Brandon A.
Fultz
,
Drake
Beery
,
Brianna M.
Coia
,
Kenneth
Hanson
and
Justin G.
Kennemur
*
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL 32303, USA. E-mail: jkennemur@fsu.edu
First published on 15th September 2020
Tris(trimethylsilyl)silane (TTMSS) is introduced as a non-toxic and kinetically superior hydrogen source for the photo-driven reduction of trithiocarbonates from poly(methyl methacrylate), polystyrene, and poly(vinyl pyridine)s (PVP)s created through RAFT polymerization. No other reagents were necessary and quantitative reduction is achieved under UV- and blue-light irradiation. PVP reduction and sequestering of chain combination events is investigated for the first time.
Light-mediated removal of thiocarbonylthio end groups has recently received increased attention due to its facile approach and performance at ambient temperatures. Mattson et al. reported irradiation at 380 nm to remove TTC groups from poly(tert-butyl acrylate) over the course of 48 h while incorporating 10-phenylphenothiazine (PTH) as a photoredox catalyst in the presence of tributylamine and formic acid.8 Soon after, Discekici et al. utilized 465 nm irradiation and a photocatalyst, Eosin Y, to promote hydrogen replacement of TTC groups in the presence of hexylamine and tri-n-butylphosphine.9 Carmean et al. reported a photoinduced removal of TTC, dithiobenzoate (DTB), xanthate, and dithiocarbamate (DTC) agents using EPHP at ambient temperatures and without the need for additional initiators or photocatalysts.10 This method was effective for a variety of polymers (acrylamides, acrylates, methacrylates, styrenes, and pyrrolidones) with little degradation but also required long irradiation times (≥24 h) for complete removal of TTC, DTB, and DTC agents. Another notable conclusion from this study was that the concentration of EPHP had little effect on the reduction kinetics and the rate limiting step was concluded to be photolysis of the C–S bond connecting the thiocarbonylthio group to the polymer chain end.10 Uchiyama et al. recently investigated thermal and photo-driven xanthate, DTB, and TTC removal from poly(vinyl acetate) (PVAc), PS, and poly(methyl acrylate) (PMA).11 Using triphenylsilane (Ph3SiH) as a hydrogen source and n-dodecanethiol as a polarity reversal catalyst, quantitative removal of the CTAs under irradiation (λ = 365 nm, 0.70 mW cm−2) occurred after ≥75 h. Notably, they also showed rapid increase in reduction kinetics when irradiating with blue light (λ = 470 nm, 70 mW cm−2) in the presence of a photo-radical initiator, biphenyl(2,4,6-trimethylbenzoyl)phosphine oxide (TPO).
To the best of our knowledge, there have been no studies on the reduction of thiocarbonylthio reagents from poly(2-vinylpyridine) (P2VP) systems and poly(4-vinylpyridine) (P4VP) that are receiving increased interest for association of variety of guests through pyridine coordination.12 Due to complications with copper association on PVPs during atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP),13–15 RAFT has become the CRP of choice to produce PVPs and a study focused on the facile removal of their CTA end groups is needed. While early studies showed success using DTB CTA for the RAFT synthesis of P2VP and P4VP,16 a large number of recent manuscripts, including ours,17 have used TTC CTAs to produce both isomers with good control.18–29
The investigation of CTA removal from PVPs is warranted due to the aromaticity of the pyridine pendant groups. This is analogous to PS which has been highly studied and is consistently problematic in earlier reports. A major issue stems from the benzylic radical chain end produced upon scission of the C–S bond on PS and its competitive termination through combination versus hydrogen abstraction. This results in the appearance of high molar mass shouldering in size exclusion chromatography (SEC) analysis and concludes significant chain coupling (doubling in molar mass) during the reduction reactions. Additionally, the benzylic radicals are comparatively stable. Photoinduced end group removal is therefore sluggish and often requires days of irradiation with non-quantitative removal.10 PVPs are also prone to termination through combination.30,31 Investigating whether similar complications occur with reduction of PVPs was the initial motivation for this study. However, we were also intrigued by the recent yet promising results of Ph3SiH as a hydrogen source for photo-driven reductions (both UV and blue light).11 Alternatively, TTMSS is a non-toxic hydrosilane that exhibited much faster reduction kinetics in the thermally driven reduction methods.6 Herein we introduce TTMSS as a powerful and rapid reducing agent, requiring no additional reagents, for photo-driven reduction of PMMA, PS, P2VP and P4VP for the first time.
IDa | Polymer | M n,SEC (kDa) | M n,NMR (kDa) | Đ | Hydrogen source | t 1/2d (h) | % TTC removale | Durationf (h) | After TTC removal | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M n,SEC | Đ | |||||||||
a All reactions were performed with hydrogen source:TTC of 15:1, ([TTS]0 = 5.5 mM) in THF and irradiated at 365 nm otherwise noted. b A 50:50 solvent mixture of DMAC:toluene was used, and molecular weight was characterized via1H NMR end group analysis. c Irradiated with 452 nm. d Values were determined as the irradiation time in which initial absorbance [TTC]0 was reduced by half. e TTS removal was evaluated by UV-Vis spectroscopy and determined to be >99% when <0.1 OD was achieved. f Irradiation time needed to reach <0.1 ABS determined by UV-Vis. | ||||||||||
1 | PMMA-TTC | 6.1 | 5.9 | 1.08 | TTMSS | 0.2 | >99 | 1 | 5.8 | 1.08 |
2 | PMMA-TTC | 6.1 | 5.9 | 1.08 | EPHP | 2 | >99 | 18 | 6.2 | 1.14 |
3 | P2VP-TTC | 8.5 | 8.3 | 1.08 | TTMSS | 0.4 | >99 | 1.5 | 8.3 | 1.12 |
4b | P4VP-TTC | — | 7.6 | — | TTMSS | 0.3 | >99 | 1.25 | — | — |
5 | PS-TTC | 7.8 | 7.8 | 1.1 | TTMSS | 2.4 | >99 | 6.25 | 7.8 | 1.16 |
6 | P2VP-TTC | 8.5 | 8.3 | 1.08 | EPHP | 5 | >99 | 26.5 | 6.5 | 1.19 |
7b | P4VP-TTC | — | 7.6 | — | EPHP | 4 | >99 | 24 | — | — |
8c | P2VP-TTC | 8.5 | 8.3 | 1.08 | TTMSS | 0.6 | >99 | 1.25 | 8.1 | 1.10 |
We were encouraged by the greatly enhanced reduction kinetics of TTMSS (1 h) versus those reported using identical molar equivalents of EPHP on acrylic-TTC end groups (24 h) previously.10 To ensure this disparity in kinetics was not an artifact of our own experimental setup, we recreated the reduction of PMMA-TTC under the exact same conditions with the exception that TTMSS was replaced with EPHP (Table 1, entry 2). After an initial rapid decrease in the UV-Vis absorbance of TTC (t1/2 = 2 h), the reaction rate decreased and total loss of TTC absorption required 18 h (Fig. S6 and S7†). The t1/2 value for TTMSS (0.2 h) was an order of magnitude faster than EPHP (2 h) (Table 1). Interestingly, SEC analysis after reduction to PMMA-H using EPHP revealed some shouldering at higher molar mass (Đ = 1.14, Fig. S8†). The rate limiting step for EPHP reduction was proposed to be photolytic degradation of the C–S bond,10 however, such a drastic difference in reduction kinetics by changing the hydrogen source may indicate other mechanistic aspects need consideration.
To investigate RAFT agent removal from PVPs, we began with P2VP-TTC (Mn = 8.5 kg mol−1, Đ = 1.08) (Table 1, entry 3). Reduction of P2VP-TTC using TTMSS (15 equiv. to TTC) in THF (5.5 mM TTC) (Fig. 1a) resulted in complete reduction in 1.5 h (t1/2 = 24 min) (Fig. 1b and c) and was accompanied by a visible change in appearance from a yellow to colorless solution (Fig. S9†). 1H NMR analysis of P2VP-H (Fig. 1e and S10†) displayed a complete loss of TTC dodecyl methylene signals (∼3.2 ppm), indicating quantitative removal. SEC of P2VP-H (Fig. 1d) displayed a small increase in elution time and a slight broadening (Đ = 1.12) at the higher molar mass side of the peak, indicating some chain combination has occurred. However, the absence of pronounced shouldering suggests these events are not as prominent compared to PS (vide infra). Due to insolubility of P4VP-TTC (Mn = 7.6 kg mol−1) in THF, reduction kinetics were investigated in a 50:50 v/v mixture of N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAC):toluene using TTMSS (15 equiv. to TTC) (Table 1, entry 4). UV-Vis analysis revealed slightly faster reduction than P2VP-TTC and complete after 1.25 h of irradiation (t1/2 = 20 min) (Fig. 2b and c). The loss of dodecyl TTC methylene signal by 1H NMR was also confirmed (Fig. 2d). Therefore, TTMSS is a fast and efficient hydrogen source to remove and replace the TTC end group on both P2VP and P4VP isomers.
Although the SEC trace for P2VP-H indicates minor chain combination events, we compared this outcome to a reduction on PS-TTC (Mn = 7.8 kg mol−1, Đ = 1.10) under identical conditions (Table 1, entry 5). UV-Vis analysis revealed complete reduction in 6.25 h (t1/2 = 2.4 h) (Fig. S11†) which is the fastest of any photo-driven reductions on PS to date. Successful removal of the TTC was again confirmed by 1H NMR (Fig. S11 and S12†). SEC analysis of PS-H revealed substantial shouldering at higher molar mass indicative of prominent chain coupling (Fig. S11†), consistent with previous reports. Therefore, we conclude P2VP to be much less prone to combination events in comparison to PS.
For additional comparison, the use of EPHP as a hydrogen source was also explored for P2VP-TTC and P4VP-TTC under the same conditions used for TTMSS (Table 1, entries 6 and 7). EPHP reduction on P2VP and P4VP resulted in longer reaction times of 26.5 h (t1/2 = 5 h) and 24 h (t1/2 = 4 h), respectively, to reach complete removal of the TTC groups (Fig. S6†). The reduction of P4VP was, again, slightly faster than P2VP. 1H NMR analysis confirmed complete removal of the TTC groups (Fig. S13–S15†), while SEC analysis indicated a higher increase in dispersity (1.19) and shouldering (Fig. S16†). The final absorbance of P2VP-H and P4VP-H minimized at ∼0.12 O.D. and the reaction solution maintained a light yellow-orange color throughout. Interestingly, reductions performed on P2VP and P4VP with TTMSS resulted in a colorless solution (<0.1 O.D. in the visible region) and a white polymer upon workup. This suggests that EPHP may be interacting with the PVP systems to cause some discoloration.
Comparative reduction kinetics for each polymer were analyzed by plotting logarithmic concentration of reduced TTC groups (ln([CTA]0/[CTA]) as a function of time (Fig. 3). Kinetic studies were validated for each polymer with linear calibrations of [TTC]0 as a function of ABS (Fig. S38–S45†). Consistent with previous studies,10 the kinetics of reduction follow a quasi-first order trend with a linear progression at the onset followed by a monotonic increase at later reaction times. This deviation is more obvious for P2VP and P4VP versus PMMA and PS within the axis limits of Fig. 3, however, PS interestingly remains linear throughout (Fig. S17†). Nevertheless, the kinetic profiles clearly indicate that the rate of reduction follows the trend of (PMMA > P4VP > P2VP ≫ PS).
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed on PMMA-TTC and P2VP-TTC before and after reduction to determine if the TTC end group effects thermal stability. Congruent with earlier reports by Chong et al.,33 PMMA-TTC displays an early multistep decomposition (175 °C initial onset) when capped by a TTC end group (Fig. S18†). Removal of the TTC end group via TTMSS resulted in an observed 92 °C increase in thermal stability (271 °C onset). Alternatively, P2VP showed little difference in thermal stability regardless of end group (Fig. S19†).
Chong et al. showed that toluene can act as a weak, additional hydrogen source when used as a solvent during reduction.6 To investigate reduction of combination events on PS-TTC, we replicated entry 5 in Table 1 and replaced THF with toluene as the solvent. Indeed, suppression but not elimination of combination was observed by SEC (Fig. S20†). Additional attempts to reduce combination of PS-TTC by dilution ([TTC]0 = 2.25 mM) and increasing the stoichiometry of TTMSS:TTC (30:1) also showed little improvement (Fig. S20†). P2VP-TTC is only partially soluble in toluene. Instead, a mixed solvent system (75:25 v/v) of toluene:THF, respectively, was utilized to investigate suppression of combination events. The mixed solvent system under identical conditions as entry 3 in Table 1 resulted in slight improvement to the broadening of the SEC trace (Fig. 4, green trace) when compared to THF (blue trace). However, by increasing TTMSS:TTC (30:1), sequestering of combination events was achieved (Fig. 4, red trace). With this success, it was hypothesized that toluene was not necessary. By recreating a 30:1 TTMSS to TTC in pure THF, similar sequestering of combination events occurred, concluding that concentration of TTMSS is a critical parameter (Fig. S21†).
Although using TTMSS with 365 nm irradiation is promising, this wavelength lies on the low energy edge of the π → π* absorption band of TTC (Fig. S47†). Alternatively, the lower energy n → π* transition, while much weaker in molar absorptivity, has a peak maximum at ∼450 nm (Fig. S47,† inset) and its excitation with blue light (452 nm) may promote reduction without photocatalysts. Using identical reaction conditions ([TTC]0 = 5.5 mM, TTMSS:TTC = 15:1), P2VP-TTC was subjected to 452 nm (<5 mW cm−2) irradiation (Fig. S22†) and aliquots were monitored by UV-Vis analysis. Under these conditions, complete reduction occurred in 1.25 h (Table 1, entry 8) and the spectral monitoring (Fig. S23†) shows a slow initial reduction rate (t1/2 = 0.6 h) that accelerates over time. We believe this acceleration is due to the higher heat produced from the LED light strip. When measuring the temperature of the reaction solution using UV light over time, it never exceeded 30 °C. However, the reaction solution under LED irradiation gradually warmed to 53 °C over the course of 1 h. Complete removal of the TTC groups and formation of P2VP-H was confirmed by 1H NMR (Fig. S23†). When comparing P2VP-TTC (Đ = 1.08) and P2VP-H (Đ = 1.10) by SEC, negligible peak broadening had occurred during the reduction (Fig. S24†). This was a promising result that indicates reduction through the n → π* excitation of TTC sequesters combination events for P2VP without the need for additional TTMSS or toluene. Future work aims to fully investigate this phenomenon through blue light-driven photoreduction of thiocarbonylthio groups using TTMSS.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0py01104e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |