Aidan E.
Izuagbe
ab,
Bryan T.
Tuten
*a,
Peter W.
Roesky
*b and
Christopher
Barner-Kowollik
*ac
aSchool of Chemistry and Physics, Centre for Materials Science, Queensland University of Technology (QUT), 2 George Street, Brisbane, Queensland 4000, Australia. E-mail: christopher.barnerkowollik@qut.edu.au; bryan.tuten@qut.edu.au
bInstitute of Inorganic Chemistry, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Engesserstr. 15, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany. E-mail: peter.roesky@kit.edu
cInstitute of Nanotechnology (INT), Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Hermann-von-Helmholtz-Platz 1, 76344 Eggenstein-Leopoldshafe, Germany. E-mail: christopher.barner-kowollik@kit.edu
First published on 12th April 2024
We introduce a light-driven methodology (λmax = 365 nm) to fold single polymer chains into single chain nanoparticles (SCNPs). Exploiting the photo-isomerization of spiropyran entities embedded into the backbone of polymer chains (ranging from 15 to 38 mol%) constituted of polyethylene glycol carrying monomer units (ranging from Mn = 28500 g mol−1 to 40000 g mol−1), we complex their open form using a range of metals, including iron, copper and cobalt. The approach offers the first direct avenue for incorporating metals into SCNPs via a photochemical folding mechanism in one step.
Fig. 1 (A) Exemplary 1H NMR spectrum of SP-36-PEGMEMA in deuterated chloroform recorded at 500 MHz. The 1H-NMR spectra of the additional polymers can be found in the ESI (ESI, Fig. S19 and S20†). (B) SEC traces of the parent polymers, SP-15-PEGMEMA, SP-36-PEGMEMA and SP-38-PEGMEMA. The folding is induced by mild UV-light (λmax = 365 nm), ring opening the spiropyran units within the polymer chains, which subsequently react with copper, iron and cobalt ions contained in metal salts. |
M p/g mol−1 | M n/g mol−1 | Đ | |
---|---|---|---|
SP-15-PEGMEMA | 32000 | 30500 | 1.3 |
SP-36-PEGMEMA | 45000 | 40000 | 1.2 |
SP-38-PEGMEMA | 29500 | 28500 | 1.4 |
Due to the propensity of spiropyran to undergo significant photo degradation upon conversion to the merocyanine isomer, it is critical to establish an understanding of the photoswitching properties of the employed spiropyran system.17,22 The photoswitching characteristics were thus investigated on one of the linear, spiropyran decorated polymers, i.e.SP-36-PEGMEMA, to identify irradiation conditions for the subsequent folding experiments. A solvent mixture of dioxane:methanol 1:6 was selected to facilitate efficient photoswitching (methanol) and polymer solubility (dioxane) and used for all subsequent photochemical characterisations. The linear polymer (0.0143 mmol L−1, 0.5 g L−1) was subjected to varying irradiation times with a 7 mW LED centred at 365 nm (refer to the ESI Fig. S21† for the LED's emission spectrum). The degree of spiropyran to merocyanine conversion was determined by monitoring the λmax of the visible region at close to 552 nm. Similar absorption at 552 nm was observed for 1, 2 and 3 min of continuous irradiation (Fig. 2A and B).
Periodic irradiation at 365 nm for 1 min and white light irradiation (refer to Fig. S22† for the emission spectrum) for 1 min to generate the merocyanine entities and recovery of the spiropyran respectively was conducted to determine the fatigue resistance of the spiropyran polymer. Photo-induced fatigue was evidenced as a loss in intensity of the visible band centred at 552 nm (Fig. 2C). Consequently, only 1 min irradiation times were employed for the subsequent folding experiments. The band centred at 552 nm was once more used to track the gradual thermal reversion of the merocyanine isomer to the closed spiropyran. As a highly solvent dependent process, increased thermal stability is reported for spiropyran switching in polar solvents.23 As the charged merocyanine form is responsible for forming intramolecular metal-crosslinks and collapsing the polymer chain, the presence of a thermally stable, long lived merocyanine isomer is critical.24 Accordingly, when irradiated in the noted methanol/dioxane mixture, the linear spiropyran polymer features a merocyanine isomer with a long thermal half-life, gradually relaxing back near-quantitatively to the closed spiropyran within a 1 h period (Fig. 2D). The photochemical folding of linear spiropyran polymers into SCNPs was conducted in a photo vial with a 7 W LED centred at 365 nm (refer to the ESI Fig. S2† for a photograph of the reaction set-up). A solution of dissolved metal salt in methanol (0.021 mol L−1, 7.05 g L−1) was added via a syringe pump via continuous addition to a solution of the respective spiropyran polymer in the noted dioxane:methanol 1:6 mixture (0.5 mg mL−1), periodically irradiated with a 365 nm LED. As noted, to avoid photo-induced fatigue, irradiation was limited to 1 min pulses interluded by 30 min of stirring in the dark. The relatively long thermal half-life in dioxane/methanol and the high amount of merocyanine generated after even 1 min irradiation allows for a sufficiently high concentration of merocyanine units for metal ion complexation without continuous irradiation (refer to ESI Fig. S3† for the irradiation pattern and setup). Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) using THF as an eluent was used to monitor the compaction of the linear polymer into SCNPs. A decrease in apparent molecular weight is indictive of intramolecular compaction and SCNP formation.25 Both the number average molecular weight (Mn) and peak molecular weight (Mp) are commonly used to evidence compaction. The resulting compactions are summarised in Table 2 and the corresponding SEC traces can be found in Fig. 4.
Co(BF4)2 | Fe(BF4)2 | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M p/g mol−1 | M n/g mol−1 | % comp | M p/g mol−1 | M n/g mol−1 | % comp | |
SP-15 | 31500 | 31500 | 2 | 30000 | 30500 | 6 |
SP-36 | 36000 | 32500 | 20 | n/a | n/a | n/a |
SP-38 | 26000 | 21000 | 12 | 22000 | 14000 | 25 |
Ni(BF4)2 | Zn(BF4)2 | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M p/g mol−1 | M n/g mol−1 | % comp | M p/g mol−1 | M n/g mol−1 | % comp | |
SP-36 | 43000 | 39000 | 4 | 42000 | 39500 | 7 |
Cu(BF4)2 | |||
---|---|---|---|
M p/g mol−1 | M n/g mol−1 | % comp | |
SP-38 | 27500 | 25000 | 7 |
Compaction of SP-38-PEGMEMA (38 mol% spiropyran units) was most significant with the introduction of FeII ions after 365 nm irradiation with a reduction in apparent molecular weight of 25%. CoII and CuII ions induced SCNP formation, albeit with less compaction for the same polymer. As an independent assessment of the compaction, an exemplary DOSY spectrum (Fig. 3) was recorded for the FeII-SCNP originating from SP-38-PEGMEMA. The derived diffusion coefficients were used to estimate a hydrodynamic diameter of 5.08 nm for the FeII-SCNP indicating a 16% compaction when compared to the parent polymer SP-38-PEGMEMA featuring a diameter close to 6.06 nm (for the primary DOSY data of both the FeII-SCNP and SP-38-PEGMEMA refer to ESI section 6†).
Fig. 3 DOSY spectra recorded in deuterated acetonitrile yield diffusion coefficients for both the linear polymer (SP-38-PEGMEMA) and the FeII-SCNP generated after irradiation and addition of Fe(BF4)2. The protons used to determine diffusion coefficients are highlighted by coloured spheres that match the corresponding resonance on the 1H NMR spectrum (top). Protons associated with the PMMA backbone were also used, labelled as backbone in the 1H NMR spectrum. The mean value of the diffusion coefficients calculated for the resonances– highlighted in grey – associated with both SP-38-PEGMEMA and the FeII-SCNP are represented by a dashed line. The mean diffusion coefficients are used to calculate approximate hydrodynamic diameters. The DH decreases after irradiation and addition of Fe(BF4)2, indicating that intramolecular folding is occurring leading to an SCNP (for the primary DOSY data of both the FeII-SCNP and SP-38-PEGMEMA refer to ESI section 6†). |
Critically, a control experiment was conducted to ensure that SCNP formation did not occur in the dark or at a slower rate compared with the irradiated samples (refer to the ESI, Fig. S4 and section 3.4† for the procedure). Specifically, polymer SP-38-PEGMEMA was exposed to Fe(BF4)2 in the absence of 365 nm light irradiation monitored by SEC. No compaction was observed after 24 h as indicated by the comparison of the Mp values before and after introduction of Fe(BF4)2. A small shift to lower apparent molecular weight and narrower Đ is observed after 24 h when comparing the corresponding Mn values. PEG is known to form complexes with metal species in a process similar to crown ether complexation.26–28 The slight shift to a lower apparent molecular weight and narrower Đ may be attributed to metal encapsulation by the PEG side chains of the SP-38-PEGMEMA polymer. As Fe(BF4)2 induced the largest compaction in the photoinduced folding experiments, further controls with Cu(BF4)2 and Co(BF4)2 were deemed unnecessary. In addition, small molecule 1H NMR studies with the spiropyran monomer, SP-MMA were also conducted using 1 min of irradiation and 0.5 equivalents of metal (0.00296 mmol). The photoinduced formation of merocyanine-metal complexes with FeII, CuII and CoII was confirmed and the percent composition of FeII merocyanine was calculated as 17% and 13% for both CuII and CoII (refer to ESI section 4.1† for the 1H NMR spectra and the procedure). In addition to SP-38-PEGMEMA, SCNP formation was attempted on a larger polymer SP-36-PEGMEMA (Mn = 40000 g mol−1; Mp = 45000 g mol−1) with a similar degree of spiropyran functionalisation (36 mol%) using CoII, ZnII and NiII (Fig. 4). SCNPs were formed with CoII as evidenced by an approximately 20% reduction in apparent molecular weight. ZnII and NiII both resulted in a negligible reduction in molecular weight, suggesting that no SCNP formation occurs. Based on these findings, folding was attempted on the polymer SP-15-PEGMEMA using CoII and FeII, similar in size to SP-38-PEGMEMA, containing only half the amount of spiropyran units (for SEC traces of SP-15-PEGMEMA refer to ESI Fig. S5 and S6†). A less pronounced compaction was observed with FeII, while no compaction was observed with CoII, suggesting that folding is highly dependent on the number of spiropyran units within the polymer chain.7 Indeed, graphing the degree of compaction (based on changes in Mp) vs. the number of spiropyran units per chain reveals a linear correlation for CoII and FeII ions, for which we saw the largest compactions (refer to Fig. S23†).
Merocyanine–metal coordination has been shown to occur with a wide variety of metals, displaying a high affinity towards late transition metals.29 A large number of spiropyran/merocyanine systems rely on the complexation of CuII or CoII ions resulting in distinct morphological changes, specifically in polymeric systems, arising from merocyanine complexation.30–35 In addition, spiropyrans have also been shown to display a high affinity for FeII ions leading to distinct colorimetric responses and selectivity.36–38 Ions such as ZnII or NiII – while known to generate complexes with merocyanine – are less abundant particularly in polymeric systems.18,39,40 In specific studies examining merocyanine/transition metal complexation, ZnII and NiII are often reported as having reduced binding affinity to the open merocyanine. In the current contribution, both CuII and ZnII resulted in small compactions compared to that of FeII or CoII, despite copper being reported to possess a binding affinity that is higher than CoII and comparable to FeII in PMMA based polymer systems.36,41 Compaction may be rationalized by the specific coordination polyhedra of each merocyanine–metal complex. Here, differing geometries (cis/trans) with the coordination of a larger or smaller number of polymer/merocyanine ligands to the metal centre may lead to a larger or smaller compaction respectively, analogous to a variation in the number of possible crosslinks in conventional SCNPs.42 Differences in the composition of the ligand sphere may occur due to steric strain of the polymer backbone as well as different binding energies of the merocyanine ligand to the corresponding metal ion.
The distinct absorption band attributed to the merocyanine (MC) isomer is clearly visible with a λmax of 552 nm in the corresponding UV-Vis spectra after irradiation with a 365 nm LED (refer to Fig. 2A).19 A blue shift of the absorption maximum is commonly utilised to monitor the complexation of metals to the merocyanine form.43 Consequently, the UV-Vis absorption spectra of the different metal containing SCNPs (FeII, CoII and CuII) reveal distinct absorption profiles similar to metal specific polymeric merocyanine complexes reported in literature. The introduction of FeII and CuII ions resulted in similar absorption spectra with broad absorption profiles expanding into the low visible range (Fig. 5). Spectra of both metals contain two noticeable shoulders, for FeII these are observed at close to 434 and 526 nm and for CuII close to 430 and 535 nm. The two shoulders – approximately 430 and 530 nm – observed in both SCNPs formed from CuII and FeII have been attributed to the presence of complexes arising from the cis and trans isomer of the merocyanine respectively.36 In a study by Fries et al., similar absorption profiles for methyl methacrylate based thin film polymers were reported; for FeII the shoulders were observed λmax 520 and 437 nm and for CuII at λmax 520 and 410 nm.36 Similarly, Byrne et al. reported a spiropyran end capped methacrylate polymer capable of complexation with copper leading to the distinct two shoulder profile, with shoulders at 434 and 510 nm.44 Both studies suggest different complexation processes for the coordination of metals to the merocyanine phenolate and carbonyl of polymeric ester side chains or from the formation of merocyanine metal complexes. In the case of the SCNPs explored in the current study, both binding mechanisms can be envisaged to induce intramolecular crosslinking. Addition of CoII results in an absorption spectrum with a profile retaining similarities to un-complexed merocyanine (MC), lacking an absorption band in the low visible region (close to 400 nm) seen in the complexation of CuII and FeII. A distinct absorption band in the mid-visible region is retained with a blue shift to 543 nm compared to 552 nm for the merocyanine maximum absorption. The aforementioned blue-shift is reported in literature for polymeric spiropyran CoII complexation, however the absorption is typically blue shifted close to 520 nm.35
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic methodologies, compound spectral information, emission and absorption spectra, methods and instrumentation. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4py00280f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |