Jiangling
He
ab,
Shuang
Li
c,
Da
Lyu
ab,
Dingfeng
Zhang
c,
Xiao
Wu
c and
Qing-Hua
Xu
*ab
aDepartment of Chemistry, National University of Singapore, 3 Science Drive 3, 117543, Singapore. E-mail: chmxqh@nus.edu.sg
bNational University of Singapore (Suzhou) Research institute, Suzhou 215123, P. R. China
cInstitute of Polymer Optoelectronic Materials and Devices, State Key Laboratory of Luminescent Materials and Devices, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou 510640, P. R. China
First published on 9th September 2019
Materials that display aggregation induced emission (AIE) can offer large contrast ratio for highly sensitive fluorescence based applications such as sensing and imaging. Conventional AIE chromophores are generally based on improved emission quantum yield due to reduced nonradiative decay rates by restriction of intramolecular motion. In this work we present another type of AIE phenomenon with a totally different working mechanism. It is based on aggregation induced plasmon coupling of metal nanoparticles (NPs) to simultaneously enhance the excitation efficiency and radiative decay rate of chromophores. The unique surface plasmon resonance (SPR) properties of noble metal NPs can give rise to a significantly enhanced local electric field to modulate the optical properties of nearby chromophores. Plasmon coupling interactions between adjacent metal NPs can cause giant enhancement in the local electric field and consequently even stronger enhancing capability. The working principle was demonstrated by using rhodamine B isothiocyanate (RiTC) as the model chromophore and cysteine as the coupling agent to induce aggregation of noble metal NPs. The fluorescence of RiTC was pre-quenched by attaching to the surface of Au and core–shell Au@Ag NPs. Upon addition of cysteine to induce the aggregation of RiTC conjugated Au@Ag NPs, the fluorescence of RiTC was significantly enhanced to a level much beyond that of fluorescence recovery. A series of core–shell Au@Ag NPs with different Ag shell thicknesses have been prepared to optimize the performance of aggregation induced plasmon coupling enhanced fluorescence. The optimum enhancement effect was achieved for Au@Ag NPs with a 5.6 nm Ag shell, which enhanced the fluorescence intensity of RiTC in the coupled nanostructures to be 44.8 times stronger than that of pre-quenched RiTC and 7.6 times that of free RiTC. Based on this method, the limit of detection of 3.4 pM was obtained for the detection of cysteine, which is highly selective and more sensitive than most previously reported methods. This quenched-enhanced (off–on) method is highly sensitive, simple, straightforward and universal, and can be easily extended for the detection of other analytes.
Aggregation of chromophores or nanoparticles generally results in fluorescence quenching, which is known as aggregation-caused quenching and poses a big problem for biological applications. Aggregation-induced emission (AIE) breaks this common belief and has attracted vigorous attention since its discovery in 2001 by Tang et al.7 It provides a new concept for lots of potential applications.8–12 The mechanism of AIE generally arises from improved quantum yield (QY) due to reduction of nonradiative decay rates by restriction of intramolecular motion.13,14 Lots of chromophores have been developed to display the AIE phenomenon.13–17 AIE chromophores are attractive probes for fluorescence based applications as they offer large contrast ratio upon aggregate formation.
Here we present another type of AIE phenomenon but with a totally different working mechanism. It is based on aggregation induced plasmon coupling of metal nanoparticles (NPs) to enhance the fluorescence of chromophores by improving both the excitation efficiency and radiative decay rate. Noble metal NPs, such as gold (Au) and silver (Ag) NPs, have been known to display unique properties of localized surface plasmon resonance (SPR), arising from collective oscillation of conduction band electrons induced by light radiation.18–20 Plasmon resonance will result in a significantly enhanced local electric field at the surface of metal NPs, which will modulate optical properties of chromophores in close proximity. Metal–chromophore interactions will result in increased excitation efficiency, radiative decay and non-radiative rates of the chromophores, all of which depend on the separation distance between the metal and chromphores.6,21–24 Generally the fluorescence of chromophores in direct contact with metal NPs will be quenched. As the separation distance between metals and chromophores increases, a transition from fluorescence quenching to enhancement could be observed, with the optimum fluorescence enhancement at an intermediate separation distance of 5 to 30 nm, depending on the nature of the chromophore and metal NPs.6,22 Plasmon coupling interactions between closely spaced metal NPs will result in giant enhancement in the electric field in the gap region,6,25,26 which has been known to be responsible for significantly enhanced optical responses such as surface enhanced Raman scattering27,28 and two-photon photoluminescence.29–31 It has also been reported that coupled metal nanostructures displayed larger enhancement in fluorescence of chromophores compared to the mono-dispersed metal NPs.6,32 Ingenious design of assembled plasmon coupled nanostructures is of great importance to modify optical responses of nearby small molecules.
Different enhancing capability of aggregated and non-aggregated metal NPs could be utilized to develop schemes to achieve aggregation enhanced emission to display significantly different fluorescence intensities before and after formation of aggregated metal NPs. Lots of chemically and biologically important species can cause aggregation of metal NPs, which could be further utilized to develop various chemical and biological sensors and bio-imaging applications.
As one of the most important amino acids, cysteine is important for many physiological processes.30 A deficiency of cysteine would lead to many diseases. It is important to detect cysteine with high sensitivity. Cysteine molecules have been known to cause aggregation of metal NPs in an acidic environment.30,33 Taking advantage of this phenomenon, we demonstrate a scheme of aggregation induced plasmon coupling enhanced fluorescence as shown in Scheme 1. Rhodamine B isothiocyanate (RiTC) was chosen as the model fluorescent probe. Its fluorescence was pre-quenched by attaching it to the surface of Au and Au@Ag NPs. Upon addition of cysteine to induce the aggregation of RiTC modified Au and Au@Ag NPs, the fluorescence of RiTC was significantly enhanced due to significantly enhanced excitation efficiency and radiative decay rates resulting from stronger interactions with plasmon resonance of aggregated metal NPs. A series of core–shell Au@Ag NPs with different Ag shell thicknesses have been prepared to optimize the aggregation induced plasmon coupling enhanced fluorescence. The optimum result was achieved for Au@Ag NPs with a 5.6 nm Ag shell, which enhances the fluorescence intensity of RiTC in the coupled nanostructures to be 44.8 times stronger than that of pre-quenched RiTC and 7.6 times that of free RiTC. Based on this method, the detection limit of 3.4 pM was obtained for the detection of cysteine, which is highly selective and more sensitive than most previously reported methods. This method is simple, straightforward and universal, and can be easily extended for the detection of other analytes.
Scheme 1 Illustration of aggregation induced plasmon coupling enhanced emission of pre-quenched fluorophores. |
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images were taken on a JEOL 2010 microscope. FT-IR spectra were recorded on a Bruker Vector 33 FT-IR spectrometer. Fluorescence and extinction spectra were measured on a Horiba Jobin-Yvon FluoroMax-4 Spectrophotometer and a Hitachi UH5300 UV-vis spectrophotometer, respectively. Fluorescence lifetime decay curves were measured by the time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC) method using the Hydraharp 400 module under excitation at 520 nm. The second harmonic generation of the output of a Ti:sapphire oscillator (Spectra Physics, Mai Tai HP) was utilized as the excitation source.
Rhodamine B isothiocyanate (RiTC) was chosen as the model fluorophore to demonstrate aggregation induced plasmon coupling enhanced fluorescence. The fluorescence emission spectrum of RiTC aqueous solution displayed a characteristic band peaking at ∼580 nm with quantum yield (QY) of 13% (Fig. S1, ESI†). Upon surface conjugation with RiTC, extinction spectra of Au NPs and Au@Ag NPs became slightly redshifted and broadened (Fig. S2, ESI†). On the other hand, the fluorescence of RiTC was quenched by a factor of 4.6 to 8.1-fold by Au NPs and Au@Ag NPs with different Ag shell thicknesses. The detailed quenching factors are summarized in Table S1 (ESI†), which were obtained by comparing the difference in fluorescence intensities of metal–RiTC NPs before and after DTT treatment to release free RiTC to the solution. The observed fluorescence quenching arises from non-radiative energy transfer from RiTC to metal NPs.6 Au NPs without the Ag shell displayed the largest quenching efficiency due to the best spectral overlap between its absorption and the fluorescence of RiTC.
Cysteine was chosen as the coupling agent to induce aggregation of metal NPs. Cysteine molecules can bind to the surface of Au or Ag NPs through their thiol groups and induce the aggregation of cysteine modified metal NPs through their amino and carboxyl groups in an acidic environment.36–38Fig. 2 shows the evolution of extinction spectra of metal–RiTC NP solutions during the aggregate formation process. Upon gradual addition of cysteine, the original SPR band from 380 to 520 nm gradually decreased while another broad band appeared in the longer wavelength region, suggesting formation of an anisotropic assembly of metal–RiTC NPs.39 Cysteine induced aggregation of metal NPs has also been confirmed by TEM images (Fig. S3, ESI†), which showed that monodispersed metal–RiTC NPs became clumped together after addition of cysteine. FT-IR spectra of the aggregated metal NPs (Fig. S4, ESI†) displayed a sharp peak at 1404 cm−1 arising from the symmetric COO stretching mode and a broad band around 3200 cm−1 arising from the stretching modes of OH and NH, which are absent from FTIR spectra of isolated metal NPs. These results further confirm the role of cysteine in the formation of aggregated metal NPs.
The corresponding fluorescence spectra are shown in Fig. 3. Upon gradual addition of cysteine to induce aggregation of Au–RiTC and Au@Ag–RiTC NPs, the pre-quenched fluorescence of RiTC in Au–RiTC and Au@Ag–RiTC NPs steadily recovered and increased to a level even beyond that of free RiTC. The fluorescence intensity reached the optimum and then decreased slightly. The fluorescence spectra with optimum enhancement of coupled Au@RiTC and Au@Ag–RiTC NPs versus free RiTC molecules and isolated NPs without addition of cysteine are summarized in Fig. 4. The optimum fluorescence of coupled Au–RiTC NPs was 24.3 times that of uncoupled Au–RiTC NPs, and 3.0 times that of free RiTC molecules. For Au@Ag–RiTC NPs, these enhancement factors gradually increased with increasing Ag shell thickness until 5.6 nm (see enhancement factors for different Au@Ag NPs in Table S1, ESI†). Coupled Au@Ag–RiTC NPs with a 5.6 nm Ag shell display optimum fluorescence intensity and the largest fluorescence enhancement versus pre-quenched RiTC (44.8-fold) and free RiTC (7.6-fold).
The effects of pH and ionic strength on fluorescence enhancement have been checked by using Au@Ag NPs with the optimum performance (Ag shell thickness of 5.6 nm) (Fig. S5, ESI†). The results indicated that fluorescence enhancement arising from cysteine induced aggregation of metal NPs was only observed in the acidic environment with a low pH. The fluorescence enhancement remained nearly unaffected when the concentration of inert NaCl was varied from 0 to 4.0 M to change the ionic strength of the solution.
Significantly enhanced fluorescence upon aggregate formation can be ascribed to both enhanced excitation efficiency and QY. Fluorescence intensity of chromophores is determined by the product of excitation efficiency and emission QY, both of which will be modulated by the metal–chromophore interactions. When a chromophore is placed near metal NPs, the excitation efficiency will be enhanced as a result of local electric field amplification due to plasmon resonance. On the other hand, the emission QY will be modulated as both the radiative and non-radiative decay rates of the chromophores will be enhanced. Generally metal–chromophore interactions will result in reduced QY for high QY molecules, while improved QY for molecules with extremely low QY. The QY of RiTC in H2O (13%) is reasonably high. Its fluorescence became significantly quenched upon attaching to the surface of Au or Au@Ag NPs due to reduced QY arising from the dominant contribution from the increased non-radiative energy transfer process, despite the improved excitation efficiency. Upon formation of aggregates, the local electric field will be significantly further enhanced in the gap region compared to the un-aggregated metal NPs as confirmed by the simulation results shown in Fig. S6 (ESI†). The numerical simulation also suggests that local electric field increases with increasing size of the aggregates. As the QY of pre-quenched RiTC in Au–RiTC and Au@Ag–RiTC molecules is very low, metal–chromophore interaction is favourable for improving the QY. Metal aggregates with larger sizes have stronger weightage of scattering components over the absorption components compared to isolated metal NPs, which is favourable for improving the radiative decay rates.40 Consequently the QY is expected to be improved upon forming aggregates of metal NPs. On the other hand, further enhanced local electric field will result in further enhancement in the excitation efficiency. These two factors (enhanced excitation efficiency and QY) add up to result in significantly enhanced overall fluorescence intensities in these aggregated metal nanostructures. Au@Ag NPs with thicker Ag shell display larger enhancement because Ag NPs generally display stronger local electric effects compared to Au NPs. Numerical simulation confirmed that Au@Ag NPs display a stronger local electric field compared to Au NPs, which increases with increasing thickness of the Ag shell (Fig. S6a, ESI†).
The possibility of observed fluorescence enhancement in Fig. 3 and 4 due to detaching RiTC from the surface of metal NPs could be excluded by the fluorescence lifetime measurements (Fig. S7, ESI†). The fluorescence lifetime of free RiTC in solution was measured to be ∼2.2 ns. Upon attaching to the surface of metal NPs, the fluorescence lifetime of RiTC was reduced to within the instrument response function time of ∼150 ps and was not well resolved. The fluorescence lifetime decay of the aggregated metal–RiTC molecules remained within the instrument response, opposite to increased emission lifetime as expected for detached RiTC molecules. The observation of shortened emission lifetime and significantly enhanced fluorescence intensity manifests the plasmon resonance enhanced excitation efficiency and improved radiative decay rates. When RiTC was attached to the isolated metal Au or Au@Ag NPs, fluorescence quenching was observed. In contrast, fluorescence intensity was enhanced when RiTC was attached to the aggregated metal NPs. The difference between the two cases arises from significantly enhanced local electric fields in-between coupled metal NPs, which will significantly enhance the excitation efficiency and radiative decay rates of chromophores in these regions to overcome the negative contribution from the non-radiative energy transfer process.
Fig. 3 shows that the fluorescence intensity exhibited a sharp increase upon the addition of cysteine. This phenomenon could be utilized to develop a platform for sensitive detection of cysteine. Among different Au and Au@Ag NPs, Au@Ag–RiTC with a 5.6 nm Ag shell displayed optimum enhancement and is expected to give the best sensitivity for the detection of cysteine. As shown in Fig. 5a, the fluorescence intensity is linearly proportional to [cysteine] in the low concentration range. The limit of detection (LOD) was estimated to be 3.4 pM based on a signal-to-noise ratio of 3.0. The obtained LOD is more sensitive compared to the previously reported methods: 10 nM to 0.27 μM for the electrochemical method,41 5 μM for the 2PPL method,30 5 μM for the fluorescent-dye-based fluorometric method,42 and 10 μM for the colorimetric method.43 This method offers high sensitivity as it is based on turning on pre-quenched fluorescence with reduced background noise to a level significantly higher than the intensity of original fluorescence.
Detection of cysteine has also been tested in laboratory tap water to mimic a real sample. Similar results were obtained with a LOD of 3.8 pM (Fig. S8a, ESI†), indicating its potential for detection in real samples. The selectivity of this method in discriminating 21 common amino acids has been further tested in laboratory tap water as shown in Fig. 5b and Fig. S8b (ESI†). Upon addition of different amino acids with a concentration of 10 μM, only cysteine and glutathione molecules displayed aggregation induced fluorescence enhancement, while no obvious fluorescence enhancement was observed for other amino acids. Cysteine displayed a slightly stronger fluorescence enhancement effect compared to glutathione. These results indicated that this aggregation induced Plamson coupling enhanced fluorescence method can effectively identify cysteine and glutathione from others. Other amino acids cannot induce aggregation enhanced fluorescence as they do not contain thiol functional groups.30 As this scheme is simply based on cysteine induced aggregation enhanced fluorescence, it is as simple and straightforward as the colorimetric method. This method could be easily extended to the detection of other analytes by changing the surface modification of the metal NPs to render analyte-induced aggregation of metal NPs.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9qm00455f |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2019 |