Wei
Si†
a,
Junhao
Li†
b,
Guangwu
Li
*a,
Chuancheng
Jia
*a and
Xuefeng
Guo
*ab
aCenter of Single-Molecule Sciences, Institute of Modern Optics, Frontiers Science Center for New Organic Matter, College of Electronic Information and Optical Engineering, Nankai University, 38 Tongyan Road, Jinnan District, Tianjin 300350, P. R. China. E-mail: guoxf@pku.edu.cn; jiacc@nankai.edu.cn; ligw@nankai.edu.cn
bBeijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences, National Biomedical Imaging Center, College of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, Peking University, Beijing 100871, P. R. China
First published on 30th November 2023
Single-molecule non-volatile memories can be designed as high-density memories and memristors. The latter, enabling real-time data processing by performing computations directly within the memory unit, holds the potential to surpass the limitations predicted by the Von Neumann architecture. This article provides an overview of the research progress on non-volatile memories associated with functional centers of single molecules. Single-molecule devices with bistable or even multistable switching characteristics have been used to achieve storage and memory resistance functions. This review aims to summarize strategies for achieving non-volatile resistance switching using single-molecule devices, including the design of functional molecules and device construction. It uncovers the physical and chemical mechanisms by which single-molecule non-volatile memories realize multistable conductance states, such as conformational transformations, tautomerisms, intramolecular motions, spin changes, and charge changes. Furthermore, it discusses the potential developments and challenges of single-molecule non-volatile memories, including the diversity in device construction, the challenges of device integration, and the possibility of achieving the high performance, while proposing potential solutions. The objective of this review is to provide readers with fresh research insights and avenues for further exploration, thereby introducing new perspectives in the field of single-molecule non-volatile memories.
Single-molecule devices, a facet of nanotechnology, renowned for their minute size and rich functionality, have piqued the interest of researchers globally.16–18 Contemporary research studies on single-molecule devices primarily concentrate on two approaches: one is to regulate the basic physical properties of single molecules, and the other is to realize the functionalization of single-molecule devices.19–22 This encompasses considerations such as electrode material selection, interface linkages, molecular functional center design, and the introduction of external fields for regulating molecular properties.23–25 Owing to the diverse and tunable designs of both devices and molecules, single-molecule devices offer innovative research avenues in electronics, optoelectronics, and spintronics, achieving noteworthy accomplishments.26–28 Recent findings in single-molecule electronics demonstrate the feasibility of stable bistable conductive states at the single-molecule scale. This suggests that a molecule can alternate between two distinct conductive states and maintain these states under working conditions. Such a characteristic lays the foundation for non-volatile memories, as binary data can be represented via these two stable molecular states. For instance, source–drain electrodes, while providing working voltages, may also alter a molecule's redox state or influence its conformation, thereby affecting its conductivity.29–31 To devise and fabricate efficient single-molecule non-volatile memories, the mechanism of molecular bistability must be thoroughly investigated. This entails understanding molecular responses under varying conditions and governing molecular states through external stimuli such as a light field, an electric field or a magnetic field.32,33 Furthermore, practical implementation necessitates the integration of these molecules with microelectronic devices, ensuring the compatibility between single-molecule devices and conventional devices during fabrication, and leveraging existing semiconductor manufacturing processes for mass production. Research in single-molecule non-volatile memories not only offers profound insights into the particular properties of a single molecule, but also charts a novel trajectory for future data memory and memristor computing. With the rapid progression of single-molecule science and semiconductor fabrication techniques, single-molecule non-volatile memories are poised for extensive applications in the future.
This review encapsulates recent research reports in the domain of single-molecule devices, aiming to furnish readers with a comprehensive overview of single-molecule non-volatile memories. The initial section elucidates fabrication methodologies of single-molecule non-volatile memories. The second part summarizes the basic principles and evolutionary trajectories of single-molecule non-volatile memories. The concluding remarks spotlight the existing challenges and impediments in the realm of single-molecule non-volatile memories, expressing our aspiration that this exposition might kindle heightened interest among researchers in this sector, laying a robust foundation for future investigations and memory applications.
Fig. 1 Preparation of single-molecule devices. (a) Schematic representation of the mechanically controllable break junction technique: two Au electrodes are stretched by mechanical forces to create nanoscale gaps. (b) Schematic representation of the scanning tunneling microscope break junction technique. The molecules deposited on the surface are picked up by the tip of STM. (c) Single-molecule FET devices using the electromigration break junction technique.36 Copyright: 2002, Macmillan Magazines Ltd. (d) Schematic representation of etching SWNTs by oxygen plasma into carboxylic acid-functionalized point contacts.40 Copyright: 2006, The AAAS. (e) Schematic representation of graphene single-molecule devices, formed by feedback-controlled electroburning.41 Copyright: 2011, ACS. (f) DLL strategy enables the fabrication of graphene triangle electrode arrays with nanogaps.42 Copyright: 2012, WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim. |
Similar to a MCBJ, a scanning tunneling microscope break junction (STM-BJ) is a dynamic break junction (Fig. 1(b)).35 Picking up individual molecules deposited on the substrate surface through atomic sized tips, a molecule can construct a connection with the substrate and the tip simultaneously. This method can offer the advantage of simplicity and the ability to detect a multitude of surface atoms thousands of times over, yielding statistically sound conductivity results with excellent reproducibility. In addition, due to the ability of the STM technology to manipulate tip movement at the nanoscale and sensitivity in the z-direction, this approach facilitates the determination of molecular mechanical properties and the conductance changed with the length of molecules during stretching. However, the tip and the substrate mode pose a huge challenge for the production of integrated devices.
The advantages and disadvantages of STM-BJ and MCBJ technologies complement each other, making them an important platform for single-molecule electrical detection. Due to their similar working principles, it is expected that conductivity measurements of the same molecular system in similar environments will show good consistency.
Other methods using Au as electrodes to prepare single-molecule break junctions are as follows. Similar to the MCBJ, the method of electromigration break junctions is to use a gradually enlarged current to burn the gold wire.36 When a large electric current is passed through, the atoms in the gold electrodes will migrate, resulting in nanoscale gaps (Fig. 1(c)). Angular evaporation, online evaporation etching, and self-template masking methods all utilize nanoscale templates, either internal or external, in conjunction with traditional lithography and etching techniques.37–39 These methods allow for the production of nanoelectrodes smaller than the template size, followed by the construction of single-molecule junctions through molecular self-assembly. These methods need to improve the success rate of device fabrication to satisfy the requirements of integration.
It is worth noting that the aforementioned methods primarily employed gold as the electrode material, which has its drawbacks. Firstly, gold's high mobility can lead to atomic electromigration under the influence of bias voltage-generated electric fields, causing configuration changes, breakages, or short circuits. Secondly, gold can undergo non-specific adsorption with numerous molecules, resulting in the connection of unrelated molecules to the device, leading to noise signals. As a result, many tests need to be conducted in a vacuum environment. Lastly, metal atoms and molecules can form three types of connections: bridge, vertex, and triangle, each yielding distinct conductance properties.
SWCNTs represent a one-dimensional quantum material with a distinctive structure. The electrical properties of SWCNTs have been extensively studied, and in particular their electronic characteristics can be tuned into metallicity, offering an opportunity to create single-molecule junctions using SWCNT electrodes.40,49 This process involves coating the SWCNT surface with a layer of polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) and employing high-resolution electron beam lithography (EBL) to produce ultra-small window precursors. Subsequently, oxygen plasma ion etching (RIE) is employed to etch the exposed SWCNT at these windows, producing nanogap electrodes with carboxyl-modified edges (Fig. 1(d)). Molecules featuring amino groups at both ends can be covalently linked to these electrodes through acylation reactions, yielding stable single-molecule junctions. It's worth noting that the size of these nanogaps can be precisely adjusted by varying the degree of oxidation, achieved by altering the exposure time under oxygen. Under optimized conditions, this method can achieve a success rate of approximately 20% to 25% in forming single-molecule connections.
Graphene, a two-dimensional semimetallic carbon material with a zero-bandgap, has played a pivotal role in various fields since its discovery. In comparison to SWCNTs, the mature technology for graphene production and transformation are well-established, providing the necessary infrastructure for incorporating graphene into single-molecule devices. Initially, the electrodes with nanoscale gaps in graphene can be achieved through feedback-controlled combustion methods (Fig. 1(e)).41 This involves employing a gradient current control based on feedback conductivity to burn away graphene. When the current decreases, the voltage is returned to zero, and the process is repeated to initiate a new voltage scan. The high-density current and Joule heat generated by applying a significant bias voltage leads to the oxidation and etching of graphene, gradually narrowing the graphene electrode to create nanoscale gaps. Molecules can then bridge between these graphene electrodes through π–π stacking interactions. However, the lack of precise control over the sites during this oxidation process makes the electric combustion method less predictable, resulting in unclear electrode configurations. To address this challenge, the dashed line lithography (DLL) strategy enables the fabrication of graphene triangle electrode arrays with nanogaps matched to the molecular scale (Fig. 1(f)).42,50 This method aims to create carboxylic acid-terminated graphene nanogap electrodes, which establish a reliable connection between the target molecule and the electrode. Initially, PMMA is spun onto the graphene surface to form a mask layer. Electron beam etching is then performed on each graphene device using a CAD file with a designed dashed line pattern. Oxygen plasma etching is employed to precisely etch the graphene bands along the exposed windows, resulting in a serrated point-to-point graphene nanogap point electrode array.
Comparison to dynamic break junctions, static single-molecule devices can achieve the field-effect transistor (FET) functionality through more intricate fabrication processes. The increased bond energy of the amide bond significantly enhances device stability, as evidenced by the high cycle numbers demonstrated in subsequent research on memristor model devices. However, the complexity of the preparation process has led to a moderate success rate for carbon-based single-molecule devices. Currently, the most critical challenge in this field is to improve the success rate of device preparation, particularly achieving integration for practical applications.
Fig. 2 Preparation of vertical molecular tunneling devices. (a) Structure and mechanism of vertical molecular tunneling devices. (b) Schematic illustrations of junctions with M = Ag, Au, and Pt.51 Copyright: 2020, American Chemical Society. (c) Schematic of a transparent and flexible molecular monolayer junction between the two graphene electrodes.52 Copyright: 2013, Springer Nature Limited. (d) Schematic illustration of the device structure of Au/Fc-SAM/SLG junction with a liquid drop on top of the chip.30 Copyright: 2020, Elsevier Inc. |
Currently, single-molecule non-volatile memory devices can be fabricated through various methods; some representative examples are as follows. Fig. 2(b) showcases a traditional device fabrication method starting with a silicon wafer, followed by the preparation of metal electrodes through thermal or electron beam evaporation. Single molecules are anchored to metal electrodes via chemical bonds, such as disulfide bonds. Ultimately, the EGaIn electrode is transferred onto the self-assembled monolayer, with EGaIn being the most popular top electrode due to its low contact resistance and high stability.51Fig. 2(c) presents another fabrication approach, where graphene is employed for bottom and top electrodes. The graphene bottom electrode forms carbon–carbon bonds with aromatic diazonium salts chemically, while the top electrode binds to the molecular film via van der Waals forces. Compared to metal electrodes, graphene offers superior conductivity, chemical stability, thinness, flexibility, exceptional mechanical bendability, and translucency, which implies that SAMs can be more easily modulated by external fields such as light and force. Furthermore, the experiment utilizes flexible PDMS/PET as its substrate, enabling mechanical bending capabilities for the device.52 Lastly, Fig. 2(d) displays a more innovative design. This design involves depositing gold on etched conductive Si to serve as the bottom electrode, followed by further molecular assembly. Employing chemical vapor deposition (CVD) grown graphene as the top electrode provides exceptional transparency. The selective permeability of graphene ensures that devices can be regulated through external factors such as ion gates. This structure allows researchers to explore the relationship between Fermi levels and molecular orbital levels between molecules and graphene more conveniently and control the oxidation–reduction states of the molecule with ease.30 This innovative design paves the way for future molecular-scale non-volatile memories and holds promise as a vital direction for the future of electronics.
Fig. 3 Diagram of the bistable transformation mechanism caused by conformational transformations. (a) Diagram of STM experiments. BPDN molecules are inserted into the C11 alkane matrix.55 Copyright: 2005, Springer Nature Limited. (b) Diagram of Gdiff–V data of BPDN-DT and BP-DT. Black arrows indicate the discontinuity in the BPDN-DT curve.57 (c) Schematic diagram of reversible conformational changes of ADT at different voltages.58 Copyright: 2015, American Chemical Society. (d) Schematic diagram of conformation changes of DEB by mechanical force.59 Copyright: 2015 Macmillan Publishers Limited. |
In addition, the pentaphenyl analog anthrthiophene (ADT) demonstrates a fully reversible binary switch between different adsorption conformations on metal surfaces with charge transfer (Fig. 3(c)).58 In the low conduction state (off state), the ADT molecule adopts a curved adsorption geometry, with the propylene ring situated close to the Cu (111) surface, and the LUMO orbital partially occupied. By applying a substantial negative bias voltage pulse, the ADT molecule transforms into a planar structure (on state), moving away from the substrate. This leads to a decrease in the energy of the LUMO orbital and the opening of a conductive window.
Apart from bias as an external stimulus, mechanical forces can also induce reversible tautomeric changes in double bonds. Using scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) to anchor para-diacetylene benzene (DEB) between silicon components to form Si/single-molecule/Si structures, a robust covalent bond forms between the molecule and the silicon electrode (Fig. 3(d)).59 This enables stable and repetitive control of the molecule's conformation through a mechanical force. Although the DEB molecule itself is symmetrical, the double bond formed after anchoring to the silicon electrode imparts asymmetry. When the two double bonds are positioned on the same side, a cis configuration is achieved, while opposite positions result in a trans conformation. When stretched along the z-axis, the DEB structure transitions from cis to trans, with the distance between the compression tip and the base changing back to cis. Calculation shows that the DEB conductance primarily relies on the energy level of the LUMO. The trans structure, characterized by a greater distance, exhibits a lower LUMO orbital energy which is closer to the Fermi level than the cis structure, consequently yielding higher conductance values.
Fig. 4 Diagram of the bistable transformation mechanism caused by tautomerisms. (a) A concept of electron-induced isomerization of an azobenzene adsorbed onto a metallic surface with a scanning tunneling microscope.63 Copyright: 2006 American Physical Society. (b) The current responses of write-read-erase-read performances at 3, −1, −3, and −1 V with 2 s of pulse width time.64 Copyright: 2013, WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim. (c) Schematic depiction of the single-molecule device with a modulating bias and the mechanism of conduction changes.27 Copyright: 2020 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim. |
Norbornene (NB) can be photoisomerized in traditional photochemical experiments.65,66 When a single norbornene molecule is connected between electrodes, tautomerisms can also occur to form quadricyclane (QC) structures under electrical stimulation (Fig. 4(c)).27,67 NB structures with higher conjugation exhibit greater conductance than QC structures. The forward transformation from NB to QC is thermally activated by an electrically heated junction, while the reverse process necessitates a high bias voltage and single electron transfer (SET) between the molecule and the gold contact to induce reverse isomerization. By adjusting the bias between the two switching potentials, both reactions can be controlled reversibly in situ. Writing NB is achieved by applying a high bias voltage of 0.75 V, reading requires a bias of 0.1 V, and erasure back to QC is accomplished by applying a bias of 0.25 V.
Fig. 5 Diagram of the bistable transformation mechanism caused by motion of inset in EMF. (a) Schematic representation of single-molecule switches of Tb@C82 that describes hysteresis and NDC caused by the interaction between its electric dipole moment and an external electric field.71 Copyright: 2005, American Chemical Society. (b) Coulomb stability diagrams of a Ce@C82 single-molecule transistor measured (left) before and (right) after the large bias voltage inducing the hysteretic behavior is applied. The schematic illustrations of possible molecular configurations for two states are showed below, respectively.72 Copyright: AIP Publishing. (c) Schematic representation of single-molecule electret of Gd@C82 using the electromigration break junction technique. The dipole moment of molecule is regulated by the gate voltages.73 Copyright: 2020, Springer Nature Limited. (d) Molecular structures and energy level diagrams of the Sc2C2@Cs(hept)-C88 device.74 Copyright: 2022, Springer Nature Limited. |
Mechanical interlocking molecular architectures, exemplified by rotaxane and catenane, can exhibit bistable properties.75–77 These molecules offer intriguing possibilities for designing memory function molecules by utilizing redox reactions to reversibly transform between several stable structures.78 [2]catenane, for instance, is assembled using a combination of components, including tetrathiofulvalene (TTF), a 1,5-dioxynaphthalene ring system (NP) and two bipyridine units.79 Monolayer composed of this compound have been found to exhibit I–V hysteresis upon testing, paving the way for the development of non-volatile memory devices. The switching mechanism is depicted in Fig. 6(a), and the TTF group undergoes formation of structure [B]. When the voltage is reduced to close to zero, the co-configuration [B+0] is established with the reduction of TTF, representing an oxidation achieved by applying a −2 V bias voltage, leading to a Coulomb repulsion with two bipyridine units, resulting in the low-conductivity state (with a reading voltage of 0.1 V). The bipyridine ring is further reduced by application of a +2 V bias voltage, regenerating it into the [A0] structure. It is important to note that thermal relaxation is required during this cycle, limiting the device's operation to temperatures above 220 K. In addition to catenanes, memory devices based on [2]rotaxanes following principles have also been introduced, featuring a capacity of 160000 bits (Fig. 6(b)).80 These cross-bar memories are assembled with 400 silicon nanowires serving as the bottom electrode (16 nm wide, 33 nm spacing; doped with phosphate), passing over 400 Ti nanowire electrodes (16 nm wide, 33 nm spacing) (Fig. 6(c)). A single layer of bistable [2]rotaxane is sandwiched between these two nanowires. Despite the presence of numerous defects in the circuit, these defects can be easily identified through electronic testing and isolated using software coding. In addition, the signal retention time measured for this device (90 ± 40 minutes; median decay 75 minutes) is statistically equivalent to the rate reported for much larger and more well-characterized devices (58 ± 5 minutes).80
Fig. 6 Diagram of the bistable transformation mechanism caused by the motion of mechanical interlocking molecular architectures and reaction. (a) Controlled by voltage regulation, [2]catenanes transfer reversibly between bistable states.79 Copyright: 2000, AAAS. (b) Structural formula of the bistable [2]rotaxane used in the crossbar memory. (c) Image of the entire circuit. [2]rotaxanes are deposited between two orthogonal nanowires.80 Copyright: 2007, Springer Nature Limited. (d) Schematic diagram of memristors based on a Fries rearrangement reaction. The rearrangement of p-PS and o-PS products can be controlled by electric field direction.81 Copyright: 2022, Wiley-VCH GmbH. |
A single-molecule memristor is proposed, designed around the concept of dynamic structure reconstruction powered by an electric field (Fig. 6(d)).81 The functional core of this memristor consists of phenyl acetate, which is tethered between graphene point electrodes via an amide bond. The inclusion of a PDMS package serves to prevent the escape of acetyl groups and enhances the device's operational lifespan. The key principle at play here is the reversible Fries rearrangement, which allows the acetyl group to be strategically positioned in the ortho–para-position of the hydroxyl or benzene ring, all under the influence of an electric field. Initially, the memristor is in a stable RS(PS) state, but this state can be effectively erased by applying a bias pulse of +0.6 V (−0.6 V) and rewritten to PS(RS) by employing a bias of −0.05 V (+0.05 V). The performance of this covalently connected solid-state single-molecule memristor is remarkable. It has demonstrated its capabilities by successfully undergoing more than 2000 high-frequency write–erase operations within a mere 10 seconds, showcasing the stability of resistance switching through structural reconstruction.
Single-molecule magnets (SMMs) exhibit magnetic behavior similar to macroscopic magnets. Typically, these molecules possess one or more unpaired electron spins, which can interact and result in the overall magnetic properties of the molecule. Since the late last century, when magnetic hysteresis of SMMs was observed, there have been numerous reports on studying molecular magnetic features using SMMs on various substrates. Nonetheless, a fundamental challenge lies in the elusive preservation of molecular magnetic hysteresis evidence when SMMs interface with metal surfaces, substantially hampering their integration into electronic devices. Roberta Sessoli's group designed a sulfur-functionalized derivative, [Fe4(L)2(dpm)6], which self-assembles into a monolayer on the Au surface (Fig. 7(a) and (b)). This Fe4 molecule, consisting of four high-spin iron(III) ions, exhibits a propeller-like molecular structure. The outer four Fe spins (S = 5/2) interact antiferromagnetically with the inner Fe spin resulting in a ground spin (S = 5) state characterized by an anisotropy barrier of about 16 K.32 For the first time, the hysteresis behavior of pure molecular SMMs on a non-magnetic Au electrode is observed. Although integrating SMMs into non-volatile memory devices still faces challenges like low operational temperatures, this study underscores the potential of SMMs to achieve magnetic bistability. Building on this research, one can envision using other means to alter the bistability of the molecule, such as the possibility of controlling magnetization reversal in the electrode–molecule–electrode nanostructure via conducting electrons.
Fig. 7 Diagram of the bistable transformation mechanism caused by spin changes. (a) Schematic diagram of the Fe4 anchoring on a gold surface. (b) Hysteresis and magnetization dynamics of the Fe4 monolayer.32 Copyright: 2009, Springer Nature Limited. (c) Three-dimensional model of a Fe-phen molecule. (d) Simplified electronic configuration of the Fe(II) 3d states in the ligand field.82 Copyright: 2012, The Author(s). (e) Zinc methyl phenalenyl (ZMP) transitions from a neutral state with no spin to a charged radical with a magnetic moment upon interaction with a ferromagnet surface. (f) Magnetoresistance measurements of a device with a single ferromagnetic electrode.33 Copyright: 2013, Springer Nature Limited. |
Beyond SMMs, spin-crossover (SCO) molecules can be used to prepare memories between low-spin (LS) and high-spin (HS) states upon external stimuli like temperature, light, pressure, magnetic or electric fields, or charge flow. As shown in Fig. 7(c) and (d) a prototypical SCO complex, Fe(1,10-phenanthroline)2(NCS)2 molecules (Fe-phen), undergoes a spin transition around 175 K, accompanied by changes in Fe–N bond distances and angles. At this temperature, the splitting energy between eg and t2g decreases, causing the Fe-phen molecule to transition from a LS (S = 0) state to a high-spin HS (S = 2) state.82 This study, at low temperatures (≈4.6 K), employed STM to probe the spin states and conductance of single Fe-phen molecules. The results revealed coexistence of HS and LS states for Fe-phen molecules adsorbed on a Cu (100) surface. However, strong coupling of the NCS group with the substrate prevented spin-state writing via voltage. Introducing an interfacial CuN layer to weaken the interaction between the molecule and the metal interface successfully achieved a spin-crossover transition at the single-molecule level through applied voltage. The research results reveal that the molecule transits from the LS state to the HS state at 3.0 V. In the HS state, with a delay of 1.4 seconds after voltage removal, there is a slight decrease in current, leading to a return to the LS state and achieving a bistable transition.
Altering the spin-injection properties of the electrode is an important method for achieving molecular spin changes. As illustrated in Fig. 7(e) and (f), the neutral molecule C14H10O2Zn (ZMP) possesses no net spin. However, when grown on a ferromagnetic surface, spin transfer at the interface facilitates the formation of a hybrid organic–metal supermagnetic layer, exhibiting significant magnetic anisotropy and spin-filtering properties. This interfacial layer produces spin-associated resistance, displaying interface magnetoresistance (IMR) effects at room temperature.33 This chemical modification at the interface arises from interactions between molecular orbitals and ferromagnetic d-orbital. These interactions yield new interface states, altering the electronic and magnetic properties of the molecule. These effects largely depend on the specific molecular structure and morphology, influencing spin polarization and spin injection efficiency. The ZMP molecule's geometric configuration allows for strong overlap between d and p orbitals, triggering d–p hybridization effects. The IMR response offers an effective means to detect and modulate the spin states of magnetic molecules, paving the way for advancements in molecular memory technology at room temperature.
Introducing redox groups into molecules is an effective means to achieve bistable conductance in single-molecule devices. Compared to C12 and OPE molecules (Fig. 8(a)), the top molecule has a redox section, and a distinct redox peak appears in the cyclic voltammetry (CV) test. To construct a comprehensive electronic apparatus, these nanowires are meticulously positioned between two larger gold electrodes, resulting in a sandwiched electrode–molecule–electrode configuration. These molecules, under ambient conditions, exhibit repeatable bistable switching characteristics, signifying their capability to toggle reversibly between two distinct states in memories.85 Further empirical investigations revealed the molecules’ cyclic voltammograms, showcasing two pronounced single-electron redox peaks. These reversible chemical transitions are likely correlated with the observed reversible switching characteristics in these conductors, suggesting that toggling the molecule's redox state can switch its conductive state. This process encompasses charge capture, where charges traverse from the source to the drain, instigating a shift in the molecular charge state. Specifically, when a potential difference is applied across the electrodes, charges migrate from one electrode to the other. During this transition, charges initially permeate the connected molecule and are either captured or released by the molecule's redox center. This dynamic sequence culminates in redox reactions, effectuating the molecular conductive state switch.
Fig. 8 Diagram of the bistable transformation mechanism caused by charge changes. (a) Molecules that were incorporated into the in-wire junctions studied here.85 Copyright: 2005, American Chemical Society. (b) Schematic illustration of the Au/Fc-SAM/SLG junction with oxidation and reduction treatments.30 Copyright: 2020, Elsevier Inc. (c) Schematic and mechanism illustration of MV junctions.86 Copyright: 2020, The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Limited. (d) The molecular formula for S-C10-HATNA.31 Copyright: 2022, The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature Limited. |
In the research as shown in Fig. 8(b), the authors harnessed a graphene-based vertical monolayer heterostructure to craft a tri-terminal molecular redox switch device. Initially, a monolayer of 6-ferrocenylhexanethiol (referred to as FcC6S) is formed on an Au/highly-doped Si substrate, which serves as the source electrode. Subsequently, a monolayer of graphene, cultivated through the CVD method, was transferred onto this SAM, acting as the drain electrode. When a 0.1 M HClO4 solution was introduced as the electrolyte, covering both the FcC6S and the gate electrode, the graphene's tight encapsulation of the FcC6S enabled the reversible modulation of electrochemical redox reactions within the graphene layer. It is noteworthy that during the oxidation of FcC6S, when it transitions into a cationic state, an electrostatic repulsion arises between it and graphene, leading to an increased separation between them.30 This electrostatic interplay plays a pivotal role during the redox processes, significantly facilitating the formation of bistability in the memories.
The process of redox reactions generating free radicals may be accompanied by the occurrence of side reactions, further facilitating the formation of high and low conductance states (Fig. 8(c)). MV (methylviologen), in its initial state, is characterized by a dicationic configuration, represented as MV2+. When subjected to a specific external stimulus, it undergoes a transformation, evolving into a radical cation, denoted as MV˙+. However, this state isn’t the molecule's final resting phase. The MV˙+ radical cation experiences an additional dimerization process, eventually leading to the formation of a stable [MV˙+]2 complex. This intricate dimerization is driven by π–π stacking interactions, a phenomenon where aromatic rings stack atop one another due to dispersive forces, and electron spin pairing, which refers to the coupling of unpaired electron spins. Simultaneously, as the molecule undergoes these transformations, there is a need to stabilize the charge that has been introduced into the molecule.
This necessitates an ion migration mechanism. During this phase, excess counter-ions, which are ions that balance the charge of the molecule, make their way to the positively charged bottom electrode. It is crucial to highlight the significance of the counter ion size in this mechanism.86 The dimensions of these counter ions have a profound impact on the efficiency of the dimerization process. Furthermore, they play a decisive role in determining the overall stability of the molecular switch and its operational efficiency. The interplay between the redox processes, dimerization, and ion migration underscores the intricate nature of the MV-based tunneling mechanism and its potential implications in nanoscale memory applications.
Multi-step redox reactions can result in multiple conductance states A particular example is the hexaazatrinaphthylene (HATNA) terminus that readily undergoes six successive proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) steps for dynamic covalent N–H bond formation (Fig. 8(d)). This switch is integrated into a tunneling junction buttressed by a SAM, wherein the terminal parts of the SAM molecule are designed to facilely undergo six consecutive PCET steps. The authors, through CV tests, demonstrated that the SAM underwent sequential PCET with stable intermediates, laying the groundwork for its emulation of synaptic behaviors. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations elucidated the electronic structure of SAM, revealing the impact of the oxidation and protonation states of HATNA on the SAM's electronic structure.31 This electronic structural shift is intrinsically tied to the redox processes, providing a theoretical foundation for the switch's dynamic behavior. Through their unique charge handling mechanisms at the nanoscale, redox-active molecules achieve efficient and stable charge states, with the molecule's redox states and associated chemical reactions playing a pivotal role in non-volatile memories.
The conductivity of molecules is correlated with their structure, including the configuration, conformation, electronic structure, electronic spin and redox state. The transformation between bistable states typically aligns with reversible structural alterations. Achieving non-volatility necessitates the existence of a specific potential barrier between transitions of bistability. From a microscopic perspective, state changes can be categorized into several types, including conformational transformations, tautomerisms, intramolecular motions, spin changes, and charge changes. Conformational transformations primarily involve the rotation of single bonds and distortion of the ring. However, due to the low conversion barriers involved, the conformation changes of most molecules are disordered. Only a limited number of molecules exhibit bistable states. Tautomeric transformations primarily include the Z/E transition of double bonds and tautomeric changes in molecules like norbornene. The intramolecular motions in EMFs, mechanically interlocked molecular architectures, and Fries rearrangement reactions play a significant role. Fullerene inclusion complexes are controlled by an applied electric field and mechanically interlocked molecular architectures use electrostatic forces between intermolecular functional groups. Redox-active molecules are capable of capturing and releasing electrons under the influence of external voltage, maintaining a relatively stable state, which lays the foundation for non-volatile memories. In addition, certain molecules undergo structural changes during charge changes, such as molecular dimerization and ion migration, which play a supplementary role in device functionality. Exploring how to utilize the spin state of single-molecule electrons for information storage and retrieval is a significant direction for future developments in this field. Both single-molecule magnets and spin-crossover molecules have demonstrated unique magnetic behaviors, which can be modulated by external stimuli. Furthermore, the spin-injection characteristics of the electrode are of paramount significance.
Despite substantial progress, the molecule non-volatile memory faces challenges that necessitate the development of new strategies. One of the primary challenges we face is the fabrication of stable and dependable single-molecule devices. Although numerous techniques exist for creating these devices, achieving stability, reliability and reproducibility has proven to be a daunting task. Enhancements in the fabrication of single-molecule devices, including the adoption of novel electromigration or etching methods, hold the promise for increasing the production of single-molecule junctions and enabling the creation of device arrays. Single-molecule devices relying on metal electrodes face issues with stability, as they can be susceptible to damage caused by atomic migration of the electrodes. Given the remarkable stability of carbon materials, such as carbon nanotubes and graphene, these materials are being explored as alternative electrode materials. In addition, there is room for improvement in the way single molecules are connected. Introducing dependable anchor groups through molecular design or establishing strong chemical bonds can significantly enhance the stability of single-molecule devices. Furthermore, there is a need for the design of a greater variety of molecules with bistable state structures. While molecules of diverse structures have been discovered, many of the conductance changes resulting from molecular structural alterations exhibit randomness and disorder. It is essential to develop more experimental assays that enable high-throughput screening of molecules at the single-molecule level. It should be mentioned that current research studies on single-molecule memristors mainly focus on the realization of storage functions, with limited explorations of practical application concerns such as service life, erase/writing time, and energy consumption. Another critical issue of integrating single-molecule memristors remains a key challenge in this field and in the broader domain of single-molecule science. Overcoming these challenges will require significant breakthroughs and advances in the overarching field of single-molecule science. In addition, theoretical calculations can serve as valuable tools to complement experiments and confirm whether a molecule possesses a bistable state. The development of an improved theoretical model to guide experiments is of paramount importance. In summary, advancing research in single-molecule non-volatile memories necessitates collaborative efforts across multiple fields to achieve the goal of practical applications for molecular non-volatile memories.
Footnote |
† W. S. and J. H. L. contributed equally to this review. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |