Nasrin
Rahmatian
a,
Shahryar
Abbasi
*a,
Naser
Abbasi
bc and
Mohammad
Tavakkoli Yaraki
*d
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Ilam, Ilam, Iran. E-mail: Sh_abbasi@ilam.ac.ir
bDepartment of Pharmacology, School of Medicine, Ilam University of Medical Sciences, Iran
cBiotechnology and Medicinal Plants Research Center, Ilam University of Medical Sciences, Ilam, Iran
dSchool of Natural Sciences, Faculty of Science and Engineering, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia. E-mail: mohammad.tavakkoliyaraki@mq.edu.au; mty206@yahoo.com
First published on 21st March 2025
Cholesterol and glucose are two important biomarkers that are linked to different human diseases. In this work, we have designed a turn-on fluorescent biosensor based on carbon dots hybridized by AgNPs (CD@AgNPs). Oliveria decumbens Vent. extract was used as a rich carbon source for the green synthesis of carbon dots, which exhibited excitation-dependent fluorescence with maximum emission at 409 nm under 350 nm excitation. In this approach, hydrogen peroxide, a by-product of enzymatic reactions between oxidase enzymes and analytes, etches AgNPs, leading to fluorescence recovery. The designed biosensor showed a great linear range (2–60 μM for cholesterol and 4–250 μM for glucose) with very low limits of detection (3 μM for cholesterol and 38 μM for glucose), which are lower than the concentrations of these biomarkers in human body fluids. The great selectivity and sensitivity of the designed biosensor enable it to be used for the detection of biomarkers in complex media such as artificial human plasma in only 30 min. This work could open new avenues for researchers in the fields of sustainability and biomedicine, where green and accurate biosensors are required.
Insulin hormone is the main regulator of carbohydrate metabolism and also prevents the breakdown of fat into fatty acids (lipolysis) in the body. Insulin resistance is when cells respond less to this process, resulting in increased blood sugar, which is why it is considered a reason for diabetes, pre-diabetes, and type 2 diabetes.6 Fats also break down quickly in the body and cause disturbances in the level of cholesterol. According to the mentioned points, developing sensitive diagnostic methods for the detection of cholesterol and glucose in body fluids is necessary to avoid false positive and negative results that threaten public health all over the world.7
The standard reference method for the measurement of cholesterol is a multi-step technique based on the modified Abell–Kendall method,8 which provides approximately accurate results with minimum errors within 24 to 72 hours after receiving the sample.9 However, this method is tedious and requires relatively complex technical facilities and skills.10,11 In the last two decades, biosensors based on various techniques such as surface plasmon resonance,12 electrochemical methods,13 chromatography,14 field effect transistors15 and enzymatic methods such as enzyme cascade system sensors16 and catalytic nanozymes17 have been developed. Although these methods effectively identify cholesterol and glucose in complex samples, the need for expensive equipment and complex sample pretreatments has limited their use in diagnostic laboratories. Among the optical biosensors, turn-on fluorescent probes have found their applications in different biomedical applications, owing to their high sensitivity and selectivity.18,19 Owing to the high selectivity of enzymes and the high sensitivity of fluorescent probes, designing biosensors based on the combination of these two approaches could open new avenues for researchers in the biomedical field.
Silver nanostructures are well known for their fluorescence quenching ability due to energy transfer from excited fluorophore molecules to silver nanostructures.20,21 Cholesterol oxidase (ChOx) and glucose oxidase (GOx) enzymes could oxidize cholesterol and glucose molecules, respectively, and produce hydrogen peroxide. The produced hydrogen peroxide could etch the silver,22 and therefore, using a fluorophore/metal hybrid nanostructure in designing biosensors could be an interesting approach for designing turn-on fluorescent probes for the detection of cholesterol and glucose.
Carbon dots (CDs), with a size of less than 5 nm, are quasi-spherical nanoparticles with 1 to 4 layers of graphene in the core and rich surface functional groups such as hydroxyl, epoxy, and carboxyl. They are a new class of carbon nanomaterials that have unique optical properties such as wavelength-dependent fluorescence, high solubility in water, low toxicity, and excellent thermal and optical stability.23,24 CDs could be synthesized from any carbonic sources,25 making them ideal nanomaterials that could play an important role in the circular economy via green and environmentally friendly synthesis approaches.26,27 While different plant extracts have been used for the synthesis of carbon dots, investigation of the potential of new plant extracts for the synthesis of carbon dots is still of interest since plant extracts are enriched with different bioactive molecules, which could give unique properties to the carbon dots.
Lal Kohestan plant with the scientific name of Oliveria decumbens Vent. from the Apiaceae family is a native plant of Flora Iranica and southwestern Iran in the Zagros mountains. The aerial parts of this plant are used in traditional medicine to treat indigestion, diarrhea, abdominal pain and fever. The two main compounds in the extract of this plant are thymol (47.06%) and carvacrol (23.31%),28 while it also contains γ-terpinene and p-cymen.29 To the best of our knowledge, there is no report on the green synthesis of carbon dots from the extract of this plant.
In this research, we have developed a green microwave-based synthesis route for converting Oliveria decumbens Vent. plant extract as a carbon source to carbon dots. Then, we have made CD@AgNP hybrid nanostructures by directly reducing the Ag+ ions on the surface of CDs. The as-synthesized CD@AgNP hybrid nanostructure with quenched fluorescence was used as a probe to detect and quantify cholesterol and glucose in the presence of cholesterol oxidase and glucose oxidase enzymes, respectively. The designed biosensor could not only be used for the quantification of the two studied analytes but could also be used as a naked-eye colorimetric assay for detection purposes. The high selectivity and sensitivity of this biosensor indicate that it is a promising candidate to replace other biosensors for cholesterol and glucose detection in complex biological samples.
:
water solvent with a volume ratio of 3
:
1 (120 mL in total) for 16 hours. The extract was filtered through Whatman no. 1 paper. Then, the filtered extract was used as a green source of carbon for the synthesis of carbon dots. 50 mL of the extract was placed in a microwave (700 W) for 10 min. The color of the extract solution changed from green to brown, and the resulting solution was centrifuged (15
000 rpm) for 20 min. After separation of the supernatant, it was passed through a 0.22 μm syringe microfilter to remove the larger particles. The brown carbon dots were stored in a dark container at a temperature of 4 °C in a refrigerator for further analysis.
Similarly, a negative control sample was prepared by adding GOx (1 mg mL−1 final concentration) and glucose (200 μM final concentration) to 50× diluted plasma, followed by incubation for 30 minutes at 37 °C. Then, 500 μL of CD@AgNPs was added to 500 μL of the prepared solution, followed by incubation at 37 °C for 30 min. Finally, the fluorescence emission was recorded for each sample.
C and C
N bonds and the peak at 210 nm originates from the n–π* transitions in CD.31,32 The size and morphology of the as-synthesized CDs were investigated by dynamic light scattering (DLS) and transmission electron microscopy. The hydrodynamic size distribution is in good agreement with the average size obtained by TEM (3 nm), where the CDs were monodisperse with a quasi-spherical shape (Fig. S1b and c†).
000 rpm for 10 minutes, where no precipitation was obtained, indicating the formation of a hybrid system with high stability. To investigate whether there is a CD@AgNP hybrid or a mixture of AgNPs and CDs, we have synthesized citrate-capped silver nanoparticles of similar size (evidenced by a similar LSPR peak position in Fig. 2b) and a mixture of these citrate-capped AgNPs (negatively charged) and CDs was prepared. This thin-layer coating creates a distance that extends and modulates the electrostatic interactions and the quenching effect by the FRET mechanism and the formation of the CD@AgNP hybrid. On the other hand, citrate-capped silver nanoparticles have negative charges around them and due to the surface functional groups of CDs and the negative charge, the repulsive interaction is more dominant.35,36As can be seen in Fig. 2b, the UV-visible spectrum of CD@AgNPs had a peak at 414 nm (for AgNPs grown by reduction on CDs) and two other peaks at 259 nm and 220 nm, which are related to CDs. However, pure CDs had two peaks at 257 nm (π–π* transition) and 210 nm (n–π* transition). The observed red shift in the position of peaks in the UV-visible spectrum of CD@AgNPs could be due to the hybridization between CDs and AgNPs. Additionally, the fluorescence quenching efficiency was 36% for the mixture of CDs and citrate-capped AgNPs with a similar size and LSPR peak, while it was 94% for CD@AgNPs due to complete charge transfer (through FRET: fluorescence resonance energy transfer) between CDs and AgNPs in the CD@AgNPs (Fig. 2c).37,38
On the other hand, the emission spectrum of CDs (showing an emission maximum at 409 nm) and the absorption spectrum of AgNPs in the CD@AgNP nanohybrid (absorption maximum at 414 nm) show a significant spectral overlap. This spectral overlap provides the necessary conditions for fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), during which an excited donor (CD) transfers energy to an acceptor group (AgNP) through a non-radiative process, leading to fluorescence quenching in the emission spectrum of the CD@AgNP nanohybrid.39,40
The TEM image shows the heterogeneous structure of CD@AgNPs with uniform dispersion and low apparent aggregation where AgNPs with a spherical shape (15 ± 1 nm) have been formed (Fig. 2d). Fig. S2a and b† show the UV-visible spectrum for CD@AgNPs and CDs. The UV-visible spectrum of CDs shows a broad shoulder at 257 nm and a sharp peak at 210 nm, which are attributed to the successive transitions in the C
C ring and C
O functional groups on the surface of CDs. The spectrum of CD@AgNPs shows a peak at 414 nm due to the presence of AgNPs in the solution, followed by peaks at 259 nm and 220 nm, which confirms the presence of CDs in CD@AgNPs.33,41 The CD solution under sunlight has very bright yellow color, and the colloidal solution of CD@AgNPs has brownish yellow color. Such a color change and the lack of observation of fluorescence in CD@AgNPs under 365 nm irradiation further confirm the presence of AgNPs in the vicinity of CDs.
We further characterized the as-synthesized CD@AgNP hybrid using different techniques. Zeta potential (ζ-potential) data obtained from different samples of CDs and CD@AgNPs are shown in Fig. S2c†. The synthesized CDs had a zeta potential of −3.07 ± 0.24 mV, which strongly indicates the presence of various functional groups on the surface of CDs. The zeta potential value for the CD@AgNP hybrid was 30.13 ± 4.15 mV, indicating the effect of AgNPs and its surface charge on the zeta potential value of the hybrid.
Energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) was performed to evaluate the composition percentage of the elements and the purity of the synthesized nanomaterials in the prepared samples. The EDX of the green synthesized CDs and CD@AgNPs obtained from different peak areas of Ag, C, N, and O in the range of 1–4 keV is shown in Fig. S2d and e.† The findings confirm the formation of AgNPs in the CD@AgNP hybrid. The images of the dispersion of each of the elements in CD@AgNPs are shown in Fig. 2e.
X-ray photon spectroscopy (XPS) analysis was used to further determine the chemical structure and bond connections in the CD@AgNP hybrid and CDs. As shown in Fig. 3a, CD@AgNPs have the same chemical structure as CDs except for a series of peaks related to silver. Comprehensive analysis of the XPS spectrum of CDs revealed the presence of C(1s), O(1s) and N(1s) elements on the surface, which are three strong peaks at 287.22 eV, 504.16 eV, and 397.01 eV, respectively. The CD@AgNP hybrid has a similar chemical structure to CDs except for a series of silver peaks at 376.51 eV.
The surface spectrum of the C(1s) nucleus shows five peaks (Fig. 3b). The peaks related to the bonding connections (C
C) and (C–C) at 283.12 eV and 284.43 eV, respectively, are related to the presence of graphite sp2/sp3 hybrid structures.42 The peaks at 284.38 eV, 286.10 eV, and 287.22 eV confirm the presence of (C–O
C), (C–N), and (C–O) bonds in the structure of the CD@AgNP hybrid, respectively. Fig. 3c shows the presence of O 1s atoms in four bond structures C
O, O–H, C–O, and C–O–C at 531.14 eV, 531.64 eV, 533.23 eV, and 533.70 eV, respectively. In Fig. 3d, the deconvolution spectrum of the N 1s level shows two peaks at 398.10 eV and 400.31 eV, which can be assigned to C
N and C–N, respectively. Additionally, the XPS profile in Fig. 3e includes Ag 3d5/2 and Ag 3d3/2 peaks at 368.32 eV and 375.22 eV, respectively, which show the unique splitting of the Ag 3d doublet, which corresponds to the metallic state of Ag0 as a result of the reduction of AgNO3.43
Furthermore, the results of Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) (Fig. 3f) support the XPS data obtained for CDs and the CD@AgNP hybrid. The FTIR spectrum of the green CDs synthesized using Oliveria decumbens Vent. plant extract by microwave radiation shows the presence of broad and strong peaks at 3410.11 cm−1 and 3366.92 cm−1, attributed to the stretching vibrations of the OH and NH groups, and at 2922.31 cm−1, related to the stretching vibrations of the CH2 CH3 group. The peak at 2368.55 cm−1 corresponds to the stretching vibrations of C
O, indicating the presence of carbon dioxide or another potential molecule with this functional group in the tested sample.44
Two peaks, one at 1737.12 cm−1, which is related to the stretching COOH groups,45 and the other at 1620.43 cm−1, which is related to the presence of C
C stretching vibrations in the aliphatic double bond or C
O stretching vibrations in an amide or ester functional group in the CD structure, respectively, are observed. The peak in the range of 1456 cm−1 often indicates the presence of a scissoring vibration of a methylene group (–CH2) or aromatic C–C stretching. The presence of a peak at 1440 cm−1 is essentially due to the C–H bending vibrations in alkanes and that at 1387.11 cm−1 is related to the OH bending group, phenol. The peak at 1037.67 cm−1 is related to the C–O stretching vibrations in alkyl aryl ether and a peak at 760.22 cm−1 is related to cyclic C–H groups in the structure of CD aromatic hydrocarbons.46 The peak at 620.22 cm−1 belongs to the halide group, since the CDs were synthesized from the natural precursor of the plant extract. The presence of these halide groups in CDs is inevitable as confirmed by CD spectroscopy.47 On the other hand, the presence of NH and OH groups in the CDs confirms their solubility in water.
The FTIR spectrum of CD@AgNPs was analysed and compared with the spectrum of CDs (Fig. 3f). It can be seen that the spectrum of CD@AgNPs shows longer bands, with the presence of common peaks at 2368 cm−1 indicating the presence of carbon dioxide in the tested sample, which comes from atmospheric CO2 present in the spectrometer environment; the sample itself may be contaminated with CO2 either from the environment or during preparation.48 The peaks at 1623.67 cm−1 and 1620.71 cm−1 can indicate the presence of C
C stretching vibrations in the aliphatic double bond or C
O stretching vibrations in an amide or ester functional group. The peak at 1456.13 cm−1 was caused by the bending shear vibration of the methylene groups and could be due to the presence of saturated hydrocarbons in the hybrid structure of CD@AgNPs. The peaks around 1245.16 cm−1 with varying relative intensities are related to the C–OH bending vibrations in the carboxylic acid and cyclic phenol groups and the C–O stretching vibrations.49 Also, the stretching vibration at 1371.81 cm−1 in the spectrum of CD@AgNPs is related to the stretching vibration of CN in its bond with AgNO3. The appearance of several sharp features in the range of 825.37 cm−1, 800.02 cm−1, 729.44 cm−1, and 596.33 cm−1 is related to the interaction between AgNPs and oxygen-containing functional groups (C
O, C–OH and C–OOH), which confirms the electrostatic interaction of silver with CDs.
Different volumes of AgNO3 solution (20 mM, 200 to 1000 μL) were added to the carbon dot solution (60 μg mL−1), where a volume ratio of Ag+
:
CD = 1
:
4 was kept in all tests. The UV-visible and fluorescence spectra were recorded for each sample to monitor the synthesis of AgNPs on CDs and its effect on the optical properties of the hybrid. As can be seen in Fig. 4a, the peak at 414 nm becomes more visible and intense by increasing the volume of AgNO3. These peaks are due to localised surface plasmon resonance in AgNPs and clearly indicate the synthesis of AgNPs in the presence of CDs. Indeed, the functional groups on the surface of CDs act as reducing agents and result in the formation of AgNPs. The strongest peak with a blue shift compared to other samples was observed for the sample containing 1000 μL of AgNO3 (20 mM), which indicates the formation of smaller AgNPs on CDs. In Fig. S3a,† the downward trend of the maximum LSPR peak (λmax) as a function of the volume of AgNO3 has been shown. It was found that increasing the Ag+
:
CD ratio led to a blue shift in λmax, finally reaching 412 nm. This indicates that with the increase of AgNO3 volume, the nucleation process and the stability of cluster distribution are more favorable and nanoparticles with smaller sizes are formed in the CD@AgNPs. The analysis of the relative fluorescence intensity of the same samples (F/F0) shows stronger quenching with an increase in the Ag+
:
CD ratio (Fig. 4b). Since AgNPs act as acceptors, the presence of more acceptors at higher Ag+
:
CD ratios would lead to stronger FRET, and in turn, stronger fluorescence quenching in the CD@AgNP hybrid.
Since time is a very important parameter in the synthesis of CD@AgNPs, the absorption and fluorescence of the synthesized sample were monitored by adding 1000 μL AgNO3 (20 mM) to the CDs at time intervals of 0 to 30 minutes. Fig. 4c shows the extinction spectrum of Cd@AgNP during the synthesis. The intensity of the localized surface plasmon resonance peak (λmax) increased over time, showing the formation and growth of AgNPs (Fig. S3b†). The formation of AgNPs is evidenced by strong fluorescence quenching through the FRET mechanism (Fig. 4d), indicating that silver nanoparticles are well formed in the structure of CD@AgNPs through electrostatic interactions with CDs.
Indirect measurement of cholesterol and glucose levels was carried out through the oxidation of these molecules by ChOx and GOx enzymes and the production of the H2O2 by-product. H2O2 undergoes a Fenton-like reaction with AgNPs that produces highly reactive oxygen species (ROS) and causes oxidative dissolution of AgNPs to Ag+ ions50. The oxidative dissolution of AgNPs in the CD@AgNP hybrid structure is proportional to the amount of produced H2O2. It should be noted that ROS, including free hydroxyl and hydroxyl radicals bound to the silver metal, lead to the formation of superoxide radicals and hydroperoxyl radicals that are the main active species in the dissolution of silver nanoparticle catalysts.51Scheme 1 shows the mechanism of this oxidative dissolution process by H2O2.52 As shown in Fig. 5a (inset image), the oxidative dissolution of AgNPs changes the color of the solution from yellowish brown to colorless as a result of etching with increasing H2O2 concentration, showing the potential for designing a naked-eye colorimetric biosensor using this method. On the other hand, it was found that the fluorescence of the sample is recovered by adding more H2O2.
It was also found in Fig. 5b that the fluorescence was recovered linearly with an increase in the H2O2 concentration (F/F0 = (3.6500 × 10−3) [H2O2] + 1.282 and R2 = 0.9902) with a limit of detection of 6.36 μM (i.e., LOD = 3σblank/slope, where σblank is the standard deviation of the blank samples, with a relative standard deviation of RSD less than 5%), as higher concentrations of H2O2 led to stronger etching of AgNPs, and in turn, the fluorescence recovery was evidenced by the change in the color of the solution from brown yellow to colorless.
The activity of enzymes might be affected by the pH of the reaction. Therefore, we considered the type of buffer and pH as important factors that might affect the kinetics of H2O2 production as well as its stability in the environment. For this purpose, the buffer medium and the pH of the Cho and Glu enzymatic reaction were optimized. Four buffers were selected and prepared, including Tris buffer (5 mM and pH = 7), acetate buffer (AB, 5 mM, pH = 7), 3-(N-morpholino)propane sulfonic acid buffer (MOPS, 5 mM and pH-7-M), and phosphate buffered saline (PBS, 5 mM and pH = 7). Different concentrations of cholesterol and glucose were prepared in the presence of ChOx and GOx enzymes in each of these buffers. After 30 minutes of incubation, leading to the reaction of cholesterol and glucose with the corresponding enzymes and the production of H2O2, 500 μL of CD@AgNPs was added and the fluorescence emission ratio in each of the buffer environments was recorded to perform the reaction and produce H2O2 and destroy AgNPs. As can be seen in Fig. 5c, the results showed the best fluorescence ratio from the reaction of ChOx and GOx enzymes with Cho and Glu in phosphate buffered saline (PBS). Then, PBS was prepared at different pH values (pH = 5.3, 6.3, 7.3, 8.3, and 9.3). The enzyme reaction environment at pH = 7.3, neutral and stable pH, led to the highest fluorescence emission ratio (Fig. 5d). Therefore, PBS with pH = 7.3 was selected as the optimal buffer and pH for further studies.
The catalytic activity of GOx decreases in the reaction with Glo in a basic pH environment, and this has been attributed to the protonation of the active site histidine in the flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) molecule in GOx, i.e., the protonated histidine leads to a decrease in the kinetic barrier for electron transfer to oxygen. But at neutral pH, the polarizability decreases, which reduces the inherent charge barrier, and in this environment, the catalytic activity of GOx with Glo is carried out optimally. Also, in the ChOx enzyme, with increasing pH, the charge on one or all of the amino acids in the ChOx enzyme is such that Cho can neither be properly bound nor react properly to produce 4-cholesten-3-one.53 But at pH = 7.3, due to structural changes in the enzyme configuration, the ionizable groups located at the active sites of the enzyme decreased, and the enzyme reacted optimally with Cho, and at pH = 7.3, the enzyme activity was more stable.54,55
To detect and quantify Cho and Glu, PBS at a pH of 7.3 was used. The fluorescence recovery was measured after 30 min, allowing the reaction to complete. The oxidase enzymes were used at 1 mg mL−1 in phosphate buffer, where the concentrations of cholesterol (2–60 μM) and glucose (4–250 μM) were varied in different experiments. In both cases, the fluorescence intensity was recovered by increasing the concentration of the analyte (Fig. 6c and d), evidenced by color changes proportional to the concentrations of the analyte. The analysis of these results revealed that the fluorescence intensity has a linear relationship with the concentrations of the analyte. In particular, for cholesterol, the LOD was 3 μM (F/F0 = (4.0960 × 10−2) [H2O2] + 1.2185 and R2 = 0.9939) and for glucose, the LOD was 38 μM (F/F0 = (1.0744 × 10−2) [H2O2] + 1.34017 and R2 = 0.9879). These LOD values were favorably lower than the amount of cholesterol (>2.7 mM) and glucose (2.8 mM) in the plasma sample of a healthy person.56,57
To investigate whether a complex medium affects the sensitivity and selectivity of the designed biosensors, we employed artificial human plasma fluid to mimic the human plasma. We first spiked glucose and cholesterol into the medium and then quantified the amount of cholesterol and glucose in the samples using the obtained calibration curves. Fig. 6e–f show that the sample is well matched with the calibration curve, where the percentage of recovery for glucose and cholesterol has less than 5% error compared with the spiked concentrations (Table S1†).
The results indicated that the CD@AgNP hybrid biosensor could be successfully used for the detection and quantification of cholesterol and glucose in a complex medium (Fig. 6e and f). In addition to the excellent sensitivity and selectivity, the optimal LODs obtained in the designed biosensor were compared to other works (Table S2†), indicating the potential applications of the CD@AgNP hybrid biosensor in the field of medicine owing to its simplicity, low cost and accuracy for the detection and quantification of two important biomarkers in human body fluids.
In order to evaluate the selectivity of the designed turn-on probe, the fluorescence recovery of CD@AgNPs was investigated in the presence of potential interfering substances such as maltose, fructose, saccharide and lactose, xylose, glutamic acid, and lysine, and ions such as Na+ and K+. It was found that interfering substances with a 10× concentration of glucose and cholesterol had no significant effect on fluorescence recovery. On the other hand, the color of the solution changed from yellowish brown to colorless when the probe was exposed to only glucose or cholesterol. The selectivity results are summarized in Fig. S4a and b,† which indicate that the assay is not only highly sensitive but also exhibits excellent selectivity towards glucose and cholesterol.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5nr00629e |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |