Patrick W.
Doheny
a,
Ravichandar
Babarao
b,
Cameron J.
Kepert
*a and
Deanna M.
D’Alessandro
*a
aSchool of Chemistry, The University of Sydney, New South Wales, 2006, Australia. E-mail: deanna.dalessandro@sydney.edu.au; cameron.kepert@sydney.edu.au; Tel: +61 2 93513777
bSchool of Science, Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology (RMIT University), Victoria, 3001, Australia
First published on 8th February 2021
The [M2(dobdc)] series of frameworks (also known as MOF-74 and CPO-27, where M2+ = Zn, Mg, for example, and dobdc2− = 4,6-dioxido-1,3-benzenedicarboxylate) have been the subject of enormous interest in respect to their attractive gas adsorption properties that arise from the ultra-high concentration of open metal sites. An interesting prospect with respect to future applications of these materials is the possibility of generating a ‘switchable’ framework in which the guest adsorption can be modulated by virtue of the redox state of the framework. Herein, we report a closely related metal–organic framework (MOF), [Zn2(DSNDI)], where the redox state of the electroactive ligand DSNDI4− (N,N′-bis(4-carboxy-3-hydroxyphenyl)-1,4,5,8-naphthalenetetracarboxydiimide) can be modulated using both in situ and ex situ methods. The material is stable to both chemical and electrochemical reduction of its organic DSNDI units without structural collapse or degradation, and remains porous to N2, H2 and CO2. The chemically reduced frameworks demonstrate notable changes from the parent material, particularly with respect to CO2 binding. The CO2 isosteric heat of adsorption (Qst) increases from 27.9 kJ mol−1 in the neutral material to 43.9 kJ mol−1 after reduction due to enhanced host–guest interactions, the latter being comparable to the best performing member of the MOF-74 series, [Mg2(dobdc)]. The origin of the enhanced interaction was probed using Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations which corroborated the presence of enhanced framework-CO2 interactions for the chemically-reduced MOF. The tuneable CO2 binding character provides an attractive mechanism to tune gas separations and capture.
A recent report by Saha26 described the synthesis of a MOF-74 analogue incorporating the redox-active DSNDI ligand (where DSNDI4− = N,N′-bis(4-carboxy-3-hydroxyphenyl)-1,4,5,8-naphthalenetetracarboxydiimide) in which the band gap of the framework was modified by infiltrating tetrathiafulvalene (TTF) electron donors that interacted with the DSNDI acceptor units. An additional report by Dincă27 focused on an analogous framework utilising a regioisomer of the DSNDI ligand, NDISA (where NDISA4− = N,N′-bis(3-carboxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)-1,4,5,8-naphthalenetetradicarboximide) that was studied for electrochromic applications upon in situ reduction of the ligand.
Motivated by previous work suggesting that the gas sorption properties of MOFs can be switched by redox modulation,28–30 we now report the electroactive properties of the [Zn2(DSNDI)] framework, hereafter denoted 1, via a combination of in situ and ex situ techniques. Particular attention was focused on the modification of its gas sorption properties (N2, H2, CH4 and CO2), and the CO2 binding enthalpies by utilising post-synthetic chemical reduction. Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were employed to gain insights into the origins of the enhanced framework-CO2 interactions for the chemically-reduced materials. Such studies are important given the strong attention that the parent MOF-74 materials have received with respect to their guest sorption properties. Notably, the presence of 1D honeycomb pores and an ultra-high concentration of open metal binding sites upon activation of the materials makes them highly attractive for industrial gas capture and separations applications. The realisation of tuneable guest adsorption by virtue of a redox-active ligand enhances the multifunctionality of this family of frameworks.
Fig. 1 CV of 1 in 0.1 M [(n-C4H9)4N]PF6/DMF supporting electrolyte at scan rates of 25–250 mV s−1. The arrow indicates the direction of the forward scan. |
The optical properties of the neutral and reduced species of 1 were examined using in situ solid-state UV-Vis-NIR spectroelectrochemistry in 0.1 M [(n-C4H9)4N]PF6/DMF supporting electrolyte. The diffuse reflectance spectrum of the neutral material at 0 V (Fig. 2a) was characterised by a single band at 23510 cm−1 that was attributed to the aromatic π → π* transition of the DSNDI ligand. Upon reduction at −1.2 V, bands in the visible region formed at 12810, 14260 and 16520 cm−1 in addition to a sharp band at 21050 cm−1; these were attributed to the formation of the DSNDI radical anion within the framework structure.33,34 The emergence of the new bands was concurrent with a colour change of the initially bright orange material to a deep brown and correlates well with the spectroelectrochemistry of the H4DSNDI ligand (Fig. S3 and S4, ESI†). Changing the potential further to −2.0 V (Fig. 2b) led to the sample turning black with a large increase in the spectral intensity alongside the appearance of bands at 17150, 18010, 19010 and 19940 cm−1 consistent with the formation of a dianionic NDI species.33,34
Returning the potential to 0 V (Fig. S5, ESI†) led to the slow decay of the visible bands and restoration of the initial spectrum over the course of several hours. The slow decay of the radical bands after the removal of the applied potential implied the formation of a stable anionic radical. The restoration of the initial spectrum and sample colour upon returning the potential to 0 V was suggestive of a degree of reversibility and stability of 1 to electrochemical reduction.
The nature and delocalisation of the DSNDI radical within the anionic MOF was further examined using in situ X-band EPR spectroelectrochemistry. The initial spectrum at 0 V was characterised by a weak isotropic signal that was attributed to the formation of a photoradical during sample preparation that is characteristic of NDI containing materials.33,35,36 Upon application of an electrochemical potential the intensity of the signal was observed to increase to give a sharp, isotropic signal (Fig. S6a, ESI†) with a simulated (Fig. S6b, ESI†) g-value of 2.0014, consistent with the formation of an organic radical. The sharpness of the spectrum implied the presence of unresolved hyperfine splitting of the signal. The EPR spectrum of the electrochemical radical at 1.2 V was recollected (Fig. S7, ESI†) using a modulation amplitude of 0.1 G to yield a poorly resolved 13-line spectrum arising from hyperfine splitting of the signal. The latter is consistent with the EPR spectroelectrochemistry from previously reported studies of NDI radical anions that also exhibit a characteristic 13-line signal arising from hyperfine coupling of the NDI radical to the 14N and 1H nuclei of the NDI moiety.34
The N2 sorption properties at 77 K were characterised by Type IV isotherm behaviour (Fig. 3a) with a minor hysteresis observed in the high pressure region that was suggestive of a microporous structure with a high concentration of vacant adsorption sites. Applying BET theory yielded a surface area of 1748 ± 40 m2 g−1, a value comparable to those reported for structurally analogous MOF-74 materials,12,37 but slightly lower than that previously reported for 1 (cf. 2044 m2 g−1) by Saha and co-workers.26 Although not significantly different, the discrepancy may reflect differences in activation methods between this and the previous study.26 Further analysis of the N2 isotherm data enabled the characterisation of the pore size distribution (Fig. S9, ESI†) and pore volume, with a single pore size of 22.5 Å (in good agreement with the 23.8 Å pore width from the calculated model structure) and associated pore volume of 0.53 cm3 g−1 calculated.
Fig. 3 Gas sorption isotherms of 1 showing adsorption of (a) N2 at 77 K and (b) CO2 at 298, 308 and 318 K. Adsorption and desorption are indicated by closed and open triangles respectively. |
Given the strong interest in CO2 capture and storage with respect to MOF-74 materials, the CO2 adsorption properties of 1 were examined at three temperatures of 298, 308 and 318 K (Fig. S10, ESI†). The CO2 isotherms were indicative of Type I sorption behaviour and modest uptake with a maximum of 1.27 mmol g−1 of CO2 adsorbed at 1200 mbar and 298 K (Fig. 3b).
Type I behaviour was also observed with respect to the H2 (Fig. S11, ESI†) and CH4 (Fig. S12, ESI†) sorption properties (Table 1) of the MOF, with considerably lower uptake of CH4 observed at 298 K (0.24 mmol g−1 at 1200 mbar) relative to CO2. The variance in uptakes of CO2vs. CH4 were tentatively attributed to the differences in binding strength of the respective guests (Fig. S13–S15, ESI†). Previous literature reports have demonstrated a preference of MOF-74 materials to adsorb CO2 over CH4 due to its greater polarisability and steric influences that prevent effective binding of the CH4 molecule at the open metal sites.38 Conversely, the smaller size and linear geometry of CO2 facilitate stronger interactions with the open metal sites leading to enhanced uptake relative to CH4.
Upon completion of the gas sorption experiments the material was examined again using capillary PXRD (Fig. S16, ESI†) to assess the effects of multiple sorption and desorption cycles of guests on the framework stability and structure. PXRD confirmed that the structure had indeed been retained with minimal changes in crystallinity (Fig. S16, ESI†).
The solid state UV-Vis-NIR spectra (Fig. 4) of the chemically reduced samples showed distinct changes relative to the neutral material. Highly intense visible bands were observed at 13070, 14460, 16210, 18480 and 20530 cm−1 and were attributed to the formation of the DSNDI radical anion.34 Additional higher energy transitions at 26840, 31560, 38070 and 43410 cm−1 were also found for these samples. The visible bands were assigned to the formation of the DSNDI radical anion and correlated well with those from the spectroelectrochemical experiment, while the higher energy bands were assigned to the aromatic transitions of the ligand.33,34 EPR spectroscopy of the reduced samples (Fig. S19–S24, ESI†) also confirmed the successful reduction of the framework with simulated signals (Fig. S25, ESI†) corresponding to the DSNDI radical anion (g = 2.0029) observed.
The surface areas of the chemically reduced materials were calculated from the N2 isotherm data at 77 K (Fig. S26, ESI†). Although the N2 sorption isotherms for the reduced samples showed a qualitative similarity to that of the neutral material, the BET surface areas (Table 2) were found to be considerably lower, with increasing Li loading correlated with lower surface areas. The N2 uptake was also found to decrease dramatically, with the relatively low uptakes for the 2.27 and 2.82 equiv. samples attributed to the presence of Li+ counterions, required to charge balance the DSNDI radical anions, within the pore space. Interestingly, although a single pore was detected in the reduced samples, akin to the neutral material, the pore sizes were slightly larger than that of the neutral MOF. This may reflect a possible structural conditioning post-reduction to accommodate the newly introduced DSNDI radical ligands and corresponding Li+ counterions, as has been observed previously.31,39 Although not detected, some residual neutral naphthalene may be present in the reduced samples which could be influencing the BET surface areas; however, this contribution cannot be deconvoluted from the relatively larger effect of Li+ filling the pore space. Future work will focus on the effects of other reducing agents and the effects on CO2 binding.
Material | BET surface area (m2 g−1) | Pore size (Å) |
---|---|---|
Neutral | 1748 ± 40 | 22.5 |
0.39 equiv. | 1462 ± 100 | 25 |
0.47 equiv. | 1298 ± 124 | 24.2 |
1.15 equiv. | 1129 ± 45 | 24.8 |
1.82 equiv. | 1084 ± 44 | 24.9 |
2.27 equiv. | 950 ± 79 | 24.7 |
2.83 equiv. | 889 ± 22 | 24.8 |
The adsorption properties with respect to CO2 at 298, 308 and 318 K were examined for the samples chemically reduced by 0.39, 0.47, 1.15 and 1.82 equiv. of LiNP. Although still maintaining modest porosity, the CO2 uptake of the 2.27 and 2.83 equiv. samples were characterised by very low uptakes and extremely long equilibration times. This was attributed to the occlusion of the pore space by Li+ counterions preventing diffusion and uptake of large, polarisable guests such as CO2. As such, only the sorption properties of the samples reduced by 0.39, 0.47, 1.15 and 1.82 equiv. are considered here, with all four materials demonstrating Type I sorption behaviour (Fig. 5a and Fig. S27–S29, ESI†). The uptakes of CO2 were found to be lower than those in the neutral material at all three temperatures, with a maximum uptake of 0.95 mmol g−1 recorded for the 0.47 equiv. sample at 298 K, a discrepancy attributed to the occupation of the pore space with Li+. Given previous reports demonstrating the tuning of the CO2 binding affinities of porous MOF materials using redox modification,24,28–30 the CO2 isosteric heats of adsorption (Qst) of the chemically reduced forms of 1 were of great interest. Applying the Clausius–Clapeyron equation (see ESI†) to the CO2 isotherms obtained at 298, 308 and 318 K for the 0.39, 0.47, 1.15 and 1.82 equiv. samples yielded Qst profiles (Fig. 5b and Fig. S30, S31, ESI†) for all four samples.
The CO2Qst value of the neutral form of 1 was calculated as 27.9 kJ mol−1, a value similar to that of the analogous Zn-MOF-74 analogue (30.6 kJ mol−1);40 this is unsurprising as the chemical environment of the parent system (Zn2+ open metal sites and an aromatic ligand system) resembles that of 1 with no major differences expected. The CO2Qst values (Table 3) of the 0.39 and 0.47 equiv. samples were similar to that of the neutral material, this being attributed to the relatively low degree of reduction that the framework had undergone. The sample reduced by 1.15 equiv. of LiNP demonstrated a larger increase in its CO2 binding affinity with a value of 43.9 kJ mol−1, while the sample reduced by 1.82 equiv. had a relatively lower Qst of 22.7 kJ mol−1. It should be noted that the Qst values for the reduced phases were calculated at the lowest pressure data point obtained. Thus, they do not strictly correspond to ‘zero-loadings’ (i.e., at 0 mbar), where the Qst may be higher.
The range of CO2 binding enthalpies recorded for the reduced materials range from weak (25–30 kJ mol−1) to moderately strong (30–50 kJ mol−1) physisorption interactions. Although this trend may suggest that higher Li loadings would lead to higher Qst values, the 1.82 equiv. sample was found to have an enthalpy of adsorption that was approximately half of the maximum value, and 5.2 kJ mol−1 lower than that of the neutral MOF. This suggests that a certain ‘optimal’ Li loading may exist, at which point the CO2Qst is maximised, and beyond which the CO2 binding interactions begin to decrease. While the binding affinities decrease at the higher loadings, the uptakes are still appreciable, suggesting that the high enthalpy sites become self-blocked at high loadings.
The observed modulation of CO2 binding enthalpies in the chemically reduced frameworks arises due to the changes in the chemical environment due to the formation of organic DSNDI radical anions and the presence of the associated Li+ counterions. To gain insight into the nature of the host–guest interactions between the framework and the CO2 and Li+ guests, DFT calculations (see ESI,† for simulation details) were employed (Fig. S32 and S33, ESI†). The static binding energy of CO2 in the neutral framework was 31.2 kJ mol−1. For the reduced framework, the initial location of one Li+ was initially identified from classical simulation, followed by a CO2 molecule. The latter yielded a binding energy of 55.5 kJ mol−1. The enhanced binding upon reduction is consistent with the experimental observations, and with previously reported examples of redox-modulated framework materials.28–30,41,42 These results demonstrate that the uptake and binding strengths of porous MOF materials can be modified by exploiting the counterion-guest interactions arising from ex situ chemical oxidation or reduction.
The successful modulation of the CO2Qst values demonstrated a successful proof-of-concept in using chemical reduction as a means to tune the guest affinities of electroactive MOF-74 analogues. Notably, the Qst value of 43.9 kJ mol−1 is significantly higher than that of the neutral framework and is comparable to the highest performing member of the MOF-74 series, [Mg2(dobdc)] in terms of its CO2 binding enthalpy.3 Given that the present study is concerned only with the Zn2+ material, this is both an encouraging result and provides motivation for further study of these electroactive MOF-74 analogues where their intrinsic redox capabilities and open metal binding sites.
Activation of the framework was achieved by exchanging the DMF solvent occupying the pore space with MeOH, with the solvent exchanged twice a day for three days. After heating under dynamic vacuum at 80 °C for 24 h, the activated framework was obtained as a bright yellow crystalline powder. At no point during the soaking or solvent exchanging steps was the sample allowed to go dry or be exposed to air, with the material kept under solvent at all times. The activated material was also protected from exposure to the atmosphere and was handled under an argon atmosphere in a glove box at all times prior to analysis.
H2 sorption studies were performed at 77 and 87 K while CO2 and CH4 sorption was carried out at 298, 308 and 318 K. Isosteric heats of adsorption for H2, CO2 and CH4 were calculated by applying the Clausius–Clapeyron equation to the sorption isotherms obtained at the corresponding temperatures.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 1868581 and 1868582. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d0ma00503g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |