A. Robert
Armstrong
and
Peter G.
Bruce
*
School of Chemistry, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Fife, , Scotland, UK KY16 9ST. E-mail: pgb1@st-and.ac.uk
First published on 29th November 2004
Layered LixMn1−yLiyO2 materials with the O3 (α-NaFeO2) structure have been synthesised by a low temperature ion exchange route from the corresponding sodium compounds. The effects on electrochemical performance (ability to store reversibly large quantities of lithium and hence charge) and crystal chemistry by partially substituting some of the Mn ions by Li have been investigated by structural and electrochemical techniques as well as chemical analysis. The materials deliver high discharge capacities; in excess of 200 mA h g−1 at 25 mA g−1 or C/8. On the first charge once all Mn is in the 4+ oxidation state further Li+ removal occurs by two unconventional mechanisms, one involving oxidation of O2− with subsequent O loss (effective removal of Li2O) and the other electrolyte oxidation generating H+ which exchanges for Li+ in the electrode. Although both mechanisms appear to occur at 30 and 55 °C, the former dominates at both temperatures. A mechanism for O loss involving O release at the surface with Mn migration into the bulk in order to fill up vacant octahedral sites in the transition metal layers is proposed, consistent with the neutron diffraction data. Evidence for tetrahedral Li and Li loss from the octahedral sites in the transition metal layers is also presented. The compounds in this study irreversibly transform to spinel-like materials on extended cycling. This is not, however, detrimental to their electrochemical performance and is analogous to the behaviour of other O3 layered lithium manganese oxides.
We have reported the synthesis of LixMn1−yLiyO2 materials (0 ≤ y ≤ 0.2) by an analogous ion exchange route.19 These compounds exhibit unconventional lithium extraction on the first charge beyond the point at which all the Mn is in the +4 oxidation state. There are two mechanisms involved in this unconventional removal of Li; these are the loss of oxygen (effective removal of Li2O) as proposed by Dahn et al. for Li(Mn,Ni,Li)O2 and Thackeray et al. for acid leaching of Li2MnO3,20–23 and proton exchange for Li+, in which the protons are generated by the oxidation of the non-aqueous electrolyte.24,25 The interplay between these mechanisms is subtly dependent on the conditions, particularly temperature. In our earlier work we focused on the synthesis and the electrochemical behaviour on the first charge; here we discuss the electrochemical performance of such LixMn1−yLiyO2 materials on extended cycling and show that it compares favourably with other singly-doped LixMn1−yMyO2 systems but with the advantage of containing manganese as the only transition metal ion. We also present further information on the structural changes occurring on the first cycle for these compounds.
Chemical analyses for sodium and lithium were carried out by flame emission and for manganese using atomic absorption spectroscopy. The average manganese oxidation state was determined by redox titration using ferrous ammonium sulfate/KMnO4. Further information on the manganese oxidation state was obtained from XPS measurements on as-prepared and charged LixMn1−yLiyO2 composite electrodes. Binding energies were charge corrected using the C 1s peak (284.4 eV).
Powder X-ray diffraction data were collected on a Stoe STADI/P diffractometer operating in transmission mode with Fe Kα1 radiation (λ = 1.936 Å) to eliminate manganese fluorescence.
The structures of the materials were further characterised using neutron diffraction. Time-of-flight powder neutron diffraction data were collected on the Polaris and GEM high intensity, medium-resolution instruments at ISIS, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory. Since lithium, and to a lesser extent manganese, are neutron absorbers, the data were corrected for absorption. The structures were refined by the Rietveld method using the program Prodd based on the Cambridge Crystallographic Subroutine Library (CCSL).26,27 Neutron scattering lengths of −0.19, −0.373, and 0.5803 (all 10−12 cm) were assigned to Li, Mn, and O respectively.28 Powder neutron diffraction experiments were also carried out on electrochemically charged samples on the GEM diffractometer. The samples were contained in 2 mm quartz capillaries.
In order to evaluate the performance of the layered materials, composite electrodes were constructed by mixing the active material, Kynar Flex 2801 (a copolymer based on PVDF) and carbon, in the weight ratios 85 : 5 : 10. The mixture was prepared as a slurry in THF and spread onto aluminium foil using a Doctor Blade technique. Following evaporation of the solvent and drying, electrodes were incorporated into an electrochemical cell in which the second electrode was formed from lithium metal and the electrolyte was a 1 molal solution of LiPF6 (Hashimoto) in ethylene carbonate–diethylene carbonate (V/V 1 : 2 (Merck)). Electrochemical measurements were carried out using a Biologic MacPile II. We define C-rate here as 1C being equal to a cell discharging in 1 h. The C-rate may be calculated for any cell at any cycle number by dividing the rate (in mA g−1) by the capacity (in mA h g−1) e.g. if the rate is 50 mA g−1 and the capacity of the cathode is 200 mA h g−1 then the C-rate is C/4.
Combined thermogravimetric analysis–mass spectrometry (TGA-MS) measurements were performed using a Netzsch STA449 Jupiter instrument coupled with a Pfeiffer Vacuum Thermostar GSD300T. The TGA heating rate was 5 °C min−1 up to 400 °C under an argon atmosphere.
Li doping level (y) | Mn valence | Formula |
---|---|---|
0.0 | 3.55 | (Li0.59Na0.069)[Mn0.94]O2 |
0.025 | 3.61 | (Li0.61Na0.047)[Mn0.92Li0.025]O2 |
0.05 | 3.64 | (Li0.60Na0.041)[Mn0.91Li0.05]O2 |
0.10 | 3.70 | (Li0.61Na0.032)[Mn0.88Li0.1]O2 |
0.20 | 3.83 | (Li0.66Na0.015)[Mn0.82Li0.18]O2 |
Let us now consider the structures of the doped LixMn1−yLiyO2 phases in more detail; fitted neutron diffraction patterns for the compositions y
= 0.05 and 0.20 are shown in Fig. 1. Similar quality fits were obtained for the other compositions. In each case the structure was refined using a rhombohedral layered model in space group Rm, as has been reported previously for LixMnyO2 and its derivatives.9–14 The structure is essentially that of layered LiCoO2 with oxygen atoms occupying the 6c sites, [Mn, Li and vacancies] the 3a sites and (Li, residual Na and vacancies) the 3b sites of space group R
m. In the refinements the sodium contents of the 3b sites were fixed at the values obtained from chemical analysis (Table 1). The Mn occupancies of the 3a sites were also fixed at the values obtained from the compositional analysis, whilst the Li occupancy was allowed to vary. The occupancy of the oxygen site was fixed at unity. Crystallographic parameters for y
= 0.2 are shown in Table 2. Excellent agreement was obtained between observed and calculated patterns as can be seen from Fig. 1 and the very good weighted profile R-factors quoted in Table 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Fits to neutron powder diffraction data for Lix[Mn1−yLiy]O2 phases; (a) y = 0.05; (b) y = 0.20. |
Atom | Wyckoff symbol | x/a | y/b | z/c | B 11 = B22 (Biso) | B 33 | B 12 | Site occupancy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Li/Na | 3b | 0 | 0 | 0.5 | 1.02(7) | — | — | 0.73(2)/0.015 |
Mn/Li | 3a | 0 | 0 | 0.0 | 0.41(3) | 0.79(5) | 0.20(2) | 0.82/0.18(2) |
O | 6c | 0 | 0 | 0.26051 (6) | 0.83(2) | 0.82(2) | 0.42(1) | 1 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Discharge capacity as a function of cycle number for Lix[Mn1−yLiy]O2 at 30 °C. Rate = 25 mA g−1 (approximately C/8). Voltage limits = 2.5–4.6 V. |
The effect of elevated temperatures on cycling stability is important for any potential electrode material and is particularly significant for Mn-rich electrodes because it is known that deleterious reactions occur with LiPF6-based non-aqueous electrolytes resulting in Mn dissolution and increased capacity fade.29,30Fig. 3 shows cycling data at 55 °C for y = 0.1 at high (1C) rates. The data show reasonable stability at 55 °C for over 200 cycles, such that the loss in capacity is only about 0.11% or 0.21 mA h g−1 per cycle. It should be pointed out, however, that at these high rates cycling is completed quickly (in this case 1 h per cycle) and inferior stability may be expected at lower rates due to Mn dissolution. Surface modification by, for example, coating the particles would doubtless improve further the capacity retention at elevated temperature, as would an electrolyte not based on LiPF6.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Discharge capacity as a function of cycle number for LixMn0.9Li0.1O2 at 55 °C. Rate = 200 mA g−1 (approximately 1C). Voltage limits = 2.5–4.6 V. |
We have investigated the cycling performance at a variety of charge–discharge rates, i.e. the ability to intercalate substantial quantities of lithium reversibly at different rates. Although LiCoO2 has a relatively low capacity (130 mA h g−1) it has good rate capability due to a high lithium diffusion coefficient and fast kinetics for transformation between the different ordered phases encountered as a function of Li content. Fig. 4 illustrates the rate capability at 30 °C of a typical Li-doped material, in this case y = 0.05. Increasing the rate by a factor of eight results in a loss in capacity of around 50% initially but dropping to only 10% after 50 cycles, such that a capacity of 175 mA h g−1 is delivered at the 1C rate. This value is almost 40% higher than LiCoO2. The initial rise is associated with transformation of the layered structure to that of spinel (discussed below). Although this is relatively facile, sufficiently so to have little effect on the capacity at low (C/8) rate, it clearly does become a factor at these higher rates.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Discharge capacity as a function of cycle number for LixMn0.95Li0.05O2 at various charge–discharge rates of 25–200 mA g−1. Voltage limits = 2.5–4.6 V. |
Layered O3 lithium manganese oxide materials have been shown to convert irreversibly to spinel-like materials upon cycling with concomitant formation of a nanometre-scale nanostructure.7,10,15,31 This nanostructure contains a mosaic or nanodomain structure within micron-sized particles of largely the same dimensions as the parent compound. Unlike lithium manganese oxide spinels prepared by conventional solid state reaction at high temperatures, the layered materials continue to show excellent reversibility when cycled over both the 3 and 4 V plateaux. This necessitates overcoming lattice strain caused by a co-operative Jahn–Teller distortion, which occurs when approximately 50% of the octahedral transition metal sites are occupied by Mn3+. In spinel this induces a first order phase transformation from cubic to tetragonal symmetry, with an anisotropic volume change. In the case of the nanostructured spinels derived from layered compounds, it is believed that slippage at the defect-rich domain wall boundaries of the nanostructure accommodate the strain caused by the transformation between the undistorted and distorted phases and allow far more facile phase transitions with consequently much higher cycling stability.
All of the Li doped samples convert to spinel-like materials upon cycling. Fig. 5 shows the incremental capacity plots for the y = 0.2 material. Double 4 V peaks, characteristic of spinel, are evident after 50 cycles. This result is consistent with previous observations for non-stoichiometric LixMnyO2 layered materials prepared by ion exchange in ethanol at 80 °C.9–11,14,15 The rate of conversion to spinel is dependent on the number of transition metal vacancies/residual sodium ions and the ratio of c/a lattice parameters. Fewer vacancies/less sodium and a lattice parameter ratio closer to 4.9 cause the conversion to spinel to be more rapid. Other factors that affect the rate of conversion to spinel are the cycling rate and temperature. Higher temperatures and lower charge–discharge rates cause the conversion to occur at lower cycle numbers.15
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Incremental capacity plots for LixMn0.8Li0.2O2 as a function of cycle number. Cycling was carried out at 25 mA g−1 (approximately C/8). Voltage limits = 2.5–4.6 V. (b) Variation of potential (vs. Li+[1M]/Li) on charging then discharging the Lix[Mn1−yLiy]O2 electrodes at 25 mA g−1 (C/8) and 30 °C. |
Powder neutron diffraction studies for samples halted at various states of charge on the first cycle have been performed for y = 0.2. Rietveld refinement of data obtained from a sample charged to the start of the 4.5 V plateau (i.e. prior to any O loss or H+ exchange) gave an excellent fit to a single phase adopting the O3 structure (Fig. 6a) with lattice parameters a = 2.850(1) Å, c = 14.446(2) Å. This is consistent with the proposed conventional oxidation of Mn3+ to Mn4+. Grey et al. have recently reported a combined NMR/theoretical study on the system Li[Li(1−2x)/3Mn(2−x)/3Nix]O2 which also exhibits a 4.5 V plateau.35 Here it was observed that Li removal from the transition metal sites occurs before the start of the plateau via tetrahedral sites in the lithium layers and is a reversible process. Extended cycling was found to induce disorder, presumably due to migration of the transition metal ions. We have observed similar tetrahedral site occupancy on charging layered LiMnO2.16 Accordingly, further refinements were conducted incorporating such a tetrahedral Li site. This yielded some Li occupancy for this site and depletion of Li from the transition metal layers, albeit with only a slight improvement in the fit. Refined parameters are shown in Table 3. We do not rule out the possibility of some Mn migration to tetrahedral sites as well, but decoupling Mn from Li is beyond the capability of the neutron data.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Profile fits for Rietveld refinement of LixMn0.8Li0.2O2. (a) Charged to 4.5 V at 30 °C (single O3 phase model), (b) charged to 4.8 V at 30 °C, model incorporating two O3 phases, (c) charged to 4.8 V then discharged to 3.3 V at 30 °C, model incorporating two O3 phases. Dots indicate observed data, solid line calculated profile. The lower box shows difference/esd. |
Atom | Wyckoff symbol | x/a | y/b | z/c | B iso | Site occupancy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Li/Na | 3b | 0 | 0 | 0.5 | 0.6(4) | 0.54(4)/0.015 |
Mn/Li | 3a | 0 | 0 | 0.0 | 0.55(14) | 0.82/0.05(3) |
Li | 6c | 0 | 0 | 0.118(5) | 0.5 | 0.09(2) |
O | 6c | 0 | 0 | 0.2622 (2) | 0.64(5) | 1 |
A sample charged to 4.8 V (end of charge) gave data which could not be fitted to a single phase model. Instead a model involving two O3 phases (Fig. 6b) having lattice parameters corresponding to: (1) similar to those obtained at 4.5 V and (2) a phase with similar a parameter (2.852(2) Å) and longer c parameter (14.646(6) Å), gave an excellent fit. The observed similarity in a parameters is to be expected since this has a strong correlation with Mn oxidation state (+4 in both cases). From our previous diffraction studies of a wide range of doped and undoped layered lithium manganese oxides, both as-prepared and after electrochemical cycling, the elongated c parameter in phase 2 points to a material of the form LixMnyO2, where y ∼ 1.9–11,16 Such a material is exactly what would be expected to result from loss of Li2O. The pattern obtained after subsequent discharge to 3.3 V again is best fitted using two phases (Fig. 6c) suggesting that complete removal of Li from the Mn layers does not occur on the first charge or is partly reversible. This is supported by the incremental capacity plots (Fig. 5) which continue to show the 4.5 V process on extended cycling.
Combining the first charge load curves and the structure refinements we can propose the following processes on first charge. The charge curve below 4.5 V shows some structure (see for example the y = 0.1 composition in Fig. 5b) suggesting that this is not a single process. It is likely that Li is first removed from the alkali metal layers, the creation of octahedral lithium vacancies in the 3b sites enables lithium (and possibly Mn) to migrate from the 3a sites within the Mn layer to tetrahedral 6c sites. This may be associated with the inflection in the charging curve at ∼4 V, most evident in the y = 0.1 and y = 0.2 data (Fig. 5b). On further charging the considerable vacancy content is eliminated by loss of Li2O from the surface of the particles along with Mn migration from the surface to the bulk to fill vacant sites. This is consistent with the formation of a 2nd phase in which the Mn content of the transition metal layers approaches more closely to 1, as observed in our neutron data of a highly charged sample. Examination of the load curves (Fig. 5b) reveals that on the first discharge there is a Li insertion process occurring close to 4 V for y = 0.025 and 0.05. This suggests that for these compositions the lower vacancy concentration stabilises the structure in the charged state, and enables the tetrahedral (4V) sites to be repopulated on Li insertion.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 (a) Discharge capacity as a function of cycle number for Lix[Mn1−yLiy]O2 at 30 °C. Rate = 25 mA g−1. Voltage limits = 2.5–4.3 V. (b) Incremental capacity plots for LixMn0.9Li0.1O2 as a function of cycle number. Cycling was carried out at 25 mA g−1, voltage limits 2.5–4.3 V. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2005 |