Daniel
Hernández-Valdés
a,
Frédéric
Avignon
ab,
Peter
Müller
a,
Giuseppe
Meola
a,
Benjamin
Probst
a,
Thomas
Fox
a,
Bernhard
Spingler
a and
Roger
Alberto
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstr. 190, CH-8057 Zurich, Switzerland. E-mail: ariel@chem.uzh.ch
bDépartement de Chimie, École Normale Supérieure, PSL Research University, 75005 Paris, France
First published on 2nd April 2020
Ferrocenes are versatile ligand scaffolds, complexes of which have found numerous applications in catalysis. Structurally similar but of higher redox stabilites are sandwich complexes of the [Re(η6-arene)2]+ type. We report herein routes for conjugating potential ligands to a single or to both arenes in this scaffold. Since the arene rings can freely rotate, the [Re(η6-arene)2]+ has a high degree of structural flexibility. Polypyridyl ligands were successfully introduced. The coordination of Co(II) to such a model tetrapyridyl-Re(I)-bis-benzene complex produced a bimetallic Re(I)–Co(II) complex. To show the stability of the resulting architecture, a selected complex was subjected to photocatalytic reactions. It showed good activity in proton reduction over a long time and did not decompose, corroborating its extraordinary stability even under light irradiation. Its activity compares well with the parent catalyst in turn over numbers and frequencies. The supply of electrons limits catalytic turnover frequency at concentrations below ∼10 μM. We also show that other ligands can be introduced along these strategies. The great diversity offered by [Re(η6-arene)2]+ sandwich complexes from a synthetic point allows this concept to be extended to other catalytic processes, comparable to ferrocenes.
In contrast to its neighbouring elements, we found that [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ type complexes are remarkably stable.4,5,16 For instance, [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ does not decompose or lose benzene rings even when heated to 160 °C or when irradiated with UV light. [Re(η6-C6R6)2]+ offers structural flexibilities in three dimensions as depicted in Scheme 1. Rotation around the rhenium axis, as well as tilting of pendent functionalities is possible without a notable energy barrier. The symmetry of all signals observed in the NMR spectra (see ESI†) supports the notion of free rotation at room temperature.5–7,16,17
Scheme 1 Different degrees of freedom for the basic arrangement of [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ type complexes with two pendent coordinating modalities. |
Electrochemistry showed that Re(I) is reversibly oxidized at E°1/2 > +1.3 V (ReI/ReII). Irreversible reductions take place at low potentials <−2.0 V, both vs. Ag/AgCl.5,7 Compared to ferrocene, Re(I) bis-arene derivatives are much more difficult to oxidize and are generally stable against atmospheric oxygen (Fig. S1 and S2†).18–20 These properties make [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ inert in several chemically interesting redox processes. A representative example is the reduction of H+ to H2 or CO2 to CO, both of which require substantial, negative potentials.21–26 Protons and/or CO2 can be reduced by molecular catalysts in systems that commonly involve multiple components; photosensitizers, electron donors and proton shuttles. The [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ building block is an elegant way to combine two or more subunits in one molecule. Those subunits would be separated by a ring-ring distance of about 3 Å (Scheme 1), making communication between these two entities conjugated to the arene rings possible. This report shows that [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ is suitable for conjugating different ligands to the arenes by common synthetic arene modification strategies. To show retention of catalytic activity and non-interference of the [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ scaffold, the photocatalytic activity of a Re(I)–Co(II) heterobimetallic complex towards proton reduction is shown in detail and compared to the catalyst in its native form.
Preparative HPLC with an isocratic gradient: 5:95 CH3CN:H2O/TFA (0.1%) in 45 min, 40 mL min−1 leads to clean separation but UPLC-MS analysis evidenced that each fraction contained, besides 3a+ and 3b+, also the corresponding hydrate, supporting the high reactivity of the aldehyde groups attached to the electron poor arene rings. Obviously, there is an equilibrium established between these two species, which is more favourable for the aldehyde form.
Cyclovoltammetry (CV) of 3a+ and 3b+ was performed to study electrochemical properties (Fig. 1). Cyclovoltammograms for complexes 3a+ and 3b+ show irreversible oxidations at +1.63 V and +1.7 V (vs. Ag/AgCl), respectively. These oxidations are anodically shifted between +0.3 and +0.4 V relative to 1+. The irreversible nature of the two oxidation processes in 3a+ suggests a ligand- and a metal-based oxidation, as observed for other sandwich complexes with functionalities bound to the arene rings.5,7 In 3b+ with two electron-withdrawing groups on the arenes, the metal-based oxidation is probably beyond the solvent window and only the oxidation of the aldehydes occurs.
Meola et al. reported the mixed-ring complex [Re(η6-C6H6)(η5-C5H4COH)] which also comprises an aldehyde.17 It is interesting to compare the electrochemistry between this mixed-ring sandwich complex and 3a+, both containing an aldehyde function. For [Re(η6-C6H6)(η5-C5H4COH)], the reversible and thus metal-centred ReI/ReII oxidation takes place at +0.44 V (vs. Ag/AgCl) (Fig. 1). For 3a+ the oxidation is irreversible and the first oxidation is ligand- and not metal-centred and shifted by about 1 V.
Nucleophilic substitution of Cl− in 2a+ gave [Re(η6-C6H6)(η6-C6H5-pyrrol)](PF6) (4a+) (Scheme 3) as the main product. The same procedure was applied to pyrazole, obtaining complex 5a+ [Re(η6-C6H6)(η6-C6H5-pyz)](PF6) in a 98% yield.
Complex 5a+ carries a single sp2-N as a potential coordination site. To extend the synthetic strategy towards bi- and multidentate ligands, the reaction of 2b+ with 2-(1H-pyrazol-3-yl)pyridine (Hpyz-py) gave complex [Re(η6-C6H5-pyzpy)2](PF6) (6b+) in almost quantitative yield. Complex 6b+ has four nitrogen atoms for coordination to further metals centres. The crystal structure of 6b+ shows that the pyzpy units are coplanar (Fig. 2).
As obvious from the symmetry of the NMR signals, both rings in complex 6b+ rotate in solution, therefore, the attached ligands can coordinate either individually to two metal centres or via both pyzpy units to a single metal centre. The symmetry of all NMR spectra and therefore the free rotation around the rhenium axis is found for all [Re(arene)2]+ synthesized by our group so far.5–7,16,17,27
Pyridines are prototypical ligands in many catalytic processes, e.g. for proton reduction in photocatalysis.21,25 To extend the concept towards such polypyridyl ligands bound to the [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ scaffold, 2,2′-dipyridylamine (Hdipyam) was deprotonated with NaH in dry THF and reacted with 2a+ and 2b+ respectively. The two complexes [Re(η6-C6H6)(η6-C6H5-dipyam)](PF6) (7a+) and [Re(η6-C6H5-dipyam)2](PF6) (7b+) were obtained as PF6− salt in 74% and 23.7% yield, respectively after separation by preparative HPLC and precipitation with NH4PF6. Single X-ray crystal structures of both complexes confirm their authenticities (see Fig. 2 and ESI†).
Compounds 7a+ and 7b+ are stable but light sensitive and decompose in acetonitrile solution by ligand loss. After exposing acetonitrile solutions of complexes 7a+ and 7b+ to light, UPLC-MS evidenced a new peak with a m/z of 248.11, corresponding to the protonated form of phenyl-di-pyridylamine (see ESI†).
A chemically different synthetic route to form ligands directly on the arene rings in [Re(η6-C6H6)2]+ starts from 3a+. Aldehydes are convenient functionalities for a number of reactions, yielding e.g. terpyridine in a Kröhnke reaction in methanol at r.t.28 Applying these conditions to the organometallic aldehyde 3a+, the complex [Re(η6-C6H5-terpy)(η6-C6H6)](PF6) (8a+) formed directly in the presence of acetylpyridine (Scheme 4). Precipitation with NH4PF6 gave complex 8a+ in good yields.
Ligand systems can also be directly conjugated to 1+ after lithiation as described before. For instance, mono- and bis-lithiated 1+ undergoes nucleophilic additions to carbonyl groups (Scheme 5). Several different keto-pyridines were employed in this way as electrophiles and products containing pendent ligands on one or both rings were isolated. Along this route, the mono and bis-substituted compounds 9a+/b+, 10a+/b+ and 11a+/b+ could be obtained and were fully characterized (see ESI†).
In comparison with complexes 7a+ and 7b+, these new bis-arene based “ligands” are remarkably more stable; no decomposition was observed in the presence of light or coordinating solvents and they are all slightly water-soluble.
Scheme 6 Synthesis of complex [12a]Br. Reaction conditions: (1) 20 eq. CoBr2, 1 h, r. t., in MeOH, (2) several washes with Et2O. |
The 1H NMR spectrum in deuterated methanol showed broad signals between −10 ppm and +80 ppm, in agreement with a paramagnetic nature of the complex. A single crystal X-ray structure analysis of 12a+ as trifluoromethanesulfonate (OTf) salt confirmed the formation of the Co(II) complex [12a]OTf (Fig. 3, full characterization in the ESI†).
The crystal structure of complex [12a]OTf shows a strong Jahn–Teller distortion at the cobalt centre. The distance Co–O(H2O) and Co–O(OTf) are 2.064(6) Å and 2.279(6) Å, respectively and the angle O–Co–O is 165°. Additionally, the two bipyridyl subunits are bent in a book-shaped fashion and out of the equatorial coordination plane by around 22°. The tetrapyridyl Co(II) moiety orients in an almost perpendicular fashion to the bis-benzene subunit.
Complex [12a]Br is photostable. Irradiation of a 20 μM solution in water with LED light at 453 nm (photon flux of 0.35 ± 0.02 μE s−1) did not show any change in the UV spectrum after 8 h. After 24 h, minimal decomposition probably related to Co(II) decomplexation was observed (Fig. S20†). In addition, the UV/vis spectrum of complex [12a]Br did not change down to pH = 1.97 (Fig. S21†). Continuous additions of NaOH to a 20 μM solution lead though to irreversible changes in the UV/vis spectrum, indicating decomposition under strongly alkaline conditions (Fig. S22†).
Accordingly, photocatalytic proton reduction experiments were performed with [12a]Br in water at pH 5, 0.1 M TCEP, 0.1 M NaAsc and 0.5 mM PS at five different concentrations of catalyst (1 μM, 5 μM, 10 μM, 20 μM, 100 μM). H2 evolution was continuously monitored by in-line gas chromatography. Blank experiments in the absence of catalyst did not show significant amounts of H2 formation in comparison to experiments with catalyst. Mercury poisoning experiments excluded the formation of nanoparticles as catalytically active species (Fig. S24†).
Fig. 4 shows a typical H2 production profile as a function of time for 5 μM catalyst (for all concentrations, see Fig. S25†). The rate of H2 evolution increases rapidly with time, reaching a maximum after around 2 h (for 5 μM of catalyst). Then, the H2 formation rate decreases and catalysis ceases after 10 h. Depending on the WRC concentration, the periods of catalytic activities as well as the time needed for reaching the maximum turnover frequency (TOF) change. At higher initial concentrations of WRC, a delay until maximum TOF as well as longer catalysis time were observed, in line with previous studies by Joliat-Wick et al.29
Varying the concentrations of the WRC or the light intensity under otherwise identical condition are useful experiments to determine rate-limiting factors. As shown in Fig. 5a, the maximum TOF of H2 formation stays about constant at around 520 h−1 for concentrations <10 μM, indicating either electron transfer to or turnover of complex [12a]Br as rate limiting.
For concentrations above 10 μM, the TOFs decrease with increasing concentrations of WRC. At 20 μM and 100 μM, the maximum TOFs drop to 320 and 36 h−1 respectively. This effect is related to a limitation in the photocycle. At concentrations higher than 20 μM, the SED is almost completely consumed and for 100 μM in WRC, catalysis stops sharply after 70 h (Fig. S25b†) since no SED is available anymore. The limitation of the photocycle, i.e. the number of photons per time, can be shown by increasing the photon flux while keeping WRC concentrations constant. As obvious from Fig. 5b, TOFs increase linearly with increasing light intensity at 10 μM in WRC. A TOF of around 2500 h−1 is obtained upon irradiation of the sample with 3.5 μE s−1, corroborating the limitations by the photocycle. Increased light intensities result in shorter but faster catalyses, overall with reduced TONs since higher photon fluxes favour the decomposition of the PS−. All together, these observations support the view that the supply of electrons limits catalytic turnover frequency at concentrations below 10 μM and that the total photon flux limits it at higher concentrations. No negative interference with the [Re(η6-arene)2]+ scaffold on the catalytic activity is observed as similar performances have been obtained for catalysts purely based on cobalt polypyridyl complexes.29–31 Quantum yields were calculated from the maximum rate of H2 formation and the number of absorbed photons. Two photons are required for one H2 molecule. The quantum yields are between 1 and 10%, reaching the maximum at 20 μM in catalyst and 0.35 μE s−1 photonflux. Although catalyst 12a+ is relatively slow at low concentrations, the TONs and TOFs at higher concentrations are comparable with those of other systems with tetrapyridyl ligands.30
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 1957333–1957341. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d0dt00731e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |