Yan-Chen
Wu
a,
Ren-Jie
Song
*a and
Jin-Heng
Li
*ab
aKey Laboratory of Jiangxi Province for Persistent Pollutants Control and Resources Recycle, Nanchang Hangkong University, Nanchang 330063, China
bState Key Laboratory of Chemo/Biosensing and Chemometrics, Hunan University, Changsha 410082, China. E-mail: srj0731@hnu.edu.cn; jhli@hnu.edu.cn
First published on 23rd June 2020
Photoelectrochemical cells (PECs) have emerged as an environmentally friendly tool for fuel production, conversion of carbon dioxide, water splitting, and pollutant degradation in the past few years. Although PECs show advantages in these areas, their application in organic synthesis has just begun. Recently, oxidation, C–H functionalization and cross-coupling have been successfully achieved in PECs by the use of an oxidizing photoanode, such as BiVO4 or WO3, for the construction of C–N, C–O and C–P bonds. This highlight article focuses on the application of PECs in organic synthesis reactions and their reaction mechanisms, with a special emphasis on enantioselective conversions.
Since the first photoelectrochemical cells (PECs) were reported in 1972, PEC-based solar water splitting was the most studied path in this promising area.2 As research progressed, scientists found that the potential of PECs was not limited to this simple field, and other applications of PECs were reported. Their applications were expanded to the fields of fuel production, conversion of carbon dioxide, and pollutant degradation.3,4 However, their application in organic synthesis was limited. Recently, much effort has been made to develop systems for this transformation through the use of numerous photoanode materials. Various oxidizing photoanodes, such as BiVO4 and WO3, have been used to realize organic redox reactions.5 Different reaction types, such as the oxidation of simple substrates, C–H functionalization and R1-H/R2-H cross coupling reactions, have been successfully achieved in PEC cell systems (Scheme 1). This organic transfer system in PEC cells has become a powerful strategy for the construction of high value-added chemicals, which has emerged as an atom-economical, environmentally-friendly, and energy saving method in organic chemistry.
Similarly to traditional photochemistry and electrochemistry,6,7 photoelectrochemistry is an environmentally friendly synthetic tool. Compared with these methods, the most obvious advantage of chemical reactions in PECs is the reduction of external bias, thereby saving electricity. Notably, organic system reactions in PECs mostly work under metal-free and chemical oxidant-free conditions, which will become an ideal research direction. With the use of a photoanode as the electrode material, the use of external power can be avoided and the applied voltage can be decreased. At present, PEC cells have no obvious advantage regarding the control of reactivity and selectivity. Organic transformation in PECs may avoid excessive oxidation and reduce side reactions to obtain better chemical selectivity due to lower external bias. We hope that these problems can be solved by designing different photoanode materials (doped with transition metal catalysts) in the future.
This highlight article aims to provide a concise overview of organic synthesis in photoelectrochemical cells for the formation of different chemical bonds and also emphasizes transformation pathways. The advantages and shortcomings of photoelectrochemical organic reactions using PEC cells are also discussed.
In 2015, Choi’s group reported a TEMPO-mediated electrooxidative reaction of HMF for the synthesis of FDCA in a photoelectrochemical cell (Scheme 2a).9 Utilizing an n-type BiVO4 material as the oxidation photoanode and a platinum plate as the reduction cathode in the presence of TEMPO as a mediator, HMF can convert into FDCA with a near-quantitative yield and 100% faradaic efficiency at ambient conditions without the use of precious-metal catalysts. Meanwhile, the authors also demonstrated a novel strategy using PECs which utilizes solar energy for HMF oxidation as the anode reaction (Scheme 2b). The results suggest that PECs can not only be used for fuel production, but can also be used in producing high value-added chemicals from simple organic substrates by photoanode oxidation processes. More importantly, by using photogenerated holes in the VB of BiVO4 for oxidation, a lower applied potential could be used for TEMPO oxidation, which is about 0.1 V versus RHE.
Subsequently, organic transformation in photoelectrochemical cells has attracted a great deal of interest in organic synthetic chemistry because it avoids using expensive and toxic reagents or catalysts. In 2017, Sammis, Berlinguette and co-workers realized a photoelectrochemical alcohol oxidation and C–H functionalization in PEC cells. Employing a BiVO4 electrode as the photoanode, MeCN as the solvent, and NHPI as the electron transfer reagent, benzyl alcohol, cyclohexene and 1,2,3,4-tetrahydronaphthalene could furnish the corresponding ketones in moderate to good yields (Scheme 3).10 Compared with traditional chemical oxidation conditions, this method avoids the use of other additives, such as metal catalysts and strong oxidants, which may cause pollution problems. Moreover, this photoelectrochemical oxidative reaction was accomplished by using sunlight as the single energy source, which can reduce the applied voltage of an EC oxidation process by 1 V. Importantly, the results of the experiments showed that NHPI was necessary for this photoelectrochemical system.
Sayama and co-workers also successfully achieved a similar photoelectrochemical oxidation of benzylic alcohol derivatives on BiVO4/WO3 under visible light irradiation (Scheme 4).11a Employing a BiVO4/WO3 composite photoelectrode in aprotic organic media, the oxidation reaction proceeded smoothly and generated the corresponding ketones in up to 97% yield. The recyclability of this electrode material was also examined and the composite BiVO4/WO3 photoelectrode could be used at least three times for the photoelectrochemical oxidation of alcohols. It was noted that the TON of products to BiVO4 was approximately 1200.
Scheme 4 The photo-assisted electrochemical oxidation of benzylic alcohol derivatives and the proposed reaction mechanism. |
A similar simple oxidant reaction was reported by Yehezkeli, Goodwin, Cha and co-workers in the same year.11b They achieved the transformation from n-butanol to 2-ethylhexenal by tandem enzymatic oxidation and aldol condensation in a PEC system by employing BiVO4 as the anode material.
Direct C–H activation reactions have attracted widespread attention in organic synthesis because this reaction can often improve the atom- and step economies. Over the past decades, many fascinating methods have been developed, including transition-metal-catalyzed C–H activation and electrochemical C–H activation.12 In order to achieve specific reactivity for C–H activation under mild conditions, Sayama’s group also developed a novel photo-electrochemical C–H bond activation reaction of cyclohexane using a WO3 photoanode and visible light in air at room temperature and atmospheric pressure (Scheme 5).13 The oxidation ability of h+ at the valence band potential of WO3 is almost identical to that of TiO2 (+3.1 V vs. RHE), and the conduction band potential of WO3 is +0.5 V vs. RHE. In this strategy, excellent partial oxidation selectivity up to 99% and apparent faradaic efficiency (76%) were obtained and the IPCE at 365 and 420 nm were 57% and 24%, respectively.
A possible mechanism was also proposed in Scheme 5. Firstly, the single-electron transfer process of cyclohexane by the photoanode affords the cyclohexyl radical through C–H bond cleavage. Then the cyclohexyl radical is activated by O2 to give a cyclohexylperoxyl radical. Finally, the cyclohexylperoxyl radical is disproportionately transformed to the corresponding products cyclohexanol and cyclohexanone. Cyclohexanol can further convert to cyclohexanone via an additional two-electron oxidation process. However, another byproduct, namely dicyclohexyl, was often detected by coupling of a cyclohexyl radical in the absence of O2.
A peroxygenase catalyzed oxyfunctionalization of C–H bonds through photoelectrochemical H2O2 generation in PEC cells was successfully demonstrated by the Park group in 2019, in which FeOOH/BiVO4 was used as the photoanode, CN/rGO as the cathode and CIGS as the solar cell.14 It was noted that they also successfully achieved photoelectroenzymatic hydroxylation of ethylbenzene to give (R)-1-phenylethanol with a TTN of 43300 and up to 99% ee via this system.
Substituted furans are found as structural units in many natural products and bioactive molecules, while they are also important synthetic intermediates in organic synthesis.15 New and green synthetic investigations of furan derivatives have continuously attracted the attention of many organic chemists. In 2017, Sayama’s group reported a selective photoelectrochemical dimethoxylation reaction between furan and MeOH by using a composite n-type semiconductor BiVO4/WO3 photoanode and Br+/Br− as a mediator, with excellent faradaic efficiency up to 99% (Scheme 6).16 The utilization of photoelectrochemistry instead of an electrochemical method under dark conditions tactfully addressed the challenge of avoiding side reactions, such as the oxidation of MeOH and the methoxylated product. In addition, the applied potential in this system could be decreased by using solar energy. In order to prove that photoelectrolysis is a useful method for decreasing the applied potential, they tested the oxidation potential under dark and photoirradiation conditions, respectively. In the case of the BiVO4/WO3 photoelectrode, the oxidation potential shifted from 1.2 V to 0 V vs. SHE under photoirradiation. The bromide ion plays an important role in the transformation process; only a trace amount of product was detected in the absence of Et4NBr as a Br− source. The addition of Et4NBF4 as a co-supporting electrolyte also improved the efficiency of the dimethoxylation.
Scheme 6 Plausible mechanism for photoelectrochemical dimethoxylation of furan with Br+/Br− as a mediator. |
Recently, Hu and co-workers successfully realized a novel photoelectrocatalytic C–H amination of arenes and pyrazoles (Scheme 7).18 In this reaction, a haematite photoanode was used as the electrode due to its low cost, high stability and suitable bandgap of 2.1 eV for strong visible light absorption; compared to organic photoredox catalysts, such as acridinium, haematite (2.3 V versus the standard hydrogen electrode) has a similar oxidation potential, which suggests similar reactivity. Using LiClO4 as the supporting electrolyte, HFPI/MeOH (4:1) as the co-solvent, and blue LED as the light source, various arenes could be converted to the corresponding substituted N-heterocycle products in up to 89% yield.
A plausible mechanism was also proposed by the authors; see Scheme 8. Unusual ortho selectivity was observed, possibly due to the formation of intermediate A, which possessed a hydrogen bond between hexafluoroisopropanol and pyrazole. Compared with the photoredox catalysed C–H/N–H cross coupling reaction, this method showed a different mechanism. The photogenerated redox process was localized in the valence band (VB) of the haematite photoanode and the PECs absorbed the light using a heterogeneous haematite semiconductor. It is worth noting that the charge in this photoelectrochemical reaction was transferred from the edge of the VB to the substrate for oxidation, which was different from the electrochemical reaction.
Organophosphorus compounds, especially α-amino phosphonates, are a valuable skeleton widely present in materials chemistry, agrochemicals, and biochemistry.19 Most of the reported methods for their synthesis suffer from various disadvantages such as the need for metal catalysts, stoichiometric oxidants or directing groups. PEC cells, as a valuable electrochemical synthetic tool to save energy in organic synthesis, can solve these problems. In 2019, the Wu group also described an energy saving electrochemical synthesis method in PEC cells to achieve P–H/C–H cross coupling with a hydrogen evolution strategy between amines and P(O)H compounds (Scheme 9).20 By using BiVO4 as a photoanode and NHPI as a mediator, a series of organophosphorus compounds were produced in good to excellent yields with hydrogen evolution. In addition, this approach showed good functional-group tolerance and broad substrate scope. Importantly, nearly 90% external bias input was saved to achieve this conversion by the use of PEC cells as the reactor (0.1 V vs. 0.5 V for the BiVO4 PEC system and glassy carbon EC system). Generally, chemists are considering using PEC cells to achieve organic reactions because this method can avoid energy waste. In this transformation, they successfully proved that PEC systems can considerably decrease the applied voltage for C–P bond construction, and serve as viable methods to realize selective redox transformations under efficient and energy saving conditions through electron transfer on the electrode surface.
A plausible mechanism for the P–H/C–H cross coupling reaction in PEC cells is outlined in Scheme 10. Firstly, high energy electron–hole pairs were generated from the BiVO4 photoelectrode once it was excited by the incident photons. Then, on the electrode surface, the radical cation intermediate D was formed from C when the holes reached the surface of BiVO4. At the same time, NHPI and 2,6-luttidine deprotonation obtained the corresponding PINO radicals by anodic oxidation, and the subsequent abstraction of a hydrogen atom (the PINO radical extracts a hydrogen atom from D to regenerate NHPI) proceeded to give the iminium ion intermediate C+, which reacted with diphenyl-phosphine oxide via nucleophilic attack to enable the formation of the final product with a C–P bond. On the cathode surface, the released protons could be reduced to release hydrogen gas during the reaction.
As we know, photoelectrocatalysis occurring in dye-sensitized solar cell (DSSC) devices serves as a novel synthetic method which has successfully been used to achieve the conversion of light energy into electric and chemical energy. Recently, Huang, Wu and co-workers reported a visible-light-induced α-oxyamination between 1,3-dicarbonyls and TEMPO via a photo(electro)catalytic process using visible light as the energy source (Scheme 11).21 By using a DSSC anode or a DSSC system, the cross-coupling of 1,3-dicarbonyls and TEMPO occurred smoothly, leading to a series of α-oxyaminated carbonyl compounds in good to excellent yields (32–97%), featuring advantages such as easy separation, environmental protection, low energy consumption, and sustainability. Notably, the DSSC anode could be reused more than 8 times.
The reaction mechanism for this visible-light-induced α-oxyamination of 1,3-dicarbonyls and TEMPO in PEC cells is shown in Scheme 12. Three different catalytic cycles with three types of catalysts (a trace amount of dissociated N719 in solution, unsensitized TiO2 film and N719-sensitized DSSC anode) were involved in the α-oxyamination reaction between 1,3-dicarbonyl and TEMPO. An excited state N719* [Ru(II)*] is formed from N719 under irradiation by blue light. Then, an electron is transferred from N719* to fill the conduction band (CB) of TiO2, which gives an oxidized Ru(III) complex. Subsequently, TEMPO is oxidized by Ru(III) to generate TEMPO+ (E) and the Ru(III) complex regains its ground state (N719), which undergoes single-electron transfer (SET) affording to the intermediate E. At the same time, a TEMPO anion (F) was formed with the aid of TEMPO oxidation. Moreover, the adsorption of TEMPO on the TiO2 film promotes the absorption of TiO2 under blue light. On the other hand, similarly to indirect electrolysis, TEMPO acted not only as coupling reagent but also as a catalyst in this transformation. Finally, the SET process and radical cross coupling happened to give the desired product L. Alternatively, the reaction between the dicarbonyl anion (G) and the TEMPO cation (E) could also afford the corresponding product L.
Scheme 12 The plausible mechanism for visible-light-induced α-oxyamination of 1,3-dicarbonyls and TEMPO in PEC cells. |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2020 |