive empirical wear mass loss rate formula was established to describe the wear rule of the NBR. Overall, the wear rates estimated by the formula are comparable with the experimental results.
(d) The knowledge gained in this study will provide the theoretical data for studying the wear theory of NBR and is useful for the optimisation of water-lubricated rubber stern tube bearings.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |