Xin-Ru
Yin
a,
Zhi-Wei
Lu
b,
Xi-Meng
Chen
b,
Li-Qing
He
*c and
Xuenian
Chen
*ab
aCollege of Chemistry, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou, Henan 450001, China
bSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Henan Key Laboratory of Boron Chemistry and Advanced Materials, Henan Normal University, Xinxiang, Henan 453007, China. E-mail: xuenian_chen@zzu.edu.cn; chenximeng@htu.edu.cn
cHefei General Machinery Research Institute Co., Ltd, Hefei 230031, China. E-mail: heli_limao@163.com
First published on 20th August 2025
The synthesis of [trans-B20H18]2− from [closo-B10H10]2− based on redox principles has been developed but is still limited. Using different oxidants often leads to various by-products and affects yields. This paper presents a facile and efficient method for synthesizing [trans-B20H18]2− by directly using the alkali metal salt of [closo-B10H10]2− as the precursor. This approach enables the synthesis of the metal salts of [trans-B20H18]2−. When Cu(OTf)2 is used as the oxidant, Cu2[trans-B20H18] is formed with a yield exceeding 94%. On the other hand, when H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O is used as the oxidant, alkali metal salts of [trans-B20H18]2− (M = Li, Na, and K) are obtained with a yield of up to 85%. All synthesized compounds were characterized by IR, TGA-DSC, and NMR spectroscopy, and M2[trans-B20H18] (M = K, Cu) was characterized by X-ray single crystal diffraction. Both methods allow for the rapid completion of the reaction in a short time. This synthesis method offers promising potential for further applications, particularly as an all-solid-state electrolyte in battery technology.
The synthesis of polyhedral borane polymers centers on utilizing the active sites of boron clusters (such as B–H bonds and heteroatom substituents) to react with oxidants, bridging agents, and metal ions, thereby achieving inter-cluster linkages through covalent or coordination bonds. These methods are potentially applicable to the expansion of highly reactive boron cages, and provide a reference pathway for the design of functionalized borane materials (e.g., ion conductors and catalyst supports).
In particular, the conjuncto-hydroborate anion, [B20H18]2−, exists as various isomers:11–18 [trans-B20H18]2−, [cis-B20H18]2−, [iso-B20H18]2−, and [cross-B20H18]2−, in which [trans-B20H18]2− is the most easily obtained and stable conformer (Fig. 1). Compared to the parent ten-boron [closo-B10H10]2− anion, each [B20H18]2− molecular formula unit contains twice the number of boron atoms. Such a {B20} family, as a high-boron content and tumor-targeting agent, is particularly important in boron neutron capture therapy. On the other hand, the aromatic behavior in such species should be noted, as it is due to the formation of the fused {B20} core. However, the inherent spherical aromatic characteristics of the parent closo-[B10H10]2− cluster is persistent in both iso- and trans-[B20H18]2− isomers as an interplay between the spherical aromatic properties from both B10 motifs, leading to an overlap of the shielding regions from shielding cone properties, ascribed to a dual spherical–spherical aromatic cluster.19 The variation of the B10–B10 backbone provided by the intercluster B-interaction, thus, results in a more effective aggregation connecting such building units, towards boron-based cluster materials.20–23
Although the synthesis of the [trans-B20H18]2− anion derivatives has been extensively studied based on oxidative dehydrogenation coupling of the [closo-B10H10]2− anion derivatives since the 1960s, the synthetic methods are still limited. The most examined starting materials are organic ammonium salts of the [closo-B10H10]2− anion. In 1962, the first ammonium salt, [Et3NH]2[trans-B20H18], was synthesized by reacting Fe3+ with [Et3NH]2[closo-B10H10] under high-temperature conditions.10 However, this method only worked for the ammonium salt and did not apply to alkali metal salts such as M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Li, Na, and K). Therefore, the various salts of the [trans-B20H18]2− anions with different counteractions and organic ligands synthesized by metathesis reactions and their coordination chemistry have been widely explored. Several silver(I) salts with PPh3 ligands were isolated and reported.24 The lead(II) salts with Bipy ligands of [B20H18]2− were synthesized and characterized by IR spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction.25 A tris-chelate manganese(II) complex with a Bipy ligand [Mn(Bipy)3][B20H18]26 and an iron(II) complex with a cyclopentadienyl ligand [CpFe(Cp-CH2-NMe2Et2)][B20H18]27 were isolated and characterized. In addition, iron(II), cobalt(II), and nickel(II) complexes with 1,10-phenanthroline and 2,2′-bipyridyl in the presence of [B20H18]2−, with varying reagent ratios and solvents, were obtained. Several tris-chelate and binuclear complexes were isolated and studied by IR spectroscopy, elemental analysis, and X-ray diffraction.28 The gold(III) salts of a [B20H18]2− anion, [Au(L)Cl2]2[B20H18] (L = bipy, phen), were isolated and characterized.29 Moreover, the synthesis of a nickel(II) complex [Ni(Phen)3][B20H18] was briefly reported, indicating Ni(II) complexes with [B20H18]2− formed by the oxidation of the complex [Ni(Phen)3][B10H10] with cerium(IV).25
The oxidative dehydrogenation coupling of the [closo-B10H10]2− anion derivatives was generally carried out in an aqueous solution with Fe3+ or Ce4+ as an oxidizer (Fig. 2). Only one attempt was made to use acetonitrile as a solvent8 and an electrochemical method used CH2Cl2, THF, or CH3CN.30 Another approach involved the high-temperature pyrolysis of [NMe4][N2B10H9] to obtain [NMe4]2[trans-B20H18], but it suffered from low yield, long reaction time, and the need for high temperature.31
To solve the limitations of these methods, especially for synthesizing alkali metal-based advanced polyhedral boron cluster compounds, we found that by using H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O as the oxidant, alkali metal salts of the [trans-B20H18]2− anion could be directly synthesized in non-aqueous solvent, based on our group's work on the synthesis of polyhedral boranes and functionalization of carborane.32–35 M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Na, K) can be obtained as solvent-free salts, while Li2[trans-B20H18]·0.23CH3CN is formed with a small amount of acetonitrile solvent. The yield ranges from 83% to 86%. Interestingly, when Cu(OTf)2 is used as the oxidant, oxidative dehydrogenation coupling of M2[closo-B10H10] (M = Li, Na, and K) leads to the formation of Cu2[trans-B20H18]·1.2CH3CN, different from the reaction carried out in aqueous solution.10 Both methods achieve rapid reactions under simple and mild conditions.
The primary synthetic methods of [trans-B20H18]2− anions36 reported so far are shown in eqn (1)–(3). Using Fe3+ as an oxidant, at 100 °C, [Et3NH]2[closo-B10H10] could convert a salt of [Et3NH]2[trans-B20H18] (eqn (1)) with a yield of up to 95%.10 Using Ce4+ as the oxidizing agent, [NiL3][closo-B10H10] was converted to [NiL3][trans-B20H18] at room temperature with a yield of 80% (eqn (2)).37 By the electrochemical synthesis, the [trans-B20H18]2− anion was obtained with a reaction time of 4 hours and a yield of 85%.30 Another method involves the pyrolysis of [N2B10H9]−, which was discovered accidentally (eqn (3)), with a lower yield, a longer reaction time, and high temperatures.31 As reported in the literature, the direct synthesis of the alkali metal salts of [trans-B20H18]2− remained unexplored.38
2 [B10H10]2− + 4 Fe3+ → [trans-B20H18]2− + 4 Fe2+ + 2 H+ | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
NMe4[N2B10H9] → (NMe4)2[B20H18] + 2 N2 | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
\scale97%{2 [B10H10]{2−} + 4 Cu2+ → [trans-B20H18]{2{−}} + 4 Cu+ + 2 H+ | (5) |
We have developed an efficient one-step direct synthesis method of M2[trans-B20H18] under mild conditions using M2[closo-B10H10] (M = Li, Na, and K) as the starting material. Yields of M2[trans-B20H18] can reach an impressive 83–86%. The mechanism of the reaction is similar to that of the ammonium salt of [trans-B20H18]2−, in which an appropriate oxidant was used to induce oxidative dehydrogenation coupling of M2B10H10 to form M2[trans-B20H18]. We initially used Na2B10H10 as the substrate and employed the established method reported in the literature to screen various Lewis acid oxidants (Table 1). The experimental results show that [trans-B20H18]2− can be obtained from both H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O and Cu(OTf)2. Both [P(Mo3O10)4]3+ (eqn (4)) and Cu2+ (eqn (5)) could act as oxidizers and exhibit high compatibility with the polyhedral borane [closo-B10H10]2−. When Cu(OTf)2 is used as the oxidant, Cu2[trans-B20H18] is produced with a yield exceeding 94%. It is worth noting that the solvents play a crucial role in these reactions. Cu2+ does not play an oxidant role to initiate such oxidative dehydrogenation coupling of M2[closo-B10H10] under similar conditions in aqueous solution, where only a CuB10H10 precipitate was formed.10 On the other hand, when H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O is used as the oxidant, alkali metal salts of [trans-B20H18]2− (M = Li, Na, and K) are obtained, with a yield of up to 85%.
Entry | Oxidant | t/h | Yieldb (%) |
---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: Na2B10H10 (5 mmol) and different oxidants (10 mmol) in CH3CN (25 mL) at 30 °C. b Isolated yield as Na+ salts. | |||
1 | PMA | 1.5 | 83 |
2 | Cu(OTf)2 | 1.5 | 91 |
3 | Al(OTf)3 | 2 | Trace |
4 | FeCl3 | 2 | 43 |
5 | Fe(OTf)3 | 2 | 46 |
6 | Ni(OTf)2 | 2 | Trace |
7 | Ce(OTf)3 | 2 | Trace |
8 | Ce(OTf)4 | 2 | 38 |
9 | Ce(NH3)2(NO3)6 | 2 | 41 |
10 | CF3COOCu | 2 | 32 |
We then examined the effects of different molar ratios of Na2B10H10 to H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O or Cu(OTf)2 and found that the optimized molar ratio for the reaction was different when the oxidants were H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O or Cu(OTf)2. The ideal ratio of Na2B10H10 to H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O is 3:
1 (Table 2). The optimal ratio of Na2B10H10 to Cu(OTf)2 is 1
:
3 (Table 3). The excess usage of H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O might have been due to every Mo6+ in PMA being an efficient oxidant.
It is worth noting that when H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O is used as the oxidant and M2[closo-B10H10] (M = Li, Na, and K) as the substrate, the corresponding alkali metal advanced polyhedral boranes M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Li, Na, and K) are obtained, with yields ranging from 83% to 86%. Alkali metal salts, Na2[trans-B20H18] and K2[trans-B20H18], can be obtained without acetonitrile coordination, while Li2[trans-B20H18]·0.23CH3CN is obtained with a small amount of solvent coordination because of the stronger coordination ability of Li+. What is more interesting is that when Cu(OTf)2 is used as the oxidant and M2[closo-B10H10] (M = Li, Na, and K) as the substrate, the final product is Cu2[trans-B20H18]·1.2CH3CN, with a yield as high as 91–94%, rather than the alkali metal salts. This result indicates that the formed Cu+ cations after reaction have a stronger interaction ability with the [B20H18]2− anions in the presence of acetonitrile solvent.
These M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Cu, Li, and K) complexes were fully characterized by NMR spectroscopy (1H, 1H{11B}, 11B, and 11B{1H} NMR) (Fig. S1−S24), XRD, XPS, and TGA (Fig. S25–29). To further prove the role of Mo6+ as an oxidizer in reactions, the valence state of Mo in H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O was detected by XPS before and after reactions. After the reactions, the valence state of a part of Mo in H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O was transformed from +6 to +5 (Fig. S29).
These M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Cu, Li, and K) complexes were fully characterized using XRD patterns and infrared spectra (Fig. S25−S27). Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) results reveal the temperatures at which the remaining solvent molecules are removed from the samples: for Li2B20H18·1.5CH3CN (Fig. S27), K2B20H18·0.3CH3CN (Fig. S28), and hydrous Cu2B20H18·1.2CH3CN (Fig. S29) the temperatures are approximately 200, 290, and 190 °C, respectively. This viewpoint has been verified through computational analysis.
The single-crystal structures of the salts [Cu·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18] and [K·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18] were successfully determined (Fig. 3). While the structure of the octadecahydroeicosaborate anion is similar to those reported in the literature, the interactions between the cation and anion are different.23–29 In the structure of [Cu·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18], each Cu(I) cation is coordinated to one CH3CN molecule with the Cu–N distance of 1.933 Å, in which CH3CN acts as a monodentate ligand. Each Cu(I) also coordinated to two B–H bonds with the distances of 2.305 and 2.328 Å for Cu-B and 1.890 and 1.628 Å for Cu–H, in which Cu adopts a three-coordination, based on which the interactions between Cu(I) and the B–H bond are partly covalent. Moreover, each B20H182− anion also interacts with four Cu(I) cations via two Cu⋯H⋯B interactions. A similar interaction between cations and H atoms also exists in the compound [Au(L)Cl2] [trans-B20H18] (L = bipy, phen).29 In contrast, [K·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18] seems to be an ion pair structure, which is different from [Cu·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18]. Each CH3CN, as a η2-ligand, bonds with two K cations with K–N distances of 2.872 and 3.029 Å, similar to the coordination geometry of K2[B20H18]·4CH3CN39 and K[B(CN)4]·CH3CN, resulting in the formation of an extended cation chain with the alternating linkages of K+ ions and CH3CN molecules. Each K cation interacts with 5 B–H bonds in its other half sphere with distances of 2.868–3.014 Å, indicating an electrostatic attraction. A similar behavior was observed for [Fe(Bipy)3][B20H18]·Bipy·2CH3CN, [Ni(Phen)3][B20H18]·2DMF, and [Co(Phen)3][B20H18]·4CH3CN complexes.28 Each [B20H18]2− anion is surrounded by eight K, with the K–B distances of 3.417–4.513 Å, consisting of a rectangular prism. Such weak interactions between K and B–H may be why Cu(I) could replace the alkali metals, Li, Na, and K, in the reaction to afford the u(I) salt.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Molecular structures of [Cu·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18] (a) and [K·CH3CN]2[trans-B20H18], (b) both showing 50% probability thermal ellipsoids. |
In conclusion, we have developed facile methods for directly synthesizing M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Li, Na, K, and Cu) by the reactions of M2[B10H10] (M = Li, Na, and K) with an oxidizer, such as H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O or Cu(OTf)2. It was found that when H3P(Mo3O10)4·xH2O was used as an oxidizer with its molar ratio to M2[B10H10] (M = Li, Na, and K) of 1:
3, M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Li, Na, and K) was obtained with yields of 83–86%. When Cu(OTf)2 was used as an oxidizer with its molar ratio to M2[B10H10] of 3
:
1, Cu2[trans-B20H18] was obtained with yields of 91–94%. This work not only provides an efficient synthetic method for [trans-B20H18]2− but also paves the way for the practical application of M2[trans-B20H18] (M = Li, Na, and K) derivatives in various fields, including solid ionic conductors.
CCDC 2449540 and 2415748 contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.40a,b
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |