Tapan K.
Pal
Department of Chemistry, Pandit Deendayal Energy University, Gandhinagar 382426, Gujarat, India. E-mail: tapan.pal@sot.pdpu.ac.in
First published on 9th December 2022
Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are a novel category of hybrid porous multifunctional materials with excellent qualitative features. These properties can be fine-tuned via the judicial choice of organic ligands and metal ions and by changing the synthetic reaction conditions. Among the various excellent applications exhibited by MOFs, the photoluminescence behaviour is very appealing and originates from their metal ions, linker, or entrapped guest molecules in their cavity. Thus, due to the tuneable luminescent properties of MOFs, they can act as sensors, enabling the selective and sensitive detection of a diverse range of analytes. In general, the sensing of analytes by MOFs can be accomplished either through a fluorescence “turn-on” (fluorescence intensity increases) or “turn-off” (fluorescence intensity decreases) process. Between them, the former is more important and significant in terms of real-time applications. This is because the “turn-on” emission occurs with the signal lighting (increases the fluorescence intensity) against a dark background. Therefore, this review summarizes the recent advances in MOFs as “turn-on” sensors for the recognition of a wide range of analytes (hazardous compounds, volatile organic molecules, cations, biomolecule, anions, etc.) and their sensing mechanism.
Generally, the main components of any sensor are a transducer and receptor, which passes a signal through several pathways. Among the various sensing pathways, the luminescence sensing process is straightforward, friendly, can be quantified by the naked eye and has great flexibility.31 The crystalline MOF network is synthesized through the self-assembly of an organic linker consisting of multiple binding sites and a single metal ion or metal ion clusters (metal node or SBU).32,33 Generally, the organic ligand possesses an aromatic surface area with free movement of π electrons, giving rise to luminescence activity upon excitation at a particular wavelength. In addition, the role of metal ions is crucial to the photoluminescence property. Particularly, the d10 transition metal ions or clusters and lanthanide ions are fascinating.34,35 Specifically, the permutation and combination of organic ligands and metal ions can be adjusted to modulate the sensing property of MOFs. In comparison to the contemporary sensory polymeric materials, MOFs demonstrate various potential benefits, as follows: (a) the direct visualization of the crystalline network, which helps to establish their structural-property correlation, (b) atomistic location of the guest interaction site, which makes easier to confirm the sensing mechanism, (c) their porous nature allows the smooth transfer of the analytes through their voids, i.e., a larger concentration of the analyte in their pores, which brings the analytes in close proximity to the guest interaction site, resulting in a very low limit of detection, and (d) highly luminescent MOFs offer ultra-selectivity, ultra-sensitivity, and rapid response time. Additionally, MOFs show a colorimetric response, which enables the naked eye recognition of the desired analytes. Thus, MOFs as luminescence sensors have excelled in diverse sensing fields (Fig. 1).
In principle, the recognition of analytes can be read out according to the changes in the emission wavelength of MOFs either by a decrease/increase in their emission intensity and/or shift in their emission wavelength peak. However, depending on the electronic nature of the analyte, MOFs can show either quenching of their emission intensity (turn-off response) or the enhancement in their emission intensity (turn-on response).36,37 The “turn-on” sensing event is an interesting research motif in terms of sensitivity and real-time applicability, given that the response signal can be denoted as an optical indicator by illuminating light in a dark environment. Alternatively, the “turn-off” sensing event reduces the optical colorimetric response against a bright background. Typically, most of the sensing by MOFs is based on the quenching of luminescence intensity, whereas sensing through “turn-on” by MOFs is very scarce and challenging. A SciFinder survey revealed that the number of MOF-based “turn-on” sensors developed for the detection of various analytes has gradually increased from 2015 to 2022 (Fig. 1, accession date 31st August 2022 and searched using the term MOF as “turn-on” sensor).
Most of the published reviews are focused on MOF-based luminescence sensors38–41 for all types of analytes, regardless of the sensing event or mechanism. However, although each review article has its own importance and purpose, the approach of this current review is different. Also, a timely review with updated research developments can forecast the past realization, present growth, and further improvement in any research field. Thus, in this review article, attention is devoted to the recent developments for the fluorescence “turn-on” detection of all types of analytes using MOF-based sensors. Various analytes including (a) neutral molecules (biological active molecules/biomarkers, toxic compounds, and volatile organic molecules), (b) cations and (c) anions that induce a luminescence “turn-on” event are discussed thoroughly. Before we summarize the research progress on “turn-on” sensing using MOFs, initially, the fundamental features of luminescence in MOFs are briefly discussed.
The luminescence process of a fluorophore can be assessed using various factors, as follows: (a) the changes in its luminescence spectrum (or emission wavelength), i.e., either a change in intensity or shift in the peak position, (b) quantum yield, which can be described as the number of photons emitted with respect to the number of quanta absorbed, and (c) average lifetime of the excited state, which indicates the time the fluorophore molecule spends in the excited state before emitting and depends on the rate constant of the non-radiative (knr) and radiative process (kr) according to the following equation:43
![]() | (1) |
Also, alterations in the luminescence of the ligand may occur due to changes in the excitation level of the linker. Two significant process are excited-state proton transfer (ESPT) and excited-state electron transfer (ESET). In the former process, the proton is attached or leaves the molecule in the excited state, whereas in the latter case, the relocation of the electron occurs from the electron-rich ligand to the electron-deficient ligand. Maji and co-workers used the H2DHT ligand to construct a magnesium-based MOF, Mg(DHT)(DMF)2, which showed a prominent intramolecular ESPT process (Fig. 2).48 The free linker H2DHT showed a UV absorption peak at around 360 nm and its emission peaks appeared at different positions depending on the polarity of the solvent molecules. For instance, the ligand showed blue emission (at 440 nm) in ethanol solvent (polar protic) and green emission (at 510 nm) in DMSO/DMF solvent (polar aprotic). This is ascribed to the keto–enol tautomerism of H2DHT. Interestingly, given that the H2DHT ligand can show fluorescence changes due to ESIPT, the MOF also exhibited luminescence changes with a variation in the solvent polarity. The MOF showed blue emission at 429 and 404 nm in ethanol, while in DMSO, these peaks were red-shifted and appeared at 508 nm. Also, in water the emission peak was strongly red-shifted and the maximum emission was observed at 532 nm. Remarkably, in the presence of TFA, the emission peak of MOF was blue-shifted, which is due to the formation of intermolecular hydrogen bonding between H2DHT and TFA, effectively stopping the ESIPT mechanism. Canivet and co-workers synthesized an Al-MIL-101-NH2 MOF for the “turn-on” detection of H2S.49 They first post-synthetically converted the –NH2 group of the linker (NH2-BDC) in Al-MIL-101-NH2 to an –N3 group for the construction of Al-MIL-101-N3. Consequently, the luminescence intensity of the daughter MOF was significantly reduced. In the presence of H2S, the azide group was converted to an amino group, and hence the fluorescence intensity of the MOF was recovered. Thus, the emission peak and its intensity during the sensing process is entirely ligand based.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 H2DHT ligand and its three-dimensional MOF network Mg(DHT)(DMF)2 (inset: solution colour of MOF dispersed in different solvents). |
Besides, d10 transition metal ions, lanthanide metal ions and/or their clusters are the main contributors to the metal-based emission in MOFs. In the periodic table, the lanthanide metal ions are identified by the regular filling of electrons in the 4f orbitals, from 4f0 (for La3+) to 4f14 (for Lu3+) with the general electronic configuration [Xe]4fn (n = 0–14). This electronic configuration produces various well-defined energy levels, leading to interesting luminescent properties.57–59 The 4f orbitals are well shielded by 5s and 5d shells, and thus the electron in the 4f orbital is less sensitive to the outer electronic environment. Moreover, the f–f transition is forbidden, offering sharp, narrow and signature emission peaks. Most of the lanthanide metal ions except Lu3+ and La3+ show characteristic emission colours. The Tb3+, Tm3+, Eu3+ and Sm3+ lanthanide metal ions produce green, blue, red and orange emissive colour, respectively. In contrast, the Nd3+, Yb3+ and Er3+ lanthanide metal ions emit in the near-infrared region.
Considering that the f–f transition in lanthanides metal ions is forbidden, their molar absorption coefficients are very low. The direct electronic transition in lanthanide metal ions is very inefficient, which can sometimes be achieved using a high power laser source. However, this difficulty can be overcome using a foreign compound that can transfer energy to the lanthanide metal ions, where this process is widely known as the antenna effect or sensitization.60–62 This antenna effect generally occurs in three steps. In the first step, upon light irradiation the organic ligand present in the lanthanide complex or MOF gets excited. In the second step, intramolecular energy relocation is accomplished from the excited level of the ligand to the lanthanide ions. The final step involves the occurrence of emission from the lanthanide metal ions. This movement of energy in the antenna or sensitization process can be clearly understood according to the following path: the initial migration of energy is the spin-allowed ligand-based transition, and then the spin-forbidden energy relocation from the excited singlet level (S1) to the excited triplet level (T1), followed by the transfer of energy from the excited triplet state T1 to the lanthanide metal ion. Finally, the metal-based emission occurs (Fig. 3). Another way of energy relocation is the direct allocation of energy from the excited singlet level of the linker to the excited energy level of the lanthanide metal, where the metal-entered emission occurs (Fig. 3). This direct transfer of energy generally observed for Tb3+ and Eu3+.63 If the energy transfer from the ligand to the lanthanide metal ion is very efficient, then phosphorescence and fluorescence from the ligand may not occur. If the energy relocation is occurs partially, then the both the ligand-based and metal-based (lanthanide) emission will be observed. In this context, the energy relocation from the ligand to lanthanide metal ions usually occurs at higher energy levels than the emission level for the metal-based emission, otherwise the back transfer of energy will occur.
Therefore, to achieve lanthanide-based emission in MOFs, the role of the organic linkers is crucial. In addition, the triplet energy state of the linker should be energetically equal or higher than the resonance energy state of the lanthanide metal ion, and thus the linker can maximize the energy transfer and decrease the back-transfer. Therefore, the design of the organic ligand is crucial to generate the luminescent lanthanide-based MOFs.64
Another important transition shown by lanthanide metal ions is the “hypersensitive transition”, in which the intensity of the transition is influenced by the local symmetry and environment.65 Although, the f–f transition is less intense, when lanthanide metal ions are introduced in a new chemical environment, the non-centrosymmetric interaction enables the mixing of the different parity wave functions. This results in “hypersensitive transitions.66 Various Eu3+ ion-based lanthanide MOFs show hypersensitive transitions and based on these transitions, the coordination environment and symmetry of the chemical environment around the metal ion can be understood.67,68
The quantum yield is a very significant parameter to assess the luminescence quality of MOFs. The quantum yield can be defined as the ratio of the number of photons released to the number of photon absorbed. The quantum yield of lanthanide MOFs sometimes decreases due to the vibration of the environmental ligands, and particularly, the high energy vibration of carbon–hydrogen, nitrogen–hydrogen and oxygen–hydrogen bonds.69 Significant progress has been made in the reduction of non-radiative transitions. The replacement of the high-energy O–H bond vibration by the low energy O–D bond vibration results the shrinkage of the vibronic de-excitation process.70 This indicates that if we remove this high energy bond vibration, then the luminescent properties of lanthanide MOFs can be significantly improved. For example, Tb3+, Eu3+, and Tb3+ metal ions have been complexed with macrocyclic polyamine ligands, and then the complex used to construct MOFs.71 In this case, the coordination environment of the lanthanides are fulfilled, and hence the vibration effect from the environmental water molecules is blocked. Consequently, the MOFs show highly luminescence features in the visible and NIR regions. Therefore, the aforementioned discussion clearly reveals that the judicial design and proper understanding of the energy transfer in lanthanide-based MOFs are key features to develop lanthanide-based luminescent MOFs.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) Diverse charge transfer in metal ligand complex (octahedral) and (b) operation of various types of charge transfer in MOFs. |
Commonly, the intense colour of complexes can be easily explained by these transitions. For example, the pink colour of KMnO4 and orange colour of K2Cr2O7 can be attributed to the LMCT process, where the charge relocation occurs from the oxygen (2p orbital) ion to the vacant d orbital on Mn7+ and Cr6+, respectively. Similarly, with the help of MLCT, the colour of a tris(bipyridyl)iron(III) complex can be explained by the charge transfer occurring from the iron metal centre to the π*-orbital of bipyridyl.72 The deep-blue colour of a Prussian blue complex can be explain by MMCT.73 LLCT is also observed in a variety of coordination compounds.74
In the case of MOFs, their network is developed through strong bonds between their ligand and metal ion. However, not all metal–ligand bonds are very strong, and the labile nature between them sometimes produces new important chemistry. Occasionally, the flexible nature of the ligand can endow flexibility to the MOF system. As discussed, the tuneable porous nature of MOFs can enable several fluorophore molecules to be embedded inside their cavity (Fig. 4b). These features enable the design of the desired MOF with interesting luminescent properties. In MOFs, the above-mentioned charge transfer process may occur very smoothly (Fig. 4b). Here, a few examples are presented where the involvement of these charge transfer processes was obviously observed.
Pei and co-workers reported an interesting work, where they demonstrated that an alternation in LMCT led to fluoro-switching in an MOF.75 By using an AIE-inactive fluorophore as the linker, they synthesized two MOFs, Gd-ETTC and Cu-ETTC (Fig. 5). Specifically, Gd-ETTC was fluorescent in nature with a high intense emission band at 455 nm, whereas the Cu-ETTC is non-fluorescent. The XPS analysis revealed that due to the efficient LMCT process in Cu-ETTC, a redox reaction occurred, which led to changes in the oxidation state of copper from +2 to +1. This process triggered a matrix coordination-induced quenching process,76 which caused luminescence quenching of Cu-ETTC. In the presence of GSH (electron donor moiety), the reduction of the Cu2+ to Cu+ state occurred, which stops the LMCT process effectively. Therefore, the fluorescence property of Cu-ETTC was recovered.
Xu and co-workers synthesized two d10-based MOFs, i.e., [Zn(2,3-pydc)(bpp)(H2O)]·2.5H2O and [Cd(2,3-pydc)(bpp)(H2O)]·3H2O, under solvothermal conditions.77 The cadmium- and zinc-based MOFs exhibited emission peaks at 438 and 436 nm upon excitation at 370 and 372 nm, respectively. The free ligand 2,3-pydcH2 showed a very feeble emission peak upon excitation at 370 nm. Therefore, the origin of the high-intensity fluorescence peak in these two MOFs is due to the LMCT process. Furthermore, the strong chelation ability of the linker to the metal node reduced the ligand flexibility, and thus the luminescence intensity of the MOFs was significantly enhanced.
Zhu and co-workers synthesized two new d10 metal ion MOFs, [Zn(L1)(bpy)0.5].(H2O)0.25 and [Cd4(L1)4(bpy)2]·(H2O), under solvothermal conditions for the detection of H2S.78 The solid-state luminescence spectra of both complexes exhibited the maximum emission peak at 560 nm under excitation at 466 nm. With respect to the free ligand (λem = 518 nm), the emission peak of the complexes was red-shifted by about 42 nm. This is ascribed to the MLCT or cluster to ligand charge transfer. Guo and co-workers reported the preparation of two MOFs, i.e., a copper-based Cu3(L2)2·3H2O and mixed-metal CuAg2(L2)2 MOF.79 The emission spectra of the free ligand L2 and CuAg2(L2)2 MOF showed a green luminescence peak at 526 nm and 515 nm under excitation at 365 nm and 358 nm, respectively. In contrast, the copper-based Cu3(L2)2·3H2O MOF displayed blue luminescence at 478 and 398 nm under excitation at 333 nm. This MOF exhibited a large blue shift of 48 and 59 nm with respect to the emission peak of the ligand, respectively, whereas the mixed MOF only showed an 11 nm blue shift in its emission peak. Therefore, the origin of the luminescence in Cu3(L2)2·3H2O is the MLCT and the source of the emission in CuAg2(L)2 is the π⋯π* electronic transition of L2.
The inclusion of a lanthanide metal ion either by the de-novo or PSM method is an interesting strategy to induce luminescent properties in the daughter MOF. For example, Qian and co-workers described the preparation of a zirconium-based MOF, UiO-66-(COOH)2, using ZrCl4 and H4btec under solvothermal reaction conditions. This MOF contained free carboxylic acids, which act as guest interaction sites to facilitate the post-synthetic incorporation of Eu3+ and Cu2+ to deliver Eu3+/Cu2+@UiO-66-(COOH)2.84 The emission spectrum of the composite displayed the ligand-centered emission at 393 nm and metal-centred emission of Eu3+ at 615 nm. Due to the strong antenna effect of H4btec, Eu3+ demonstrated a strong peak at 615 nm. In the presence of Cu2+, the antenna effect of H4btec decreased, i.e., the degree of charge transfer from the ligand to Eu3+ significantly declined given that Cu2+ (d9) is an electron-deficient system, which withdraws more energy from the ligand. Thus, in the composite, the emission intensity at 615 nm decreased. Interestingly, the composite showed the very fast recognition of H2S (Fig. 6) with an LOD value of 5.45 μM. The soft sulphide ion interacted strongly with the soft Cu2+ ion, and thereby reduced the energy transfer from the linker to Cu2+. Therefore, the energy transfer increased from the ligand to Eu3+. Consequently, the emission of Eu3+ sharply increased.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Post-synthetic incorporation of Eu3+ and Cu2+ in UiO-66-(COOH)2 to from Eu3+/Cu2+@UiO-66-(COOH)2, followed by the detection of H2S. Reproduced with permission from ref. 84, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2016. |
In an early report, Rosi and co-workers reported the synthesis of lanthanide-based luminescent MOFs, Ln3+@bio-MOF-1, by doping lanthanide metal ions (Ln3+ = Tb3+, Sm3+, and Eu3+) via post-synthetic cation exchange in bio-MOF-1 (Fig. 7).85 All the doped MOFs showed a distinct colour upon excitation at 365 nm. Specifically, Eu3+@bio-MOF-1, Sm3+@bio-MOF-1 and Tb3+@bio-MOF-1 emitted red, orange-pink and green color, respectively which could be clearly observed by the bare eye. Importantly, all these doped MOFs showed characteristic emission wavelengths, where Eu3+@bio-MOF-1, Sm3+@bio-MOF-1 and Tb3+@bio-MOF-1 produced an emission at 614, 640 and 545 nm, respectively. Simultaneously, all these complexes exhibited a common peak at 340 nm, indicating that the energy transfer occurs from the same electronic state situated in the doped lanthanide complexes. Importantly, the lanthanide-doped MOFs were found to be highly luminescent in water solvent, despite the strong quenching effect of the aqua molecules. This illustrates that bio-MOF-1 efficiently sensitized the guest lanthanide ion. In addition, all the lanthanide metal ions nicely fitted inside the pore, which resulted in a high quantum yield for these doped MOFs.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Doping of Tb3+, Sm3+, and Eu3+ in bio-MOF-1 and the respective colour of the doped MOFs. Reproduced with permission from ref. 85, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2019. |
Carbon dots (CDs) are well-known fluorophore compounds, which can be nicely incorporated in the cavity of MOFs to generate new fluorescence MOF entities.86 Chi and coworkers reported the inclusion of BPEI-CQDs in ZIF-8 and the new MOF composite (BPEI-CQDs/ZIF-8) showed a high quantum yield. The composite exhibited strong blue emission at 440 nm upon excitation at 385 nm and it could detect copper ions.87 Similalrly, Wang and co-worker used the ZIF-8 framework to encapsulate CDs in its cavity to form CDs@ZIF-8 for the recognition of quercetin.88 The luminescence intensity of CDs@ZIF-8 appeared at 480 nm upon excitation at 365 nm. The ZIF-8 did not show any peak at 480 nm, indicating that the emission originated from the CD moiety. Besides CDs, the inclusion of dye and luminescent organic molecules in the MOF cavity, the luminescence properties of the MOF composite could be tuned. Li and co-workers incorporated three different dyes (fluorescein (green), rhodamine B (red) and coumarin C-151 (blue)) molecules in the cavity of ZIF-8 (Fig. 8).89 The judicial tuning of the ratio of these dyes caused the MOF composite (model 3) to show white light emission upon excitation at 365 nm. The increase in the quantum yield of dye@ZIF-8 is due to the reduction in the aggregation-caused quenching process.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 (a) Cavity size of ZIF-8 and the dimensions of C-151, fluorescein and rhodamine B and (b) synthetic methodologies for dye-encapsulated ZIF-8. Reproduced with permission from ref. 89, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2019. |
Su and co-workers described the construction of a highly luminescent MOF composite (Rh6@NENU-519) via the post-synthetic encapsulation of dye molecules (Rhodamine 6G and Rh6) in the cavity of the anionic MOF, NENU-519.90 Under excitation at 350 nm, the Rh6@NENU-519 material exhibited emission peaks at 406 nm and 565 nm, which correspond to the emission from NENU-519 and Rh6 molecule, respectively. By comparing the emission intensity ratio at 565 nm and 406 nm of Rh6@NENU-519 in the presence of various analytes, it was found that the composite was selective for the recognition of para, meta and ortho-xylene. The differences in the intensity ratio of Rh6@NENU-519 is owing the diverse amount of charge transfer between the composite and the organic analytes.
The inclusion of organic molecules or inorganic complexes in MOF composites enables the creation of a fluorophore entity. In this regard, Wang and co-worker described the encapsulation of Ru(bpy)32+ in UiO-66-NH2.91 The MOF composite demonstrated two peaks at 437 nm and 604 nm, which correspond to the emission of UiO-66-NH2 and Ru(bpy)32+, respectively. However, by comparing the emission intensity ratio of the composite in the presence of various analytes, the composite could recognize Hg2+ ions. Importantly, the authors also demonstrated the formation of a hydrogel composite, where the luminescence intensity of the network remained intact. Although the gel composite contained the maximum percentage of water and despite the resilient quenching influence of the aqua molecule, the MOF-based gel composite showed luminescence activity. This indicates that the MOF composite could sufficiently protect the guest molecule Ru(bpy)32+, causing it to show luminescence behaviour. Interestingly, the gel composite also enabled the colorimetric detection of mercury ions. Recently, Chen and co-workers published an important work in which the fluorescence property of the encapsulated fluorophore molecule could be tuned (photo-switchable phenomena) in the presence external stimuli (light).92 They synthesized a photo-switchable Eu3+-based MOF by capturing diarylethene (DAE) moiety in its porous cavity. In the presence of light, the DAE unit underwent a ring-closing reaction. Thus, the ring-opening and ring-closing form of DAE displayed distinct colours. This colour-changing phenomena is also reversible, and this technique is used to demonstrate reversible data storage application.
Lantham and co-workers showed the detection of electron-rich aromatic VOCs through a “turn-on” process using a zinc-based MOF, (Zn2Cl4Py-TPE)·4(TCE).96 As is known, molecular networks containing TPE derivatives can show AIE in highly concentrated solution or in the solid state. In these states, the motion or rotation of the central phenyl ring is generally blocked, which stops the intramolecular rotation, and hence inhibition of the non-radiative decay of the excited state occurs.97 Based on this concept, the synthesized zinc MOF showed luminescence property. However, its fluorescence emission intensity was further enhanced in the presence of aromatic VOCs (Fig. 9) together with the red shifting of its emission peak. The shifting in the emission peak and the “turn-on” luminescence response illustrate that the analytes gradually locked the rotation/vibration of the central phenyl ring, which led to an increase in the fluorescence intensity. Fig. 9 indicates that with an increase in the methyl substituent on the benzene ring, the emission intensity of the MOF was gradually reduced. For instance, the luminescence intensity of the MOF was greater with benzene than with mesitylene. The size of mesitylene is larger than the benzene ring, and thus the latter can smoothly enter the pores of the framework and block the rotation of the TPE moiety, whereas the diffusion of mesitylene is not favorable.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 Emission intensity of Zn2Cl4Py-TPE in the presence of a variety of aromatic VOCs. Reproduced with permission from ref. 96, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2016. |
Similar to the detection of VOCs, another important class of compounds is organic amines, which are widely used in several industries such as pesticides, pharmaceuticals and tobacco.98 However, the environmental and public health hazards caused by organic amines cannot be overlooked. This concern is one of the frontier research fields in the scientific community. Huang and co-workers strategically developed an AIE luminogen-active linker, TPPE, for the construction of CuI-based MOFs towards the “turn-on” detection of ammonia.99 In this network, the ligand TPPE acts as a receptor rather than transducer. The emission of the MOF is a linker-based emission and when the MOF was exposed to ammonia vapor, its emission peak was red-shifted. This illustrates that the ammonia vapor interacted with TPPE. The mechanism of sensing was established with the help of GCMC and DFT study. The suitable supramolecular interaction between the receptor and analyte restricted the free rotation of the AIEgen component. This reduced the non-radiative decay of the MOFs, resulting in the “turn-on” emission.
Xing and co-workers reported the synthesis of a triazine-based porous copper-based MOF, Cu-TBDA, for the detection of o-phenylenediamine (OPD).100 Interestingly, the MOF showed a concentration-dependent luminescence “turn-on” and “turn-off” response for OPD. The Cu-TBDA MOF showed an emission peak at 430 nm under excitation at 345 nm. Upon screening of the fluorescence intensity with various aromatic amines, it displayed the highest luminescence intensity for OPD (Fig. 10).
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 (a) FL intensity of Cu-TBDA with a variety of amines and (b) recognition of OPD by Cu-TBDA coated on a strip paper, and then different concentrations of OPD were added under UV light 365 nm. Reproduced with permission from ref. 100, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2021. |
Given that the sensitivity of Cu-TBDA is concentration dependent, the authors carefully examined the effect of the concentration of OPD on the luminescent intensity of Cu-TBDA. It was revealed that the addition of 0–200 μL of OPD caused the luminescence intensity of OPD to remarkably increase. Interestingly, the emission peak in this case appeared at 550 nm in place of 430 nm. This illustrates the existence of effective interaction between OPD and Cu-TBDA. According to the linear relation between the lower concentration of OPD and the luminescence intensity, the calculated LOD was found to be 5.00 μM. Remarkably, after the addition of more than 200 μL OPD, fluorescence intensity diminished. The detection of OPD was also achieved through a colorimetric response. A paper strip was coated with Cu-TBDA, and then different concentrations of OPD were added. The color of the strip paper gradually became brighter (Fig. 11). The bathochromic shift in the emission peak in the presence of OPD indicates that the porous network plays an important role. This was further confirmed by the addition of OPD to the free ligand, where the fluorescence intensity of the ligand did not change. Thus, the porous network enabled effective interactions between OPD and the MOF. OPD is electron rich and the Cu2+ metal ion in MOF is d9, i.e., electron-deficient moiety. Therefore, the smooth PET process occurs by the transfer of electrons from OPD to the vacant d orbital on the Cu2+ ion. Simultaneously, the strong interaction between OPD and the MOF inhibits the free rotation of the –NH2 group, developing a stable planar network and enhancing the extent of conjugation. Therefore, upon the addition of OPD, the luminescence intensity of Cu-TBDA is largely augmented.
Although some MOF-based sensors employed the paper strip methodology for the detection of analytes, the fabrication of MOFs as membranes for the recognition of particular analytes is also an exciting approach in the field of MOF-based sensors. In this regard, Fan and co-workers published an interesting work, where they developed two copper-based MOFs with two different oxidation states of metal ions.101 Interestingly, the MOF membrane showed the “turn-on” detection of p-arsanilic acid. The Cu(II)-tpt-on-Cu(I)-tpt membrane was fabricated via a layer-by-layer method. Firstly, by using a one-pot methodology, the Cu(I)-tpt layer was developed on a Cu2O nanostructure, and then with the help of the liquid-phase epitaxy method, a second layer of Cu(II)-tpt layer was developed on the Cu(I)-tpt layer (Fig. 11). Actually, the Cu(II)-tpt-on-Cu(I)-tpt membrane was luminescent in nature, and when it adsorbed the poisonous Cr2O72−, it typically induced the fluorescence quenching of the membrane. Afterwards, in the presence of p-arsanilic acid, the membrane displayed a “turn-on” luminescent response. Therefore, the adsorption of Cr2O72− led to the highly sensitive recognition of p-arsanilic acid with an LOD of 0.0566 μg L−1.
The mechanism of sensing is very interesting and the role of Cr2O72− is very important. The Cu(II) ion in Cu(II)-tpt-on-Cu(I)-tpt is electro-positive and can adsorb Cr2O72− in the rhombic channel of the Cu(II)-tpt layer. Then, Cu(I)-tpt participates in the sensing. After the adsorption of Cr2O72−, the membrane showed the luminescence quenching phenomenon. This is because the excitation spectrum of Cu(I)-tpt perfectly overlapped with the absorption spectrum of Cr2O72−. Thus, Cr2O72− captured all the light in the solution and there was no opportunity for the excitation of Cu(I)-tpt. In presence of p-arsanilic acid, an oxidation-reduction reduction occurred, where the reduction of Cr2O72− to Cr3+ is attributed to the electron-donating power of the amino group of p-arsanilic acid. Concomitantly, the oxidation of the benzenoid amine (–NH2) of p-arsanilic acid to quinoid imine (–N+) occurred. Consequently, the membrane showed a luminescence enhancement. This sensing mechanism was further supported by the XPS analysis, which demonstrated the existence of a Cr3+ ion (peaks at 576.9 eV and 587.3 eV) and quinoid imine (–N
+, N1s peak at 401.3 eV) during the sensing mechanism. The presence of the amino group of p-arsanilic acid is crucial for the “turn-on” recognition of p-arsanilic acid.
The utilization of chiral molecule is very significant in several fields including the chemical, pharmaceutical, food additive, agrochemical, and biomedical industries. The enantiomers from the same molecule act in different ways, and surprisingly a specific isomer may have a negative impact on the living body. For instance, L-lactic acid is used as a food additive, whereas the D-lactic acid has adverse effects on humans.102 Therefore, the detection of enantiomers is vital. Zhang and co-workers synthesized homochiral MOF nanosheets (HMOF-3-NS) for the “turn-on” detection of hydroxyl carboxylic enantiomers.103 Initially, they synthesized a homochiral 2D MOF (HMOF-3) from the chiral ligand R,R-CHCAIP, bpy and zinc salt. Then, the exfoliation of HMOF-3 though a solvent-assisted sonication process afforded HMOF-3-NS. The free ligand R,R-CHCAIP and HMOF-3-NS in acetonitrile showed an emission wavelength at 430 and 435 nm, respectively, upon excitation at 325 nm. The luminescence in HMOF-3-NS is due to the n → π* transition. Interestingly, the luminescence intensity of HMOF-3-NS in acetonitrile was significantly enhanced in presence of R and S-mandelic acid. The fluorescence augmentation caused by R-mandelic acid was less than that by S-mandelic acid in comparison to the initial intensity of HMOF-3-NS (Fig. 12).
![]() | ||
Fig. 12 Luminescence spectra of HMOF-3-NS with R-mandelic (a) and S-mandelic (b) in acetonitrile solvent. Reproduced with permission from ref. 103, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2021. |
With the help of Benesi–Hildebrand plots, the calculated KBH value of HMOF-3 with R- and S-mandelic acids was found to be 3.7 × 104 M−1 and 9.9 × 104 M−1, respectively. These values strongly suggest the efficient interaction between the MOF networks with the analytes. The luminescence enhancement of HMOF-3-NS due to the decomposition of the framework was ruled out based on the well-matched PXRD peak pattern of the recovered HMOF-3-NS after sensing with the pristine HMOF-3-NS. Thus, the only possibility is the existence of strong host–guest interaction during the sensing event. The surface of HMOF-3-NS is exposed with numerous interaction sites such as pyridine N from bpy, carboxylic acid and acylamino group of the main ligand, and coordinated water molecules to the zinc metal ions. These interaction sites can induce supramolecular interaction (hydrogen bonding) with the analytes (Fig. 13). Consequently, HMOF-3-NS and the analyte come in close proximity for the PET effect to occur very smoothly. HMOF-3-NS acts as an electron acceptor and α-hydroxyl carboxylic behaves as an electron donor. Thus, the PET effect occurs from the LUMO of the analyte to the LUMO of HMOF-3-NS, resulting in the “turn-on” luminescence enhancement of HMOF-3-NS. This mechanism was further justified by DFT. The versatile sensing capability of HMOF-3-NS towards other hydroxyl carboxylic enantiomers was also demonstrated by the sensitive detection of D/L-lactic acid and D/L-tartaric acid. Remarkably, HMOF-3-NS could also detect D/L-tryptophan and D/L-alanine.
![]() | ||
Fig. 13 Geometrical optimization of the structures between HMOF-3-NS R-mandelic acid (a) and S-mandelic acid (b). Reproduced with permission from ref. 103, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2021. |
Organic solvent molecules are also considered a subclass of VOCs. The rapid industrial development globally, particularly in the chemical, pharmaceutical, and drug industry, has resulted in a significant increase in the use of solvents. In this case, although the outmost care is taken in handling the toxic solvent molecules, the safety issues and negative health effects of these solvent molecules are still a major concern. Some solvents have a low boiling point and easily evaporate into the atmosphere. During inhalation, humans are negatively affected by these solvent molecules, where direct and even indirect contact with these solvents molecules can cause several adverse health effects. Thus, their monitoring is critical. In this regard, MOFs are very effective, where their “turn-on” detection is essential for their practical application.104,105
For example, formaldehyde (HCHO) is a very simple aldehyde molecule and widely used in several chemical reactions. However, despite its many advantages, formaldehyde is very toxic to human health. Banerjee and co-workers showed the “turn-on” detection of HCHO in solution and the vapour phase using a Cd-based MOF, CMERI-1.106 Moreover, for its real-time application, its detection applicability for HCHO was also demonstrated in a food sample. The CMERI-1 MOF showed a weak emission at 430 nm upon excitation at 350 nm. The reason for the weak emission is possible owing to the intra-ligand charge transfer in the MOF network. Fluorescence titration of CMERI-1 with HCHO demonstrated that its emission peak at 430 nm regularly increased with the bathochromic shift. The enhancement in fluorescence is due to the formation of an imine bond (–CN–) between dangling –NH2 moiety in the framework and HCHO. Consequently, the inhibition of the PET effect occurred, resulting in the restoration of fluorescence. Subsequently, to detect the HCHO in the vapour phase, a hydrogel MOF composite membrane was developed using PVA and CMERI-1, which showed the detection of HCHO within a minute (Fig. 14). The LOD value for the detection of HCHO was found to be 0.62 μM (0.019 ppm).
![]() | ||
Fig. 14 (a) Gel composite kept inside the experimental set up (inside circle), (b) gel composite inside formaldehyde vapour, (c) luminescence of gel appeared in the presence of formaldehyde vapour and (d) after 30 minute exposure of the gel composite to formaldehyde vapour. Reproduced with permission from ref. 106, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2021. |
Recently, Mandal and co-workers synthesized {[Zn2(oxdz)2(tpbn)]·14H2O}n (1) for the “turn-on” detection of acetyl acetone and water solvent molecules.107 The emission spectrum of the MOF revealed the maximum peak at 390 nm under excitation at 310 nm. This is due to the π–π* and n–π* transitions. Further the MOF showed diverse luminescence intensities in polar protic and polar aprotic solvents. When this MOF was treated with a variety of ketone molecules, it was found that its luminescence intensity was significantly enhanced with acetylacetone and the emission peak at 390 nm progressively increased upon the addition of acetylacetone with a blue shift (Fig. 15). Interestingly, this MOF also displayed the detection of water in a variety of organic solvents. The strong affinity between the pores in its walls (carboxylate oxygen) and the water molecules established a strong hydrogen bonding interaction, and thereby the energy transfer from the MOF to O–H bond oscillators decreased. Subsequently, the fluorescence intensity of the MOF improved. The sharp selectivity and high sensitivity of this MOF towards acetylacetone was well-justified by calculating the binding constant between the analyte and MOF with the help of the Benesi–Hildebrand plot. The KBH was determined to be 1.131 × 104 M−1, signifying the resilient interaction between the analyte and MOF. Further, the DFT experiment disclosed the operation of the PET effect from the LUMO of acetyl acetone to the LUMO of H2oxdz, resulting in the enhancement of the fluorescence intensity.
![]() | ||
Fig. 15 (a) Emission spectra of the MOF after the gradual addition of acetyl acetone and (b) plot of intensity against concentration of 1 in the presence of a variety of ketones. Reproduced with permission from ref. 107, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2022. |
Wu and co-workers synthesized Eu-HODA for the selective and sensitive “turn-on” recognition of methanol in the presence other polar protic solvents (Fig. 16).108 When this MOF was excited at 305 nm, the emission peak was dominant at 614 nm (5D0 → 7F2) due the electrical dipole of Eu-HODA. This luminescence intensity largely changed in the presence of a variety of solvents and a significant enhancement was observed for methanol solvent (3.1-fold increment). Table 1 illustrates the various MOF-based “turn-on” probes for the recognition of a variety of neutral molecules including solvents.
![]() | ||
Fig. 16 (a) Emission of Eu-HODA gradual increased upon the addition of methanol and (b) comparison of the luminescent intensity of Eu-HODA in methanol with respect to other solvents. Reproduced with permission from ref. 108, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2016. |
MOFs | The metal in node/SBU | λ excitation (nm) | λ emission (nm) | Nature of analyte | LOD | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
IRMOF-3(–N3) | Zn | 395 | 430 | H2S | 28.3 μM | 140 |
UiO-66@NO2 | Zr | 334 | 436 | H2S | 188 μM | 141 |
CAU-10-N3 | Al | 330 | 405 | H2S | 2.65 μM, | 142 |
Tb3+@Cu-MOF | Tb | 280 | 489, 544, 585 and 620 | H2S | 1.20 μM | 143 |
FeIII-MIL-88-NH2 | Fe | 333 | H2S | 10 μM | 144 | |
DUT-52-(NO2)2 | Zr | 390 | 474 | H2S | 20 μM | 145 |
Zr(TBAPy)5(TCPP) | Zr | 365 | H2S gas and its derivatives S2− | 1 ppb | 146 | |
Al-MIL-53-NO2 MMMs | Al | 396 | 466 | H2S | 92.31 μM | 147 |
MOF-5-NH2 | Zn | 365 | SO2 gas | 0.168 ppm | 148 | |
Al-MIL-53-NO2 | Al | 339 | H2S | 69.3 μM | 149 | |
Sm-MOF@Fe3+ | Sm | 300 | 562, 595, 643 and 706 | TBHQ | 5.6 ng mL−1 | 150 |
UiO-66-MA | Zr | H2S | 3.3 nM | 151 | ||
RhB/UiO-66-N3 | Zr | 302 | 425 and 575 | H2S | 29.9 μM | 152 |
Eu3+/Cu2+@Znpda | Zn | 408 | 614 and 386 | H2S | 1.45 μM | 153 |
3 ∞[Ce (Im)3ImH]·ImH | Ce | 366 | 422 | H2O, O2, and CH2Cl2 | 154 | |
[Sm2(abtc)1.5(H2O)3(DMA)]·H2O·DMA | Sm | 400 | 612 | Benzyl alcohol and benzaldehyde | 155 | |
[Me2NH2][EuL(H2O)]·1.5H2O | Eu | 324 | 591, 613, 649 and 697 | Methanol | 156 | |
SB1, SB2, SB3 and SB4 | Cd | 365 | Water | 157 | ||
Zn(hpi2cf)(DMF)(H2O) | Zn | 365 | 463 and 493 | Water | <0.05% v/v (ZnO-based film) | 158 |
QG-loaded MOF | Zn | 424 nm | Water in ethanol and DMF | 0.015% and 0.030% | 159 | |
SXU-4 | Cd | 365 | 430 | DMSO | 160 | |
{[Y0.9Tb0.1Mn1.5(PDA)3(H2O)3]·3.5H2O} | Y and Mn | 280 | 315,491, 545, 586 and 623 | Trace water in EtOH, CH3OH, CH3CN, THF and n-heptane | 1.12% (v/v), 0.47% (v/v), 0.04% (v/v), 0.13% (v/v) and 0.53% (v/v) | 161 |
[(UO2)(H2DTATC)] (HNU-39) | U | 373 | 430 | 162 | ||
Tb3+@Ag-BTC | Ag | 365 | 494, 547, 587 and 622 | HCHO | 1.9 mM | 163 |
[In(BDC-NH2)(OH)]n | In | 350 | 429 | H2O2 | 0.42 μM | 164 |
Zr-UiO-66-B(OH)2 | Zr | 328 | 425 | H2O2 | 165 | |
PSM-1 and PSM-2 | Cd | 335 | ∼435 and ∼430 | 1,4-Dioxane | 1.079 ppm and 2.487 ppm | 166 |
MIL-100(In)@Eu3+/Cu2+ | In | 285 | 594, 619, and 699 | H2S | 0.535 ppm | 167 |
Fe-MIL-88 | Fe | 326 | 445 | GSH, Cys and Hcy | 30 nM, 40 nM, and 40 nM | 168 |
Fe-MIL-88-H2O2-o-phenylenedia-mine | Fe | 433 | 576 | Dopamine | 46 nm | 169 |
[Cu(mal) (bpy)]·2H2O | Cu | 480 | 518 | Glycine and serine | 0.81 μg mL−1 and 1.51 μg mL−1 | 170 |
[Cd(μ3-abtz)·2I]}n | Cd | 242 | 350 | Dopamine | 57 nM | 171 |
Ag@Au nanoprism-MOF | Zn | 532 | 550 | Glucose | 0.038 mM | 172 |
CD-MONT-2 | Pb | 330 | 526 | Uric acid | 4.3 μM | 173 |
Cu-BTC/Tb | Cu | 238 | 488, 545, 583, and 621 | Amyloid β-peptide (Aβ1-40) | 0.3 nM | 174 |
RhB@Cu-BTC | Cu | 365 | 575 | L-Cysteine | 0.702 μmol L−1 | 175 |
Zr-MOF; UiO-68-An/Ma | Zr | 375 | 420 | Biothiols (Cys, Hcy, and GSH) | Low concentration of 50 μmol L−1 | 176 |
ZJU-108 | Zn | 323 | 419 | Tryptophan | 42.9 nM | 177 |
NH2-MOF-76(Eu) | Eu | 385 | 400 | Dipicolinic acid | 3.8 mM | 178 |
CrO42−@Cd-MOFs | Cd | 358 | 414 | Ascorbic acid | 7.27 ppm | 179 |
ZIF-67 | Co | 540 | 585 | Biothiols | 31 nM | 180 |
Eu3+@Ga-MOF(MIL-61) | Ga | 370 | 614 | Ciprofloxacin | 2.4 μg mL−1 | 181 |
RSPh@EuBTC | Eu | 306 | 546, 592, 615 and 692 | DPA | 0.52 μM | 182 |
Eu3+@[(Me)4N]2[Pb6K6(m-BDC)9(OH)2]·H2O | Pb and K | 377 | 612 | Fleroxacin | 43.91 ng mL−1 | 183 |
UiO-67-sbdc | 340 | 465 | Glutathione (GSH) | 107.2 μM | 184 | |
Eu3+/Cu2+@UiO-67-bpydc | Zr | 372 | 592, 615, 651 and 700 | GSH | 54.3 nM | 185 |
Cu(HBTC)-1 nanosheets | Cu | 518 | Oxytetracycline | 0.40 μg L−1 | 186 | |
[(CH3)2NH2]3[(In3Cl2)(bpdc)5]·(H2O)5(DMF)2.5 | In | 340 | 410 | Cysteine and 1-butanethiol | 5.71 × 10−4 M and 4.38 × 10−4 M | 187 |
[Tb0.43Eu1.57(1,4-phda)3(H2O)] (H2O)2 | Tb and Eu | 260 | 544 and 614 | Dipicolinic acid | 5.9 nM | 188 |
FCS-3 | Zn | 400 | 450 | Fluoroquinolone | 0.52 μM | 189 |
UiO-HQCA-Al | Zr | 339 | 438 | Creatinine | 4.7 nM | 190 |
Eu-in-BTEC | Eu | 365 | 526 and 617 | Doxycycline | 47 nM | 191 |
Tb-MOF | Tb | 394 | 506 | Dicarboxylic acid | 2.4 μM | 192 |
Eu@ZIF-90-PA | Zn | 463 | 579 | Flumequine | 0.24 ppm | 193 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 17 Detection of gossypol via the luminescence “turn-on” effect in the NIR region by Yb-NH2-TPDC MOF. Reproduced with permission from ref. 110, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2020. |
The simulation study showed that the hydroxyl group of Gsp forms strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding with the framework, which brings them in close proximity. Consequently, Gsp sensitizes (antenna effect) the Yb3+ ion through a sequential charge transfers process, i.e., from the singlet state of Gsp to the triplet level of NH2-TPDC, and then to the triplet level of Gsp, followed by the transfer of energy to Yb3+. The LOD for Gsp by Yb-NH2-TPDC was calculated to be 25 μg mL−1.
Amino acids are the basic building blocks for proteins in the living body.111,112 In the food industry, arginine tends to release urea by fermentation. However, if the arginine content is high, then a high amount of urea will be released, which reacts with ethanol to produce urethane, posing carcinogenic threat to human health.113 Thus, for the detection of arginine, Zheng and co-workers synthesized uranyl-based MOFs, (UO2)(nip)(2,2′-bpy) (MOF 1) and (H2bpp)·[(UO2)2-(nip)3]·H2O (MOF-2), under solvothermal reaction conditions.114 When MOF-1 and MOF-2 were treated with several amino acids, it was revealed that the fluorescence intensity of both MOFs showed a fluorescence “turn-on” enhancement in the presence of arginine (Fig. 18). The LOD values for arginine by these two MOFs were found to be 1.06 × 10−6 mol L−1 and 6.42 × 10−6 mol L−1, respectively. The calculations were based on the linear relation between the lower concentrations of the analytes with the emission peak at 515 nm of the MOFs.
![]() | ||
Fig. 18 (a) Fluorescence intensity of MOF-1 with various amino acid and (b) fluorescence intensity of MOF-2 with various amino acids. Reproduced with permission from ref. 114, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2020. |
The shape of the emission spectra of the MOFs changed in the presence of arginine during the sensing process. This indicates that there was an obvious interaction between the MOFs and arginine. Arginine is a basic amino acid, which contains a guanidine part. This moiety can be protonated, and resulting ionic species can establish an electrostatic interaction with the MOF. This interaction is responsible for the “turn-on” effect on the luminescence intensity. Furthermore, this postulation was proven upon the interaction between guanidine carbonate solutions and the MOFs. Interestingly, the emission peak of both MOFs was considerable enhanced. Therefore, the interaction between the guanidine part of arginine and the MOFs was the responsible for the sensing of arginine.
An abnormal concentration of histidine in the human body hampers several neurological activities. However, the recognition of histidine especially in the complex biological system is challenging. Liu and co-workers synthesised a highly luminescent Eu3+ ion-based MOF composite (Eu/Bi-MOF) via the post-synthetic insertion of Eu3+ in the pore of Bi-MOF.115 This new Eu/Bi-MOF composite could selectively detect histidine via the luminescence “turn-on” process among several other amino acids. Interestingly, Eu/Bi-MOF showed strong red fluorescence due to the strong sensitization of Eu3+ by the ligand through the antenna effect. However, in water, the transfer of energy from the linker to Eu3+ in Eu/Bi-MOF was significantly hindered. Consequently, the composite became non-luminescent. When the luminescence titration of the composite was carried out with histidine in water, the fluorescence intensity of the composite recovered. In the presence of histidine, the aromatic surface area of histidine forms a π⋯π interaction with the aromatic surface area of the ligand. Consequently, the transfer of energy from the linker to Eu3+ in Eu/Bi-MOF is rejuvenated, which results in the fluorescence “turn-on” response of the composite. Besides the fluorometric response, the detection of histidine by Eu/Bi-MOF was also observed by a colorimetric response. The LOD for histidine was found to be 0.18 μM.
Besides the detection of basic amino acids, MOF sensors have been used significantly for the detection of acidic amino acids.116,117 Similar to other amino acids, aspartic acid (Asp) plays a great role in the living organisms such as myocardial function and metabolism in mammals.118 Thus, an abnormal concentration of Asp poses a threat to human health such as stroke and hepatic problems.119 Liu and co-workers post-synthetically incorporated Cu2+ and Tb3+ ions in a Zn-MOF to deliver Cu/Tb@Zn-MOF, which displayed the selective and sensitive “turn-on” recognition of Asp.120 The incorporation of the Tb3+ ion in the Zn-MOF resulted in the characteristic emission peak of the Tb3+ ion due to the antenna effect. When the Cu2+ ion was embedded in Tb@Zn-MOF, the Cu/Tb@Zn-MOF composite showed the quenching of fluorescence. This was due to the effective LMCT process from the ligand to Cu2+ ion (strong coordination between Cu2+ ion and S site of ligand), which reduced the charge transfer from the ligand to the Tb3+ ion. This Cu2+ ion and the size effect of the pore acted as a strong interaction site for Asp, resulting in the selective and sensitive detection of Asp. Given that the Cu2+ ion interacted with Asp, the LMCT process from the ligand to Cu2+ ion decreased. Simultaneously, the antenna effect from the ligand to Tb3+ ion was revived, leading to a “turn-on” luminescence response. The interaction between the Cu2+ ion and Asp was confirmed by the XPS analysis. The composite material showed the Cu 2p1 peak at 953.87 eV, and after treatment with Asp, this peak appeared at 953.03 eV. This shifting of the Cu 2p1 peak to a lower energy illustrates the weak interaction between Cu2+ and Asp.
MOFs have also been used for the detection of antibiotic molecules.121–123 With the increase in the population globally, the intake of antibiotics has significantly increased, which has a negative effect on the environment.124 Also, the side effects associated with antibiotics negatively impact human health and cause several diseases.125,126 More importantly, taking antibiotics a for longer time will result in the development of antibiotic resistance in the body, which is fatal. In this regard, Neogi and co-workers strategically devised a highly luminescent porous zinc-based framework, CSMCRI-2, possessing free basic amino groups.127 The activated MOF network could detect the antibiotics sulfadiazine (SDZ) and adenosine monophosphate (AMP) through a luminescence “turn-on” fashion with an increase in fluorescence intensity by almost 30 and 13.8 fold, respectively. The LOD values for SDZ and AMP were calculated to be 65 nM and 10 nM, respectively. The detection of these analytes was also realized through a colorimetric response. Besides the experimental evidence, the mechanism of sensing was established by deep theoretical investigation. The LUMO of SDZ is energetically higher than that of the MOF. Therefore, the transfer of electrons occurs from the LUMO of SDZ to the LUMO of the MOF, causing a luminescence enhancement in the MOF. The presence of free amino linkers in the MOF network resulted in intermolecular hydrogen bonding interaction with the analytes, which bring them in close proximity. Thus, the charge or transfer of electrons is possible between the MOF and analyte.
The recognition of antibiotic residue in food samples is imperative for real-time application. In this regard, Ghasemi and co-workers deliberately prepared a zirconium-based luminescent MOF coated with MIP polymer as a guest recognition site for the “turn-on” detection of chloramphenicol (CAP) antibiotic residue in food samples (honey and milk).128 The porous structure and creation of a specific binding site in the composite resulted in the selective sensing of CAP. The LOD value for CAP was 0.013 μg L−1. The mechanism of sensing for the detection of CAP is as follows: the coated MIP on ZrMOF interacts strongly with the CAP analyte. ZrMOF shows an emission peak at 440 nm and the linker ATA in the free state displays an emission peak at 436 nm. This indicates that the emission of the MOF is a ligand-based emission. Interestingly, the emission of ATA in the free state is almost 2.5-times higher than that of the MOF. This is due to the LMCT from the ligand ATA to the Zr–O clusters in the MOF. When CAP was added to the system, it prohibited the LMCT from the ligand to metal clusters, resulting in an enhancement in the emission intensity of ATA. The IR analysis was helpful to justify the sensing mechanism. In the presence of CAP, the carbonyl group of CAP forms a stronger interaction with the Zr4+ ion in the Zr–O clusters than with ATA. Consequently, the interaction between the Zr–O clusters and ATA declines, and hence the LMCT process almost stops. Therefore, the fluorescence intensity of ATA in ZrMOF is augmented. The diverse MOFs with their crucial features towards the “turn-on” recognition of several types of biomarkers and biomolecules are presented in Table 1.
Zhou and co-workers reported an excellent work for the “turn-on” recognition of nitrogen-rich heterocyclic compounds (NRHCs) using a cobalt-based MOF (Co-TCPE), which was derived from the AIE-active ligand H4TCPE.134 Although this MOF contained highly conjugated linkers, it was almost non-fluorescent (signal off) because of the presence of the Co3 scaffold, which acted as a quencher (LMCT) for the emission of AIE-MOF. The Co-TCPE MOF showed an emission peak at 515 nm upon excitation at 375 nm, which remained unchanged over a wide pH range (3 to 12). This indicates that the MOF has the potential to act as an efficient sensor under different conditions. Interestingly, when Co-TCPE was titrated with NRHCs such as NTO (single ring) and DNBT (dual ring), the luminescence intensity of the MOF was significantly enhanced (Fig. 19). In contrast, polyamines and non-energetic heterocyclic molecules did not affect the fluorescence intensity of the MOF much (Fig. 19).
![]() | ||
Fig. 19 (a) Intensity ratio of Co-TCPE in the presence of a variety of nitrogen-rich organic compounds (compound numbers 1 to 19 in the x-axis are given in the abbreviations list) and (b) illustration of competitive coordination of Co-TCPE with NRHCs. Reproduced with permission from ref. 134, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2022. |
Additionally, the increase in fluorescence intensity caused by the double-ring NRHCs was much greater than that by the single-ring NRHCs. The mechanism for fluorescence the “turn-on” phenomenon by NRHCs was explained based on PXRD, TEM, mass and NMR studies. The PXRD pattern of the recovered Co-TCPE showed the absence of the signature peak at 7.56°, indicating that the framework collapsed. Further, the NMR and mass spectrometry study revealed the formation of a complex between the linker H4TCPE and DNBT (dual-ring NRHCs). Therefore, all these experimental evidence suggested that upon the addition of NRHCs, the deformation or collapse of the MOF occurred through the competitive coordination substitution. Consequently, the H4TCPE linker was released from the MOF network and became self-aggregated (restricted intramolecular motion) in the water medium, which caused aggregation-induced emission. The detection of NRHCs was also realized through colorimetric changes to yellow (Fig. 19b).
Li and co-workers published an excellent work based on the “turn-on” detection of explosive molecules (aliphatic nitro-organics) with the help of the dye@bio-MOF-1 composite.135 The aperture channels of the MOF were decorated with free amine functional moieties, which induced non-covalent bonding with the incoming (guest) molecules. This facilitated the encapsulation of nitro explosive molecules (Fig. 20).
![]() | ||
Fig. 20 Dye@bio-MOF-1 showing luminescence “turn-on” detection for aliphatic nitro compounds. Reproduced with permission from ref. 135, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2022. |
The composite showed a “turn-off” luminescence response for aromatic nitro explosive molecules. On the contrary, the framework demonstrated the luminescence “turn-on” phenomenon with aliphatic nitro explosive molecules. After the inclusion of dye molecules inside the MOF cavity, very limited space was available in the MOF. Thus, it was difficult for the aromatic nitro compounds to enter the pores of the composite, whereas the smaller aliphatic nitro compounds could easily enter the cavity and occupied the available space to induce host–guest interactions. Due to this space confinement, the vibrations and torsions of the dye molecules were restricted, and consequently the nonradiative decay decreased. Thus, an increment in fluorescence (confinement-induced enhancement) was observed.
With the increasing world population, the demand for the food has significantly increased. Thus, the farmers are focused on increasing the productivity from cultivation. In this case, large amounts of pesticides are utilized in the agro field. Although pesticides are important to enhance the crop productivity, they profoundly affect human health.136 Thus, smart sensors are necessary for the monitoring of pesticide molecules. Neogi and co-workers detected the pesticides DEP and IPT by using de-solvated CSMCRI-8 through the fluorescence “turn-on” mechanism with the LOD values of 79.8 nM and 226 nM, respectively.137
Moorthy and co-workers synthesized a bisimidazole-based tetracarboxylic acid ligand (H4ANTBI) having anthracene in its core, and using this ligand, they constructed a cadmium-based MOF, Cd-ANTBI. This MOF showed the sensitive “turn-on” detection of toxic nerve agent mimics.138 Due to the self-quenching of the MOF in the crystalline state, the fluorescence intensity of the MOF significantly diminished. The solvent aided the exfoliation of the MOF, affording 2D MOF nanosheets (MOFNS), which exhibited a significant enhancement in fluorescence intensity. Interestingly, MOFNS displayed the “turn-on” recognition of nerve agent mimics (diethyl chlorophosphate, DCP) with an LOD of 0.52 ppm.
The mechanism of “turn-on” emission in the presence of DCP is presented in Fig. 21. The protonation reaction between the imidazolium moiety of the linker and the DCP, followed by nucleophilic attack leads to the structural modification of the linker in MOFNS. This ligand structural orientation induces rigidification of the overall framework by inhibiting the torsional motions of the benzene ring. Consequently, the deactivation pathways are block, and a hence fluorescence enhancement is observed. With an increase in the concentration of DCP in the experimental solution, the luminescence intensity proportionally increased because the rigidification was enhanced in the linker.
![]() | ||
Fig. 21 Turn-on mechanism for the detection of DCP. Reproduced with permission from ref. 138, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2021. |
Hydrazine is also another hazardous compound that is widely used in several fields such organic synthesis, pharmaceuticals, and catalysts. Because of its large enthalpy value, it is used as a fuel in space craft and rockets. However, although it has lots of potential value-added qualities, it is regarded as carcinogenic and toxic. Thus, the detection of hydrazine is essential. Biswas and co-workers reported the selective and sensitive detection of hydrazine through the “turn-on” luminescence process using a zirconium-based MOF, Zr-UiO-66-(OCOCH3)2.139 They judiciously used the H2BDC-(OCOCH3)2 ligand to introduce the acetoxy functionality as a guest reaction site in the zirconium framework. The detection of hydrazine was also visualized through the naked eye.
The sensing mechanism is presented in Fig. 22. The nucleophilic attack by the hydrazine occurs on the acetoxy functionality, which is then converted to a hydroxyl moiety. Therefore, the H2BDC-(OCOCH3)2 linker is transformed to H2BDC-(OH)2. The enhancement in the luminescence of the MOF is due to the formation of H2BDC-(OH)2. The generation of the hydroxyl group was also further supported by the IR and 1H NMR analysis. Table 1 presents different MOFs for the “turn-on” detection of hazardous entities and high-energy compounds.
Das and coworkers reported the preparation of a 3D porous anionic stable cobalt-based MOF, {[Me2NH2]0.5[Co(DATRz)0.5(NH2BDC)]·Gx}n, for the discriminating “turn-on” recognition of Al3+ ion.196 The MOF network was nicely oriented with free –NH2 groups (Fig. 23), which interact efficiently with the guest metal ions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 23 (a) Three-dimensional packing of MOF, which contains Me2NH2+ in its rectangular cavity and (b) decoration of guest interaction–NH2 sites in the framework. |
The MOF displayed the maximum emission peak at 430 nm (blue emission) upon excitation at 340 nm, which is due to the intra and inter LLCT occurring in its framework. Upon screening the luminescence intensity of this MOF with various metal ions, it was observed that its emission intensity at 430 nm sharply increased in the presence of Al3+ ions. This illustrates that the MOF showed unique selectivity and sensitivity for Al3+ ions with an LOD of 17.5 ppb. The rectangular large cavity of the MOF consists of a dimethyl ammonium cation (Me2NH2+), i.e., an ionic environment, which allows the facile transfer of metal ions through the cavity and forms a strong host–guest interaction. The mechanism for the sensing of Al3+ was explained based on the absorbance-caused fluorescence increment. The Al3+ ion embedded entity (Al3+@MOF) absorbs more excitation light than the free MOF and gets excited. From the excited level, the Al3+@MOF reaches the ground level by releasing a large amount of energy (wavelength), showing a “turn-on” luminescence response. The Al3+@MOF unit releases a larger amount of energy than the free MOF in the emission process. Further, the authors exhibited the detection of Al3+ using the paper strip method to make the sensing approach portable, convenient and economic.
Guo and co-workers synthesized a cadmium-based highly stable MOF, [Cd(3-NH2-pba)2]4·8DMF, under solvothermal conditions for the selective and sensitive “turn-on” detection of silver metal ions.197 The crystallographic investigation disclosed that the framework is decorated with basic amine functional moieties. The emission spectrum of the MOF revealed the maximum emission at 470 nm (blue emission) upon excitation at 322 nm. This emission is due to the π–π* transition in the organic ligand. The luminescence intensity of the MOF was quenched in water, thus it acted as a water sensor in ethanol solvent. Interestingly, when this MOF was treated with several metal ions in water medium, its emission intensity at 479 nm considerably increased (almost 50 times) in the presence of silver metal ions (Fig. 24).
![]() | ||
Fig. 24 (a) Fluorescence intensity of MOF in the presence of different metal ions in aqueous medium and (b) significant enhancement in the luminescent intensity of the MOF in the presence of silver metal ions (inset: colorimetric response of the MOF with silver ions). Reproduced with permission from ref. 197, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2021. |
The interaction between the amino group and Ag+ ion was confirmed by IR and XPS analysis. The IR spectrum showed the signature peaks for the amino group at 3230 and 1673 cm−1, which are vanished for Ag+@MOF. According to the XPS data, the N1s binding energy of the –NH2 group shifted from 399.2 eV for the MOF to 399.4 eV for Ag+@MOF. Further, the lifetime decay measurement indicated an increase in the lifetime of the excited state of Ag+@MOF (5.877 ns) compared to the simple MOF (3.803 ns). This study illustrated that the interaction between –NH2 and the Ag+ ion is very strong to overcome the luminescence quenching induced by the O–H oscillators of the water molecule. Besides the fluorometric method, the detection of silver ions was also investigated through a colorimetric response (Fig. 26).
Hong and co-workers described the synthesis of zinc-based porous 3D MOF, [Zn3(L3)2(bpy)], for the discriminating “turn-on” recognition of Cd2+ ions.198 Interestingly, the diffusion of Cd2+ ions into the pores of the MOF was directly visualized by two-photon confocal microscopy. Among a pool of several metal ions, the Cd2+ ion significantly enhanced the luminescence intensity (60 fold) of the framework compared to the free MOF. The mechanism of sensing was confirmed with the help of XPS. The L3 and bpy linkers contain nitrogen atoms in their backbone. The nitrogen atom of bpy is sterically congested given that it is linked with the metal ion (Zn2+ ion) to form the MOF network. The N1s peak position of the nitrogen atom of the L3 linker in the MOF slightly shifted to 398.63 eV (Cd2+@MOF) from 398.34 eV (MOF), indicating the interaction between the nitrogen atoms of the L3 linker with the Cd2+ ion. The XPS analysis of the O atoms (O1s peak) of the methoxy and carboxylate groups of the L3 linker in the free MOF and in the MOF in the presence of Cd2+ ions did not show any obvious change, which ruled out the interaction between the O atoms and Cd2+ ions.
Duan and co-workers synthesized an Eu3+-based MOF, [Eu2(L4)3(DMF)3] 2DMF·5H2O, for the detection of Cr3+ ions through luminescence recovery of the MOF material.199 In the MOF network, the anthracene moiety of the ligand stacked nicely, as confirmed by SCXRD, which reduced the emission intensity of the MOF.200 The H2L4 linker and MOF exhibited an emission peak at 460 and 475 nm under excitation at 365 nm, respectively. The emission intensity of the MOF indicated that is almost non-fluorescent in nature and its luminescence under a UV lamp was also not visible. The characteristic emission peak of the lanthanide ion in the MOF was not observed, which may be due to the presence of an anthracene moiety in the ligand of the MOF, acting as s triplet-state quencher (triplet–triplet annihilation). Consequently, the metal based luminescence was significantly reduced.201,202 Also, this MOF showed an extremely low ligand-based emission due to the self-absorption process, i.e., the absorption band of the MOF overlaps with its emission band. When the MOF was treated with various metal ions in aqueous medium, its luminescence intensity at 450 nm significantly increased for Cr3+ ions. Furthermore, the detection ability for Cr3+ ions remained unaffected in the presence of other metal ions with the LOD for Cr3+ ions of 7.52 × 10−8 M. The mechanism of sensing was well-established with the assistance of IR, SEM, XPS and UV visible analysis. The appearance of the free MOF and Cr(NO3)3-embedded MOF was the same in the SEM images. The atomic mapping of Cr(NO3)3@MOF showed the presence of five elements (carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, europium and chromium). This suggests that the Cr3+ metal ion was incorporated in its framework. The IR stretching vibration peak appeared at 1287 cm−1, which is the signature peak of NO2. This illustrated the successful encapsulation of the nitrate anion in the MOF to counter the charge balance of the chromium ion. Further, the interaction of the Cr3+ ion within the framework was confirmed by XPS. The UV-visible spectrum showed that in presence of Cr3+ ions, the self-absorption effect of Cr(NO3)3@MOF was greatly reduced compared to the free MOF, which indicates its strong luminescence response for Cr3+. Alternatively, its emission spectrum was red-shifted during the recognition process, signifying that apart from the reduction of the self-absorption effect, the ICT between the different aryl groups and/or the changes in the excitation-state energy levels largely contributed to the enhancement of the luminescent intensity of the MOF in presence of Cr3+.
Mercury is a lethal pollutant to the human body, which is present in the ecosystem through various anthropogenic activities and natural sources. Although the Hg2+ ion, as the inorganic form of mercury, is very dangerous, its organic form the methylmercury ion (CH3Hg+) is fatal. These two ions are generally accumulated in the human body through the food chain, causing serious health issues including cardiovascular, nerve, and kidney failure.203 Therefore, the selective and sensitive detection of these toxic species are very important, and particularly on-site cost-effective methods are desirable. Qu and co-workers synthesized a boric acid (BA)-functionalized Eu3+ ion-based MOF (BA-Eu-MOF) for the ultra-sensitive “turn-on” recognition of CH3Hg+ and Hg2+.204 Upon excitation at 275 nm, the BA-Eu-MOF displayed signature emission peaks at 620 (5D0 → 7F2) and 595 nm (5D0 → 7F1), which illustrate the occurrence of the antenna effect. However, the red emission of the complex was very weak in water medium, which is attributed to the electron-withdrawing nature of BA, deactivating the antenna effect. Upon the addition CH3Hg+ and Hg2+ ions, the C–B bond of BA is destroyed and the formation of a C–Hg bond occurs, i.e., transmetalation reaction occurs (Fig. 25). Therefore, the electron-withdrawing nature of BA is completely lost, and concomitantly the antenna effect of the ligand is revived, which boost the red emission.
![]() | ||
Fig. 25 Synthesis of BA-Eu-MOF and schematic presentation for the sensing of CH3Hg+ and Hg2+ through the transmetalation reaction, i.e., C–B bond of BA is ruptured and the formation of a C–Hg bond occurs. Reproduced with permission from ref. 204, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2020. |
Although the Fe3+ ion is a very important element in living organisms,205,206 its excess leads to harmful health effects such cardiac arrest and Alzheimer's disease.207,208 Hence, the detection and on-site monitoring of Fe3+ ions are critical. Zhang and co-workers used an AIE-active ligand (L5) for the construction of a stable cadmium-based luminescent MOF, [Cd(NDA)(L5)(H2O)2]n, for the discriminating sensitive recognition of Fe3+ ions in water medium through the fluorescence “turn-on” process.209 The emission peak of the MOF appeared at 440 nm upon excitation at 324 nm. When the MOF was treated with a large number of metal ions (Fig. 26), its emission intensity was considerably enhanced in the presence of Fe3+ ions with an LOD of 2.06 × 10−3 mM.
![]() | ||
Fig. 26 (a) Network of MOF showing π⋯π interaction between the parallel fluorene moiety and (b) selective detection turn-on detection of Fe3+ ions in aqueous medium. |
The PXRD pattern of the recovered MOF after the sensing of Fe3+ ion was exactly the same as that of the pristine MOF, which ruled out the degradation of the framework. XPS analysis of Fe3+@MOF showed two peaks at 726.4 eV and 713.9 eV, which are ascribed to the Fe 2p1/2 and Fe 2p3/2 configurations, respectively. This study directly suggests the presence of Fe3+ cation in the framework. The SCXRD data of the MOF revealed the existence of a π⋯π interaction (3.613 Å) between the parallel aryl moiety of the ligand. The authors suggested that the Fe3+ ion forms a π⋯cation⋯π-type interaction within the framework, which helps to transport electrons and enhances the emission intensity of the MOF.
Similar to other metal ions, the Mg2+ ion plays a significant role in the human body in several physiological processes, cell proliferation, activating membrane proteins and influencing biochemical processes.210,211 Consequently, an imbalance in Mg2+ ions can lead to several diseases including osteoporosis, diabetes, and coronary heart problems.212,213 Thus, the monitoring of the Mg2+ ion concentration is very important. In this regard, Han and co-workers reported the synthesis of a dye-entrapped magnetically active MOF, Fe3O4/RhB@Al-MOF, for the discriminating sensitive “turn-on” recognition of Mg2+ ions.214 This composite showed two emission peaks at 610 nm (from RhB) and 440 nm (Al-MOF) upon excitation at 330 nm. When the MOF composite was treated with a variety of metal ions, it selectively detected Mg2+ ions. Consequently, its emission peak at 440 nm increased, while the peak at 610 nm remained constant. The composite displayed an initial recognition time of about 90 s for Mg2+ ions and almost 5-fold enhancement in luminescence intensity with an LOD value for Mg2+ ions of 8 × 10−7 M. Further, the detection of Mg2+ ions was also exhibited in biosystems (HL-7702 and A375 cells). The mechanism of sensing was corroborated by the XPS analysis. The emission peak at 440 nm sharply increased, which indicates that Mg2+ efficiently interacts with the nitrogen element of the –NH2 group of the 2-ATA linker in the Al-MOF. This interaction permits facile energy transfer and enhances the ligand-based emission. According to the XPS data, the N1s peak of the 2-ATA linker in Fe3O4/RhB@Al-MOF appeared at 402.25 eV, which illustrates the coordination of Mg2+ with N of the –NH2 group. A list of the various MOFs and their vital features for the “turn-on” recognition of different types of cations is presented in Table 2.
MOFs | Metal ion in node/SBU | λ excitation (nm) | λ emission (nm) | Nature of analyte detects | LOD | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[Co(OBA)-(DATZ)0.5(H2O)] | Co | 283 | 407 | Al3+ | 57.5 ppb | 215 |
PCN-222-Pd(II) | Zr | 275 | 351 | Cu(II) | 50 nM | 216 |
UPC-17 | Ba | 330 | 546 | Fe3+ | 217 | |
[Cd3L2(μ-H2O)(H2O)]·3DMF·5H2O | Cd | 369 | 484 | Mg2+ | 0.021 μM | 218 |
NUM-2 | Zn | 324 | 377 | Al3+ | 0.10 ppm | 219 |
UiO-66-N![]() |
Zr | 342 | 468 | Cd2+ | 0.336 mM | 220 |
CTGU-1 | Tb | 595, 619, 654 and 703 | Eu3+/Dy3+ | 5 × 10−8 and 1 × 10−4 M | 221 | |
1 and 2 | Zn(1) and Cd(2) | 364 for 1 372 nm for 2 | 478 and 514 nm for both 1 and 2 | Al3+ and Cr3+ for 1, Al3+ and Cr3+ and Pb2+ for 2 | 222 | |
IRMOF-3 | Zn | 379 | 450 | Cr3+, Al3+, Ga3+ and In3+ | 0.293 ppm, 0.267 ppm, 0.598 ppm and 0.616 ppm | 223 |
Gold nanoclusters/Zn-MOF | Zn | 410 | 570 | Zn2+ | 6 nM | 224 |
Mg-TPP-DHBDC | Mg | 367 | 505 | Al3+ | 28 nM | 225 |
JXUST-1 | Cd | 354 | 404 | Al3+ | 0.048 ppm | 226 |
Cd-TCHO | Cd | 350 | 450 | Al3+ | 0.54 ppb | 227 |
JXUST-2 | Co | 394 | 530 | Fe3+, Cr3+, and Al3+ | 0.13 μM, 0.10 μM and 0.10 μM | 228 |
Zn2(BDC)2(DABCO) | Zn | 360 | 436 | Zn2+ | 0.7 μM | 229 |
Zn(NH2-bdc)(4,4′-bpy)] | Zn | 365 | 426 | Al3+ | 30 nM | 230 |
UiO-(OH)2@RhB | Zr | 420 | 583 | Al3+ | 10 nM | 231 |
[Cd4(NDC)3(4-Hptz)2(H2O)2]·H2O | Cd | 325 | 400 | Cr3+ | 0.164 μM | 232 |
[Zn(bimpy)(1,4-ndc)]·H2O | Zn | 370 | 422 | Fe3+ | 8.82 × 10−7 M | 233 |
Tb-TCPP | Tb | 428 | 652 | Al3+, Cr3+, and Fe3+ | 7.79 nM, 9.94 nM and 16.4 nM | 234 |
Cu-HBIBA | Cu | 337 | 460 | Bi3+ and Fe3+ | 43 nM and 0.16 mM | 235 |
Zn-DHNDC MOF | Zn | 350 | 367 | Al3+ and Fe3+ | 95 nM, 33 nM | 236 |
JXUST-5 | Zn | 365 | 420 | Al3+ and Ga3+ | 0.17 and 0.69 ppm | 237 |
JXUST-6 | Cd | 452 | 499 | Al3+ and Ga3+ | 0.081 and 0.047 ppm | 238 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 27 Installation of the fluorophore and the recognition site in the MOF for the selective sensing of CN−. |
Perborate is essential in daily life, which is present in detergent materials, cosmetics, and bleaching agents.245 Due to its low cost and oxidising property, it is widely used in industry and considered as an alternative to H2O2.246 Thus, because of the large use of perborate, it has become a common pollutant in drinking water and the environment. Biswas and co-workers synthesized an acetoxy-functionalized Al-based MOF, CAU-10-OCOCH3, for the selective and sensitive “turn-on” detection of perborate anions in aqueous medium.247 Upon the treatment of the MOF with several anions, in the case of perborate, its fluorescence intensity at 402 nm dramatically increased by 65 fold (Fig. 28). The “turn-on” detection of perborate by CAU-10-OCOCH3 remained unaffected in the presence of various competitive anions present in the sample solution. The selective and sensitive detection of perborate is due to the conversion of the acetoxy functional group on the linker in the MOF to the auxo-chromic moiety –OH group (5-hydroxy isophthalic acid), leading to the fluorescence enhancement in the system. This functionality conversion was confirmed by IR and 1H NMR analysis. The LOD for perborate was found to be 1.19 μM. Further, the MOF showed detection ability for perborate in various environmental samples.
The same group further reported the “turn-on” detection of the ROS superoxide using a Zr-based MOF.248 Here, the new zirconium-based MOF UiO-66-NH-SO2-Ph-NO2 was synthesized using BDC-NH-SO2-Ph-NO2 ligand under solvothermal reaction conditions. The MOF and linker displayed an emission peak 422 and 436 nm, respectively, upon excitation at 350 nm in methanol solvent. After the injection of 350 μL of 1 mM superoxide (O2˙−) in a dispersed solution of the MOF, the fluorescence intensity of the MOF was significantly enhanced by almost 10 fold with a shift in its emission peak by 14 nm to the blue region. This shifting in its emission peak is due to the elimination of the coordinated linker from the MOF. However, the luminescence intensity of the MOF remained unaffected in the presence of other ROS. The mechanism of sensing was established with the help of PXRD, IR and mass analysis. The PXRD study indicated that the after first sensing process, the MOF was not recoverable, illustrating the collapse of the MOF network. The IR study revealed that the intensity of the carboxylate stretching vibrations of the ligand in the MOF gradually declined upon the steady addition of O2˙−. Finally, the IR peak was almost similar to that of the free ligand. This again confirmed the collapse of the MOF. Further, the release of the ligand from the MOF was confirmed by the mass analysis with the appearance of a sharp peak at 365.1619. All these studies vividly elaborated that the framework collapsed in the presence of O2˙− and the BDC-NH-SO2-Ph-NO2 linker became free in the methanol solution, resulting in a “turn-on” fluorescence emission.
Dong and co-workers reported the sensing of the reactive oxygen species HClO using an MOF-based fluorescent mixed matrix membrane composed of UiO-68-PT and poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA).249 This detection was very sensitive with a colorimetric response, and importantly the sensing was reversible when triggered by Vitamin C (VC) (Fig. 29 and 30). Among several cationic and anionic analytes, UiO-68-PT showed an enhancement in its emission peak at 392 nm upon excitation at 323 nm in the presence of the ClO− anion. The detection limit for the ClO− anion was 0.28 μM.
![]() | ||
Fig. 29 Colour change in UiO-68-PT (and its membrane) during the sensing of HClO and the conversion of the MOF to UiO-68-PTO (and its membrane) upon treatment with VC. Reproduced with permission from ref. 249, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2020. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 30 (a) Mechanism of sensing during the recognition of HClO and (b) colorimetric response of UiO-68-PT with HClO. Reproduced with permission from ref. 249, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2020. |
The pristine MOF UiO-68-PT was almost non-fluorescent in nature. This is because the electron-donating ability of phenothiazine to benzimidazole through the PET process reduced its luminescence intensity. When ClO− anion was added to the system, it converted the phenothiazine moiety to phenothiazine sulfoxide (UiO-68-PTO). Consequently, the PET effect was completely inhibited from the phenothiazine sulfoxide to benzimidazole moiety, and thus the fluorescence property of the latter was significantly amplified. The IR spectrum of UiO-68-PTO showed a peak at 1045 cm−1, which corresponds to the signature peak for the SO bond. Interestingly, upon the addition of VC, the phenothiazine sulfoxide reverted to phenothiazine, and consequently the emission intensity was quenched. This reversible redox conversion was also observed through a visual colour change.
Pyrophosphate (PPi) plays an essential role in physiological functions and it acts as a crucial character in DNA sequencing.250 Thus, its concentration is very important and its monitoring in living cells imperative. Hu and co-workers reported the synthesis of MOF-5-NH2 for the selective detection of pyrophosphate (PPi) through the turn-on process.251 This framework showed an emission peak at 431 nm upon excitation at 325 nm. Actually, the MOF acts as a dual-type sensor, i.e., it detects two varieties of analytes. Firstly, the MOF recognises metal ions (Cu2+ and Pb2+) through the “turn-off” process. Interestingly, in the presence of PPi, the non-luminescent entity Cu2+@MOF-5-NH2/Pb2+@MOF-5-NH2 displayed the fluorescence “turn-on” phenomenon (Fig. 31).
![]() | ||
Fig. 31 Synthesis of MOF-NH2, followed by its complexation with Cu2+/Pb2+ ions for the sensing of PPi. |
The overall sensing mechanism was established with the help of the host–guest interaction. The luminescence of MOF-5-NH2 is primarily due to its amino-based linker. In the presence of Cu2+/Pb2+, the excited electrons on the ligand of the MOF are donated to the vacant orbital on Cu2+ (3d orbital) and Pb2+ (6p orbital). This leads to a reduction in the fluorescence intensity of MOF-5-NH2. However, when PPi is added to the system, it pulls out the Cu2+/Pb2+ metal ion from the system. Thereby, the inhibition of electron transfer between MOF-5-NH2 and Cu2+/Pb2+ occurs. Thus, the fluorescence of MOF-5-NH2 is rejuvenated. Further, this mechanism of sensing was supported by excited lifetime decay study, zeta potential measurement and FRET analysis.
Ghosh and co-workers strategically designed an MOF as a scaffold for the selective “turn-on” detection of the bisulfite anion (HSO3−) in aqueous solution.252 They used the well-known MOF NH2-MIL-68(In) for the PSM process of –NH2 groups in the MOF with glyoxal to enable –CHO interaction site for the guest molecules (Fig. 32). Interestingly, upon the formation of the Schiff base, the MOF sensor lost its fluorescence intensity with respect to the pristine MOF. When the post-synthetic-modified MOF was treated with a variety of anions, it was found that it regained its florescence intensity with HSO3− anions. Accordingly, the emission peak at 437 nm was significantly enhanced upon excitation at 320 nm. The LOD value in this case was 0.047 ppm. The sensitivity and selectivity of the post-synthetic-modified MOF for HSO3− anions remained unaffected in the presence of several other competitive anions. The mechanism of the sensing process was validated using IR spectroscopy. The IR spectrum of the MOF treated with HSO3− anions showed a stretching peak at ∼1130 cm−1, correspong to the SO bond of the HSO3− anions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 32 PSM process of NH2-MIL-68(In) with glyoxal to produce the final probe and its sensing mechanism for the HSO3− anion. |
The detection of fluoride ions is very important given that they play various important roles in biological and environmental systems.253 The recognition and quantification of fluoride ions are necessary, and in this context, MOFs are very efficient. Yan and co-workers post-synthetically incorporated the Tb3+ ion in a Zr-MOF to form Tb3+@Zr-MOF for the discriminating sensitive “turn-on” recognition of fluoride ions in aqueous medium.254 In the solid state, the luminescence spectrum (λex = 302 nm) of Tb3+@Zr-MOF showed the signature peaks for the Tb3+ ion at 620, 584, 544 and 488 nm, which correspond to the 5D4 → 7FJ transition where, J = 3, 4, 5 and 6, respectively. This indicates that the ligand effectively sensitized (antenna) Tb3+ in the luminescence process. However, when the luminescence spectrum (λex = 302 nm) of Tb3+@Zr-MOF was recorded in water medium, the ligand-centred emission at 398 nm appeared, whereas the intensity of the Tb3+ emission decreased. This reduction is owing to the stretching vibration of the O–H bond of the water molecule. On screening the luminescence intensity of Tb3+@Zr-MOF in water medium with several anions (Fig. 33), its fluorescence intensity sharply increased with F− ions. Under UV light in the presence of F−, the MOF also showed a colorimetric response with bright green color, which corresponds to the major peak at 544 nm (5D4 → 7F5) (Fig. 33, inset). The detection limit for F− ion was found to be 0.35 ppm.
![]() | ||
Fig. 33 Emission peak pattern of Tb3+@Zr-MOF with diverse anions (inset: colorimetric response of Tb3+@Zr-MOF with F− ion) and (b) highest increment of fluorescence intensity of Tb3+@Zr-MOF with F− ion among a variety of competitive anions. Reproduced with permission from ref. 254, the American Chemical Society, Copyright 2018. |
The PXRD pattern of the recovered MOF after the first sensing process ruled out the degradation of the framework. Interestingly, the MOF having imperfect bonds indicates that the coordination number around Zr4+ remained vacant, which acts as a Lewis acid and furnished the guest interaction site.255 In water, the intensity ratio value of I545/I398 was 1.5, which significantly increased to 29 upon the interaction of Tb3+@Zr-MOF with F− ions. The F− ion is a Lewis base, and thus strongly interacts with the Lewis acid Zr4+ ion, causing the energy transfer from the ligand to Zr4+ to considerably decline. Concomitantly, the energy transfer was enhanced from the ligand to Tb3+. Thus, the luminescence intensity of Tb3+@Zr-MOF increased. The MOF-based “turn-on” probes for the recognition of diverse anions are listed in Table 3.
MOFs | The metal ion in node/SBU | λ excitation (nm) | λ emission (nm) | Nature of analyte detects | LOD | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Zr | 310 | 465 | CN− | 0.14 μM | 256 |
UiO-66-NH2 | Zr | 360 | 470 | 8.2 × 10−7 M and 7.3 × 10−7 M | 257 | |
ZIF-90-BA | Zn | 475 | 544 | OCl− | 6.25 μM | 258 |
Zr-UiO-66-N2H3 | Zr | 360 | 430 | PO43− | 0.196 μM | 259 |
NH2-MIL-101(Al) | Al | 490 | 520 | F− | 0.05 μmol L−1 | 260 |
Zr-UiO-66-NH-CH2-Py | Zr | 330 | 430 | O2˙− | 0.21 μM | 261 |
PDA/Eu/PDA-UiO-66-NH2(x) | Zr | 280 | 591, 614, 650 and 698 | ClO− | 0.10 μM | 262 |
The MOF-based “turn-on” sensing phenomenon can be explored for device-based sensors or OLED devices, which is in its infancy. Similarly, MOF-based membrane or thin film sensors need to be considered, and many aspects can evolve from this methodology in terms of sensitivity, selectivity, response time and recyclability. Nanoscale luminescent MOFs have potential application in tissue and cell imaging, i.e., in vivo sensing. In this regard, hydrolytic stability and robustness in the biological environment are crucial. The aqua solvent has the ability to coordinate with metal ions and there is a chance of the collapse of the MOF network. However, currently, there are ample MOFs that are very water stable. Nevertheless, we have to look at other parameters for diverse applications in the line with “turn-on” sensing. For example, the cytotoxicity of MOFs should be properly investigated for biological sensing and considerably absent in this case. Moreover, multidisciplinary collaboration between bioengineers, materials scientist and biomedical scientists will enable the execution of luminescence MOFs for practical biological applications.
TPPE | 1,1,2,2-Tetrakis(4-(pyridin-4-yl)phenyl)ethane |
DMA | N,N-Dimethylacetamide |
CSMCRI-3 | [Ni2(μ2-OH)(azdc)(tpim)](NO3)·6DMA·6MeOH |
tpim | 4,4′,4′′-(1H-Imidazole-2,4,5-triyl)tripyridine |
H2azdc | azobenzene-4,4′-dicarboxylic acid |
H2DHT | 2,5-Dihydroxyterephthalic acid |
TFA | Trifluoroacetic acid |
LLCT | Ligand to ligand charge transfer |
H3L | 4,4′,4′′-Nitrilotribenzoic acid |
ETTC | 4,4,4,4-(Ethane-1,1,2,2-tetrayl)tetrabiphenyl-4-carboxylic acid |
XPS | X-Ray photoelectron spectroscopy |
H2L1 | 4,4′-Dicarboxy-4′′-nitrotriphenylamine |
L2 | 4-Hydroxypyridine-2,6-dicarboxylate |
2,3-pydcH2 | Pyridine-2,3- dicarboxylic acid |
Bpp | 1,3-Bis(4-pyridyl)propane) |
H3L3 | 4′,4′′′,4′′′′′-Nitrilotris(3-methoxy-[1,1′-biphenyl]-4-carboxylic acid |
H2L4 | 5-[(Anthracen-9-ylmethyl)-amino]-isophthalic acid |
L5 | 4,4′-((9H-Fluoren-9-ylidene)-methylene)dipyridine |
bpy | 4,4′-Bipyridine |
SCXRD | Single crystal X-ray diffraction |
3-NH2-Hpba | 3-Amino-4-(pyridin-4-yl)benzoic acid |
MMCT | Metal to metal charge transfer |
RhB | Rhodamine B |
HDATRz | 3,5-Diamino-1,2,4-triazole |
H2NH2-BDC | 2-Amino-1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid |
G | Guest molecule |
CAU | Christian-Albrechts-University |
UiO | University of Oslo |
ROS | Reactive oxygen species |
TPDC | 3,3′′-Diamino-1,1′:4′,1′′-terphenyl-4,4′′-dicarboxylic acid |
2,2′-bpy | 2,2′-Bipyridine |
bpp | 4,4′-Trimethylenedipyridine |
H2nip | 5-Nitroisophthalic acid |
NIR | Near infrared |
LMCT | Ligand to metal charge transfer |
Ag12 | [(Ag12(StBu)6(CF3COO)6(CH3CN)6]·CH3CN |
Py-TPE | Tetrapyridine-tetraphenylethene |
AIE | Aggregation enhanced emission |
Htpt | 5-[4(1H-1,2,4-Triazol-1-yl)]phenyl-2H-tetrazole) |
R,R-CHCAIP | 5,5′-((1R,2R)-Cyclohexane dicarbonyl bis-(azanediyl)) diisophthalic acid |
NACs | Nitro aromatic compounds |
MLCT | Metal to ligand charge transfer |
H4TCPE | Tetrakis[4-(4-carboxyphenyl)phenyl]ethane |
DCP | Diethyl chlorophosphate |
H2BDC-(OCOCH3)2 | 2,5-Diacetoxy-1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid |
H2BDC-(OH)2 | 2,5-Dihydroxyterephthalic acid |
DEP | 3-(Diethylamino)phenol |
IPT | Isoproturon |
PVA | Poly(vinyl alcohol) |
OXDZ | Nitrogen-rich heterocyclic dicarboxylate linker |
HODA | 2,2′,3,3′-Oxidiphthalic acids |
MIP | Molecularly imprinted polymer |
MMM | Polymer mixed-matrix membranes |
pda | 1,10-Phenanthroline-2,9-dicarboxylic acid |
HDATRz | 3,5-Diamino-1,2,4-triazole |
PDA | 2,6-Pyridinedicarboxylic acid |
H4DTATC | 5,5′-(9,10-Dihydroxy-4a,9,9a,10-tetrahydroanthracene-9,10-diyl)-diisophthalic acid |
H2hpi2cf | (5-(2-(5-Fluoro-2-hydroxyphenyl)-4,5-bis(4-fluorophenyl)-1H-imidazol-1-yl)isophthalic acid) |
1 | DNBT (dual-ring NRHC) |
2 | H3bta (bis(1H-tetrazol-5-yl) amine) |
3 | NTO (single-ring NRHC) |
4 | 5H-tetrazol-5-amine |
5 | 3-Nitro-1Hpyrazole |
6 | 1-Methyl-1H-tetrazol-5-amine |
7 | 4H-1,2,4-Triazol-4-amine |
8 | DABT (3,3′-diamino-5,5′-bis(1H-1,2,4-triazole)) |
9 | Pyrazole |
10 | 4H-1,2,4-Triazole |
11 | HMX (1,3,5,7-Tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocane) |
12 | RDX (1,3,5-Trinitroperhydro-1,3,5-triazine) |
13 | TNT (Trinitrotoluene) |
14 | FOX-7 (1,1-diamino-2,2-dinitroethylene) |
15 | 4,4′-Bipyridine |
16 | 2,2′-Biimidazole |
17 | 2,2′-Bipyrimidine |
18 | 1,4,7-Triazacyclononane |
19 | Tris(2-aminoethyl)amine |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |