Yan
Yang
a,
Mathew D.
Anker
b,
Jian
Fang
*a,
Mary F.
Mahon
b,
Laurent
Maron
c,
Catherine
Weetman
b and
Michael S.
Hill
*b
aKey Laboratory of Nonferrous Metal Chemistry and Resources Utilization of Gansu Province, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, PR China. E-mail: fangj@lzu.edu.cn
bDepartment of Chemistry, University of Bath, Bath BA2 7AY, UK. E-mail: msh27@bath.ac.uK
cLPCNO, Université de Toulouse, INSA Toulouse 135, Avenue de Rangueil, 31077 Toulouse cedex, France
First published on 1st March 2017
Organic isocyanates are readily converted to methyl amine products through their hydroboration with HBpin in the presence of a β-diketiminato magnesium catalyst. Although borylated amide and N-,O-bis(boryl)hemiaminal species have been identified as intermediates during the reductive catalysis, the overall reduction and C–O activation is metal-mediated and proposed to occur through the further intermediacy of well-defined magnesium formamidato, formamidatoborate and magnesium boryloxide derivatives. Examples of all these species have been identified and fully characterised through stoichiometric reactivity studies and the stability of the borate species leads us to suggest that, under catalytic conditions, the onward progress of the deoxygenation reaction is crucially dependent on the further activation provided by the Lewis acidic HBpin substrate. These deductions have been explored and ratified through a DFT study.
Hydrodeoxygenation of carbonyl-containing compounds (e.g. aldehydes, ketones, amides) has attracted increasing attention given its potential applications in biofuels and fine chemical syntheses.8 Although a number of stoichiometric protocols for the deoxygenation of ketones are known,9–11 these methods typically require harsh reaction conditions. In a catalytic context, Stephan has very recently reported a mild protocol for the deoxygenation of ketones in the presence of silanes in conjunction with a highly electrophilic phosphonium cation.12 Similarly, the reduction of primary, secondary and tertiary amides to amines with silane hydride sources may be achieved under either transition metal-catalysed13 or ‘metal-free’ conditions through the use of catalytic amounts of electrophilic boranes.14 Of greater relevance to the current work are a number of Mg-based processes that have also been described. In an initial report, we observed that compound 1 was able to effect ester cleavage during the hydroboration of 3-methylnicotinate with pinacolborane (HBpin).15 This reactivity was subsequently extended by Sadow and co-workers to a variety of ester hydroboration and amide reduction reactions mediated by a magnesium tris(oxazolinyl)phenylborate catalyst.16 Importantly, mechanistic analysis of these latter reactions implicated the intermediacy of zwitterionic alkoxyborate intermediates rather than a conventional σ-bond metathesis pathway. In related work, we have shown that carbon dioxide may be subjected to the complete and selective rupture of a CO bond and the formation of the methanol-equivalent H3COBpin through the use of a modified catalyst system derived from 1 and a B(C6F5)3 co-catalyst.17 With this reactivity in mind, we speculated that analogous hydrodeoxygenation could be applied to the isoelectronic isocyanate function (eqn (1)) to provide a more amenable system from which to develop a detailed understanding of the molecular basis for such Mg-centred CO activation. Although a Schwartz reagent-mediated reduction of isocyanates has been described as a straightforward and direct route to otherwise inaccessible formamides and the in situ hydroboration of t-BuNCO with HBpin catalysed by [Mg(THF)6][HBPh3] has been very recently reported to provide the bis-borylated hemiaminal, t-BuN(Bpin)CH2OBpin,18,19 the successful development of the reactivity shown in eqn (1) would also enable a viable and, to the best of our knowledge, unprecedented catalytic route to methyl amines.
(1) |
Extension of this reactivity to other commercially available alkyl isocyanates provided similar reactivity to i-PrNCO. Entries 1 to 6 in Table 1 present the outcome of these reactions performed with a range of alkyl isocyanates of varying steric bulk. All the reactions were characterised by the appearance of a singlet methyl 1H NMR resonance in the range δ 2.5–3.0 ppm and a single new N-B resonance at ca. δ 27 ppm, which appeared along with the signal associated with the O(Bpin)2 by-product in the 11B NMR spectra. Contrary to expectation, increased RNCO substituent steric demands provided generally faster reaction times; R = i-Pr (entry 1) and t-Bu (entry 5) evidenced complete consumption of the isocyanate in less than 4 hours compared to Et (entry 3) and n-Pr (entry 4) both of which required 21 hours. The increased reactivity associated with enhanced alkyl substituent steric demands also coincided with the onset of secondary side reactions. Although attempts to identify the products of these side reactions were unsuccessful it is likely that oligomerisation of the isocyanates is competitive with the reductive CO cleavage.21 Notably, further reactions performed with N-phenyl and N-mesityl (Mes) isocyanate substitution provided ca. 90% conversion in 24 hours (entries 7 and 8), while an increase of the N-aryl substituent's steric demands to 2,6-di-isopropylphenyl (Dipp) resulted in a significantly reduced conversion during the same time period (entry 9).
Addition of one equivalent of HBpin to a solution of compound 2 in d8-toluene resulted in the formation of a single species, compound 3, which was characterised by the appearance of a new resonance at δ 4.3 ppm in the 11B NMR spectrum. A subsequent single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis confirmed compound 3 to be a borate species formed by the formal insertion of HBpin into the Mg–N bond of the magnesium amidate. The boron-bound hydride (H1) was readily located and freely refined, clearly demonstrating that there was no significant Mg–H interaction in the solid state. The structure of compound 3 is reminiscent of a previously described borate species resulting from addition of HBpin to a magnesium formamidinate supported by the same β-diketiminate ligand.3c
Attempts to induce the extrusion of the N-borylated formamidine, DippN(Bpin)HC(O) (compound 7, vide infra), by prolonged (>24 hours) heating of samples of compound 3 in d8-toluene either at 60 °C or 80 °C failed to provide any evidence of onward reactivity. Similar treatment of 3 at the higher temperature of 100 °C for 16 hours, however, resulted in the production of a single new β-diketiminato species (4) along with the methylene imine, DippNCH2, which was tentatively identified through the appearance of an AB spin system in the 1H NMR spectrum with signals at δ 6.90 and 7.25 ppm. The identity of compound 4 was confirmed through the isolation of single crystals suitable for an X-ray diffraction experiment. The results of this analysis revealed that 4 was a dimeric magnesium boryloxide species (Fig. 3) arising from the cleavage of the C–O bond of the amidato moiety of compound 3.
While the formation of compound 4 implicates the direct extrusion of DippNCH2 as the mode of C–O activation, the elevated temperature required for this reaction militates against its operation during the catalytic reactions summarised in Table 1. A further reaction between compound 3 and a single equivalent of HBpin was, thus, undertaken. Although no consumption of 3 took place at room temperature, heating of this d8-toluene solution at 60 °C for 8 hours resulted in the predominant formation of DippN(Me)Bpin along with a variety of β-diketiminato magnesium species which could not be identified with any meaningful level of confidence. In an attempt to shed further light on this reactivity, compound 1 was reacted with 3 molar equivalents of HBpin and 2 equivalents of DippNCO. This reaction at room temperature surprisingly resulted in the generation of the amidate derivative (2) along with the concomitant production of a single new compound (5). This latter species was identified as the bis-borylated hemiaminal, Dipp(pinB)NCH2OBpin, through the appearance of a distinctive methylene singlet resonance at δ 5.35 ppm in the 1H NMR spectrum and two broad signals of equal intensity at δ 28.3 and 24.8 ppm in the corresponding 11B NMR experiment. Furthermore, continued treatment of this reaction mixture with additional equivalents of HBpin and DippNCO in a 2:1 ratio provided for the catalytic production of compound 5.
Subsequent investigation revealed that this catalytic reactivity could be straightforwardly replicated through the reactions of either DippNCO or MesNCO with two molar equivalents of HBpin performed in the presence of 10 mol% 1 to provide compound 5 and the analogous N-mesityl species (6) within 10 minutes at room temperature (Table 2, entries 1 and 2). Repetition of the latter reaction with half the catalyst loading (5 mol%) also provided efficient turnover at room temperature with similar full conversion being observed after 15 minutes (Table 2, entry 3). Subsequent preparative scale reactions provided single crystals of compounds 5 and 6 suitable for X-ray diffraction analysis which confirmed the formation of the bis-borylated hemiaminal species (Fig. 4).
Attempted extension of this bis-borylation protocol to PhNCO and the range of N-aliphatic isocyanates shown in Table 1 was unsuccessful with no evidence of any reactivity observed at room temperature beyond the initial activation of the pre-catalyst. Although subsequent heating of these reactions at 60 °C induced consumption of the borane reagent, this procedure also resulted in C–O cleavage and ca. 50% conversion of the isocyanate to the N-methylated amine product and the bis(boryl)oxide, O(Bpin)2, by-product.
To provide further insight into the role of such hemiaminal species as potential intermediates during the course of the C–O activation catalysis, a reaction was carried out between compound 6 and Jones' β-diketiminato magnesium hydride complex, [CH{C(Me)NDipp}2MgH]2.22 Monitoring of this reaction by 1H NMR spectroscopy demonstrated that heating to 60 °C resulted in the generation of the N-borylated methyl amine, pinBN(Me)Mes, along with the magnesium boryloxide (4) (eqn (2)). A further reaction performed by addition of compound 6 to a d8-toluene solution of the pre-catalyst (1) and HBpin provided a similar result. Subsequent addition of HBpin to either of these reaction mixtures or to a solution of an isolated sample of compound 4 in d8-THF resulted in the consumption of the magnesium boryloxide with concomitant production of (pinB)2O and the regeneration of [CH{C(Me)NDipp}2MgH]2 (eqn (3)). Although these routes to compound 4 and its reactivity with HBpin suggest that the C–O cleavage reaction is primarily magnesium mediated, it is notable that heating of a solution of compound 6 at 60 °C for 12 hours in the absence of any other reagents also resulted in the consumption of ca. 50% of the hemiaminal and production of (pinB)2O and the methylene imine, MesNCH2.
An additional intermediate was identified during our investigation of the catalytic production of compound 5. Although a 1H NMR spectrum recorded five minutes after the initiation of the catalytic reduction of DippNCO with two equivalents of HBpin catalysed by 1 demonstrated the facile production of compound 5, the formation of this species was accompanied by a new compound (7) characterised by the appearance of a high frequency singlet resonance at δ 9.04 ppm in the 1H NMR spectrum. Compound 7 was assigned as the N-borylated formamidine, DippN(Bpin)HC(O), which was completely consumed upon completion of the reaction. Several attempts to generate compound 7 by the reaction of a single equivalent of HBpin and DippNCO in the presence of 10 mol% 1 resulted in the consumption of only 50% of the isocyanate starting material and the production of compound 5. A similar reaction performed at lower catalyst loading (0.1 mol%) and in the minimum amount of toluene solvent, however, resulted in the formation of a significant quantity of crystalline material. Mechanical separation of single crystals formed within this material enabled a series of single crystal X-ray diffraction analyses which showed it to be primarily a mixture of compound 5 and compound 7. The results of the analysis of compound 7 are shown in Fig. 5, which demonstrates the O(1)–C(1) bond distance [1.206(4) Å] and O(1)–C(1)–N(1) angle [24.9(2)°] to be consistent with the formation of the formamide function.
The significance of these observations with respect to the catalytic reactivity was assessed by in situ monitoring (1H NMR spectroscopy) of a reaction of HBpin and i-PrNCO catalysed by 10 mol% 1 at 60 °C. Fig. 6 illustrates the evolution of this reaction over 105 minutes and highlights a complex profile en route to the ultimate methyl amine product (inset spectrum, Fig. 6). In the earliest stages of the reaction a new compound was characterised by the appearance of a high frequency singlet resonance at δ 8.90 ppm (indicated by the identifier in Fig. 6). This species, which we assign as an N-borylated formamidine, i-PrN(Bpin)HC(O), analogous to compound 7, was observed to accumulate during the initial 15 minutes of the reaction prior to any observable methyl amine formation (). After this time, however, it was consumed simultaneously with the appearance of significant quantities of a bis-borylated hemiaminal derivative, i-Pr(pinB)NCH2OBpin, analogous to compounds 5 and 6, which was apparent as a persistent singlet resonance at δ 5.08 ppm (). A further low field singlet was observed at δ 7.80 ppm (). Once evolved, this latter resonance persisted at an effectively constant intensity throughout the course of the catalysis. This chemical shift is reminiscent of the signal associated with the amidato methine proton observed for compound 3 (δ 7.69 ppm) and leads us to postulate that a borate species with a comparable constitution is also formed in a steady state concentration as a key intermediate during the reduction of i-PrNCO. The initial appearance of this species was accompanied by the emergence of a clear AB spin system (), which may be cautiously assigned to the methylene imine, i-PrNCH2. This small molecule is evidently consumed, however, at more mature phases of the catalysis.
Evidence for a sequential mechanism was provided by examination of the temporal evolution of the signals assigned to i-PrN(Bpin)HC(O) (), i-Pr(pinB)NCH2OBpin () and i-PrN(Bpin)Me () during the reduction of i-PrNCO. Fig. 7 illustrates that the observed intermediate products accumulate during the course of the reactions in quantities greater than that of the catalyst loading, suggesting that the formamidine and hemiaminal species are released but can re-insert into the catalytic cycle to undergo further reduction. Notably, the accumulation of the ultimate methyl amine product describes a sigmoidal curve reminiscent that observed during N-borylated amidine production in our recent report of carbodiimide hydroboration catalysed by 1.3c Similar sigmoidal profiles are also typical of enzyme kinetics and generally associated with the positive cooperative binding of substrate molecules, which is implied by the thermal stability of compound 3 in the absence of further HBpin.
Fig. 7 Plot of [product] versus time for the hydroboration of i-PrNCO catalysed by 10 mol% 1 at 60 °C. ( = i-PrN(Bpin)HC(O), = i-PrN(Bpin)CH2OBpin; = i-PrN(Bpin)CH3). |
Although these observations attest to a complex mechanistic landscape, we postulate that the gross features of this reactivity may be rationalised by the generic mechanism for the reduction of RNCO illustrated in Scheme 3. No attempt is made to delineate potentially dimeric or monomeric intermediates. In common with our previous mechanistic studies of a variety of reactions catalysed by β-diketiminato magnesium centres, however, we suggest that a necessity for dimer to monomer pre-equilibration is likely to exert a crucial influence on the kinetics of the individual reactions.6 Although we also suggest that the persistence of any magnesium hydride is doubtful under catalytic conditions, catalysis is initiated through borane activation of the pre-catalyst (1, not shown) to provide the transient magnesium hydride (or borohydride) necessary to generate formamidate and borate intermediates analogous to compounds 2 and 3. The apparent stability of this latter compound mitigated against its direct thermal conversion to boron-containing small molecules at temperatures relevant to the catalysis. We, thus, suggest that the most kinetically accessible cycle necessitates breakdown of a similar borate species to produce RN(Bpin)HC(O).
We postulate that this process occurs by the necessary activation of the borate intermediate through its interaction with a further equivalent of Lewis acidic HBpin prior to intramolecular boron to magnesium hydride transfer. This process is, thus, reminiscent of our recent reports on related magnesium borate species identified during the hydroboration of organic carbodiimides and nitriles.3c,6b Although viable concentrations of the N-borylated formamidine were observed to accumulate during the early stages of the catalytic reduction of i-PrNCO, this species is apparently consumed through its onward reaction with magnesium hydride. We have not identified any resultant magnesium hemiaminalate species but suggest that compounds of this type will be rapidly consumed through further B–H/Mg–O metathesis to yield R(pinB)NCH2OBpin. The ultimate production of RN(Bpin)Me and closure of the catalytic cycle are then predicated upon a sequence of C–O/Mg–H and Mg–O/B–H metathesis steps reminiscent of the stoichiometric reactivity summarised for the isolable species 6 and 4 in eqn (2) and (3).
Although our observations suggest that this reaction sequence predominates under the mild conditions applied during catalysis, the mechanism must also reconcile the production and consumption of RNCH2. It is notable that appreciable quantities of i-PrNCH2 were only observed after the generation of significant amounts of i-Pr(pinB)NCH2OBpin during the reduction of i-PrNCO. We infer, therefore, that this small molecule is generated by the direct decomposition of i-Pr(pinB)NCH2OBpin rather than any higher energy magnesium-centered process and implicates a second plausible pathway for the production of i-PrN(Bpin)CH3.
Fig. 8 Calculated reaction pathway for the magnesium-catalysed hydrodeoxygenation of organic isocyanates. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures and full characterisation data of compounds 2–7, along with the catalytic protocols and NMR spectra. CCDC 1504016–1504019 contain the supplementary crystallographic data for compounds 2, 3, 4 and 6, respectively, while the data for compound 5 and 7 have respective codes of CCDC 1526366–1526367. Computed Cartesian coordinates of all of the molecules reported in this study. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c7sc00117g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |