C bond enables difluorideboron β-diketonate derivatives with high contrast mechanoresponsive luminescence for reversible writing and information encryption†
Yan
Xia
a,
Geng
Li
a,
Xiangkai
Yin
a,
Jie
Li
*a,
Juemin
Zhao
a,
Kunpeng
Guo
*a,
Yaxing
Tang
a and
Hua
Wang
*ab
aMinistry of Education Key Laboratory of Interface Science and Engineering in Advanced Materials, College of Materials Science and Engineering Taiyuan University of Technology Taiyuan, 030024, China. E-mail: lijie01@tyut.edu.cn; guokunpeng@tyut.edu.cn; wanghua001@tyut.edu.cn
bCollege of Textile Engineering Taiyuan University of Technology Jin Zhong, 030600, China
First published on 6th December 2024
Promoting the contrast of mechanoresponsive luminescent materials is of great significance in the application of information storage and encryption. In this work, two D–π–A difluorideboron β-diketonate derivatives were developed by varying the structure of the π-bridge. By incorporating a C
C bond into the phenyl π-bridge of BF2-PhCz, BF2-PVCz with a phenyl vinyl π-unit achieved bathochromic fluorescence with a higher quantum yield and a higher contrast of mechanoresponsive luminescence (MRL). Theoretical calculations and experimental characterization revealed the C
C bond contributed to the enhanced oscillator strength of the molecule and head-to-head molecular packing in the crystal. The applications of reversible writing and information deep-encryption were then realized based on the high-contrast and reversible MRL behavior of BF2-PVCz.
On the other hand, enhancing the reversibility and contrast of MRL materials has been a key prerequisite for applications in information storage and encryption.11–18 The strategies for developing high-contrast MRL materials typically involve reducing the types of noncovalent interactions through heterocyclic effects,19 utilizing solvents to adjust the packing arrangement,20 increasing steric hindrance to produce loose arrangement, etc.21–24 Among the different types of molecules identified for their bright fluorescence properties, the difluoroboron β-diketonate derivatives are well-known for their mechanofluorochromic behavior.25–28 For example, tetraphenylene based difluorideboron β-diketonate derivatives showed MRL properties from yellow to orange emission.29 Acylamino substituted difluorideboron β-diketone derivatives exhibited green to yellow emission through crystalline-to-amorphous transformation.25 Azepane-substituted β-diketone difluorideboron complexes realized multi-stimuli responsive fluorescence switching.28,30 Nevertheless, some of them still suffer from low contrast, poor reversibility or low fluorescence quantum yields. Moreover, red emitting candidates with high solid-emission efficiency and contrast remained challenging due to the balance between the rigid packing structure (for high quantum yields) and adjustable intermolecular interactions (for high-contrast MRL).
To achieve highly emissive red mechanoresponsive luminescent (MRL) materials with satisfactory contrast, in this work, two D–π–A molecules, BF2-PhCz and BF2-PVCz, were developed with carbazole (Cz) and difluoroboron β-diketonate (BF2bdk) as the electron donor and acceptor, respectively. Phenyl (Ph) and phenyl vinyl (PV) groups were chosen as the π-bridges, respectively, to regulate the band gap, emission efficiency and solid-state luminescence behaviors. In comparison with the phenyl π-bridge in BF2-PhCz, the phenyl vinyl group with more extended π-conjugation in BF2-PVCz significantly reduced the band gap and enhanced the luminescence efficiency by increasing the oscillator strength. Moreover, in the crystals of BF2-PVCz, the molecules formed “head-to-head” arrangement, which inhibited dipole–dipole interactions and resulted in crystallization-induced blue-shift in emission. Upon grinding, BF2-PVCz crystals achieved significantly improved MRL contrast (Δλ = 54 nm) by crystalline-to-amorphous transition accompanied by trans-to-cis isomerization of the C
C bond. Moreover, the reversibility of the MRL process enabled successful applications in reversible writing and information deep-encryption.
Both compounds possessed moderate distorted conformation, and the dihedral angles of carbazole and phenyl groups were 48.9° and 50.0° for BF2-PhCz (Fig. 1a) and BF2-PVCz (Fig. 1b), respectively. Comparing with organic luminophores with planar structures, these molecules with moderately twisted geometries may be better candidates to form various packing patterns in the aggregation state, which may promote MRL with phase transition.31 The molecules showed negative and relatively positive electrostatic potentials distributed on the difluoroboron groups and the carbazolyl unit, respectively, implying the dipole–dipole interactions would contribute to the intermolecular interactions. The twisted conformation, combined with the separate electrostatic potentials of the molecules, suggested that the π–π intermolecular interactions would be inhibited and efficient emission in the solid state could be realized. Then Multiwfn 3.8 software package and VMD 1.9.3 were used to analyze the charge distribution.32–35 In the excited state (S1), the holes of the molecules were distributed on the carbazole group, while the electrons were mostly located on the BF2bdk group and the π bridge, indicating the charge transfer (CT) characteristic of the excited state. In comparison with BF2-PhCz, BF2-PVCz with a more extended π-bridge showed a narrower band gap in both ground and excited states (Fig. 1 and Fig. S1, ESI†). The singlet excited state energies of BF2-PhCz and BF2-PVCz were 3.07 and 2.94 eV with oscillator strengths (f) of 0.0309 and 0.0539 calculated from the excited state transition dipole moment (Fig. S2, ESI†), respectively, indicating redder emission with a higher PLQY of BF2-PVCz.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Molecular structures, electrostatic potentials and singlet excited state properties of molecules (a) BF2-PhCz and (b) BF2-PVCz. | ||
In DMSO/H2O mixtures, both compounds exhibited typical aggregation induced emission (AIE) properties. As shown in Fig. 2c and d, the emission was quenched when the water fraction was lower than 50% due to the large polarity of the solvent, and dramatically turned on when the water content was above 50% because of the aggregation of molecules (Fig. S4, ESI†).36 Impressively, the aggregation of molecules achieved highly efficient orange (λPL = 611 nm, 21.25%) and red (λPL = 649 nm, 22.68%) emissions when the water content was 90%, respectively, implying the efficient solid-state luminescence capability. Both the PL performance in solution and aggregation confirmed that BF2-PVCz possessing more extended π-conjugation realized bathochromic emission with higher fluorescence quantum yields, which verified the calculation prediction and overcame the challenge of “the redder, the brighter”.
The crystals that were cultivated from a mixture of n-hexane and acetone solution exhibited PL emission peaking at 649 (ΦF = 15.34%) and 587 nm (ΦF = 26.76%) for BF2-PhCz and BF2-PVCz, respectively. Comparing with the aggregation of molecules obtained from the DMSO/H2O mixture, the BF2-PhCz crystal showed bathochromic shift emission, while BF2-PVCz exhibited hypsochromic shift emission (Fig. S5, ESI†). Single crystal analysis of BF2-PVCz (CCDC No. 2369031†) revealed that the molecule adopted a linear and twisted skeleton with a trans-conformational C
C bond and a dihedral angle between carbazolyl and phenyl ring units of 52.9° (Fig. 3a), which was consistent with the theoretical calculations. In a long-range view, the molecules formed “head-to-head” arrangement and packed in overlapped layers without any typical π⋯π interactions (Fig. 3b), which would suppress the dipole–dipole interactions and inhibit red-shifted emission. In the crystal, one BF2-PVCz molecule interacted with four adjacent molecules, resulting in four kinds of dimers with illustrated intermolecular interactions (Fig. 3b and Fig. S6, ESI†). In particular, the strong F⋯H hydrogen-bond interaction between the phenyl ring and boron difluoride (d1 = 2.482 Å) in Dimer 1 could fix the bond angle and rotation of the phenyl ring. This rigidified structure would lead to a smaller reorganization energy than that in aggregates, which was indispensable to realize crystal-induced blue-shifted emission.37–39
In order to further analyze the intra/intermolecular interactions in Dimer 1, Hirshfeld surface analysis using Multiwfn was employed.32 As depicted in Fig. 3c, there are efficient intermolecular interactions on the molecular surface. The red isosurface portion, indicative of strong intermolecular contacts, was predominantly F⋯H interactions (contributing 8.41% to the total) between the phenyl group and F atoms, which could effectively inhibit the dipole–dipole interaction, promote the blue-shifted emission and improve the luminescence efficiency (Fig. 3d and e). To more clearly visualize the F⋯H interactions in the molecular aggregates, reduced density gradient (RDG) analysis was performed on Dimer 1.32,40 The green region in the isosurface map of the RDG (Fig. 3g) and the prominent spikes in the region where sign(λ2)ρ (isovalue = 0.5) in the scatter plot (Fig. 3h) indicated the presence of intermolecular interactions between the F and the H atoms in the adjacent phenyl and BF2 groups. On the right-hand side of the finger pattern, the yellowish plates were mainly distributed by the CH⋯π (contributing 20.4% to the total; Fig. 3d and f) interaction between the phenyl and carbazolyl groups, inhibiting the π⋯π interaction and promoting the radiative transition rate. As a result, the abundant intra/intermolecular interactions such as F⋯H, B⋯H and CH⋯π (Fig. S6 and S7, ESI†) were expected to enhance molecular rigidity, which decreased nonradiative rotations and vibrations, ultimately supporting the high PLQY.
The structure of each state was investigated by powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurement to identify the mechanism of MRL (Fig. 4c and d). The original crystals of BF2-PhCz and BF2-PVCz exhibited sharp diffraction peaks. The main peaks in the small angle region were located at 6.27 and 6.10° for BF2-PhCz and BF2-PVCz with d-spacings of 14.23 and 14.47 Å, respectively, implying that BF2-PVCz may possess a larger intermolecular distance and a looser arrangement, which was conducive to the phase transition.41 Upon grinding, the diffraction peaks of BF2-PhCz remained almost the same, indicating that grinding could not disturb the crystal arrangement. However, the sharp peaks of BF2-PVCz vanished after grinding, meaning the sample underwent a crystalline-to-amorphous transformation. The ordered molecular packing was disrupted, and then the dipole–dipole interactions governed by the molecular electrostatic potential distribution became dominant, resulting in a red-shift in luminescence and a decrease in PLQY. In the FT-IR spectra, the stretching vibration peak of the F–B–F bond in the ground sample shifted to 1303 from 1297 cm−1 in the initial state with increased intensity, suggesting grinding resulted in the rupture of the F⋯H hydrogen bond.42 Meanwhile, the out-of-plane bending vibration peak of the C–H bond in the vinyl group shifted from 1083 to 770 cm−1, and the stretching vibration peak of the C
C bond shifted from 1623 to 1628 cm−1 (Fig. 4e). These changes indicated that trans–cis isomerization of the C
C bond occurred upon grinding. Upon fuming with CH2Cl2 vapor, the characteristic vibration peaks of the C–H bond in the vinyl group and the F–B–F bond were restored from 770 to 1082 cm−1 and 1303 to 1297 cm−1, respectively, which means the good reversibility of the F⋯H hydrogen bond in the grinding and fuming cycles. In contrast, the stretching vibration peak of the F–B–F bond at 1303 cm−1 in BF2-PhCz did not change before and after grinding, indicating there were probably no variable F···H hydrogen bonds in the solid (Fig. S9, ESI†). In the DSC curve, an exothermic peak (T = 120 °C, ΔH = 4.2 J g−1) emerged in the heating process before melting in the ground sample of BF2-PVCz, revealing the thermodynamic metastable nature of the ground state and the possibility of reversibility (Fig. 4f).
C bond. Information reversible writing and deep encryption applications were demonstrated taking advantage of the efficient MRL switching of BF2-PVCz. Our work provided a promising strategy for designing considerably emissive red MRL materials with high contrast in the application of information storage and security.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details, theoretical characterization, photophysical properties, crystal structure, MRL properties, and NMR spectra. CCDC 2369031. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4tc04206a |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |