Shang-Lin
Yeh
a,
Piyush
Deval
a,
Jhih-Guang
Wu
b,
Shyh-Chyang
Luo
b and
Wei-Bor
Tsai
*a
aDepartment of Chemical Engineering, National Taiwan University, No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Rd., Taipei, 10617, Taiwan. E-mail: weibortsai@ntu.edu.tw
bDepartment of Material Science and Engineering, National Taiwan University, No. 1, Sec. 4, Roosevelt Rd., Taipei, 10617, Taiwan
First published on 31st December 2021
Electrochemical techniques are highly sensitive and label-free sensing methods for the detection of various biomarkers, toxins, or pathogens. An ideal sensing element should be electroconductive, nonfouling, and readily available for conjugation of ligands. In this work, we have developed a facile, one-step electrodeposition method based on pyrogallol polymerization for preparation of a nonfouling and biotinylated surface on indium tin oxide (ITO). A copolymer of sulfobetaine methacrylate and aminoethyl methacrylate (pSBAE) was synthesized and deposited on ITO in the presence of pyrogallol via cyclic voltammetry. The deposition took less than 15 minutes to sufficiently inhibit cell adhesion. Using biotinylated pSBAE, the modified surface resisted nonspecific protein adsorption from the fetal bovine serum solution and detected added avidin concentrations. The results show an efficient platform to fabricate an electrochemical biosensor for the detection of biomarkers. We expect that this facile one-step technology could be applied to conjugate various biosensing elements for nonfouling biosensors.
For the construction of electrochemical biosensors, ideal biosensing elements should be electroconductive, nonfouling, and readily used for conjugation of ligands that recognize specific target biomolecules. A simple and reliable surface modification technology to meet the requirements of electrochemical biosensors is highly desirable. In recent years, the poly(dopamine) (PDA) deposition technique,4 based on spontaneous self-polymerization of dopamine (DA) under alkaline conditions (pH 8.5), has attracted much attention in the construction of biosensors. DA polymerization forms a thin polydopamine ad-layer that strongly interacts with various organic and inorganic materials, such as polymers, metals, and metal oxides.5,6 The PDA ad-layer contains many functional groups such as quinone, catechol, amine, and imine, which could bind ligands.7 Furthermore, the PDA deposition process cannot only be initiated by self-oxidation at alkaline pH, but also electrochemical stimuli using cyclic voltammetry.8,9 The PDA ad-layer prepared by electrodeposition can also assist immobilization of molecules on the conductive surfaces for further applications. Characterization of PDA makes it a good technique for modification of electrochemical biosensors.10–12
Bioelectrodes generally experience surface biofouling, triggered by nonspecific attachment of proteins, lipids, cells, and microorganisms. Surface modification with antifouling hydrophilic polymers, such as polysaccharides, poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG), and poly(zwitterions), could greatly reduce nonspecific binding of biomolecules. These highly hydrophilic polymers adsorb a great amount of water to form a barrier to reduce nonspecific interactions between surfaces and biological systems.13 A recent study used PDA as a platform to co-immobilize thiolated PEG and thiolated aptamers through the Michael addition reaction as a biosensor, detecting adenosine triphosphate.10 The study demonstrated that in the presence of PEG protection, the aptasensor was capable of sensing adenosine triphosphate in human plasma with a significantly reduced nonspecific adsorption effect. Similarly, a recent study constructed sensitive and antifouling biosensors via copolymerization of PDA and poly(sulfobetaine), followed by attachment of thiolates aptamers to the PDA for detection of carcinoembryonic antigen.14
In addition to dopamine, many polyphenolic molecules possess similar characteristics for surface modifications.15–17 An advantage of polyphenolic compounds is their lower price compared to dopamine. Polyphenolic molecules, such as pyrogallol, tannic acid and gallic acid, containing catecholic or pyrrolic moieties, are prone to oxidization to quinones and further self-polymerize on most materials under oxidized conditions. It has been demonstrated that electrodeposition of polyphenolic molecules on the surface of conductive materials induces the formation of a conformal coating without aggregates of reacted monomers in the bulk of the solution.18–22
The aim of this study was to fabricate a biosensing platform with antifouling ability using one-step electrodeposition of an antifouling polymer. A model binding system, avidin/biotin, was used to demonstrate the feasibility of the platform. One major distinguishing feature of the avidin/biotin system is its extraordinarily high affinity (the affinity constant, Ka, is 1013–15 M−1), which is extremely stable under harsh pH or temperature conditions.23 Avidin/biotin technology has been extensively applied to biotechnology, such as affinity chromatography, histochemistry, diagnostics, immunoassay, and drug delivery.24 Our group previously used the avidin/biotin system to immobilize cell adhesive peptides on polydopamine surfaces to elicit specific cell adhesion.25 In this study, biotin molecules were conjugated to polysulfobetaine as ligands, and then deposited on Indium tin oxide (ITO) glass via electrodeposition with pyrogallol. The ability of the modified ITO to resist nonspecific biointeractions and to detect avidin in serum solutions was demonstrated in this study.
The aqueous solutions were prepared from Milli Q water (Millipore, Molsheim, France) with a resistivity of 18.2 MΩ cm. Indium tin oxide (ITO) glass (0.7 mm in thickness and 7 Ω in resistivity) was purchased from Uni-Onward Corp., Taiwan.
For the synthesis of biotinylated pSBAE (b-pSBAE), 30 mg pSBAE was dissolved in 1 mL of 0.1 M MES buffer (pH 5.5) in the presence of biotin at 12, 36 or 100 μg mL−1. After the addition of 31 mg (0.2 M) EDC and 5.7 mg (0.05 M) NHS, the mixture was incubated in the dark for 20 hours with constant stirring. After the reaction, the solution was dialyzed against deionized water to remove impurities. The ratio of conjugated biotin to pSBAE was quantified using a biotin quantification kit (MK171, Sigma-Aldrich, USA). The grafting ratios for b1-pSBAE (12 μg mL−1), b2-pSBAE (36 μg mL−1) and b3-pSBAE (100 μg mL−1) were 8.89%, 16.30% and 45.93%, respectively.
The scheme of the electrodeposition setup is shown in Fig. 1. ITO was used as a working electrode, while a platinum coil and a silver chloride electrode (Ag/AgCl) were used as the counter and reference electrodes, respectively. Pyrogallol was electrodeposited on ITO slides. Electrodeposition was initiated by performing cyclic voltammetry between −0.8 V and 1.2 V versus the Ag/AgCl electrode with a scan rate of 0.02 V s−1 for 10 cycles. After electrodeposition, the modified ITO slides were washed copiously with deionized water and dried in air at room temperature. For codeposition of PG/pSBAE, PG (8 mg mL−1) and pSBAE (30 mg mL−1) dissolved in 0.1 M phosphate buffer, pH 5.0. All reactions were performed in an electrochemical cell at room temperature.
The static water contact angle (WCA) apparatus (FTA-125, First Ten Angstroms, USA) was used to determine the surface wettability. Water droplets (5 μL) were placed on the samples and then the digital images were collected. The water contact angles were measured from the images. For every sample, 10 water contact angle measurements were taken at different points. The reported WCA values were averaged from three samples of each type of surface.
The surface morphology and topography were examined using a scanning electron microscope (SEM, NovaTM NanoSEM 230, Scanservice, USA) and an atomic force microscope (AFM, NanoScope IIIa, Digital Instruments, USA). The samples sputter-coated with a ∼10 nm gold film prior to SEM examination.
The first cycle in the PG cyclic voltammogram was examined in Fig. 2A. An oxidation peak appeared around 0.56 V, which is caused by the oxidation of hydroxyl groups in pyrogallol, while a small reduction peak occurs at ∼0.05 V on the reverse scan. Furthermore, the oxidation peak potential shifted toward more positive potentials, accompanied by a rapid decrease in the peak current with an increasing number of cycles. The result indicates that pyrogallol oxidation is irreversible, consistent with a previous report.30 The oxidation step leads to the formation of orthoquinones, which are transformed into ortho-semiquinones in the reduction step. Ortho-semiquinones form oligomers as the origin of the film deposition.31 A PG film gradually thickened on ITO during the oxidation process of pyrogallol, and resulted in a gradual decrease in the current. The cyclic voltammogram of PG/pSBAE was similar to that of PG (Fig. 2B).
The surface hydrophilicity, determined by static water contact angle measurement, was monitored during CV cycles. Bare ITO was relatively hydrophobic with WCA of 77.3°. The PG deposition made ITO more hydrophilic. The WCA decreased to 75.1° after one cycle, and further decreased to 57.3° after ten cycles (Fig. 2C). The surface hydrophilicity increased further when the surface was modified with polyphenol-assisted pSBAE coatings. Deposition of PG/pSBAE further increased surface hydrophilicity. The WCA decreased to 51.6° after one cycle, reached a minimum of 21.8° after four cycles, and increased to 40.4° after 10 cycles (Fig. 2C). We guess that during the coating cycles, the concentration of pSBAE in the solution decreases faster than that of PG. Thus, at a higher cycle, e.g. 10, the ratio of PG to pSBAE in the solution was raised and thus more PG was deposited on the top layer, resulting in decreasing surface hydrophilicity. The trend of WCA measurement is similar to our study in the deposition of PG/pSBAE on PDMS through a one-step immersion deposition under alkaline conditions.17 WCA decreased to a minimum after 12 hours of soaking and increased slightly after 24 hours. Using electrodeposition, the time required for minimal WCA decreased greatly to less than 15 minutes (4 cycles) from spontaneous immersion deposition of 12 hours.
Zwitterionic molecules form a stable hydration shell via strong electrostatic induced hydration, which repels the nonspecific adsorption of biomolecules on the surface.32,33 A more hydrophilic surface tends to be more antifouling. Next, the resistance to cell adhesion on the modified ITO was studied. After one CV cycle, cell adhesion decreased greatly to 9.1% or 9.6% of that on ITO or PG (Fig. 2D). After 4 CV cycles, cell adhesion was almost inhibited, less than 0.5% of cell adhesion to ITO. Further CV cycles slightly increased cell adhesion. The decrease in anti-cell adhesion performance with increasing CV cycles is probably due to the local depletion of pSBAE in the PG/pSBAE solution around ITO. Therefore, an increased amount of PG was deposited on the topmost layers. The results indicated that PG/pSBAE could be deposited on ITO via CV. Compared to our previous immersion deposition study which showed that 12 hours is needed to reach a minimum cell adhesion,17 the fabrication time decreased to less than 15 minutes by electrodeposition. The results indicate that electrodeposition is an efficient method to deposit antifouling polymers on ITO. Because the best anti-cell adhesion effect appeared in the fourth cycle, the condition was used for subsequent biosensing experiments.
SEM was used to observe the topography of the PG-modified surfaces. PG electrodeposition appeared as particulate aggregates, whose size increases with CV cycles (Fig. 3). After 10 cycles, a few fibrous structures appeared. On the other hand, electrodeposition of PG/pSBAE created a feature of marble stripes after 4 CV cycles, and the structure became denser after 10 CV cycles. The SEM images show that incorporation of pSBAE facilitates the formation of fibrous deposition on ITO.
A similar observation was also confirmed using AFM. No obvious change in surface topography was found after ITO was deposited with PG for 1 or 4 cycles (Fig. 4). After ten cycles of deposition, a feature of interwoven fibers was found on ITO, and surface roughness increased significantly from 5.7 nm for ITO to 50.9 nm. On the other hand, a fibrous feature was found on PG/pSBAE after one CV cycle, and became more prominent with increasing CV cycles (Fig. 4). The fiber length ranged from 50 to 250 nm. Surface roughness also increased rapidly from 45.1 nm after 1 CV cycle to 106 nm after 10 CV cycles.
Fig. 4 AFM images of surface topography of bare ITO, and ITO electrodeposited with PG and PGSB for 1, 4 and 10 cycles. Scale = 1.0 μm. |
It is interesting to note that when PG is electrodeposited, an interwoven fiber-like structure appears, as reported previously.30 On the other hand, the PG coating by immersion deposition does not exhibit interwoven fiber-like structures.34 This phenomenon suggests that PG polymerization/deposition on a substrate via electrodeposition and immersion deposition might occur differently. In immersion deposition, PG polymerization occurs in the bulk solution and then deposits onto a substrate as particulate forms. On at other hand, the electrodeposition the oxidation/reduction reaction occurs on the surface of the working electrode, so PG polymerization is initiated on the working electrode, and the PG polymerization develops into a fibrous structure.
Next, we determined the avidin capture ability of the PG/b-pSBAE modified ITO from 0.1 mg avidin per mL of PBS using EIS measurement. Pristine ITO adsorbed a large amount of avidin, while PG deposition decreased the change in Rct, that is, avidin adsorption, to ITO (Fig. 5B). The modification of PG/pSBAE modification further decreased the nonspecific adsorption of avidin to a very low level. The addition of b1-pSBAE did not show significant avidin capture, probably due to low biotin conjugation. The conjugation of b2-pSBAE greatly improved avidin attachment, higher than that of b3-pSBAE. The results proved that the PG/b-pSBAE coating could capture avidin. Since PG/b2-pSBAE gained maximal avidin attachment, it was used in subsequent experiments and indicated as b-pSBAE.
The conductivity of a biosensor is important for its sensing ability.35,36 A sensing element with a high conductivity could result in a high current and possess a high sensing ability without any lag. The conductivity of the PG/pSBAE modified surfaces was evaluated using the Rct by electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The Nyquist plot shows that the deposition of PG greatly increased the impedance of ITO (Fig. 6A). Electrodes have been reported to lose their conducting properties due to the formation of a thin insulating layer by polymerization of polyphenolic molecules.38,39 However, the co-deposition of PG and pSBAE or b-pSBAE only slightly increased the impedance compared to the bare ITO (Fig. 6B). The result suggested that incorporation of pSBAE facilitates the transfer of Fe ions to the working electrode through a PG film. Thus, more Fe ions become oxidized and reduced at the PG/b-pSBAE-deposited working electrode. PG/b-pSBAE deposited ITO shows high potential for electrochemical biosensing.
The electrochemical sensing performance of the PG/b-pSBAE ITO for the determination of avidin was first investigated in PBS. Rct increased with increasing avidin concentrations (Fig. 7A). We found that the ΔRct/Rct0 (%) exhibited a good linear correlation with the logarithm of avidin concentrations with a regression equation ΔRct/Rct0 (%) = 48.66 log(C) (μg mL−1) − 4.81 (R2 = 0.9949) (Fig. 7B). The good sensing performance of the b-pSBAE–ITO indicates that the modified surface provides a good microenvironment to retain the binding affinity of the biotin–avidin pair.
Next, we evaluated avidin recognition of PG/b-pSBAE in complex media, such as serum. Complex media are prone to elicit significant nonspecific protein adsorption. We first tested the resistance of PG/b-pSBAE to nonspecific protein adsorption from fetal bovine serum (FBS) at various concentrations (Fig. 8A). When the PG/pSBAE and PG/b-pSBAE samples were immersed in 0.1% or 1% FBS, the increase in the change of Rct was very low, while significant amounts of nonspecific protein adsorption were found when the samples were immersed in 5% and 10% FBS. Furthermore, the PG/b-pSBAE coating elicits more nonspecific protein adsorption, indicating that biotinylation affects the antifouling efficacy of pSBAE.
Since the PG/b-pSBAE substrate resisted nonspecific protein adsorption from 1% FBS, we next tested the avidin recognition of PG/b-pSBAE from 1% FBS solution containing various amounts of avidin. Rct change increased with increasing avidin concentrations in a good linear relationship (Fig. 8B). However, the correlation of Rct changes and avidin concentrations is not as excellent as that in pure avidin concentration. The complex protein solution may affect the avidin/biotin binding.
Electrodeposition of polyphenolic molecules has been applied to the surface modification of biosensors.37–41 Many studies used a two-step process to conjugate antifouling molecules or biomolecules. For example, an impedimetric biosensor for the detection of breast cancer-related gene was first electrodeposited with polydopamine; tannic acid was deposited through Fe3+ mediation; finally PEG was grafted as an antifouling layer via a layer-by-layer technique.37 For immobilization of thiol-functionalized oligonucleotides, the platform was further electrodeposited with gold nanoparticles. Finally, the modified biosensor could detect the target gene. In another study, SBMA monomers were polymerized and deposited on a biosensor in the presence of dopamine and oxidizing agents, on which thiol-functionalized aptamers were conjugated to detect carcinoembryonic antigen even in the clinical sample.38 These preparation methods involve multiple time-consuming steps to create a non-fouling substrate and conjugate sensing probes. Here, we showed a facile one-step electrodeposition to immobilize antifouling polymers and detect molecules simultaneously over an electrode in 15 minutes. Biotin was used as the sensing element in this study to capture avidin molecules from a protein solution. Other sensing elements, such as antibodies, aptamers, and receptors, could be easily immobilized on a biosensor using our technology.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |