Max
Widemann
a,
Sebastian
Jeggle
a,
Maximilian
Auer
a,
Klaus
Eichele
a,
Hartmut
Schubert
a,
Christian P.
Sindlinger
*b and
Lars
Wesemann
*a
aInstitut für Anorganische Chemie, Auf der Morgenstelle 18, 72076 Tübingen, Germany. E-mail: lars.wesemann@uni-tuebingen.de
bInstitut für Anorganische Chemie, RWTH Aachen University, Landoltweg 1a, D-52074 Aachen, Germany. E-mail: christian.sindlinger@ac.rwth-aachen.de
First published on 22nd February 2022
In a reaction of tantalocene trihydride with the low valent aryl tin cation [Ar*Sn(C6H6)][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] (1a) the hydridostannylene complex [Cp2TaH2–Sn(H)Ar*][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] (2) was synthesized. Hydride bridged adducts [Cp2WH2EAr*][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] (E = Sn 3a, Pb 3b) were isolated as products of the reaction between Cp2WH2 and cations [Ar*E(C6H6)][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] (E = Sn 1a, Pb 1b). The tin adduct 3a exhibits a proton migration to give the hydridostannylene complex [Cp2W(H)Sn(H)Ar*][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] 4a. The cationic complex 4a is deprotonated at the tin atom in reaction with base MeNHC at 80 °C to give a hydrido-tungstenostannylene [Cp2W(H)SnAr*] 5a. Reprotonation of metallostannylene 5a with acid [H(Et2O)2][BArF] provides an alternative route to hydridotetrylene coordination. Complex 4a adds hydride to give the dihydrostannyl complex [Cp2W(H)–SnH2Ar*] (7). With styrene 4a shows formation of a hydrostannylation product [Cp2W(H)Sn(CH2CH2Ph)Ar*][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] (8). The lead adduct 3b was deprotonated with MeNHC to give plumbylene 5b [Cp2W(H)PbAr*]. Protonation of 5b with [H(Et2O)2][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] at −40 °C followed by low temperature NMR spectroscopy indicates a hydridoplumbylene intermediate [Cp2W(H)Pb(H)Ar*]+ (4b). Hydrido-tungstenotetrylenes of elements Ge (5c), Sn (5a) and Pb (5b) were also synthesized reacting the salt [Cp2W(H)Li]4 with organotetrylene halides. The metallogermylene [Cp2W(H)GeAr*] (5c) shows an isomerization via 1,2-H-migration to give the hydridogermylene [Cp2WGe(H)Ar*] (9), which is accelerated by addition of AIBN. 9 is at rt photochemically transferred back to 5c under light of a mercury vapor lamp. Zirconocene dihydride [Cp2ZrH2]2 reacts with tin cation 1a to give the trinuclear hydridostannylene adduct 10 [({Cp2Zr}2{μ-H})(μ-H)2μ-Sn(H)Ar*][Al(OC{CF3}3)4]. Deprotonation of 10 was carried out using benzyl potassium to give neutral [({Cp2Zr}2{μ-H})(μ-H)μ-Sn(H)Ar*] (11). 11 was also obtained from the reaction of low valent tin hydride [Ar*SnH]2 with two equivalents of [Cp2ZrH2]2. The trihydride Ar*SnH3 reacts with half of an equivalent of [Cp2ZrH2]2 under evolution of hydrogen and formation of a dihydrostannyl complex 13 [Cp2Zr(μ-H)SnH2Ar*]2 and with further equivalents of Ar*SnH3 to give bis(hydridostannylene) complex [Cp2Zr{Sn(H)Ar*}2].
Low-coordinate cations of heavy Group 14 elements are attractive compounds for reactivity studies.33 Due to their high sensitivity, preparation of these cations was realized using bulky ligands.34,35 Cp* ligands as well as terphenyl derivatives are prominent substituents in this context and cations like [Cp*E]+ (E = Ge, Sn, Pb) and [Ar*E–L]+ (E = Sn, L = NHC, PtBu3; E = Pb, L = toluene) were reported.34,36–40 Furthermore, amides provided with sterically demanding groups stabilize Group 14 element cations, which exhibit further contacts with flanking aryl or imine groups.41–43 Chelating ligands like diketiminates or aminotroponiminates have also been employed for synthesis of low-coordinate cations of Ge, Sn and Pb.44,45 So far, reactivity studies of those low valent cations focus on studies of oxidative additions.33,35,46 Thus, Tobita and co-workers studied insertion of a cationic metallogermylene into E–H bonds (E = H, B, and Si).35 We present in this publication reactions of low-valent Group 14 cations of Sn and Pb with bis(cyclopentadienyl) hydrides of zirconium, tantalum and tungsten resulting in the formation hydridotetrylene coordination compounds. The metallocene hydrides were chosen because of their good accessibility and different electron configurations. In the case of germanium, a reversible interconversion between a coordinated hydridogermylene and hydrido-metallogermylene is presented.
Dissolved in 1,2-difluorobenzene (o-DFB) the cations were reacted with one equivalent of a benzene solution of tantalocene trihydride Cp2TaH3. In the case of the tin cation a product was selectively formed (Scheme 2) and in the lead case a mixture of undefined reaction products was obtained. The tantalum complex 2 was isolated by crystallization and in Fig. 1 the molecular structure of the cation of 2 is depicted.
In the cationic tantalum complex 2 a Ta–Sn bond is formed, and a hydride is transferred from the tantalum atom to the tin atom resulting in coordination of hydridoorgano stannylene [Ar*SnH]. The Ta–Sn bond length of 2.7207(2) Å can be compared with the Ta–Sn bond [2.752(1) Å] found in complex Cp2TaH2(SnCl2CH3).52 The LUMO of cation 2 shown in Fig. 1 exhibits to a larger extent an empty p-orbital at the tin atom. In the 1H NMR for the Ta–H units a doublet was found at −3.75 ppm (3JHH = 1.4 Hz), also showing coupling with the tin atom (2JSnH = 300 Hz). The signal for the Sn–H unit (t, 3JHH = 1.7 Hz) was found at a relatively high frequency, 15.55 ppm, showing a large 1JSn–H coupling constant (1JSnH = ca. 1040 Hz). Hydridostannylene coordination at osmium exhibits a comparable signal in the 1H NMR spectrum [Cp*(iPr3P)(H)OsSn(H)trip, 1H NMR 19.4 ppm (SnH), 1JSnH = 775 Hz, 119Sn NMR 786 ppm].19 The 119Sn NMR signal of 2 at 1161 ppm (dt, 1JSnH = 1047 Hz, 2JSnH = 308 Hz) can be compared with signals found for triply coordinate stannylium cations [R3Sn]+ (R = Trip 714 ppm, R = Dur 720 ppm, R = tBu2MeSi 2653 ppm) (Trip = 2,4,6-iPr3C6H2, Dur = 2,3,5,6-Me4C6H).53–57 To rationalize the 119Sn NMR data of 2, NMR chemical shift calculations have been carried out using ORCA and ADF program packages.58–60 The calculated chemical shift of the tin atom of 2 amounts to 981 ppm (exp. 1161 ppm). Furthermore, in the optimized structure of 2, contacts between one of the aryl moieties of the terphenyl substituent and the tin atom were found. Thus, complex 2 can be regarded as a hydridostannylene complex with a stannylene acting as σ-donor ligand exhibiting no π-acceptor character. This results in an empty p-orbital at the tin atom and the triply coordinate tin atom can be regarded as a stannylium cation. Furthermore, a 119Sn NMR signal at 1161 ppm lies in the range of known triply coordinate stannylium cations (vide supra) and therefore interactions of the TaH units with the stannylium cation of 2 can be excluded.
In contrast to tantalocene trihydride Cp2TaH3 the transition metal in tungstenocene dihydride Cp2WH2 is not in the maximum possible oxidation state but in state four and has two valence electrons. Reacting the cations [Ar*Sn]+1a and [Ar*Pb]+1b (see ESI for synthetic details†) with Cp2WH2 at low temperature (−40 °C) resulted in highly coloured reaction mixtures [E: Sn (3a) pink; Pb (3b) violet] (Scheme 3). Unlike complex 2, the resulting products 3a and 3b do not show any hydride transfer to the main group metal, instead, coordination of the Cp2WH2 fragment via the hydride substituents at the electrophilic Group 14 element was found.
In the 1H NMR spectrum both complexes 3a and 3b exhibit at rt a broad resonance for the hydride substituents [−10.83 (3a), −7.55 ppm (3b)]. Below −20 °C two different isomers are observable, a symmetric one (3s): 3as −10.86 ppm, JW–H 78 Hz; 3bs −7.49 ppm, JW–H 75 Hz; and an asymmetric one (3as): 3aas −11.13 ppm, JW–H 51 Hz, −8.57 ppm, JW–H 77 Hz; 3bas −12.31 ppm, JW–H 52 Hz, −4.30 ppm, JW–H 76 Hz (signal at higher frequency corresponds to the bridging W–H–E unit). Only in the 1H NMR spectra of 3a183W satellites were unambiguously observed. Due to shorter relaxation times of the 119Sn nucleus, tin satellites are expected to be broadened beyond recognition, however 1J119Sn–H coupling was observed in the 119Sn NMR spectrum. These isomers have also been characterized by an 1H–183W-HMQC-NMR experiment at −40 °C featuring cross peaks for the symmetric and asymmetric isomer (see ESI for spectra†). Rocchigian, Bochmann and Hrobárik et al. reported recently on the different coordination modes of Cp2WH2 at Au(I)/Au(III) cations.61 In the case of asymmetric hydride coordination a comparable 1H NMR spectrum was observed: −11.4 ppm, JW–H 48 Hz, −9.6 ppm, JW–H 61 Hz.61 Furthermore, chemical exchange of all hydrides in cations 3 was proven by 1H–1H EXSY NMR studies. For the characterization of the isomers by 119Sn, 207Pb and 183W NMR spectroscopy see Table 1 and the ESI.† The chemical shift of the heteroatoms tin and lead in the hydride bridged complexes 3a (119Sn: 1786, 1735 ppm) and 3b (207Pb: 7986 ppm, 207Pb NMR signal of other isomer was not observed) can be compared with the values found for the rhodium complexes showing a comparable structural motif [(Ph3P)2RhH2EAr*] [E = Sn 1728 ppm, E = Pb 8195 ppm].62 The 183W chemical shifts of 3a and 3b (Table 1) lie in the range known for metallocene hydride complexes of tungsten.63–65 The 183W chemical shift is more affected by the isomerism, symmetric or asymmetric (3asvs.3aas, 3bsvs.3bas: ≈300–400 ppm), than the nature of the tetrel, tin or lead (3asvs.3bs, 3aasvs.3bas: ≈35–80 ppm).
Compound (E) | 1H NMR M–H [ppm] | J 183W–H [Hz] | 1H NMR E–H [ppm] | J E–H (E: 119Sn/207Pb) [Hz] | 119Sn/207Pb NMR [ppm] | 183W NMR | d M–E [Å] |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Not isolated, observed in solution as intermediate. | |||||||
2 (Sn) | −3.75 | 15.55 | 1040 | 1161 | 2.7207(2) | ||
3a (Sn) | |||||||
3a s | −10.86 | 78 | ca. 270 | 1786 | −3910 | ||
3a as | −11.13, −8.57 | 51, 77 | 1735 | −4309 | |||
3b (Pb) | |||||||
3b s | −7.49 | 75 | 7986 | −3994 | |||
3b as | −12.31, −4.30 | 52, 76 | −4259 | ||||
4a (Sn) | −12.57 | 67 | 15.13 | 1193 (1J), 129 (2J) | 1057 | −3629 | 2.6221(2) |
4b (Pb) | −13.67 | 66 | 42.13 | ca. 530 | |||
4c (Ge) | −11.08 | 69 | 11.30 | −3585 | |||
5a (Sn) | −12.37 | 90 | 2883 | −4182 | 2.7589(4)/2.7488(4) | ||
5b (Pb) | −16.15 | 91 | 10534 | −2772 | 2.8226(2) | ||
5c (Ge) | −11.03 | 92 | −4079 | ||||
6 (Sn) | −13.82 | 63 | 6.33 | 1344 (1J), 165 (2J) | −231 | −4378 | |
7 | −12.91 | 66 | 5.12 | 1274, 1216 | −236 | −3921 | 2.7582(2) |
8 | −12.51 | 68 | 132 (2J) | 1223 | −3526 | ||
9 | 10.04 | −3096 |
Using a slight excess of Cp2WH2 in the synthesis of 3a (E: Sn), the deep pink solution decolourises to orange to form the cationic hydridotungsten hydridostannylene complex 4a. Presumably, mediated by the basic Cp2WH2, as a proton-shuttle, a tungsten-bound proton of 3a migrates to Sn and a W–Sn bond is formed.66 The model of a proton-migration mediated by a Bronsted-basic Cp2WH2 is corroborated by the observation that addition of amine-bases such as diethyl methylamine to isolated 3a equally enables the isomerization (Scheme 4). The molecular structure of the cation of 4a is shown in Fig. 2. The W–Sn bond length of 2.6221(2) Å is shorter than typical single bonds (2.68–2.81 Å)2,67–71 between these elements and longer than the W–Sn triple bond (2.46–2.50 Å).72,73 In quantum chemical calculations π-donation from tungsten to the empty p-orbital at tin atom was found in addition to a W–Sn σ-bond (see ESI† for details of DFT calculations using ORCA and NBO analysis).58,59,74 The short W–Sn bond in 4a together with the slight π-donation from W to the empty p-orbital at tin might be interpreted as an indicator for partial double bond character between tin and tungsten. In the 1H NMR spectrum the signals of the hydride units in 4a (W–H −12.73 ppm, Sn–H 15.13 ppm) were found at frequencies typical for Cp2WH-fragments and hydridostannylene coordination.19,22,30,61 The 1JSn–H coupling constant of 1193 Hz lies close to the values found in 2 and in the literature examples [Cp2M(Ar*SnH)2] M: Ti 1250 Hz, Zr 1125 Hz, Hf 1060 Hz.30 In the 119Sn NMR spectrum the signal was found at 1057 ppm corroborating stannylene coordination at transition metals.19,75 Deprotonation of 4a was carried out in reaction with a N-heterocyclic carbene 1,3,4,5-tetramethylimidazol-2-ylidene (MeNHC) at 80 °C in toluene/1,2-difluorobenzene (Scheme 4). The colour of the solution changes from orange to yellow to green and metallostannylene 5a was isolated after crystallization in a yield of 44%. The molecular structure of 5a is presented in Fig. 2. The W–Sn bond length of 2.7589(4) Å is a short single bond for a metallostannylene of tungsten (vide supra).76,77 Comparing the W–Sn bond lengths in 4a [2.6221(2) Å] and 5a [2.7488(4) Å], due to the partial double bond character, found for 4a, the protonated derivative 4a exhibits a shorter W–Sn length. In the 119Sn{1H} NMR spectrum of 5a a signal at high frequency of 2883 ppm indicates a metallostannylene.76 The signal for the W–H hydride of 5a was found in the 1H NMR spectrum in the typical range for transition metal hydrides at −12.37 ppm. Reprotonation of metallostannylene 5a at the tin atom was achieved in reaction with the acid [H(Et2O)2][BArF]78 to give the cationic hydridostannylene complex 4a, now with the weakly coordinating anion [BArF]− (Scheme 4). Thus, protonation of metallostannylene complexes is an alternative route for the synthesis of hydridotetrylene coordination compounds.
Scheme 4 (i) MeNHC, toluene/C6H4F2, 70 °C, 3 d, – [MeNHC–H][Al(OC{CF3}3)4], (ii) [H(Et2O)2][BArF] toluene/o-DFB. {[B(3,5-{CF3}2C6H3)4]− = [BArF]−}. |
Deprotonation of the cation 4a was achieved with MeNHC at 80 °C (Scheme 4). Reacting the cation with the carbene at rt an adduct (Scheme 5, 6) of the N-heterocyclic carbene at the tin was isolated and characterized by NMR spectroscopy. This adduct 6 is also the product of the reaction between 3a and MeNHC. Heating this adduct 6 to 80 °C gives the deprotonation product 5a. Tobita et al. studied the NHC-induced conversion of hydrido(hydrogermylene) complexes into a germylyne coordination compound. In this stepwise procedure NHC-adduct formation was found followed by deprotonation of a W–H unit by the NHC.79,80 The reactivity of the cationic arylhydridostannylene complex 4a was investigated in reaction with LiAlH4 (Scheme 6) and styrene (Scheme 7). Nucleophilic attack of a hydride anion at the tin atom of cation 4a was observed in reaction with LiAlH4. The aryldihydridostannyl ligand coordinates at the tungsten atom in complex 7 with a W–Sn bond length of 2.7582(2) Å.2,67–71 The reverse reaction, hydride abstraction from complex 7 was also investigated in reaction with the trityl salt [Ph3C][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] to give the salt 4a in moderate yield of 71% based on results of NMR spectroscopy (Scheme 6). Direct addition or elimination of hydrogen (to transfer of 5a into 7 or 7 into 5a) was not observed (heating or photochemical activation of 7, addition of hydrogen to 5a, 1–3.5 atm). However, stepwise addition and abstraction of protons and hydride ligands is a possible pathway for the reversible conversion of 5a into 7 (Scheme 4 and 6).
Scheme 6 Addition and abstraction of protons and hydride ligands. (i): rt, LiAlH4, Et2O; (ii): rt, [Ph3C][Al(OC{CF3}3)4], o-DFB. |
With an excess of styrene, hydride complex 4a exhibits hydrostannylation of the olefin at 75 °C (Scheme 7). Insertion of olefines and carbon dioxide into the Sn–H bond of low valent organotinhydrides was studied by Power et al. and for a coordinated organohydrido germylene another example of styrene insertion is presented in the literature.14,29,81
In the case of the low valent lead cation the tungstenocene dihydride adduct 3b does not exhibit a hydrogen atom migration from tungsten to lead as in the case of the tin compound 3a. Lead adduct 3b was readily deprotonated at rt by MeNHC to yield the plumbylene complex 5b (Scheme 8). Evidence for the formation of an NHC adduct comparable to 6 was not found. Plumbylene 5b was crystallized from a pentane solution at −40 °C (see Fig. 3 for ORTEP of the molecular structure). The W–Pb distance of 2.8226(2) Å found in 5b is shorter than the W–Pb distance in the plumbylene [Cp(CO)3W–PbAr*, W–Pb 3.006(1) Å].82 Furthermore the 207Pb NMR resonance of 5b was observed at a very high frequency of 10534 ppm [Cp(CO)3W–PbAr* 207Pb NMR 9374 ppm].82 Protonation of 5b was carried out at −40 °C using [H(Et2O)2][Al(OC{CF3}3)4] as the proton source (Scheme 8). The cold reaction mixture was directly investigated by low temperature 1H NMR spectroscopy. Besides signals of the starting material 5b, and the product 3b two new signals at very low (−13.67 ppm) and very high (42.13 ppm) frequencies were detected. Based on a 1H–1H–COSY-LR-NMR experiment (see ESI†) both signals belong to the same compound. Furthermore, the signal at high frequency exhibits both 207Pb- (530 Hz) and 183W-satellites (39 Hz). In the case of the low frequency signal 183W-satellites (66 Hz) were observed. Due to comparable spectroscopic data, we speculate about the structure of this intermediate 4b and suggest a hydridoplumbylene motive like in the tin case 4a. Based on this molecular structure of 4a the tin atom was exchanged against a lead atom and this structure was optimized using DFT calculations (see ESI for details†).58,59 This optimized structure was used for chemical shift calculations of the protons with the ADF program package.60 The results of these calculations [PbH exp. 42.13 ppm, calc. 39.3 ppm and WH exp. −13.67 ppm, calc. −11.5 ppm] lie close to the experimentally observed signals. This extreme high frequency chemical shift of the PbH unit at 42.13 ppm can be explained with the spin–orbit coupling of the heavy atom with the light atom (SO-HALA effect).83 This effect was already observed for low valent lead hydride exhibiting a 1H NMR signal at 35.61 ppm.49 However, 4b is only an intermediate in the protonation of 5b and the isolation was not possible, which could be due to the weak Pb–H bond. With these NMR data of 4b we present first indications for a hydridoplumbylene ligand as the missing piece of Group 14 hydridotetrylene coordination chemistry.
Scheme 8 (i): + MeNHC, toluene/o-DFB, rt, 3 h, − [MeNHC–H][Al(OC{CF3}3)4], (ii): + [H(Et2O)2][Al(OC{CF3}3)4], toluene/C6H4F2, rt, – 2 Et2O. |
An alternative protocol for the synthesis of tungstenocenyl substituted tetrylenes 5a and 5b starts with deprotonated tungstenocene dihydride [Cp2W(H)Li]4 (Scheme 9). In reaction of the anionic hydride with the respective low valent aryltetrylene halides, the tetrylenes of tin and lead were straightforwardly synthesized. Based on NMR spectroscopy the products were formed nearly quantitatively and after crystallization isolated in moderate yield.
To synthesize the homologous tungstenocenyl substituted germylene 5c the tetrameric anion [Cp2W(H)Li]4 was reacted with arylgermanium chloride (Scheme 10). After five minutes stirring at rt in the dark green solution, a mixture of products was identified by 1H NMR spectroscopy: two signals exhibiting 183W-satellites were found at −11.03 ppm (1JW–H = 92 Hz) and +10.02 ppm (1JW–H = 35 Hz). The signal at low frequency together with the 1JW–H coupling constant is an indicator for a W–H unit and fits in the series of tetrylene tungsten hydride complexes [Cp2W(H)-EAr*]: E = Pb (5b) −16.15 ppm, (1JW–H = 91 Hz), E = Sn (5a) −12.37 ppm, (1JW–H = 90 Hz), E = Ge (5c) −11.03 ppm (Table 1). After stirring the product mixture for further 24 h the signal at low frequencies indicating 5c vanished and only the hydride signal at high frequency remains. Therefore, we suggest germylene 5c being the kinetically controlled product. Crystallization at −40 °C yields dark green crystals of the arylhydridogermylene complex 9 in moderate yield (53%). The molecular structure of 9 is shown in Fig. 3. Probing the electronic structure of complex 9 DFT calculations together with NBO analysis were performed. Representative NLMOs for the σ- and π-bond were placed in the ESI.† The WGe distance of 2.427(3) Å found in 9 can be compared with hydridogermylene coordination at a CpW(CO)2 fragment synthesized by Tobita et al. [2.4289(8) Å].21
To further investigate the transformation of the kinetically controlled product 5cvia a 1,2-H-shift into the thermodynamically controlled product 9, a solution of a crystalline sample of 9 was treated with light from a mercury-vapor lamp. A mixture between 9 and 5c (40%/60%) was observed (Scheme 11). Interestingly, from this mixture transformation of 5c to 9 is much slower (14 d at 40 °C) than in the original reaction mixture (Scheme 10). The faster 1,2-H-shift in the original reaction mixture is probably caused by side products resulting from the synthesis. After addition of AIBN to this mixture (crystalline sample) a much faster conversion of 5c to 9 was observed making a radical mechanism feasible. With the reversible conversion of 5c to 9 a rare example for a reversible 1,2-H-shift together with the direct observation of both species, the hydrido-metallogermylene (5c) and hydridogermylene (9) is presented. DFT calculations confirm both germanium isomers 5c and 9 being close in energy (see ESI for further details of DFT calculations†). However, in the case of the homologous tin compounds DFT calculations clearly indicate higher stability of the hydrido-metallostannylene isomer (5a) compared to a hypothetical arylhydridostannylene-coordination (analogous to Ge-compound 9). Tilley and co-workers investigated the 1,2-hydrogen migration of heavy group 14 element hydrides coordinated at transition metal centres and have drawn the conclusion, that for tin the hydrido-metallotetrylenes are favoured, in contrast to silicon and germanium, both preferring the hydridotetrylene coordination.14,19,20,22,84,85 Green et al. published a reversible 1,2-H-shift equilibrium between a hydridocarbene transition metal complex and a methyl ligand.86 In the case of metallostannylene 5a our results are in line with the findings made by Tilley et al.84,85 The germanium isomers 9 and 5c are remarkably close in energy and therefore we were able to characterize both products of 1,2-H shift (Scheme 11).
Protonation of complex 9 was studied in reaction with acid [H(Et2O)2][BArF] in a mixture of pentane and 1,2-difluorobenzene (Scheme 12). Yellow crystalline material was isolated in moderate yield and based on the NMR data (Table 1) the protonation of the tungsten atom was found. This type of reaction was already presented in the literature in the case of a germylene complex of ruthenium, which was protonated at the transition metal in reaction with a strong Brønsted acid.14 Cation 4c is a homologue of the isolated tin cation 4a and the intermediately formed plumbylene 4b. The 1H NMR data (signals of GeH and WH, Table 1) of 4c are in line with the data of the heavier homologues.
Both cations, the low valent lead and tin cation (1a, 1b), were also reacted with zirconocene dihydride [Cp2ZrH2]2, but only in the case of the tin salt reaction products could be isolated (Scheme 13).87–89 Salt 10 was selectively formed no matter which stoichiometry was chosen. After stirring an equimolar mixture of 1a and dimeric dihydride followed by crystallization from 1,2-diflourobenzene at −40 °C yellow crystals of 10 were isolated in a yield of 69%. The molecular structure in the solid state is depicted in Fig. 4. The dimeric motif of the zirconocene dihydride remains intact. The tin cation coordinates at two Zr–H units forming two hydride bridges showing almost similar Zr–Sn distances [3.0185(2), 3.0325(2) Å]. Due to the hydride bridge the Zr–Sn distances are much longer than bond lengths found for typical stannylene coordination [2.794(1)–2.872(1) Å].30,75,90,91 One hydride ligand is transferred to the tin atom as a terminal coordinating hydride. The hydride atoms inside the six membered ring were found in the final difference Fourier map and the [–Zr–H–Sn–H–Zr–H–] ring shows an almost planar structural motif. This type of dimeric zirconium–hydride complex chelating a main group element fragment was also described by Bulychev et al. for [(Cp2ZrH)2H(AlCl2)].92,93 In the 1H NMR spectrum the Sn–H hydride ligand exhibits a signal at 9.06 ppm (1JSn–H = 1344 Hz), which can be compared with values observed for Ar*SnH coordination at group 4 metallocene fragments.30 The signals for the bridging hydride ligands were observed at lower frequencies Zr–H–Sn (−0.06 ppm) and Zr–H–Zr (−6.24 ppm), lying in the region typical for zirconium hydrides.92 The 119Sn-NMR signal was observed at relatively low frequency (440 ppm) for low valent tin but can be explained with the high coordination number at the tin atom. The electronic situation was investigated using DFT calculations together with NBO analysis. The lone pair of the tin atom is shared between the two Zr (24, 23%) and the Sn (48%) atoms featuring a three centre two electron bond (see Fig. 4 for NLMO). Both Zr–H units (H2, H3) donate roughly 10% of the two electrons of the bond into the empty p-orbital of tin (see ESI for NLMO†). We interpret compound 10 as a low valent aryl tin hydride Ar*SnH chelated by the cation [(Cp2ZrH)2H]+via two hydride bridges.
Scheme 13 Synthesis of the hydride bridged trinuclear SnZr2–cation and deprotonation to give 11 (L = C6H6). |
Deprotonation of the cationic hydride 10 was successful with the strong base benzyl potassium to give the trinuclear hydride [(Cp2Zr)2H2SnHAr*] 11, which was crystallized from hexane solution at −40 °C (Scheme 13, Fig. 5 and ESI† for molecular structure and NLMOs of 11). The deprotonation reduced the zirconium atoms to oxidation state III. Reprotonation of 11 was achieved at −40 °C with [H(Et2O)2][BArF] in 1,2-difluorobenzene as solvent (Scheme 13). Hydride 11 features a Zr–Sn bond of 2.8597(5) Å, which can be compared with stannylene coordination at zirconocene fragments [2.79–2.87 Å].75,90,91 Complex 11 was also investigated using DFT calculations and NLMOs representing the Zr–Sn σ-bond and the three centre Zr–Sn–Zr two electron bond are presented in ESI.† In the 1H NMR spectrum recorded at rt only broad signals were observed. At −20 °C however for each Cp–ligand and the hydride substituents sharp signals were found [Sn–H: 7.19 ppm 1JSn–H ≈ 860 Hz, Zr–H–Zr −12.90 ppm, Zr–H–Sn −3.08 ppm]. Via1H–1H-EXSY-NMR an exchange between the terminal Sn–H and the bridging Zr–H–Sn hydride ligands was detected. The exchange of these hydride ligands (Scheme 14) should be responsible for the broadening of the signals in the rt NMR spectrum.
An alternative synthetic pathway for the formation of complex 11 was found with the reaction of Power's low valent tin hydride 12 with zirconocene dihydride in toluene at room temperature (Scheme 15, ratio Sn/Zr: 1/2).47 After a spontaneous liberation of dihydrogen, product complex 11 was isolated in high yield (92%) and, based on NMR spectroscopy, in high purity. Crystallization from hexane affords 11 as black/brown crystals. Interestingly, the stepwise formation of 11 was found by stirring a pentane suspension of the zirconium hydride [Cp2ZrH2]2 and low valent tin hydride 12 (ratio Sn/Zr: 1/1) at rt for 2 h. Double insertion of the tin moieties into the terminal Zr–H units was found and the bis(aryldihydridostannyl) complex 13 (Scheme 15, Fig. 5 for molecular structure) was isolated in a yield of 82%. After addition of a further equivalent of zirconocene dihydride to a toluene solution of 13, liberation of dihydrogen together with formation of 11 was found (Scheme 15).
Complex 13 was also formed in reaction of Ar*SnH3 and 0.5 [Cp2ZrH2]2. Addition of further equivalents of Ar*SnH3 yields together with liberation of hydrogen the hydridostannylene complex [Cp2Zr(SnHAr*)2] (14) (Scheme 16).30 The formation of the Zr–Sn bonds in 13 and 14 is an example for dehydrocoupling reactions between Zr–H and Sn–H species via a σ-bond metathesis. This type of M–Sn bond formation was discussed as part of the mechanism in dehydropolymerizations of secondary stannanes catalyzed by zirconocene and hafnocene derivatives.94–96
Metallotetrylene complexes of tungstenocene [Cp2W(H)EAr*] (E = Ge, Sn, Pb) were also synthesized in reaction of the deprotonation product [Cp2W(H)Li]4 with aryltetrylene halides of germanium, tin, and lead. Only in the case of germanium a reversible transformation of the hydrido-tungstenogermylene [Cp2W(H)GeAr*] (5c) to the hydridogermylene [Cp2WGeHAr*] (9) was observed. In comparison to the 1,2-H shift at 40 °C (14 d), after addition of AIBN product formation (40 °C) was completely finished after 5 days. Likely, this 1,2-H shift from the tungsten to the germanium atom is catalyzed by radical species. Under the influence of light, a 1,2-H transfer back to the tungsten atom was found. Therefore, interconversion between metallogermylene (5c) and hydridogermylene (9) represents a system that exhibits a directly observable and reversible 1,2-H-migration. Corroborated by DFT calculations the 1,2-H shift between 5c and 9 is almost an isenthalpic reaction.
Dimeric zirconocene dihydride [Cp2ZrH2]2 was reacted with the low valent tin cation [Ar*Sn]+ and the low valent tin hydride [Ar*SnH]2. Whereas the cationic product was deprotonated to give the dimeric Zr(III) complex [({Cp2Zr}2{μ-H})(μ-H)Sn(H)Ar*] (11), this complex together with hydrogen resulted directly from the reaction with [ArSnH]2. Aryltintrihydride Ar*SnH3 reacts with dimeric zirconium dihydride to give, as a product of dehydrocoupling reactions via σ-bond metathesis, the bis(hydridostannylene) complex of zirconocene [Cp2Zr(SnHAr*)2].
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Full characterization, NMR spectra, DFT details and XYZ coordinates. CCDC 2142080–2142089. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d2sc00297c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |