Yongmin
Cho
a,
David N.
Oakland
a,
Sol Ah
Lee
a,
William R.
Schafer
b and
Hang
Lu
*a
aSchool of Chemical & Biomolecular Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, USA. E-mail: hang.lu@gatech.edu
bMedical Research Council Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Cambridge, UK
First published on 9th January 2018
Mechanosensation is fundamentally important for the abilities of an organism to experience touch, hear sounds, and maintain balance. Caenorhabditis elegans is a powerful system for studying mechanosensation as this worm is well suited for in vivo functional imaging of neurons. Many years of research using labor-intensive methods have generated a wealth of knowledge about mechanosensation in C. elegans, and the recent microfluidic-based platforms continue to push the boundary for this field. However, developmental aspects of sensory biology, including mechanosensation, are still not fully understood. One current bottleneck is the difficulty in assaying larvae because they are much smaller than adult worms. Microfluidic devices with features small enough for larvae, especially actuators for the delivery of mechanical stimulation, are difficult to design and fabricate. Here, we present a series of automatic microfluidic platforms that allow for in vivo functional imaging of C. elegans responding to controlled mechanical stimulation at different developmental stages. Using a novel fabrication method, we designed highly deformable pneumatically actuated on-chip structures that can deliver mechanical stimulation to larval worms. The PDMS actuator allows for quantitatively controlled mechanical stimulation of both gentle and harsh touch neurons, by simply changing the actuation pressure, which makes this device easily translatable to other labs. We validated the design and utility of our systems with studies of the functional role of mechanosensory neurons in developing worms; we showed that gentle and harsh touch neurons function similarly in early larvae as they do in the adult stage, which would not have been possible previously. Finally, we investigated the effect of a sleep-like state on neuronal responses by imaging C. elegans in the lethargus state.
Caenorhabditis elegans, a free-living nematode, is an excellent model organism to study mechanosensation during development. Many of the genes known to govern both mechanotransduction and development are conserved from worms to humans.8–19 Furthermore, C. elegans has a relatively short developmental period (3 days) and a stereotyped and well-categorized cell lineage. The developmental origins of all 302 neurons in an adult hermaphrodite have been traced from zygote to adult. A combination of easy genetic manipulation and the optical transparency of the worm allows for non-intrusive in vivo imaging of neuronal activity.
In addition, C. elegans exhibits sleep-like states (lethargus) at the end of each larval stage.20,21 The expected duration and placement of these states in the worm's life are well documented and generally last around 1–2 hours at the completion of and transition to a new larval stage.20 Lethargus displays fundamental similarities to mammalian sleep, such as suppressed locomotion and feeding, a specific posture, and decreased responsiveness.20–28 Moreover, changes to synaptic connectivity are known to occur during lethargus periods,29–31 suggesting that sleep is necessary for healthy nervous system development. Therefore, C. elegans may also be a good model system to study the relationship between sleep-like states and developmental changes in the nervous system.
Previous systems have demonstrated a classic approach to the delivery of mechanical stimuli to adult worms and the optical or electrophysiological recording of neuronal responses using a piezo-driven micro-stylus.16,32–36 However, these systems require animals to be immobilized with glue, limiting the experimental throughput and preventing the recovery of animals for further study.
Recently, microfluidics has been applied to not only mimic conventional assays, but also deliver mechanical stimuli with greater precision and throughput of experiments on adult worms, compared to traditional methods.37–40 For example, our system demonstrated several advantages compared to traditional methods and other microfluidic platforms for in vivo functional imaging.38 First, the platform could stimulate both gentle and harsh touch neurons with single pulse mechanical stimulation. Second, it could elicit a tuneable response from both gentle and harsh touch receptor neurons depending on the strength of the stimulus delivered. Third, our device could be operated automatically, allowing for a high-throughput drug screen for small molecules that affect mechanosensation. However, these microfluidic-based systems (including ours) only permitted the recording of neuronal activity in adult worms. This is because delivering controlled mechanical stimuli to and handling smaller worms are difficult. With elegant agarose hydrogel microcompartments,28,41 neuronal responses of ALM or AVA to tapping stimuli during early developmental stages or in sleep-like states have been observed; however, responses in these and other neurons to controlled stimuli (strength and duration), with precision of the stimulation position, are unknown.
Since the size of larval worms is smaller than that of adult ones, all of the structures in the microfluidic systems, including the actuator, should be reduced in size compared to the device for adult worms. However, the development of a highly deformable PDMS membrane structure on a smaller scale proved to be difficult. Specifically, while the width and height of the actuated PDMS membrane should be decreased to accommodate smaller larvae, the same membrane thickness as the device for adult worms (25 μm) had to be used to ensure a highly successful bonding rate and create an actuator working robustly in an realistic operating pressure range. As a result, the reduced aspect ratio of the width and height to the thickness of the actuators would require much higher pressure to achieve deformation similar to that of the adult platform. These pressures would have operated outside a practical pressure range.
Here, we present a series of microfluidic platforms that can record neuronal responses to mechanical stimuli in early larval stages. By using a hybrid device fabrication method, we have created easily deformable PDMS structure that can deliver controlled mechanical stimuli to developing worms. As before,38 we demonstrated that these platforms can greatly improve the throughput and robustness of experiments compared to conventional in vivo functional imaging methods by coupling them with an automation step. We validated the design and utility of these systems by recording neuronal activities in developing C. elegans. We show that worms in the L2 stage used the same functional mechanosensory circuits as those in the adult stage. Moreover, we show that in comparing the response to mechanical stimuli during sleep and awake periods, worms have highly reduced neuronal activity in the lethargus state.
AQ3236 ljSi2[mec-7::GCaMP6m::SL2TagRFP, unc-119] II; unc-119(ed3), TV21149 wyls587[ser-2prom3::mCherry::unc-54 3′UTR, ord-1::GFP]; wyls5007[ser-2prom3::GCaMP6, elg-17::mCherry], ZM9059 hpIs580[rig-3::GCAMP6::mCherry], RW1596 stEx30[myo-3::GFP + rol-6(su1006)], GT247 mec-4(e1611); ljSi2[mec-7::GCaMP6m::SL2TagRFP, unc-119] II; unc-119(ed3), GT253 mec-4(u253); ljSi2[mec-7::GCaMP6m::SL2TagRFP, unc-119] II; unc-119(ed3), CX11935 kyEx3252[Pstr-2:GCaMP3.0 Pofm-1:GFP].
A hatch-off procedure was used to synchronize larvae.43 Briefly, adult hermaphrodites laid eggs overnight at 20 °C on NGM plates. Hatched larvae and adults were removed from the plates with three successive washes with M9 buffer. The embryos remaining on the plates were incubated at 20 °C for only 1 hour. Highly synchronized L1 larvae that hatched in the 1 hour window were washed off and transferred to new NGM plates.
To create the easily actuated PDMS structure to stimulate and trap worms, a 30:1 ratio of the PDMS monomer and a curing agent (Sylgard 184, Dow Corning) was deposited via spin coating to create a thin layer for the bottom feature layer (speed: 1000 rpm, ramp: 5 s, and spin time: 30 s). Separately, a 10:1 PDMS mixture was directly poured onto a blank master, which does not have any features, to create a thick and mechanically rigid handle layer. Both PDMS layers were then placed into an 80 °C oven for 25–30 minutes until they were rigid but sticky. After they were manually aligned, an additional 10:1 PDMS mixture was poured on top of the layers to fill the gap between the aligned layers and the Petri dish, and then the Petri dish was placed into an 80 °C oven overnight.
After curing, PDMS devices were cut to size, and featured PDMS chunks were created via puncturing the cured PDMS with sharpened gauge needles (18 gauge for worm in- and outlet and 19 gauge for all valves). The prepared devices were then cleaned with scotch tape and exposed to air plasma for 15 seconds before being placed and covalently bonded to a glass surface to create closed channels. Right after this bonding procedure, the devices were placed on top of a 150 °C hot plate for 3 min to increase the adhesion between PDMS and the cover glass.
Fig. 1 A key engineering challenge is the scaling-down of the device for adult worms38 to match the size of the imaging channel to the size of developing worms. (A) Schematic diagrams of the PDMS actuator for the delivery of mechanical stimulation for adult (left) and L2 stage worms (right). All scales of the device for adult worms have to be scaled down except the thickness of the PDMS membrane (25 μm) for L2 stage imaging to minimize the worm movement and deliver localized mechanical stimulation. (B) Example images of worms in the device made by using a standard ratio of the PDMS mixture (10:1). 10 psi (left) and 50 psi (right) are applied by using anterior touch valves (red arrows). Worms were cultured 20 hours after hatching. Scale bar: 25 μm. |
Moreover, C. elegans has two different receptive fields of mechanosensory neurons: the anterior and posterior regions of the body.47 As before,38 our platform was designed to deliver precise, localized “touches” in order to stimulate distinct neurons. For the delivery of localized stimulation to small larvae (the length of L2 animals is ∼360–380 μm), the width of the actuated PDMS membrane that comes into contact with the worm is reduced to 50 μm from 150 μm for adult worms (the length of adults is ∼1110–1150 μm).48 Using the larger 150 μm width actuator for L2 worms would result in both the anterior and posterior touch circuits being activated.
Even though all the dimensions of the structure have been reduced, the thickness of the PDMS membrane (25 μm) had to be kept the same as that in the device for adult worms to ensure a high success rate in bonding and create an actuator working in a realistic operating pressure range. If we decrease the membrane thickness, the area available for bonding to the cover glass is reduced, resulting in the devices rupturing when we apply pressure to actuate the structures. Retaining the same membrane thickness, however, dramatically reduces the aspect ratio of the width and height to the thickness of the actuators (Fig. 1A). This would lead to an increase in the pressure needed to deform the membranes, quickly reaching an impractical point. As shown in Fig. 1B, even at 50 psi, the membrane deformation is negligible and not sufficient to activate any of the mechanoreceptor neurons in C. elegans larvae (data not shown).
One possible approach to overcome this problem of PDMS membrane deformability is to decrease its elastic modulus (by reducing the amount of cross-linker in the PDMS mixture, for example). We tested this idea using computational modeling (COMSOL Multiphysics, see Materials and methods) to simulate the deformability of the membrane designed to fit the size of L2 stage worms at various applied pressures (Fig. 2). The simulation suggested that a higher ratio of PDMS to cross-linker (30:1) leads to sufficient deformability of the PDMS structure for L2 stage worms. In comparison, the membrane made with the standard ratio of PDMS to cross-linker (10:1) is not deformed even at high pressures (>50 psi) (Fig. 2B).
Decreasing the elastic modulus of the PDMS results in additional design challenges for our platforms. One potential source of challenges is that the use of a higher ratio of the PDMS mixture for the entire device would affect its handling and operability. To address this issue, we developed a hybrid fabrication method that simultaneously creates a more deformable membrane structure while maintaining the necessary mechanical rigidity of the overall device structure (Fig. 3A). Specifically, the high-ratio PDMS mixture (30:1) is spin coated onto the featured master wafer for a uniform and consistent thickness of the layer. Generating a uniform thickness is critical for reproducing devices with the same pressure-to-deformation ratio. Separately, the standard 10:1 PDMS polymer mixture is poured onto a blank wafer in order to make the entire device thick and mechanically rigid for the connection with tubing via metal pins. Both layers are partially cured for ∼30 minutes at 80 °C, which renders the PDMS solid enough for alignment of the two layers. Using two solid layers in this process is important, as the cross-linker would permeate from the top to the bottom layer in the liquid form, which would reduce the ratio of PDMS to cross-linker and increase the rigidity of the PDMS membrane.
Fig. 3 Schematic of the new device fabrication method and results of membrane displacement measurements. (A) Schematic of the new fabrication method. (B) Example images of worms in the device made by using a high ratio of the PDMS mixture (30:1). 10 psi (left), 30 psi (middle), and 50 psi (right) are applied by using anterior touch valves (red arrows). Worms were cultured 20 hours after hatching. Scale bar: 25 μm. (C) Displacement of the actuated membrane by applying pressures. Experimental (blue) and simulation results (gray, the same as red in Fig. 2B). The R-square value is 0.9892. (D) Sample frames from an activated ALM neuron show changes in fluorescence due to mechanical stimuli (scale bar: 5 μm, used 100× magnification). |
To examine the reproducibility and robustness of the membrane deformation, we measured its displacement using different applied pressures and took images from transgenic worms that express GFP along the body-wall muscle in our device for L2 stage worms (Fig. 3B and C). We observe no obvious deformation of the worms' body wall when using a low applied pressure of 10 psi to the anterior touch valve (left panel of Fig. 3B). However, as we increase the pressure, we observe a corresponding increase in the deformation of the body wall in that specific region (middle and right panels of Fig. 3B). Experimental measurements over a large range of pressures show that the deformation in the body wall is linear to the actuation pressure (Fig. 3C). Remarkably, this trend agrees with the predictions of our computational modeling, where the only changeable variable was the elastic modulus of the PDMS (Fig. 3C). This linear relationship makes the strength of mechanical stimulation easy to control via applied pressure. Moreover, the error in the measurement of membrane displacement is small, which indicates that the mechanical stimulation delivered by our platforms is highly reproducible. In addition to the direct measurement of the tissue deformation, we also measured the activation of mechanoreceptor neurons labeled with a calcium indicator. Upon well-controlled deformation of the PDMS membrane, the gentle touch neuron ALM is activated in an L2 worm (Fig. 3D). Not surprisingly, the chemosensory neuron, AWC, does not show response to typical mechanical stimuli in our system (Fig. S1†).
To enhance the viability and robustness of mechanostimulation on C. elegans larvae, we proceeded to automate the operation of the platform as with the device for adult worms.38 This greatly improves the experimental throughput, while minimizing the variability introduced by human handling/manipulation. Specifically, all actuated valves were connected to a pressure source via individually controlled off-chip solenoid valves. This allows for automated and rapid operation with a custom MATLAB script:38 the automated worm loading/unloading procedure takes only a few seconds and experiment duration ranges from several seconds to a few minutes depending on the assay. Therefore, experimental throughput is only limited by the length of the assay. Since our synchronization protocol typically yields several hundred worms (see Materials and methods), up to ∼100 worms per hour can be assayed in this new platform.
Another important advantage of our device is that worms' neurons can be easily imaged and tracked, as the animals have limited movement in the channel. Both the width and height of the imaging channel and trapping valves minimize the movement of worms, allowing high-quality calcium imaging without using other immobilization techniques that may affect neuronal responses. Because we want to image worms at different developmental stages of their lives, we designed devices ranging from 10 μm to 25 μm in width. A series of devices were optimized for worms at each developmental stage20 to minimize the worm's movement within the channel. Table 1 summarises the ideal post-hatching developmental time in hours for each of our device sizes. Thus, by using a set of our devices, we can monitor the activity of neurons in mechanosensory circuits from early larvae to adult worms.
Time after hatching (h) | 18–24 h (20 °C) | 28–34 h (20 °C) | 38–42 h (20 °C) | 46–50 h (20 °C) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Channel width | 10 μm | 15 μm | 20 μm | 25 μm |
To demonstrate the utility of the system, we conducted in vivo functional imaging experiments. First, we asked how the functional role of touch receptor neurons changed during development. Studies reported previously using conventional methods, due to technical challenges, have not directly demonstrated neuronal activation in larvae in response to mechanical stimuli. In a previous study, we observed that both gentle and harsh touch receptor neurons in adult worms clearly distinguished the difference in magnitudes of an applied mechanical stimulation.38 We asked whether these neurons are functionally developed as early as the L2 stage, and whether they exhibit graded responses as in the adult stage.
We used our system to measure the responses of both gentle (AVM, ALML/R, PVM, and PLML/R) and harsh touch (PVD) receptor neurons at different extents of deformation or different stimulation durations. The critical parameter in mechanosensory stimulation is displacement, not force.33 Our design has the advantage of simplicity in operation to deliver both gentle and harsh touches, because the deflection of the PDMS actuator is directly proportional to the applied pressure. We show for the first time that ALM neurons of L2 animals (18–22 hours after hatching) can respond to anterior stimuli at varying levels of pressure and duration (Fig. 4A and S2 and Movie S1†). The strong mechanical stimulus (25 psi) can elicit higher calcium transient peaks in ALM neurons compared to the weak stimulus (15 psi). (Fig. 4A and C and S2†).
Similarly, we delivered posterior stimuli of varying pressure and duration and observed the response in PVD neurons in L2 larvae (Fig. 4B and S2 and Movie S2†). As in the adult animals,38 PVD required stronger mechanical stimulation to be activated than gentle touch neurons. PVD had a negligible response to stimuli in the gentle touch regime (lower than 25 psi, data not shown). On the other hand, in the harsh touch regime, either a longer duration of stimuli (1 s) at low pressure (35 psi) or a shorter duration of stimuli at high pressure (45 psi) can elicit PVD neuronal response (Fig. 4B and C and S2†). Interestingly, it is known that PVD does not grow its multidendritic processes until L3 and L4; in the L2 stage, PVD has only a simple longitudinal primary dendrite.49 Our data suggest that these anatomical specializations are not required for harsh touch sensation. Beyond L2, both gentle and harsh touch neurons continue to respond to controlled mechanical stimuli (Fig. S3 and S4†).
Another gentle touch neuron of interest is AVM. Previously, based on behavioural assay in combination with laser microsurgery, AVM's function was detectable at 35–40 hours after hatching (e.g. late L3) and was assumed to be not functionally developed in L2.50 We tested AVM activities directly via functional imaging and found that AVM can indeed respond to mechanical stimulation in L2, in both gentle and harsh touch regimes (Fig. 4D and E and Movie S3†). This suggests that AVM itself is sensitive to mechanical stimulation in L2, but might not be functionally wired into the escape circuit yet. We also measured the response of the AVM neuron in mutants with specific defects in gentle touch. The mec-4 gene encodes a DEG/ENaC channel; u253 is a null allele that only affects gentle touch sensation while e1611 is a dominant allele that causes necrotic neurodegeneration in older worms.32,50 Although insensitive to stimulation in the gentle touch regime (anterior touch with 1 s and 15 psi), the mec-4 mutants were responsive to stimulation in the harsh touch regime (anterior touch with 1 s and 35 psi) (Fig. 4D–F), consistent with previous reports in adult worms.32,38 The observation that the mec-4 mutants show defects may indicate that the MEC-4 protein is essential for touch neuron activity in response to gentle touch in the L2 stage of the worm. Thus, the data suggest that the functional role of mechanosensory neurons is already developed by the L2 stage and similar to that in the adult stage.
We next asked how the neuronal response to mechanical stimuli is modulated based on physiological states in developing worms. C. elegans normally passes through four larval stages, L1 to L4, to reach adulthood. At the end of each developmental stage, the worm enters the lethargus state.20,21,24 However, due to the limitation of techniques, most of the in vivo imaging in lethargus has thus far been done with larger L4 stage animals.23,24,27 Although Schwarz et al. observed reduced ALM responses to tapping stimuli in the sleep-like state,28 it is still unknown whether other neurons such as touch neuron AVM and interneuron AVA in mechanosensory circuits remain responsive during lethargus in early larvae. To investigate the behavior of these circuits, we measured the response of two sensory neurons, ALM and AVM, and the interneuron AVA to mechanical stimuli in awake L2 animals (18–22 hours after hatching) versus lethargic L2 animals (24–25 hours after hatching) (Fig. 5A). In order to reduce stochastic effects on the neuronal response, we applied a strong mechanical stimulus (50 psi) to the anterior region and recorded the calcium transients (Fig. 5B–E). As seen in Fig. 5, even at this extremely strong stimulation, lethargic worms elicit almost no response. In contrast, the activities of neurons are clear in the awake worms and show a large response. Interestingly, the effect of L4 lethargus (about 50% reduction in touch responses compared to L4 or adult)27 was much less dramatic than the effect of L2 lethargus on touch-evoked ALM responses. The reduced neuronal responses are seen in both gentle touch neurons, ALM and AVM, along with the interneuron, AVA (Fig. 5B–E). While this phenomenon has been observed before at the behavioral level,20 our data further demonstrate that mechanosensory neurons display reduced sensitivity to stimuli in the lethargus state. Therefore, this demonstrates that our device can be used to study the sleep states of C. elegans, which is difficult to do using conventional methods.
Together, these experiments demonstrate that we can activate distinct types of mechanosensory neurons by simply changing the magnitude of applied pressure in our system. This technical development allowed us to make novel observations into early development and functional analysis of the mechanosensory neurons.
With access to highly improved throughput and more standardisable assays in our platforms, compared to conventional methods, it is now possible to develop high-throughput assays that screen genes or drugs for their effects on neuronal activity of mechanosensory circuits during the developmental period of C. elegans. We envision that this system will allow the study of both the fundamental biology of mechanosensation and the role of development in the formation of mechanosensory circuits. Finally, we expect that our platform greatly accelerates the discovery of drugs that target diseases linked to impaired mechanosensation, such as deafness.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c7lc01201b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |