Rishi
Verma‡
,
Sushma
Kundu‡
and
Vivek
Polshettiwar
*
Department of Chemical Sciences, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR), Mumbai, 400005, India. E-mail: vivekpol@tifr.res.in
First published on 11th September 2024
Dendritic plasmonic colloidosome, also known as “black gold”, is a unique plasmonic material with broad-spectrum light absorption extending from visible to near-infrared wavelengths. Black gold has demonstrated remarkable performance in challenging and industrially relevant reactions, such as CO2 reduction, alcohol oxidation, acetylene semi-hydrogenation, and purification of seawater. Unfortunately, one of the major shortcomings of black gold lies in its intricate multi-step synthesis procedure. This involves the step-by-step growth of Au nanoparticles on a dendritic fibrous nanosilica (DFNS) support, a task spanning several days. Furthermore, the need for solid separation through centrifugation after each cycle is an additional bottleneck. Consequently, this complexity poses a challenge for industrial scaling. In this work, we report a simplified and efficient one-pot synthesis of plasmonic black gold. The one-pot method streamlines the synthesis process, significantly reducing the time from days to hours and eliminating the need for solid separation steps, thereby enhancing sustainability. Characterization studies reveal the optimal reaction time of an hour (instead of days) during the growth step, resulting in black gold materials closely resembling those synthesized via the conventional cycle-by-cycle method. We further demonstrated that DPC-60 synthesized via a one-pot protocol efficiently catalyzes CO oxidation under light, achieving 87% CO conversion at 4.0 W cm−2 without external heating. In situ DRIFTS studies revealed key adsorption sites involved in the CO oxidation reaction, with bridged CO adsorbed on Au0 sites reacting faster than linearly adsorbed CO, and CO on high-coordinated Au0 sites exhibiting a faster reaction rate than that on low-coordinated sites. Thus, the one-pot synthesis will facilitate rapid exploration of black gold's applications in a range of fields and also pave the way for scalable industrial deployment.
The phenomenon of plasmonic excitation presents a distinct solution to this challenge through the manipulation of plasmonic coupling.28,29 Plasmonic coupling occurs when two or more plasmonic nanoparticles are in close proximity, typically within a few nanometers, resulting in the coupling of their plasmonic modes. This engenders broader absorption bands, as there are now multiple modes of light absorption: the pristine plasmonic mode and the coupled mode with differing excitation energies.28,29 Precisely controlling the distances between nanoparticles to induce plasmonic coupling poses a challenge in colloidal solutions, prompting the development of materials where plasmonic nanoparticles are supported on high-surface-area substrates.
Our recently discovered plasmonic “black gold” also referred to as dendritic plasmonic colloidosomes (DPCs), represents a notable example of one such plasmonic material.30 Its synthesis involves the controlled nucleation and growth of gold nanoparticles (Au NPs) on high-surface-area dendritic fibrous nanosilica (DFNS),31–33 resulting in varied interparticle distances and particle size distributions. This diversity enables black gold to exhibit broad-spectrum light absorption extending from visible to near-infrared (NIR) wavelengths. The presence of different particle sizes and plasmonic coupling among Au NPs creates thermal and electric hotspots within black gold, rendering it an efficient catalyst for various reactions.30
Despite its effectiveness, there exists potential for enhancing the catalytic activity of black gold. As gold nanoparticles do not universally exhibit activity for all chemical transformations, the concept of an antenna reactor has been introduced.34 We loaded different active metals, such as Ni or Ru–Pt, onto black gold to form an antenna–reactor complex where black gold functions as the antenna.35–37 These plasmonic catalysts have demonstrated remarkable performance in challenging and industrially relevant reactions, such as CO2 reduction, alcohol oxidation, hydrosilylation of aldehydes, H2/D2 dissociation, hydrodechlorination, alkene and alkyne hydrogenation, one-electron ferricyanide reduction, and acetylene semi-hydrogenation as well as in protein unfolding and purification of seawater to drinkable water.30,35–37
Unfortunately, one of the biggest drawbacks of black gold is its complex multi-step synthesis process. It involves cycle-by-cycle growth of Au NPs to precisely adjust their size and interparticle distances, a process that requires several days. Moreover, the necessity for solid separation via centrifugation after each cycle presents a considerable bottleneck, rendering its synthesis complex, time-consuming, and consequently unsustainable. This factor also renders it less suitable for industrial scaling.
In this study, we report an innovative one-pot synthesis protocol for black gold that circumvents the cycle-by-cycle method, thereby significantly reducing synthesis time from days to mere hours. This approach not only accelerates the process but also reduces chemical consumption and energy demands, contributing to a more sustainable and efficient synthesis. The simplicity and ease of this method make it a significant advancement over the conventional cycle-by-cycle method, allowing for rapid and scalable production. By streamlining the synthesis process, this approach facilitates the swift exploration of black gold's potential applications across diverse fields and makes the scale-up process more practical and economically viable for industrial purposes. The black gold synthesized through this one-pot protocol was subsequently utilized as a plasmonic photocatalyst, demonstrating its effectiveness in photocatalytic CO oxidation to CO2. This underscores the practical advantages of the new method, highlighting its potential to revolutionize the production and application of black gold in various industries.
We evaluated the one-pot synthesis protocol by characterizing the resulting black gold material using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), scanning transmission electron microscopy-energy dispersive spectroscopy (STEM-EDS), powder X-ray diffraction (pXRD), ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) absorption spectroscopy, and N2 sorption measurement. We also used in situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) under light and in the dark to explore the binding nature of CO on Au sites and the reaction mechanism of CO oxidation to CO2.
During this step, the utilization of a strong reducing agent, NaBH4, induced a rapid increase in the concentration of Au0, surpassing the critical concentration necessary for the formation and nucleation of small Au NPs. These formed Au0 nuclei served as sites for the subsequent growth of Au NPs upon further reduction of Au3+ ions. The material obtained at this stage was denoted as DPC-N, where ‘N’ signifies the nucleation step. Subsequently, the loading of Au was performed on DPC-N within the same reaction mixture without isolation.
In the subsequent step, the existing Au nuclei were allowed to grow into larger NPs with varied sizes and interparticle distances. For this, in a 50 mL falcon tube, HAuCl4·3H2O (150 mg) and K2CO3 (280 mg) were dissolved in 45 mL of DI water, and the solution was vortexed for 15 minutes. The amount of gold precursor was carefully calculated to achieve a 43 wt% Au loading on the silica spheres. This reaction between the Au precursor and K2CO3 served to passivate the Au3+ ions, ensuring their slow reduction and favoring the growth of Au nanoparticles rather than new nucleation.
The resulting solution, termed K–Au solution, was then added dropwise to the reaction mixture containing DPC-N in 1.5 minutes using a 10 mL pipette under stirring. Subsequently, ammonium hydroxide solution in water (1 mL, 25% v/v) was added dropwise in 30 seconds into the reaction mixture, followed by the dropwise addition of formaldehyde solution in 1 minute (20 mL, 37 wt% in H2O). The ammonium hydroxide solution provided a basic environment in the reaction mixture, while formaldehyde acted as a weak reducing agent under these basic conditions. Over the course of 5–10 minutes, the color of the solution gradually transitioned from brown to black, indicating the progression of the reaction. The reaction mixture was stirred at 400 rpm for different durations: 30 minutes, 60 minutes, and 120 minutes, and denoted as DPC-30, DPC-60, and DPC-120, respectively. Following the selected stirring period, the solid product was isolated by centrifugation at 10000 rpm for 10 minutes. The isolated product was then washed with ethanol (20 mL, three times) and water (20 mL, three times). Finally, the resulting black gold powder was obtained by drying the isolated and washed product in an oven at 80 °C for 10 hours, ensuring complete removal of the solvent and moisture.
Additionally, we synthesized black gold using the conventional cycle-by-cycle approach by conducting 4 cycles of Au loading.30 This was done to enable comparative analysis between the outcomes of our new protocol and the standard black gold, also known as DPC-C4.
In the case of the DPC-N sample, Au NPs were not readily visible in the SEM images, attributed to the small sizes of the Au NPs (Fig. 1a and S1†). Subsequent HRTEM analysis revealed the presence of small Au NPs distributed on the DFNS sphere (Fig. 1b and c). Particle size distribution analysis indicated the presence of small Au NPs ranging from 1 to 6 nm (Fig. 1d). Following the addition of formaldehyde solution, more Au NPs were loaded onto the DFNS sphere. SEM and HRTEM images demonstrated the uniform presence of Au NPs (Fig. 1e–g and S2†). Varying the reaction time from 30 minutes to 120 minutes showed that 30 minutes of reaction was sufficient to facilitate the growth of Au NPs on existing nuclei. Particle size distribution analysis of DPC-30 revealed slightly larger Au NPs, with sizes ranging from 2 to 16 nm and an average size of 6.7 ± 2.6 nm. Increasing the reaction time to 60 minutes maintained a similar morphology to DPC-30 (Fig. 1i–k and S3†), albeit with some observation of slightly larger Au NPs. Particle size distribution analysis of DPC-60 indicated sizes ranging from 2 to 19 nm with an average size of 7.8 ± 2.7 nm (Fig. 1l). Further extension of reaction time to 120 minutes revealed some Au NP overgrowth on the silica sphere, observed through SEM and HRTEM analysis (Fig. 1m–o and S4†). Particle size distribution of DPC-120 showed sizes ranging from 2 to 23 nm with an average size of 9.5 ± 3.5 nm (Fig. 1p). In comparison, standard black gold prepared through the cycle-by-cycle approach exhibited uniformly loaded Au NPs on the silica sphere (Fig. 1q–s and S5†), with particle sizes ranging from 2 to 18 nm and an average size of 8.3 ± 3.3 nm (Fig. 1t). Electron microscopy analysis suggested that a reaction time of 60 minutes represents the optimal condition for growing existing Au nuclei in DPC-N toward the formation of black gold. Despite similar morphologies and particle size distributions across all three stirring times, the product obtained after 60 minutes of stirring closely resembled the standard black gold sample.
The elemental composition of the materials was evaluated using SEM-EDS. The gold weight percentage loading increased from 4.4 ± 1.0% in DPC-N during the nucleation step to 42 ± 5% in the growth step. Interestingly, the gold loading remained consistent in the case of DPC-30, DPC-60, and DPC-120, suggesting that prolonged reaction times did not necessarily yield a significant increase in gold loading (Table 1). The obtained gold weight percentage closely matched the theoretical loading, which was calculated to be 43.2 wt% based on the amount of gold precursor introduced during synthesis. Additionally, the achieved gold loading closely resembled that of standard DPC-C4 (Table 1). However, it was noted that the weight percentage of additionally grown gold nanostructures outside the silica sphere in DPC-120 was predominantly composed of gold (∼84 wt% gold). This observation indicated that optimal reaction time was crucial to prevent the undesired growth of gold nanostructures outside the silica sphere.
Si (wt%) | O (wt%) | Au (wt%) | |
---|---|---|---|
DPC-N | 44 ± 0.5 | 51 ± 0.5 | 4.4 ± 1 |
DPC-30 | 25 ± 0.5 | 34 ± 0.5 | 41 ± 1 |
DPC-60 | 24 ± 3 | 33 ± 3 | 42 ± 5 |
DPC-120 | 23 ± 6 | 32 ± 5 | 47 ± 11 |
DPC-C4 | 24 ± 3 | 31 ± 4 | 45 ± 5 |
Further characterization was conducted through STEM-EDS elemental mapping to visualize the distribution of gold NPs in DPCs. The mapping revealed that the gold NPs were uniformly distributed over the silica sphere (Fig. S6†). In the case of DPC-N, due to the low counts resulting from the low concentration of gold NPs, some signals were also observed from outside the sphere in addition to the bright spots observed from the location of gold NPs (Fig. S6a†). However, in the case of DPC-30, DPC-60, and DPC-120, the gold signals originated from all over the silica sphere, indicating uniform loading of gold NPs (Fig. S6b–d†). The distribution of gold NPs closely matched that of DPC-C4 prepared using a standard cycle-by-cycle approach (Fig. S6e†). Overall, the morphological and compositional characterization indicated that the black gold or DPC formed using the new one-pot synthesis closely resembled DPC-C4 made by the cycle-by-cycle approach.
We further investigated the light absorption properties of the DPCs using UV-vis absorption spectroscopy. The DPC-N powder was brown in color and demonstrated very weak absorption in the visible region (Fig. 2a and b). This weak absorption was attributed to the lower concentration of gold NPs on the silica sphere during the nucleation step. In the case of growth samples, DPC-30 appeared dark red to purple rather than completely black. Its absorption spectrum displayed a broadband absorption with a minor hump at around 460 nm (Fig. 2a and b). This coloration could be attributed to the presence of a larger number of smaller Au NPs, which tend to absorb in the 450 nm region, resulting in the material appearing dark red to purple instead of completely black.
Fig. 2 Optical and crystallographic characterization of black gold (DPC). (a) Optical images, (b) UV-vis absorption spectra, and (c) pXRD patterns of DPC-N, DPC-30, DPC-60, DPC-120, and DPC-C4. |
Upon further increase in reaction time for DPC-60 and DPC-120, the solid powder achieved a dark black color with broadband absorption across the entire visible range (Fig. 2a and b). This phenomenon occurred because sufficient stirring time allowed for the growth of Au NPs, leading to heterogeneity in particle sizes and distances between adjacent Au NPs. This ensured optimal plasmonic coupling between the Au NPs, facilitated by the appropriate distances between them and the overlapping of multiple plasmon modes due to particle size heterogeneity, thus imparting the characteristic black color and broadband absorbance in the visible range to the black gold material (Fig. 2b).30 These findings suggested that achieving a completely black gold material necessitates adequate reaction time during the growth step to facilitate Au NP growth. Moreover, the absorption profiles of DPC-60 and DPC-120 closely resembled those of DPC-C4 synthesized using the cycle-by-cycle approach (Fig. 2b).
The pXRD patterns of the samples revealed peaks corresponding to the diffraction pattern of the gold cubic lattice and a hump at around 22° due to the amorphous DFNS support (Fig. 2c). In the case of DPC-N, characterized by small sizes and low concentration of Au nanoparticles (NPs), the diffraction peak intensities were low and the peaks were broader (Fig. 2c). Following the growth step, all samples exhibited increased peak intensities due to larger particle sizes and a higher concentration of Au NPs (Fig. 2c). Notably, the diffraction pattern closely matched that of DPC-C4 synthesized using the standard cycle-by-cycle approach (Fig. 2c).
The extensive applicability of black gold in plasmonic catalysis, particularly as a plasmonic support for anchoring active sites, is not only due to its optical properties but also due to its exceptional textural characteristics. These include high surface area and pore volume, which ensure effective dispersion of active sites, efficient adsorption–desorption of reactant molecules, and facile diffusion of reactants within the nanostructure. To evaluate these textural properties, nitrogen sorption measurements were conducted on the black gold prepared using the one-pot synthesis method. The nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherms of DFNS-APTS, utilized as a support for loading Au NPs, exhibited type-II curves with hysteresis (Fig. 3a). The Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area was determined to be 298 m2 g−1, with a Barrett–Joyner–Halenda (BJH) pore volume of 0.34 cm3 g−1 (Fig. 3a). Upon loading of Au NPs during the nucleation step, a reduction in the BET surface area to 218 m2 g−1 was observed, accompanied by a BJH pore volume of 0.33 cm3 g−1 (Fig. 3b). Notably, weak type-II hysteresis persisted throughout this phase (Fig. 3b).
During the subsequent growth steps, a further decrease in surface area and pore volume was observed in DPC-30 (169 m2 g−1 and 0.23 cm3 g−1), DPC-60 (165 m2 g−1 and 0.19 cm3 g−1), and DPC-120 (149 m2 g—1 and 0.21 cm3 g−1), accompanied by the loss of hysteresis (Fig. 3c–e). Despite increasing reaction time, surface areas and pore volumes remained relatively unchanged, indicating that additional growth of initially formed Au nanoparticles did not significantly impact these parameters. The primary reduction in surface area and pore volume occurred during the initial growth phase (Fig. 3c–e). Comparatively, black gold prepared using the standard cycle-by-cycle approach exhibited surface area (188 m2 g−1) and pore volume (0.32 cm3 g−1) within a similar range to that of DPCs formed using the one-pot synthesis after the growth step (Fig. 3f). Overall, the morphological, optical, and textural characterization corroborated the successful synthesis of black gold using the one-pot synthesis protocol, with 60 minutes as the optimum reaction time.
We investigated the photocatalytic CO oxidation capabilities of black gold (DPC-60). Plasmonic CO oxidation using O2 was carried out in a pike flow reactor with a catalyst bed thickness of approximately 1 mm, allowing light photons to penetrate each DPC-60 sphere throughout the catalyst bed (Fig. S7†). A xenon lamp (240–1100 nm) was used as the light source, and the reaction was monitored by using online microgas chromatography (GC) (Fig. S7†). The reactant gas feed consisted of CO (10% in helium), O2 (100%), and argon (Ar, 100%). Initially, we optimized the total flow of the reactant feed while maintaining an O2:CO:Ar ratio of 1:1:1 under light exposure (240–1100 nm, 1.6 W cm−2). CO2 productivity increased from 54 mmol g−1 h−1 to 454 mmol g−1 h−1 as the total flow increased from 6 mL min−1 to 300 mL min−1, though CO conversion decreased from 73% to 11% (Fig. 4a). This decrease was attributed to the reduced residence time of the reactant gases on the catalyst surface at higher gas flows. We determined that a 6 mL min−1 flow rate was optimal. At this optimum flow, we varied the ratio of the reactant gases to optimize CO conversion and CO2 productivity. While CO conversion remained nearly constant (∼71%) with varying gas ratios, CO2 productivity increased to 78 mmol g−1 h−1 with a higher CO ratio in the feed (Fig. 4b). Thus, the optimum conditions were an O2:CO:Ar ratio of 1:2:0 and total flow of 6 mL min−1.
Under these optimized conditions, we then conducted CO oxidation at different light intensities (without external heating) and in the dark (with external heating) (Fig. 4c). A thin thermocouple inserted directly into the catalyst powder bed measured the catalyst bed temperature (Fig. S8†). CO conversion increased with light intensity, increasing from 27% at 0.29 W cm−2 to 77% at 2.4 W cm−2, and further increases in light intensity led to a saturation of conversion rates at 3.3 W cm−2 (Fig. 4c). Catalyst bed temperature increased from 45.5 °C to 140 °C with an increase in light intensity from 0.29 to 4 W cm−2 (Fig. 4c and S8†). CO oxidation in the dark using external heating showed that CO conversion increased from 29% to 66% as the catalyst temperature increased from 45 °C to 141 °C (Fig. 4d).
In the case of DPC, following the decay of LSPR, the initial few femtoseconds (fs) involve the dephasing of LSPR, leading to the generation of excited electron–hole pairs via Landau damping.2,37 During this short period, these excited electron–hole pairs exhibit a non-thermal distribution and decay either through radiative processes (photon re-emission) or non-radiative processes (electron–electron interactions). Subsequently, over a timespan ranging from 100 fs to several picoseconds, the excited carriers transfer their energy to lower-energy electrons through electron–electron interactions, resulting in the formation of a quasi-Fermi–Dirac distribution for electron energy. Eventually, the electron–hole pairs relax, releasing thermal energy via electron–phonon interactions. This relaxation process occurs over a relatively extended timescale, from hundreds of picoseconds to nanoseconds.37 Plasmon decay generates sufficient local temperatures, and this local heat has a sufficient lifetime to drive the reaction. Consequently, the generation of local heat following LSPR decay and the utilization of this local heat for catalysis are feasible due to the longer lifetime of the local heat compared to the extraction of short-lived hot charge carriers. In the case of photocatalytic CO oxidation, the similarity in CO conversion under both light and dark conditions indicated that DPC-60 catalyzed CO oxidation through photothermal pathways.
Additionally, we performed photocatalytic CO oxidation using conventional DPC-C4 under optimized conditions at a total flow of 6 mL min−1 with an O2:CO:Ar ratio of 1:2:0 at a light intensity of 3.3 W cm−2. DPC-C4 achieved a CO conversion of 75%, comparable to that of DPC-60 under the same reaction conditions (Fig. S9†). This suggested that DPC-60 synthesized via the one-pot method possessed not only structural similarity but also similar chemical properties to the conventionally synthesized DPC-C4.
This dynamic behavior was further probed using in situ DRIFTS under light on–off cycles, recording spectra in the dark–light–dark–light–dark sequence (Fig. 5c and S11†). In each cycle, the 1990 cm−1 shoulder rapidly disappeared (Fig. 5c and S11†), and the relative intensities of the 2033 and 2013 cm−1 peaks changed (Fig. 5c, d and Table S1†). The faster disappearance of the bridged CO peak suggests quicker reaction kinetics for this adsorbed species due to a more polarized carbon atom, which is bound to two gold sites. The decrease in the ratio of the intensity of the 2033 peak to the 2013 peak (I2033/I2013) indicated that, under light, CO adsorbed on high-coordinated Au0 reacts faster than CO on low-coordinated Au0 (Fig. 5d and Table S1†). This phenomenon may be attributed to the presence of more thermal hotspots around highly coordinated Au0, facilitating faster reaction kinetics (Fig. 5d and Table S1†).
We also demonstrated that plasmonic black gold (DPC-60) synthesized using the one-pot protocol efficiently catalyzes CO oxidation under light. The reaction took place without external heating. It showed a CO conversion of 87% at 4.0 W cm−2 under the optimized conditions. The similarity in CO conversion under both light and dark conditions indicates that DPC-60 primarily operates via photothermal pathways. The in situ DRIFTS provided important insights into the reaction mechanism. In situ DRIFTS showed that the CO adsorbed in a bridged manner reacts faster as compared to linearly adsorbed CO on Au0 sites. Additionally, the relative peak intensities of the CO adsorbed on low and high-coordinated Au0 sites indicated the faster kinetics of the CO adsorbed on high-coordinated Au0 sites.
Overall, this one-pot synthesis approach not only optimizes the synthesis of black gold but also enhances its practical application potential, making it a valuable method for industrial-scale production and diverse catalytic applications. Additionally, the ability to rapidly produce high-quality black gold materials allows for quicker experimentation and development of new applications, ranging from environmental remediation to advanced chemical reactions.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details, Fig. S1–S11, and Table S1 are available for this paper. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ta05117c |
‡ Shared 1st authors. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |