Karolin K.
Kroening
a,
Morwena J. V.
Solivio
a,
Mónica
García-López
ab,
Alvaro
Puga
c and
Joseph A.
Caruso
a
aUniversity of Cincinnati/Agilent Technologies Metallomics Center of the Americas, Department of Chemistry, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH 45221-0172, USA. E-mail: joseph.caruso@uc.edu
bOn student study leave to the University of Cincinnati from the Department of Analytical Chemistry, Instituto de Investigación y Análisis Alimentario (IIAA), University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain
cDepartment of Environmental Health, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, 45221-0172, USA
First published on 18th November 2008
The arsenic metallome in African Green Monkey kidney cells is probed by measuring cytotoxicity, cellular arsenic uptake and speciation studies on arsenic-containing chemical warfare agent degradation products (CWDPs) during cell uptake. Inorganic arsenic compounds and methylated species also were studied during cell uptake as a means of providing cytotoxicity information relative to the CWDPs. The degradation products used were phenylarsine oxide (PAO), phenylarsonic acid (PAA), diphenylarsinic acid (DPAA), triphenylarsine (TPA) and triphenylarsine oxide (TPAO). These are the warfare agent’s primary degradation products. The parent warfare agents (red agents) are diphenylarsine chloride (DA or referred to as Clark I) and diphenylarsine cyanide (DC or Clark II), sternutator agents, sneezing gases able to cause bronchial irritation. Cytotoxicity levels and cellular uptake were compared to those of inorganic species: sodium arsenite, NaAsO2 [As(III)], sodium arsenateNa2HAsO4 [As(V)] and methylated arsenicals such as dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) and methylarsonic acid (MMA). The arsenic uptake was demonstrated in an African Green Monkey kidney cell line , CV-1. Quantification of lactate dehydrogenase activityreleased from damaged/dying cells was then measured via an LDH assay . The purpose of this study is to initially investigate toxicity to cells when exposed to different arsenic containing compounds over different concentrations and time ranges from 3 h to 24 h. Furthermore, exposed cells were then analyzed for different arsenic species by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry to isolate and speciate arsenic fractions followed by nanoLC electrospray ionization mass spectrometry to analyze the molecular level changes of the arsenic based degradation products in the kidney cells. Metabolic changes to the arsenic species were found, and interestingly, at the lowest uptake levels, cytotoxicities were generally higher for the chemical warfare agent degradation products than the inorganic arsenic species.
Chemical warfare agent degradation products (CWDPs) include diphenylarsinic acid (DPAA), phenylarsonic acid (PAA) and phenylarsine oxide (PAO). In the degradation pathway, byproducts such as triphenylarsine (TPA) and triphenylarsine oxide (TPAO) are found and their structures are shown in Fig. 1. Previous papers have mentioned that groundwater and soil have been contaminated from some of these organoarsenical compounds, leading to environmental problems.3,4 Oyama et al. reported as recently as 2007 the presence of degradation products DPAA, PAA and PAO in groundwater and soil in Kamisu City, Japan.5 With known population exposure, it is important to understand the biological uptake mechanism for these degradation products in mammalian organisms. Examples of other studied arsenic species include sodium arsenate, Na2HAsO4 [As(V)], sodium arsenite, NaAsO2 [As(III)], dimethylarsinic acid (DMA) and methylarsonic acid (MMA) as shown in Fig. 1 as well as parent agents Clark I and Clark II.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Structures of primary warfare agents, their degradation products and other arsenic species used in the cytotoxicity study. |
The aim of this work was to do an initial study investigating CWDPs cytotoxicity on mammalian cells by comparing the effects of different CWDP concentrations over different time periods. To generate metallomics information an As speciation study was performed utilizing liquid chromatography (LC) coupled to both inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICPMS) and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) to identify the molecular level changes the CWDPs might undergo.
The cytotoxicity evaluation was conducted on an African Green Monkey CV-1 cell line based on quantification of lactate dehydrogenase activity as released from damaged/dying cells. Kidney cells were chosen as target cells because kidneys take up and excrete a variety of substances produced by the cell metabolism. A comparison of different concentration levels over different time ranges was completed, following the toxic compounds addition to the cells. The cells treated with the various arsenic species were then tested for cellular arsenic uptake by ICPMS detection of the monoisotopic 75As.
The interest in arsenic speciation analyses continues to grow with the increasing need to assess its biological effects. Total arsenic analyses, though necessary, are insufficient to fully address the complexities and questions posed by biological systems. While As totals are useful, they provide no information on the various arsenic forms, which have widely varying toxicities. The inorganic species, which are commonly found in the environment, are known to be the most toxic species, while some of the organic arsenic forms are less toxic and even innocuous.6 Hence, speciation analysis is required and further identification and verification by molecular mass spectrometry as necessary.
Unlike many other cytoplasmic enzymes, which exist in many cells either in low or unstable amounts (e.g., alkaline and acid phosphatase), LDH is a stable cytoplasmic enzyme present in all cells and rapidly released into the cell culture supernatant upon plasma membrane damage. LDH activity can be determined by a coupled enzymatic reaction: LDH oxidizes lactate to pyruvate, which then reacts with tetrazolium salt INT to form formazan. The increase in the amount of formazan produced in culture supernatant directly correlates to the increase in the number of lysed cells. The formazandye is water soluble and can be detected spectrophotometrically at 492 nm.7
During these experiments the amount of FBS had to be lowered to 1% instead of 10% as recommended because of possible interference during the absorbance measurement. Target cells were seeded in a 96 well microtiter plate (5 × 103 cells/well) together with different concentrations of the above mentioned As compounds and tested on different incubation time frames.
Triton X-100, known to be highly toxic to the cells, was added for a high control to measure the correct cell death. The cell medium was used as low control to indicate the favorable environment for cell growth. These two controls were used for the calculation of cytotoxicity by subtracting the low control from the high control as background correction. A microtiter with blank control has been plated also and has been subtracted from the final values. The LDH assay required the following steps: addition of a mixture of lyophilized catalyst and thawed dye solution and no exposure to light for 30 min, centrifugation at 250 × g for 10 min, 2 times dilution with DDI water, and the LDH activity measured at 492 nm.
ICPMS parameters | |
---|---|
Instrument | Agilent 7500cx ICPMS |
Forward power | 1500 W (with shielded torch) |
Plasma gas flow rate | 14.6 L min−1 |
Auxiliary gas flow rate | 1.1 L min−1 |
Carrier gas flow rate | 0.93 L min−1 |
Nebulizer | Glass expansion micro-concentric |
Spray chamber | ≈2 °C (Scott double channel) |
Sampling depth | 7.5 mm |
Sampling and skimmer cones | Nickel |
Dwell time | 0.1 s |
Isotope monitored (m/z) | 75As |
Octopole reaction system | H2 (flow rate: 3.5 mL min−1) |
QP bias | −16 V |
Octopole | −18 V |
HPLC parameters | |
---|---|
Instrument | Agilent 1100 HPLC |
Flow rate | 1.0 mL min−1 |
Injection volume | 100 μL |
Buffer | 10 mM NH4COOH + 15% MeOH |
PH | 8.2 |
Column | Zorbax 300S-C3, (4.6 × 150 mm, 3.5 μm) |
ESI-MS parameters | |
---|---|
Instrument | MSD Ion Trap XCT Ultra system |
Flow rate | 18 μL h−1 |
Drying gas | N2, 4 L min−1 |
Temperature | 300 °C |
MS capillary voltage | 1800 V |
Skimmer | 25.0 V |
Capillary exit | 110.7 V |
Trap drive | 32.3 V |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) Image of CV-1 cells after 4 days of cultivation, showing evidence of about 80% confluency and the ability to detect for dead cells. (b) Cell confluency after 1 day of cultivation, indicating low proliferation, therefore very low confluency. |
The results indicate that treatment with CWDPs after 24 h of incubation resulted in higher cytotoxicity compared to the other arsenic species (Fig. 3a–i). Overall, PAO caused the most cell death. The cytotoxicity level of PAO at the highest concentration (500 μM) is 3.5 ± 0.3 times higher than DMA, 2.3 ± 0.1 times higher than the As(V) species and 1.7 ± 0.1 higher than As(III). Also TPA and TPAO, other products in the degradation pathway, show still higher toxicity levels compared to non CWDPs. It may be possible that species with phenyl groups more easily enter the cell membrane, but the relationship between chemical structure and passage through the mitochondrial membrane is not yet clear.8 As(III) shows higher toxicity when compared with As(V), but possibly lower toxicity relative to several CWDPs. Also it is generally known that As(III) forms of methylated species have genotoxicities similar to inorganic As(III), which may extend to additional organoarsenicals. It has been suggested that the difference between As(III) and As(V) is due to the faster uptake of As(III) by endothelial cells with inorganic arsenic exerting its toxicity, at least in part, viaintracellular oxidative stress.9 The experiment also showed that the higher the concentration of arsenic species added, the stronger the cell damage. Calculations for cytotoxicity were performed based on triplicate experiments and error bars at ±1 std dev. obtained for each experiment (as is generally accepted for these types of experiments).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (a–i) Cytotoxicity studies at different arsenic species concentrations (0.5, 5, 50, 500 μM) taken at 24 h exposure. Error bars represent ±1 std dev. |
Fig. 4 demonstrates cell damage/death after incubated exposure for 3, 12 and 24 h, respectively, to the arsenic compounds (concentration at 500 μM). Significant differences between different exposure times are noted. PAO, TPA and sodium arsenite have strong cytotoxicity after 3 h and the prolonged exposure to arsenic does not significantly increase cell death when compared to the pentavalent species. The relative PAO toxicity on target cells grows only 8.5% from 3 to 24 h of exposure, while toxicity increases 24% for DMA and 32% for MMA.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Toxicity effects on target cells after 3, 12 and 24 h based on different As species with 500 μM added in each experiment performed in triplicate with ±1 std dev. shown as the error. |
Tsuchiya et al. conducted experiments on the metabolism of arsenic species, providing evidence that pentavalent inorganic arsenic is metabolized to the trivalent form, which is then methylated. Therefore, the most active arsenic compound is trivalent inorganic arsenite, followed by the pentavalent inorganic arsenate.10 This explanation might be applied to the CWDPs’ trivalent arsenic compounds also, but further investigation is required, since very little information about metabolic interactions and toxicity is known about chemical warfare degradation compounds.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Cellular arsenic uptake results based on a 500 μM addition, after 24 h exposure to varying As species. Cellular As uptake percentage refers to the amount of As present in 1 mg of cell pellet. Error bars indicate ±1 std deviation. |
For each compound a standard LC separation was run with As species standards, media and cells. The culture medium was treated with the same amount of As species at the same conditions as for the target cells, i.e. after 24 h As species exposure to 500 μM solution in an incubator.
Fig. 6a shows HPLC-ICPMS detection, demonstrating that DPAA was not present in its original form after metabolism, but it is still present in the medium, indicating the species changes occur during cell metabolism. An unknown low intensity peak at 160 s, when compared to the peak from DPAA in the medium, is due to the lower arsenic uptake and possible sample loss during cell lysis.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) LC-ICPMS for speciation analysis with DPAA standard, spiked medium, and target cells showing complete loss of DPAA to PAA as determined by spike addition. (b) ESI mass spectrum obtained for the collected peak in Fig. 6a. |
Identification of the unknown LC-ICPMS peak with nanoLC-CHIP-ITMS (+ ion mode) and spiked LC-ICPMS analysis demonstrates the complete chemical transformation of DPAA to PAA after cell interaction (Fig. 6b). Evidence is shown for the molecular ion, [PAA+H]+ at m/z = 203.1. The mass spectrum represents the fraction collected for the unknown peak in Fig. 6b. There is no evidence of this conversion in the medium. It is interesting to note in Fig. 6a how the [DPAA+H]+ peak, expected at m/z = 262.9, is absent. In the cell medium the mass spectrum, performed under the same conditions, stands out with a relative abundance of 5 × 107 and no PAA mass peak is shown. LC-ICPMS with standard spike confirmed this observation. The outstanding peak at m/z 242.3, which also is present in the cell blank, requires further investigation by exact mass identification, currently underway. ESI-MS2 data of this unidentified compound show characteristic peaks at m/z = 279.0 and 372.9. T. Nakayama et al.11 have suggested possible conversions involving phenylarsonic acid–diglutathione complex, PAA-(GSH)2 and fragments of this might offer possibilities. Also no sulfur or phosphorous were detectable in the fraction taken from ICPMS for ITMS experiments. Further mass spectrometry is required for the identification of the 242.3 m/z peak.
Fig. 7a demonstrates that PAO metabolizes also to PAA, with a higher intensity yield. The ESI experiment (Fig. 7b) and LC-ICPMS std spike analysis confirms the presence of this As species. The peak at m/z = 203.1 shows the presence of PAA. The main peak of m/z = 169.1 [PAO+H],+ due to PAO is completely absent. Peaks at m/z = 185.3 are due to water loss [PAA-H2O]+. Also an outstanding peak of m/z = 242.3 is present and not yet identified.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 (a) LC-ICPMS for speciation analysis with PAO standard, spiked medium and target cells. (b) ESI-MS mass spectrum obtained for the collected peak in Fig. 7a. |
The fact that both arsenic containing CWDP compounds, DPAA and PAO, transform to PAA matches with their degradation pathways as reported by Oyama.5
TPA and TPAO, byproducts of the CWDPs degradation pathway, the two inorganic species As(III) and As(V), as well as the methylated species DMA and MMA gave poor intensity in the LC-ICPMS separation. The As uptake by the cells was sufficient for total analysis, but too low for speciation. Minimal sample is due to the logistics in preparing larger sample amounts. However, this has been resolved and larger sample quantities are being prepared.
The study also indicates possible metabolic changes CWDPs might undergo after interaction with the African Green Monkey kidney CV-1 cells. Two degradation products, DPAA and PAO generate PAA in their degradation pathway and confirm that the metallomic approach of multiple mass spectrometries is highly viable.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2009 |