Vijay K.
Tomer
*a,
Otavio Augusto Titton
Dias
a,
Abdelaziz M.
Gouda
b,
Ritu
Malik
*a and
Mohini
Sain
*a
aDepartment of Mechanical & Industrial Engineering, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. E-mail: vj.kumar@utoronto.ca; ritu.kumar@utoronto.ca; m.sain@utoronto.ca
bSolar Fuels Group, Department of Chemistry, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
First published on 16th April 2024
Lithium–sulfur batteries (LSBs) show promise for achieving a high energy density of 500 W h kg−1, despite challenges such as poor cycle life and low energy efficiency due to sluggish redox kinetics of lithium polysulfides (LiPSs) and sulfur's electronic insulating nature. We present a novel 2D Ti3C2 Mxene on a 2D graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) heterostructure designed to enhance LiPS conversion kinetics and adsorption capacity. In a pouch cell configuration with lean electrolyte conditions (∼5 μL mg−1), the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode exhibited excellent rate performance, delivering ∼1061 mA h g−1 at C/8 and retaining ∼773 mA h g−1 after 190 cycles with a Coulombic efficiency (CE) of 92.7%. The battery maintained a discharge capacity of 680 mA h g−1 even at 1.25 C. It operated reliably at an elevated sulfur loading of 5.9 mg cm−2, with an initial discharge capacity of ∼900 mA h g−1 and a sustained CE of over 83% throughout 190 cycles. Postmortem XPS and EIS analyses elucidated charge–discharge cycle-induced changes, highlighting the potential of this heterostructured cathode for commercial garnet LSB development.
New conceptsWe designed a novel 2D/2D heterostructure composed of MXene nanosheets stacked with graphitic carbon nitride (g-C3N4) to enhance the conversion reaction kinetics and adsorption capacity of lithium polysulfides (LiPSs). The g-C3N4 in the nanocomposite is derived from a cheap precursor (melamine) and exhibits a high pyridine nitrogen content, which inhibits polysulfide shuttling by demonstrating strong interactions with LiPSs while the presence of Ti2+ ions (from Ti3C2 MXene) functions as catalytic sites (Sx–Ti⋯Li) for effectively grafting the LiPSs and accelerating conversion kinetics. Under lean electrolyte (∼5 μL mg−1) conditions, the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode exhibited excellent rate performance, delivering ∼1061 mA h g−1 at C/8 and retaining ∼773 mA h g−1 after 190 cycles with a Coulombic efficiency (CE) of 92.7%. The battery maintained a discharge capacity of 680 mA h g−1 even at 1.25 C. It operated reliably at an elevated sulfur loading of 5.9 mg cm−2, with an initial discharge capacity of ∼900 mA h g−1 and a sustained CE of >83% throughout 190 cycles. By employing post-mortem analyses, we have correlated the excellent electrochemical results with the chemical and structural changes in the battery composition. Overall, we have devised a straightforward route for the synthesis of the sulfur cathode that not only differs from the existing host matrices in terms of the synthesis method and composition but also shows superior electrochemical performances in the extremely flexible pouch cell format. |
Among diverse host materials for LSBs, encompassing various multidimensional carbon (1D CNTs, 2D graphene, and 3D porous carbon)12 and its derivatives (acetylene black, active carbon, and biocarbon),13 polar materials (metal oxides/sulfides/phosphides/selenides/nitrides/bromides),14–16 and polymeric materials (organic polymers and organic frameworks),17,18 graphite-phase carbon nitride (g-C3N4) stands out as a promising candidate.19 It is a two-dimensional, metal-free conjugated polymer semiconductor with a distinctive energy band structure and offers promise due to its straightforward one-step polymerization process.19–21 Notably, g-C3N4 exhibits a high nitrogen content of approximately 61 wt%, predominantly in the form of pyridine nitrogen which serves as an active site for interacting with lithium polysulfide (LiPS), resulting in significant advancements in reducing the shuttle effect and improving the anchoring mechanism.22,23 Leveraging these advantages, the use of g-C3N4 as the sulfur host material in LSBs holds great promise, offering a potential and effective strategy for enhancing LSBs’ overall performance. Liu et al.24 synthesized a Nb2O5/g-C3N4 composite through electrospinning and double crucible gas–solid reactions, finding that ultralong 1D Nb2O5 nanofibers prevent g-C3N4 aggregation, forming tight heterojunctions. The nanocomposite efficiently adsorbs polysulfide, catalyzing its conversion, yielding an initial discharge capacity of 900 mA h g−1 at 0.5 C, with <0.1% decay after 500 cycles. Chen et al.25 created a g-C3N4 network in N, S co-doped carbonized wood fibers using an etching induction strategy. Benefiting from a large specific surface area and interfacial C–N–C bonds, the composite improved polysulfide redox kinetics, achieving capacities of 1590.8 mA h g−1 at 0.5 C and 976.9 mA h g−1 at 2.0 C. Zou et al.26 prepared N-doped porous carbon-coated graphitic carbon nitride heterojunction composites. The g-C3N4/g-C3N4/C heterojunction and conductive porous carbon served as an S host, ensuring an initial capacity of 752 mA h g−1 at 1 C, a reversible capacity of 496 mA h g−1 after 400 cycles, and a higher rate capacity of 468 mA h g−1 at 2 C for Li–S batteries. Additionally, Liu et al.27 assembled graphitized g-C3N4 with highly dispersed nickel as a catalyst to accelerate lithium polysulfide reaction kinetics. The Li–S battery exhibited a reversible capacity of 1271.6 mA h g−1 at 0.1 C, retaining 53% even after 500 cycles at 1.0 C. While these examples underscore the efficacy of g-C3N4 as a sulfur host, the high pyridine nitrogen content of g-C3N4 alone introduces irreversibility due to its strong affinity for Li atoms. Consequently, there is an urgent need for a suitable counterpart material to create a heterostructured hybrid with superior sulfur hosting performance in LSBs.
Within the intriguing 2D materials that can effectively be embedded in the layered sheet structure of g-C3N4, the use of layered 2D transition metal carbide (MXene) emerges as a promising strategy to counter the polysulfide shuttle phenomenon in lithium–sulfur batteries.28,29 MXene's attributes, including high electronic conductivity, abundant surface functional groups, and active surfaces bonding with polysulfides, distinguish it for this purpose.28 However, the persistent issue of anisotropy and restacking in Ti3C2 MXene nanosheets, attributed to van der Waals interactions, poses a major constraint observed in many 2D materials.28 This limitation restricts ion accessibility to interlayer sites and hampers the full utilization of surface areas for Li+ intercalation/de-intercalation.30 A layered heterostructured composite of g-C3N4 and MXene is envisioned, expected to mitigate restacking on MXene nanosheets and facilitate channels for Li+ ion intercalation during charge–discharge cycles.31 Additionally, hydroxyl terminal groups on MXenes are anticipated to adsorb LiPSs, initiating redox reactions like the Wackenroder reaction.32 These reactions connect with long-chain soluble LiPSs, forming poly-thionates and reducing them to insoluble Li2S concurrently. These chemisorption and redox processes effectively suppress the shuttle effect of LiPSs, minimizing sulfur loss, and consequently, enhancing the cycling performance of Li–S batteries.33
Another prominent but less studied factor that guides the practicality of LSBs is the performance evaluation under lean electrolytic conditions.34 Although great progress has been made in designing LSBs with long cycle life (>1000 cycles) and superior rate performances (>10 C), these improvements have been achieved with an excess electrolyte ratio (>10 μL mg−1) which inevitably reduces the actual energy density of LSBs.35 Therefore, a lean electrolyte is an essential condition for practical LSBs. To promote the development of practical LSBs, it is necessary to meet an E/S ratio below 5.0 μL mg−1.36 Recently, an electrolessly developed tin-plated sulfur nanocomposite shows a high gravimetric capacity of 520–663 mA h g−1 at a low electrolyte-to-capacity ratio of 3.75 μL mA h−1.37 Similarly, the core–shell polysulfide/carbon cathode with a high sulfur loading (12 mg cm−2) exhibits a high peak charge-storage capacity (832 mA h g−1), and long-term cyclability with high capacity retention approaching (200 cycles) at a low E/S ratio (4 μL mg−1).38 Reducing the amount of electrolyte in a battery, although inversely proportional to its energy density, can increase battery impedance, slow redox kinetics, and decrease sulfur utilization, eventually causing premature battery failure. This effect is observed when the electrolyte reaches saturation with LiPSs, leading to sulfur conversion following a quasi-solid mechanism that limits its maximum theoretical capacity. To solve this issue while leveraging the advantageous characteristics of both g-C3N4 and MXene, we designed a 2D/2D g-C3N4/MXene heterostructure to serve as a sulfur host, featuring prominently exposed active sites conducive to LiPS adsorption and catalytic conversion. The resultant g-C3N4-Mx/S composite electrodes, integrated into a pouch cell assembly, exhibited robust cycling performance. They showcased a capacity of ∼1061 mA h g−1 at C/8 and sustained ∼773 mA h g−1 after 190 cycles, maintaining a CE of 92.7%. Notably, under lean electrolyte conditions (∼5 μL mg−1), the discharge capacity remained at 680 mA h g−1, even at a high rate of 1.25 C. Furthermore, the pouch cell demonstrated exceptional flexibility, retaining an uncompromised open circuit voltage (OCV) even at a folding angle of 360°, underscoring its potential applications in wearable devices.
:
7 weight ratio) for 1 h and subjected to heating at 160 °C for 15 h, yielding g-C3N4/S and g-C3N4-Mx/S composites, respectively (Scheme 1).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Schematic illustration for the synthesis of g-C3N4-Mx/S nanocomposites and the structure of pouch cell demonstrating arrangements of electrodes and a separator. | ||
:
1 volume ratio of 1,3-dioxolane (DOL) and 1,2-dimethoxyethane (DME), maintained a volume at 5 μL mg−1 sulfur. Sealed pouch cells underwent pressing for 2 h under an Ar atmosphere and were subsequently transferred to a vacuum oven for 12 h at 50 °C for aging.
:
5 molar ratio) were combined in a DOL and DME solution (1
:
1, v/v) with vigorous stirring at 60 °C for 24 h in an Ar-filled glovebox. The resulting Li2S6 solution had a concentration of 5 mmol L−1. Before the polysulfide adsorption test, pure g-C3N4 and g-C3N4-Mx hybrids were dried at 60 °C under vacuum for 12 h. Subsequently, g-C3N4 and g-C3N4-Mx hybrids, each weighing 20 mg, were immersed in a 5 mL of Li2S6 solution for static adsorption over 12 h. The color variation of the supernatant over time was observed, and the adsorption capability of g-C3N4 and g-C3N4-Mx for Li2S6 was tested via UV-vis spectroscopy. A blank Li2S6 solution served as the reference.
In Fig. 1a, pure g-C3N4 exhibits two distinct peaks at 13.2° and 27.5°, attributed to the (100) and (002) faces of g-C3N4, corresponding to the stacking motifs of the in-plane tri-s-triazine structure and the planar stacking of the conjugated aromatic system, respectively.40 The well-aligned diffraction peaks of the orthorhombic sulfur phase (JCPDS card no. 08-0247) in both g-C3N4/S and g-C3N4-Mx/S confirm the crystalline nature of sulfur within the respective host matrix.12 The absence of significant peaks for MXene is observed, attributed to its lower doping and crystallinity. Chemical structure analysis using FT-IR (Fig. 1b) reveals that the characteristic peak at 735 cm−1 originates from the stretching vibration of the heptazine ring. At the same time, bands at 1227–1521 cm−1 correspond to the aromatic C–N stretching and CN heterocycle stretching modes of g-C3N4.43 The broad peaks in the region of 2800–3500 cm−1 are associated with the N–H characteristic vibration of –NHx and the O–H characteristic vibration of the remaining hydroxyl group or absorbed H2O molecules. Additionally, the band at 2319 cm−1 corresponds to the signals from S–H stretching modes.44
Raman spectroscopy, a non-destructive technique for chemical analysis, provides detailed insights into the chemical structure and molecular interactions of materials. The Raman spectra in Fig. 1c reveal peaks at 706, 768, and 1230 cm−1, corresponding to the breathing modes of the s-triazine ring in g-C3N4.45 Notably, all samples display peaks at 1412 and 1570 cm−1, attributed to the d-band and G-band, respectively. The d-band signifies disordered carbon or defects, while the G-band reflects the stretching motion of all carbon atoms in the aromatic ring, indicating the symmetry and graphitization degree (sp2) of the material.46 The calculated relative intensity ratios of the d-band and G-band (ID/IG) for pure g-C3N4, g-C3N4/S, and g-C3N4-Mx/S composites are approximately 1.02, 1.008, and 1.0, respectively. The decreasing ID/IG ratios with sulfur and MXene addition indicate a higher degree of crystalline graphitic structure and improved electronic conduction,47 aligning with the XRD pattern in Fig. 1a. For a comprehensive analysis of material-specific surface area changes, nitrogen adsorption–desorption experiments were conducted, and the results are depicted in Fig. S2 (ESI†). All three materials display a small adsorption volume at low relative pressures, a prominent H3 hysteric loop at medium relative pressures (0.30–0.80), and a distinct upward trend (type IV) at high relative pressures (0.90–1.0).48 These features indicate the simultaneous presence of micropores, predominantly mesopores, and some macropores in the sample. The specific surface area (SSA) of pure g-C3N4 was measured to be 65 m2 g−1 which decreases with the addition of sulfur and an SSA of 54 m2 g−1 was observed for the g-C3N4-Mx/S composite thus demonstrating the reduction in the pore volume on account of further loading of other components. The cathode host's conductivity is crucial, considering sulfur and its discharge products (Li2S) are insulators. In this study, the four-point probe method revealed the conductivity of the g-C3N4-Mx/S composite ranging between 10−2 and 10−3 S cm−1, significantly higher than that of pure g-C3N4/S materials, which falls within the range of 10−12 to 10−13 S cm−1.
The morphologies of the prepared active materials were scrutinized through TEM and SEM, complemented by elemental mapping. The TEM image in Fig. 1d highlights the sheet-like structure of g-C3N4, signifying thermal exfoliation at 600 °C effectively split bulk g-C3N4 into small nanosheets. The TEM image in Fig. 1e reveals that the morphology of g-C3N4-Mx/S with the 1% content of Ti3C2 MXene was not distinguished from that of the g-C3N4 nanosheets. This could be attributed to the thin-flake morphology of both the g-C3N4-Mx/S composites and the g-C3N4 NSs, and it is hard to distinguish from the TEM images. The SEM images in Fig. 1f illustrate the composites’ well-defined 2D layered morphology, indicating superior sulfur dispersion in g-C3N4-Mx/S. Elemental mapping in Fig. 1g vividly demonstrates uniform C, N, and S dispersion throughout g-C3N4-Mx/S, with mappings precisely conforming to sample shapes, confirming the uniform sulfur deposition on g-C3N4-Mx surfaces. Additionally, Mx prevents agglomeration by encapsulating g-C3N4, tightly coupling them, enhancing material dispersion, increasing the average surface roughness, and creating a larger reaction surface area with more channels, serving as a loading platform with N-containing functional groups to trap sulfur particles. The highly integrated g-C3N4-Mx/S with N-containing functional groups effectively confines LiPS, ensuring exceptional cycling performance. To determine the weight ratio of sulfur in the g-C3N4-Mx/S composite, TGA analysis was performed (Fig. S3, ESI†). The weight loss in the temperature range of 180–350 °C, attributed to the sulfur component's vapor, suggests a sulfur content of approximately 69.5%. This aligns with the experimentally executed mass ratio of g-C3N4-Mx to sulfur (3
:
7). The high sulfur content indicates that sulfur-rich g-C3N4-Mx/S possesses a high energy density, particularly crucial for the cathode material of Li–S batteries.
The elemental composition and valence information of the g-C3N4-Mx/S surface were acquired through XPS. The XPS survey spectra in Fig. S4 (ESI†) depict peaks at approximately 162.5, 226.1, 282.8, 398.1, 455.3, and 532.2 eV, corresponding to S 2p, S 2s, C 1s, N 1s, Ti 2p, and O 1s binding energies, respectively. The high-resolution fitted spectra in Fig. 2 for C 1s reveal five peaks: –Ti–C– (281.7 eV) and –C–C– (282.65 eV) from external and graphitic carbon, conjugated –C
N–/–C
C– (284.9 eV) at the heptazine unit structure's edge, C
O (285.9 eV) after thermal annealing of g-C3N4, and –S–C
N (286.9 eV) likely originating from sulfur and nitrogen-containing heptazine rings' interaction (sp2 bonds).49 The high-resolution XPS spectrum of N 1s exhibits four peaks: pyridinic-N (C
N–C, 397.4 eV), pyrrolic-N (–S–N
C–, 398.6 eV), graphitic-like N/amino N (C3–N and N–H, 401.1 eV), and oxidized-N (N–O, 404.4 eV).50 The abundant electron-rich pyridinic N content in g-C3N4-Mx/S enhances LiPS adsorption by providing binding sites for positively charged Li+ of LiPSs, forming Li–N interactions, hindering LiPS migration, and further inhibiting the shuttle effect.51 The S 2p spectrum of g-C3N4-Mx/S shows peaks at 162.1 (S 2p3/2) and 163.2 eV (S 2p1/2), attributed to –S–S– bonds (S8 molecules).52,53 For Ti 2p, the spectrum was deconvoluted into four components: peaks at 455.2 eV (Ti–C, 2p3/2), 456.8 eV (Ti–O, 2p3/2), 459.3 eV (Ti–C, 2p1/2), and 462.1 eV (Ti–O, 2p1/2). Besides N, C, S, and Ti, oxygen (O) at 531.2 eV was detected, originating from g-C3N4 oxidation during heat treatment in air.54 These oxygenated groups contribute to chemically adsorbing sulfur, effectively preventing polysulfides from dissolving into electrolytes.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a–e) XPS spectrum showing the complete scan and the corresponding spectra for the elements present in the g-C3N4-Mx/S composite. | ||
To evaluate adsorption ability, g-C3N4, and g-C3N4-Mx materials were immersed individually in a Li2S6 solution under magnetic stirring (30 min) and allowed to attain equilibrium for 24 h in an Ar-filled glove box. The adsorbents were then retrieved, and optical photographs of the solutions were captured (the inset of Fig. 3). Remarkably, the original bright-yellow color of the Li2S6 solution becomes nearly colorless after immersion in g-C3N4-Mx, indicating effective absorption of most polysulfides. In contrast, pristine g-C3N4 has a minimal effect on the color change of the Li2S6 solution. UV-vis measurements for Li2S6 reveal a strong absorption band in the 225–325 nm region, assigned to S62− polysulfide species (Fig. 3). According to the visible color tests, g-C3N4 exhibits lower absorbance than neat Li2S6, while g-C3N4-Mx demonstrates the lowest absorbance, likely due to the catalytic effect from adding MXene. This validates the robust affinity between polysulfides and Ti, particularly effective in suppressing polysulfide dissolution in the electrolyte (Sx–Ti⋯Li interactions).55 This robust affinity significantly contributes to enhancing the cycling stability of the sulfur electrode.
, a larger
implies a higher D. This equation elucidates a linear relationship between the peak current and the square root of the scanning rate, with the slope indicative of lithium-ion diffusion.61 In g-C3N4-Mx/S, the slopes for both reduction peaks (peaks C1 and C2) and oxidation peaks (peaks A1 and A2) surpass those for g-C3N4/S at the same electrode area for each sulfur reduction and oxidation reaction. This larger slope value correlates with accelerated Li ion diffusion and improved LiPS redox kinetics during discharge/charge processes due to the presence of MXene. MXene not only fosters LiPS transformation but also expedites rapid Li+ migration.62 EIS on the g-C3N4-Mx/S and g-C3N4/S cathodes further elucidated the kinetics of the electrode processes at the electrode/electrolyte interface. As depicted in Fig. 4i, the Nyquist plots outline three frequency regions: a high-frequency segment indicating electrolyte resistance (Re), a middle-frequency semicircle corresponding to charge transfer impedance (Rct), and a low-frequency spike representing Warburg impedance (W) associated with Li+ diffusion in the cathode.63,64 The semicircle diameter and Rct value of the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode cell (34.9 Ω) markedly reduced compared to those of the g-C3N4/S cathode cell (58.3 Ω), indicating diminished charge transfer resistance due to enhanced electrical conductivity and improved electrical contact upon Ti3C2 incorporation into g-C3N4. Additionally, the Re of g-C3N4-Mx/S is 4 Ω, nearly half compared to that of g-C3N4/S (8.1 Ω), affirming exceptional cell conductivity. This outcome underscores lower electrochemical impedance in the g-C3N4-Mx/S host, attributed to the presence of Ti3C2 as chemically active sites that avidly adsorb LiPSs, facilitate charge and ion transfer, and diminish electrode–electrolyte interface resistance and charge transfer resistance. Parameters from the Nyquist plot are detailed in Table S1 (ESI†).
The electrochemical performance of the as-prepared g-C3N4-Mx/S and g-C3N4/S cathodes was evaluated in pouch cell batteries. The sulfur content in the cathodes is ∼69%, and the capacity is calculated according to the sulfur weight. The charge–discharge voltage profiles for cells prepared by using g-C3N4-Mx/S and g-C3N4/S cathodes at a rate of C/8 are shown in Fig. 5a. As can be seen, two discharging voltage plateaus and one major charging voltage plateau were observed which are consistent with the multistep reduction of sulfur indicated by CV curves in Fig. 4a. The polarization potential (ΔE), calculated as the gap between the anode and cathode peaks, is significantly lower for g-C3N4-Mx/S (213 mV) than that for g-C3N4/S (272 mV), reflecting reduced polarization in the g-C3N4-Mx/S electrode facilitated by Ti-N active site catalysis. Additionally, the capacity of the lower discharge plateau (QL) and higher discharge plateau (QH) is calculated from discharge curves. The higher QL/QH signifies superior electrocatalytic activity for polysulfides, where QH corresponds to sulfur conversion into high-ordered soluble polysulfides, and QL represents efficient reduction of polysulfides to Li2S.65 In Fig. 5b, the capacity ratio (QL/QH) of g-C3N4-Mx/S (2.12) surpasses that of g-C3N4/S (1.86), indicating enhanced sulfur utilization owing to the presence of a higher amount of lower ordered polysulfides and the superior catalytic activity of Sx–Ti⋯Li in the g-C3N4-Mx/S electrode. The charge–discharge profiles of g-C3N4-Mx/S at C/8 over 190 cycles (Fig. 5c) reveal the persistent maintenance of the discharge plateaus and charging curves, demonstrating rapid mass transport and reaction kinetics. A comparison of long-term cycle performances between g-C3N4/S and g-C3N4-Mx/S (Fig. 5d) illustrates initial capacity decay attributed to the activation process. During the process of charging–discharging, the non-activated sulfur may aggregate on the g-C3N4-Mx surface leading to the formation of a non-stable solid electrolyte interface (SEI) layer.66 As can be seen, the g-C3N4-Mx/S witnessed enhanced sulfur utilization and uniform depreciation in capacity with an initial discharge capacity of 1061 mA h g−1 and a CE of 92.7%. The capacity drops to 773 mA h g−1 after 190 cycles with a capacity retention ratio of 73%. In contrast, g-C3N4-Mx/S achieves an initial discharge capacity of 749 mA h g−1 for 105 cycles only. The rate performance of the pouch cells prepared using g-C3N4-Mx/S and g-C3N4/S cathodes in Fig. 5e indicates higher discharge capacity for g-C3N4-Mx/S than that for g-C3N4/S for all current rates, with g-C3N4-Mx/S recovering well at C/8 which is ascribed to the porous structures of g-C3N4 ensuring fast Li+ transportation and chemical confinement for LiPSs.67,68 In conjugation with results presented in Fig. 5e, the galvanostatic charge–discharge profiles at different rates (C/8 to 1.25 C) for g-C3N4-Mx/S in Fig. 5f demonstrate excellent preservation of discharge plateaus even at a higher rate of 1.25 C, affirming swift mass transport and reaction kinetics. The cathode exhibits high reversibility, maintaining capacities of 1013, 830, and 682 mA h g−1 at C/4, 0.75 C, and 1.25 C, respectively, corresponding to 95.5%, 79%, and 65% of the original capacity.
To better understand the performance of g-C3N4-Mx/S-based LSBs, we have compared its capacity and CE with that of commercial porous carbon-based sulfur (C/S) composites. As can be seen in Fig. S5 (ESI†), the C/S cathode (S loading = 4.7 mg cm−2) based LSB shows an initial higher capacity (1273 mA h g−1) at C/8 than that of the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode (1061 mA h g−1); however, with further cycling, the capacity decreases rapidly to 703 mA h g−1 demonstrating a capacity retention of 55.2% after the end of 125 cycles. This concludes the fact that g-C3N4 exhibited better performance as a host material than the porous carbon because the g-C3N4 possesses an ample electron-rich pyridinic N content (Fig. 2b). In LSBs, N-rich active sites in g-C3N4 are particularly beneficial. These sites enhance the chemical interaction between sulfur chains and oxygen functional groups on the g-C3N4 matrix during sulfur loading, forming more thiosulfate and sulfate species (Fig. 7c, discussed later). This promotes a uniform distribution of sulfur in the carbon host during charge/discharge processes. Additionally, the highly positively charged Li cations in Li2Sn can directly bind to the electron-rich pyrrolic and pyridinic nitrogen atoms with lone pair electrons in the N-rich g-C3N4, leading to a Li–N interaction (Fig. 7d, discusses later) and enhanced LiPS adsorption. Moreover, N-active sites adjacent to oxygen functional groups improve the interaction between the oxygen functional groups and LiPS, effectively reducing the polysulfide shuttle.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 (a–f) XPS spectra of the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode obtained from the pouch cell cycled for 190 charge–discharge cycles. | ||
For practical success in Li–S batteries, emphasizing high areal sulfur loading is crucial. Hence, pouch cells with sulfur loadings of 3.8, 4.6, and 5.9 mg cm−2 underwent testing (Fig. S5, ESI†) at C/8 for the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode. The 5.9 mg cm−2 cell exhibited the lowest initial discharge capacity of 795 mA h g−1 (CE of 83.2%), reducing to 573 mA h g−1 after 190 cycles with a 72% retention rate. In the case of mild sulfur doping (3.8 and 4.6 mg cm−2), the cycled Li is a negligible fraction of the entire Li anode and the stripping/plating behavior is relatively facile at an electrolyte dosage of 5 μL mg−1, due to which the cell performance, including capacity, CE, and cycle life, is less affected by the Li anode. However, at a high sulfur loading (5.9 mg cm−2), the Li plating process is not as mild owing to the depleted electrolyte,69 which causes a decrease in the battery capacity due to the inevitable “shuttle effect”. The results highlight the g-C3N4-Mx/S's outstanding electrochemical performance under high-loading (4.6 mg cm−2) and lean electrolyte (5 μL mg−1) conditions, showcasing robust LiPS inhibition and accelerated kinetic conversion for enhanced sulfur utilization.
Comparisons with other pouch cells (Table S2, ESI†) demonstrated that the g-C3N4-Mx/S cathode outperforms most previously reported cathodes. The exceptional electrochemical performance of the integrated 2D/2D structure, consisting of g-C3N4/MXene nanosheets, arises from several key factors. Primarily, this structure facilitates faster electron transport during charge/discharge cycles and ensures a homogeneous distribution of sulfur between the g-C3N4 and MXene nanosheets, thereby enabling high sulfur utilization. Furthermore, the 2D structure of the g-C3N4 nanosheets prevents the stacking of MXene layers, creating additional active sites for polysulfide adsorption during the charge–discharge process. MXene also enhances the charge transfer process within g-C3N4, catalyzing the conversion of polysulfides. Additionally, the hydrophilic and polar nature of MXene prevents the stacking of g-C3N4, promoting an even distribution of components and effectively trapping polysulfides, suppressing the “shuttle effect”, respectively. To showcase the superior mechanical flexibility of the designed g-C3N4-Mx/S electrodes, various folding angles for pouch cells were tested. Fig. 6 reveals impressive open circuit voltage (OCV) stability at 2.3 V, successfully powering the red LED bulb formation of “LIS” at varying bending angles, with no discernible change in LED brightness or OCV readings at horizontal (90°), vertical (180°), or crumpled (360°) bending angles, demonstrating favorable electrical performance for practical utility in wearable and portable electronic device applications.
N–/–C
C–, C
O, and –S–C
N, mirroring the active material C 1s spectra in Fig. 2. However, a new peak at 291.5 eV, representing –C–F– due to electrolyte passivation, emerged. Deconvoluting the N 1s spectra revealed peaks at 397.7 eV for pyridinic-like N (–C
N–) in the g-C3N4 structure, 399.5 eV for –S–N
C–, and 403.2 for oxidized N (N–O).72 The 396.5 eV peak confirmed Li–N bond formation during cathode lithiation, contributing to lithium storage.73 Additionally, the 406.5 eV peak indicated the nitrate (NO3−) presence on the cathode, formed by LiNO3 reduction during cycling.70 For S 2p, various new reduction products and intermediates were identified after cycling including sulfites at 166.3 eV, and S–F bonds at 168.3 eV.74 Compared to the S-spectra in Fig. 2, more sulfates were observed in the cycled cathode which could be a result of oxidized S-species (O–S) from the reaction between LiPSs and oxygen species. The O–S bond surfaced due to sulfate species interacting with residual oxygen-containing species, and the S–F bond indicated a covalent interaction between F-containing electrolytes and polysulfides.75 Besides, the doublet peaks at around 163 eV in Fig. 2 for elemental sulfur were shortened in the cycled cell which could be due to the presence of a partial amount of ‘dead’ sulfur on the cathode after 190 cycles.76 The Ti 2p spectrum was deconvoluted into four components and the peaks at 455.4 eV (Ti–C, 2p3/2), 456.7 eV (Ti–O, 2p3/2), 459.1 eV (Ti–C, 2p1/2), and 461.9 eV (Ti–O, 2p1/2) are aligned well to the spectrum in Fig. 2. In Li 1s spectra, peaks at 53.9, 54.9, 55.6, and 56.6 denoted Li–C, Li–S, Li–N, and Li–O bond formations, signifying the C
N bond involvement in lithium storage in addition to Li–S bonds during discharge.44,77,78 F 1s peaks at 684.4 and 687.6 eV reflected the electrolyte and PVDF passivation, suggesting an interaction between the electrolyte and g-C3N4-Mx/S during cycling. Overall, the XPS analysis of the cycled cell affirmed polysulfide adsorption on the g-C3N4-Mx/S surface.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Comparison with previously published works and results obtained from Nyquist plots; BET sorption isotherms; TGA; CV cycling performance; complete XPS scan and EIS spectra for the cycled cell. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4mh00200h |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |