Ana
Valero
a,
Francisco
Merino
a,
Floor
Wolbers
ab,
Regina
Luttge
a,
Istvan
Vermes
b,
Helene
Andersson
ac and
Albert
van den Berg
*a
aBIOS, the Lab-on-a-chip Group, MESA+ Institute for Nanotechnology, University of Twente, PO Box 217, 7500 AE, Enschede, The Netherlands. E-mail: a.vandenberg@ewi.utwente.nl; Fax: +31534892287; Tel: +31534892691
bDepartment of Clinical Chemistry, Medisch SpectrumTwente, Hospital Group, Enschede, The Netherlands
cRoyal Institute of Technology, Microsystem Technology, 100 44 Stockholm, Sweden
First published on 6th December 2004
This paper presents the design, fabrication and first results of a microfluidic cell trap device for analysis of apoptosis. The microfluidic silicon-glass chip enables the immobilization of cells and real-time monitoring of the apoptotic process. Induction of apoptosis, either electric field mediated or chemically induced with tumour necrosis factor (TNF-α), in combination with cycloheximide (CHX), was addressed. Exposure of cells to the appropriate fluorescent dyes, FLICA and PI, allows one to discriminate between viable, apoptotic and necrotic cells. The results showed that the onset of apoptosis and the transitions during the course of the cell death cascade were followed in chemically induced apoptotic HL60 cells. For the case of electric field mediated cell death, the distinction between apoptotic and necrotic stage was not clear. This paper presents the first results to analyse programmed cell death dynamics using this apoptosis chip and a first step towards an integrated apoptosis chip for high-throughput drug screening on a single cellular level.
Apoptosis is studied both as a target for drug discovery and as a cellular process. Suppression or enhancement of apoptosis is known to cause or contribute to many diseases such as cancer neurodegenerative diseases and AIDS.1 Apoptosis occurs during the period of embryogenesis and goes on during post-embryonic life, thus controlling cell numbers and organ size in a dynamic balance between cell proliferation and cell death. Apoptosis is a very complex biological process to study. For example, the duration of apoptosis is short, involves single cells with morphological changes only after the “point of no return”, ending in phagocytosis without reaction in the neighbour cell.1
At present there are about 300 different apoptosis-related kits and techniques that are developed for apoptosis detection and quantification.6 However, all of these techniques have a number of limitations, the most important of which is that cells must be stained, fixed or destroyed for analysis, meaning that intact cells cannot be analysed today.1,2 There are no methods available for studying apoptosis of single cells. In addition, cell preparation for analysis is time consuming (at least 15–30 min) and therefore real-time monitoring of the cell death cascade is not available or it can only be reconstructed from flow cytometry measurements of cell samples stained at different stages of the apoptotic process. Further, conventional bioanalytical techniques need highly sophisticated equipments and technicians to perform these measurements which are very labour-consuming and expensive. Hence, there is a real need for simple chip technology to study apoptosis in real-time on single cell level with high-throughput that will provide valuable additional and complementary information to existing conventional methods to analyse the process of apoptosis.7–10
Recent advances in microfluidic Lab-on-a-Chip techniques have increased the potential of high-throughput biochemical assays on individual mammalian cells. Of particular interest is the ability to parallelize up-front assay protocols and still be able to examine and treat every individual cell in the assay separately retrieving single-cell event information.11–13
Studying apoptosis on chip is a completely new approach which has almost not been explored at all. Until today, only three reports on apoptosis analysis on chips were presented.14–16 In all three reports either cell labeling, cell lysis or very advanced optical system are required. Hence, none of the drawbacks for the conventional techniques were circumvented.
In this paper real-time monitoring of individual cells is addressed presenting the geometrical design, chip fabrication and first results of apoptosis studies in a new microfluidic assay format. The cross-flow devices introduced in this study offer to broaden the tools to characterize single cells in a format that allows integration of high-throughput techniques with unique assay functionality, for example, to identify the apoptotic cascade of HL60 cells.
Integration techniques such as known from microelectronics allow placing electrodes close to a single cell either to stimulate the cell or reading the cell impedance, which can give a measure for the cell status.17,18 High-throughput is achieved if electrodes and cells are arranged in an array (parallel) fashion. The device as introduced here presents an intermediate step towards this class of operations by first positioning cells in pre-defined locations of the chip leading to a one dimensional array of cells under investigation. In this stage of development optical detection is performed to compare the results to classical methods.3 Numbering-up of devices and two dimensional arrayed cell investigation can increase the throughput of observed events. Translating the optical information in cell impedance spectra can help to further optimize automated operation on a large number of cells without the need for complex optical and robotic equipment.
The aim of this work is to eventually be able to measure apoptotic cell death dynamics on a chip in real-time on single cell level. A new microfluidic chip has been developed in which the apoptotic process can be optically followed. Electric field mediated and chemically induced cell death has been attempted. Exposure of cells to a fluorochrome-labeled inhibitor of caspases (FLICA) labels cells after caspase activation and arrest further progress of the apoptotic cascade.3,19 Loss of membrane integrity (late apoptosis and necrosis) was observed by exposing cells to propidium iodide (PI).
For the electroosmotic flow (EOF) control a computer-controlled high-voltage power supply (CU 411, IBIS technologies BV, Hengelo, The Netherlands) with four independently controllable positive voltage outputs was used. Gold wires immersed in the reservoirs of a chip holder were used for making the electrical connection to the high-voltage supply unit with the fluid in the chip.
Fig. 1 (a) Drawing of the microfluidic chip with dimensions in mm. Photographs of the trapping sites, (b) layout 1 and (c) layout 2, in the microfluidic chip design. |
Fig. 2 SEM picture of the trapping sites (close-up) for layout 1. |
The devices are made of a silicon/glass sandwich. The schematic of the fabrication process is shown in Fig. 3. In the silicon substrate the microfluidic channels and trapping sites are etched by reactive ion etching using the Bosch process (a–d). Access holes from the back side of the silicon wafer are powderblasted (e). After this step the silicon wafer is thermally oxidized at 1100 °C (g). A glass wafer is anodically bonded to the silicon wafer (h) which allows the visualization of the channels and the trapping process as well as optical detection of the fluorescence signal.
Fig. 3 Schematic of the fabrication process. |
To be able to discriminate between apoptosis and necrosis, the cell treatment was as follows; 125 µl of HL60 cells (0.5 × 106 cells ml−1) were treated with 15 µL of PI (1.5 µM final concentration) and 10 µL of the inhibitor FLICA (20 mM final concentration; FLICA is a mixture of 5 mM FAM-VAD-FMK and 15 mM z-VAD-FMK) obtained from Intergen Co. (Purchase, NY, USA). FLICA blocks the activation of caspases and arrests further progress of the apoptotic cascade and prevents cellular desintegration. In the last case, to study the effect of the apoptotic inducer TNF-α, 99.5 µl of HL60 cells (0.5 × 106 cells ml−1) were treated with 15 µL TNF-α/10.5 µL CHX (3 nM/50 µM final concentrations) (Sigma, St. Louis, MO, USA), 15 µL of PI (1.5 µM) and 10 µL of the inhibitor FLICA (20 mM). Immediately after the cell sample preparation, 100 µl of this sample solution was introduced manually in the inlet reservoir of the central channel (see Fig. 1a, inlet R1)
The voltage scheme used for driving the cells from the central channel towards the trapping sites was set at the sample compartment (R1) to 100 V, at the reservoir behind the trap (R3) to 0 V and at the other two reservoirs to 50 V (see Fig. 1a). These settings were maintained until the cells were getting close to the trapping sites. At this moment, the electrical resistance in the trapping site is increased due to the presence of the cells and in order to continue addressing the coming cells towards the trap the voltage in the reservoirs 2 and 4 was increased to a value of 80 V.
At first, by using the cell trap device with layout 1 (Fig. 1b), we observed that cells get trapped also at the small side channels located between the traps. Therefore for the next series of experiments the mechanical trap with layout 2 (Fig. 1c) was used, where all the traps have the same size.
Fig. 4 Equivalent electrical circuit of the cell trapping device (layout 2) using 20-Sim (Control Lab Products B. V., Enschede). |
In Fig. 5 the result of the EOF driven cell trapping is shown. Fig. 5a shows the fluorescence image of the first cells trapped when the voltage scheme is on; cells inside of the trap took up PI immediately after docking. Fig. 5b shows the light microscopy image of the cells 10 s after the electroosmotic flow was stopped and Fig. 5c is the fluorescence image of Fig. 5b. Comparing Fig. 5b and 5c, we can conclude that the cells inside of the trap show the red fluorescence but the cells in the vicinity of the trap do not, and they can be further investigated (as done in subsection 3). Observation of the cells located in other places apart from the trap, e.g. channels, did not show red fluorescence, therefore we can conclude that the presence of the EOF in the channels did not affect the cell viability as shown in Fig. 5d and 5e. With this assessment we were able to show the electropermeabilization effect of the applied electric field used for the microfluidic control over the cells being located in the trap. Likewise, the experiment confirms the validity of our simulations. On the other hand, with the performed experiment it is not possible to discriminate whether the cells are dead (necrotic cell) or in the process of dying (late apoptotic cell), because in both cell states the cell membrane has lost its integrity, thus showing red fluorescence. In the next step an apoptotic indicator (FLICA) will be added to the cell sample in order to find out whether cells die through apoptosis or necrosis when an electric field is applied.
Fig. 5 PI uptake in HL60 cells sitting at the trap due to the high electric field lines density. (a) Fluorescence image at the time the HL60 cells arrive at the trap. (b) Light microscopy image of the cells 10 s after EOF control was stopped. (c) Fluorescence image from image (b). (d) Light microscopy image of the central channel (R1). (e) Fluorescence image from image (d). |
In Fig. 6a it is observed that during the EOF control cells moved towards the trap in the direction of the EOF, while FLICA, being a negative charged molecule moved by means of its electrophoretic mobility. The trapped cells showed red fluorescence, in agreement with the previous experiment. Once the EOF was stopped, FLICA diffused towards the trap where cells were located (see Fig. 6b). At this point, the cells first showing red fluorescence now show red (PI) and green (FLICA) fluorescence (FLICA+/PI+, see Fig. 6c). This bicolor fluorescence pattern is characteristic of cells being at the late apoptotic state. These results could suggest that apoptotic cell death was induced by the electric field applied. In the case that the electric field mediated cell membrane permeabilization is reversible, meaning that the cell membrane reseals after the EOF voltage is off, the presence of the green fluorescencent label (FLICA+) will determine if the process of apoptosis is activated by the applied electric field, because FLICA only binds to activated caspaspes within the cell. At this point of the experiment, the reversible or irreversible electropermeabilization of the cell membrane remains uncertain and the green fluorescence label can be either by diffusion through a disrupted cell membrane or by caspase activation. However, impedance measurements could allow us to know if resealing of the cell membrane has occurred.
Fig. 6 Cell discrimination by fluorescence. (a) EOF control on; cells sitting at the trap get permeable and PI is uptaken. FLICA moves by means of its electrophoretic mobility. (b) EOF control off; FLICA diffuses and enters in contact with the cells being located at the trap, (c) zoom in from Fig. 6b. Cells sitting in the traps show the green (FLICA+) and red (PI+) fluorescence. A second row of cells that have not received the influence of the electric field do not show any fluorescence label; no apoptosis has been induced, viable cells (FLICA−/PI−). |
As described in literature, inducing apoptosis and labeling cells with FLICA and PI makes it possible to identify four subpopulations with flow cytometry: (i) Viable or non-apoptotic cells show neither FLICA nor PI fluorescence. (ii) In the initial phase of apoptosis, the caspases become activated and FLICA binds to these activated caspases while the plasma membrane is still able to exclude PI. In the initial phase of apoptosis, HL60 cells are FLICA+/PI−, early apoptotic. (iii) Subsequently, HL60 cells lose their plasma membrane integrity and their ability to exclude PI. These late apoptotic cells are FLICA+/PI+. (iv) Finally, HL60 cells lose the ability to bind FLICA, because the caspases are either inhibited or degraded, and become FLICA−/PI+. This phase is called the ‘necrotic stage’ of apoptosis. In the continuous presence of FLICA, this latter phase (FLICA−/PI+) is normally not visible, due to the fact that FLICA arrests the apoptotic pathway in the late apoptotic phase.
Fig. 7 shows the bivariate distributions of green and red fluorescence intensity from TNF-α/CHX-treated cells exposed to FLICA and PI in the microfluidic cell trap device. HL60 cells, in the continuous presence of FLICA, transit from the viable stage to the early apoptotic stage and then to the late apoptotic stage (see black dotted circles in Fig. 7, lower and upper cell).
Fig. 7 Optical images of cell death dynamics. Light (1) and fluorescence (2) microscopy images of HL60 cells sitting at the trap over time. (a) 1 h, (b) 2 h, (c) 4 h, (d) 6 h, (e) 24 h. V: Viable cell; EA: Early apoptotic; LA: Late apoptotic. |
At completion of the experiment, analysis of the fluorescence images from Fig. 7 was performed. For each series of fluorescent images, areas of interest were defined manually for each cell (named upper and lower cell) upon their positions over time. Image areas of approximately of 92 × 93 pixels2 containing one cell only, were estimated from the white light image. The average green and red scale intensity of each area of interest was then automatically calculated for each image. This was calculated, for the two cells of interest, three times and an average value ± std dev. is given. Consequently, the temporal development of FLICA and PI fluorescence in individual cells across time could be graphed as mean fluorescence intensity (in arbitrary units) versus time, as shown in Fig. 8. An increase in FLICA fluorescence (between 4 and 6 h) determines that the apoptotic process has been activated.
Fig. 8 TNF/CHX induced apoptotic cell death dynamics. Green (FLICA) and red (PI) fluorescence intensity of upper (a) and lower (b) HL60 cell in time (trend is indicated by the arrow.) |
It is known in literature that electric fields induce apoptosis in HL60 cells.22 However, with the used biochemical assay we were not able to compare the effect of the two inducers (TNF-α/CHX and electric field) because uncertainty remains in electric field mediated cell death.
In the near future impedance measurements will be performed to ensure that electric field mediated apoptosis has occurred. This will make it possible to compare the effects of different inducers on the apoptosic process. In addition, coupling a spectrometer to the microscope will allow quantitative measurements in fluorescent intensity from the different apoptotic stages of the cells in more detail.
Nowadays there are many assays present to detect cell death, however measuring apoptosis in a microfluidic cell trap device offers many advantages over the present conventional (flow cytometry) methods. Besides the benefits to measure apoptosis on a single cell level and in real time, it is now also possible to follow the intracellular changes within a cell. Conventional apoptotic methods use cell suspensions as a representation of the total cell culture (tissue), not knowing how the different cells react. However, in this device it is possible to investigate the reaction of one cell to a certain inducer and also investigate how cells react with each other in time. Further, fewer cells are needed, which is of special interest when primary cells (directly prepared from fresh tissue or fluids from an organism) are used.11 Moreover, this device offers possibilities to investigate dose-response relations within the same cell and between cells in real time. Thus, adapting the present conventional techniques to chip technology will offer many benefits and will obtain new insights into the apoptotic cascade.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2005 |