Kira A.
Samoilova
*,
Olga N.
Bogacheva
,
Ksenya D.
Obolenskaya
,
Miralda I.
Blinova
,
Natalya V.
Kalmykova
and
Elena V.
Kuzminikh
Institute of Cytology, Russian Academy of Sciences, 4 Tikhoretsky Ave., Saint Petersburg, 194064, Russia. E-mail: kirasam@mail.cytspb.rssi.ru; samoilova3@yandex.ru; Fax: 007-(812)-247-03-41; Tel: 007-(812)-247-23-67
First published on 1st September 2003
The systemic mechanisms of the wound healing effect of low intensity lasers remain largely uninvestigated. The goal of this randomized, placebo controlled, double blind study is to prove that irradiation of a small area of the human body with visible and infrared polarized (VIP) light (400–3400 nm, 95% polarization, 40 mW cm2, 12 J cm2) leads to an increase of the growth promoting (GP) activity of the entire circulating blood for primary cultures of human keratinocytes (KCs).
Thirty minutes after the VIP-irradiation of a sacral area of volunteers, the GP activity of circulating blood was seen to increase through the elevation of the number of KCs cultured with the isolated plasma by 20 ± 3%, p < 0.001. A similar increase in GP activity was seen in plasma derived from the in vitro irradiated blood of each volunteer, and from the mixture of irradiated and non-irradiated autologous blood (1 ∶ 10). Enhanced GP activity was also recorded at 24 h after the 1st and 4–9th daily phototherapeutic sessions. Hence, exposure of volunteers to VIP light leads to a fast increase in the GP activity of the entire circulating blood for human KCs in vitro, which is a consequence of the transcutaneous photomodification of blood and its effect on the rest of the circulating blood volume.
For the last few years, studies at the authors' laboratory have been concentrating on the experimental substantiation of the role of transcutaneous blood photomodification in the development of systemic effects produced by certain phototherapeutic modalities. We have put forward a hypothesis based on the fact that visible and IR light that penetrates into the skin to a depth of up to several millimeters4 and reaches the dense superficial network of microvessels is able to affect the blood. Taking into account the comparatively low rate of blood flow in capillaries, in addition to the extravascular movement of blood components between terminal arterioles and venules in non-wounded skin and in open wounds, we suggest that the systemic consequences of the light-induced modification of blood in cutaneous microvessels may be of high clinical significance.10 One of the arguments in favor of the actual photomodification of blood is seen in the phototherapy of neonatal jaundice by which exposure of newborn babies to visible blue light converts plasma bilirubin from its toxic to its non-toxic form.11 In addition, it is recognized that factors necessary for the wound healing processes, (cytokines, chemokines, growth factors, etc.) are not only transported by the blood, but are also produced by blood cells. Accelerated release of these mediators seems to be one of the mechanisms responsible for enhanced repair and/or regeneration of damaged tissues, and for stimulation of hemogenesis and immunogenesis after extracorporeal photomodification of a small amount of a patient's blood, or after an intravascular irradiation of blood with visible laser light.12,13
It is generally excepted that coherency, monochromaticity and polarization are “key” laser properties responsible for its biomodulation.4 Meanwhile, there are some studies in the literature that suggest that laser coherency and monochromaticity play a less important role in photobiomodulation,14,15 than polarization of light14,16,17 and that the combination of visible and IR radiations produces a better effect than using either visible light or IR in isolation.1,9,18 These findings have stimulated the development of a new generation of phototherapeutic systems delivering a powerful polychromatic beam of polarized visible + IR light. According to reports in the literature, this light has pronounced anti-inflammatory, immunomodulatory, wound healing and analgesic effects.1,9,10,14,16,18,19
The goals of the present study were two-fold: (1) to study effects of single and multiple (treatment course) VIP-irradiations of healthy volunteers on the ability of the blood plasma to stimulate proliferation of human keratinocytes in vitro; and (2) to find out to what degree this effect might be associated with transcutaneous blood photomodification.
After 1 day of cultivation, this medium was replaced with fresh medium. However, instead of the FC serum (10%), plasma of volunteers' blood (2.5%) was added. It was withdrawn prior to the light exposure (control cultures), at certain periods of time after exposure to light of volunteers or of their blood samples (experimental cultures). To test the blood of the volunteers' group placebo, added to the medium was plasma isolated from the blood prior to the start of trials and after hemoexfusions at the same time periods as at the testing of the blood plasma of irradiated subjects. To evaluate the initial level of the blood GP activity of each individual, the cells were cultured in parallel in the standard medium, i.e. in the presence of 10% FC serum.
Each assay was carried out in triplicate. The visual control of cell growth was performed daily under an inverted microscope.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Stimulation of human keratinocyte proliferation by soluble factors of volunteers' blood irradiated with polychromatic visible + infrared polarized (VIP) light in vivo (transcutaneously) and in vitro. Primary cultures of keratinocytes were cultured in presence of 2.5% of human plasma (instead of 10% of fetal calf serum) separated from different samples of volunteers' blood: (A) Withdrawn at 0.5 and 24 h after the 1st irradiation of volunteers, accompanied with 2–3 fold exfusions of blood for studies (to a total of 25 and 30 ml, respectively); withdrawn on the 5th and 10th day (at 24 h after four and nine daily irradiations of volunteers and 4–5-fold exfusions of blood, to a total of 35 and 40 ml, respectively). (B) Withdrawn at 0.5 and 24 h after the 1st sham-irradiation of volunteers of the placebo group, accompanied with 2–3-fold exfusions of blood for studies (to a total of 25 and 30 ml, respectively); withdrawn on the 5th day at 24 h after four daily sham-irradiations of volunteers accompanied with 4-fold exfusions of blood for studies (to a total of 35 ml). (C) At 0.5 h after irradiation of blood in vitro and mixing the irradiated and non-irradiated autologous blood, at a volume ratio of 1 ∶ 10. This in vitro procedure models events in the blood circulation in vivo when a small amount of transcutaneously photomodified blood contacts the much greater volume of circulating blood. Whereas a significant stimulation of keratinocyte proliferation occurs if they are cultured in presence of blood plasma irradiated in vivo and in vitro, a pronounced inhibition effect is recorded if keratinocytes are grown in presence of sham-irradiated volunteers' plasma. Control: withdrawn before the trials; Single asterisk indicates P < 0.05; double asterisks indicate P < 0.01 and triple asterisks indicate P < 0.001. |
Analysis of the obtained results revealed a clearly seen inverse dependence of the fast changes of the blood plasma GP activity on its parameters prior to irradiation: the correlation coefficient r was −0.60, p < 0.01. In all volunteers with initially decreased blood GP activity, plasma GP potential rose, whereas in subjects with initially high parameters, it remained steady or decreased. We subdivided all individuals into two subgroups: those with initially low and initially high parameters (below and above the median) and found that in all subjects with an initially low blood GP activity, it increased, on average, by 20 ± 3% after 0.5 h and by 11 ± 3% after 24 h post-irradiation. On the other hand, in volunteers with an initially high blood activity, it did not change statistically significantly at 0.5 h, but it rose by 18 ± 7% in 24 h (Fig. 2). It is to be noted that at 24 h after the single and repeated phototherapeutic sessions, no dependence on the initial blood GP potential was revealed (the r values varied from 0.01 up to 0.27). In the placebo group, this dependence was not detected at any of the time periods tested.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Stimulation of human keratinocyte proliferation by soluble factors of volunteers' blood withdrawn at 0.5 and 24 h after irradiation of blood with VIP light in vivo (transcutaneously): dependence of stimulatory effect on the initial growth promoting (GP) activity of blood. Primary cultures of keratinocytes were cultured in presence of 2.5% of human blood plasma of 25 volunteers. The initial (before the trials) GP activity of plasma (capacity to support cells proliferation in vitro) varied in individuals by a factor of 3.5, which determined different characteristics and values of light effects. Therefore all volunteers were subdivided into two subgroups: with low and high initial parameters (below and above the median). Exposure of volunteers to VIP light resulted to rapid enhancement of the GP activity of plasma only in subjects with initially low GP activity values. Control: the GP plasma activity before the trials. Single asterisk indicates P < 0.05; double asterisks indicate P < 0.001. |
Values of the correlation coefficient r | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st irradiation | 4th irradiation | 9th irradiation | |||
Effects compared | 0.5 h PI | 24 h PI | 24 h PI | 24 h PI | |
a Statistically significant r values, p < 0.01. | |||||
A | in vitro (1 ∶ 10) | 0.49 a | – | – | – |
B | in vivo and in vitro | 0.53 a | 0.20 | 0.27 | 0.49 |
in vivo (1 ∶ 10) | 0.71 a | 0.15 | 0.08 | 0.45 |
The next stage was to investigate if a small amount of the transcutaneously photomodified blood under in vivo conditions could lead to changes in its entire circulating volume. To model the in vivo situation, when a small volume of transcutaneously photomodified blood contacts a much greater volume of the non-irradiated blood in the circulation, we mixed in vitro irradiated and non-irradiated samples of autologous blood at a volume ratio of 1 ∶ 10. Testing the plasma isolated from this mixture showed that not only did the GP activity fail to decrease, but it was even higher than that in the samples directly irradiated with light (Fig. 1). An increased level of the blood GP potential was recorded in 72% of cases and exceeded its initial level by 20% on average. Correlation analysis revealed a similarity with the effects induced by direct irradiation of blood in vitro and by addition of the photomodified to the intact samples, with a coefficient r of 0.49, p < 0.01. These data show that, instead of a decrease of blood GP potential due to the dilution of the irradiated blood, there occurred a translation of light-induced changes from the photomodified blood to a ten-fold volume of intact blood. This mechanism appears to be responsible for the fast rise of the GP properties of the entire circulating blood of VIP-irradiated volunteers, as changes of this parameter correlate with those in experiments involving mixing samples of the autologous blood, with r = 0.71, p < 0.01 (Table 1). In addition, like the fast changes in the GP properties of transcutaneously irradiated blood, photomodulation effects under in vitro conditions also correlated inversely with the initial parameters (r = −0.56 and −0.60), whereas at 24 h after the 1st, 4th and 9th irradiations of volunteers, any similarity in the changes to GP properties between in vitro and in vivo conditions disappeared (Table 1).
The statistically significant correlation of the rapid changes in GP activity in all volunteers after blood irradiation in vivo and in vitro, on one hand, and after irradiation in vivo and mixing the irradiated and non-irradiated blood samples, on the other hand, points to a connection of the rise of the blood GP activity under in vivo conditions with transcutaneous blood photomodification, and suggests an rapid “translation” of the photobiomodulated changes from the irradiated blood to the entire blood circulating pool. An indirect argument in favor of this mechanism is the fact that, following phototreatment of the volunteers' body surface, the in vitro irradiation of blood, and mixing irradiated and non-irradiated blood samples, the character and value of changes of the blood GP activity depended inversely on the initial level of this activity of the subjects' blood. The disappearance of any correlation of changes of the blood GP activity at 24 h after the irradiation of volunteers with changes following direct blood photomodification and mixing the irradiated and non-irradiated samples, as well as the disappearance at these time periods of dependence of the circulating blood changes on the initial growth potential, strongly suggests that at 24 h after the phototherapeutic procedure, the increased blood GP activity is rather due to involvement of changes of other tissues, for example skin components, than due to direct effects of blood photomodification.
Although all factors necessary for cell proliferation circulate in blood, the amounts and levels of activity, for whatever reason, can be higher or lower than the optimal values. It seems that blood photomodification is accompanied either by a fast increase in the pool of growth factors and chemoattractants or by neutralization of inhibitors of proliferation. In our earlier studies, when we were investigating the mechanisms of wound healing effects following extracorporeal blood UV irradiation with subsequent blood retransfusion, we showed a fast increase in the growth potentials of photomodified blood plasma for primary cultures of human embryonal fibroblasts, bone marrow cells, lymphocytes as well as for murine thymocytes.24,25 The elevation of plasma mitogenic activity in these experiments was due to effect of light on platelets and mononuclear cells, and to the release of some proteins from these cells. These results agree with the data showing that the source of growth factors for human fibroblasts of the line 3T3 was a conditioned medium obtained from macrophages irradiated with polychromatic or monochromatic visible and IR polarized light.17
In human blood, a possible source of growth factors regulating keratinocyte proliferation might be platelets, which have been shown at activation and blood coagulation to release EGF in the form of several fractions of different molecular weights (the ratio is determined by peculiarities of inductor); however, only intermediate and low molecular fractions are able to be bound to EGF receptors.26,27 A number of authors have described the high sensitivity of platelets to visible and IR laser irradiation and to the combination of these two wavelengths.28,29 Olban et al.30 have found that the irradiation of platelets with red light at doses of 1.8–2 J stimulates the generation of superoxide radicals, peroxidation of membrane lipids and secretion of proteins and adenine nucleotides.
In platelet-poor plasma the content of EGF is 20 times lower, EGF being characterized by a high molecular weight and presumably biological inertness.26 Most likely, this is due to the fact that EGF, like other growth factors, cytokines, and some hormones, circulates in the blood in a complex with one of the main plasma proteins, the high molecular alpha-2 macroglobulin (α2M).31 Under in vivo conditions, most of these biologically active substances (EGF, βNGF, PDGF, bFGF, TGF-β1, IL-1, IL-2, IL-6 and TNF-α) are predominantly bound to α2M non-covalently, i.e. not too firmly, so the formed complexes, under certain conditions, can dissociate with preservation of specific activities.32 Complex formation with α2M provides not only transport of active protein-peptide molecules, their protection from destruction by proteinases, and a fast elimination from circulation, but also a similarly fast increase of their content in blood plasma. Thus, about 70% of PDGF in blood plasma is bound to α2M non-covalently, while 30% is bound covalently. With decrease of pH from 7.5 to 4.0, about 50% of PDGF are released in a biologically active state.33 On the contrary, binding of EGF to α2M is maximal at low pH values and decreases with elevation of pH to 9.31
In many investigations, a dependence of complex-forming properties of α2M on its structural state, concentration, and peculiarities of microenvironment has been demonstrated.34,35 In terms of the present study, of great interest are findings that the activity of α2M to bind growth factors and cytokines changes significantly under the action of oxidants. Using hypochlorite, a neutrophil-derived oxidant, Wu et al.36 have shown that the oxidized α2M, as compared with its native form, has an increased capacity to bind to the proinflammatory cytokines TNF-α, IL-2 and IL-6, but on the other hand the binding to NGF, PDGF-BB, TGF-β1 and TGF-β2 is decreased. Similarly, the oxidant affects the binding capability of another form of the circulating α2M, its complex with proteinases. These authors suggested that oxidation served as a switch mechanism that down-regulated progression of acute inflammation by sequestering TNF-α, IL-2 and IL-6, while up-regulated development of tissue repair processes by releasing NGF, bFGF, PDGF-BB and TGF-β from binding to α2M. According to current concepts, the effects of coherent and non-coherent visible and IR light on cells, including blood cells (mononuclear and polymorphonuclear leukocytes and platelets) are connected with the formation of reactive oxygen species.30,37,38 Therefore, it can be suggested that the fast enhancement of blood plasma GP properties, after application of polychromatic light, results from a release of growth factors from a complex with the oxidized α2M.
As mentioned above, the mechanism of elevation of the blood GP activity in VIP-irradiated volunteers might be connected with effect of the light not only on blood but also on the superficial skin componemts. A significant contribution seems to be made by keratinocytes themselves. According to the recent review by Gröne,39 they produce either constitutively or upon induction many of the currently identified cytokines. Apart from cytokines, keratinocytes secrete growth factors that are very important for skin repair processes. Prominent among them are ligands for the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGF-R): EGF, TGF-α, heparin-binding EGF-like growth factor (HB-EGF) and amphiregulin (AR). They have been shown to be synthesized as membrane-anchored forms that can be shed as active soluble forms under effects of various agents.40,41 Within the EGF-R ligand family, TGF-α, HB-EGF and AR have been characterized as autocrine growth factors for keratinocytes. Following percutaneous application of light, it could be proposed that these growth factors can be shed from the keratinocyte surface, enter the blood plasma, and enhance its GP potentials for keratinocytes.
It is also possible that under in vivo conditions, the light potentiates the dermal–epidermal interactions and the keratinocytes growth factor (KGF) is secreted by fibroblasts. For example, it has been shown that after an irradiation and injury of skin the epidermal cells secrete IL-1 which stimulates secretion of KGF by fibroblasts.42,43 However, it remains unknown whether KGF is released into the circulation, leading to a possible systemic effect, or if its effect on keratinocyte proliferation is of a topical character. Results of the present work indicate indirectly that even if the growth factors of the dermal–epidermal origin enter the circulation of the irradiated volunteers, this occurs not at once but only at 24 h after the VIP-session: it is at this time period that the similarity of growth potential changes in the blood irradiated in vivo and in vitro disappears.
Also of note, with regard to the photomodulative mechanism, is the significant inhibitory effect of the three-fold hemoexfusions within the first 24 h of the experiment (to a total volume of 30 ml) on the blood GP properties in the placebo group volunteers. In our opinion, this mechanism deserves a special study, as it indicates that even a small blood loss combined with some emotional and pain stress might induce the appearance in blood of inhibitors of keratinocyte proliferation. Since the complex of the above events may also develop at cutaneous wounds, it can be suggested that this might result in a decrease of blood GP potentials for epidermal cells, and might thus be a contributory cause of slow wound epithelization. Restoration of this blood activity would be promoted by irradiation of the wound with visible and IR light.
In conclusion, it is worth discussing the phenomenon of translation of the changed GP properties of the photomodified blood to its entire circulating pool, as it is due to this event that the local change of the blood GP properties is transformed into the systemic effect. At present, because of the lack of experimental evidence, the mechanism of this phenomenon can be discussed merely as a hypothesis. Specifically, we propose considering the translation of the light-induced changes from the directly photomodified blood to the rest of the blood as a consequence of formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by irradiated leukocytes and platelets (owing to that the surface membranes of these cells contain the light-absorbing NADPH-oxidase complex) and to the immediate initiation by these ROS of a cascade of the ROS-forming reactions in the volume of the entire circulating blood. The oxidative reaction cascade can lead to fast structural modifications of all circulating blood cells and of plasma macromolecular complexes. Their consequences can be not only an increase of the blood GP activity for various targets, but also a modification of the functional state of circulating immunocompetent cells, changes of rheological properties of erythrocytes, of their transport, gas transport, metabolic functions, and initiation of other systemic effects. Such a hypothesis agrees well with the currently accepted concepts in cell biology about an important role of ROS in the intracellular and intercellular transduction of activational signals.44–46
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and Owner Societies 2004 |