Zhi Huangab,
Jianwei Weic,
Xiang-Yu Wanga,
Shaojie Xua,
Ling Huangb and
Le Zeng*a
aSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, National Institute for Advanced Materials, Nankai University, Tianjin 300350, P. R. China. E-mail: zengle@nankai.edu.cn
bTianjin Key Laboratory of Biosensing and Molecular Recognition, Research Center for Analytical Sciences, College of Chemistry, Nankai University, Tianjin 300071, P. R. China
cHebei Technology Innovation Center for Energy Conversion Materials and Devices, College of Chemistry and Materials Science, Hebei Normal University, Shijiazhuang 050024, P. R. China
First published on 22nd July 2025
Anthracene (An) is a well-known photoactive unit that undergoes [4+4] dimerization upon UV excitation or a hetero-Diels–Alder reaction with singlet oxygen to form epoxide under visible light. Despite this dual reactivity, there is no single material exhibiting both photoresponses simultaneously. Herein, by utilizing an electron-deficient metal–organic framework (MOF) host, we obtain an An-dimer-encapsulated MOF cocrystal enabling wavelength-dependent tri-state photoswitching. Specifically, the strontium-containing MOF with preorganized arrays of naphthalene diimide (NDI) dimers and suitable cavity size of 10.3 Å is found to incorporate an An dimer in each cavity, forming extended crystalline π stacks with an A–D–D–A motif. Detailed structure–property analysis reveals the significant impact of dimer formation and charge-transfer stacking on the photophysical properties and photoactivity of the Sr-NDI@An cocrystal. Remarkably, Sr-NDI@An exhibits three distinct wavelength-selective photoresponses: (i) UV-triggered [4+4] dimerization of guest An, (ii) red-light-induced hetero-Diels–Alder reaction between singlet oxygen and An, and (iii) near-infrared-light-driven radical generation. This conceptual work opens the door toward the facile modulation of aromatic stacking for desirable complex functions.
New conceptsMost of the photoresponsive materials can only undergo one transformation toward light excitation, which hardly meets the requirement for advanced smart materials for applications in secured information transaction, high-capacity data storage, and biomedical microrobotics. Herein, utilizing an electron-deficient metal–organic framework (MOF) as a host, we obtain the An dimer encapsulated MOF cocrystal for wavelength-dependent tri-state photoswitching. Specifically, the strontium-containing MOFs with preorganized arrays of naphthalene diimide (NDI) dimers and a suitable cavity size of 10.30 Å are found to incorporate An dimer in each cavity to achieve the fabrication of extended crystalline π stacks with A–D–D–A motif. Spectral evidence verified that three photoreactions occurred for this single crystal: UV triggered [4+4] dimerization of guest An, red light-excited hetero-Diels–Alder reaction between 1O2 and An, and near-infrared light (NIR) driven radical generation. The synergy of CT interaction and dimer formation is essential for this unprecedented three-way photoresponsiveness. Our conceptual work opens up opportunities for the goal-oriented design of functional materials exploiting the rational packing of donors and acceptors, which might contribute to the development of smart materials for applications in product authentication, next-generation opto-electronics, and microrobotics for engineering or biomedicine. |
Anthracene (An) is a good candidate for constructing multiple photoresponsive materials in view of its varied photoreactions under distinct conditions. Firstly, the photodimerization of An to dianthracene represents the oldest known [4+4] photocycloaddition reaction for wide applications in the synthesis of two-dimensional polymers,10 photomechanical grippers of soft robotics,11 and the chirality transfer from helical metal nanostructures to organic molecules.12 Normally, UV excitation of wavelength longer than 320 nm is required to initiate the [4+4] photodimerization without decomposing the product dianthracene. In the meantime, the distance between the two participating An molecules needs to obey Schmidt's rule, implying that it should be less than 4.2 Å. Therefore, most [4+4] photodimerization reactions occur in the solution state to ensure the collision between An molecules. For rare solid-state examples, the confinement of multiple An molecules within host materials13,14 or strong π-interactions between An derivatives15,16 are essential preconditions. Importantly, the photodimerization of An is reversible with high-energy UV irradiation (λ = 250–280 nm) or thermal treatment (≈200 °C), enabling dynamic behaviors in smart materials and optical writing/erasing cycles.
Besides the [4+4] photodimerization, the [4+2] hetero-Diels–Alder cycloaddition between singlet oxygen (1O2) and An is another widely utilized photoreaction of An. Typically, a photosensitizer is required for the light-induced generation of 1O2. In previous reports methylene blue (MB)17,18 or porphyrin derivatives19,20 have been constantly utilized as photosensitizers under red-light excitation (λ = 620–660 nm). To date, this An-involving [4+2] cycloaddition was only reported in solution, which might originate from the requirement for an additional photosensitizer and the efficient diffusion of reactive species 1O2.
Therefore, the key to furnishing the target material possessing a dual photoactivity for [4+4] photodimerization and [4+2] hetero-Diels–Alder reaction, is simultaneously satisfying the close alignment of the An dimer and the efficient generation of 1O2. As mentioned above, the confinement of the An dimer in the host materials is a feasible approach to realize [4+4] photodimerization. However, no study has unambiguously determined the spatial arrangement of An dimers within a single host lattice to enable efficient [4+4] photodimerization. Existing host–guest systems for this reaction rely on computational models for An distribution.13,14 The other challenge is the generation of 1O2 within An-dimer-encapsulated host. The photosensitizer MB or porphyrin act as a guest rather than a structural component of porous materials. Additionally, for a porphyrin-based host, the interaction between porphyrin and An is too weak. Alternatively, 1O2 may be generated via charge transfer (CT) systems involving An, bypassing traditional photosensitization. Recently, through space CT (TSCT) has been suggested as a workable mechanism to render a donor–acceptor (D–A) system with thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF).21,22 The CT excited singlet state (1CT) can undergo intersystem crossing (ISC) to reach the triplet state (3CT), which can transfer energy to ambient oxygen, giving 1O2. Critically, An is an electron-rich aromatic molecule, which easily forms CT complexes with electron-deficient acceptors such as naphthalene diimide (NDI).23
To enable simultaneous incorporation of anthracene dimer and CT pair within a single solid, organic D–A cocrystals represent a promising solution. Ordered arrays of D–A pairs are characteristic for organic cocrystals, and the interchromophoric electronic coupling D–A pairs contribute to varied properties including wavelength-tunable luminescence,24 multi-photon harvesting,25 and spin qutrit.26 Nevertheless, diverse weak interactions between D–A pairs often lead to polymorphism and stoichiomorphs for a given D–A pair.22,27 For precisely controlling the arrangement of an An dimer and the CT pair, the template effect is crucial. Stoddart utilized the supramolecular engineering strategy to select a porphyrin cage with the pore size of 10.4 Å, in the range of 9.9 to 10.5 Å for hosting two guest molecules at suitable π–π stacking distances (3.2–3.5 Å).28 This molecular container forms a 1:
2 host–guest complex with perylene to enable red-to-blue triplet–triplet annihilation upconversion (TTA-UC) in solution. Klajn reported a cage with triimidazolylbenzene (TImB) as the four panels to encapsulate the dimer of an An derivative in its cavity, whereas for different An derivatives, the rate for [4+4] cycloaddition was accelerated or hampered by the “topochemical postulate”.29 These studies highlight that the host with a suitable cavity size and the appropriate orientation of An dimer are all important to achieve our goal. Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are promising candidates to fulfil these requirements in view of their porous nature, varied topology and designable skeletons.30 Notably, D–A host–guest MOFs with tris(4-pyridyl)triazine (TPT) as the panel ligand31 incorporate donors such as An, coronene,32 dibenzothiophene, and N-phenylcarbazole,21 demonstrating tunable CT emission and TADF.21 NDI is another widely used acceptor in MOF cocrystals.33–35 For these NDI-based MOF cocrystals, donors with small π-surfaces such as derivatives of benzene and naphthalene were found to be encapsulated efficiently. However, such systems have exclusively featured 1
:
1 guest–cavity ratios, with functionality largely limited to luminescence rather than photoresponsive behavior.
Previously, utilizing NDI-based tetracarboxylic acid ligand H4BINDI and strontium ion (Sr2+), we obtained extended π-stacked assemblies between pyrene (Py) and NDI with the A–D–D–A pattern.36 This represents the first report of the dimer encapsulation of polyaromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) in MOF cocrystals. Later, Zhang utilized the same MOF host Sr-NDI to form cocrystals with 9,10-dimethylanthracene, enabling visible-light triggered 1O2 generation for dye degradation.37 Complementarily, covalent-linked NDI-An dyads have demonstrated efficient 1O2 production via spin orbit charge transfer ISC.38 Thus, we propose that the MOF cocrystal between Sr-NDI and An might achieve dual photoreactivity: [4+4] photodimerization and [4+2] hetero-Diels–Alder cycloaddition under selective photoexcitation. Furthermore, NDI-based MOFs are established photochromic materials due to the photogenerated NDI radical anion, serving as another possible photoreaction for Sr-NDI cocrystals.39,40 As shown in Fig. 1, the An dimer is encapsulated in the cavity of Sr-NDI to give the cocrystal Sr-NDI@An. Spectral evidence verified that three photoreactions occurred for this single crystal: UV-triggered [4+4] dimerization of guest An, red-light-induced hetero-Diels–Alder reaction between 1O2 and An, and near-infrared (NIR)-driven radical generation. The unprecedented tri-state photoswitching originates from the synergy of CT interaction and dimer confinement. These findings establish a design paradigm for precisely engineering functional π-units, while elucidating fundamental principles for integrating complex functionalities in supramolecular systems.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Crystal structures of the host Sr-NDI and the MOF cocrystal Sr-NDI@An. The π interactions are highlighted (a) along with the spatial arrangement of the An dimer (b). |
Consequently, the distance between NDI dimers is 10.17 Å for Sr-NDI@An, nearly identical to that in Sr-NDI (10.30 Å). This close alignment of PAHs has been extensively utilized to study the smallest dye aggregate, revealing photophysical properties distinct from monomers.41 However, direct observation of An dimer in the extended crystalline π-stacks has not been reported before. Moreover, the space group of Sr-NDI@An is still tetragonal I41/a, identical to the pristine Sr-NDI (Table S1, ESI†).36 As exhibited in Fig. S2 (ESI†), the coordination mode of Sr2+ remains unchanged upon An inclusion. Besides, the Sr-oxygen bond lengths show fluctuations of less than 0.02 Å, which explains the similar SCXRD parameters between Sr-NDI and Sr-NDI@An (Table S1, ESI†).
Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) results of Sr-NDI@An are well matched to the simulated one (Fig. S3, ESI†), indicating the phase purity of the obtained MOF cocrystal. There are no noticeable peak shifts between Sr-NDI@An and Sr-NDI (Fig. S4, ESI†), indicating their similar skeletons. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of Sr-NDI@An (Fig. S5, ESI†) demonstrates this cocrystal is stable up to 520 °C, with a residual skeleton mass fraction of 74%. Compared to the 82% residue for Sr-NDI at 550 °C, this confirms consumption of the encapsulated An dimer between 180 and 500 °C, consistent with anthraquinone-incorporated Sr-NDI.42 1H NMR analysis of acid-digested MOF cocrystals (see the ESI† for details) indicates that the cavity loading ratio for Sr-NDI@An is around 14% (Fig. S6, ESI†). The above-mentioned data confirmed the successful encapsulation of the An dimer in Sr-NDI, for which the unique DA stack with close π-interactions are promising for the [4+4] cycloaddition between An dimers and the hetero Diels–Alder reaction involving singlet oxygen (1O2).
Additionally, CT interactions between NDI and An endow Sr-NDI@An with red-light photoresponsiveness. Under 635 nm excitation, the 1H NMR of Sr-NDI@An exhibits a distinct peak at 8.23 ppm (Fig. S10, ESI†), which should be the signal for the epoxide of An after the hetero-Diels–Alder reaction between singlet oxygen and An.18 Prolonged red-light irradiation progressively intensifies this peak while diminishing the signal at 7.46 ppm (Fig. S11, ESI†), confirming An consumption. This [4+2] cycloaddition involving anthracene typically relies on additional triplet photosensitizer because 1O2 is the crucial active species.18,19 For Sr-NDI@An, the red-light enabled generation of 1O2 was verified by the obvious absorption decrease of diphenylisobenzofuran (DPBF) during the 635 nm excitation (Fig. 4b) as well as the EPR signal enhancement for the TEMP-trapped 1O2 adduct (Fig. S12, ESI†).37 Moreover, the 1O2 generation rate of Sr-NDI@An was calculated as 0.022. The mechanism for the production of 1O2 by Sr-NDI@An likely stems from the CT interaction between NDI and An, which was reported to facilitate the intersystem crossing (ISC) from the singlet CT state (1CT) to the triplet CT state (3CT) via the through-space CT (TSCT) or spin–orbit charge transfer (SOCT) mechanism of the D–A system.21,22,38 For these two mechanisms, the interaction between D–A pairs plays a key role. The dihedral angle of 57.5° between NDI and An in Sr-NDI@An supports the electron communication or orbital coupling between D–A pairs, enabling efficient generation of triplet state.23 After 6 hours of irradiation, the epoxide yield is calculated as 72%, suggesting efficient 1O2 diffusion inside Sr-NDI@An for effective hetero-Diels–Alder reaction (Fig. S11, ESI†). To further verify the importance of 1O2 for this Diels–Alder cycloaddition, we conducted the red-light excitation of Sr-NDI@An under N2. After two hours of 635 nm irradiation, only a trace product of Diels–Alder reaction was detected, which is significantly reduced compared to that under ambient air (Fig. S13, ESI†). These results collectively verify that the triplet state is involved in this [4+2] Diels–Alder cycloaddition.
Interestingly, the compact stacking of An and NDI enables exhibition of near-infrared photoresponsiveness by Sr-NDI@An. After only 10 seconds of 808 nm irradiation (0.4 W cm−2), the initial transparent light-purple Sr-NDI@An crystals transform to opaque dark solids. The EPR spectra show a sharp increase of the radical intensity with a g value of 2.002 (Fig. 4c), suggesting that upon NIR excitation, charge separation within NDI and An occurs to generate long-lived radical species.51 This radical generation was also supported by the weaker EPR signal of the irradiated Sr-NDI@An after 5 days, whereas the small variation between air-exposed and nitrogen-protected samples suggests the high oxygen-tolerance of the generated radical pairs (Fig. 4c). The stability of NDI radical anion of the ligand H4BINDI has been reported to enhance after incorporation into MOF Sr-NDI, as the NDI units adopt an orthogonal arrangement, suppressing radical quenching via transport mechanism.40 In our MOF cocrystal Sr-NDI@An, the nearest NDI distance (3.55 Å) exceeds that in Sr-NDI (3.48 Å). This increased inter-NDI distance, combined with the orthogonal arrangement of NDI units, inhibits radical quenching via the transport mechanism, thereby stabilizing photo-generated NDI radical anions within Sr-NDI@An.23 Moreover, the oxygen-blocking effect of the crystalline skeleton and the guest-filled pores endows the radical pairs in Sr-NDI@An with high oxygen tolerance.
These distinct photoresponses of Sr-NDI@An to different wavelengths are confirmed to arise without structural degradation, since post-treatment PXRD patterns and TGA curves remain nearly identical to pristine samples (Fig. 4d and Fig. S14, ESI†). This result is consistent with the low loading ratio of An (14%) in Sr-NDI@An and our analysis for the light-induced product. The reason for the three photoreactions of Sr-NDI@An toward distinct light excitation originates from its special A–D–D–A stacking pattern and the different energies of the respective photon (Fig. 4e). UV photon exhibits the highest energy to excite the guest An of Sr-NDI@An to its singlet excited state (S1), which then reacts with the nearby An to give the product of [4+4] cycloaddition. Prior studies have demonstrated Schmidt's rule for the close alignment of An units for [4+4] cycloaddition.16,29,52 For Sr-NDI@An, the core-to-core distance between the encapsulated An dimer is 3.49 Å, satisfying the Schmidt's rule. To further emphasize the significance of the dimer encapsulation, we synthesize the control MOF cocrystal Ca-NDI@An, which possesses an isoreticular framework to Sr-NDI@An but accommodates only one An guest in its cavity (Fig. S15, ESI†). No photodimerization product is detected in Ca-NDI@An after 3 hours of UV irradiation (Fig. S16, ESI†). This result provides direct experimental evidence that the dimer arrangement is crucial for [4+4] photodimerization within MOF cavities. In contrast, the red light can only excite the cocrystal Sr-NDI@An to its 1CT, which decays to the triplet state (3CT) to activate oxygen for producing 1O2. Subsequently, the Diels–Alder reaction between 1O2 and An is allowed to give the epoxide. Furthermore, the NIR photon could excite the cocrystal Sr-NDI@An to the charge separation (CS) state, leading to the generation of radical ion pairs, which can be utilized as photothermal agents or spin converters.53 Notably, the charge-transfer stacking is essential for red light-driven Diels–Alder reactions and NIR-induced radical generation, given that Sr-NDI exhibits no absorption beyond 600 nm (Fig. 3a). DFT calculations of Sr-NDI@An reveal that the HOMOs are concentrated on the electron-donating An guests while the LUMOs are located on the ligand NDI, verifying the strong CT interaction between NDI and An within Sr-NDI@An (Fig. S17, ESI†). Therefore, synergy between dimer encapsulation and charge-transfer stacking is required for Sr-NDI@An to achieve tri-state photoswitching. This MOF cocrystal represents the first crystalline material integrating [4+4] cycloaddition, [4+2] cycloaddition, and radical generation functionalities. Its multimodal photoreactivity provides a platform to advance stimulus-responsive materials in optical writing, data storage, smart displays, and sophisticated information transfer.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2418888 and 2419043. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5mh01024a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |