David G.
Schauer
ab,
Jona
Bredehoeft
a,
Umar
Yunusa
b,
Ajith
Pattammattel
c,
Hans Jakob
Wörner
a and
Emily A.
Sprague-Klein
*b
aETH Zurich, Dept. of Chemistry and Applied Biosciences, Laboratory of Physical Chemistry, Vladimir-Prelog-Weg 2 (HCI E 241), 8093 Zürich, Switzerland
bDepartment of Chemistry, Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island 02912, USA. E-mail: emily_sprague-klein@brown.edu
cNational Synchrotron Light Source II, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY 11973, USA
First published on 24th September 2024
In recent years, nanophotonics have had a transformative impact on harnessing energy, directing chemical reactions, and enabling novel molecular dynamics for thermodynamically intensive applications. Plasmonic nanoparticles have emerged as a tool for confining light on nanometer-length scales where regions of intense electromagnetic fields can be precisely tuned for controlled surface chemistry. We demonstrate a precision pH-driven synthesis of gold nanorods with optical resonance properties widely tunable across the near-infrared spectrum. Through controlled electrostatic interactions, we can perform selective adsorbate molecule attachment and monitor the surface transitions through spectroscopic techniques that include ground-state absorption spectrophotometry, two-dimensional X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, and surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. We elucidate the electronic, structural, and chemical factors that contribute to plasmon-molecule dynamics at the nanoscale with broad implications for the fields of energy, photonics, and bio-inspired materials.
Because of the structural anisotropy, GNRs possess both translational and rotational degrees of freedom resulting in a longitudinal (length) as well as a transverse (diameter) surface plasmon wavelength (LSPW, TSPW).11,16,17 Depending on the length-to-diameter aspect ratio, the GNRs exhibit unique absorption spectra indicated by a distinct surface plasmon resonance. Plasmons describe collective oscillations of the quasi-free electrons excited by the electric field of the incident light. Looking at GNRs with a size much smaller than the wavelength of the incident light, the plasmonic oscillations encompass the entire surface of the GNRs, then referred to as localized surface plasmons resonance (LSPR), as shown in Fig. 1. These charge oscillations induce a dipole negatively interfering with the incident electric field, leading toward the absorption of either the LSPW or TSPW in the Vis/NIR range. The LSPW can cover a broad spectrum in the Vis/NIR range (in this work, between ≈ 700–1100 nm). The shorter the length of the GNRs, the more blueshifted their LSPW.2,18–25
In order to control the length of the GNRs – and hence the LSPW – the pH, growth time, and volume of the solutions are among the critical parameters to be considered during the synthesis process. At present, there is a variety of methods for synthesizing GNRs using different techniques and chemicals. The method of seed-mediated growth can be applied to control the LSPW.26–31 In this method, adjusting the pH, growth and reaction time, chemicals used, and the upscaling factor have a significant impact on the shape, the geometry, and the size of the GNRs.22,32–35 Throughout this work, the seed-mediated growth method from Leng et al.36 was further developed by including a precise adjustment of the synthesis parameters mentioned above. This can lead to an unprecedented level of detail in fine-tuning the morphology of the GNRs and their optical properties.
Herein, we demonstrate a nanofabrication approach that allows us to reliably and reproducibly tune the LSPR to the photothermal region for controlled heating applications that are not hot electron-activated. This approach confers three main advantages: surface selectivity, tunability of the optical and electronic properties, and control of heat dissipation. An application where this approach is especially advantageous is when considering molecular analytes commonly employed in photodynamic therapy applications. Notably, a common therapeutic dye, methylene blue (MB), degrades under ultraviolet light and from hot electron excitation in solid-state materials. Therefore, utilizing LSPR scaffolding to enhance molecular dynamics and absorptive properties is beneficial.37 In this manuscript, we evaluate site-specific coordination of a target analyte molecule for bio-inspired complex materials and demonstrate the utility of a pH-mediated synthetic approach to create nanostructures with a high degree of uniformity, shape, and size control. The tunability of surfactant chemistry also enables preferential binding of blue dyes to the nanoparticle surface, which has important applications in phonon (heat) dissipation into condensed phase media.38–47
For obtaining the GNRs, the pH in the growth solution was set between ≈5.0–8.0 since a higher pH led to the formation of gold nanospheres (GNSs). To initiate the growth process, 15 L of the seed solution, consisting of CTAB (0.20 M, 5 mL), HAuCl4·3H2O (5.0 × 10−4 M, 5.0 mL) and freshly prepared (<30 min) ice-cold sodium borohydride (NaBH4, 0.01 M, 0.60 mL), were added into the growth solutions after precise adjustment of the pH, using a pH-meter (Metrohm 744 pH with a Hamilton SlimTriode electrode, Orion Star A211). After seeding, the growth solutions were kept in screwable amber glass vials (20 mL) in a 28 °C water bath throughout the whole growth process. A scheme of the synthesis process is shown in Fig. S1 in the ESI.† These CTAB-GNRs are stable for months in the water bath (excess CTAB will crystallize at room temperature). After 24–48 h, the growth process has ended naturally or can be terminated by centrifugation (5600 rpm, 15 mL conical falcon tubes, 5–10 min). A more detailed synthesis protocol can be found in the extended experimental section of the ESI.†
In order to investigate the different plasmon resonance responses and electrostatic interactions between the GNRs, the surfactant stabilizing the growth process and the attached dye molecules can be exchanged, as illustrated in Fig. 2a. Briefly, the CTAB-GNRs (OD ≈ 5) were centrifuged in 1.5 mL conical falcon tubes (6000 rpm, 30 min), and the supernatant was carefully removed, and the same volume of a 0.7 wt% poly(sodium 4-styrenesulfonate) (Na-PSS) dissolved in MilliQ-water was added. The suspension was put in a sonicator bath to redisperse the GNRs. Subsequently, the same process was repeated a second time using Na-PSS and another 1–2 times (depending on the concentration of the GNRs) using 0.7 wt% of sodium citrate (Na-CIT) dissolved in MilliQ-water. Both the PSS- and CIT-GNRs are stable at room temperature for several weeks and do not have to be stored in a water bath compared to CTAB-GNRs. Fig. 2b shows the resonance shift and the broadening of the absorption spectra using different surfactant-capped GNRs, and Fig. 2c a scanning and transmission electron microscope (SEM, TEM) image verifying the homogeneity and precise size distribution of the GNRs.48
Due to the positive/negative surface charge of the surfactant-capped GNRs, it is possible to attach different dye molecules to the GNRs' surface electrostatically. The following dyes were selected for this study: indigo carmine (IC), MB, and leucomethylene blue (LMB). IC (negative) is attached to the CTAB-GNRs, whereas LMB (neutral) and MB (positive) are attached to the CIT-GNRs. The dyes were prepared in 100 M stock solutions in MilliQ-water. For the CTAB-GNRs (OD ≈5), 1 mL of the solution was centrifuged (6000 rpm, 20 min), and ≥ 90% of the supernatant was carefully removed. The subsequent addition of the same volume of IC from its stock solution led to a color change from red/orange to purple/violet, as seen in Fig. 2b. For the CIT-GNRs (1 mL, OD ≈1), 50 L of LMB were added, and after ≈10 min 100 L of 10 wt% of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) in MilliQ-water were added to prevent precipitation through agglomeration of the CIT-GNRs. The exact process was repeated for MB. The absorption spectra are displayed in Fig. 5. All these solutions are stable at room temperature for several weeks and were used for the subsequent characterizations.
p = ε0εmα|E0|, |
panisot. = ε0εm(α‖|E0|‖ + α⊥|E0|⊥) |
The absorption spectra of the GNRs discussed in this work can be found in Fig. S2–S4 in the ESI.† The peak associated with the TSPW is present at shorter wavelengths (≈500 nm), and the peak indicating the LSPW covers a spectrum between ≈ 700–1100 nm. A lower pH (≈5) led to a redshift (longer wavelengths), whereas an increase in pH (≈8.5) led to a blueshift (shorter wavelengths) of the LSPW. In order to illustrate this trend, all absorption peaks were precisely evaluated, using Voigt-fits (Fig. S4 in the ESI†), and plotted against their pH, as shown in Fig. 4b. At pH values greater than 7, the TSPW of the GNRs underwent a redshift and broadened spectrally. This change was either indicated by a small discontinuity of the curve up to the formation of a new third peak corresponding to the formation of isotropic particles, marked as “△” in Fig. 4b. As spheres only possess a single geometric parameter (diameter), they only show a single absorption peak in the spectra (≈550 nm), which neither corresponds to the LSPW nor the TSPW of the GNRs. As most samples contain traces of spheres, confirmed by SEM imaging, the Voigt model utilizes three distinct absorption peaks. The third peak corresponding to the spheres only became clearly visible at a basic pH, as shown in Fig. 4b.
When the GNRs were synthesized in the appropriate acidic pH regime, a clear correlation between the position of the LSPW and the growth time and the pH value was observed. The lower the pH, the more redshifted the LSPW and the greater the length of the GNRs. If the pH was adjusted to a more basic value, the LSPW became more blueshifted; hence, the GNRs' length would decrease. This is due to the increased reducing power of NH2OH·HCl at larger pH values,54,55 which leads to the formation of shorter GNRs in the growth process due to a faster consumption of the educts in the growth solution, leaving no sufficient time to form longer GNRs. The trend was no longer present for growth times shorter than one hour (yellow “◊”) since, at a lower pH, the LSPW was blueshifted. With an increasing pH (≥6.5), a trend comparable to that of GNRs with growth times longer than one hour was observed. This can be explained by the fact that at lower pH values (≈5), the reduction of HAuCl4·3H2O from Au+3 to Au0 takes longer (pH ≈ 2.7 of the growth solutions before adjustment). Adjusting the overall volume of the synthesis (upscaling with a factor of 10) while holding the pH, the concentration, and the growth time constant resulted in a blueshift of the LSPW, indicated as light-blue and -red “◊” in Fig. 4b. This trend could be explained by an inhomogeneous distribution of the seeds after the injection of the seed solution, leading to longer diffusion times and, thus, different reaction kinetics. This might be important to consider for large-scale applications of GNRs.
Fig. 5 shows the recorded UV/Vis/NIR spectra of the different surfactant-capped GNRs with the respective dyes (IC, LMB, MB) attached to their surface. CTAB-GNRs possess a bilayer of CTAB around the surface of the GNRs consisting of a hydrophobic (negative, carbon-tail) middle part and a hydrophilic (positive, nitrogen-head) end (Fig. 2a), leading towards an overall positive surface charge of the CTAB-GNRs. In comparison, PSS-GNRs exhibit a delocalized negative surface charge due to the benzene-π-system, making it easier to exchange the surfactant from CTAB to Na-PSS and subsequently to Na-CIT, having a negative surface charge, enabling the electrostatic attachment of differently charged dyes to the surfactant-capped GNRs. The negative IC binds with the CTAB-GNRs, whereas the neutrally charged LMB and the positively charged MB are attached to the CIT-GNRs.48 A clear shift of the LSPW (Δλ) can be observed in all the spectra (Fig. 5). This can be explained by the increased area over which the electron cloud is delocalized due to the attachment of the dye molecules. This increase in size leads to a decrease in the restoring force of the plasmonic electron cloud, which results in a redshift of the LSPR. This can be observed for the CIT-GNRs with MB and LMB attached to their surfaces, whereas the CTAB-GNR + IC follows an opposing trend (blueshift), possibly due to electron excess of the GNRs, when bound to CTAB.56
Fig. 3 shows the nano-XANES mapping of CTAB-stabilized GNR oligomers with two different LSPRs. A 2D-XRF map was acquired at every X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) monochromator position, yielding spatial resolution correlated to electronic information for the Au L3-absorption-edge dominated by 2p3/2 → 5d5/2,3/2 dipole allowed transitions. For the 772 nm LSPR, the brightest pixel region corresponds to the highest concentration of GNRs, giving a distinct 2D-XANES spectrum (red trace). Similarly, the nanorods with a 706 nm optical LSPR yield a 2D-XANES spectrum (blue trace) with an edge energy that overlaps nearly precisely with the gold foil standard (yellow trace). In contrast, a redshift of ≈2 eV (green box) is observed for GNRs with an optical LSPR of 772 nm. The electronic energetic shift of 2 eV in the 2D-XANES edge correlates to an observed optical shift of 66 nm, where additional phaseshifts are also observed in the oscillatory features past the white line energy (blue boxes). The magnitude of the LSPR redshift that we observe is much greater than ≈10 nm, signifying that the origin of this redshift is not due to subtle corner rounding or narrowing alone, as can be seen in previous studies on corner-sharpness-controlled gold nanoparticles.57 We therefore attribute the redshift to changes in GNR aspect ratio, electronic changes in the longitudinal LSPR mode, and ligand-induced electronic restructuring. Further correlation to structural and morphological information obtained by TEM imaging shows that the redshift can be ascribed primarily to a change in the oscillator strength of the longitudinal plasmon resonance going from a nanorod of dimensions ≈ 10 × 25 nm (706 nm, blue) to a nanorod of dimensions ≈20 × 60 nm (772 nm, red) resulting in a size-dependent shift in the gold d-band holes. This lowering in relative oscillator strength is also correlated with out-of-phase XANES amplitudes occurring at energies 11.935 keV and 11.930 keV, suggesting a shift in the 5d valence electron distribution across coordination sites ranging from Au0 ↔ Au−1 due to the increased electron-donating ability of the CH2 and CH3 groups of CTAB and a shift to more acidic growth solutions as the LSPR redshifts.58 The synthesis methodology included in this report uses the same chemical and surfactants from a prepared stock solution under identical conditions. Given the high fidelity of this one-pot synthesis protocol, we can draw comparisons in the LSPR redshift in the 772 nm and 706 nm GNR samples with only CTAB functionalization.
Fig. 6 displays the FTIR and SERS optical vibrational spectroscopy results following gold nanorod surface stabilization with CTAB and Na-CIT, after which the nanostructures underwent surface functionalization with blue dye adsorbates. In Fig. 6a, the 2915.90 cm−1 and 2849.01 cm−1 modes correspond to a symmetric and asymmetric stretching of the methyl and methylene groups in the CTAB surfactant. Vibrational modes in the mid-wavenumber region (1486.61 cm−1, 1472.38 cm−1, 1462.32 cm−1, 1430.86 cm−1, 1407 cm−1) correspond to asymmetric and symmetric bending of C–H bonds of the H3C–N+ moiety. Notably, modes in the fingerprint region exhibit higher peak amplitudes, suggesting a greater number of active sites for adsorbate molecule attachment. The modes include C–H bending motions that are typically not observed in pure CTAB (1012.20 cm−1 and 981.29 cm−1), C–N+ stretching motions (959.59 cm−1), and rocking modes of the CH2-chain (938 cm−1 and 908 cm−1). Fig. 6b shows the FTIR-detected CIT-GNRs following the surfactant exchange and surface stabilizing with citrate ions. The most prominent modes can be assigned to the symmetric CO vibration (1584 cm−1) and the antisymmetric vibration of COO− (1400.73 cm−1). Both modes are shifted to higher relative wavenumbers (Δṽ > 5 cm−1) indicative of surface interactions and monodentate or bidentate binding to gold. High-wavenumber modes corresponding to O–H stretches are also present (2359 cm−1 and 2341 cm−1) where these are commonly seen in pure citrate but less often observed in citrate-GNRs. Vibrational modes below 1100 cm−1 correspond to symmetric and asymmetric stretches of C–O–C bonds.59–69
SERS-detection of adsorbate molecules that are confined to nanometer regions between GNRs through electrostatic interactions are shown in Fig. 6c. IC displays prominent SERS modes at 1633.64 cm−1 (CO, CC stretches with in-plane C–H modes), 1622.96 cm−1, 1574.67 cm−1 (CC asymmetric stretches in the pyrrolidone ring combined with CO stretching), 1296.83 cm−1 (symmetric stretches of the SO3− group with C–C bending and N1–C2 stretching), 770.85 cm−1 (out-of-plane bending in the C–C and C–H bonds combined with pyrrolidone ring breathing), 676.01 cm−1 (out-of-plane N–H and C–C motion), 573.65 cm−1 (CC−CO−C bending), 551.74 cm−1 (CC−CO−C stretches), and 270.40 cm−1 (skeletal deformation modes combined with Au−O vibrations). Of interest are the absence of sulfonate modes with SERS transitions at 1360 cm−1, 1301 cm−1, 1141 cm−1, and 611 cm−1 which are suppressed likely due to symmetric electrostatic interactions at both ends of the anionic IC molecule with the cationic CTAB at the gold nanorod surfaces.
MB displays normal vibrational modes at 1622 cm−1, 1433 cm−1, and 1405.53 cm−1 that are consistent with unbound surface-free molecules where structural motions correspond to skeletal bending at the C−N stretch and C−N ring stretch (1622.96 cm−1), asymmetric vibrations about the C−N stretch (1433.11 cm−1), and stretching about the C9−N10, C3−N2, C−N ring, and in-plane C−H bending motion (1405.53 cm−1). These C−N based modes are also the most intense peaks in the spectrum, which contrasts with previous studies of MB on silver nanocaps. A pronounced relative decrease in mode amplitude for the 400–1400 cm−1 region was observed. The relative peak amplitude changes can be ascribed to asymmetric electrostatic interactions between one end of the cationic MB molecule and the anionic citrate surface of the GNRs. All other modes shift when MB is adsorbed to GNRs with citrate surfactant functionalization. These shifts in SERS transitions include the C−N stretching mode (1217.67 cm−1), CH3 rocking motion with in-plane C−H bending (1157.68 cm−1), C−H out-of-plane bending (1126.03 cm−1), in-plane bending of C−H bonds (1041.88 cm−1), and skeletal deformations at the C−N−C moiety (479.28 cm−1). LMB was also used to functionalize the surfaces of GNRs, which shared many overlapping modes with MB. One of the more intense bands in LMB is centered at 1371 cm−1 corresponding to the CC ring stretch, less prevalent in our GNRs system. According to the SERS spectra, both LMB and MB share similar peak intensities, suggesting similar binding or attachment configurations to the GNRs. This observation of varied absorption dynamics is further supported by similar peak intensity shifts of the LSPR where the IC molecule induces the most pronounced shift followed by smaller effects in the MB and LMB surface attachment varieties.70–76
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Extended description of the experimental methods and synthesis instructions. Overview of the fitting algorithm (Voigt-fits) applied to the absorption spectra of the GNRs to extract the peak positions. Raw data and acquisition using 2D X-ray absorption near-edge structure (2D-XANES) spectroscopy at the National Synchrotron Light Source II (NSLS-II) at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL). See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4cp01993h |
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2024 |