John H.
Reed
,
Johannes
Klett
,
Craig
Steven
and
Nicolai
Cramer
*
Laboratory of Asymmetric Synthesis and Catalysis, Institute of Chemical Sciences and Chemical Engineering, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland. E-mail: nicolai.cramer@epfl.ch
First published on 3rd September 2020
P-Hydrido 1,3,2-diazaphospholenes (DAPs) are a class of nucleophilic molecular hydrides capable of addition to a variety of substrates. They can be turned over with terminal reductants and emerged over the last few years as powerful and versatile catalysts. This review highlights developments made in understanding the chemistry of these unusual compounds and applying them in catalysis. An overview of the synthesis and important structural features of the DAPs is followed by a discussion of methodologies that exploit their chemistry in catalysis, including the rise of enantioselective reductions. We conclude with a brief analysis on the current limitations of the field and discuss how these might be overcome and which directions the field might take in the future.
Phosphorus-containing compounds with one or more P–H bonds are generally characterized by a partial negative charge on the phosphorous atom, and therefore a protic reactivity of the hydrogen.6 The electronegativities of phosphorus and hydrogen (χR(P) = 2.19, χR(H) = 2.20) are very closely matched. Consequently an Umpolung of the canonical reactivity is feasible.7 Indeed, the P-hydrido variants of 1,3,2-diazaphospholenes (DAPs), in which the electronic environment of the phosphorous is modulated by the surrounding atoms, exhibit a reversed polarity resulting in hydridic behavior of the P–H bond (Fig. 1).8 DAPs were first reported in the 1980s by the groups of Schmidpeter, Pudovik, and Hargis,9 but received little attention in the following decades. Gudat initiated their renaissance by investigating the structural and reactive properties of the P-hydrido substituted DAPs. DAPs exhibit markedly different properties to the compounds they most closely resemble, the saturated N-heterocyclic phosphines (NHPs), in that significant ionization of the exocyclic P–X bond is observed, even for substituents with relatively low electronegativity.10 Crucial to harnessing this unusual property was a better understanding of the electronic factors that contribute to it. To this end, the interactions between the π-electrons of the 5-membered ring (the two lone pairs on the nitrogen atoms, and the CC bond) and the σ*-orbital of the exocyclic P–X bond were investigated both experimentally and computationally.11 The abnormally high degree of P–X bond polarization that results is the basis for the hydridic reactivity observed in DAPs.
The following review highlights the substantial progress made in understanding the chemistry of DAPs and harnessing these properties to develop synthetically useful catalytic transformations using their P-hydrido variants. We begin by discussing the synthesis of DAPs and their structural and electronic features. An overview of the catalytic applications that have since been developed is then presented. To date, both achiral and enantioselective transformations have been reported. Finally, an opinion on the future directions that should be taken within this research field is offered.
The hydridic nature of the DAPs was confirmed by a series of reactions with acids and electrophiles (Scheme 2).8 Compound 3 reacts with triflic acid to evolve hydrogen gas and form a diazaphosphenium triflate. Furthermore, compound 3 readily participates in hydride transfer reactions. It traps the triphenylcarbenium ion to give triphenylmethane, and it was also shown to reduce benzaldehyde to 4. Follow-up studies revealed that DAPs exhibit total 1,4-selectivity in the reduction of α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compounds such as cinnamaldehyde.13
An important contribution to access the P-hydrido DAPs was reported by Kinjo and co-workers.14 They demonstrated that P–O substituted DAPs undergo a σ-bond metathesis event with boranes such a pinacol borane (HBpin) thereby exchanging the P–O and B–H bonding pattern (Scheme 3). This remarkable discovery set the stage for the development of catalytic applications of DAPs as the σ-bond metathesis enables the in situ regeneration of the P-hydrido DAPs from P-alkoxy DAPs such as 5. It has been subsequently shown that secondary phosphine oxides (SPOs), such as 6, can also be converted to the P-hydrido congeners upon treatment with HBpin.15 This transformation presumably occurs through the thermodynamically less favored trivalent tautomer 6a and enabled the direct utilization of the air- and water stable SPOs as precatalysts for reduction reactions.
Recently, the potent nucleophilicity of the DAP-hydrides was quantified according to the Mayr nucleophilicity scale by Cheng and co-workers.16 Their systematic study on the kinetics of hydride addition to several benchmark electrophiles established that 1 is, at the time of writing, the most nucleophilic hydride donor ever quantified, with a nucleophilicity parameter (N) of 25.54 (cf. for NaBH4, N = 14.74).
Building on the first catalytic application of DAPs to effect P–C bond formation,17 a number of protocols have been reported over the last ten years using DAP-hydrides in catalytic systems to effect reductive transformations. Such methodologies have helped to establish this field as an alternative to more developed metal-based catalytic systems that suffer from economic and ecological issues. To provide an overview of the variety available, a number of DAPs that have been applied in catalysis are presented (Fig. 2). The isolated P-hydrido DAP 1 has been used directly as a catalyst, while in some cases, more stable and user-friendly pre-catalysts have been used, which are converted to the active P-hydrido species in situ by the action of a stoichiometric reducing agent. These include the SPO 6. It has also been demonstrated that the P-neopentyloxy substituted DAP 7 exhibits greater tolerance to air and water than other alkoxy substituted DAPs such as 5.18 Upon treatment with HBpin, the strained triaminophosphine 8, reported by the Radosevich group, undergoes cleavage of one P–N bond to uncover the diazaphospholene unit.19 Efforts to fine-tune the chemical properties of these catalysts have resulted in the synthesis and application of DAPs bearing diverse structural modifications: the steric and electronic environment around the phosphorus center can be modulated by employing different amine components such as diisopropylaniline in the DAP synthesis (9).20 Conversely, benzannulated DAPs such as 10, 11, and the cationic diazaphosphenium triflate 12 use the carbon backbone as a means of introducing structural variance.21 Furthermore, recent interest in the development of enantioselective applications of DAP catalysis has seen the design of a growing family of chiral DAPs. First generation chiral scaffolds have been based around commercially-available chiral amines, giving quick and efficient access to the targeted DAPs 13–18.22,23 Subsequent chiral DAPs have employed annulated chiral manifolds to give more rigid DAP structures with conformationally locked stereochemical environments (19–29).20,24 The methodologies (both racemic and enantioselective) in which these catalysts and precatalysts have been utilized will now be systematically discussed.
Fig. 2 Representative examples of achiral (top) and chiral (bottom) 1,3,2-diazaphospholene catalysts and precatalysts. |
Kinjo et al. have also reported a DAP-catalyzed reduction of CO2 and demonstrated that the reduced product could be trapped in a one-pot process with primary and secondary amines to efficiently access a range of formamides (Scheme 5).26 Interestingly, Ph2SiH2 was used as the terminal reductant, demonstrating that, in addition to boranes, certain silanes can also undergo a σ-bond metathesis with P-alkoxy substituted DAPs. The catalytic cycle commences with hydride addition from 1 to CO2, generating P-formyl substituted DAP 31. Consecutive hydride transfers from Ph2SiH2 lead to the formation of Ph2Si(OCHO)2 and the regeneration of 1. Acyl transfer from Ph2Si(OCHO)2 onto the amine component then completes the reaction by giving the desired formamide and the silanol byproduct. Primary and secondary amines, including a variety of electronically and sterically diverse anilines, engage in the coupling with the silanol, providing a glimpse into the remarkable tolerance of DAPs towards protic functionality.
Similarly, the Speed group also showed that the neutral DAP 7 was also able to catalyze the hydroboration of pyridines.27 The majority of substrates were selectively reduced at the C-4 position, albeit with one substrate, bearing a CF3 group at the C-3 position resulting in a 1:1 mixture of regioisomers, somewhat in contrast to the pattern observed by the Kinjo group. Furthermore, this catalytic system was unable to reduce more electron rich pyridine substrates that the cationic diazaphosphenium manifold could. This difference in reactivity is likely indicative of a slightly different mechanism (Scheme 7). Based on DFT studies, Kinjo and co-workers proposed that the interaction of the cationic 12 with pinacol borane and one equivalent of the pyridine substrate leads to formation of the Lewis adduct 32 with concomitant hydride transfer to generate the neutral P-hydrido DAP 33. Complexation of another pyridine unit to the boron gives the activated boronium species 34. 33 then effects the addition of hydride to one pyridine unit, while the other decomplexes to release the hydroborated product and regenerate the diazaphosphenium 12 and close the catalytic cycle. Based on NMR studies, Speed et al. proposed that the key boronium intermediate 34 of Kinjo's report does not form under the neutral manifold, which potentially explains the slight differences in reactivity and selectivity observed.
Scheme 7 Diazaphosphenium catalyzed pyridine hydroboration proceeds through an activated boronium species. |
Analogously to aldehydes and ketones, imines were demonstrated to be viable substrates independently by the groups of both Speed (Scheme 9, top) and Radosevich (bottom) in 2017.18,19 Rather than employing the isolated P-hydrido DAP, the two groups demonstrated that P-R and P-NR2 substituted DAPs could be used as pre-catalysts. In particular, it was demonstrated that 7, bearing a neopentyloxy substituent, displays significantly greater stability towards both air and moisture than the P-hydrido DAP 1 and other alkoxy substituted DAPs. Upon treatment with pinacol borane, conversion to 1 enables entry to the desired catalytic cycle. The Radosevich protocol employs the strained triaminophosphine 8 as the DAP catalyst. Activation with pinacol borane induce a σ-bond metathesis event with one of the flanking P–N bonds to generate a C1-symmetric P-hydrido species. In both reports, aldimines and ketimines could be efficiently converted to the corresponding amines at room temperature.
The DAP-catalyzed reduction of imines was extended by the Speed group in 2017 with the disclosure of a chiral C2-symmetric DAP precatalyst 13 capable of enantioselective hydride additions (Scheme 10a).22 This catalyst is based off a cheap, commercially-available chiral amine and is synthesized in three steps. The reaction proceeds under mild conditions providing access to a series of amines with low to good enantioselectivities. Aided by analysis of the crystal structure of 13, the authors rationalized the observed enantioselectivity based on a quadrant model. The approach of the substrate to the active catalytic species is dictated by the favorable placement of the large substituents in the relatively empty quadrants of the catalyst. Conversely, the smaller substituents on the substrate align with the quadrants occupied by the bulky naphthyl groups. As such, a sufficient difference in the steric bulk on either side of the imine was necessary for efficient transfer of chirality. A subsequent report in 2019 disclosed a more reactive catalytic system based on the chiral cationic diazaphosphenium triflate 15, that was able to reduce cyclic imines to the corresponding piperidines and pyrrolidines with good to excellent enantioselectivities (Scheme 10b).23 The chiral scaffold used in both catalytic systems is the same, however, the heightened activity of the cationic diazaphosphenium system enabled the reaction to proceed efficiently at −35 °C, giving an extra boost to the enantioselectivity.
In 2018, Cramer and co-workers reported the first asymmetric conjugate reduction catalyzed by DAPs (Scheme 12).24 Catalysts based off simple, commercially-available chiral amines were examined, however, they did not display sufficient levels of enantioselectivity. It was hypothesized that free rotation about the exocyclic C–N bonds resulted in a poorly defined stereochemical environment around the reactive phosphorus centre. To achieve high enantioselectivities, it was necessary to design a new class of chiral DAPs that were locked into a more rigid conformation. Catalysts with chiral substituents that were annulated onto the backbone (19–28, Fig. 2) were synthesized and showed an improvement in selectivity. The best performing DAP from this class, 28, catalyzed the reduction of a range of substrates including α,β-unsaturated acyl pyrroles, ketones, and amides with enantioselectivities ranging from moderate to excellent.
Scheme 12 A designer chiral DAP enables excellent enantioinduction in conjugate reductions of α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compounds. |
An interesting application of DAP-catalysis was disclosed in 2019: conjugate reduction of allyl-ester enoates, catalyzed by DAP 5, yielded allyl enolates, which then underwent [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangements (Scheme 13).20 This is the first instance of a DAP-catalyzed process forming C–C bonds. A wide variety of substrates, many with sensitive functionality, could be engaged in the reaction. The diastereoselectivity of the reaction could be modulated with different catalysts, such as 9, and solvents. In some cases, this enabled access to either of the two possible product diastereomers with good selectivity.
Using the chiral DAP 29 as the catalyst, a single example of an enantioselective rearrangement was described (Scheme 14). Hydride addition to substrate 35 generated the transient enolate 36 with a chiral DAP counterion. This species rearranged spontaneously to give the Claisen product 37 in excellent yield and diastereoselectivity, and with moderate enantioselectivity, proving that the chiral DAP counterion provides sufficient bias to favor one enantiomeric rearrangement product over the other. In doing so, this provided the first example of enantioselective α-carbonyl functionalization under DAP catalysis.
Scheme 14 An enantioselective reductive claisen rearrangement under DAP-catalysis opens the door for enantioselective α-functionalization of enolates. |
The potent nucleophilic properties of DAP-hydrides, and their remarkably low basicity, was recently exploited by the Cramer group who showed that the combination of DAP-precatalyst 38 and phenylsilane (PhSiH3) as the terminal reductant can effect the selective 1,4-reduction of α,β-unsaturated carboxylic acids (Scheme 15).29 Despite the presence of the potentially problematic acidic proton, the reaction smoothly proceeds to completion with only 0.35 equivalents of PhSiH3, demonstrating that each hydride on the stoichiometric reducing agent is competent for catalyst turnover, and that any acid–base reactivity is virtually negligible under the reaction conditions and is dominated by the nucleophilic delivery of hydride to the β-position of the substrate. A wide variety of functional groups were well tolerated in the reaction, and when the chiral DAP 29 was employed with pinacol borane as the terminal reductant, 2-phenylpropionic acid was obtained with moderate enantioenrichment (64:36 er).
Scheme 15 The low basicity of diazaphospholenes enables the direct conjugate reduction of α,β-unsaturated carboxylic acids. |
• Next-generation chiral DAP scaffolds.
• Parametrization of substituent effects.
• Hydrogen gas as stoichiometric reductant.
• New reduction-induced methodologies.
• Group transfers beyond hydride.
Progress within each area will facilitate a holistic development of the research field and will serve to accelerate the uptake of this chemistry. In first place, new structural designs of DAPs would provide an opportunity improving the structure – reactivity understanding. The development of powerful chiral DAPs able to induce high enantioselectivities on a variety of substrate types is still in its infancy. This leaves ample room for further catalyst development, ideally based on rapidly accessible or even commercially available chiral amines (Fig. 3). Further designs may take advantage of the potential for structural modifications on the carbon backbone. As more catalysts are reported and benchmarked, the extra data will permit a parametrization of the catalytic performance. A systematic analysis of the steric and electronic factors that affect such reactivity would then aid the rational design of subsequent catalysts.
To date, the terminal reductants used for catalyst turnover are limited to boranes and silanes. While these are very convenient and easy-to-handle solids or liquids in a laboratory setting, they have shortcomings in atom economy and price. In this respect, hydrogen gas would be a game changer and enable DAP-catalysis to compete with metal-catalysts in industrial scale applications. Accordingly, investigations towards the possibility of H2 splitting with DAPs are warranted. So far, DAP-catalyzed reductions have only been reported for polarized π-bonds. A significant step ahead would be an upgrade of its capabilities to engage in reductions off unbiased olefins putting it closer into competition with transition-metals based catalysts. To this end, the enantioselective reduction of heterocycles such as pyridines and quinolines would offer a highly sought-after entry point into chiral amine-containing building blocks. Moreover, DAP-catalyzed 1,4-reductions operate under very mild conditions without the need for strong bases and cryogenic temperatures, leading to phosphorus enolates as intermediates. Having a chiral DAP near, these intermediates may allow to tap into the very broad reactivity portfolio of transformation with nucleophilic enolates and render them enantioselective. Notably, during the drafting of this manuscript, two reports, detailing the use of DAP-hydrides in radical reactions appeared.30,31 These results open the possibility for a complementary reactivity mode involving hydrogen radicals instead of the hydride paradigm. Whereas both reactions utilise a stoichiometric amount of DAP-hydride, it remains to be investigated whether these processes can be affected using a catalytic amount of the DAP. The prospects of using them as an alternative and mild entry point to access radical-based transformations would open further versatility to the DAPs. While catalytic hydride transfer is unquestionably a cornerstone process, the transfer other groups would greatly extend the utility of DAPs in the future (Scheme 16). For example, it is well understood that silyl is an isolobal fragment to hydrogen. Additional elements or groups are conceivable to be transferred as well. With appropriate reagents, new catalyst designs may open the door to such transfer reactions.
The emergence of DAP catalyzed reactions over the last few years impressively showed again the great importance of the element phosphorus for organic chemistry. We strongly believe, that DAP-catalysis is just at its beginning. It holds the promise of attractive reactivity with implications on many aspects of catalysis and synthetic organic chemistry just waiting to be unlocked.
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2020 |