Jianliang
Gong
a,
Lichao
Sun
b,
Yawen
Zhong
a,
Chunyin
Ma
b,
Lei
Li
*a,
Suyuan
Xie
b and
Vladimir
Svrcek
c
aCollege of Materials, Xiamen University, Xiamen, 361005, P. R. China. E-mail: lilei@xmu.edu.cn; Fax: +86-592-2183937; Tel: +86-592-2186296
bCollege of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Xiamen University, Xiamen, 361005, P. R. China
cNext Generation Device Team, Research Center for Photovoltaic Technologies, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Central 2, Umezono 1-1-1, Tsukuba, 305-8568, Japan
First published on 14th November 2011
Multi-level carbon nanotube (CNT) arrays with adjustable patterns were prepared by a combination of the breath figure (BF) process and chemical vapor deposition. Polystyrene-b-poly(acrylic acid)/ferrocene was dissolved in carbon disulfide and cast onto a Si substrate covered with a transmission electron microscope grid in saturated relative humidity. A two-level microporous hybrid film with a block copolymer skeleton formed on the substrate after evaporation of the organic solvent and water. One level of ordered surface features originates from the contour of the hard templates; while the other level originates from the condensation of water droplets (BF arrays). Ultraviolet irradiation effectively cross-linked the polymer matrix and endowed the hybrid film with improved thermal stability. In the subsequent pyrolysis, the incorporated ferrocene in the hybrid film was oxidized and turned the polymer skeleton into the ferrous inorganic micropatterns. Either the cross-linked hybrid film or the ferrous inorganic micropatterns could act as a template to grow the multi-level CNT patterns, e.g. isolated and honeycomb-structured CNT bundle arrays perpendicular to the substrate.
In contrast, self-assembly provides efficient and fundamentally simple methods for creating microstructures. The breath figure (BF) process is one of the most promising self-assembling strategies towards large-scaled patterns with an ordered two-dimensional array of holes.5 In a typical BF process, a water-immiscible solution containing polymer is cast onto the substrate under high humidity. Hexagonally packed water microdroplets form on the solution surface due to the evaporative cooling of the solvent, and are then transferred to the solution front driven by convection flow and the capillary force. After the evaporation of the solvent, the honeycomb-patterned polymer film forms, with the water droplet array filling it as a template. Finally, a microporous polymer film is obtained after water evaporation. Various types of polymers can be fabricated into a honeycomb-patterned film with controlled pore size, ranging from hundreds of nanometres to hundreds of micrometres.6 This simple method offers new prospects in the field of microporous films, and also opens new routes to the preparation of patterned nano/micro materials in low cost and large scale. Quite recently, we developed a robust static BF process to fabricate honeycomb-structured polymeric films using amphiphilic diblock copolymer polystyrene-b-poly(acrylic acid) (PSPAA), hybrid diblock copolymer polydimethylsiloxane-b-polystyrene, commercially available triblock copolymers of polystyrene-b-polybutadiene-b-polystyrene and polystyrene-b-polyisoprene-b-polystyrene, and linear PS without polar end groups.7 Particularly, highly ordered microporous hybrid films of polymer/inorganic precursors were also formed in a wide solution concentration range tolerating temperatures, molecular weights and chemical compositions. In the following ultraviolet irradiation, the polymer matrix was cross-linked and worked as a structure-directing agent during the subsequent pyrolysis process to construct inorganic micropatterns on the substrate. By simply changing the precursor, various functionalized inorganic micropatterns could be created, and were further used to initiate the growth of ZnO nanorods and CNT arrays.7b,7c
In this article, based on our previous work, we develop a new method to prepare two-level CNT patterns, using a transmission electron microscope (TEM) grid and honeycomb-patterned polymer film prepared through the BF process. One order level of the CNT pattern originates from the contour of the TEM grid; while the other level originates from the BF arrays. The beauty of this process is that a number of different CNT patterns can be easily obtained by choosing different hard templates. Circumventing expensive lithographic techniques, the reported methodology provides a convenient way to prepare patterned CNTs in large area that may be valuable for the nanoscale engineering applications.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Schematic pictures of fabrication process of multi-level CNT arrays with adjustable patterns on a substrate. (a) A droplet of PSPAA/ferrocene solution was cast onto the Si substrate covered with a TEM grid using a microsyringe; (b) the TEM grid was removed after total evaporation of the solvent under high humidity; (c) a two-level microporous hybrid film was formed on the substrate; (d) the polymer matrix was cross-linked by ultraviolet irradiation and the two-level honeycomb structures were well preserved after the photochemical process; (e) two-level isolated CNT bundles were developed templating from the cross-linked microporous polymer film; (f) two-level ferrous inorganic micropatterns in honeycomb structures were formed on the substrate after pyrolysis; (g) two-level dense CNT arrays with a hexagonal shape were formed, guided by the inorganic micropatterns. |
The formation of regular BF arrays on nonplanar substrates (guided by placing TEM grids, clay particles or other hard templates on flat surfaces) has been investigated by Qiao et al., by using a library of core cross-linked star polymers with different arm compositions. The glass transition temperature (Tg) of the series of star polymers ranged from −123 to 100 °C. It was found that all the polymers successfully formed ordered microporous films on flat surfaces.8 However, only the polymers with a Tg below 48 °C could show enough “fluid-like” character to contour the surface features of the nonplanar substrates. For PSPAA, the Tg of PS and PAA are 100 and 102 °C, respectively,9 thus the PSPAA is not believed to be a good material to form microporous film on the nonplanar surface during the BF process. Astonishingly, scanning electronic microscopy (SEM) images demonstrate that, not only on the mesh spaces but also on the grid area, the hybrid film effectively contours the whole TEM grid surface with ordered BF arrays (Fig. 2a and 2b). This result reveals that the Tg of the polymer may not be the exclusive factor which influences the formation of 3D microporous films on non-planar substrates. A detailed description of the formation of microporous polymer (hybrid) films on nonplanar substrates with such rod–rod copolymers will be published elsewhere. Once peeled off the grid by a tweezer, multi-level surface features are formed on the substrate, originating from the self-assembly of water droplets, and the pattern of the TEM grid (Fig. 2c). As reported in our previous publications, a single layer of the microporous film is necessary for the formation of ordered inorganic micropatterns.7d The cross-sectional view (Fig. 2d) reveals that the resultant film has a monolayer of independent pores on the dense polymer stratum without network structures. The successful preparation of multi-level microporous hybrid films indicates that non-planar substrate does not alter the behavior of PSPAA/ferrocene during the static BF process.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) SEM image of an ordered porous PSPAA/ferrocene hybrid film formed on the surface of a 150 mesh hexagonal TEM grid; (b) magnified image of (a); (c) a two-level microporous PSPAA/ferrocene hybrid film on the substrate after removing the TEM gird; (d) a cross-section view of the honeycomb structured PSPAA/ferrocene hybrid film; (e) SEM image of the two-level honeycomb structured PSPAA/ferrocene hybrid film after 4 h ultraviolet irradiation, the inset shows a cross-sectional view; (f) a cross-section view of the cross-linked PSPAA/ferrocene hybrid film after heating at 750 °C for 10 min; (g) SEM image of the two-level ferrous inorganic micropattens after pyrolyzing the cross-linked hybrid film at 450 °C for 5 h, the inset shows a magnified image; (h) close examination of the formed inorganic micropattens, indicating that the hexagonal edges are isolated from the Si substrate. |
Block copolymers (BCPs) are believed to be super structure-directing agents in solution, in the bulk and on surfaces, thanks to their amphiphilic character. The synthesis of organic/inorganic hybrid materials using BCPs as structure-directing agents or templates is an area of rapid growth.10 For example, highly-ordered nanostructured silica (MCM41 and SBA15) has been developed by templating from commercially available triblock copolymers, Pluronics.11 However, in order to use the as-prepared microporous hybrid film as a template to guide the following CVD growth, some further treatments are needed to increase its thermal stability, because CVD growth demands relatively high temperature at which the film will melt and its microstructures will totally disappear. Cross-linking should be an efficient method for stabilizing the film structure against solvents and heat annealing.12 Either PS or PAA composition can be effectively cross-linked under deep ultraviolet irradiation, as discussed in our previous research.7a Therefore, the microporous hybrid film was firstly treated with ultraviolet irradiation, and the SEM image shown in Fig. 2e demonstrates that the structures in the hybrid film were maintained after the photochemical process. After cross-linking, since the unzipping and depropagation reactions of the block polymer were strongly prohibited, the thermal decomposition rate of the macromolecular chains was slowed down. As revealed by the thermogravimetric (TG) results (see the ESI†), the char yield of cross-linked PSPAA was close to 40%, even when heated up to 450 °C at a rate of 5 °C min−1 in an air atmosphere. The microstructures on the cross-linked hybrid film were found to survive after thermal treatment at 750 °C for 10 min (the same condition in CVD, Fig. 2f), indicating that the cross-linked film was applicable to the further CVD growth. From the SEM images, some changes in the morphology of the film can also be observed after annealing. The film thickness was found to shrink significantly, because the photochemical cross-linking occurs mostly on the film surface, and the less cross-linked polymer stratum collapses during annealing. SEM observation (Fig. 2g) reveals that the walls of the obtained inorganic micropattern become thinner and sharper, suggesting that much material was burned out. In fact, the core scan of Fe (see the ESI†) definitely shows that the incorporated ferrocene has been oxidized to Fe2O3. Therefore, pyrolysis decomposes the polymer matrix and converts the incorporated ferrocene into Fe2O3, leaving the skeleton of inorganic micropatterns. The formed micropatterns have the identical spacing with that of the micropores on the as-prepared film surface, indicative of the in situ formation of inorganic patterns on the honeycomb structures. The cross-linked polymer matrix and the ferrous inorganic micropatterns are used to template the multi-level CNT growth with adjustable arrays as discussed below.
To grow CNT on the micropatterned templates, CVD was carried out. The deposition was operated under a constant flow rate of Ar/H2/C2H2 with 500/200/78 standard-state cubic centimetre per minute (sccm), while the growth temperature was 750 °C and the time was 10 min. To avoid the undesired reactions during the ramping step, the Si wafers with template were kept at the cool end of the furnace until the temperature of the furnace reached the predetermined working value. When C2H2 gas was induced into the reactor carried by Ar and H2, CNTs began to grow from the micropatterned templates. Two different CNT arrays can be prepared, depending on the template used. If the cross-linked hybrid film was used as template (Fig. 2e), isolated CNT bundles would form from the cavities of the film (Fig. 3a), and were isolated by the walls of the honeycomb structures (Fig. 3b and 3c). The high-resolution (HR) TEM image definitely shows that the formed CNTs are multi-walled tubes with an average diameter of 15 nm (Fig. 3d and the inset). Either the CVD temperature or carbon feedstock can have an influence on the formation of single- or multiple-wall CNTs. As pointed by Coville and Campbell,13 low CVD temperature (below 750 °C) and acetylene feedstocks facilitate the growth of multi-wall carbon nantotubes. Since the CVD temperature is 750 °C and carbon source is acetylene in our experiment, we just obtain multi-wall carbon nantotube arrays. If ordered ferrous inorganic micropattens were used as the template in the CVD growth (Fig. 2g), a honeycomb-like skeleton of dense CNT bundles would form, as shown in Fig. 3e and 3f. The spacing of the skeleton is identical with that of the inorganic micropatterns, indicating an in situ inorganic pattern formation on the honeycomb structures. The cross-sectional view demonstrates that the aligned CNTs are perpendicular to the substrate without collapse (Fig. 3g), because the supporting force among the continuous CNT bundles counteracted the effect of gravity.14 The well-aligned CNT bundles have a uniform length of 8 μm and this length can be controlled by changing the time of CVD. The HRTEM image of the formed CNTs is shown in Fig. 3h.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 SEM images of the hierarchically isolated CNT bundles in hexagonal arrays developed from the cavities: (a) top view, (b) magnified image of (a) and (c) side view; (d) a TEM image of the patterned CNTs in Fig. 3a, the inset shows HRTEM view of one multi-walled CNT. SEM images of the hierarchically dense CNT bundles with a honeycomb structure perpendicular to the substrate, (e) top view, (f) magnified image of (e) and (g) side view; (h) a TEM image of the patterned CNTs. In Fig. 3e, the inset shows a HRTEM view of one multi-walled CNT. |
The pattern of CNT is determined by that of the Fe catalyst on the substrate, therefore, the formation of multi-level CNT arrays with adjustable patterns results from the different distribution of catalyst in the cross-linked hybrid film and ferrous inorganic micropatterns (a schematic illustration is shown in the ESI†). Ferrocene has strong intermolecular interaction with aromatic molecules and polar groups because of its molecular structure.15 The added ferrocene should disperse into the polymer matrix uniformly. However, the selective growth of isolated CNT bundles from the cavities is attributed to the selective interfacial aggregation of ferrocene on the walls of the cavities, resulting from the Pickering emulsion effect,16 a common phenomenon in which emulsion can be stabilized by solid particles adsorbing onto the interface. In a typical BF formation process, water droplets floating on the surface of the solution are arranged into highly ordered arrays. Hence it introduces patterned liquid/liquid phase interfaces which can be utilized to control the assembly and alignment of ferrocene particles. Before the polymer film becomes too viscous, the ferrocene particles aggregate at the interface and form a uniform layer. As the concentration of the polymer/ferrocene mixture increases with solvent evaporation, the polymer film undergoes glass transition and solidifies, fixing the droplets and the ferrocene particles. On evaporation of the water, spherical cavities remain with the walls decorated by the ferrocene particles.17 After crosslinking of the polymer film by ultraviolet irradiation, the ferrocene particles are either located on the walls of the cavities or embedded in the hybrid film. Upon H2 treatment, ferrocene particles exposed on the cavity walls are reduced and become activated to catalyze the growth of CNTs in the cavities. However, the ferrocene particles embedded in the hybrid film are isolated from H2 and acetylene gas (carbon source). As a result, we have been able to achieve the selective growth of CNTs in the cavities. The change of CNT arrays from isolated bundles to continuous CNT honeycomb structures is explained as follows. During pyrolysis, the polymer matrix is gradually decomposed and the cavity bottoms sink down onto the substrate, while a chemical reaction occurs between the Si wafer and ferrocene at high temperature.18 This results in a complete change in the chemical nature of the active ferrocene catalyst to stable compounds such as iron silicide (FeSi2) and iron silicate (Fe2SiO4), which are known for their noncatalytic activity for CNT growth.19 Although a 2-nm thick native oxide layer was examined to exist on the commercially available Si wafer (determined by ellipsometry in our lab), it cannot prevent Fe from diffusing through it and reacting with the Si substrate.20 On the other hand, the ferrocene particles embedded in the polymer matrix, especially on the hexagonal edges, are oxidized and exposed to the surface because most of the polymer composition has been burned off during pyrolysis. The close SEM view, as shown in Fig. 2h, indicates that the height difference between the edges and bottoms of the inorganic micropatterns is 50 nm, which is thick enough to isolate the ferrous micropatterns from the Si substrate. Although ferrocene is oxidized into Fe2O3, they still can be reduced 21 and effectively catalyze the growth of highly dense CNTs.
The beauty of this process is that a number of different patterns can be obtained simply by choosing different TEM grids, therefore it is easily scaled up to large area. To highlight these patterning technologies, we utilized TEM grids with different sizes and shapes to construct multi-level surface features (100 mesh, square pattern and 200 mesh, square pattern). The resultant multi-level CNT arrays with two level orders are displayed in Fig. 4.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 SEM images of two-level CNT arrays templating from the TEM grids with different mesh sizes and patterns: (a) 100 mesh TEM grid with square pattern; (b) magnification of (a), the inset shows the side view with higher magnification; (c) 200 mesh square TEM grid; (d) magnification of (c). The inset in (d) shows a single bundle of CNTs. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c1nr11191d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |