Ali Hossain
Khan
a,
Sasanka
Maji
a,
S.
Chakraborty
a,
N. B.
Manik
b and
Somobrata
Acharya
*a
aCentre for Advanced Materials, Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science, Kolkata, 700032, India. E-mail: camsa2@iacs.res.in
bCondensed Matter Physics Research Centre, Department of Physics, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, 700032, India.
First published on 3rd November 2011
Peanut shaped PbS nanocrystals are synthesized and their self-assemblies have been studied by means of solvent evaporation. Multi-scale ordered self-assemblies of PbS nanopeanuts have been achieved by solvent evaporation route and interparticle interactions in the solution phase. The self-assembly mechanism produces compact monolayers with long-range ordering over macroscopic areas, which have been utilized for fabricating photovoltaics devices. A current–voltage response upon white light irradiation was measured with increasing photocurrent upon increasing incident light intensity. Repetitive on-off device response to white illumination flux is found to be sharp and repeatable over successive on/off irradiation cycles. Such simple self-assembled route is useful for the fabrication of technologically important ultra thin film materials for sensors and photovoltaic devices.
Lead chalcogenide nanocrystals (PbS, PbSe & PbTe) are of current interest because of long range optical tunability from UV-vis to the near IR region.30 The lead chalcogenides have small bulk band gap and exceptionally large exciton Bohr radii, which make them susceptible to carrier quantum confinement effects over a broad range of nanocrystal sizes and shapes.31,32 The discovery of efficient multiple exciton generation by single photons in lead chalcogenide nanocrystals has initiated an intense effort to build lead chalcogenide based photovoltaic devices.33–37 We report on a simple synthesis technique of fabricating unique PbS peanut shaped nanostructures and their multi-scale ordered self-assemblies by solvent evaporation route. Flower like assemblies are obtained at higher concentration which evolves into monodispersed ordered compact film spanning over a large area upon dilution. We show how the morphology of drop-casted PbS peanut films is controlled by evaporation kinetics and interparticle interactions in the liquid phase. The drop-drying process is simple, robust and scalable, and is insensitive to the substrate material, and has a strong preference for forming monolayer films. The self-assembly mechanism produces monolayers with exceptionally compact long-range ordering over macroscopic areas, which have been utilized for fabricating photovoltaics devices. A current–voltage response upon white light irradiation was measured with increasing photocurrent upon increasing incident light intensity. Repetitive on-off device response to white illumination flux is found to be sharp and repeatable over successive on/off irradiation cycles. Such simple self-assembled route is useful for the fabrication of technologically important ultra thin film materials for sensors and photovoltaic devices.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 SEM images of concentrated peanut shaped PbS nanoparticles with (a) flower like structures, (b) and (c) are the higher resolution SEM image of a part of the PbS flower showing the assembly of peanuts. (d) Schematic showing droplet-evaporation-induced formation of flower likes nanostructures by the peanut shaped PbS nanoparticles. |
The flowers and the petals are likely to form as a result of the strong interparticle interactions forming standing morphologies. In cases, the petals are observed growing from the centre of the flower with repetitive layered stacking. Nanoparticles may exhibit a range of ordered two or three dimensional assembled structures easily upon solvent evaporation and the process is highly sensitive to the concentration of the particles.38 During evaporation of the droplet of PbS peanut suspension, an in-plane compression developed due to the decrease in the surface area, concurrently the concentration of peanuts within droplet is gradually increases (Fig. 1d). When the concentration of peanuts within the droplet increases up to the super saturation point as a result of solvent evaporation, PbS peanuts start sedimentation on top of the substrate. Since the concentration of the peanut particles changes with drying time, the sedimentation process is continuous leading to the close packed layered stacking of the peanuts. Such continuous process of stacking might lead to the vertically standing flecks as a result of increasing concentration at the end of the evaporation process. Because of strong interparticle interaction between the peanuts a continuous fleck structure occurs.
The in-plane packing of the peanuts is found to vary depending on the concentration of peanuts and with the evaporation rate of the solvent used (see ESI†, Fig. S2).38 In order to investigate the effect of concentration on the self assembly of PbS peanuts, we carried out concentration dependent evaporation rate study of the as-synthesized peanuts by drop casting on top of solid substrate.
Simultaneously, we attempted to identify an optimum condition for obtaining a large area of ordered monolayer of the peanuts during the evaporation process. We observed that the flowers break into the three-dimensional (3D) stacked assembled petals (Fig. 2a) with the dilution (CPbS = 10 mM) of the mother suspension (CPbS = 40 mM). Upon further dilution (CPbS = 5 mM), the petals appear flat while the peanuts still remain in tightly packed configuration within the petals (Fig. 2b). Continuing the dilution process (CPbS = 3.33 mM) further led to a large area self assembled 2D compact monolayer of closely packed peanuts (Fig. 2c). Upon further dilution (CPbS = 2.5 mM), better dispersion is obtained within a closed packed monolayer of individual peanuts (Fig. 2d), indicating that the concentrations of the PbS peanuts significantly affect the self-assembly of these structures.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 SEM images of self-assembled structures of PbS peanuts for different concentrations: (a) Flacks from 10 mM solution. (b) Plates from 5 mM solution. (c) Closed packed film from 3.33 mM solution. (d) Monolayer film from 2.5 mM solution. |
Detailed structural and morphological investigations were carried out using XRD and HRTEM analysis. The XRD pattern of the as-prepared PbS peanuts shows a high degree of crystallinity (Fig. 3). Most of the peaks match well with Bragg reflection conditions of the standard face-centred cubic (fcc) structure of bulk PbS (JCPDS #05-0592). The XRD reveals sharp intense (200) diffraction peaks and a relatively broader (111) diffraction peaks. It is also worth noting that the ratio between the intensities of the (200) and (111) diffraction peaks is 1.202 which is somewhat higher than the reported value (1.049) indicating that the peanuts may be abundant in {100} facets, and grow along the <100> directions. Moreover, some additional weak intense peaks are also observed in the XRD patterns, which are not matching with the cubic PbS phase, are the contributions from the unremoved surfactants (see ESI†, Fig. S3).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 The XRD of the drop casted films of the purified peanut shaped PbS nanoparticles, which matches well to the standard cubic rock-salt structure with strongest (200) reflection. The expected positions and intensities of the standard peaks rock-salt cubic PbS (JCPDS #05-0592) are indicated by blue vertical lines. |
The morphology and crystallinity of the PbS peanuts was further investigated using TEM. The typical TEM image of the PbS nanostructures (Fig. 4a) clearly shows that peanuts are of nearly identical in size with an average diameter of 100 nm. HRTEM (Fig. 4b) confirms the crystallinity showing well-resolved lattice planes with an inter-planar distance of 0.29 nm corresponding to (200) planes of PbS bulk rock salt structure. Notably, the HRTEM measurement points out to a local structure, while the XRD pattern is representing the global nature of the sample. However, both these techniques together may represent the crystal structure of the entire sample and both indicate an orientation in which the <100> crystallographic axis is parallel to the growth axis of the peanuts. The SAED patterns (Fig. 4c) shows the predominant 200, 220 and 311 diffraction spots, corresponding to the inter-planer distances of 0.29 nm, 0.24 nm and 0.20 nm of PbS bulk rock salt structure (JCPDS powder diffraction file #05-0592) respectively. The strongest intensity of the 200 reflection is supportive to the previous XRD and HRTEM observations.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) TEM image of peanut shaped PbS nanoparticles. The zoom of the selected portion of the main figure (Fig. 4a) is shown in the inset and it's demonstrating the presence of small cubic shaped PbS nanoparticles along with the peanuts. (b) HRTEM image of PbS peanuts with well resolved lattice planes. The inter-planner distance of 0.29 nm corresponds to the (200) sets of d-spacings. (c) SAED pattern from the peanuts visible in Fig. 4a. (d) HRTEM image of small cubic PbS nanoparticles present at the edge of the peanuts with well resolved lattice fringes corresponding to inter-planar distance of 0.29 nm, consistent with the (200) planes of PbS bulk rock salt structure. |
The TEM image (Fig. 4a) reveals the existence of few small sized particles near the periphery of the peanuts, which were not observed in SEM. Higher resolution TEM image (inset of Fig. 4a) shows that these small particles are PbS cubes of 10 nm size. The HRTEM image of the PbS cubes (Fig. 4d) shows well-resolved lattice spacings corresponding to (200) PbS planes, the same as peanuts. The coexistence of cubes along with the peanuts in an identical crystal structure might point out to the mechanism of growth direction of the peanuts.
To investigate the formation mechanism of the peanuts, we carried out control reactions by tuning the nature of ligands. First, we have carried out the reaction for 10 min at 110 °C by injecting lead nitrate and thiourea into TOPO only. The temperature was then increased to 130 °C, where the reaction was stopped immediately when the reaction mixture turned to milky-gray color. Flat bundle like aggregated whiskers are evidenced in this reaction condition, while surprisingly maintaining uniformity in the width around 100 nm (see ESI†, Fig. S4). These aggregated whiskers turned into bundles of tightly bounded rods upon increasing the reaction temperature to 160 °C and annealing for 60 min (see ESI†, Fig. S5). These control reactions supports that HDA is essential for PbS peanut shape formation. In the absence of HDA, aggregated whiskers turned into bundle of tightly bounded rods. We have injected HDA in the reaction mixture after formation of whiskers aggregates in TOPO in a separate reaction condition to obtain the peanuts. The use of HDA prevents further growth of whiskers aggregates resulting in peanuts of similar dimension.
The structure of initial PbS seed that form PbS peanuts may consists of a truncated cuboctahedron with six {100} facets, eight {111}, and twelve {110} facets as demonstrated previously for crystalline equivalent lead chalcogenide systems.14,39 During crystal growth, the seed will minimize the most energetically unfavourable facets and removal of the {111} and {110} facets were earlier observed during the nanoparticle growth.14,39 We anticipate a similar growth mechanism leading to the peanuts using mixture of HDA and TOPO and bundles of nanorod aggregates using TOPO only (Fig. 5). The chemical nature of stabilizing capping agents is significantly affecting the facet energies and the growth of PbS nanocrystals. Presumably, TOPO adsorb on the {100} facets of PbS nucleating seeds resulting in truncated cuboctahedron particles with mainly {100} planes. With increasing the reaction temperature, {100} facets becomes highly reactive and are preferentially consumed yielding whiskers like aggregate and bundle of rod aggregates at elevated temperature (Fig. 5, Path 1). In fact, a thermal gradient may lead to a growth toward the high-temperature side as reported by Wagner and the growth rate can have a striking effect on the resultant morphology.40 When hot HDA is injected into the reaction mixture, HDA prevents the oriented attachment process owing to the presence of long aliphatic chain leading to the peanuts shaped PbS (Fig. 5, Path 2). The uncoalesced truncated cuboctahedron which were weakly attached to the periphery of the peanuts as observed in TEM turned into cubes after HDA injection by the elimination of the {111} facets.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Schematic diagram of PbS whiskers like aggregate (path 1a), bundle of rod aggregates (path 1b) and peanut (path 2) formation from small PbS truncated cuboctahedron which was the nucleating seed. |
Notably, the controlled assembly of peanuts is obtained by means of drop casting and simultaneously drying routes without using an external driving force such as electric field or pressure induced assemblies to bring the peanuts into closer proximity.41,42 This predicts that controlling the interaction between the peanuts in the liquid phase is the key to the realization of highly ordered aggregates. Since the peanuts are capped with both TOPO and HDA, an organic shell is formed by the ligands around the PbS core. The van der Waals interaction among the shells and the inherent dipole moment provides the attractive force to induce the self-assembly, where as the steric repulsion due to the ligand interdigitation provides the balancing force to create a stable structure. In fact a finite dipole moment may exist in PbS nanocrystal owing to the asymmetric structure, the magnitude of which depends on the size and volume of the nanocrystal.43 The mixed {100} and {110} facets are formed by both Pb and S atoms, while the {111} facets consist of either S or Pb atoms. Due to the difference in electro-negativities between Pb and S, {111} facets are polar and their arrangement will determine the net electric charge distribution and dipole moment within the PbS nanocrystal.
The nature of assembly and packing of the peanuts within the flowers and petals are highly dependent on concentration and solvent evaporation rate. Since toluene is a high boiling solvent, the peanuts find enough time to orient them in the suspension phase at their favourable orientation in comparison to a low boiling solvent such as dichloromethane (see ESI†, Fig. S2). When the solvent molecules evaporate from the top surface of a concentrated drop, the dispersed peanuts at the air-toluene interface can diffuse into the drop interior creating a steep concentration gradient resulting in a supersaturated environment within the drop with drying time.44 An in-plane compression developed due to the decrease in the surface area along with the change in the contact angle of the droplet with the substrate. Concurrently, the concentration of peanuts is gradually increased as a result of solvent evaporation. When the concentration of peanuts within the droplet increases up to the super saturation point, PbS peanuts start sedimentation on top of the substrate. However, in a closed packed configuration, the minimum separation distance between two adjacent peanuts is defined by the layer thickness of the organic shell formed by TOPO and HDA. Hence a bi-layer of the surfactants is always expected between adjacent peanuts even in supersaturated environment. In supersaturated environment, the van der Waals interaction between the ligand shells and the inter PbS dipolar interaction are supposed to be strong enough owing to the shorter interparticle distances. Since the concentration of the peanut particles increases with the evaporation process, the continuous sedimentation process leads to the standing flacks and flower-like structures of closely packed peanuts. Upon dilution, the interparticle separation distances increases and the van der Waals and dipolar interaction reduces resulting in the flowers to break into the closely packed assembly petals. Upon further dilution, at a critical concentration, a large area 2D self assembled compact monolayer of peanuts can be achieved. However, as these monolayers extend over macroscopic dimensions, the upper limit for the area to be covered depends on the droplet size and the concentration of peanuts.
We fabricated photovoltaic devices making use of uniformity, dimensionality and packing of these self-assembled structures. The self-assembled PbS films are important in exciton migration owing to the close packing of the peanuts.45 We have fabricated thin film photovoltaic devises by drop casting PbS peanut suspension using 3.33 mM concentration on indium tin oxide (ITO) substrates (Aldrich, 100 Ω/squares inches). A sandwiched pattern device has been fabricated using Al sheet as counter electrode. We deliberately avoided the use of any additional layer which may enhance the photovoltaic property or other post-preparative process such as ligand exchange for photovoltaic measurement purposes.35–37 We have tested photovoltaic response of the devices in ambient condition. The current–voltage characteristics in dark and under 64.6 mW cm−2 irradiation when exposed to an active area of 9 mm2 are shown in Fig. 6a.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) Current–voltage characteristics of pure peanut shaped PbS nanocrystals films with (red dotted curve) and without (black curve) illumination with respect to external applied voltage. The inset shows the current vs. light intensity plot (b) Photo switching performance of peanut shaped PbS nanoparticles film on illumination. The light source for photovoltaic measurement was a 200 W tungsten lamp. |
In the case of the dark measurement, the current increases up to 4.5 μA with the increase in voltage up to 5V. Upon illumination of light, the current increases sharply resulting in orders of enhanced current. With the increase in light intensity, the photocurrent increases exponentially as expected (inset of Fig. 6a). The photoswitching responses of these devices show uniform on-off cycles in presence and absence of light illumination respectively (Fig. 6b). The repetitive on-off device response to white illumination flux was found to be sharp and repetitive over successive on/off cycles (Fig. 6b). Photocurrent increased sharply upon light exposure and decays linearly in the subsequent absence of light source while retaining reproducibility in successive on-off cycles. The long term photo switching property suggests a higher stability of the devises. The device performance retains even after several days after keeping in open air defining the stability of the devises.
Footnote |
† Electronic Supplementary Information (ESI) available: Additional discussions, SEM and TEM images. See DOI: 10.1039/c1ra00321f/ |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |