Douglas C.
Kirkpatrick
,
Christiana
Antwi
and
R. Scott
Martin
*
Saint Louis University, Department of Chemistry, 3501 Laclede Avenue, St Louis, MO 63103, USA. E-mail: martinrs@slu.edu; Fax: +1 314-977-2521; Tel: +1 314-977-2836
First published on 10th June 2010
This work demonstrates that recordable compact discs (CDs) that contain gold as a reflective layer can be used as an electrode substrate for microchip-based analysis systems. A fabrication procedure that enables the reproducible patterning of multiple electrodes has been developed. It is shown that the microelectrodes can be integrated within a PDMS-based fluidic network and used for amperometric detection of electroactive analytes at both single and dual microelectrodes. A detailed comparison is made between the CD-based patterned electrodes and electrodes made by the traditional method of sputtering gold and titanium adhesion layers onto a glass substrate. It is also shown that mercury can be electrodeposited onto a CD-based microelectrode and the amalgam electrode used to selectively detect thiols. Finally, it is demonstrated that a decoupler for microchip-based electrophoresis can be made by electrodepositing palladium onto a gold electrode and a separate downstream gold working electrode can be used for amperometric detection. These CD-based patterned electrodes are attractive alternatives for situations where device cost is of a concern or sputtering facilities are unavailable.
One possible way to produce more economical thin-layer planar electrodes for microchip-based analysis systems is through the use of recordable compact discs (CDs). These long-term storage devices have been reported to contain a 50–100 nm reflective gold layer on a polycarbonate substrate and are relatively inexpensive (∼$1 per CD). A gold layer is more resistant to oxidation, as compared to other common reflective materials such as aluminium, and is preferred for long-term archival storage. Fig. 1A demonstrates the different layers that are found in such CDs. By removing the protective coating and lacquer layers, the gold layer is exposed and can be used for electroanalytical purposes.19–24 Previous studies have defined the working electrode area either by dicing the CD19,22 or adding an insulating toner layer on top of the gold layer.20,21,23,24 The resulting electrodes have been used for static studies including cyclic voltammetry,19,20 potentiometric stripping,19,21 and self-assembly of monolayers.22 In addition, electrodes made with a toner-based method have been used with capillary23 and microchip electrophoresis24 in an end-column configuration, where the electrodes are aligned at the column/channel exit.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (A) Depiction of the layers in a recordable CD; (B) outline of the fabrication steps used to pattern CD-based gold electrodes for use in microchip-based analysis. |
The purpose of this paper is to investigate whether archival CDs can be used as an electrode substrate for microchip-based analysis systems. A fabrication procedure that enables the reproducible patterning of multiple electrodes has been developed and it is shown that the microelectrodes can be integrated within a PDMS-based fluidic network and used for amperometric detection of electroactive analytes at both single and dual microelectrodes. A detailed comparison is made between the CD-based patterned electrodes and electrodes made by the traditional method of sputtering gold/titanium onto glass substrates. It is also shown that mercury can be electrodeposited on the microelectrodes and the resulting Hg/Au amalgam electrodes used to detect thiols at low potentials. Finally, it is demonstrated that a decoupler for microchip-based electrophoresis can be made by electrodepositing palladium onto a gold electrode and a separate downstream gold working electrode can be used for amperometric detection. These CD-based patterned electrodes are attractive alternatives for situations where device cost is of a concern or sputtering facilities are unavailable.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (A) Picture of a typical patterned CD electrode plate; (B) picture of a PDMS-based flow channel reversibly sealed over a patterned CD electrode plate with the capillary being connected to an off-chip 4-port injection valve (not shown); (C) micrograph of patterned electrodes with the electrodes being 10 µm in width and separated by 100 µm. |
A glass electrode plate with sputtered adhesion (titanium) and gold layers was used for comparison studies and fabricated as previously described.10 The Nanofabrication Facility at Stanford University was responsible for sputtering a layer of titanium (200 Å) followed by gold (2000 Å) on high quality borosilicate glass. Upon receipt of the plates, electrodes were patterned in a similar fashion as described above by using a positive photoresist and UV exposure through a positive transparency. Following photoresist development, the un-protected gold was etched with aqua regia (at room temperature) followed by etching of the exposed titanium layer with Titanium Etchant (Transene Company Inc., Danvers, MA) at 85 °C. The remaining resist was then removed by an acetone rinse.
Masters used in the production of poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) microchannels were fabricated based on previously published methods.4,10,17 Raised microstructures of the desired dimensions were formed on a 4-inch silicon wafer using either SU-8 50 (for microchip-based electrophoresis channels) or SU-8 10 (for microchip-based electrophoresis) negative photoresist (MicroChem Corp., Newton, MA). Structure heights were measured using a surface profiler (Dektak3 ST, Veeco Instruments, Woddbury, NY), which corresponded to the channel depth of the desired PDMS structures. For experiments involving microchip-based flow analysis, the 2.6 cm (in length) PDMS flow channel had a cross-section of 100 (width) × 108 (height) µm and was made with a 20:1 mixture of Sylgard 184 elastomer base and curing agent. A hole punch was used to create a outlet reservoir, an inlet hole for fluid introduction was made with a 20 gauge luer stub adapter (Becton Dickinson and Co., Sparks, MD), and the microchip was reversibly sealed to the CD in a manner where the flow channel intersected the desired microelectrode (Fig. 2B). The effective electrode width is defined by the microchannel width (100 µm) and the electrode length was varied in this study. For experiments involving microchip-based electrophoresis, the PDMS flow channel had a cross-section 50 (width) × 27 (height) µm and was made with a 25:1 mixture of Sylgard 184 elastomer base and curing agent. The separation channel length (from intersection to the decoupler) was 1.4 cm and the side channel lengths were 0.7 cm. A hole punch was used to create buffer reservoirs. The effective electrode width is defined by the microchannel width (50 µm) and the electrode length was 500 µm.
A LabSmith HVS448 3000 V High Voltage Sequencer (LabSmith, Livermore, CA) was used as the voltage source for studies involving microchip-based electrophoresis. A gated injection sequence was utilized. The separation was performed by applying +400 V to the buffer reservoir and +300 V to the sample reservoir, with the sample waste and decoupler set at ground. An injection was accomplished by applying 0 V to the buffer reservoir for 0.5 s. Injection plug sizes were obtained using fluorescein and a fluorescence microscope (as previously described11) and were found to be 0.32 nL. Detection was achieved at +450 mV with a CH Instruments potentiostat (810B) in a 2-electrode format using a platinum counter electrode inserted into the buffer waste reservoir.
Several studies involved the use of electrodes modified with different metals via electrodeposition. All depositions were carried out with a CH Instruments potentiostat (810B) in a 3-electrode format with a Ag/AgCl reference and a platinum auxiliary electrode. The gold electrode of interest was amalgamated with Hg by suspending a 5.8 mM Hg2(NO3)2·2H2O salt solution containing 1.0 M KNO3 and 0.5% HNO3 over the electrode and applying a potential of −230 mV for 45 s. For the microchip electrophoresis studies, a palladium decoupler was created by electrodepositing Pd onto a gold electrode. This was done with a 1011 mg L−1 palladium(II) chloride solution that was 5% in HCl (Sigma Aldrich, St Louis, MO) and applying a deposition potential of −100 mV for 120 s.
As shown in Fig. 2, multiple electrodes of varying dimensions and spacings could be patterned with this procedure, with the size and spacings being defined by the lithographic mask. This ranged from dual 3 mm electrodes with a 1 mm spacing (Fig. 2A), a 3 mm electrode and 500 µm electrode with a 1 mm spacing (Fig. 2B), and a set (12) of 10 µm electrodes with a 100 µm spacing (Fig. 2C). Previous reports of CD-based electrodes have stated that the gold layer is between 50 and 100 nm in thickness. With the archival CDs tested here, the resulting patterned electrodes were measured (via a surface profiler) to also be in this range, with an average step height of 70 ± 23 nm (n = 8). PDMS-based fluidic channels could be reversibly sealed over these electrodes as demonstrated in Fig. 2B. A syringe pump was used to hydrodynamically introduce buffer into a 2.6 cm (in length) flow channel (108 × 100 µm cross-section) at flow rates varying from 1.0–5.0 µL min−1 (0.15–0.77 cm s−1) and no leakage was seen around the electrode/channel interface. Studies involving the deposition of metal layers onto glass substrates usually involve an adhesion layer (such as titanium) to improve the stability of the electrode upon exposure to a buffer solution.3,9–16 As shown in Fig. 1A, there is no such layer in these CDs. The sealed devices could be used without any signs of delamination under most of the experimental conditions described below; however, the electrodes did occasionally delaminate when the reversibly sealed PDMS layer was removed from the CD, with the gold layer coming up with the detached PDMS layer. The electrodes were stable for long periods of time as long as the device was not disassembled. Therefore, similar to irreversibly bonded glass devices, the final sealed device could not be routinely disassembled and re-used.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (A) Comparison of HDVs (200 µM catechol) obtained with a CD electrode plate and a traditional sputtered glass plate using microchip-based flow injection analysis; (B) comparison of calibration curves (analyte = catechol) obtained with 2 different CD electrode plates and a sputtered glass plate using microchip-based flow injection analysis (+450 mV vs. Pt counter electrode). For each comparison, electrode size = 3 mm × 100 µm, flow rate = 3.0 µL min−1, and the buffer = 10 mM phosphate (pH 7.0). |
The CD-patterned electrodes were further characterized by repeated injections of a catechol solution into a device where the effective electrode area was 100 µm (defined by the channel width) × 500 µm (length). As shown in Fig. 4A and 5 injections of this catechol solution led to an average response of 6.80 ± 0.45 nA. The same device was subsequently used to perform a limit of detection (LOD) study for catechol. The LOD (S/N = 3) was estimated from the injection of a 500 nM catechol solution and found to be 240 nM. It was also seen that multiple electrodes can be patterned and integrated with microchip-based flow analysis. The set of dual electrodes shown in Fig. 2A were used to monitor the chemically reversible redox couple of catechol by operating the upstream generator electrode at +450 mV and the downstream collector electrode at 0 mV. Repeated injections of a 200 µM catechol solution led to a collection efficiency (ratio of the cathodic and anodic currents) of 35.6%.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (A) 5 consecutive injections of a 200 µM catechol solution with detection at a 500 µm × 100 µm CD-based gold microelectrode (+450 mV vs. Pt counter electrode). (B) 3 consecutive injections of a 200 µM catechol solution followed by dual electrode detection at 3 mm × 100 µm electrodes (1 mm spacing). For each the flow rate = 3.0 µL min−1 and the buffer = 10 mM phosphate (pH 7.0). |
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Hydrodynamic voltammogram (200 µM cysteine) obtained with a CD-based Hg/Au amalgam electrode (250 × 100 µm in size) using microchip-based flow injection analysis. Inset shows 2 consecutive injections of the cysteine solution at the optimal potential of +100 mV (vs. Ag/AgCl reference). For these experiments, the flow rate = 3.0 µL min−1 and the buffer = 10 mM MES (pH 5.5). |
One popular method of integrating electrochemical detection with microchip electrophoresis involves the use of a palladium decoupler. This electrode is integrated within the fluidic network to provide an electrophoretic ground (cathode) and absorb hydrogen produced from the reduction of water.8,13,18,30 The decoupler provides a field-free region for downstream detection electrodes that can also be integrated within the fluidic network so that band broadening is minimized.13 In this work, two electrodes were patterned, a 3 mm Au electrode onto which palladium was electrodeposited11 as well as a 500 µm detection electrode (1 mm spacing between the two electrodes). A PDMS microchip with a 1.4 cm separation channel (Fig. 6A) was reversibly sealed over the electrodes, with the Pd/Au electrode being used as a decoupler. A gated injection scheme and 140 V cm−1 field strength were used to analyze a dopamine and catechol solution. As can be seen in Fig. 6B, a baseline resolution was achieved with an average of 74,740 plates per metre for dopamine. The response for each was also reproducible, with average peak heights being 0.51 nA for dopamine (1.4% RSD) and 0.28 nA for catechol (0.7% RSD). The Pd/Au decoupler effectively dissipated the hydrogen produced and was stable over the course of a day at this field strength; however, the use of a higher field strength (350 V cm−1) led to delamination of the decoupler from the CD surface after ∼30 min of operation. Since this field strength can be used with sputtered palladium electrodes that include an adhesion layer,13 the delamination is probably due to the absence of the adhesion layer. While a baseline resolution separation was achieved for this 2 component mixture, lengthened serpentine electrophoresis channels could be used to improve the resolution11 while maintaining a field strength where the CD-based decoupler is stable.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (A) Picture showing PDMS-based electrophoresis microchip sealed over the CD-electrode plate. Inset shows micrograph of electrophoresis channel and the detection electrode. (B) Electropherogram showing 3 consecutive injection, separation and detection events. Analytes = 200 µM dopamine (DA) and catechol (CAT). Decoupler = 3 mm, electrode size = 500 × 100 µm. Buffer = 25 mM boric acid with 1 mM SDS (pH = 9.2). Reservoir abbreviations: B = buffer; BW = buffer waste; S = sample; SW = sample waste. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |