Gongzhou
Chen
,
Shijian
Wu
,
Hongli
Liu
,
Huanfeng
Jiang
and
Yingwei
Li
*
Key Laboratory of Fuel Cell Technology of Guangdong Province and The Key Lab of Enhanced Heat Transfer and Energy Conservation, Ministry of Education, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou 510640, China. E-mail: liyw@scut.edu.cn
First published on 22nd November 2012
Highly dispersed palladium nanoparticles were deposited on an acidic MOF (MIL-101) by using a simple colloidal method. The resulting Pd/MIL-101 catalyst was highly active in the liquid-phase aerobic oxidation of a wide range of alcohols including benzyl, allylic, aliphatic and heterocyclic alcohols as well as diols, affording the desired oxidation products in high yields under base-free and mild conditions. The catalyst was shown to be able to efficiently catalyze aerobic oxidation even at ambient temperature using air instead of pure O2. The solvent-free oxidation of benzyl alcohol gave a remarkably high turnover frequency (TOF) of approximately 16900 h−1. However, the catalytic activity was significantly suppressed when ethylenediamine was grafted on the uncoordinated Cr sites of the MIL-101 support, which suggests that the open Cr sites might play an important role in promoting the oxidation of alcohols in the present catalytic system.
Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are a new class of porous materials assembled with metal ions and organic linkers.27 Owing to their high surface area, porosity, and chemical tunability, the applications of MOFs in heterogeneous catalysis have recently attracted tremendous attention, especially, those using MOFs as a support for metal (e.g., Pd, Au, Ru, and Pt) nanoparticles.28–41 A few MOF-supported noble-metal (e.g., Au, Pt) nanoparticles have also been investigated as active heterogeneous catalysts in the aerobic oxidation of alcohols,42,43 even under base-free conditions.35
Here we report a new and highly active heterogeneous Pd catalyst, which was deposited on a zeolite-type MOF (i.e. MIL-101) using a simple colloid method. The supported Pd nanoparticles have been shown to be highly efficient in the liquid-phase aerobic oxidation of a variety of alcohols in the absence of base under mild conditions. We have chosen MIL-101, Cr3F(H2O)2O[(O2C)–C6H4–(CO2)]3,44 because it has a large surface area and pore size as well as a good water stability, which jointly make it an attractive support for depositing small palladium nanoparticles. On the other hand, MIL-101 possesses numerous potentially unsaturated chromium sites (up to 3.0 mmol g−1) upon removal of the terminal water molecules.30,45,46 The significant Lewis acidity of the MIL-101 support has been demonstrated to play significant roles in promoting the reactivity of aromatic substrates.40,46 The effect of the open chromium sites of the support on the reactivity of alcohol oxidation was also investigated in this work.
Fig. 1 Powder XRD patterns of MIL-101 samples: (a) MIL-101; (b) 0.15% Pd/MIL-101; (c) 0.35% Pd/MIL-101; (d) 0.59% Pd/MIL-101; (e) 0.94% Pd/MIL-101; (f) 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 after five runs; (g) 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101. |
Fig. 2 TEM images (a–c) of 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 and corresponding size distribution of Pd nanoparticles (d). The inset in (c) is the EDX pattern. |
The specific surface areas of the samples were measured by N2 adsorption at 77 K and the results are presented in Fig. 3 and Table 1. The appreciable decreases in nitrogen adsorption amount and surface area indicate that the cavities of MIL-101 are occupied by highly dispersed Pd nanoparticles or/and blocked by Pd nanoparticles that are deposited at the pore surface. In addition, the possible residual PVA (added as a protecting agent in the course of preparation) in the samples could also have some impact on the gas adsorption capacities of the catalysts.
Fig. 3 Nitrogen adsorption isotherms at 77 K of the as-synthesized MIL-101 (◆), 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 (■), 0.59% Pd/MIL-101 (●), and 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 (▲). |
Sample | S BET (m2 g−1) | S Langmuir (m2 g−1) | V pore (cm3 g−1) |
---|---|---|---|
MIL-101 | 2869 | 4874 | 1.59 |
0.15% Pd/MIL-101 | 2506 | 3947 | 1.36 |
0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | 2412 | 3875 | 1.25 |
0.59% Pd/MIL-101 | 2084 | 2648 | 1.11 |
0.94% Pd/MIL-101 | 2029 | 2581 | 1.07 |
0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 | 2173 | 2836 | 1.18 |
The XPS spectra of the 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 and 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 samples are shown in Fig. 4. The two samples both exhibit Pd 3d5/2 bands at ca. 335–336 eV (Fig. 4a), typical of Pd metal,47 indicating that the Pd(II) cations were transformed to Pd(0) after reduction by sodium borohydride. No appreciable differences were observed in the binding energies and intensities of the Pd(3d) spectra for the two materials. The results suggest that the ethylenediamine molecules were not grafted on the Pd nanoparticles nor had a strong interaction with Pd.
Fig. 4 XPS spectra of 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 and 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 catalysts: (a) Pd3d; (b) Cr2p; (c) survey spectra of 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101. |
Fig. 4b presents the Cr(2p) spectra of Pd/MIL-101 and Pd/En-MIL-101. It can be seen that the Cr(2p) spectrum of the amine-grafted material is less intense compared to Pd/MIL-101. In addition, the Cr(2p) peaks of Pd/En-MIL-101 are shifted by ca. 0.6 eV toward lower binding energies, compared to those of the pristine Pd/MIL-101. Such shifts reflect an increase in the electron density of Cr that may be attributed to the metal–ethylenediamine interactions on the Pd/En-MIL-101 sample. The incorporation of ethylenediamine in the sample was also confirmed by the presence of a well-defined band corresponding to N(1s) in the survey spectrum (Fig. 4c).
The infrared spectra of the 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 and Pd/En-MIL-101 samples are shown in Fig. 5. The γ(N–H) and γ(C–H) stretching regions observed for Pd/En-MIL-101 indicate the presence of ethylenediamine by comparing with the spectrum of ethylenediamine in the liquid phase (not shown here). The aliphatic C–H stretching vibrations (at 2800–3000 cm−1) are shifted to higher wavenumbers (from 2848 and 2924 cm−1 to 2860 and 2931 cm−1, respectively), as observed when the molecule is coordinated to a Lewis acid center,48 further demonstrating the successful grafting of ethylenediamine onto the coordinately unsaturated Cr sites of the MIL-101.
Fig. 5 Infrared spectra of (a) Pd/En-MIL-101 and (b) Pd/MIL-101. |
The aerobic oxidations of alcohols were carried out under atmospheric O2 pressure and the prepared Pd/MIL-101 samples with different Pd loadings were used as catalysts. The results of the oxidation of cinnamyl alcohol are summarized in Table 2. The use of the parent MIL-101 gave essentially no conversion in this reaction system (Table 2, entry 1), confirming as expected the need of a metal to perform the oxidation of alcohol. The incorporation of Pd nanoparticles significantly promoted the reaction. Results of the aerobic oxidation pointed to an optimized performance of 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 (Table 2, entry 3), which provided a complete conversion of cinnamyl alcohol to cinnamyl aldehyde within 0.5 h at 80 °C. With the 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 catalyst, various solvents were subsequently screened, which indicated that toluene was the best solvent for this transformation under the conditions (Table 2, entries 6–10). In principle, the conversion increased with a decrease in the polarity of solvent. The relatively low activity of the reaction in isooctane (with a low polarity) may be attributed to the poor solubility of cinnamyl alcohol in this solvent. The activity could be enhanced remarkably when toluene was added in this system to improve the solubility of cinnamyl alcohol in the mixed solvents (Table 2, entry 10).
Entry | Catalyst | Solvent | Time (h) | Conv./sel. (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: cinnamyl alcohol (1 mmol), catalyst (Pd 1 mol%), solvent (10 mL), 80 °C, 1 atm, O2 bubbling rate (20 mL min−1). b 1 eq. NaOH was added. | ||||
1 | MIL-101 | Toluene | 3 | <3/98 |
2 | 0.15% Pd/MIL-101 | Toluene | 0.5 | 75/97 |
3 | 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | Toluene | 0.5 | 99/99 |
4 | 0.59% Pd/MIL-101 | Toluene | 0.75 | 93/99 |
5 | 0.94% Pd/MIL-101 | Toluene | 0.75 | 90/99 |
6 | 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | DMF | 1 | 74/99 |
7 | 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | o-Xylene | 0.5 | 97/99 |
8 | 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | DMSO | 1 | 6/95 |
9 | 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | Isooctane | 0.5 | 61/98 |
10 | 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 | Isooctane + toluene (1:1) | 0.5 | 78/99 |
11 | 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 | Toluene | 3 | 45/99 |
12b | 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 | Toluene | 3 | 95/99 |
13 | 0.35% Pd/AC | Toluene | 2 | 23/99 |
For comparison, the amine grafted sample 0.35% Pd/En-MIL-101 was also tested in the aerobic oxidation of cinnamyl alcohol under the optimized reaction conditions. The use of En-grafted MIL-101 as support led to inferior activity in the oxidation (Table 2, entry 11), giving only 45% yield of cinnamyl aldehyde even though the reaction time was prolonged to 3 h. Nevertheless, when a small amount of NaOH was added to the reaction system, the activity was restored significantly, furnishing 95% conversion of alcohol within 3 h (Table 2, entry 12). As is well known, the addition of base additives may promote the oxidation of alcohols by facilitating the dehydrogenation of alcohols.43 Therefore, this result implies that most of the Pd active sites were not covered by the ethylenediamine molecules, in agreement with the XPS data (Fig. 4a). The remarkably reduced activity of Pd/MIL-101 upon amine grafting on the unsaturated chromium sites of MIL-101 suggests that the uncoordinated Lewis acidic Cr sites have played an important role in the alcohol oxidation, which correlates well with the low activity observed for Pd/AC under the same reaction conditions (Table 2, entry 13). These findings also support previous findings of the group related to a promoting effect observed in MIL-101-supported metal nanoparticles for the conversions of aromatics.40,46
The scope of the presented catalyst system was then subsequently extended to the aerobic oxidation of a large variety of alcohols under base-free conditions using the optimum 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 catalyst. The results summarized in Table 3 show that Pd/MIL-101 was highly active and extremely selective for the oxidation of all substrates, indicating a high versatility of the MOF-supported Pd catalyst. Substituted benzyl alcohols containing electron-donating groups such as CH3, OCH3, or OH, (Table 3, entries 1–4) are more easily oxidized than those containing electron-withdrawing groups (Table 3, entry 5). Secondary benzylic alcohols were also converted to the corresponding ketones in quantitative yields (Table 3, entry 6). A complete conversion of allylic alcohols, for example, cinnamyl alcohol and trans-2-hexen-1-ol, to the desired aldehydes was achieved within 1 h (Table 3, entries 7 and 8). The CC double bonds remained intact without an intramolecular hydrogen transfer over Pd/MIL-101 under the investigated conditions.
Entry | Substrate | Time (h) | Conv./sel. (%) |
---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: alcohol (1 mmol), 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 (Pd 1 mol%), toluene (10 mL), 80 °C, 1 atm, O2 bubbling rate (20 mL min−1). b Pd 1.5 mol %, 100 °C. c Lactones were the predominant oxidation products. d Pd 3.0 mol %, 25 °C, air was used as the oxidant instead of pure O2. e Alcohol (10 mmol), toluene (30 mL), O2 bubbling rate (30 mL min−1). | |||
1 | 1.5 | 99/99 | |
2 | 0.75 | 99/99 | |
3 | 1 | 99/99 | |
4 | 1.5 | 99/99 | |
5 | 4.5 | 97/99 | |
6 | 1.5 | 99/99 | |
7 | 0.5 | 99/99 | |
8 | 1 | 99/99 | |
9b | 10 | 95/96 | |
10b | 5 | 99/98 | |
11b | 6 | 96/99 | |
12b | 4 | 99/98 | |
13b | 4 | 99/98 | |
14c | 4 | 99/90 | |
15c | 6 | 99/88 | |
16d | 24 | 99/99 | |
17e | 3 | 99/98 |
Aliphatic alcohols have been reported to be difficult compounds to undergo oxidation.9,35 Our Pd/MIL-101 catalyst was also applicable to the oxidation of various aliphatic alcohols including primary and secondary linear, and cyclic aliphatic alcohols, to afford the corresponding aldehydes or ketones in excellent yields within short reaction times under mild and base-free conditions (Table 3, entries 9–11). Heterocyclic alcohols, such as 2-pyridinemethanol and furfuryl alcohol, were also smoothly oxidized into the corresponding aldehydes in excellent yields (Table 3, entries 12 and 13). The Pd/MIL-101 catalyst was also active in the oxidation of diols, furnishing the corresponding lactones in high yields (Table 3, entries 14 and 15).
Encouraged by these promising results, we further examined the catalytic activity of Pd/MIL-101 for the aerobic oxidation of cinnamyl alcohol using air instead of pure O2 at ambient temperature. Cinnamyl alcohol was selectively oxidized into cinnamyl aldehyde in the absence of water or base, furnishing a complete conversion with 99% selectivity after 24 h of reaction (Table 3, entry 16). We also investigated the oxidation of cinnamyl alcohol on the 10 mmol scale, which gave a complete conversion with 98% selectivity for cinnamyl aldehyde (isolated yield: 94%) within 3 h (Table 3, entry 17).
The recyclability of the Pd/MIL-101 catalyst was examined in the aerobic oxidation of cinnamyl alcohol under the optimized conditions. After the catalytic reaction, the catalyst was isolated from the liquid phase by centrifugation, thoroughly washed with ethanol, and then reutilized as catalyst in subsequent runs under identical reaction conditions. The results included in Table 4 indicate that no efficiency loss was observed in the aerobic oxidation of alcohol for up to five runs. These findings were in accordance with AAS experiments for which no Pd traces (below the detection limit) were detected in the reaction solution as well as with the PXRD experiments of the catalyst after the fifth run which showed no appreciable changes in the crystallinity of the MIL-101 material (Fig. 1).
The high reactivity of the present catalyst system was further highlighted by a 50 mmol scale oxidation of benzyl alcohol employing 1 × 10−3 mol% Pd under base- and solvent-free conditions. The Pd/MIL-101 catalyst provided an extremely high turnover frequency (TOF) of 16900 h−1, with greater than 99% selectivity for the desired product. It is noteworthy that the TOF value achieved by Pd/MIL-101 is comparable to those reported for most other active catalysts, e.g., Pd/7Mn3Ce-C that afforded a TOF of 15235 h−1 for the conversion of benzyl alcohol under similar conditions as used in this study (Scheme 1).49
Scheme 1 TOF for the aerobic oxidation of benzyl alcohol for the initial 1 h of reaction (ratio of moles of benzaldehyde per mole of Pd per hour). Reaction conditions: 0.35% Pd/MIL-101 (1 × 10−3 mol%), benzyl alcohol (50 mmol). |
Synthesis of Pd/En-MIL-101: amine-functionalized MIL-101 was prepared according to the reported protocol.45 Identical procedures were followed to deposit Pd nanoparticles onto the En-MIL-101 as for the synthesis of Pd/MIL-101. The Pd content in the sample was ca. 0.35 wt% based on AAS analysis.
Synthesis of Pd/AC: prior to use, the activated carbon (DARCO®, SIGMA-ALDRICH, BET surface area: 981 m2 g−1) was washed with acetone and dehydrated at 150 °C for 12 h. Then, identical procedures were followed to deposit Pd nanoparticles onto the AC as for the synthesis of Pd/MIL-101. The Pd content in the sample was ca. 0.36 wt% based on AAS analysis.
For the recyclability tests, the reactions were performed under the same reaction conditions as described above, except using the recovered catalyst. Each time, the catalyst was isolated from the reaction solution at the end of the reaction, washed with ethanol, and then heated at 150 °C under vacuum.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2013 |