Lin Wanga,
Xiaomei Zhaoa,
Yan Zhanga,
Wenqi Zhanga,
Tianrui Ren
a,
Zhihong Chenb,
Feng Wang*a and
Haifeng Yang*a
aThe Education Ministry Key Lab of Resource Chemistry, Shanghai Key Laboratory of Rare Earth Functional Materials, Shanghai Municipal Education Committee Key Laboratory of Molecular Imaging Probes and Sensors, Department of Chemistry, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai, 200234, P. R. China. E-mail: wangfeng@shnu.edu.cn; hfyang@shnu.edu.cn
bCollege of Information, Mechanical and Electrical engineering, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai, 200234, P. R. China
First published on 28th April 2015
An intelligent PNIPAAm/AgNP composite film was fabricated by the simple assembly of silver nanoparticles on the surface of photo-polymerized PNIPAAm film via electrostatic interaction. Surface enhanced Raman scattering study and finite-difference time-domain simulation demonstrated that the local electric field intensity and the SERS intensity of this resultant composite film can be easily tuned by changing the interparticle distance triggered by temperature or solvent variations. The composite film showed a high stability in a polar organic solvent and concentrated saline solution. The smart composite film might find applications as a SERS sensor for temperature/solvent variation detection as well as a versatile SERS substrate for the detection of analyte in sea water and organic solvent.
Intelligent polymers (also called smart polymer) that can reversibly change their properties in response to environmental stimuli, have drawn numerous research interests in the preparation of dynamic SERS substrates.18–22 Among them, poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm) has been studied in detail with regard to its well-known phase behavior in aqueous solutions, which undergoes a reversible phase transition at its lower critical solution temperature (LCST, ∼32 °C in water). The conformation of PNIPAAm chain changes from a swollen state (below LCST) to a shrunken state (above LCST) upon temperature increments due to the weakened amide–water interaction and the enhanced hydrophobic interaction between isopropyl groups.23,24 The conformational changes together with the significant dimensional variations make PNIPAAm a good candidate for the preparation of dynamic SERS substrates.25–29 However, many of the reported dynamic SERS substrates are prepared tortuously or are time consuming. In addition, AgNPs fabricated by in situ silver ion reduction in some dynamic SERS substrates are hard to control in terms of size and particle number. What's more, the conformational changes of PNIPAAm can also be triggered by solvent changes or salt ion, yet up to now few reports can be found about the responses of dynamic SERS substrate to such stimuli.
We report in this work a facile approach to fabricate PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite films, in which uniform silver nanoparticles were densely loaded on photo-polymerized PNIPAAm film via electrostatic interaction. The temperature-dependent optical properties of the composite film were confirmed by UV-reflectance spectroscopy and Finite-Difference Time-Domain (FDTD) simulation. When the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film was used as dynamic SERS substrates for detecting 4-mercaptopyridine in an aqueous solution, the SERS signals could be modulated by temperature and solvent changes and are relatively stable even at high salt concentrations. Therefore, the composite film holds promise as a SERS sensor for temperature detection, and can also act as a versatile SERS substrate for analyte detection in sea water and many organic solvents.
C double bond at 1247, 1405 and 1620 cm−1 could be clearly seen in Fig. 1A(a). After UV irradiation for 15 min these three peaks dramatically decreased (Fig. 1A(b)), which confirmed the transition of monomer into polymers.32 FTIR was also utilized to monitor the photopolymerization (Fig. 1B). The peaks at 1414 and 1624 cm−1 respectively due to C
C and –C
C stretching vibrations in NIPAAm monomer disappeared after UV irradiation, which is consistent with the results of Raman study. What's more, after thoroughly rinsing with cold water to remove unreacted monomers, the absorption peak at 3450 cm−1 in FTIR spectrum of PNIPAAm (N–H vibration in AEMH segment) can be clearly seen,33 confirming the incorporation of amine group in the PNIPAAm chain.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (A) Raman spectra of NIPAAm (a) and PNIPAAm (b); (B) FTIR spectra of NIPAAm (a) and PNIPAAm (b). | ||
In the second step, positively charged AgNPs were prepared according to Lee and Meisel's protocol. Uniform AgNPs with an average diameter of 35 ± 4 nm were obtained (Fig. 2A). This kind of AgNPs suspension showed an absorption peak at 407 nm in UV-vis spectrum (Fig. 2B), which agrees with the previous report.34,35 This citrate protected AgNPs showed a negative charge (−34.7 ± 2 mV) by zeta-potential measurement, which will facilitate the further assembly of AgNPs on amine-group bearing PNIPAAm film.
In the third step, PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film was fabricated by electrostatic assembly of AgNPs on amine-group bearing PNIPAAm film. The color of the translucent PNIPAAm film gradually became dark brown (Fig. S1a and b†) after immersing the film in AgNPs suspension for 1 h (Fig. S2†). After rinsing the film with water and drying it in the air, a greyish-green luster was observed (Fig. S1c†). SEM image (Fig. 3A) also showed a closely stacked AgNPs layer, indicating the successful assembly of AgNPs on PNIPAAm film.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 (A) SEM image of PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film in dry state; (B) UV-reflectance spectra of PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film at 25 °C (a) and 40 °C (b). | ||
As PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film is opaque, UV-reflectance spectroscopy was performed to study the thermo-sensitivity of the film at 25 °C and 40 °C. Fig. 3B showed that the reflectivity of the composite film at 40 °C was larger than that at 25 °C over a wide wavelength ranges (300–700 nm). This could be explained by the closeness of the AgNPs induced by the shrinking of PNIPAAm chain network upon heating.36–38 With closeness of the AgNPs and the increase of the particle density, the extinction/anti-reflection feature of the AgNPs weakened, the composite film then becomes similar to the reflective bulk silver film at higher temperatures.
The calculation of interparticle distances between the adsorbed AgNPs at low and high temperatures was performed in order to better understand the dynamic changes of the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film. Based on the assumption that all AgNPs were distributed evenly on the PNIPAAm film with a pattern schemed in Fig. S3,† we can calculate the average interparticle distance between the AgNPs at 25 °C and 40 °C. Specifically, the density of AgNPs in dry state was obtained from SEM image (Fig. 3A), and dimensional variations of the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film can be evaluated from digital camera image (DCI) (Fig. S1†) at 25 °C, 40 °C and dry state. According to calculation results, the interparticle distance decreased from 15 nm at 25 °C to 4 nm at 40 °C, indicating the shrinking of PNIPAAm chain at higher temperatures and the increased particle density of the composite film. The observation further corroborates the UV-reflectance result. As a consequence, the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film can be expected to serve as a dynamic SERS substrate.
To further understand the mechanism of the SERS effect tuned by temperature, the near-field electric distribution of the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film was calculated based on FDTD solution software. A thin layer of water (Z = 0–30 nm) and PNIPAAm (Z = −30–0 nm) was added to mimic the real condition. The refractive index of PNIPAAm was set to be 1.35 at 25 °C and 1.65 at 40 °C.39 As shown in Fig. 4, the simulated electric field profiles at different temperatures showed a significant field enhancement at 40 °C than at 25 °C. The thermo-induced local electric field enhancement depicted that the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film with high sensitivity could be employed as the dynamic SERS substrates for molecular sensing.
Using 4-mercaptopyridine (4-Mpy) as a probe molecule due to its distinctive Raman spectral feature and strong binding with AgNPs via S–Ag bond,40–42 the SERS activities of PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film with increasing temperature were investigated. The recorded SERS spectra are presented in Fig. 5A. The bands at 1006 and 1097 cm−1 can be assigned to the ring breathing and C–C–C/C–S stretching, respectively. A peak at 1216 cm−1 is assigned to the β(CH)/β(NH) stretching. The peaks at 1577 and 1609 cm−1 are from the ring stretch modes of the 4-Mpy molecules with deprotonate and protonated nitrogen atoms. The occurrence of Raman band at 1097 cm−1 corresponding to the ring breathing/C–S stretching mode indicates that 4-Mpy was bound to the AgNPs surface through the sulfur atom.35,42,43 Fig. 5B shows the temperature-dependent SERS intensity at 1097 cm−1, which increased sharply at ∼35 °C and then leveled off with temperature increasing. It's not surprising to find that phase transition of PNIPAAm (LCST ∼32 °C) just happened in the temperature region (30–35 °C) where the SERS signal showed a significant improvement of at least 3 fold. Moreover, upon cooling from 40 °C to 25 °C, the intensity could go back to the original intensity at 25 °C. As seen in Fig. 6, showing the reversible thermo-induced change can be repeated for at least three-times. Therefore, the thermo-induced SERS signal changes on the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film is quite reversible. Similar results were obtained while detecting CV (10−9 M) and anthracene (10−4 M) on the composite film (Fig. S3 and S4†). A clear increase in SERS intensity can be observed with temperature increases. These results indicate that the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film hold potential as a SERS sensor for temperature variation detection.
In addition, the reproducibility of the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film was investigated by comparing SERS signals from 20 different spots on the same composite film (Fig. 7A) and different composite films (Fig. 7C). The peak at 1097 cm−1 was chosen to evaluate the reproducibility of composite film (Fig. 7B and D). The relative standard deviations are 17.5% (Fig. 7B) for spot-to-spot and 18.6% (Fig. 7D) for batch-to-batch respectively, which prove that the SERS substrate exhibits a good reproducibility.
PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film was immersed in basic, acid or salt solution to study the durability of the film. The SERS intensity is relatively stable within pH range of 5–9, but significantly decreases at lower pH value (≤4) or higher pH value (≥10) (Fig. S6†). As above mentioned, the main driving force of the formation of PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film is electrostatic interaction, harsh pH conditions might destabilize the electrostatic interaction between PNIPAAm chain and AgNPs, leading to the detachment of AgNPs from the film and the decreased SERS signal. Interestingly, the SERS signal is reasonably stable even at high salt concentration equal to 15 wt% (Fig. S7†). This might be attributed to the “salting out” effect of PNIPAAm chains: the chains dehydrate and collapse at lower temperature with the presence of salt ions,44 protecting the AgNPs against detachment from the film.
As PNIPAAm chain can also respond to other stimuli such as solvent polarity change, SERS intensities of 4-Mpy in H2O, EtOH and H2O/EtOH mixture were studied. Fig. 8c shows a significant SERS signal increase in H2O/EtOH mixture with a volume ratio of 1
:
1 compared to that in pure H2O and pure EtOH (Fig. 8a and b). Though the introduction of organic solvent can alter the LSPR of AgNPs,45 the SERS signal normally becomes weaker in organic solvent (herein, EtOH) than in water (Fig. 8b).46 Generally the SERS enhancement factor in nonaqueous media is only 1/10 to 1/100 of that in aqueous media.47 So the highest SERS signal of PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film in H2O/EtOH mixture in this study could only be attributed to the greatest enhancement of LSPR induced by the closeness of AgNPs in solvent mixture such as 1
:
1 v/v H2O/EtOH. As well known, the competition of ethanol with water will cause the dehydration and the collapse of PNIPAAm chain, leading to the shrinking of PNIPAAm film and the decreased interparticle distances.48,49 This finally caused the formation of more SERS hot-spots in 1
:
1 v/v H2O/EtOH mixture. In Fig. 8c, it's worth mentioning that SERS signals related to ring-breathing mode at 1006 cm−1, β(CH)/β(NH) stretching mode at 1216 cm−1 and the ν(C–C) with protonated nitrogen mode at 1609 cm−1 become much stronger compared to that of the ν(C–C) with deprotonated nitrogen mode at 1577 cm−1, also hinting the improved charge transfer process and the formation of hydrogen bond between the N atom of 4-Mpy and the hydroxyl group of ethanol.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 The SERS spectra of 1 × 10−4 M 4-Mpy using PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film as SERS substrate in H2O (a), EtOH (b) and EtOH/H2O mixture (volume ratio = 5 : 5) (c). | ||
To evaluate the long-term stability of the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film as SERS substrate, the composite film was simply stored in water for 4 months. The composite film was then taken out and the SERS intensity of the analyte was measured. Fig. S8† showed that the SERS signal of 4-Mpy only decreased 12.0% compared to that of the original value, illustrating the good stability of the PNIPAAm/AgNPs composite film.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra04361a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |