Dingbin
Liu
ab,
Zhuo
Wang
*a and
Xingyu
Jiang
*a
aCAS Key Lab for Biological Effects of Nanomaterials and Nanosafety, National Center for Nanoscience and Technology, Beijing, 100190, China. E-mail: xingyujiang@nanoctr.cn; wangz@nanoctr.cn; Fax: (+86)10-82545631; Tel: (+86)10-82545611
bGraduate School of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100080China
First published on 28th February 2011
In recent years, gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) have drawn considerable research attention in the fields of catalysis, drug delivery, imaging, diagnostics, therapy and biosensors due to their unique optical and electronic properties. In this review, we summarized recent advances in the development of AuNP-based colorimetric and fluorescent assays for ions including cations (such as Hg2+, Cu2+, Pb2+, As3+, Ca2+, Al3+, etc) and anions (such as NO2−, CN−, PF6−, F−, I−, oxoanions), and small organic molecules (such as cysteine, homocysteine, trinitrotoluene, melamine and cocaine, ATP, glucose, dopamine and so forth). Many of these species adversely affect human health and the environment. Moreover, we paid particular attention to AuNP-based colorimetric and fluorescent assays in practical applications.
Dingbin Liu | Dingbin Liu is currently a PhD candidate at NCNST under the supervision of Prof. Xingyu Jiang. He received his BS from Lanzhou University in 2006 and MS from Chengdu Institute of Biology, Chinese Academy of Sciences in 2009. His current research interest is the design of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) for ultrasensitive detection of biomolecules. He is also interested in the construction of AuNP-based drug delivery systems. |
Zhuo Wang | Zhuo Wang received her MS from the Northeast Normal University (P. R. China) in 2003 and her PhD in Organic Chemistry from the Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences in 2006. After two years of postdoctoral research at Bowling Green State University (USA), she joined the NCNST as an assistant professor. Her research interests focus on the synthesis and modification of nanoparticles, and the biochemical assays based on small organic molecules and nanomaterials. |
Xingyu Jiang | Xingyu Jiang is a Professor in the National Center for NanoScience and Technology of China (NCNST). His research interests include surface chemistry, microfluidics, micro/nano-fabrication, cell biology and immunoassays. He obtained his BS at The University of Chicago (1999), followed by an AM (2001) and a PhD (2004) from Harvard University (Chemistry), working with Professor George Whitesides. After a postdoctoral fellowship with Professor Whitesides, he joined NCNST in 2005. |
AuNP-based colorimetric assays are of particular interest because molecular events can be easily transformed into color changes, which can be observed by the naked eye alone, hence, no sophisticated instruments are required. The color change is highly sensitive to the size, shape, capping agents, medium refractive index, as well as the aggregation state of AuNPs.28 In general, solutions containing well-dispersed AuNPs (normally 10–50 nm in diameter) display a ruby red color while those containing large AuNPs (>50 nm) or aggregates of small AuNPs exhibit a purple or blue color. During the aggregation of AuNPs or dispersion of AuNP aggregates, the color change is associated with the interparticle plasmon coupling that generates a significant absorption band shift in the visible region of the electromagnetic spectrum.29,30 There are two main kinds of aggregation mechanisms. One is based on the target-triggered removal of stabilizing ligands from surfaces of AuNPs, which is called “non-crosslinking aggregation”, the other is dependent on the binding of ligands modified on AuNPs with target analytes, which is defined as “interparticles crosslinking aggregation”.31 Owing to their extremely high extinction coefficients (e.g., 2.7 × 108 M−1cm−1 for 13 nm AuNPs), >1000 times higher than those of organic dyes,29 the limit of detection (LOD) for AuNP-based colorimetric assays can be as low as nM level, which makes this colorimetric sensor widely used in detecting analytes related to diagnosis of diseases, and monitoring environmental contamination and food safety. Since many reviews focused on the colorimetric detection of DNAs and proteins using AuNPs have been provided,32–36 we therefore attempt to exclusively review recent advances in the development of AuNP-based colorimetric and fluorescent assays for ions including cations and anions, and small organic compounds.
The most important example for non-crosslinking aggregation mechanism is based on DNA-conjugated AuNPs (DNA-AuNPs). Hg2+-induced abstraction of ligands such as short single-stranded DNA or double-stranded DNA from the surfaces of AuNPs can cause the aggregation of AuNPs, which can be used to detect Hg2+.41–44Single-stranded DNA, designed to contain thymine-rich (T-rich) domains, can absorb onto the surfaces of unmodified AuNPs. The functionalized AuNPs are monodispersed in aqueous media due to the electrostatic repulsion between the nucleic acid. Upon the addition of Hg2+, the complexation of Hg2+ with T-rich domains yields a hairpin structure, removing the single-stranded DNA from surfaces of AuNPs. The abstraction of ligands from Au surfaces induces aggregation of AuNPs.45
Based on the non-crosslinking aggregation mechanism, we recently developed a simple AuNP-based colorimetric assay for Hg2+. AuNPs were firstly modified with the hydrophilic (11-mercaptoundecyl)trimethylammonium (MTA) terminated in positively charged quaternary ammonium groups (QA) to form QA–AuNPs, which were well-dispersed only in acidic aqueous solution due to the electrostatic repulsion between the QA cations and the positively charged hydrogen ions in media.46 Upon the addition of Hg2+, the extremely high affinity of thiolates toward Hg2+ triggered the breakage of Au–S bonds on the surfaces of AuNPs, causing QA-terminated thiols to dissociate from Au surfaces. The partial removal of ligands from the Au surfaces leads to the aggregation of AuNPs (Fig. 1A). Interestingly, since AuNPs may employ the photothermal effect to absorb photons to break the Au–S bond on the Au surface, we anticipated solar light irradiation could greatly improve the sensitivity of this assay via accelerating the displacement reaction of QA–AuNPs and Hg2+. The limit of detection of this assay by the naked eye can be successfully decreased to as low as 30 nM (Fig. 1B, C), which is particularly attractive because the World Health Organization (WHO) has set a guideline value of Hg2+ in drinking water of 0.006 mg L−1 (30 nM), a value lower than the LOD of most currently available assays employing AuNPs. Therefore, we realized a simple colorimetric sensor for Hg2+ without resorting to any advanced instruments, and its selectivity and sensitivity is sufficient to monitor Hg2+ in drinking water. The practical potential of this assay was further evaluated in the real world by using simulated polluted samples.
Fig. 1 Colorimetric detection of Hg2+ based on the abstraction of quaternary ammonium group-terminated thiols from the surfaces of AuNPs. (A) The proposed mechanism for the Hg2+-induced colorimetric response of QA–AuNPs. (B) Light irradiation-assisted detection of Hg2+ with the color change upon the increase of concentrations of Hg2+ from left to right. (C) Absorbance response for (B). Inset: A670/A520vs.Hg2+ concentrations. The irradiation time was 30 s, the pH value of the solutions was 1.0. Reproduced with permission from ref. 46. Copyright 2010, ACS. |
Compared with the probes based on non-crosslinking aggregation mechanism, assays relying on the interparticle crosslinking aggregation mechanism have been increasingly explored. One classical interparticles crosslinking aggregation-based colorimetric assay for Hg2+ still relies on DNA-AuNPs. This simple platform for Hg2+ is dependent upon the binding of the T–T mismatches on the hybridized DNA-AuNPs with Hg2+ through interparticle T–Hg2+–T complex formation (Fig. 2),47,48 which induces a more thermally stable DNA duplex that endows a higher melting temperature (Tm) as compared with that in the absence of Hg2+. This assay provides a LOD of 100 nM, which cannot satisfy the guideline value (30 nM) set by the WHO. Therefore, it is highly desirable to find a convenient colorimetric assay with sufficient sensitivity.
Fig. 2 Colorimetric detection of Hg2+ based on DNA-modified AuNPs. Reproduced with permission from ref. 47. Copyright Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. |
A chip-based scanometric assay with much higher sensitivity for Hg2+ has been provided to satisfy the guideline value set by the WHO. This method is based on the catalytic properties of the nanoparticles to reduce Ag+ as an amplification. The LOD of this assay is 10 nM for Hg2+ in buffer and natural samples (Fig. 3). This method is attractive for potential point-of-use applications due to its high throughput, convenient readout, and portability.49 Importantly, to confirm the capacity of this method in the practical application, real samples from a lake were obtained and added with various concentrations of Hg2+. The results fully agreed with those from ICP-MS.
Fig. 3 (A) Conventional chip-based scanometric detection of target DNA using DNA-AuNPs; and (B) chip-based scanometric detection of Hg2+ using DNA-AuNPs. (C) Average scanometric signal intensity as a function of the Hg2+ concentration in buffer. The corresponding scanometric signal images are shown as an inset. The spot diameter is ∼200 μm. Reproduced with permission from ref. 49. Copyright 2008, ACS. |
Although DNA-AuNP-based methods are commonly sensitive, selective and simple, however, they require accurate control of temperature in this system to induce a visual color change. It is desirable to develop a detection system that is not only sensitive and selective, but also convenient and practical. Two types of non-complimentary DNA-AuNPs probes and a specific single-stranded DNA sequence were designed to detect Hg2+ at room temperature. The single-stranded DNA is used as a linker that recognizes the two non-complimentary sequences capped on surfaces of AuNPs. However, with the increasing number of T–T base-pair mismatches, the DNA-AuNPs cannot form aggregates in that the Tm of complimentary DNA is lower than the operating temperature. As the researchers anticipated, a selected number of T–T base-pair mismatches would allow the hybridization of DNA-AuNPs at room temperature only in the presence of the Hg2+.50 This colorimetric assay that operates at room temperature makes DNA-AuNPs based sensor convenient in the real applications of detecting Hg2+. Nevertheless, the as-reported LOD (1 μM) is much higher than the guideline value set by the WHO, a signal amplification method should be combined with this system.
Certain assays based on the formation of T-Hg2+-T complexes are promising to improve the simplicity and efficiency in real applications. For example, the use of fluorescence polarization assay (FPA) can significantly increase the sensitivity of the detection of Hg2+. The LOD of this assay can reach as low as 1.0 nM.51 Another crosslinking strategy for Hg2+ detection is in the formation of sulfur–Hg2+–sulfur (S–Hg2+–S) complex between different AuNPs, because Hg2+ exhibits much stronger thiophilic tendency than the competing heavy cations such as Pb2+, Cd2+, and Cu2+.52,53
Although the DNA-AuNP-based assays are promising tools for Hg2+ determination, DNA can be costly and difficult to handle. In addition, DNA-AuNP-based assays rely on accurate control of detection conditions.
Another kind of simple colorimetric assay for Hg2+ based on the interparticles crosslinking aggregation mechanism is carried out by using 3-mercaptopropionic acid (MPA)-functionalized AuNPs (MPA-AuNPs).54 The ion-templated chelation between the acid groups on surfaces of AuNPs and Hg2+ can induce the aggregation of AuNPs. Actually, the MPA-AuNPs lack sufficient selectivity for Hg2+, because metal ions such as Cd2+ and Pb2+ can readily interact with acid groups to cause the aggregation of MPA-AuNPs. To improve the selectivity, 2, 6-pyridinedicarboxylic acid (PDCA) must be added for masking Cd2+ and Pb2+.55,56
Most reported colorimetric assays lack sufficient sensitivity for Hg2+ determination. In order to enhance sensitivity, other technologies can combine with AuNPs. For example, hyper-Rayleigh scattering (HRS) can assist to improve the sensitivity of AuNP-based sensors modified with mercaptopropionic acid (MPA), homocystine (HCys), and PDCA in the rapid and selective determination of Hg2+ in tap water.57 This approach has provided a high sensitivity (5 ppb). Another assay employs AuNP-based fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) to screen mercury levels in contaminated soil, water, and fish with excellent sensitivity (2 ppt).58 Recent advances have demonstrated the sensitivity for detecting Hg2+ could even reach picomolar level by using localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR).59
In general, assays based on fluorescence allow high sensitivity.60 Ultra-small gold nanoparticles, often called gold nanoclusters (AuNCs), display strong fluorescence signals if the ligands capped on surfaces of AuNCs contain electron-rich groups.61 Unlike colorimetric assays based on distance-dependant SPR absorption properties, fluorescent AuNCs (F-AuNCs) provide a promising perspective for bio-chemical analysis because they provide much lower LOD than colorimetric assays. AuNCs (2.9 ± 0.5 nm) capped by 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid (MUA) (MUA-AuNCs) are used as a fluorescent probe that exhibits strong fluorescence signals. The ion-templated chelation between the acid groups and Hg2+ can induce the aggregation of MUA-AuNCs, quenching the fluorescence of MUA-AuNCs. The LOD can be as low as 5.0 nM,62 which is lower than the guideline value (30 nM) set by the WHO. The potential of this assay was evaluated in detecting environmental samples obtained from a pond, and the value was in good agreement with that determined by using ICP-MS. Another kind of fluorescent assay for Hg2+ based on F-AuNCs has been reported owing to the fluorescence quenching of AuNCs caused by the specific and strong interactions between Hg2+ and Au+ on the gold surface, by which Hg2+ can be detected with high sensitivity and selectivity.63–65 For example, BSA-functionalized AuNCs (BSA-AuNCs) possess relatively high fluorescence (quantum yield ∼ 6%), upon the addition of Hg2+ into BSA-AuNPs solution, the fluorescence of AuNCs significantly diminished due to the metallophilic Hg2+–Au+ interactions (Fig. 4).65
Fig. 4 (A) Schematic of Hg2+ sensing based on the fluorescence quenching of AuNCs resulting from high-affinity metallophilic Hg2+–Au+ bonds. (b) Photoemission spectra (λex = 470 nm) and (inset) photographs under UV light (354 nm) of AuNCs (20 μM) in the (1) absence and (2) presence of Hg2+ ions (50 μM). Reproduced with permission from ref. 65. Copyright 2009, RSC. |
Another kind of AuNP-based assay relies on the quenching of the fluorescence of organic dyes by Au.66 When Rhodamine 6G (R6G) adsorbs on the surfaces of AuNPs through noncovalent interactions, its fluorescence is efficiently quenched. Upon the addition of Hg2+, R6G are replaced from the surfaces of AuNPs to recover the intense fluorescence, which can be used to further detect Hg2+. The corresponding LOD can be as low as 6.0 × 10−11 mol L−1. The recovered fluorescence intensity is proportional to the concentrations of Hg2+. This fluorescent assay has been successfully utilized in detecting real samples from tap water, pond water and river water. The values by using this method are consistent with those obtained by using atomic absorption spectroscopy.
In general, although many publications described various AuNP-based colorimetric and fluorescent methods in detecting Hg2+, most of them lacked sufficient sensitivity in monitoring Hg2+ in real samples. Furthermore, some of these assays show potential applications in environmental water and biological fluids, however most of them are limited to samples where Hg2+ is added to pure aqueous solutions. The primary obstacle for these assays is the interference from complicated components and high concentration of salt in environmental samples as well as biological fluids. Therefore, great effort is indispensable to develop more stable, reliable and accurate readout methods with sufficient sensitivity for Hg2+ in real samples.
Recently, our group provided a AuNP-based colorimetric method to detect Cu2+ ions by azide- and alkyne-functionalized AuNPs using click chemistry.68 The catalyst of click chemisty, Cu+, which can be quantitatively converted from the reduction of Cu2+ in the presence of sodium ascorbate which can in turn be used to conjugate the azide- and alkyne-functionalized AuNPs (Fig. 5A). The conjugation led to the aggregation of AuNPs along with the color change of the solution, and a precipitate eventually appeared after 24 h (Fig. 5B1). The procedure can be confirmed by UV-vis absorption spectrum. The absorption band red-shifted from 520 nm to about 580 nm, and the intensity decreased gradually (Fig. 5B2). This method allows the naked eye, without any advanced instrument, to detect Cu2+ with high selectivity over other metal ions. The LOD of the assay is 20 μM, which is attractive because this value is the maximum contaminant level (MCL) for copper in drinking water defined by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).69
Fig. 5 (A) The detection of Cu2+ ions using click chemistry between two types of AuNPs, each modified with thiols terminated in an alkyne or an azide functional group. (B) The assay for Cu2+ ions by the naked eye: (1) photographs of the solution containing only the mixture of functionalized AuNPs (left) and the same mixture after the addition of Cu2+ (right); (2) UV-vis spectrum obtained from solutions of functionalized AuNPs and after 24 h in the presence of Cu2+ ions and sodium ascorbate. Solid line: AuNPs–Cu2+; dotted line: AuNPs + Cu2+. Reproduced with permission from ref. 68. Copyright Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. |
One of the classical AuNP-based colorimetric probes for Cu2+ is based on Cu2+-dependent DNA ligation DNAzyme, which can be catalyzed to form a phosphodiester bond in the presence of Cu2+, thus, yielding a ligation product that is designed as a linker to assemble AuNPs, as a result, a red-to-blue color change is observed.70
Another interesting assay for Cu2+ is based on F-AuNPs, which has been functionalized with glutathione (GSH) that can interact with Cu2+ selectively to induce the aggregation of the GSH-capped F-AuNPs, accompanied by the decrease of the fluorescence intensity. The LOD is 3.6 nM, much lower than that from colorimetric assays.71 Another work was based on fluorescence for detecting Cu2+ by using AuNPs as an ultra-efficient quencher. AuNPs were functionalized with the perylene bisimide chromophore (PBC) to form PBC-AuNPs by weak N–Au interactions, quenching the fluorescence of this chromophore. Upon the addition of Cu2+, the chromophore was removed from the surfaces of AuNPs with fluorescence recovery owing to the stronger coordination ability of Cu2+ toward the pyridyl moiety in comparison with that of the AuNPs.72
The practical application of AuNP-based colorimetric assay has been demonstrated by using unmodified-AuNPs, which are easy to aggregate in high concentration of salt even in the presence of long Cu2+-dependent DNAzyme. The addition of Cu2+ led to the self-cleave of the long DNAzyme into short pieces, which could absorb rapidly onto the unmodified-AuNPs to prevent the aggregation of AuNPs, thus the solution color remained red. Real samples from lake water were collected to further evaluate the availability of this colorimetric assay. The results were in a good agreement with those determined by using ICP-MS, demonstrating the capacity of this assay in detecting real samples.73
Fig. 6 Colorimetric detection of Pb2+ based on DNAzyme modified AuNPs. (A) Secondary structure of the “8–17” DNAzyme. (B) Cleavage of 17DS by 17E in the presence of Pb2+. (C) Schematics of the colorimetric Pb2+ sensor design. The three components (the extended substrate strand, 17E and 12-mer DNA-AuNPs) of the sensor can assemble to form blue-colored aggregates. Nanoparticles were aligned in a “head-to-tail” manner. A heating-and-cooling process (annealing) was needed for detection. (D) Schematics of the new colorimetric sensor design. Nanoparticles were aligned in a “tail-to-tail” manner. Reproduced with permission from ref. 77. Copyright 2004, ACS. |
Another piece of work is based on the phenomenon that single-stranded DNA can easily absorb onto AuNPs and prevent the salt-induced aggregation of AuNPs, while double-stranded DNA is stiffer and has negatively charged groups that repulse the interactions between double-stranded DNA and AuNPs, thus cannot prevent the salt-induced aggregation of AuNPs.79,80 The Pb2+-induced cleavage of DNAzyme releases single-stranded DNA from the surface of AuNPs to prevent the aggregation of AuNPs under high concentration of salt. By contrast, the absence of Pb2+ or the presence of other cations cannot prevent the formation of aggregates. This kind of assay, based on unmodified-AuNPs, has a LOD of 3 nM, which is much lower than the value defined by the EPA.81 Based on the same principle, the authors transferred the DNAzyme-AuNPs into dipstick tests for the measurement of Pb2+, and successfully demonstrated the validity of this sensor for the detection of Pb2+ in household leaded paints.82
Another kind of assay for Pb2+ is based on gallic acid-capped AuNPs (GA-AuNPs), on which Pb2+ can preferentially coordinate with phenolic hydroxyl groups of GA.83 The LOD of GA-based probe was further improved to 10 nM by narrowing the size distribution of GA-AuNCs and minimizing interparticle repulsion between each GA-AuNC.84 In addition, the feasibility of this GA-AuNC-based assay has been evaluated in seawater.
The levels of Ca2+ are associated with several kinds of diseases,95 thus accurate assays for Ca2+ are highly desirable. Calsequestrin (CSQ) is the most abundant calcium-binding protein and an endogenous Ca2+ ion sensor in the sarcoplasmic reticulum, so CSQ-functionalized AuNPs can be designed as a highly selective assay for Ca2+ determination.90 The conformation of the CSQ molecules on surfaces of AuNPs can form dimers or polymers upon the addition of a threshold concentration of Ca2+, thus results in the aggregation of AuNPs and a red-to-blue color change. Compared with most chemical chromophore-based Ca2+ ion sensors, this sensor is highly selective for Ca2+ over other divalent ions. This assay was used to detect Ca2+ in physiological samples, in which the contents of Ca2+ in normal and abnormal (hypocalcemic) conditions are different. After incubating these real samples with CSQ-functionalized AuNPs, the color of the solutions of abnormal condition changed from red to purple, and eventually a precipitate appeared, indicating the higher concentrations of Ca2+ in abnormal condition, while the color remained red for the normal condition of real samples. This tool is a classical AuNP-based sensor that used in the detection of physiologically related analytes, which is useful for monitoring certain diseases associated with high concentrations of Ca2+.
We summarized the AuNP-based colorimetric and fluoresecent assays for various cations in Table 1. From the overview of the AuNP-based assays for the detection of cations, we can perceive that the real samples are almost limited to the water-soluble samples, in which pretreatment is commonly required to remove other complicated components. So it is still difficult for AuNP-based systems to be used directly in complicated real samples owing to the instability of AuNPs, and more research is needed to focus on the improvement of the stability for AuNPs. Moreover, the uniform modification of AuNPs should be addressed, which is the key for the real sample applications based on AuNPs systems.
Target | Probe | Readout | LOD/μM | Real sample | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hg2+ | DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.01 | Underground water | 45 |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0. 1 | — | 47 | |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/Scanometric | 0.01 | Lake water | 49 | |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.0 | — | 50 | |
QA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.03 | Drinking water | 46 | |
MPA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.1 | — | 54 | |
MUA-AuNCs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 5.0 × 10−3 | Pond water | 62 | |
Lysozyme-AuNCs | Fluorescence | 0.01 | — | 63 | |
Lysozyme-AuNCs | Fluorescence | 3.0 × 10−6 | Seawater | 64 | |
BSA-AuNCs | Fluorescence | 5.0 × 10−4 | — | 65 | |
R6G-AuNPs | Fluorescence | 6.0 × 10−5 | River water | 66 | |
Cu2+ | Alkyne-AuNPs/Azide-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 20.0 | — | 68 |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 5.0 | — | 70 | |
GSH-AuNPs | Fluorescence | 3.6 × 10−3 | — | 71 | |
PBC-AuNPs | Fluorescence | 1.0 | — | 72 | |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.29 | Lake water | 73 | |
Pb2+ | DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.1 | Paint | 77 |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 3.0 × 10−3 | Paint | 82 | |
GA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 5.0 | — | 83 | |
GA-AuNCs | Fluorescence | 0.01 | Seawater | 84 | |
K+ | Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.0 × 103 | — | 85 |
DNA-AuNPs | Fluorescence | — | — | 86 | |
As3+ | GSH/DTT/Cys-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.3 × 10−4 | Underground water | 88 |
Ca2+ | CSQ-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.0 × 103 | Human serum | 90 |
Ag+ | DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 5.9 × 10−4 | — | 91 |
Cr3+ | DTNBA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.8 | — | 92 |
Al3+ | CALNN-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.2 | Cellular surface | 93 |
The Griess reaction has been used to crosslink AuNPs and cause aggregation. This assay is based on the fact that sulfanilamide and naphthylethylenediamine can react to form an azo dye in the presence of nitrite ions (NO2−) (Fig. 7A).99,100 After preparing the “aniline AuNPs” and “naphthalene AuNPs” cofunctionalized with hydrophilic (11-mercaptoundecyl)trimethylammonium (MTA), which enhances the solubility and stability of AuNPs in aqueous solutions (Fig. 7B), nitrite ions cause the cross-coupling of the two kinds of AuNPs via the Griess reaction.99 As a result, the color of the solution changes from red to colorless (Fig. 7C). The MCL for nitrite ions in drinking water defined by the EPA is 1 ppm (21.7 μM),101 a value similar to the LOD this assay presents (Fig. 7D). The capacity of this AuNP-based colorimetric assay was evaluated for the measurement of NO2− in environmental samples, such as lake water, and the results were similar to those in distilled water. Moreover, the products of NO2− derived from a reduction reaction were also monitored.
Fig. 7 (A) Griess reaction. (B) Colorimetric detection of nitrite with functionalized AuNPs. (C) Photograph of particle solutions after incubation with various concentrations of nitrite. The nitrite concentrations, in μM, are listed next to the respective solutions. The MCL of nitrite in drinking water (21.7 μM) is highlighted in red. (D) Particle solution extinction at 524 nm after incubation as a function of nitrite concentration. The red dashed line indicates the nitrite MCL. Reproduced with permission from ref. 99. Copyright 2009, ACS. |
Another important kind of anion is cyanide (CN−), which has been extensively used in industry and has become a potential contaminant to ground water.102,103Cyanide can form stable complexes with transition metallic ions such as Cu2+ ions and abstract them from Cu2+ complexes to form new, more stable Cu2+-cyanide complexes. Based on the fact, adenosine triphosphate-stabilized AuNPs (ATP-AuNPs) were designed to combine with Cu2+-phenanthroline complexes. When exposed to cyanide, Cu2+-phenanthroline can be decomplexed to release free phenanthroline, which can bind to Au surfaces accompanied with the removal of ATP from surfaces of AuNPs. Phenanthroline-coated AuNPs are unstable in aqueous media, thus lead to aggregation quickly along with a dramatic visible color change from red to blue of the solution.104 The sensitivity of AuNP-based colorimetric assays for cyanide is generally insufficient for many settings. F-AuNPs is beneficial to improve the sensitivity for detecting cyanide. Most assays for cyanide based on F-AuNPs rely on the cyanide-induced etching of AuNPs,105,106 in that cyanide can dissolve Au or Ag in water to form aqueous soluble metal–cyanide complex. By the addition of cyanide into solutions containing F-AuNPs that display molecule-like fluorescence,107 the cyanide-based etching induces the decrease of the size of AuNCs, causing the fluorescence to decrease and even disappear completely. The highly reactive property of cyanide with inert Au endows this sensor superior selectivity over other common anions.
Some anions can be used as a negatively charged component in ionic liquids. In aqueous media, hydrophilic ionic liquid-coated AuNPs are mono-dispersed. When hydrophilic anions are replaced by hydrophobic species, the hydrophilic AuNPs aggregate, along with a color change of the solutions from red to blue. Based on this fact, hydrophobic anion such as PF6− can be detected by the naked eye by using methylimidazolium chloride-modified AuNPs (MC-AuNPs). The water soluble Cl− species of ionic liquids on Au surfaces can be easily anion-exchanged by PF6− to form hydrophobic AuNPs, which are insoluble in aqueous media and thus lead to aggregation of AuNPs.108 Hydrophilic fluoride ions (F−) can interact with phenylboronic acid under acidic conditions to form hydrophobic trifluoroboronate anions (Ar-BF3−). Similar to PF6−, Ar-BF3− are hydrophobic species and can displace the hydrophilic anions originally absorbed on surfaces of AuNPs via an anion-exchange process. The formation of hydrophobic surface causes the aggregation AuNPs in aqueous media due to the hydrophobic interaction between different AuNPs.109
In addition, AuNP-embedded plasticized polymer membrane has been used to selectively recognize I− by colorimetric sensing.110 However, the detection limit of this assay is insufficient to determine I− in the environmental and biological samples. The sensitivity for detecting I− has been remarkably improved by using fluorescein isothiocyanate-capped AuNPs (FITC-AuNPs). The addition of I− can remove FITC from Au surfaces accompanied with the release of the fluorescence of FITC, by which the total inorganic iodine (I− and IO3−) in edible salt and seawater have been determined as a practical application for this assay.111 Similarly, colorimetric assays for oxoanions such as AcO−, HPO42− and melonate in aqueous methanol by using isothiouronium-modified AuNPs have been reported.112
We summarized the AuNP-based colorimetric and fluoresecent assays for various anions in Table 2. We noticed that even though more and more AuNP-based assays have been reported, it is still a challenge for the accurate determination of specific anions in aqueous media, because water soluble species surrounding the anionic analytes interfere with the desired interaction between anionic analytes and ligands on AuNPs, resulting in poor sensitivity and selectivity. Compared with ligands for cations, receptors for anions are more difficult to design, so AuNPs detection based on the surface modification still needs much work.
Target | Probe | Readout | LOD/μM | Real sample | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
NO2− | Aniline-AuNPs/naphthalene-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 22 | Lake water | 99 |
CN− | ATP-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 14 | — | 104 |
RB-Au NPs | Fluorescence | 0.08 | — | 105 | |
BSA-AuNCs | Fluorescence | 0.2 | Lake water | 106 | |
PF6− | MC-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | — | — | 108 |
F− | Isothiouronium-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 8.0 × 104 | — | 109 |
I− | FITC-AuNPs | Fluorescence | 0.01 | — | 111 |
Oxoanions | Isothiouronium-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 100 | — | 112 |
Target | Probe | Readout | LOD/μM | Real sample | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cys /HCys | FSN-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.8 | Human urine | 125 |
Cys | FSN-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.0 | Human urine | 121 |
HCys | FSN-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.18 | Human urine | 126 |
TNT | Cysteamine-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 5.0 × 10−7 | Lake water | 130 |
Cys-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis/SERS | 2.0 × 10−6 | — | 131 | |
Melamine | Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.32 | Milk | 136 |
Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.2 | Milk | 137 | |
PolyTn-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.02 | Milk | 138 | |
MTT-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.02 | Milk | 139 | |
Cocaine | Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 20 | — | 114 |
DNA-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 50 | — | 140 | |
Dopamine | Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.03 | — | 113 |
ATP | Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 0.6 | — | 115 |
CTAB-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 200 | — | 116 | |
Glucose | Citrate-AuNPs | Colorimetric/UV-vis | 1.0 × 103 | Rat brain microdialysate | 117 |
Based on FSN-AuNPs, the Tseng group developed two assays that can selectively detect Cys and HCys.121,126 One is based on the fact that HCys can form a five-membered ring under the pretreatment of NaOH, which decreases the rate of HCys-induced removal of FSN ligands from surfaces of AuNPs, thereby slowing down the aggregation of FSN-AuNPs, but it is difficult for Cys to form a four-membered ring transition state under the same condition. Therefore, by pretreatment of aminothiols with NaOH, only Cys can remarkably induce the FSN-AuNPs aggregate.121 Another FSN-AuNP-based assay has been successfully achieved for the selective detection of HCys. This method is based on the combination of several components including FSN-AuNPs, o-phthaldialdehyde (OPA), as well as 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME). FSN-AuNPs are used to abstract Cys and HCys, which can be easily removed from Au surfaces by 2-ME via ligand exchange. The released free HCys form complexes with OPA/2-ME and emit strong fluorescence, while the derivatization of Cys with OPA/2-ME displays extremely weak fluorescence. By comparing the finally resulted fluorescence, HCys are detected with good sensitivity as well as selectivity. The main drawback of this assay the requirement for a complex procedure.126
Some other organic small compounds show significant threat to both human beings and the environment, such as trinitrotoluene (TNT), which is most commonly used as an explosive for landmines.127 Therefore, ultrasensitive assays for TNT have been increasingly developed in the past decade,128,129 Mao etc reported an excellent AuNP-based sensor for TNT. This sensor relied on the donor–acceptor (D–A) interaction between TNT and primary amines that modified AuNPs. The strong D–A interaction not only induced a direct colorimetric visualization for TNT, but also enabled this sensor to have a picomolar level of sensitivity.130 By combining with SERS, Ray presented an accurate and fast probe to determine TNT.131 In the presence of TNT, the Cys-modified AuNPs can form Meisenheimer complex with TNTvia electrostatic interactions, thus can undergo aggregation, by which several hot spots formed and provided a significant enhancement of the sensitivity for TNT in aqueous solution with excellent selectivity.
Due to its harm to human health and its potential presence in dairy products, melamine has become a heated target for many types of assays.132–135Melamine itself contains several primary amine groups that can strongly bind with Au, thus readily displaces stabilizing agents (citrates) from surfaces of AuNPs and causes the aggregation of AuNPs.136,137 However, these unmodified AuNP-based assays cannot provide sufficient sensitivity for melamine determination. So the use of ligand-functionalized AuNPs is still a better choice to detect melamine.138 Recently, Lu and his coworkers provided a simple but effective colorimetric assay with high sensitivity to detect melamine.139 The working mechanism is based on the specific triple hydrogen-bonding recognition between melamine and a cyanuric acid (AC) derivatively functionalized on the surfaces of AuNPs (Fig. 8). The formation of the stable melamine-AC complex can lead to the aggregation of AC-modified AuNPs, along with a color change from red to blue just within 1 min even the concentration of melamine is as low as 2.5 ppb. Although the authors demonstrated the availability of this AuNP-based colorimetric assay in detecting melamine in real samples such as raw milk as well as commercially available infant formula, it is time-consuming and a complicated pretreatment of real samples to remove the interference components was required. Therefore, more convenient AuNP-based colorimetric assays are still in high demand.
Fig. 8 (A) Hydrogen-bonding recognition between melamine and cyanuric acid derivative. (B) Colorimetric detection of melamine using the cyanuric acid-stabilized AuNPs. Reproduced with permission from ref. 139. Copyright 2009, ACS. |
Fan and his coworkers provided a novel design to visually detect cocaine with high sensitivity by unmodified AuNPs and engineered aptamers. An anticocaine aptamer was firstly cut into two flexible ssDNA pieces, which can be assembled in the presence of cocaine. In previous discussions, we stated that unmodified AuNPs were easy to aggregate in aqueous solution with high concentrations of salt, while ssDNA-coated AuNPs were well-dispersed even at higher concentrations of salt. Therefore, the specific interaction between the pieces of aptamer and cocaine decreased the content of ssDNA, thus led to the aggregation of AuNPs in solution containing high concentrations of salt.114 SsDNA aptamers can be designed to selectively interact with cocaine so that the structure of ssDNA aptamers changed, subsequently the hybridized bases that induced the aggregation of AuNPs decreased to several pairs, which were unstable at room temperature. The dehybridization of ssDNA aptamers thereby resulted in the redispersion of the aggregates of AuNPs.140
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 |